Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you all so much for your support this month! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-not-1-73957718

Comments

Eel Splatterson

In your review of We Cool by Jeff Rosenstock you mention not liking BTMI! You’ve seemed to warm to Jeff’s music considerably over the years. Have you ever revisited BTMI?

Sam Gavshak

The go-betweens are the most underrated band of all time, streets of your town and cattle and cane are easily top 10 all time singles from the 1980s

Scott Stephens

"Song For Our Daughter", while a brilliant album, is not as good as Laura Marling's earliest work, such as "Alas I Cannot Swim" or "I Speak Because I Can"

bressig

do you think pay-to-plays are morally unethical to make young artists do or are they more-or-less accepted as necessary to get your work in front of people? With the way the entertainment industry has been headed the last decade (less money paid to artists, commodification of music/media via streaming) it seems young artists really have no other choice but to shell out more and more money to get their work seen or heard

adamlatif

The W, Iron Flag, and 8 Diagrams are all solid albums with great production and they’re heavily overlooked in the Wu-Tang catalogue. RZA was still killing it with his beats. ALSO I WANNA KNOW YOUR RANKING FROM 1-10, FAVOURITE TO LEAST FAVOURITE, OF ALL WU-TANG MEMBERS ♄ (including Cappadonna)

Oscar Barroso

Not sure if this was ever asked before, but do you think at some point in the future that Music and Artificial Intelligence will take over the music industry and humans will just strictly be stuck working crappy jobs until the planet dies or some crap?

Sammy Tompkins

CLB is the best Drake album since NWTS. The production does carry at times, but it has everything you could want from a Drake project. It's got the bangers in Knife Talk, No Friends, and, goofy as it is, Way 2 Sexy, and the vibey fuckboy tracks like Race My Mind, Pipe Down, and IMY2. Definitely a couple duds in there, but the album as a whole has aged fantastically and is up there with Drake's best, considerably better than Her Loss. Also, cringey chorus aside, Girls Want Girls is a vibe and is way overhated

Spencer Maples

Have you ever considered discussing the work of Daniel Johnston?

Titas Mičiulis

There will be no arguments against this take but Fantano's doggo is very cute. When doggo appears on various segments on the TheNeedleDrop project, such as the New Music Friday livestreams or is heard randomly barking in videos, the sheer cuteness of TheNeedleDog takes over any disagreements and unites all music fans across the world to appreciate the bestest dog.

jonas

any particular reason you didn't review the latest Moor Mother record? you seemed to have liked the singles and are fond of her besides that anyway. Did the record just didn't do much for you or was there some other reason? (not that you need one though, I'm just curious bc it's one of my favorites from this year and seeing her perform that shit live with a whole jazz band was incredible)

Robert Paul

Is the “trap era” of music officially over now?

William Maranci

ten is one of pearl jam’s worst albums. the production is cavernous garbage that doesn’t fit the band’s songwriting. their next several albums, while not as beloved as ten, were far superior and more interesting. vitalogy and yield kind of slap

Gabe Duncan

vinyl updates should make a return

Isaac Wardwell

a smallish, portland based artist named Wynne, dropped one of the hardest hip hop Ep's of the year in 2021, in collaboration with producer Christo, who often works with JID, and she simply deserves far more praise than what's been provided.

Trevor Young

It's sad af when punk bands that were big in the 80s try to grasp at their glory days. Saw "Black Flag" a few weeks ago and it was terrible. Some of these groups need to accept that the best is behind them and hang it up. Their youthful gen x punk ethos doesn't hold up -- it died a while ago and when we need to let it rip.

Evan Sawatzke

A One Direction reunion (without Liam) would cure the planet of all disease and unhappiness.

Herbieguy

Sample clearance laws should not exist. Point blank period. If a composer thinks they're owed thousands of dollars in royalties and """damages""" over a 10 second song snippet, they're greedy to a delusional level. Imagine how many more 'Since I Left You's and 'Low End Theories' we would have without those stupid laws in place.

Tuck

Is there an artist that you enjoy every single thing they ever put out? Songs, albums, B-sides, etc.? Is there an artist that is so embedded in your soul due to personal connection or nostalgia, that you can't look at any part of their discography with a critic's eye? You just simply love everything they do? There's basically only one artist like that for me and it's They Might be Giants. Would love to know your thoughts.

Tuck

For your sake, let's hope melon goes easy on you

Philip Coulam-Jones

What do you think is the poorest-aged Grammy's BNA pick (either because of the winner fizzling out or the other nominees completely eclipsing them)?

Ander Gomez

Where the heck is the review for Shygirl’s album?!

Amicia Huelsman

Robert Smith really took a page from the video game industry on making project announcements way too early.

Gio

You’ve mentioned that you’re not the biggest fan of Grace by Jeff Buckley, how come?

Jack Darnell

The opening guitar lick to Johnny B Goode is the most important opening guitar lick in rock music history.

Drake Parker

I feel like the only albums that ever get red flannels are the mainstream ones. Sometimes it’d be nice to know which obscure albums you’d want us to stay away from

Danu Jackson

is there any albums that have songs on it that have probably not aged well, due to either the artist making offensive comments or just poor timing around the albums release? me and my bf are huge fans of your videos and we appreciate your takes on albums that have probably not aged well or are not the most amazing records ever

Kristofer Mc Cormack

Has your opinion on Mac Miller's Swimming changed? I've noticed you seem to hold earlier albums like Faces and Watching movies in higher regard than your original reviews.

Rossyp

How can the new house music trend survive an era where songs just keep getting shorter and shorter?

Nick

How important is album art to you and does it affect the rating of an album you give? (I.e. a record might be 10/10 but is brought down to a 9 if the artwork is poor).

Andrew Shaktah

More artists need to release live versions of their albums or music. A band’s live performance can completely change an opinion on an album or existing track. Recently saw Ethel Cain perform and hearing the emotion in her voice elevated the experience of the music for me.

Josh Timko

Susumu Yokota is never a part of the conversation when people discuss the GOATs of ambient music, and I think that is a little bit dumb.

darrenfx

Let it be by the replacements is better than let it be by the Beatles. The Beatles could never pull or Garry's got a boner đŸ˜€đŸ˜€đŸ˜€

MV Calil

giving out 10's for older records is way easier than newer ones since it's possible to rely on it's fame/impact, or use it to boost it's "value" instead of only the music like a new release would be judged on, since we can't predict what will be influential or not

Sam Bird

King Gizzard and the Lizard Wizard are the best band of the 10s and 20s

chorogon

Disintegration is a better album than The Queen is Dead (and it's not even close), but There Is a Light That Never Goes Out is a better song than nearly every song on Disintegration.

Nick

You’re right. When you go on RYM, everyone on that site tend to give loads and loads more 10s to records that are least 10 years. Anything under that is normally few and far between.

Self-Aware Onion

The 2 minute and 5 second instrumental intro in For Whom the Bell Tolls is the best intro in any piece of music ever. The ominous bells at the very start set the stage perfectly for what's to come, Cliff's distorted bass solo that follows is incredibly creative, the grimy and groovy headbanging riff after the bass solo is intense, the guitar lead that pops in at 1:16 is amazing, and the final riff of the intro (that later is restated in the chorus) leads into the verse smoothly; it is the perfect intro.

Noah

Mac Miller is a top 5 rapper. I can't think of another artist more beloved by the hip-hop community than Mac. I don't think he's ever beefed with anyone and his list of co-collaborators is honestly staggering. Off the top of my head: J Cole (Prod. Hurt Feelings) Steve Lacy (Prod. Jet Fuel) Thundercat Kendrick Young Thug Anderson .Paak SZA (he produced for her "Z" EP) Tyler the Creator Earl Sweatshirt Vince Staples JID (ad libs on Self Care) Ty Dolla $ign Schoolboy Q Rick Ross Ab Soul Lil B Chief Keef and load more... You could play six degrees of Kevin Bacon with Mac Miller. Mac Miller was the Kevin Bacon of hip-hop. R.I.P.

Dez

Black up is one of the most underrated rap albums. It’s production is light years ahead of its time and feels pretty dang Influential. It had an insane amount of buzz when it came up but I feel like it was followed up by like 4 terrible albums no one talks about it anymore. It should be consider a top 5 greatest rap album of the 2010s.

Dez

Lift to experience’s Texas Jerusalem crossroads is an incredibly underrated post rock classic. Have you heard that shit????? Massive fantastic Christian post rock that can easily stand next to GY!BE or Slint. No one talks about it and it’s a crime.

Dez

Spelllings the turning wheel is only a 10 on the first couple listens. The more you listen to the record the more it looses its magic and starts to sound like a god dang cheesy musical.

Dirty Randy

Not enough people talk about the dark side of listening on vinyl. As someone who enjoys listening to whole albums front to back, I am seriously forced to reflect when a song I don’t like comes on.

Dirty Randy

Opposite, if you choose to buy into it, each concurrent listen actually adds 10 points to the score

Dirty Randy

There it is TMBJ is BACK baby

Gray Lefkowitz

Wrong. I don't think it's a 10, but it certainly does not lose its magic the more you listen to it. Cheesy musicals are great if they're not trying to be showtunesy, it's just a fucked up Disney movie and I love it

Ryan Craig

its not a dark side its just expected, if i put on an album, i want to hear the album not the songs i like from the album

Ryan Craig

richard dawson is one of the most underrated artists of this current generation, arguably the most. the man's creativity, song writing, themes, and skill with his wonky vocals and insane guitar playing all fail to ever garner any vast attention, and the man deserves more credit for being one of the best to do it right now

Ryan Craig

i tend to not factor in fame/impact when scoring an album, scoring for me is strictly a person thing

Kyle Cahill

When it comes to list week, how do you compare and contrast two albums that got a 10/10?

Nick Denhalter

Ethan Klein from h3h3 gets way more hate than he deserves. I have always understood why Ethan is not every bodies favorite youtuber, but I have never understood the hatred he gets from so many different subgroups on YouTube. If you want to say he is not funny, too needlessly controversial, reckless or brazen, I think that is fine. However, having someone so unfiltered on live podcasts who is willing to own up to when they make mistakes is a valuable thing. Especially considering his journey over the years, Ethan owns up to his mistakes and doesn’t try to hide them. I haven’t seen another fan base so intent on holding their favorite creator accountable. Usually fans jump to defend the creators they like but Ethan’s consistently push him to do better and correct his mistakes. From what I’ve seen, he’s not folding either. He will take time to reflect and then confess and apologize or occasionally he will stand his ground if he feels justified. I’ve never seen a creator have so many groups attempt to cancel or silence them, people from either side of the political spectrum, too. He has had tons of violent threats, doxing, swatting, etc for speaking his mind, but it doesn’t stop him. He is losing sponsorships and brand deals constantly for the stuff he says, (like the nra stuff)but he stays loyal to his code. He has an integrity to being authentic and accountable that I really don’t see in many creators and so I feel the need to say that here.

Caspa

Not really an argument but more like a statement, we need more goth clubs in ct that play a mix of old stuff and current releases that fit would fit the goth ethos like Post-Punk ,Synth Pop ,Goth Rock Goth Metal and and also throw in some rappers that fit the goth esthetic like Sematary.

Nick Denhalter

I’m shocked more people aren’t aware of NASA’s The Spirit of the Apollo album. It’s not straight fire beginning to end, BUT with the absolutely legends featured on that album and the genre fusion that takes place using those artists, it’s insane to me that it’s not a topic of more conversation in the rap community. David Byrne, Tom Waits, Del, KRS-One, most of wu tang including ODB, Fatlip and MIA??? Not to mention a verse from Ye that aged really
bad? Or good, idk. It’s impact only increases with recent behavior. Either way, I think it deserves more place in rap discussion.

Nick Denhalter

Also it got a 1.6 from pitchfork wtf????

Dirty Randy

Anthony just destroyed my entire take on the Fantano channel but imma leave it up for the shame

bressig

Forgot about this vid! My b Antoine, then my other question is: what is the best song written specifically for other media in your opinion? Examples: Back in Time from Back to the Future, You're Not Here from Silent Hill 3, etc

The Needle Drop

takes collected; thank you! anyone commenting beyond this point will be looked at for the next one

Caspa

I actually just came up with another take but ok I definitely hope you use it for the next one.

Caspa

Canibus ,Ras Kass,Chino XL and Esham were proto fake deep rappers they had big vocabularies ,rapped coherently ,had Wordplay but weren't really saying anything profound once you dug deep into it.

Cole

ok I've been on an MF DOOM kick lately and lemme just say the skits have just become straight up annoying at this point having listened to his albums around once a day for the past couple of months. Some of the skits like the one in "America's Most Blunted" are okay and flow into the song really well, but the one at the end of "One beer" is just plain annoying and quite honestly shit. There is this looped beat that is just straight up worse than the one playing on the actual song, and then its back for seconds on Guinneses. I didn't really have a huge problem with them at first but why did this dude make half of his songs have 1-2 minute skits at the beginning/end?