Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you so much for all of your support this month (and year; how tf is it the end of the year already)! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-fuck-75252333 (great url)

Comments

Nolan Reiling

I'd be interested to hear your reasoning.

Kyle Cahill

Sigur Ros is more dream pop than post rock

8hu

year end lists/recaps being released in december is the stupidest trend in modern media, especially when they stop recording oct/nov. atleast tumblr does october to october before releasing in december

bressig

Kiss From a Rose should be in the Top 10 of any "Best Songs of All Time" list, if not the #1 spot

Jackson Moeller

Never meant memes have the same energy as weezer memes

marcy

Brakence dropped the album of the year IN DECEMBER

BlueZones

“69 Love Songs” by the Magnetic Fields is the best album of the nineties. Just the sheer volume of quality music makes it an easy contender, and the fact that it remains varied sonically and the songwriting is consistently fantastic throughout makes it one of the most rewarding risks in rock history. It is truly unparalleled in indie pop.

Josh

If you don't plan on doing a classic review of a Mastodon album this year, can you confirm that Crack the Skye is your favorite album of theirs? I remember you said Leviathan isn't your favorite in a video from a few years ago, but you didn't mention which one is your favorite.

Zach Stolpa

Shawn cee has been doing streams where he takes a multitude of songs and randomizes them and compares them in a tournament style way. Would you consider doing something like this? I know you’re sort of doing something like this with the top 10 hits of each year videos but I think even then some gems for certain years get ignored if you only restrict it to the billboard 10 songs of a particular year, Just a suggestion that I think would be up your alley.

Herbieguy

(As a teeth expert you should enjoy this one): Adults deserve more toothpaste diversity. It's always kids toothpaste that ends up having these amazing selections of fruit and dessert flavors while us adults are stuck with just the same old tired cinnamon and mint every time. Why can't WE have some fun flavors of toothpaste for once? It's not fair.

Zach Stolpa

What was the best illegal downloading site of the 2000’s? (Limewire, Napster, bit torrent, Kazaa, etc)

Evan Sawatzke

People shouldn’t separate the art from the artist.

prodbypope

You are the Roger Ebert of music reviewers

Gabe Duncan

Vinyl update should make a return it’s been too long

The Needle Drop

we've talked abt this in argue before and will prob do a standalone vid. decidedly not a new trend tho

8hu

yeah may not be the most modern but i feel like spotify wrapped has made it worse

Purajit Malalur

Fuck yeah! I love mint but mint toothpastes are too artifical and strong, and don't like the extremely sharp feeling they leave in your mouth. I've been using a bamboo-anise flavored one this last year and it's so damn good

MV Calil

giving out 10's for older records is way easier than newer ones since it's possible to rely on it's fame/impact, or use it to boost it's "value" instead of only the music like a new release would be judged on, since we can't predict what will be influential or not

Pneuma Apologetics

Three days grace is underrated. One x is a Classic by post grunge standards and I hate everything about you is one of the best hit songs of the 2000s.

Spencer Maples

If you could be gifted at any instrument, which would you choose?

Adrian Vargas

Of the records you've reviewed thus far, how many do you actually own on vinyl? Are there records you've never reviewed within your collection? (I'm assuming so as you probably have older albums that you may not have done a "Classic" review for yet.)

ToadMan101

As much as people like to shit on AJR, hear me out on this: AJR is this current generation's version of AC/DC. If you expect something better from AJR, man do you have your hopes very high. Their instrumentation is always going to be the same kind of Pro Tools "in your face" production, with lyrics always about being growing up, even if these lyrics are starting to get stagnant. AC/DC, meanwhile, has the same kind of rock production you'd expect of crunchy guitars, and the lyrics all have the same "rock and roll" style to it. With this in mind, wouldn't it be best to just not give AJR a score for any future albums and simply put them in the YUNOREVIEWs?

Squanto

AnCo’s early stuff up until Sung Tongs kind of sucks tbh. Have no clue why critics and MU cream themselves over it

Robyn

Live acts/venues/nightclubs should take a least *some* responsibility if they’re pumping out music at dangerously loud volumes by encouraging people to wear earplugs or even making them available. It’s easy to assume that everyone knows nightclub volumes in particular cause hearing damage/tinnitus but in my experience this isn’t that case.

Thomas Ratcliff

Need an ice cube tier list / predator review

jeff

rustie deserves more recognition as one of the main pioneers of the pc music/hyperpop style, even down to its more mainstream sensibilities now pervasive in the electronic scene. he was basically the first artist i ever heard bring together huge trance supersaw chords with heavy 808 kits, paving the way for artists like flume, and the rage beat trend down the line. regardless of if you agree, his formula was undeniably prophetic given how ubiquitous the style now is

membertatooine

Sebastian Murphy and Raygun Busch are keeping the dadbod alive and well.

FredDenza

Fantano's patreon content is mid if he won't do NMF on the reg. All in all It's still good karma to support the melon though so đŸ€·â€â™‚ïž

FredDenza

Though fun there's way too many skippable tracks on 69 Love Songs for it to be superior to even other indie classics of the nineties. If Steven trimmed the fat and released it as 59 Love Songs I might agree

FredDenza

Idk, getting Anthony's best of lists reliably over Christmas vacation is the highlight of the YouTube year. If his lists came out some other non-Yuletide month I'd have a blue blue blue blue youtube Christmas. Don't be a list-grinch! Lol

FredDenza

That's a great powerful passionate pop song, I can see making a case for this

Lousey

What's your favorite instance wherein you endorsed a small artist who went on to drop a record that you love?

FredDenza

Woah I def felt thus way in my youth but as an old dude that cant afford dental work I just want as little pain as possible. Sense-o-dine all the way

FredDenza

Ha good one, but no he's just americas record store clerk, listening to music on the store stereo, giving out recommendations, and fielding eye-rollingly doofy music questions from ignoramuses all day long

FredDenza

Hey Anthony how about a best comedy record tier list? My top five would be: George Carlin-Operation Foole, Mitch Hedberg-Strategic Grille Location, Richard Pryor-Crazy, Firesign Theatre-I Think We're All Bozos On This Bus, and The Album of the Soundtrack of the Trailer of the Film of Monty Python and the Holy Grail.

Foxx Navarro

Dead Cowboy is the greatest song of all time

Charlie Fraser

Joji could easily make one of the best albums for a year if he wasn't so controlled by his label and fleshed all his songs out more

Charlie Fraser

The Ramones were arguably the biggest influence in music when they came out for at least a decade, their self titled project invented punk

All Good In The Neighborhood

Tame by The Pixies is the ultimate crack head anthem and Idk what could beat it (maybe some death grips) PS. FUCK YE!

Adam ODonnell

I recently came across your old review for the Danger Mouse & Sparklehorse collab “Dark Night of the Soul” and I really respected what you had to say about the unfortunate circumstances that led to the records release and why that made you refuse to review it. Especially in light of recent posthumous albums from beloved stars I took your words as a warning of what to expect from major labels trying to cash in on artists after their untimely death. I’m curious in the years since have you revisited the album and do you still hold the same anger to the labels that halted the original release?

A Dizzy Bat

I see a lot of people continually underrate and undervalue newly-penned christmas music! Sure, all of the classics have their place, but I don't see how people can complain about getting original (non-cover) yuletide offerings from the likes of LCD Soundsystem, Tyler the Creator and 100 gecs. (Also, someone needs to get Sufjan's ass back in the studio for another 60-track christmas album already; it's been long enough!)

Nick

This is going to get very heated over something quite trivial in the grand scheme of music. But Britain’s new post-punk scene is a total mess. It seems that for every one band we get within this scene with a unique and exciting sound, another band comes along with a flat and derivative style. The quality gap between these artists are so huge that it’s difficult not to notice, with some quickly gaining all-time greatest status and others that will probably linger in the “could’ve been great but never was category”. But then again, most of these artists sound nothing alike each other with no real line as to what does and doesn’t count in the scene. Some have clearly evolved beyond their post-punk beginnings and have moved into different genres altogether. For example, when you look at Black Midi and Yard Act, both bands are commonly lumped into the same scene despite the former being a zany, maximalist avant-prog band whilst the latter is a political and minimalistic post-punk group with heavy spoken word influences and are therefore incomparable to each other. Those are just two out of many examples.

vvvvvictoria

Was there no NMF again last Friday? I just realised and I don’t see an upload

Ali Rizvi

Trip hop can be a popular genre in this current musical genre. The works of Portishead, Tricky, and Massive Attack were seminal pieces of the 90s, but I can see the genre returning to popularity. The rise of experimental hip-hop, synthpop, and psychedelic acts show that the elements of the genre have appeal. Who knows, maybe later this decade people are gonna want to do a 90's revival movement the same way we got an 80's wave in the late 2010s early 2020s, and genres like trip hop and shoegaze will have heavy influences in popular music albums.

Alex Sim

thoughts on why The-Dream never broke thru as a Star (capital S)? He's got his fingerprints all over R&B/hip-hop, definitely above average vocal chops, etc., but he's always been loudest in the background..

Nkosi Kamal

The American Gothic by Vernon Harris is arguably the BEST rap album from unknown rap artists this past decade. I believe that this album stands against the best of this year including JID and Kendrick while being undiscovered.

Jesus Roche

Idk if you’ve done this before but can you a tier list of the various different ways one can consume music (8 track, cassette, CDs etc.) and a quick explanation as for why?

Erik Abramson

While the Tony Hawk soundtracks are undeniable classics, I don't feel like the Crazy Taxi soundtracks get enough praise. They introduced me to the Offspring which led to me asking my mom to get my first CD ever, their 1998 album Americana. This was probably my earliest memory of actually loving music.

mothboy

i much more enjoy takes that an album/artist is underrated rather than overrated. the latter just serves to drive negativity out into the world upon people who already appreciated a piece of work, while the former may get you to think deeper about one you may have previously dismissed and see where people who liked it are coming from

Drake Parker

The Best Tracks should come before the Worst Tracks in Weekly Track Roundup, so that it’s easier to ignore the worst tracks and close the video after getting your good recommendations.

Nick Denhalter

RXKNEPHEW is the new and improved Lil B

kapildh

In my opinion, The Roots>OutKast>ATCQ. But when we talk about best jazz rap, ATCQ gets that spot and OutKast often takes the best rap collective honor. How are The Roots the most underrated when their discography and the lead emcee are as good or I'd argue even better than the other two? Also, when is the Roots tier list/worst to best coming out? Please soon.

FredDenza

Kendrick Lamar is becoming so high concept his next drop is just going to be an informational pamphlet.

ammiguy

How do you feel about the new direction Black Country, New Road is heading in now that Isaac is gone? Have you listened to any of the new stuff they've performed live?

Drake Parker

If there were an AI hip hop album, it would just be a Jaden Smith album

Self-Aware Onion

Alice in Chains > Nirvana > Soundgarden > Stone Temple Pilots > Pearl Jam

membertatooine

can you sign Little Deer by Spellling for my birthday?

Cole

songs about Jane is a somewhat decent album. I would go so far as to say some of the songs are catchy

Caspa

Are there any albums besides your albums of the years that you're considering in putting in your decade end list?