Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you so much for all of your support this month; wishing you a lovely 2023! Now's the time to shake off the rust and hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-vs-76563680

Comments

memphis rap gf

People reacted way too negatively to Ariana Grande's placement on Rolling Stone's top 200 singers list. There were definitely people on the list that should've been above her but I was kind of surprised that pretty much every commentator I came across turned their nose up at her placement. I think she was placed perfectly. Almost feels like there's no middle ground with her, you're either an overzealous stan who overrates her music to death or you just refuse to entertain the idea that she's worthy of any serious recognition.

Amyr

Britpop is overhated

Nick

But he’ll probably go for something like Baha Men

EZGames69

Vine was not ā€œBetter than Tiktokā€. People often try to claim that the era of Vine back when it was a thing was better than what Tiktok is today in terms of content. However, people completely like to ignore that Vine had some awful content as well, I mean it was literally the platform that people like Logan Paul got their start.

Larry Ronstadt

Hip hop would be no where without Kayne, he is one of the most influential artists of all time.

Zach Stolpa

Weezer is going to have a resurgence in popularity thanks to weezer memes.

Nathan Roberts

Sicko Mode is not the classic everyone makes it out to be. The beat is fine, but the lyrics (especially Drake’s) are complete ass and the switch-ups aren’t all that interesting. Still not sure why everyone likes it so much.

Music Guy

Ordinary World by Duran Duran is the greatest 80’s song to be released in the 90’s.

Christian Tom

Most songs would be better with a 16th note hi-hat beat

bressig

Do you think Kurt Cobain legitimately considered The Shaggs' "Philosophy of the World" one of his favorite albums, or do you think he was just screwing with his critics?

Amicia Huelsman

Now that we are three years into the decade, what sounds and trends are appearing that set the ā€˜20s apart from the ā€˜10s?

MusicEnjoyer8

How can Drake be overrated when he is constantly hated on. I never see any praise for Drake. I think people are insecure and just want to hate on anything that is mainstream. If anything, he is underrated at this point. Artists like JID, Tyler, and Denzel are hyped up by the online community to the point where they’re actually overrated. It doesn’t make you cool or unique to like these artists when 99% of people on the internet already do. You’re just feeding into the hive mind.

MusicEnjoyer8

This isn’t an opinion. This is a fact. Most influential hip hop artist of all time.

Slester TV

Impact is an importand criterion for how good an album is. Impact shows that the album stayed relevant through the years, really influenced people, and the sub-genre of it wouldn't be the same, if it wasn't for that album. That's why retrospective reviews of classic albums are most of the time better.

Herbieguy

Meta Take: The Beatles are the ONLY music artist that it's impossible to have a hot take on. With them being the most popular music group, every single take that could be said about them has been said 1000x over. There's no way to have a unique perspective on them anymore since all of them have been milked dry at this point.

Kai (From KaisTestKitchen)

Music exploration is important in personal growth. It gives you different perspectives and shapes you as a person

Zach Stolpa

Rock will continue to suck for the most part if the mentality of the more vocal part of its fanbase continues to beā€ it’s not as good as the old stuffā€ when being introduced to a new artist or band and giving them a chance to be in their music rotation.

Joseph K

Kinda a deep one here but something I’ve been thinking about. Does the nature of your job not allow you to change as a person? We are never a finished product and always are working to be better. Could having to standby opinions you had at a younger age, impede your progression as a person. After all, if I liked something today, there is no reason I can’t dislike it tmrw. The nature of your job however, discourages wavering opinions like this. Thanks Anthony luv what you do āœŒļø

Zach Stolpa

The first part I totally understand, but the second part I have to disagree cause the internet is pretty much constructed to make saying something more noticeable than in irl/mainstream so you are going to be more widely exposed to how an artist is particularly received.

Trevor Young

"Shredder" culture (i.e. Satriani, Vai, etc) will probably die off with the Gen-X'ers. It feels like younger generations are increasingly less interested in 'virtuosity' as musically valuable.

Gabe

Do you think that finally liking one project from an artist that you didn't previously like all that much makes you more open-minded when you check out some of their new releases? One example I'm thinking of would be Paramore, who you said that you didn't really like up until they released After Laughter. Do you think you'd be as big of a fan of their new singles if you hadn't heard a project that you liked from them beforehand? Hopefully this question makes sense to some extent.

New Music Jason

Ben Folds is one of the best songwriters of our time and deserves to be as famous as Springsteen.

Barish A

you never see any praise for Drake but everybody and their mom is bumping Drake out in the real world.

Christian Sharp

Not my opinion, but my partner thinks that Nirvana is buttrock, especially Nevermind and In Utero. And this makes me think that they don't understand what buttrock really is.

Barish A

Assigning point values to albums and comparing music using that as a metric is nonsensical, but it is our only method of meaningfully discussing our opinions in a way where the conversation can include as many people as possible. Pitchfork and other reviewers' points going down to one or two decimal places is just ridiculous. I like your system of light to decent to strong within each point, but you have to agree it's not a perfect system - and there will never be a perfect system because everyone views music and art in general so differently. People get so hung up on point values and what is overrated/underrated that I feel when people post takes about that kind of stuff, they don't even understand what they're actually arguing because what they think they are trying to argue doesn't actually make any sense.

Reid Sweatt

Big Thief’s ā€œDragon New Warm Mountainā€ is this generation’s The White Album. A double album that covers multiple bases, is the ultimate culmination of the quartets talents, is reliably fun to listen to, and the covers are white, obviously.

hiram rivera

Sade is one of the most important bands of the 80s - 90s as they not only changed what was acceptable in the mainstream but also changed the landscape of soul and many other genres.

MusicEnjoyer8

Well then maybe there is a reason people enjoy his music?

Filip KaÅŗmierczak

If you could soundtrack a road trip movie which song would start playing as the car drives away in the distance and credits start rolling? I would probably pick Instant Disassembley by Parquet Courts

Richard Lawson

Not sure If a turntable setup still worth it these days when you could spend the same amount of money on a high quality pair of headphones, and headphone amp, DAC and a lossless streaming service and theoretically have access to an unlimited library of high fidelity music.

Adrian Vargas

What nostalgic band has stayed with you all of these years? Is it your guilty pleasure? Do you even have a guilty pleasure?

Nicolas Babick

If I recall correctly you once mentioned something about wanting to write a book on your top 50/100 albums of all time towards the end of your career, is this still something you want to do eventually?

Ivan Antonio

Disco only "died" in the late 70s/early 80s because white people figured out we weren't as good at making it

Uncle Jam

You made fun of yet another "the Beatles are overrated" take in a recent Fantano Short. Are there any other music "hot takes" you've heard so many times that they just make you roll your eyes? Personally, I'd die happy if I never hear "Nirvana and/or Nevermind is overrated" again.

Bennett Gottesman

Roy Orbison, while certainly a little dated, is super underrated. He has a fantastic voice with great range. He sings with such powerful emotion. Songs like Crying and In Dreams are able to generate such distinct feelings. It’s haunting and beautiful. His songs make for some of the best moments in the films of David Lynch.

Bennett Gottesman

What do you think is the best use of a pop song in a movie? Some of my favorites are tiny dancer in almost famous and I’ve told every little star in mulholland drive

Alexander Einoder

Standards for lyrics and composition are drastically inconsistent between genres. If an alt rock or folk band had the content of the average 8/10 hip hop track it would be sub 6/10 easy. Similarly you can sing/rap absolute deadshit lyrics in a different language without anyone batting an eye.

William Maranci

ā€œonly god knows whyā€ by kid rock is the first major song with excessive autotune. it was recorded and released before ā€œbelieveā€ by cher , yet gets virtually no credit for being the first. in a sea of bro-country and in a time where nashville is courting a more trap-influenced sound, it may be the most forward thinking song i’ve ever heard in recent memory. also: DETROIT TILL I DIE, MOTHERFUCKER!!!!

kapildh

R&B seems to be your least favorite mainstream genre in general. You do give positive reviews on some records here and there. Still, I've always thought the classic contemporary R&B (classic meaning without any alternative touches) would be more "sleepy" for you to enjoy. Please change my mind with some album recommendations you greatly enjoy and think are the true staples of the genre.

Martha

Like a Rolling Stone is lyrically fantastic, but I can't help but feel like the references to Edie Sedgwick are kinda cruel and gross. Her life was tragic and it bothers me that she was treated like such a punching bag in art at the time.

I, II, II, IL

If it weren't for the "Death of Disco" Electronic dance music would be more popular in America. Evidence is that the "EDM Boom" of the late 2000s/early 2010s was designed to bring dance music to America, while in places like Europe it had been popular since the 80's

Squanto

The Flaming Lips early-90s stuff is severely underappreciated because it doesn’t sound like what they became known for later in their career. It’s not as dreamy or heavily arranged as their most popular works for sure and it’s a little unrefined. However, Clouds Taste Metallic and Transmissions are some of their finest records and laid down a lot of the sounds and tropes that would define the rest of their discography.

Squanto

I think he’s responded to this one more than once

Erik Vowels

Hip hop is sorely missing the rap duo. It's more popular these days to pair producer and lyricist, but stylistically there's something so unique about the back-and-forth flow of two MCs with great chemistry (Outkast, Clipse, Cannibal Ox, Mobb Deep) that you just can't replicate with one-off features. RTJ and Armand Hammer were standouts in the 2010s, so here's hoping for more this decade!

Jac

Fake band tier list please: Spinal Tap, Venus in Furs, Blues Brothers, Sex Bob-omb, The Committments, The Wonders, Steel Dragon... let's go!

Oscar Barroso

Am I weird to think that some mashup music are sometimes way better than the original work?

Jac

Where can I find a list of these mysterious artist ratings that apparently always exceed or underestimate their actual talent?

Sleepy Joe

Out of all Taylor Swifts albums(Taylor's version included), which one is your favorite and which one would you like to see be redone or done as a Taylor's version?

James Carlisle

Mr. Morale & The Big Steppers is gonna be one of those albums that grows on people overtime. there’s obviously some imperfections & uncomfortable moments throughout the album. but that’s a huge part of what makes it Kendrick’s most honest and human work of art. that’s a quality that i think will resonate with people more and more overtime.

Self-Aware Onion

What are your opinions on Korn? In certain videos you've said that you don't care for the band's first couple of records, but you respect the fact that they had a unique sound for the time. Are there any records/songs from them that you really enjoy? Personally I think that their first four records were all pretty decent.

Jordan Bickett

The only solution to the Taylor Swift ticket scandal is for her to perform all day, 7 days a week, until the sun explodes to have any hope of meeting demand. Otherwise, there just aren't enough tickets for everyone who wants one. I don't get the entitlement people feel to get an artificially low cost ticket thru a pre-sale, and balk at resale prices when that's more the actual value and if more people resold their tickets the prices would come down.

Nick

When doing your comparisons to other artists in reviews, do you feel the need to keep them consistent with artists that you push and/or do you usually keep it to artists and albums that you personally enjoy? E.g. Swans and LCD Soundsystem seem to come up a lot in reviews, even when a comparison may feel strange.

Jac

Yeah funny when people are confronted with the reality of the market economy. Supply n demand, b**ches... it's God's preferred economic system, right?

Jac

I feel like it would definitely be more popular if so much of it wasn't formulaic repetitive crap that excises the soul of samples for a cheap hook and relies on their listeners being so overstimulated that they think tedious looping is blessed relief, or (ironically) auditory nirvana.

Jac

This is a good question, but maybe constrain "pop song"? Do you mean any era? I enduringly love "I Say a Little Payer for You" in My Best Friend's Wedding, but does that count as a pop song? (it was in 1968...)

Jac

UK grime case in point :'-( *However*, if one is judging whether lyrics in another language are any good, caution is advised. Google Translate makes everyone sound like a complete idiot. "Enthusiasm is a matter of light in space by itself two times." - Einstein.

Jac

Is it Crazy Frog?? Is it? Is it?

Jac

road trip movie? King Gizzard Dripping tap surely

Jac

100%

Jac

Changing your mind is a sign of openness, growth, maturity, and progression. The flip-flop nonsense is anti-intellectual bs. imho.

Jac

I have an enduring affection for Weezer, despite them somehow typifying both the nuclear bomb of pop (sublime brilliance followed by toxic awfulness) and the unassailable cockroach of mainstream musical sensibility that it's dropped on.

Jac

I'm running with k-pop and j-pop redefining pop/dance/alt genres in a similar way to the reinvention of the Hollywood action movie (00s) and horror movie (10s) inspired by (or derivative of) Chinese and Korean productions

Jacob Dickens

Do you think the persistence of Mariah Carey’s All I Want for Christmas is You every holiday season could backfire on her in a generation or two when she ends up known to young people primarily as the woman who wrote the Christmas song? I don’t know how many kids are gonna grow up being familiar with Fantasy or We Belong Together vs. the annual memes of her omnipresence around Christmas time.

Lousey

I've noticed that during your NMF streams, almost always pause after a track is done playing, even on a full record; do you consider this to be an essential part of building your experience with a particular song? I find I have trouble committing some songs to memory if I've only played it once or twice; for me the only tracks that really stick on a cursory listen are the ones at the end of the record. If I pause, than this isn't an issue.

Alex Sim

thoughts on the YouTube creator @Spectre0799? this guy makes ridiculous "[ ] ...but it's just my voice" videos and the fact that he hasn't EXPLODED in recognition yet is incredible to me

Alexander Einoder

Wolfmother's self-titled album has proven itself to be a classic. Any track instantly elevates a soundtrack and fills the body with vigor (in addition to sweating the cheeks)

Jesse Short

Long ramble incoming: I'm curious as to your experience with the different mixes/vinyl pressings of The Beatles' discography since among audiophile Beatles fans that seems to be a topic of hot debate and can come up when discussing the production of certain Beatles albums since the mastering/mixing on different pressings/releases can be different. There are entire channels on YouTube (like Parlogram) entirely dedicated to examining the history of Beatles releases and comparing them in terms of mastering and sound quality. Some examples of schools of thought: Original Mono Mixes/Pressings are the only way to go through '68 since they were the ones the Beatles approved, the 2009 Stereo mixes that are the only non-remix stereo masters available on streaming are complete shit and should be disregarded, etc. It gets very much in the weeds in terms of pressing/mastering history and people have VERY strong opinions in vinyl/audiophile forums, so when commenting on new remixes it can be helpful to know your experience with these, considering that the true original stereo mixes of their albums have never been available on streaming.

Andrew Shaktah

Not every moment of music listening has to be through the best device or some high end Bluetooth speaker, sometimes just hanging out with music playing through a phone can be a vibe and I’d argue adds an almost lofi aesthetic when not all of the music can be heard clearly

Kenneth Mulvihill

Coping Mechanism by Willow was one of the best rock records on the year, maybe even of this decade. The growth Willow has made with this record is immense, and is most certainly a very unique record. She has brought an intensity to her music that is quite enjoyable and gives it a personality. Did not feel a dull moment on the record. Can’t wait for what she publishes in the future.

Christian Tom

I generally agree with you, as a old zoomer myself I've never really cared for this style of guitar playing, but I think it's taken on a completely different approach with younger guitar players like Tim Henson and Ichika Nito who have taken shredding to a more complex, interesting and melodic place. As long as they're making music I think this kind of virtuosity will continue to have legs going into the future.

Alivia Keatts

If an artist lacks instrumental/production skills, do you think it has potential hinder their music? If so, do you find that even with the most talented voice, it is essential to learn an instrument? Regardless of the plentiful behind the scene professionals, do you think there is a chance of disconnect or lost potential within the music?

Austin Blenkinsop

An overlooked component of Kendrick Lamar’s brilliance is how the narrative of one of his songs/albums is enhanced in the context of the rest of his discography. For example, the vivid depictions of his upbringing and Compton overall in GKMC make the survivors guilt experienced during TPAB so much more palpable. This is what makes the shedding of his saviour complex/role on Mr Morale such a watershed and impactful moment, as he was embracing said role for his whole career. We’ve truly been fortunate to see such a rich, layered and emotional portrait of this artist spanning across many bodies of work

The Needle Drop

we've covered a couple of his vids on the fantano channel; check em out

Alex Sim

something told me that that was the case but i had to shout him out just in case!!

Frankie P

You consistently go too hard on Chance!! šŸ˜”šŸ˜”ā¤ļø

Dirty Randy

Suffering is necessary for art.