Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you so much for all your support this month! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them later next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-drake-78000060

Comments

bressig

Duel of the Fates is a certified banger

MV Calil

Even though it's not the most influential or revolutionary to it's genre, Death's "Symbolic" may be the greatest metal album of all time, considering every possible subgenre. It has everything a great metal album should have: smart lyrics, remarkable riffs, a lot of energy, anger and groove

Josh

MF DOOM is the rap version of Frank Zappa. DOOM is your favorite rapper's favorite rapper and Zappa is your favorite guitarist's favorite guitarist. Same goes for Allan Holdsworth.

NevadaNate

Sarah McLachlan is underrated. The fact that the song "Angel" became a meme and that sappiness took over her career and image really distracts from how interesting her early work is. Her first album is, like, Celtic prog, and Fumbling Towards Ecstacy is really solid.

Danny Gillespie

I fully agree with your thoughts on Taylor Swift's Midnights, but it's strange you didn't review the "3 AM" tracks too. They're a lot more like the sound of Folklore, and generally the better songs on the album.

William Maranci

the beatles could never write a song as excellent as “champagne supernova”

bressig

you never posted a review or a YUNOREVIEW of Health's "Disco4: Part 2" album from last year even though you liked Part 1 and seemed to like a lot of the singles, did you ever get around to listening to the whole thing? if so what were your thoughts?

Herbieguy

It would be great to see Lizzo release an instrumental based / flute-centric album. Not only would it showcase her skills in the instrument to her harsher critics, but it also may inspire a lot of her female fans to pick up an instrument of their own. It would be nice to see a few more Alice Coltranes or Bobbi Humphreys in the world.

Lousey

When people ask you for a Redux review on an album, what they're really asking is "give the album a higher score"

Amealya Hike

Question- what do you do while you listen to music? I always imagine you have a very clean house, since I like to listen to new music while I clean.

James Jordan

GKMC vs. TPAB debate is hip hop's Blue Album vs. Pinkerton debate.

Tuck

LONG ONE: I am 23 and apart of Gen Z. I am a huge music fanatic like everyone else, and have listened to music all my life. I am NOT diagnosed with ADHD, but I feel as though I am an early victim being raised by the internet, which has effectively whittled my attention span down to basically nothing. I am completely addicted to my phone and cannot just simply sit down and watch a movie without needing to play a game on my phone, while also check Twitter, etc. The biggest problem though is that I cannot enjoy albums in the way I used to. I cannot simply enjoy a long album anymore, and I feel myself gravitating more to singles, or EPs. Do you have this problem? I know you have ADHD, and you're also online a lot, so what's your experience with this? I feel as though it's really taking away my full music experience and I want it back.

Ben

Miss Anthropocene was one of the biggest missed opportunities in an album, not only because it was very unrefined but I feel like it had massive potential. The singles were some of her best work to date and unlike anything any other artist is doing + they were just extremely enjoyable songs, yet the tracks on the album feel like Grimes just attempting to do 'good enough' with a lot of careless mistakes. It's really sad to see her going backwards as an artist and her recent output seems like a humongous waste of talent and creativity.

Christian Sharp

Purity Ring has a flawless discography. Shrines is their dark album, Another Eternity is the opposite of Shrines by being basked in light, and WOMB is their rebirth album

Danu Jackson

In Utero by Nirvana is better than Nevermind

Taycrens

ACDC is an overrated, over-played, uninspiring group and all of their songs sound the same.

Joshua C Holton

Vaporwave is a REAL genre and people should pay more attention to it.

Ben B

Ween is the greatest American rock band of all time Source: Beatles-quality hooks/riffs; unparalleled genre diversity and sonic experimentation; nine studio albums that range from good to just about flawless; kickass 3-hour live shows; witty and sarcastic but always sincere in their love for the music

Alex Sim

Do you prefer artists whose flames burn insanely brightly for a short period of time, or ones who have a steady output over decade(s) without ever making a "classic" album?

Nick

Where would Beach House’s Bloom rank for you in their discography these days? When you reviewed it back in 2012 you seemed very enthusiastic about it but when 7 was released, you’d drastically doubled-down on a lot of your comments about it. What do you feel may have caused that?

Evan Ortiz

What makes an S-tier track? I get chills just about every time I listen to a track I consider to be S-tier, but why? Because of how layered/multi-faceted it is? Because of its acclaim? Because of how substantial, or influential it might be? Context within the album it appears on? How technical or essential should a single track be in your mind to be regarded as one of the best songs ever recorded?

Benjamin Tirone Nunes

champagne supernova would just not exist without the beatles but ok

Andrew Shaktah

“Wake Me Up” was actually once a great song back when it was purely an auditory experience. Ever since the release of the music video, album art, Ben Affleck’s Dare Devil, and the various memes it’s become impossible to take seriously but when it lived purely in our minds and there were zero visual references to think of it was a great song.

ToadMan101

The Jonas Brothers were on par for the same career trajectory as Blur before initially breaking up in 2013. Sounds like the most insane statement, but as someone who's a massive fan of both acts, hear me out. The first album was getting into a genre that was pretty popular, but didn't stand out much from the crowd. Album two was the introduction of both acts into the musical style that they would become known for, while also becoming more hyped up in their respective scenes. While the third album was the huge mainstream breakthrough, the fourth album was pretty much a 'victory lap' of sorts, but with experimenting different sounds and unfortunately, selling less than their last record due to changing trends. (Blur had to deal with Oasis becoming more popular; Jonas Brothers and Hollywood Records as a whole dealt with another rising pop star with the initials of JB) Blur's fifth album was a direct 180 from their Britpop sound, and becoming more acclaimed for their alternative sound. The abandoned 2013 album for the Jonas Brothers was also a 180 in that sense, going from pop rock to diving into multiple sounds at the same time. I don't think it would've sold much though, given their declining name at the time. Would it have been more acclaimed than their previous albums were? Possibly, as most music critics learned to be poptimists between 2009 and 2013. Either way, I may be the only person in the world who thinks of this comparison, but it's kinda interesting. To clarify, after reuniting in 2019, I believe the music they put out since was when the Jonas Brothers no longer seemed to be on the same trajectory as Blur.

EZGames69

Vine was not better than tiktok, people seem to write off tiktok for having cringe users, yet completely forget that Vine gave people like Logan Paul a career.

Kyle Cahill

Do you think it's worse for a good album to have a bad opening track or a bad closing track?

WellSeeHowIFeelLater

Herbie Hancock’s Sextant doesn’t get the credit it deserves in the shadow of other experimental jazz albums like Bitches Brew. It paved the way for more synthesis-based and effects-driven jazz, and it also gave some hints toward the direction of ambient music, but often Head Hunters gets attention over it when it comes to that period of his work.

Andy Boy

(excluding american dream) every lcd soundsystem studio album got better and better than the last by A LOT

Drake Parker

Anthony, what is your personal favorite review that you’ve put out? Are there any particular reviews that stand out as you having a genuinely fun time, or just any review that you felt you really *killed it*?

Squanto

Mission of Burma were a far more cutting edge punk band than Sonic Youth was for the 80s. SY really is less impressive when you considered Signals, Calls, and Marches and Vs. we’re released in the early 80s and completely dump on any of SY’s material in that time


Zach Stolpa

Big time rush were more iconic than one direction

Zach Stolpa

In the the overall lore of rock music how should the foo fighters be viewed.

Squanto

In hindsight, you probably overrated Pure Comedy a little bit. Musically, it’s a pretty standard singer/songwriter album and FJM’s voice isn’t one of the most unique tbh. Obviously, it’s got a grand concept and themes, but it’s nothing special sonically


Hunter Eggers

The Bloodhound Gang may have been a one-trick (horny) pony, but they made the most of their time and have a surprisingly deep catalog of catchy songs

Rossyp

The saxophone was a prominent staple in most 80's music but has never resurfaced in pop music since. Bring back the sax solo!

Alexander Einoder

Mr morales is easily Kendricks weakest album lyrically. I don't know what all the hype is about. I mean production is 10/10 for sure but features are boring overly autotuned pop vocals mostly, the acted scenes are gratingly monotonous at best and there isnt anything really memorable or catchy (any hooks?) Even Ghostface is boring. Is this just the standard for pop-rap now or what?

memphis rap gf

When people talk about "west coast hip hop" or using "west coast style" as a descriptor for a song or artist, they should just call it "California hip hop/style" instead because 49 times out of 50 they're NEVER thinking about Washington or Oregon. As a native Oregonian our only good musical export is Aminé and his music sounds like it could come from any major US city. Washington has some great musical exports, but the ones that come to mind (Big 4 of Grunge, Phil Elverum, Modest Mouse, etc) aren't distinctly west coast either.

Caspa

So I've listen to Numerous rap albums and the more I go back to TPAB the more emotionally compelled moved I am not only by the talent ,message and production buy the over all story and sequence so can we finally say TPAB is the greatest Rap Albun of all time?

Endseeker

Bullet For My Valentine is one of the greatest Metalcore bands. They're more influential to the genre than people think just cuz they had a span of a few meh albums before becoming great again ( I love all their albums tho)

Caspa

That would be hilarious .

Alex Alcalde

Childish Gambino is one of the most overrated artists of my generation. Atlanta is fantastic but most of his other work is nothing to write home about.

Pink Bolo Club

Berlin is one of Lou Reed's best and the superior album to Transformer. The way the music completes the story he tells through the lyrics is just immaculate, exploring some of the darkest and most depressive corners of humanity and tinkers with how broken people respond to incredibly fucked up circumstances under the influence of drugs, corruption and apathy. Although the album has been getting some more love recently, it is still quite underrated, in my opinion.

Kai (From KaisTestKitchen)

I'm not going to waste my time on an album that's more than 75 minutes unless it's an artistic like then it gets bumped up to 90 minutes

Austin Blenkinsop

Marvin Gaye's "What's Going On" is one of the few albums that can simultaneously evoke a strong sense of existential dread and an equally palpable sense of hope and faith in humanity.

lazarusinashes

I've been listening to Have a Nice Life's Voids, which contains the original version of Destinos, which was remade on Sea of Worry. In your review of Sea of Worry, you took issue with the sample being so long on Destinos, and you felt as though it was not related to the track at all. However, on the original Destinos (which is now on streaming under Destinos - Demo), you get a clearer picture of what the sample is there for; "what grounds does God have to forgive the most vile and wretched of people?" repeats, growing more and more distorted, and it's clear the sample is there as a way for HANL to ask, "What grounds does God have to forgive me?" Because I understood what the sample was there for, I have no issue with the length of the sample on the new version of Destinos. And I wonder, has your perspective shifted on certain tracks, or even albums, based on recontextualization of this sort? For example, let's say you listened to the original Destinos and gained a new appreciation for the sample on the new Destinos, resulting in you withdrawing your gripe. Does this ever happen to you?

Jack Bayley

Just wondering, as an Australian I don’t hear you talk too often about a lot of classic Australian artists (outside a handful like Nick Cave and such). Just wondering if there are any in particular that you find to be really great! In my opinion Silverchair are an over hated band and deserve a bit of a critical re-evaluation, especially considering their progression over the years!