Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thanks so much for all your support this month! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them later next week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-rym-79319969

Also I'm taking a break from doing the main edits for the series on our YouTube channel, but will continue to do so here. Last month's episode was very fun imo; let's keep up that energy!

Comments

Navarrm

What are the music-based conspiracies you find most entertaining?

Dennis Vilensky

There is simply too much music. I need all artists to pause putting out new music so I can catch up on the last 50+ years first.

Jake Bell

London bridge>fergalicious

Spencer Portis

Ska is going to come back in a huge way. Zoomer Ska will be inescapable. I don’t have any evidence for this, I just feel it in my bones.

Nick Larsen

Kurt Rosenwinkel’s Heartcore was way ahead of its time and underrated for the specific way it blended jazz and hip hop with help from Q-Tip. Its influence is now being seen with the likes of Domi + JD (who featured Kurt on a track on their album) but continues to be a gem off of most people’s radar

Pink Bolo Club

Lou Reed's best solo record is Berlin, and not even close.

MV Calil

Even though it's not the most influential or revolutionary to it's genre, Death's "Symbolic" may be the greatest metal album of all time, considering every possible subgenre. It has everything a great metal album should have: smart lyrics, remarkable riffs, a lot of energy, anger and groove

bressig

Musicians who reference other, better songs/artists in their own lyrics for clout should have their writing privileges revoked

jeff

imogen heap deserves more credit as one of the most influential electronica/pop songwriters of this generation. her influence can be seen in artists from bon iver to porter robinson, to a.g. cook, to caroline polachek. she's also one of the most sampled artists ever in the cloud rap subgenre, but still underrecognized for her contributions to modern music

Nolan Reiling

The Forever Story is a poor man's GKMC. The individual production, lyricism, flows, and narrative are all far better on GKMC. Additionally, The Forever Story is very forgettable having few memorable moments, whereas GKMC has incredible highs with The Art of Peer Pressure, m.A.A.d city, and SAMIDOT.

Opiemes

Kid Cudis MOTM trilogy is superior to Kanye’s Graduation trilogy

Herbieguy

Buying vinyl without the intent to play it is at best a giant waste of your money and at worst insulting to other record collectors. Someone else could be enjoying that album but instead you're letting it collect dust as a glorified house decoration. It'd be like buying a PS5 and using it as a drink table. If you're not gonna play the album just get a poster for fuck sake.

Nkosi Kamal

The American Gothic By Vernon Harris was the best rap album of 2022 and no one acknowledges it. From the dense and layered concept and story to the well crafted and forward production it stands toe to toe with The Forever Story and even Mr.Morale.

Greenville_Gent

Drake is a terribly disappointing headliner for Dreamville Festival. Usher isn't much better.

Tuck

Who's the best panderer? In other words, out of all the inauthentic panderers out there, whose talent and high quality music overpowers their inauthenticity? I'm mostly just talking about stylistic pandering. My example would be John Fogerty/CCR. The dudes were from Nor Cal and made arguably the best southern rock of all time.

Josh Brown

How do I know if a creative idea is worth pursuing? I have always wanted to make music but am not a skilled singer and can't play any instruments. Recently I have started jotting down some lyrics I think could turn into something but am not sure if they are good or really dumb. I have never been good at creative songwriting either and I don't want to invest energy into something that will come out sounding really stupid.

Bunny Mayhem

hot take is that small bands (eg. Faetooth- please listen to them!) would totally take off if it weren’t for the fact tons of people won’t give small bands a chance

Hogan99

The Moody Blues are one of the most underrated rock bands of all time. Their "original 7" albums are extremely influential in the world of progressive and symphonic rock, and they don't get talked about nearly as much as their peers such as Pink Floyd, Genesis, Yes, etc. Just listen to the album "Days Of Future Passed", which came out a few years before prog really started to explode, that album has every trademark sound of a 70's progressive rock album, and its a concept record. An incredible band that should be re-evaluated.

Alex Sim

Timbaland's beats have aged in a really strange way. On one hand, they sound awesomely futuristic and i dont think that any other producers have been able to replicate the sounds of his drums or his particular sense of rhythm. At the same time, when I hear some of what I consider to be his best beats (The Way I Are, Dirt Off Your Shoulder, Big Pimpin, etc), they sound.. a little corny? But also so f***** hard??

The Needle Drop

i will pass this one to Anthony but in the meantime will also recommend the "too old to be making music" vid we posted recently, as his commentary there kinda touches on your closing concern. a personal recommendation fwiw is, if you intend to self-record, to set aside some time to get a handle on that. the process can be trial & error, but not too bad. first takes can often be the most potent, so you wanna be prepared for them

Marek Moreno

In your "These Albums are 10s" series, you shout out 5 records from a given decade that you think are 10s, but mention this might not be all the records from that decade worthy of a 10. For all of the 2010s though, you gave only 5 10s total. If there is at least one more 10 per decade you left off each video, why do you think the 2010s had the lowest number of 10s? Is it easier to pick out incredible records from decades you don't have to live through moment to moment (i.e. ideas might seem more novel without listening to all the copycat albums/weaker albums), or do you think the 2010s just had less greatness than decades of yore?

Anonymous

Brian May's hair is the worst part of Queen.

TheEggMcWaffle

NieR: Automata has the best soundtrack in a video game and it’s not even close. Every single song blends perfectly in with the mood and atmosphere the game is trying to build at any given time, plus the concept of coming up with a completely new language for a piece of music is an awesome concept that should be explored more

Noah Coleman

People who think favourite ≠ best are insecure about their opinions. If you think album A is more enjoyable than album B but you think album B is better from a lyrical or conceptual standpoint, shouldn't mean it's better in your eyes, the main variable that determines the quality of music is the amount of enjoyability and pleasure the listener gets out of it.

I, II, II, IL

Justin Hawkins of The Darkness has a better taste (and appreciation) in music than you.

Vishal Rameshbabu

Where does music start and end? When does a collection of sounds turn into music? I'm not making a Ben Shapiro "rap isn't music" suggestion, I'm wondering where we draw the line between random sounds and music. Basically everyone sees an instrumental solo as music and most people a drum solo. A lot of people see noise like Merzbow as music. Is music just whatever our brains inherently pick up as "music" or is it just culturally defined? Is it cultural or psychological or both?

Squanto

The Rolling Stones only have 2-3 good songs on there albums, the rest is kinda just there tbh. The only exception to this rule is Sticky Fingers, all of their other classic albums have a great disparity in quality between the hits and deep cuts.

Drake Parker

Louder for those in the back

Matthew Rhoney

I’ve been trying to figure out a track list for tpab is untitled unmastered we’re the deluxe version of the album. Is this possible?

Tyler Bonpietro

AI generated music is probably going to be mediocre and soulless but is going to absolutely dominate the pop charts, especially if it can capture the nature of virality and tik-tok culture (read: write a good earworm)

Edwin A.

Is "Reviewing Your Music" ever coming back?

PurplySkye

Logic's Highlife on his new record is the best song on it. It has simple but effective production, the vocal mix is pleasant, and the track is just good vibes all around.

Dirty Randy

There is a pretty definitive “girl pop” sound but there doesn’t seem to be a pin on “boy pop”. Where is all the boy pop? I don’t think something like Troye Sivan counts.

Ben B

I was obsessed with DoFP and To Our Children’s Children’s Children for a while

wordsfrombirds

mainstream alternative music is to the point where it’s now a bunch of indiscernible synth pop and it’s all tame impalas fault

Andrew Shaktah

Lose Yourself is the white mans Juicy

NevadaNate

Mmm maybe this applies to some others but Let It Bleed has great deep cuts too and Exile on Main St. is very consistent

Slester TV

Hurt Nine inch nails > Johnny Cash

Slester TV

You said the score is based on your personal enjoyment of the album. But why is not in rainbows your #1 radiohead album since as you've said is your favourite?

Slester TV

I mean it's not always about how many 10s it does have. For example 2010s might have more strong 9s. It might also have more variety in music. I personally don't judge a decade for how many 10s does it have

Slester TV

The outkast's skits on early albums are cringe.

EZGames69

What was better? TikTok or Vine?

Nick

The only reason why people are sticking by the debut Maroon 5 album is by virtue of how terrible their discography gets afterwards. Otherwise, we mostly likely would’ve forgotten about Songs About Jane by now.

Squanto

Sad, but true. Every “alternative” playlist on streaming services is just a bunch of washed out psych pop

Squanto

I can’t remember what half the track list sounds like on Exile on Main St tbh. I think Let It Bleed is pretty bookended except for Monkey Man

Uncle Jam

It's super obnoxious when artists remove their lyrics from lyric websites. (Examples: Your Old Droog, Mach-Hommy, Cocteau Twins.) I'm sure their reasons for doing so seem justified to them, but those lyrics matter because they wrote and performed them and they're part of what makes their songs feel complete. Withholding them just feels arbitrary and somewhat petty.

Adam Washington

In your review of Sea of Worry, you took issue with the sample being so long on Destinos, and you felt as though it was not related to the track at all. However, on the original Destinos (which is now on streaming under Destinos - Demo), you get a clearer picture of what the sample is there for; "what grounds does God have to forgive the most vile and wretched of people?" repeats, growing more and more distorted, and it's clear the sample is there as a way for HANL to ask, "What grounds does God have to forgive me?" And I wonder, has your perspective shifted on certain tracks, or even albums, based on recontextualization of this sort? For example, let's say you listened to the original Destinos and gained a new appreciation for the sample on the new Destinos, resulting in you withdrawing your gripe. Does this ever happen to you? Full disclosure I've been listening to Voids for years, and because I understood what the sample was there for, I have no issue with the length of the sample on the new version of Destinos.

Zach Stolpa

People are hesitant to the label of metal music more than actual metal music.

Kyle

Dave Mustaine is a terrible vocalist. Even on Megadeth’s better written songs (e.g. Holy Wars), the vocals come off as campy and annoying and just an absolute turn off for me. Guy can play guitar like nobody’s business but I feel like whoever let him front the band owes me civil damages

Kyle Cahill

You have to choose one of these hypothetical albums to review: An album that has all 5-6/10 tracks or an album where half of the songs are 10/10 and the other half is 0/10. Which would you choose?

lazarusinashes

My question is one about recontextualization: have you ever had something recontextualized, which shifts your perspective on a particular track? Not necessarily hearing in the context of the album. For example, in your review of Sea of Worry, you took issue with the sample being so long on Destinos, and you felt as though it was not related to the track at all. However, on the original Destinos (which is now on streaming under Destinos - Demo), you get a clearer picture of what the sample is there for; "what grounds does God have to forgive the most vile and wretched of people?" repeats, growing more and more distorted, and it's clear the sample is there as a way for HANL to ask, "What grounds does God have to forgive me?" And I wonder, has your perspective shifted on certain tracks, or even albums, based on recontextualization of this sort? For example, let's say you listened to the original Destinos and gained a new appreciation for the sample on the new Destinos, resulting in you withdrawing your gripe. Does this ever happen to you? Full disclosure I've been listening to Voids for years, and because I understood what the sample was there for, I have no issue with the length of the sample on the new version of Destinos.

lazarusinashes

I reposted this and JUST realized I could've just edited my original comment. I have an IQ of 2

Cheekapo Teetoo

Has anyone asked for a review the latest album by Sauce Walka? I think Needle Drop might like it a lot.

Machine Gun Philly

â€ȘI feel like bands such as The Red Hot Chili Peppers and Pearl Jam rarely get enough credit for all of the QUALITY artists that they influenced. Instead they get all the blame for either bad rap-rock or post-grunge that came out in their wake, unlike Nirvana who always seem to avoid blame. I think they both deserve way more credit in this regard (I say this as a guy who doesn’t even enjoy a lot of RHCP, I’m just trying to be fair). **Please note that I am not asking you to reiterate these lists below verbally, but I am including them for visual reference** RHCP - SZA, Kanye, Sublime, RATM, Korn, Incubus, Anderson.Paak, Lana Del Rey, Linkin Park, Lil Peep, Incubus, System of a Down (etc.) plus, yes, nu-metal and Nickelback Pearl Jam - The Strokes, Jack White, Ben Gibbard, Taking Back Sunday, John Mayer, Ellie Goulding, The Fleet Foxes, Pharaoh Monche, Arcade Fire, Post Malone, St. Vincent, The Killers, Gaslight Anthem, Sleater-Kinney, The War on Drugs (etc.) plus, yes, Creed and post-grunge

Machine Gun Philly

Alicia Keys could have been the R&B version of Fiona Apple. Instead she went on autopilot after her first two records and clung to safe-sounding singles and mediocrity. She’s basically the musical equivalent of a highly skilled business admin major - high IQ and talent, but floor level ambition and absolutely zero penchant for risk-taking. She was barely more distinctive than Jordin Sparks (!!) What a waste of such incredible talent.

Drake Parker

Indie pop is a contradiction

Christian Sharp

Homework is the best Daft Punk album not only because of how enjoyable it is, but because it's Daft Punk's most experimental album ever (even more than Random Access Memories)