Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you so much for supporting us this month! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em in the comments below and we'll look through them all in like a week or two—you have plenty of time to cook. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-not-85389320

Comments

Genatossio3000

The Velvet Underground’s 1969 self titled is THE essential indie rock record

Jules Pearce

Awaken my love was a key factor in developing albums like IGOR in terms of break late 2010’s and 2020’s genres and its high quality let it do that.

Alex Sim

Threads is the perfect platform for The NEEDLE Drop

Alex Sim

how do you like to be approached (if at all) by fans in public?

bressig

Duel of the Fates is a certified banger and ALMOST makes The Phantom Menace worth watching, John Williams is the GOAT

Shalom Guy

HOT TAKE: Michael Jackson is overrated as hell! If you listen to all the albums under his discography from Got to Be there to Invincible he has only four hits, and 4/10 does not the GOAT make

Dan Riskey

When are we getting the AnCo tier list? Need to know your full thoughts on Spirit They're Gone and Strawberry Jam

Alex Sim

does remixing/remastering an album "ruin" it when the vibe/memory of the album itself is so tied to its poor mixing/mastering?(examples like Californication, VU stuff, Springsteen's Nebraska, etc.)

Andrew Bradford

Most of the people listed as songwriters on music these days are doing arrangement which does not legally qualify as songwriting but their name and arrangements are popular so the producers push the real writers to give them credit.

Benjamin Lisboa

Melon needs to make a bass apology video for calling 2023 mid

Titas Mičiulis

Although this should have been discussed and regulated more often before, it's great to see the importance of concert etiquette being brought to light now with recent events (the Adele, Bebe Rexha, Paramore, Tyler the Creator, P!nk etc. concerts). Do you think the recent media coverage regarding this topic will help prevent these incidents? Could this change the entire landscape of concert safety? And, most importantly, now that Travis Scott has tour dates coming up again, will people learn from their mistakes once and for all?

Duke86fan

How do you deal with the possibility of musical burnout? I find it hard to listen to the hundreds of other albums available that I kinda dissociate from the music

Nick Denhalter

The TEMPS album that James acaster made with a bunch of Quelle Chris features and some open Mike Eagle features too, is easily the most overlooked album of this year (including by you). I was so stoked when you reviewed its single which you seemed to like a lot, which I why I was surprised we never got a full album review

Andrew Shaktah

I think people trying to get into Death Grips for the first time should actually end their journey with Exmilitary

Herbieguy

Herbie Hancock, Chick Corea, and Joe Zawinul. All three are legendary Fusion Keyboardist, amazing band leaders, and essential sideman to Miles Davis' Golden period. How would you rank them from favorite to least?

Danu Jackson

what is your opinion on how music fans hold their favorite musicians on a pedestal and when said musician does something different, the fans automatically attack said artists? i've been seeing it a lot with former doja cat stans

Tuck

Fuck Marry Kill: Marvin Gaye- Heard It Through The Grapevine Creedence Clearwater Revival- Heard It Through The Grapevine The Slits- Heard It Through The Grapevine

FuturisticPat

Music from any specific decade or era is not unequivocally better than other eras of music. People who say so are usually blinded by nostalgia or are just trying to be different. There's too many variables and music that flies under the radar to be able to compare eras or years for music.

FuturisticPat

Candy corn is fire and the people who say otherwise are wrong

Filip KaĆșmierczak

Zooropa is the most underrated U2 album. Nearly all of the tracks hit, there industrial vibe of the instrumentation creates a consistent atmosphere for the record and the fact that they managed to make "Numb" such an earworm despite centering it around those monotone vocals and screeching guitar is really impressive. Personally I think it's the biggest highlight of their 90s output and the last great album they have released

ToadMan101

One of the things that's irritated me regarding the discussion of Olivia Rodrigo's 'vampire' and her upcoming LP GUTS, is the complaints from people who are saying that the vibes are "too similar to SOUR" and that the lead single is "an uninspired retread of drivers license". In general, I think there's this unrealistic expectation from people these days (especially towards female artists, tho recently some males have gotten this flak as well) to always have a new era/aesthetic with a new album that drops. That the next project is supposed to be a "big event". For an artist like Olivia, she should not have a dramatic switch up after only having one album under her belt. The people complaining about this new song being too similar are a bit too blind to realize that for someone with a rapid mainstream rise as Olivia, having a dramatic shift to something completely unconventional than what she's currently known for might alienate a ton of her audience. I always thought this album was mainly going to be a more mature version of SOUR's strongest elements, and so far, that's what I've been hearing, which I'm curious to see how it all turns out. Now with that being said, in general, sure, switching up with a new aesthetic/era can be fun, but I'm of the personal belief that artists should only do so if they're in a really comfortable position to do so/if the creative part of their brain is really pushing towards a certain aesthetic.

Kai

Nirvana is way better than Foo Fighters but Everlong is better than every Nirvana song.

ToadMan101

I think it depends on the type of listener one is and what the album exactly is. For example, while I don't think Metallica's Death Magnetic is all that good, there are some songs that I do enjoy off it, like That Was Just Your Life. Unfortunately, the album is mixed so poorly in part thanks to the "loudness wars", so I really can't volunteer myself to actually listen to it. However, there has recently been a re-mixing and re-mastering from someone on YouTube that I've downloaded, and now I enjoy the song to all of its content. Yes, I also know the Guitar Hero stems exist, but the mixing wasn't exactly so superb as the example I've linked below. (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ketQzC1YTJw)

Adrian Vargas

Is finding an album you enjoy more rewarding nowadays than it was back then? Because you had to buy the physical release, listen to it, & basically risk having spent your money for nothing versus streaming it. But because of how much more saturated the internet is with music, finding a "diamond in the rough" can be rewarding as well. Thoughts?

Noah Coleman

Only listening to 1-2 genres of music because they're the only genres you believe you like is just blatant ignorance to all the music out there across all genres. If you sit down and listen to the essential works of all the main genres in music, you should be able to enjoy a majority of them to some extent.

EZGames69

Pendulum was very ahead of their time when it comes to the way they mixed EDM and rock music. It’s amazing how well their music has aged despite being from the late 2000s, if these songs came out today they would still sound super fresh. Also Rob Swire is an underrated vocalist.

Tuck

something tells me Strawberry Jam is his fav

New Music Jason

People don’t listen to New Music as they age because they’ve already heard and decided what they think is ‘The Best’. The urge to continue searching dissipates, and the gate-keeping begins.

Deejay Cloney

Music To Be Murdered By is a great album and a step in the right direction for Em. Sure there’s some corny bars & the pop features are a bit overdone, but the beats, hooks & flows on a lot of the songs sound fresh for Em, especially on songs like Yah Yah or Darkness

Drake Parker

Why do 3s get red flannels if 7s don’t get yellow flannels? The scale is unbalanced

Hello There

You and LosPollosTV make a cute couple. Not a take, just an observation. You two should go on a date. Maybe a quaint little night out at a small club playing One Dance. Or a late night Drake and Drive playing Liability.

Caspa

Rank these bands worst to best even though they're all great The Stooges,Bad Brains ,Minor Threat,Misfits and Dead Kennedys

Squanto

Hard agree

Squanto

It kinda has been tho, not really that many major releases or smaller records that stand out too much

Deejay Cloney

“Ordinary Man” by Christy Moore is the best song ever written

Sillst

Future Bass is the EDM genre which I think has had the most squandered potential thus far. In theory, it should be a genre with plenty of good records due to the typically lush and beautiful sound palettes utilized. However, not many producers have taken advantage of them and instead have opted to create senseless club "bangers" Also, during its brief stint in mainstream relevancy, The Chainsmokers were the main purveyors of the genre, so that likely didn't help things

Zach Stolpa

Any chance we can get a Patreon “let’s agree” for one of these months and if not can you at least agree that “send me on my way” by rusted root is a damn great song? Like imagine that being the first song you listen to if you’ve never heard music before.

Tazmanian

No matter how good JPEGMAFIA is, he will never win rap album of the year. His style is not taken seriously by the Recording Academy. I would love to see SCARING THE HOES win it this year, but the fact that his style is seen more as a joke than anything else will prohibit it from getting past maybe a nomination at best.

Hendrix

LET'S AGREE's are a breath of fresh air even though it presents the pickle that you have to find correct takes amongst the mad patrons. "Your takes are garbage" is one of the funniest LET'S ARGUE eppy's. I'm all for more abuse for me and my fellow patrons cherry picking the bad rather than the good takes and mercilessly destroying them. Just a suggestion.

HM James

Sonic Youth’s album Goo is better than Daydream Nation. I think the guitars and song writing are a lot more flushed out on Goo and it genuinely feels that they had a lot of fun making it. Daydream Nation is too bouncy.

The Needle Drop

those episodes do turn out good (esp the first one), but they were also born out of my frustration going through entire threads and not finding a single usable tweet out of the 300 or so that would load. so eh, let's just try keeping things fresh around here. (this is Austen btw; Anthony tends to be less uptight lol)

Hendrix

I... Agree

Nick

Given your proximity to James Acaster, your appearance on his Perfect Sounds podcast and mentioning in his book about the music of 2016. Could you see yourself interviewing or appearing on podcasts hosted by other comedians in the future? E.g. an Ed Gamble discussion seems reasonably plausible to me.

Chris Hickson

I never understood why Evil Empire by RATM didn’t get the same level of critical acclaim as the self titled. The aggression was definitely on par with the first record and the performances were MUCH tighter on Evil Empire as well. There is definitely an equal amount of essential Rage songs on both records and I’m tired of people pretending that there isn’t!

Drake Parker

Saxophone is almost always way too loud

Hendrix

Bagpipes are the most annoying instrument of all time. It's just the least subtle, shrill blaring imaginable and it's impossible to use Bagpipes as part of a modern song. Other terrible instruments can be used sparingly in modern songs without ruining the whole thing. The only reason Bagpipes are not extinct is their place in Scottish history. All Bagpipes in the world should be ceremoniously destroyed in a sweet, cleansing fire. Case closed.

gingerfish

I see your take and I raise you a “Blood & Butter” by Caroline Polachek

Hendrix

Challenge accepted. I will listen to the bagpipes in that song with pricked ears and report back to you. I do love me some Caroline.

Hendrix

I think Sinead O'Connor's "Nothing Compares 2 U" is the greatest cover song of all time. The Fugees' "Killing Me Softly" is a close second for me. They both eclipse the original by a mile. What is your favorite cover song of all time? What is an underrated cover?

Herbieguy

I mean, I agree with you but this seems a bit 'cold' of a take. Bagpipes are kind of a punchline in the music world. Up there with recorders and triangles.

Kyle Cahill

Time for a hypothetical situation!!! If you were to start doing reviews in 2020 instead of 2009, what albums from the 2010s would you do for various “classics weeks?”

Chris Hickson

What is the best music movie? My money is on Almost Famous or School of Rock

Slester TV

Probably has to do with groundbreakingness. I agree with you, but when you have done something in the past, people don't care about it that much if you do it again, even if you executed it better. Take for example the Fleet Foxe's sophomore. It is way better than the debut but still the debut is the most acclaimed one.

Slester TV

Public image ltd are better than sex pistols

Slester TV

Outsider's music should get more recognition considering some of the stuff that came back then from artists like Wesley Willis or Shooby Taylor, if they weren't written from a mentally ill person would be considered experimental masterpieces.

Greninka

pestilence's spheres is a great album and show be respected on the same level as unquestionable presence or focus. most of the hate comes from what it isn't rather than what it is, and being a big change in style doesn't make the record any worse

Slester TV

A song being overplayed isn't a factor to judge if the song is good or not. I see so many people using that argument to describe a song as bad, when it's wrong. A better point would be if the song passes the test of time and doesn't sound boring/derivative after time, but not if it's overplayed.

Hendrix

I did not mean for this shout to become topical. What a shame about Sinead...I love her music.