Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Update  Thank you so much for the kind words, everyone. But to clarify, the 2nd Garbage Takes episode was the final (non-Patreon) LET'S ARGUE episode I've edited, and that is partly where I am coming from. Every vid on the fantano channel since some point in 2018 is edited and published by me, unless there is a credit in the description box.

Hey, this is Austen. This is going to be a kind of self-indulgent post and sorry for that, but I don't really have another venue to give my thoughts directly like this and get feedback, which obviously yours will be valuable to me and appreciated.

Gonna be kind of vague and just ask, how do you guys feel about my editing on the fantano channel? Like, do I do just enough, too little, or too much? Basically I hear all three sometimes and would like to know if there's like a consensus. I'd also like to take some constructive criticism into account going forward. Will leave it at that for now. Lemme know and thank you in advance!

Comments

Andrew Conrad

The editing has added a lot more entertainment to the videos IMO.

cranderveldt

Trust your instincts, you do a great job editing! I've enjoyed your editing voice as it has evolved over the years and I hope it continues to delight. No notes.

Sev Obzen

Don't have much to add other than I've been happy with what you've been doing. Keep up the good work. Don't let anyone convince you into making things too chaotic.

Reid Sweatt

I say keep having fun with the editing. As an editor myself, I find that often times, leaning into the absurdity and rolling with the off-the-cuff ideas results in a fun edit. I love the videos y’all make.

Andy Boy

the editing is getting better with each video please keep doing what you’re doing

Adam F.

The editing is one of my favourite parts of the videos. It never feels forced, and I always find that it either adds to the entertainment value, or provides some insight or context into something I might not be familiar with that Anthony brings up. I think you have struck a perfect balance of adding enough to each video without distracting from the main content

The Needle Drop

thank you; I love having this supportive role. some ppl don't like when i interject w/ the text onscreen but i try to keep that to a minimum

Saku Lintala

Do whatever you find natural! Your and Anthony's sense of humour compliment each other, and the editing is one of my favorite things about Anthony's videos. Keep it up!

The Needle Drop

eh that's partly where i'm coming from. i haven't been editing those LA episodes. tbh i've been grappling w/ ocd, which has contributed to me not editing the series anymore (besides patreon). but i'm happy ppl enjoy Ryan's style

Brian Carey

I laughed so much when fantano was talking about Boom Boom Pow and he said he liked the slide effect on "Boom" and you enlarged his head like a balloon as he sang it. Keep doing your thing Austen.

Malcolm Perez-Rios

Definitely noticed a change in the editing pacing of the most recent Let's Argue. You giving Anthony a little bit more space in between his thoughts was interesting, but I personally think the quicker cuts from prior videos suited the energy better? It might also be because I'm more used to those quicker cuts having watched the channel for so long tho! Either way, you're a great editor and bring such an important style to the channel, you're doing such an awesome job!!

Jac

I love AF/tND, but nothing truly great is a one-man band. What you (and other editors?) add is like a great novel/movie/TV series where the side characters really make it. No matter how great the hero/antihero, it's always the supporting characters that take it to the next level. Keep adding your spin and humour, without undermining AF's sorely needed independent and personal viewpoint, and you have gold.

Kai (From KaisTestKitchen)

I love the editing. It's getting better with each video and the more freedoms you get. Keep it up !

CarlySortof

Your editing is phenomenal without being showy. The recent Let's Argue on youtube with the guest editor is funny for the intro for sure, but if they edited the whole thing they do not get the jump cuts right and it winds up feeling kinda slow, stunted, and awkward throughout. that doesn't happen for 99% of the videos

Titas Mičiulis

I've definitely noticed a solid continuity across all of the different videos and the way they are edited, and also creative use of imagery behind Fantano. In terms of constructive criticism I can't say much except perhaps for the little editor notes that pop up occasionally that disappear really quick. I know the timing is likely made like that on purpose and it might just be a personal dislike, whenever I have to scroll back a bunch of times and try to pause at the perfect millisecond moment. They could maybe be a bit slower? But with everything else the quick pacing actually really works, the cuts are great and it really feels like you put a shit ton of work into all of these and I have the upmost respect. 💜

Herbieguy

The editing is just beautiful and I will not hear otherwise.

Tuck

I've really enjoyed the recent development of your personality coming through in videos like the Parannoul review. I think you're doing a great job.

Sean.

Idk anything about Fantanos editors but the latest Let’s Argue I saw was edited slightly slower than they typically are. Usually the cuts are more abrupt where in that video Fantano kept staring at the camera for a milisecond too long and makes it feel kinda off

Carmen Lipp

If youre on a computer pausing and typing the comma or period key will move the video frame by frame.

Andy

I feel like your personality has really come through in the editing over the past few months. It’s always been there, but recently I notice it more, which is great! I don’t think anything is too slow, too fast, etc. it’s your own unique style and we are all here for it!

Guy Mendes

I've never seen a better marriage between your editing style and Melon's presentation. I've noticed you gave melon more breathing room in the more recent let's argue, instead of the sharp and tight presentation you usually go for, not better or worse IMO, but different.

Barish A

I like the style! Keeps it fun. I guess my only complaint would be the little snarky responses to what Melon is saying that are only there for a millisecond, but I feel like thats the whole point of that anyway. Just sometimes hard to scrub through the video and stop where i can read them

The Needle Drop

yooo! what a coincidence. glad you've gotten better; congrats!

The Needle Drop

Yeah I get this sometimes. The subliminal nature of them is kind of a holdover from the early says of TND, when Anthony himself would put quick bits of text onscreen. Recently I've started putting my interjections onscreen longer. It's just mostly funny when ppl are like "look at editor trying to be the main character" when i'm trying to stay out of the way and be easily ignorable 😅

Barish A

Personally, I really enjoy and appreciate your snarky comments haha, especially when Fantano is contradicting himself or a previous comment he made and you're calling him out about it. My complaint wasn't about the text itself but just how quickly they disappear. All in all though this is really not a big deal, just me thinking real hard for any piece of criticism or feedback I can provide. Also the speed of the text does make it so most people can just watch past and ignore, while anybody else, like me, who cares about what you say can go back and read the message. I'd say keep em coming but maybe experiment with how long they are on the screen for? You've definitely had some bangers there, but I'm also sure I've missed a ton of them when I wasn't giving my full attention to the video and having it on on the background.

The Needle Drop

oh i didn't take your comment personally ha; thanks for your feedback!

The Needle Drop

hey sorry, can you hmu? i'm not able to dm you it seems. Patreon ate my message 😭

Herbieguy

Wait, why did you have to stop editing the main channel Let's Argue-s?

The Needle Drop

basically i requested a break from the segment to work on a personal project, and Ryan stepped up. simultaneously, ocd had been making editing the series (and vid editing in general) more difficult, and i'd also just felt kinda tired of doing the segment for the most part. i still find myself enjoying doing the Patreon episodes most months tho, so there's that :)

Herbieguy

Well hey, it's good you're recovering at least.

The Needle Drop

ah like in the dbox? yeah sometimes i get quirky w/ the genres & blurbs too but usually keep it dry. thank ya lol

The Needle Drop

i responded to a similar critique (from Barish) abt the text blips further down, but wanted to say thanks for the thoughtful & constructive response!

glorb glorbson

i've always had a particular appreciation for your editing style. i'm really not crazy about how ryan does it and thought the shift was pretty glaring. sometimes the more elaborate bits he does are fun but on the whole it feels kinda tryhard with the prominent use of stock footage and how full tilt he goes on most jokes

alonomer

i think the videos are great no matter what or who edits them

Tuck

The channel wouldn't be the same without ya!