Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Thank you so much for all your support this month! Now's that magical time when you hit us with your HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS; drop them down in the comments RIGHT NOW! We'll look through them all in like a week. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-king-90098776

Comments

Jules Pearce

Praising good music is more fun to talk about than criticising bad music

Zach Stolpa

What would be your choice for a new updated national anthem if it were up to you?

Jim đŸ€˜

Frank’s Wild Years is Waits best.

Sara

Broken Social Scene should’ve got the credit that Arcade Fire did off of YFINP, way better and more creative than Funeral. You could say even predicted a lot of the noisier indie acts lately

Gone

There are way more sad songs with great lyrics than happy songs with great lyrics.

Chris Hickson

Outsider music will have a mainstream moment in 2024. Maybe a Tonetta comeback?

bressig

White rappers referencing Eminem in their songs only serves to draw attention to how much better Em was in his heyday

CrypticTriscuit

Metalcore is more interesting than a lot of black metal and can even be heavier at times.

glowmoss3

King diamond’s solo work is better than mercyful fate’s output overall. “Fatal portrait” through “The Eye” are some of the best straight heavy metal records of the era.

Alex Sim

N.E.R.D. is extraordinarily underappreciated (for the jams and influence-wise)

Filip KaĆșmierczak

Zooropa is the most underrated U2 album. The industrial aesthetic makes for a very consistent atmosphere and there are some fantastic cuts on it like Numb or Daddy's gonna pay for your crashed car. Noone seems to remember it but I think it's one of their best

Talon Fusco

Travis Scott's Utopia is overrated. personally, I really needed to hear travis say something more significant about the astroworld tragedy then what we got. when I first read the track list before my first listen I thought the songs were maybe going to tell some story and was disappointed to get little to no substance in the lyrics of the album

Tuck

NevadaNate

Fun fact: David Bowie liked that album a lot and said he felt it was continuing some of the themes of his Berlin trilogy.

Kai (From KaisTestKitchen)

King Gizzard will go down as the greatest rock band of all time. The Quality matches the quantity the band puts forward while exploring different rock Subgenres

Trevor Young

Dogs are Metalcore. Cats are Doom Metal.

Paul

Has the encore become corny? I've been to dozens of live shows over the last 10+ years and it's all but expected and I'm getting kind of tired of it. Just play a couple extra songs at the end of the set without making a spectacle out of it lmao

Paul

Definitely Fuck I Heard It Through The Grapevine, Marry I Heard It Through The Grapevine, and Kill I Heard It Through The Grapevine

Ray Casillas

Laufey is the savior of Jazz music and you’re just mad because she has gorgeous auburn locks and you don’t.

James Jordan

đŸ”„ đŸ„” Take. Vimeo is not good. Can we get an audio only download link or better audio only stream link for NMF streams. Vimeo keeps losing track of the stream on my phone.

Reid Sweatt

Big Thief’s “Dragon New Warm Mountain” is their white album. Double album, white cover, loads of variety, and the best album in their discog

Boogalyhu .

Websites like RYM underrate foreign and older black American music. Most people engaging in music in this way are from a certain young, white demographic and it shows.

Justin

playboi carti and (early) Beach house make superficially contrasting but in reality similar songs. despite differences in production choices and vocal style, what makes either acts' songs listenable comes from the same place. Their songs follow pop structures although are frequently bridgeless. The cyclic and repeating phrases are used to the same hypnotic effect, especially in the choruses (Norway / Control). the strange and vague lyrics of both evoke abstract "vibes" in a way that would actually be inhibited by a more particular story/message. The words follow along and defer to the instrumentation and how they fall into patterns that make them particularly easy to remember and sing along to. Both of their first three albums even have a similar progression of brightening and intensifying.

Uncle Jam

Which rapper, preferably one that's been in the top 40, should collab with David Tibet?

simsimma

Anthony was wrong about Born this Way and his review of it was disrespectful because he blatantly dismissed it as dumb pop music. Melons bro era.

ToadMan101

Instead of an argument, I'd like to pose a question, inspired from a forum post I saw on AOTY; Imagine you are the host of a radio show, and you have the ability to bring in any artist (dead or alive) to ask them a question regarding a particular song they wrote. Which artist are you going with and what's the question you ask them?

Herbieguy

The 5th Dimension didn't deserve to get forgotten the way they did. They went from one of the biggest Soul groups of the 60s to filler in every other Goodwill bargain bin. Their legacy could use some reappraisal. They should be given more credit by contemporary listeners for their fantastic vocal abilities and helping to shine a light on great composers like Laura Nyro and Jimmy Webb.

I, II, II, IL

Bloc Party didn’t go downhill when Gordon Moakes and Matt Tong left, but rather they went downhill after the release of Intimacy. They were doomed to be a band who only had good singles instead of good albums, as Traps was by far the best track of Alpha Games, similar to how Octopus (and to an extent Ratchet) were the best tracks off Four.

Corey the music fan

We as music fans need to stop demanding artists to drop music. Artists are not entertainment puppets and are allowed to take time to release material. Not releasing music doesn't make the artist selfish or hate their fans either.

BigMouthBillyBass

one thing thats not taken into account enough when rating the quality of a band is how replaceable band members are and what they bring to the table individually. Is King Gizzard really that great if they can remove a whole ass drummer and it made no difference musically? How much do the rest of Queen really bring to the table versus Freddie?

Dalton Johnson

Melvins are one of the most influential and IMPORTANT bands in rock/metal history. countless bands cite them as an influence and they’re always forging their own path and unwilling to take bullshit. not enough self proclaimed music nerds know about them. very underrated in my opinion!

Sebastian van de Vegte

Radiohead is a good band but not nearly as good as all the pretentious rateyourmusic members claim to be. 3 albums in the top 10 albums of all time is way too much.

Drake Parker

Bongos is sonically better than WAP. WAP was only a big deal because of the video and the song pissing off right wing media critics

Hendrix

I'll bite: which band of my generation (I was born in 1988) has been better across their discography than Radiohead? They're not my favorite band or so, but I just think "Radiohead is overrated" is such a tired take, is all.

Sebastian van de Vegte

I agree with you that it's the best band of your generation, but my point is that all these 3 albums are for example higher than any of the Beatles albums.

Hendrix

Yeah the RateYourMusic thing I can get behind, I don't think Radiohead has made 3 out of the 10 best albums of all time. Idk maybe younger listeners gravitate less towards vintage music than they used to.

jeff

now that pc music is ending after its 10 year run, what's your overall assessment on the label and its impact on the broader musical landscape?

Drake Parker

Happier Than Ever wasn’t a sophomore slump. One of the big reasons the album wasn’t as big as her debut, was because most of the mainstream music audience had their sights set on other popular music at the time; such as Sour and Fearless (Taylor’s Version). It also didn’t help that it was released in the middle of the Donda/CLB pandemonium. While you can make the valid criticism that the production may not be as adventurous and otherworldly as her debut, I still think it is a great sophomore album and shows the maturity and coming of age for Billie excellently, and is the furthest thing from a sophomore slump.

Self-Aware Onion

Code Orange's new record is one of the most disappointing records in a while. The band inhabits a genre that desperately needs more refreshing ideas, and their last record more than sufficed given the boundary pushing creativity with way above average execution, whereas the new record is the opposite with the band living in the past and not adding anything new to the sound they achieved on Underneath. Not to mention the quality of the record is okay at best. The band had an opportunity to continue to push forward and lead the way in a genre that is begging for some innovation, and they fumbled it hard.

CraziestBoyEver

The specials is the best ska band, not only did they start the revival of ska but also made most of the best music in the genre.

Mohmi

Rock fell out of the mainstream because the major labels hitched their wagons to the wrong horse. They spent the 00's flooding the airwaves with increasingly thin pastiches of the 90's grunge sound/trashy nu-metal while ignoring the more interesting and downright poppy rock experiments happening in the underground. It gave mainstream audiences the impression that Rock had run out of gas as a genre while genres like electronica and rap were really flourishing on the majors. The only reason a similar thing didn't happen in the 90's is because Geffen managed to snap up Nirvana right as they were about to peak creatively.

Mohmi

WHOLEHEARTEDLY AGREE. Grunge and modern Sludge metal don't happen without King Buzzo.

Mohmi

I mean he was absolutely right that the cover makes you wanna throw up.

Waffles!

As time goes on, some albums that you've already reviewed will retroactively become 10s for reasons we can only imagine right now. We can only predict what aspects of these albums will age that tremendously well until they create a historical reputation for the music industry that's bigger than we could've anticipated upon release. We will look back on some albums and be surprised by their legacy much later down the line.

The Needle Drop

i used to let it run longer; it doesn't impact the poll. the early submissions are the ones that get upvoted, not that we always go w/ the most popular. i think there's a decent spread of decades so far; the 60s are probably the most under-represented tho

Andri Matthiasson

The rateyourmusic "top album" system is flawed to begin with. It's a competition in having the least people that dislike the album. If half of the users hate one album and the other half loves it. The half that loves are the only ones that matter to me, but not to rateyourmusic.

Caspa

So I was listening to Mariah Carey's "Always Be My Baby" and and there times where it takes me back to that particular sence in Beau is Afraid , does that song bring you back to that as well?

Endseeker

If mayonnaise is an instrument than is every condiment an instrument or are there some that you wouldn't classify as such