Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Bumping as I'll be collecting takes in the next few days, so if you've got some more, drop 'em in the comments pls!

Thank you guys so much for all your support this month! Especially as we near the end of the year, I wanna make it clear how much this means to me (Austen) in particular, so here's a big thank you!

Now let's see those HOT TAKES, UNPOPULAR OPINIONS, and TOUGH QUESTIONS! Drop 'em down in the comments, and we'll look through them all in a couple of weeks. If you want to do Christmas/holiday-themed takes, go for it, but def not mandatory. Let's go!

In case you missed last month's episode: https://www.patreon.com/posts/lets-argue-pop-93843575

Comments

John Coffey

What is your 2023 opinion on Young Nudy? You’ve only reviewed one mixtape from him and Pierre Bourne Sli’merre. He’s been slowly progressing over the past couple years from a underground Southern legend to a nationally recognized artist.

bressig

Prince is one of, if not THE most expressive pop singer of all time

Herbieguy

I think Rhett and Link are easily the best thing to come out of early YouTube. Consistently good content, no drops in viewership, no controversies, no cringy pandering, and just generally all around very likeable, friendly people. They're pretty much the face of what great youtubers should be

E

Hot Take: I feel like during and after Covid, music has became less distinct. There is a sense of recycling, similar to movies that every year it’s getting worse, e.g., the new Jack Harlow song, the lazy remakes of 90s classic. Def the label and monetary incentive of capitalist art. But like Mark Fisher (philosopher) said” it feels like it’s ringing true. On the one hand, this is a culture that privileges only the present and the immediate - the extirpation of the long term extends backwards as well as forwards in time (for example, media stories monopolize attention for a week or so then are instantly forgotten); on the other hand, it is a culture that is excessively nostalgic, given over to retrospection, incapable of generating any authentic novelty. It may be that Jameson's identification and analysis of this temporal antimony is his most important contribution to our understanding of postmodern/post-Fordist culture”

Alex Sim

AOTY lists shouldn't be ranked below the Top 10. Ain't no way you're telling me why you ranked "X" at 27 and "Y" at 28!

Zach Stolpa

The general public has a narrow view of what would be defined as metal. I think if you asked someone off the street what genre they thought Black Sabbath more likely they’d be categorized as rock by them or hard rock. When the general public think of metal what they picture most of the time is something more akin to death or extreme metal.

Zach Stolpa

Eddie vedder’s singing style influenced mumble rap/SoundCloud rap

Cameron Blatnik

If you could go back and start over at being a music critic, would you still use the number rating system that you do currently? Seems like its the thing you get the most heat for

Tyler Burnside

Have a nice life’s Deathconsciousness is a 10 your capping with any other number no other 90 min project come close with the vibe and textured aesthetic. There just isn’t another project that be doing that and none that do it better

Oscar Barroso

What's the worst gift you can give to a music fan: an artist's worst album from their catalogue or a shirt that's not even their size lol?

Trevor Young

Despite being the biggest star in the world right, I don't see T Swift having the same staying power as pop legends of old. We still listen to and appreciate the Beatles, Michael Jackson, Queen, etc. But I have a hard time imagining people in 30/40 years putting on a Swift track. She feels very of the moment, a flash in the pan. Not a statement on her skill or quality. Just interesting that she's potentially the first major pop artist of that magnitude who will probably be forgotten after their 'moment' is up.

Gabriel Gannon

People care to much about personal and others number ratings and not the actual description of how they feel about a record. So many "criticisms" people have are just "that's not an 8 it's a 7" like who cares what number you associate to the music what do you actually feel about it. (This is not directed at you more of music Twitter)

The Needle Drop

Lol if it's any consolation we don't do a bunch of thumbnail faces separately; they're just frames from the videos. sometimes i'll comb thru a vid before posting and be like "damn he didn't give me much to work w/"

Valdyr the Hyena

People who go around vehemently hating nu metal just hate having fun

tMinozaJ

if you’ve never jammed out to Mannish Boy by Muddy Waters you’re missin out

ToadMan101

Honestly, yeah. I find that if the list is a personal ranking and not an aggregation of a selection of people, then honorable mentions seem to be the way to go in that regard.

E

Other examples: indie artists tend to lean into thick nostalgia for past reiterations of the rock genre. Even Danny Brown and JPEG album while good, still shows signs via the album cover art. Not all artist are as big of culprits of others and def not universal but it does feel like Fisher is right in some aspects and Covid helped it grow.

Caspa

Due to there always being horrible music what rappers In terms of catalog were the worst in the 90s?

Zach Stolpa

I guess for them it was “one of those days” 💀

Nick

Here’s a left field non-music suggestion for you. How do you feel about the idea that “Americans can’t get British humour?” Personally, I see this as a really week means of gatekeeping American audiences away from our shows just because of failed adaptations. It also forgets how much British sitcoms owe to American comedy (I.E, no IT Crowd without Seinfield, no Inbetweeners without America inventing the teen genre). Not to mention various times we’ve seen American contestants hold their own on British panel shows against the sarcastic banter.

EZGames69

We need to re-normalize giving coal to shitty people on Christmas

CrypticTriscuit

Frost children is one of the best “hyperpop” acts right now.

ripplingSun

Aesop Rock should be in the conversation as the GOAT. He’s been releasing solid albums since ‘99. From early classics like Labor Days, Bazooka Tooth, None Shall Pass, Float, to recent ones like ITS, Garbology, SWFG. His consistency is unmatched. Not to mention he spits absolutely wild bars on every project. No rapper in history can match his consistent greatness.

BigMouthBillyBass

A2B2 started strong but so far has been underwhelming

Josh Brown

Anthony, do you give yourself time at the end of the year to listen to new albums you either hadn't heard of but might enjoy enough to mention on a year-end-list, or that you didn't get around to reviewing when they first dropped? Have you ever made a last-minute change or ranking to a list based on having heard a great record that fell into your lap way late into the year?

Hendrix

I'm curious, have you seen "Amadeus"? I love Whiplash but Amadeus is in a class of it's own.

Filip Kaźmierczak

Weezer's Teal Album has zero artistic value and you really overrated it by giving it a 6. they chose the most basic songs to cover and did the bare minimum to adapt them to their sound. Sure, the record is technically listenable but there isn't one interesting idea on it and deserves no credit just because it is competently recorded and produced. Teal is the first thing I think of when I think of a band "selling out"

Kai (From KaisTestKitchen)

Spotify is no longer the best streaming platform. Alternatives like Apple Music, Tidal and Soundcloud offer better algorithms , sound quality and payouts to artists. Spotify also no longer has the catalogue advantage either. They've fallen behind

Jake Perry

The Glow, Pt. 2 is incredibly boring and Phil has at least two albums in his catalogue that are much more impressive musically and tonally. Maybe it’s a “you had to be there” kind of thing but there are multiple albums from the era that are way better and much more rewarding listens. I’ll never understand the enormous hype this album gets and I personally think it’s unwarranted.

Jake Perry

Earthbound OST is goated as well

Zachary F Parker

Stopping the "reviewing your music" series before I finished and released my album was an absolute tragedy but one you can change.

Kegan Padot

Streetlight Manifesto is the best band you’ve never once mentioned on your channel

Uncle Jam

I love a lot of the releases from this wave of low-key, almost monotone underground rappers who rap over minimal (frequently) drumless beats. Navy Blue and MIKE and Mach-Hommy and late career Earl Sweatshirt and stuff like that. Again, I love these artists and their work, but I'd be lying if I said they didn't all kinda sound alike and I think we're hitting a point of diminishing returns on how much they can offer. Or we will be soon.

MV Calil

with the new controversy in regard to Spotify's payments of small artists, it's close to impossible for people to call themselves indie music/small artists fans/supporters and still renew their subscription plans with the platform

Chris

Mission Of Burma is really underappreciated every single song they drop in the 80s was perfect especially on vs.

Chris

This*

Chris

I was born 5 years after The Glow Pt 2 I'll tell you no you didn't have to be there

Torben Juache

Christmas >> Thanksgiving Christmas is just a better Holiday all around and it is just spellbinding in some cases. Happy Christmas and Happy New Year to Austin and Anthony ❤️

John Coffey

Unpopular opinion: DJ Drama ruined CMIYGL and only sparingly does him talking on tracks works. I get that's his job as a DJ but going back through that Tyler album on some songs it sounds like he's talking just to hear his own voice.