No, Toni Storm Is Not Actually Retiring. Why Are You Reporting A Kayfabe Story As Fact? (Patreon)
Content
My ongoing (and increasingly failing) attempt to rid the wrestling world of bad aggregation and reporting has, believe it or not, failed again today with a wave of supremely terrible aggregations that saw an obviously worked retirement reported by multiple outlets as if it were a real one.
Today's idiocy started with SB Nation writer James Dator's "BREAKING: Toni Storm to retire from pro wrestling and AEW, effective immediately." In the piece's lede, Dator says:
"Toni Storm is leaving pro wrestling. After losing the AEW Women's World Championship to Mariah May at All In 2024, and following losses in both NJPW and CMLL, Storm told SB Nation in an exclusive interview (and in a style all of her own) that there's nothing left for her in the sport."
In the piece, Storm is quoted as apologizing to her fans for being "such a failure" and later saying, "I'm not used to being such a loser. I've failed at everything. I lost in AEW, I lost in Japan, I lost in Mexico. This is the last you'll hear from me again. Enjoy Mariah May as your champion. You can all enjoy that."
Storm says in the piece that she has not spoken to AEW President and CEO Tony Khan about this news, and the first time he will hear of it is in this SB Nation exclusive.
Okay.
I'll give Dator a modicum of credit because the following paragraph—I'm hoping this was his intention—is so bad, it's supposed to be a giant wink-wink, nudge-nudge; this is a bullshit article.
Again, I hope.
"I explained to Storm that her career isn't defined by recent results, and that millions of people love seeing her work. Storm thanked me, but again confirmed that she won't be returning to wrestling — while also suggesting we get coffee together some time. I suggested a flat white, and she seemed to like that."
The rest of the article is filled with dumb, quippy, obviously in-character lines like "I can't even handle a rhino-sized hamster" and confirmation that she likes poached eggs. Riveting stuff. The closing line, meant to signify the end of Storm's career, is:
"Chin down. Tits in. Don't bother watching for the shoe."
That was the sound of my eyes rolling.
Anyway, nowhere in this piece is it indicated that it's satire or in-storyline, but like I said, I can give Dator a little credit because it's so on the nose that nobody should take it as anything more than an in-character storyline retirement. The headline BREAKING is embarrassing for what's clearly media doing storyline advancement, but again, I'll give Dator and SB Nation the slightest of breaks.
That's where the breaks end.
The Takedown (a Sports Illustrated wrestling-focused vertical) wasted little time aggregating this story and treating it as real news.
Writer Zack Heydorn's lede is:
"AEW star and former AEW Women's World Champion, Toni Storm, has announced her retirement from pro wrestling. During an interview with SB Nation, the former champion revealed the news and stated that she simply isn't used to being a loser."
The following paragraphs give a little background to Storm's career—primarily focused on her runs in WWE and AEW.
The piece's headline is "Toni Storm Announces Retirement From Pro Wrestling," with absolutely zero context, pushback, or doubt in the article. It is just an aggregation of the clear storyline, tongue-in-cheek, treated as reality.
Sadly, they weren't alone.
411Mania followed the same tact, aggregating the piece as if it were a fact with no thought or context.
Thankfully, a few sites handled this story properly. SEScoops reporter Andrew Ravens handled it perhaps the best, treating the first few paragraphs of his piece as all other aggregators, then immediately casting doubt to this being anything more than a storyline:
"Despite her declaration, speculation is rife that Storm could make a surprise appearance at AEW Full Gear this Saturday, where Mariah May is set to host a championship celebration alongside Mina Shirakawa."
Later in the piece, there is an entire section called "Is This Real or Storyline?" that further doubts this as anything more than a worked retirement, citing several of the things I mentioned above as clear tells.
"The tone of the interview and Toni Storm's exaggerated remarks suggest this is likely part of an ongoing storyline rather than a genuine retirement announcement."
Thank you, Andrew; this is how it's supposed to be done.
While not as obviously pointing to this entire thing being a work, WrestleZone's Matt Black did point out something the bad aggregators didn't: Storm is still advertised for CMLL's show on December 13.
Black also ended his piece by asking people their thoughts on whether this was true or a storyline:
"Do you believe she's truly retired from professional wrestling? Or is this just another chapter in her storyline with Mariah May?"
While this was done to gas up the comments section, it's still better than what most others did.
This entire debacle reminds me of an unbelievably great article I recently read from Ed Zitron, "Lost In The Future." (Subscribe to his newsletter Where's Your Ed At right now. You won't be sorry.)
In the piece, Zitron discusses modern media's role in fact-checking and distributing news.
While Toni Storm's worked pro wrestling retirement isn't nearly on the same level as, you know, the future of the United States, a lot of what Zitron talks about applies to wrestling media as much as it does CNN or The New York Times.
"The news...is always separated from opinion, always guarded, always safe, for fear that they might piss off somebody and be declared "biased," something that happens anyway. While there are columnists that are given some space to have their own thoughts in the newspaper, the stories themselves are delivered with the kind of reserved "hmmm..." tone that often fails to express the consequences of the news itself and lacks the context necessary to deliver the news itself...
This is, by the way, not always the fault of the writers. There are entire foundations of editors that have more faith in the markets and the powerful than they do in the people who spend their days interrogating them, and above them entire editorial superstructures that exist to make sure that the "editorial vision" never colors too far outside the lines. I'm not even talking about Jeff Bezos, or Laurene Powell Jobs, or any number of billionaires who own any number of publications, but the editors editing business and tech reporters who don't know anything about business and tech, or the senior editors that are terrified of any byline that might dare get the outlet "under fire" from somebody who could call their boss."
Presenting facts and having discretion is okay. It should be encouraged!
SEScoops could aggregate the same story as everyone else but present it in a way that makes it evident to the reader that Storm is not retiring because, let's face it, she's not. She will likely appear at AEW Full Gear this Saturday, if not soon thereafter. She's probably going to make her CMLL return in December. You can still present a "story" without looking like a boob that's essentially carrying water for the protagonist or the wrestling company that employs them.
If you recall, I lost my mind in July when outlets presented Jesse Ventura's return to WWE as some monumental, world-shaking, hell freezing over event despite the numerous times he had returned to WWE over the years.
Why did they present it as such in the light of overwhelming evidence?
Because WWE and Jesse Ventura told them it was a big deal.
None of these outlets stopped and thought, "Wait, is this as big of a deal as WWE is saying?"
This is just one of many examples of wrestling news sites, media, and aggregators haphazardly reporting and platforming stories that are obvious PR, flat-out lies, or as we see today: kayfabe stories used to push forward a storyline.
I'm not saying wrestling news sites should entirely ignore stories like this. I get the game. I do. I choose not to participate in it, probably against my better judgment. But I don't see why more people can't do what SEScoops did today and present the "news" while questioning it and pushing back on it at the same time. Just because a former Attitude Era wrestler says something in a podcast, we don't have to present that as a fact without pushing back or presenting facts along with the untrue or baseless statement.
All it takes is a little effort.
Alas, there's no time for that.
Time spent offering an opinion or adding actual journalistic value to a piece gets in the way of the next regurgitated, vapid, and entirely worthless aggregation of Rikishi's podcast or an Eric Bischoff tweet.
-Rich