40/30/20/10: NXT Starts A Revolution at R Evolution (2014) (Patreon)
Content
Ten years ago this month, NXT foretold a revolution and Evolution that's still being felt today.
The December 12, 2014, NXT special: NXT TakeOver R Evolution wasn't the first NXT special on the still-new WWE Network; that distinction went to February's NXT ArRIVAL show. That show came out of the gates red hot with one of the best WWE matches of the year: Cesaro (Claudio Castiglioni) vs. Sami Zayn (the former El Generico). It was the first live show streamed on the new WWE Network, and it was, as the show's title indicated, NXT's arrival onto the mainstream pro wrestling scene. While the NXT brand evolved from WWE's Florida Championship Wrestling, NXT was largely something that existed outside most wrestling fans' purview. Devoted, hardcore fans checked in and followed the NXT brand to see the next generation of "WWE superstars." Still, it was a microscopically small audience that cared at all about what was going on with WWE's developmental brand. A few promos and matches would emerge as things people needed to seek out (famously the Dean Ambrose/William Regal feud), but only a little emerged from the Winter Park, Florida facility.
NXT ArRIVAL changed all that.
NXT was on the map, and it had never been easier to watch the program, launch WWE's new over-the-top streaming service, and NXT specials and weekly shows were at your fingertips.
With Cesaro vs. Zayn, WWE also told you that this isn't the NXT of old.
Don't sleep on what we're doing here.
Another match on the NXT ArRIVAL show tipped off what type of revolution and Evolution we'd see from the NXT brand moving forward: Paige (Saraya) vs. Emma. If you watch this match now, it's pretty pedestrian and basic, but for 2014 viewers of primarily major American wrestling, it was an eye-opening experience.
Through their developmental brand, WWE let two women enter the ring and wrestle a back-and-forth pro wrestling match for 13 minutes. This may not seem like a big deal in 2024, but in 2014, trust me, it was. For years, WWE's "Divas" division was a laughing stock and a convenient way for Vince McMahon and WWE to parade beautiful women in front of a crowd for catcalls.
Despite whatever some dumb Twitter/X account tells you about Alicia Fox being "A PROBLEM! 😤😭" there really wasn't much to the division.
The matches were short and usually bad.
TNA's famed Knockouts Division, a legit ratings draw for the company, was slightly better at times due to a bevy of talented workers, but had also fallen into similar "Diva" trappings by 2014.
So WWE rolling out the ball and letting two women on their roster WRESTLE while fans were engaged with the WRESTLING of the two women was, very sadly, revolutionary.
NXT returned in May for NXT TakeOver 2014, their second live special on WWE Network. Like NXT ArRIVAL, the brand took the next step in presenting itself as something wholly unique from its parent company: Tyler Breeze and Sami Zayn had a really fun 15-minute match.
In the main event, Adrian Neville successfully defended his NXT Title against Tyson Kidd in a well-worked 20-minute main event. It was the semi-main event that would capture the attention of many, though, as Charlotte, the daughter of Ric Flair, would face off with Natalya, the daughter of Jim "The Anvil" Neidhart.
Both Flair and Natalya's uncle Bret Hart were at ringside to watch. Like the NXT ArRIVAL, NXT didn't use this match to sexualize the women in any way; it was two WRESTLERS WRESTLING, and they just so happened to be women. They weren't fighting over men or fighting because they hated one another. They were fighting because they wanted a title and the claim of being the best women's wrestling in the world.
Again, this match watched in 2024 isn't going to knock your socks off, but it holds up; it's still very good.
Charlotte would win the match and the NXT Women's Title for the first time. Overall, the show was FINE, but NXT specials were starting to gather some buzz.
September's NXT TakeOver Fatal 4 Way was good but not great. The show featured a lot of boring, mundane matches, with The Lucha Dragons defeating The Ascension to win the NXT Tag Team Titles, Baron Corbin squashing CJ Parker (Juice Robinson) in less than a minute, Enzo Amore beating Sylvester Lefort in a Hair vs. Hair match, Bull Dempsey blitzing through Mojo Rawley in a 1:10 match. Charlotte defended her NXT Title against Bayley in a match that was just... okay. The show's main event, a four-way between Neville, Zayn, Breeze, and Kidd, was well-received but didn't have the cache the following NXT special would.
Which brings us to NXT TakeOver R Evolution, 10 years old this month.
This is the show, that more than any of the specials prior, really signaled to the wrestling world at large that NXT was a force to be reckoned with.
The show featured many high-profile debuts, the emergence of a new women's star, and, in my mind, still the best NXT main event ever. NXT TakeOver R Evolution was the proof of concept more than any show before and maybe after.
NXT combined homegrown "WWE Superstars" in training with top-level international stars like Hideo Itami (KENTA), Adrian Neville (PAC), and Finn Balor (Prince Devitt), emerging, young lucha stars like Kalisto and sprinkled in two standouts in the American independent scene in Kevin Owens (Kevin Steen) and Sami Zayn.
The recipe was perfect.
NXT offered the high-level wrestling lapsed WWE fans or indie wrestling fans craved with WWE's patented storytelling.
The show began with the debut of Owens, who made quick work of CJ Parker. Later in the show, Owens and Zayn were seen interacting backstage. WWE's subtly hammer didn't rear its ugly head either. The two exchanged pleasantries, and if you knew the history of the two from their days growing up in the industry, teaming and feuding, you did the Leonardo DiCaprio meme, and if you didn't, ah, well, you knew these two knew each other. In a rare instance, WWE made pro wrestling's history their history. It wouldn't be the last time we saw these two.
Next, The Lucha Dragons (Kalisto & Sin Cara - no, not that Mistico) defeated The Vaudevillains. It wasn't anything spectacular, but it was a nice, solid win for a Lucha tag team that was allowed to be themselves and wrestle their way.
Baron Corbin made quick work of Tye Dillinger in a nice, clean squash match.
Both Finn Balor and Hideo Itami made their NXT TakeOver/NXT specials debuts here as two international superstars—Itami, formerly one of the top stars of the Pro Wrestling NOAH promotion, and Balor, NJPW's top junior and the leader of a little up-and-coming stable named BULLET CLUB—now trying to prove their worth in WWE's developmental company.
Balor and Itami easily defeated The Ascension duo of Konnor & Viktor in a match that felt like a changing of the guard. The big, lumbering duo of Konnor and Viktor instantly felt like relics of WWE's developmental past while the new wave of signees took center stage.
The night's semi-main event saw Charlotte defend her NXT Women's Title against Sasha Banks. Charlotte was destined, by hook or by crook, to be a "WWE Superstar."
As long as she wasn't the drizzling shits (and she wasn't), WWE was going to push her to the moon. Banks, was more of an unknown. Trained at Chaotic Wrestling in Massachusetts, Mercedes KV wrestled in the Northeast indies, garnering some attention.
Still, her wirey, thin, and small frame didn't exactly portend a career as one of history's best women's wrestlers.
In June 2012, she participated in a WWE tryout camp and, in August, was signed and reported to NXT under the new name Sasha Banks.
Throughout 2013, Banks emerged as a key component of NXT's growing women's division. Banks began as a follower of Summer Rae, trying to learn the ropes from the then-veteran NXTer. Once a babyface, Banks turned heel and fully embraced the rulebreaker ways of Rae. This was when Banks stripped her former "just happy to be here" persona and adopted "The Boss."
The duo wrestled the rest of the division until, in a fate-determining move, Rae was called up to the main roster, and Banks no longer had her tag team partner, but it was a blessing in disguise. Banks started feuding directly with the other top women in NXT, mainly Charlotte, Bayley, and Becky Lynch. Months of back-and-forth tension between Charlotte and Banks led to NXT TakeOver R Evolution.
Like many of the women's matches I've mentioned in this piece, it probably doesn't hold up as great in 2024. Particularly with these two, they've had dozens of matches better than this one in the following years. But the match was a revelation. Banks, a bright-eyed, bushy-tailed, smiling babyface just a year prior, had become the total package. Her charisma and confidence had developed slowly in the ring and character-wise, but it was shown off to the whole world at R Evolution. This women's division in NXT was becoming an embarrassment of riches.
I've written and talked about the NXT TakeOver R Evolution main event a lot in my life. It's flat-out one of my favorite matches ever.
I voted it my 2014 Match of the Year. Here's what I wrote about it back then:
“When wrestling is done right, there’s nothing like it. There’s moments and matches that make you remember why you devote so much of your life to such a stupid endevour. This match was one of those moments I will never forget, one of those moments that makes it all worth it. For those who have been invested in the Sami Zayn/El Generico/Rami Sebei story for years, this was your moment of glory, this was your pay off. Even if you just picked up on Sami Zayn through NXT, you felt the same way, that’s how well done this angle and this match was. The uber babyface Zayn is constantly told he’s too nice to win the big match, he finally snaps at the go-home show and put his career on the line to prove he CAN win the big one. In the match, he dodges every step, jumps over every hurdle and then is met with his own mortality. He has a chance to cheat and win the title, he stars at it, the crowd is begging him to win the right way. Think about that, for all the narrative post-Steve Austin that people want the badass/renegade/take no shit babyface, you have a building of people BEGGING a wrestler to win without cheating, win with honor. Fuck, if that doesn’t get you excited, I don’t know what will. Zayn throws the title down and wins his way making the moment that much more special and that much more important. The technical aspects of the match are perfect and filled with callbacks to each of their previous encounters. Once this was over, I knew it was my Match of the Year and it may be one of my top five matches of all-time. It’s not often I jump up and down and yell when something happens in a wrestling ring anymore — this match made me do that. ”
I watched it earlier today in anticipation of writing this piece, and it still holds up. I still love it.
The story was simple.
Neville, the cocky and confident champ, against his former friend and ultimate underdog babyface Sami Zayn. Throughout the build to this match, Neville poked and prodded at Zayn: you don't have IT. You don't have the confidence; you don't have the drive to be where I'm at.
"You can't win the big one."
In the matches that built up to R Evolution, Zayn refused to take the easy way out and resisted the temptation to cheat. His opponent had no issue doing so. Neville faked an injury in a match the two had weeks earlier, and Zayn, ever the good guy, stopped his attack to check on his friend.
Neville then rolled up Zayn for the win. Zayn's kindness was weakness.
"It's hard to sit back and watch your friend fail."
Zayn raises the stakes of the match. I'm done if I don't win the NXT Title against you. I'm quitting NXT. In the go-home promo for the show, Neville big brothers Zayn telling him he doesn't want to be responsible for Zayn's NXT run ending. Zayn snaps and slaps Neville. The killer instinct that Neville kept poking and prodding that Zayn didn't have had been awoken.
I always say this, but come on, man, pro wrestling is so easy. Why do we keep inventing ways to make it harder?
Zayn's former best friend (but also one of his most bitter rivals) gasses him up before the match. You got this, man!
When Zayn entered Full Sail University, he entered as a mega babyface. The most over guy in NXT to that point. A genuine, bonafide superstar. The Full Sail faithful are eager, nervous, and determined to clap along, scream LET'S GO, and will their favorite NXT wrestler to the world title.
I got goosebumps watching it again this morning.
The match is excellent, legit, fucking great. The ending is what puts it over the top. With the referee knocked out and the NXT Title lying on the mat, Zayn has a crisis of conscious.
He picks up the NXT Title to literal SHRIEKS from the audience. Everyone in Full Sail is screaming, "NO! NO! NO!" Not this way, Sami. Win the title, but win it being the good guy; win it the right way.
Zayn stares longingly at the title, thinking about everything Neville and others had said about it, his killer instinct, and his inability to win the big one.
"Now is not the time for morals."
Zayn goes to put the title down, but Neville rolls him up. Kindness is a weakness again, but Zayn kicks out to a monstrous pop from the crowd, and now he's in complete control.
An Exploder Suplex and a Helluva Kick for the ages follow as Zayn pins Neville for the 1-2-3 as the roof blows off Full Sail. Zayn had won it, and he had done it his way.
There's a misnomer around these parts that Joe and I don't like "stories" in our wrestling. And that really couldn't be further from the truth. Wrestling without stories is meaningless, devoid of emotion or reason. Why would anyone care? Wrestling needs stories. I don't think those stories should involve people being run over by cars or devil masks.
Sami Zayn's ability to overcome his insecurities without sacrificing his morals or integrity is not only a great story but also simple and relatable. It's the type of wrestling story you can explain to a normal human being, and they'll understand it without looking at you like you're a buffoon.
It's the type of story Vince McMahon, a man of few morals and little integrity, wouldn't be able to write for anyone on the WWE main roster. He has no frame of reference for it.
But here in NXT, it was possible. Sadly, NXT took what worked once with the right people and drove the story into the ground several times over the next handful of years, with the likes of Johnny Gargano asking his hands why they were so violent.
On this night, though, they nailed the landing and told the story to perfection.
The babyface locker room emerges, and backstage employees like Pat Patterson fill the ring.
It's pure, unbridled joy.
Owens, Zayn's long-time friend and foe, comes out to celebrate, but the party doesn't last long.
As we begin to sign off the show, Owens turns on Zayn and destroys him with a powerbomb on the apron.
Bask in the glow of the good guy winning for a few moments, but reality snaps back quickly. The wrestling industry is built on heat.
In just one show, Owens went from debuting to vaulting himself into the brand's top storyline and title.
NXT TakeOver R Evolution received rave reviews across the wrestling pundit sphere. NXT specials had emerged as a must-see and arguably the best draw on WWE Network, beyond even WWE's regular suite of pay-per-views or the vast archive of wrestling history.
By the following year, NXT TakeOver's were the safest bet in pro wrestling.
It is nearly always guaranteed to deliver top-to-bottom great shows with high-level wrestling. And the eyeballs continued to grow.
Soon, NXT TakeOver outgrew Full Sail and started traveling, piggybacking on major WWE PPV weekends and filling buildings nationwide.
The women's revolution/Evolution, whatever you want to call it, would migrate to the main roster, culminating in Becky Lynch vs. Ronda Rousey vs. Charlotte as the main event of WrestleMania 35.
While the NXT brand has had its fair share of ups and downs in the years that followed, its undeniable impact on American pro wrestling began in earnest on December 11, 2014.
No show showed NXT's proof of concept better than NXT TakeOver R Evolution.
-Rich
40/30/20/10 is a written series looking back at the most important and memorable wrestling matches, moments, and news stories 40, 30, 20 and 10 years ago this month. Read the full archive of 40/30/20/10 at https://www.patreon.com/collection/316673