Does Nobody Else Notice WWE's Piped-In Boos? (Patreon)
Content
Crowd-sweetening has been a thing in wrestling for decades.
As long as pro wrestling has been on TV, companies have added, removed, or altered crowd noise to better fit an agenda. One of the more famous examples came at the iconic 1992 WWF Royal Rumble, in the closing moments of the Royal Rumble match, Sid Justice eliminated Hulk Hogan from the match. Live in the building, the crowd cheered loudly, happy Sid had thrown Hogan out of the match.
In all subsequent replays shown on television and in future VHS/DVD/WWE Network uploads, those cheers were turned into boos. WWF didn't want you to cheer Sid or be happy that Hogan had been eliminated. They were building to WrestleMania 8; Hogan was the babyface, and Sid was the heel. The crowd didn't follow their storyline, so they just changed it in post-production.
Everyone knew what WWF was trying to do by switching the crowd noise, and the 1992 Royal Rumble crowd-sweetening is known and recognized by wrestling fans and journalists.
WCW was criticized heavily by many of those same people in 1998 for piping in "Goldberg" chants during Bill Goldberg's entrances on TV and PPVs. The biggest reason people were so upset was that fans were already chanting for Goldberg, but by forcing piped-in chants, it started to look like the company was insecure and desperate.
In one example uploaded to YouTube, you can hear a pretty clear example of WCW production adding Goldberg chants in a spot when the crowd wasn't chanting for it.
Make sure to focus on the 4:00 minute mark, as there is an audio glitch or an instance of the audio track repeating.
Again, this is an egregious example because the crowd was intensely chanting "Goldberg" throughout the segment, but the intensity of the chants noticeably decreased as it continued. Then, out of nowhere, the chants surged again.
There are several more examples but you get the idea.
This brings me to modern-day WWE.
I've made it known many times on audio, both on this Patreon and on our weekly Flagship shows, that I have some gripes with WWE's use of piped-in noise.
In the final days of WWE's ThunderDome, Joe and I had a long discussion about how piped-in noise used during the COVID-19 pandemic, empty arena, ThunderDome may be something the company tries to use more frequently for live shows.
WWE has always been open about using crowd-sweetening or piped-in noise. Taped WWE shows dating back to the 80s have clear examples of crowd-sweetening, not to mention taped episodes of SmackDown, RAW, and more. It was a widespread practice.
WWE almost always stayed away from piping in crowd noise on PPVs or live shows.
COVID-19 changed that.
And my fears were realized; they didn't stop using them once the fans returned.
One of the clearest examples that I pointed out previously was during Vince McMahon's return to television following sexual misconduct allegations, WWE very clearly (as I pointed out with audio evidence) added in live boos to drown out the overwhelmingly positive response that McMahon had received.
Over the last few weeks, I've noticed several new examples of WWE's crowd-sweetening and piped-in reactions—mostly boos.
What annoyed me was not that WWE was piping in crowd noise; as I said above, it's been used throughout their history. It doesn't bother me, even if I find it unbecoming of what pro wrestling is supposed to be.
My main frustration is that few people notice that crowd reactions are artificially enhanced or are simply choosing to ignore these obvious WWE production choices.
Am I going crazy? How is nobody else not noticing what is blatant crowd manipulation?
Last weekend at Survivor Series: War Games, Solo Sikoa's Bloodline entered the ring to what might sound like intense boos to the untrained ear. Did they really receive that level of heat, though?
I grabbed an audio clip directly from Peacock. And here's what their entrance sounded like.
At the six-second mark, several seconds after The Bloodline's music hits, you hear loud thunderous boos. I don't know about you guys, but I've been in many wrestling crowds in my life, and typically, the first note of a wrestling entrance song is when crowds typically start reacting to that wrestling, whether positive or negative. Jim Johnston, WWE's legendary former music composer, was great at ensuring that the first note of the entrance theme elicited your reaction. The screeching guitar is in Bret Hart's theme, the glass breaking in Stone Cold's, or the fade-up in Mr. McMahon's "No Chance in Hell."
Sure, maybe the fine folks in Vancouver haven't quite figured out The Bloodline's theme yet and needed a few seconds to lock in that this was Solo's Bloodline coming out. I'm dubious.
By the 14-second mark, the boos have dissipated for the most part. Yet, by the 18-second mark, they are back to being loud again. That's not a very natural way for a crowd to react. Yet, when you listen to or read reviews of War Games, you'll be told that Solo's Bloodline came out to unbelievable levels of heat. Like Goldberg, there were A LOT of people booing The Bloodline last Saturday, so the alleged crowd-sweetening wasn't necessary.
But they can't help themselves.
A more egregious example occurred last night during the first New Day segment after their great angle turning on Big E last week. If you search for reviews today, you'll read and hear about how The New Day was BOOED out of the building on RAW.
And they were booed. No question. These fans definitely booed The New Day.
I believe the level of boos and the timing of the boos, though, were coordinated by WWE production.
The first example is from the building.
I've also made a short clip that ties to isolate the very clear in-arena piped-in boos strategically placed to stop Kofi Kingston and Xavier Woods from being able to explain their actions last week. Make a note of the 18-second and 37-second marks.
Like the Goldberg example, the crowd is booing The New Day. The crowd is reacting the way WWE wants them to, but when the noise beings to wane a bit around the 15-16 second mark, you can hear a clear beginning of piped-in boos.
The same thing happens at the 37-second mark.
What if it was just a weird audio glitch from someone recording the show and the promo from their phone?
Sure. Fair. Okay. But wait!
WWE uploaded a replay of the promo from TV on their YouTube channel, and you won't believe it, but the same very obvious piped-in boos come at exactly the same time on the YouTube upload as well.
Here's an isolated clip of the specific points where you can hear the piped-in boos.
My favorite part is the six-second mark when Woods starts his promo and stops in a classic pro wrestler: "I'm not going to keep talking while you are making noise." But he stops before the crowd starts booing loudly.
Whoops.
They would start up a few seconds later, though.
The 18-second mark is another excellent example, the crowd again is booing, but at the 19-second mark, they add in even more boos. It's a noticeable jump in the noise and heaviness of boos, a very unnatural way that doesn't reflect how noise, sounds, or boos actually would. Crowd reactions are gradual as people in the arena catch up to the boos, cheers, or chants; thousands of people don't start booing at exactly the same tone and level at exactly the same time.
WWE's piped-in crowd reactions are one of those "once you hear it" type things that may not seem obvious right away, but once you hear it, once it clicks, once you figure out the "tells," you'll never be able to unhear it.
Can we chalk this up to an audio engineer who is always a little late on the dial turning up in-arena crowd noise?
That's possible. I'm dubious, though.
WWE production, particularly in a post-Kevin Dunn universe, is a well-oiled machine. So much so, I've touted how their evolution in how they produce pro wrestling, while decidedly not for me, has left AEW in the dust, making the challenge brand look and feel like a dated product. Again, WWE production isn't for me or my sensibilities but is undeniably good.
Production snafus like mistimed audio cues are few and far between in modern WWE, so I don't know if I'm willing to attribute these rapid audio-level jumps to simple incompetence on the part of WWE production.
It's quite the contrary, really.
WWE production is so good at what they do that they've successfully manipulated fans, reviewers, and pundits alike who either don't notice obvious crowd-sweetening or don't care.
And I don't know which is worse.
-Rich