Joe Reviews Four Random Matches (12/16): Bayley vs Meiko, Shelley vs Sabin, Robbie Eagles In Texas, And An Under The Radar NXT Level Up Banger (Patreon)
Content
One final batch of reviews for 2024, featuring a couple of indie matches and two under-the-radar boutique WWE bouts that I really enjoyed.
Light year for match reviews, but we did help you keep up with lower profile indies like EPW in Australia and Kyushu Pro in Japan, among others. Here’s what you may have missed. You can always use the tags to catch up on review batches from prior years.
Bouncin’ Around The Indies (5/28)Bryan Keith vs KENTA (Defy)Brick Savage vs Pac Ortega (Borracho Pro)Jesse Lambert vs Damian Slater (EPW)Puncher vs Babathunder (PTW)
Lanza Reviews Four Indie Matches (7/10)Dynamite Kid vs Jet Wei (Kyushu Pro)Máscara Sagrada NG vs El Hijo de Fishman (RIBA)Daisuke Sekimoto vs Mentai Kid (Kyushu Pro)Marcius Pitt vs Alex Kingston (EPW)
Also ICYMI, earlier this year I examined one of the most hotly debated topics in wrestling - whether or not Kurt Angle ever had a 5-star match.
Searching For Angle - The Elusive Kurt Angle Five Star Match Project
This closes the books on 2024 reviews. Look for the first batch of 2025 matches sometime around late January or early February.
Bayley (c) vs Meiko Satomura - WWE Women’s Title - WWE “SuperShow Summer Tour”, 7/27
This match took place on the back end of a Sumo Hall double shot, on the third night of a two stop, three night WWE tour of Japan in July.
Those three shows featured the only three matches Satomura, who is presumably still with the company (in a training role) wrestled for WWE all year. She does all of her fan facing work these days in Japan, mostly for Sendai Girls (where she recently won the Sendai Girls World Title from DASH Chisako), having not worked a match in the United States since being taken off of NXT TV in March of 2023.
Satomura’s WWE career has been baffling. Arguably the greatest women’s wrestler of her generation (and for some, in the conversation for the greatest of all time), she was used as the centerpiece of the NXT UK women’s division for about a year and a half, before being moved to Orlando to work out of the Performance Center, which included a brief two month TV run on NXT proper (where she was used to put over Roxanne Perez), which to date has been the only WWE stateside work she’s been given. The WWE July 2024 Japan swing are the only three main roster matches she has worked in the company to date, and are the last WWE matches she has worked as of this writing period.
Satomura is renowned as a trainer, so I’ve got no problem using her in that role. What I can’t wrap my head around is only having her work 27 total matches since being signed in early 2021. 27 total matches over three full years for someone who is very likely the best women’s wrestler in the world. It’s not as if she’s too busy with whatever they have her doing in Orlando to find time to wrestle, as evidenced by her frequent trips back to Japan to work Sendai Girls and other joshi promotions. Even setting the main main roster or TV aside (which is where she should be, but I suspect age and look is presenting a barrier), why not at minimum put her on the road on the NXT Largo Loop to work with the ultra green talent? How could they not see the value in this? I’d have her working main roster house shows too, with all of the green call ups and underdeveloped potential stars (Jade Cargill, Tiffany Stratton, and a host of others). Seems like a no brainer. Am I missing something here?
If you haven’t seen Satomura work in a while and are thinking age and physical ability might be the issue, you would be dead wrong. In this match against Bayley, which was making the rounds earlier this summer on fancam before being released pro shot (single cam, no commentary) on the WWE Vault YouTube channel (which tells us that the other matches from this tour were likely filmed, although I wouldn’t recommend holding your breath waiting for them to be released), it is evident from the very first move of the match, a hammerlock takedown, that Satomura is leagues above every other woman on the WWE roster. That probably sounds silly, but watch it for yourself and you’ll see what I mean. The snap in her execution of that hammerlock, the intensity behind the simple collar and elbow tie up that follows, and the execution of the ensuing quick and deep armdrag takeover, which are all simple, perfunctory moves of a typical opening sequence of a match, instantly grab your attention and smack you over the head with how crisp and perfect and great it all is in comparison to literally anything you ever see on WWE TV. I like Bayley a lot, and have often said that if she isn’t the best wrestler out of the Four Horsewomen she has no doubt been the most consistent, but even she is totally outclassed here instantly by Meiko.
Bayley hasn’t been the same wrestler as she used to be over the last couple of years, but she really stepped it up here and brought the fire, which is evidence that being in the ring with people who are better than you often (if not always) brings out the best in a wrestler. Bayley has lost a step physically, but is still very good at putting together a match and dragging decent stuff out of some of the less talented women on the roster. It was obvious that she was having the time of her life against Meiko (this is the only time these two have ever faced one another), absorbing stiff kicks to the chest (Meiko throws the best strikes in the company, man or woman, and that includes Gunther) and working snugger and stiffer than usual to keep up as the match moved along. This was not only the best Bayley performance I’ve seen in years, it was undoubtedly the best WWE women’s match of 2024, even accounting for the awful, needless, and extremely annoying “Its’s Tiffy Time!” mid match run in that totally took me out of the moment just as I was inching up in my seat and REALLY getting into it. WWE always finds a way to ruin just about anything cool.
The reverse weebs that attend WWE shows in Japan mustered up a “This Is Awesome” chant by the end of this, and this is one of the rare times that I had to agree with the WWE Universe, because this was awesome, at least until Tiffy teased her silly Money In The Bank gimmick and killed all of the momentum. Bayley graciously allowed Meiko to kick out of the Bayley-To-Belly suplex before finishing her off with her modified facebuster finish that no doubt has some silly play on words name that I’m not aware of. A really great ~12:00 match that was taken down a notch by typical WWE bullshit. I still recommend it, if only to see how astoundingly better Meiko still is than every other woman on the WWE roster. ***3/4
Chris Sabin vs Alex Shelley - Prestige Wrestling “Combat Clash PDX”, 7/12
I can’t explain why, but the Motor City Machine Guns have never landed with me like they seem to land with everyone else. Don’t get me wrong, I think they’re a fine tag team, really good even, and I do understand how highly influential they are and all of that jazz. I don’t dislike the MCMG’s by any means (I love the 2009 Apollo 55 matches in New Japan) but I have never thought of them as great, which is something many, many other people do.
It doesn’t make much sense, because their style is right up my alley. Maybe it’s because as a team, they mainly worked the midwestern ROH loops as opposed to NY/NJ/Philly during peak ROH, which is the time and place where I formed my attachment to many of their contemporaries. They later spent giant bulks of time with TNA, which I have always drifted in and out of in terms of interest, so I likely haven't seen some of their best work. Beyond that, I really can’t explain it, because I don’t have any tangible critiques their work other than the ambiguous and vague “I don’t know man, they just don’t hit for me like they do for everyone else”. That bothers me, because I can go on for days breaking down just about any other act and why they do or do not connect with me.
As singles wrestlers, I’ve always loved Alex Shelley’s stuff, while Chris Sabin is someone I’ve always thought about as just pretty OK. I love the way Shelley moves around the ring in almost constant motion, keeping your eyes occupied almost like a magician, even when he isn’t really doing much. We haven’t seen a lot of it lately, but his shitheel work has always been top notch, helped along by an underrated punchable face that somehow doesn’t come across that way when he’s working as a babyface. He’s always been a fun wrestler. As far as Sabin goes, I can’t really explain why I don’t appreciate him as much, but he’s probably better than my mind gives him credit for. Perhaps I’ve now diagnosed my MCMG problem, it’s all Chris Sabin’s fault, and for reasons I can't put my finger on.
This was their final match for Prestige before shuffling off for a well earned WWE run. As you would expect, this was all wrrrrreeeeestling!, with crisp grappling, mirror image spots, and clean work as the long-time tag team partners enjoyed some fair and square competition. I was waiting for the spot where one guy takes a little cheap shot or accidentally breaks the unspoken code of honor, leading to a grittier closing stretch where both guys stop being polite and start getting real, but it never comes. They worked it straight, all the way through, with Sabin catching Shelley with a sunset flip out of nowhere, catch-as-catch-can style, after what I was surprised to find out was a brisk ~15:00+. The match was good, very good even, but never got over the hump to great, which perfectly sums up my relationship with this team. ***1/2
Lil’ Evil (c) vs Robbie Eagles - Inspire Pro Title - Inspire A.D. “May The Circle Be Unbroken”, 9/1
With no disrespect intended whatsoever to Lil’ Evil or Robbie Eagles, who put together a fine match, the star of the show was Walker Stewart, the (disgustingly) young and talented NJPW play-by-play man, who put on a master class of pro wrestling commentary that should be watched and studied by any and all independent wrestling commentators.
During the entrances, Stewart set up the credentials of each man beautifully, noting that Eagles recently won the Soul Of PWA title in Australia and making sure we knew Eagles was a New Japan Pro Wrestling regular without falling into the easy indie commentary trap of going TOO hard in extolling the virtues of the “big name” outsider to the point it makes your guys seem minor league. Later, to hammer home that we should be rooting for the hometown guy, Stewart noted that Eagles had promised to defend his Australian titles worldwide, but ever since his “change in attitude” (joining TMDK in New Japan), had become more selective in choosing his challengers. Stewart then mentioned that Eagles had recently challenged Atlantis Jr for the ROH TV title while listing off other high profile indies he recently appeared in, a neat little trick to put over Inspire, Lil’ Evil, and the Inspire Pro title on the level of those other Eagles stops. Stewart made sure to put over the credentials of Lil’ Evil equally, telling us about his long Inspire history as the former Prince Adam and being the 13th Inspire Pro champion.
As the match got underway, Stewart calmly filled the time during the feeling out period talking about how it is so rare for the 5’10”, 176lb Eagles to be the larger man, opining that he should exploit that size advantage against his 5’3” opponent. Stewart doesn't take for granted that everyone watching is intimately familiar with Eagles, making sure to explain the Ron Miller Special and how dangerous it is, describing the application and how Eagles often uses it to win his matches. Having called many Robbie Eagles matches, this is Stewart wisely understanding that 90% of his bouts are meticulously built around the leg work to set up that hold, and now anyone watching, some of whom might just be Texas indie fans and not overly familiar with an Australian wrestler who primarily works in Japan, were all caught up on on Eagles most important move and set up properly for the psychology of the match. In roughly ten or so minutes of real time, during the intros and before the match ever got cooking, Stewart’s calm, measured presentation of facts and history had you all set up on who these guys were and what this match was all about, even if you knew nothing about either man coming in. This kind of homework and attention to detail is the difference between some random guy calling a match and a pro. Tremendous work.
As Stewart so succinctly set up, Eagles did indeed spend the match working towards the RMS. Lil’ Evil escaped the first try rather easily, leading to a big comeback punctuated by a double foot stomp off the top rope that Eagles sold like a shotgun blast. Eventually, Eagles worked Evil back into the hold, and this time after fighting to the ropes for his escape, Evil spent the back third of the match selling the leg damage big. This made him an easy target for cutoff spots, and signaled that a third RMS would likely end the match. Eagles eventually went for it, but Evil fought it off with upkicks to the face, firing up Fighting Spirit style before hitting Eagles with a Hirooki Goto style guillotine driver to the knee to put Eagles away. The finish was a little abrupt, and I would have liked to have seen Evil sell the leg a little more after the first RMS escape, but it was a well structured match and a nice piece of booking with the local champ beating an international star who was likely going to be a one and done. Add an extra quarter star for the commentary. ***1/2
Dion Lennox vs Uriah Connors - WWE “NXT Level Up”, 7/23 (airdate 7/26)
As I've said about Level Up many times before, if you like watching rookies and watching young wrestlers develop in real time, Level Up a good show and a quick and easy weekly watch (most episodes clock in under 30 minutes, some under 20). The wrestling is simple and basic, by design, the best way I can describe it being the Japanese young boy style with slightly more flair and some extremely basic (and as a result, refreshing) storylines. Look, some of the matches are abysmal for obvious reasons, but Level Up is a much, much, MUCH better show than NXT proper if you’re someone who just likes to watch (mostly) no frills, straight up wrestling without the over the top, community theater, poorly performed sports entertainment. Unlike NXT, nobody on Level Up attempts to do wild, way over their heads shit that they can't handle and shouldn't be doing, and the storyline stuff is way less goofy and corny. The matches are all five minutes tops, with a heavy focus on the basics, and as a result, even factoring in how green most of the wrestlers are (some with less than 10 matches under their belt), I genuinely think the wrestling on this show is better and cleaner, match for match, than what you see on NXT.
A great example of what I’m talking about is this Dion Lennox vs Uriah Connors match from July. This was recommended to me by Griffin Peltier, and I immediately understood why.
Connors is the fourth generation, Twitter shitposter son of David, brother of the other David, Brogan Finley. In typical “this makes no fucking sense” WWE fashion, they acknowledge his family and who he is, but instead of leveraging that history to help get him over, he was given a name straight from the NXT name randomizer. He’s just 22, but with being so well traveled and growing up in the business, even in this sub-5 minute match, it’s so obvious that he’s really good, and realistically, probably the best wrestler in NXT not named Nathan Frazer or Axiom. He doesn’t have a WWE TV look, but the work and the instincts are leagues above everyone in NXT. He gets it, and sometimes you either do or you don’t, and it can’t always be taught.
Lennox is former Oregon St LB Andrzej Hughes-Murray, who also had a training camp cup of coffee with the Rams a few years ago. For some reason, he wears thick rimmed Poindexter glasses to the ring like another NXT wrestler from another generation, Percy Watson (the “OH YEAH!” guy).
“Dion Lennox vs Uriah Connors” may be an S-tier NXT name randomizer match, but the match was anything but generic. The backstory was simple, as these guys were briefly tag partners. It didn’t work out, because Lennox is a Nice Guy (they literally tell us this), and Connors is a grade-A asshole. Finley, err, Connors, understands his role here is to take little cheap shots and fill in the banks with shitty banter and scuzzy mannerisms, and his look (he looks like an indie scummer who would work a Japanese garbage groups teaming with Ricky Fuji) fits the gimmick. Lennox is the All American Nice Guy Glasses Wearing Boy Next Door Babyface, the guy you want dating your daughter, who promised his parents he would always do his best (they literally tell us this), and he fights through the cheap shots, vicious (and I mean vicious) chops, shortcuts, and other assorted assholery to win the match by reversing a cradle, in which Connors is caught by the ref trying to hold the ropes for leverage, with a cradle of his own.
The match is simple in structure, but it’s so great in execution. Connors is clearly excellent. But I already knew that, and it was to be expected. I came away more impressed with the rookie Lennox, who showed incredible fire after working from underneath and hitting a huge (and gorgeous) spinebuster, while showing great burst and athleticism and good selling.
Perhaps most impressive, in what was the most satisfying spot of the bout, Lennox started the match with a simple but super airtight and snug side headlock takeover, which instantly grabbed my attention and blew me away, because it was the kind of tightness on a simple hold that you rarely see on American TV these days and N-E-V-E-R ever ever ever see on NXT proper. I say this ALL THE TIME when I talk about the NJPW young lions, who often give up on the basics post-excursion, but I'm begging rookies across pro wrestling these days to keep that same attention to detail and snugness in their work once they move up the cards.
This was better than any NXT match I’ve seen this year that didn’t involve Nathan Frazer and/or Axiom. Strong rec, track it down. ***1/4