The Streaming Silence: Early Returns on AEW and WWE's New Era Are Quiet (Patreon)
Content
A conspicuous absence of celebratory announcements from AEW and WWE suggests that their streaming debuts may not have met expectations.
UPDATE (January 9, 2025 - 10:30AM EST)
WWE and Netflix have released numbers about the performance of RAW's debut on the streaming platform.
Per the release, RAW "wrestles up 4.9M global views for Netflix debut." That 4.9M comes from Live+1 views. In this case, views are "the total view hours for the program divided by the runtime."
According to VideoAmp data, the show averaged 2.6 million households live + same-day in the United States. That number would be a significant increase over RAW's 2024 average of 1.2M households per episode and a higher total than any other RAW in the last five years.
Using VideoAmp's data, RAW's debut on Netflix more than doubled the 18-to 49-year-old audience compared to last year.
As a report from Deadline points out, Nielsen viewership is not a 1:1 comparison to VideoAmp or any other digital viewership service, and the processes are very different.
-Rich
-----------------------
Original Published on January 8:
We're officially one week into our new streaming reality with AEW Dynamite and AEW Collision simulcasting on TNT and TBS, respectively, and MAX and WWE RAW debuting as a Netflix exclusive.
The early returns are... quiet.
That's the best way to put it.
Quiet.
After Dynamite debuted on the MAX streaming service, AEW and Warner-Bros Discovery didn't release or tout any streaming numbers. Even after Collision aired last Saturday, still nothing. While nobody could have expected concrete, solid data regarding MAX streaming numbers, the fact that we didn't get any press release touting the numbers lets us know the number of people viewing Dynamite on MAX was deemed either bad or fine. We know it wasn't good.
If it was good, we would've heard about it.
We haven't.
We do know that Dynamite's regular cable viewership number was largely unaffected by the simulcast on MAX. Airing on New Year's Day, AEW Dynamite averaged 588,000 viewers and 0.16 in the key 18-49 demo. That's a 2% increase in total viewership but an 11% drop week-over-week. Obviously, it wasn't a standard week, as AEW Dynamite aired on Christmas Day the previous week. Tonight's show airs with almost no significant sports competition aside from an NBA game featuring two of the best teams in the league: Oklahoma City Thunder vs. Cleveland Cavaliers, and on a regular ass Wednesday with no holiday.
Will we be able to glean anything from this week's Dynamite number?
Maybe.
Collision's numbers are a bit murkier. The January 4 episode, the first to simulcast on MAX, had huge drops week over week (down 46% in total audience and 55% in the demo). Did all of Collision's regular cable TV viewers head over to MAX? Probably not. The previous week's Collision had a monster lead-in from the College Football Playoff game, while the January 4 show went head-to-head with an NFL game between the Cincinnati Bengals and Pittsburgh Steelers.
That's a lot of words to say: who knows how the simulcast on MAX affected Dynamite and Collision?
We may have a better idea this week.
Ultimately, though, no PR blitz from WBD or AEW or even a carefully worded tweet from Tony Khan lets one assume the MAX number, again, is either insignificant or poor.
On the WWE side, the silence is even more deafening.
We've covered WWE's smart PR strategy here for several years. The pre-show marketing blitz for RAW's debut on Netflix was some of their best work. You couldn't escape the hype for Monday's show.
Since it's airing, though, crickets. WWE is not shy about promoting or manipulating numbers and metrics to toot its own horn. Their content partner, Netflix, is not typically shy about touting its numbers. In the hours following the Mike Tyson/Jake Paul fight on November 15, 2024, Netflix had a massive PR blitz, letting the world know that 60 million households had tuned in for the fight.
After successfully airing NFL games on Christmas Day, a similar PR blitz ensured everyone knew that "an unduplicated audience of nearly 65 million U.S. viewers on December 25" was watching the NFL on its service.
On Tuesday, Wrestlenomics' Brandon Thurston contacted Netflix PR regarding an announcement of RAW's numbers on the service. At the time, Thurston said Netflix had "no information to announce."
According to Flixpatrol.com, on Tuesday and Wednesday morning, RAW was listed as Netflix's #1 show in America on the streamers' internal ranking system.
As of the publication of this piece, RAW is currently ranked 4th in the United States.
Every Sunday, Netflix releases global rankings on their TUDUM website which also gives view numbers for all the shows. We'll, of course, have to wait until this Sunday to see how RAW ranks.
During his post-show press conference, Paul Levesque said he was informed of viewersNetflix'srs throughout the night and that Netflix executives were pleased with the number, but no specific numbers were given or indicated.
Today, we received the first bit of information (potentially) about RAW's performance on Netflix as SambaTV reported that 664,000 U.S. households watched the RAW debut on Netflix "when it aired."
SambaTV is an attempt to replicate the classic Neilsen Box for Smart TVs. It's a user-enabled app that tracks viewing data on Smart TVs. Per their website, SambaTV has agreements with 24 Smart TV brands and boasts "48 million addressable TV devices globally powering massive end-to-end viewership data and a household identity graph."
Of course, this doesn't fully show how many people watched RAW's debut on Netflix.
To my knowledge, SambaTV only tracks Smart TVs (24 brands of them—but missing significant industry leaders like Samsung, LG, and more) and does not have data on people watching through laptops, phones, game consoles, or other means of accessing RAW.
If true, that number would represent a significant drop from what RAW was doing on USA Network, as the show averaged around 1.131 million total viewers in December 2024.
Again, what's most telling to me is that WWE hasn't said anything about the number.
The vagueness of streaming numbers (particularly on Netflix) would allow them to release a worked or massaged number if they wanted to, but they haven't.
WWE has never been shy about promoting itself or its TV ratings; just last October, when NXT debuted on The CW, WWE.com had an article focusing on the success with a day of the show airing:
"Last night’s WWE NXT broadcast television debut The CW Network delivered the largest audience for the weekly program since October 2023, with 895,000 Total Viewers, up +44% compared to last week’s episode on cable TV. The premiere peaked at 965,000 total viewers from 8:15-8:30 p.m. and was the #1 telecast on The CW this year among adults 25-54 (406,000) and adults 18-49 (354,000)."
Yet, today, days removed from the much-hyped RAW debut on Netflix, we haven't heard a thing.
As I said above, the silence is deafening and leads me to believe, similar to AEW, that the number was either insignificant, disappointing or just okay.
If so, that's certainly not the start WWE wanted with its new streaming reality, particularly not on a show that featured PPV-level matches in Roman Reigns vs. Solo Sikoa and CM Punk vs. Seth Rollins, plus appearances by The Rock, John Cena, Hulk Hogan, and The Undertaker.
-Rich