Dreams, Dollars, and Disruption: Cobb, May, Vaquer & The State of Play in Wrestling Free Agency (Patreon)
Content
Recent news about Jeff Cobb, Mariah May, and Stephanie Vaquer highlights a shift where loyalty is absent, dreams hold more value than money, and change is positive.
This post is free- share it! If you like what you read, consider subscribing to FlagshipPatreon.com for more great articles like this and thousands of hours of bonus pro wrestling audio covering modern and historical wrestling. We have price tiers to fit all budgets ($1, $5, $10) and even offer a FREE tier.
---
Doesn't it feel like it's been a busy week of wrestling news already, and it's only Tuesday?
I'm writing a brief (ha!) piece today about three names—Jeff Cobb, Mariah May, and Stephanie Vaquer—that reveal much about the current state of wrestling free agency.
We'll start with Jeff Cobb.
Joe has been on top of the Cobb situation from the jump with Weekend News Updates and a Monday morning Flagship Plus featuring exclusive details on Cobb's NJPW departure and, by all accounts, soon-to-be WWE arrival. Cobb's situation is a unique one in that just a few days before announcing his departure, NJPW had him win the IWGP Tag Team Titles and, by all accounts, had planned on having him face Hirooki Goto for the IWGP World Heavyweight Championship after the Wrestling Dontaku tour.
As Joe pointed out in his audio, all signs point to his WWE arrival date being moved up and catching NJPW by surprise.
This is a huge departure from how WWE handled free agents during the bulk of Vince McMahon's tenure atop the company. Despite being pro wrestling's ultimate disrupter, McMahon still adhered to one of the key unwritten rules throughout wrestling history: finish up your bookings. McMahon had no issue stealing top stars from various territories during his rapid expansion in the mid-80s.
Still, he almost always respected those wrestlers finishing up their contractual obligations and bookings before they made the jump.
We're watching it happen in "real time" on my Tour of the Territories series. Sgt. Slaughter just showed up in McMahon's WWF, but at the same time, he's on Mid-Atlantic TV putting the final touches on his legendary feud with Ricky Steamboat & Jay Youngblood. McMahon allowed Slaughter to work in Mid-Atlantic for another few weeks before bringing him in full-time.
McMahon would adhere to that unwritten rule throughout much of his tenure, even into recent years when he'd signed top talent internationally or from the indies.
As we've seen with Karl Anderson, Stephanie Vaquer (more on her later), and now Jeff Cobb, that same courtesy is not being maintained in the Nick Khan/Paul Levesque era.
This brings us to another question: is Jeff Cobb being factored into WrestleMania plans? Joe theorized that something in Cobb's schedule caused NJPW to bail on their plans, strip him of the title, and move Callum Newman into the Dontaku match with Goto. Is there any idea of Cobb being involved in some major angle at WrestleMania? Could my man, The Disrupter, posting a photo of himself wearing an NJPW shirt the day before this Cobb news dropped, while looking at a Rubik's cube be related?
Never say never with my main man, The Disrupter!
On this morning's Wrestling Observer Radio, Dave Meltzer and Bryan Alvarez discussed rumors surrounding Mariah May and her AEW contract, which is assumed to be up in the summer.
Meltzer reiterated what many of us have been told throughout May's career: her goal is to be in WWE.
Her dream is WWE.
There will undoubtedly be a rollercoaster of emotions from fans on all ends of the spectrum related to this.
AEW fans are going to freak out and doom about AEW losing a 26-year-old talent who just finished up one of the hallmark women's feuds in company history.
WWE fans are rearing up for another round of "Tony Fumbled" takes.
I get it. A generation of pro wrestling fans never lived through a healthy wrestling ecosystem where wrestlers jumped and moved to different companies.
As such, each move, particularly AEW to WWE moves, is seen as a seismic shift and a massive perception loss in the ongoing pro wrestling war. That's not a very healthy way to live or consume wrestling.
Losing May is a blow for AEW, no doubt about it, but you move on, next man up. As Joe and I have recently discussed on The Flagship, Mariah May's AEW arc was perfect. It was a throwback. She came in as an understudy of Toni Storm. She turned on Toni Storm, and she won a title. Then Toni Storm beat her to win the title back with the literal words THE END draped across the screen. If that's the last we see of May in AEW, that's fine.
They told a two-year story that culminated in an excellent blowoff match for a PPV that did well financially, and the result was Storm, one of your talents, winning the feud and the title. Storm, who is only 29 herself, comes away from the feud as a bigger star than ever.
That's perfect, no?
It won't be seen that way, though. Again, the never-ending desire to "win" a wrestling war will cause a move like this to be seen as a disaster of epic proportions for AEW and something they cannot and will not recover from.
It's very dull and dumb, but such is modern pro wrestling discourse!
The crux of the issue, which will loop in Stephanie Vaquer, is that an entire generation of pro wrestlers knows only one company and dreams of working for only one company. The desire for "moments" and "dream chasing" is an uphill battle that AEW has to figure out how to navigate.
Harry Ruiz, a sports reporter and Spanish-language radio announcer for the Las Vegas Raiders, recently shared what he knew about Vaquer's negotiations with AEW and WWE.
Essentially, Vaquer was offered more money by AEW, WWE told her they couldn't match that offer, and to take the AEW deal, but she so badly wanted to be in WWE, her dream company, that she ended up taking WWE's deal.
With May, it's much of the same.
AEW could and probably will offer May more time to stay with the company, but will she take it?
A scroll of her Instagram feed pre-AEW shows a woman who very clearly sees WWE as the end goal of her career. You don't "make it" until you've been there. If the money is close enough, you take a pay cut to chase your dreams and create moments. There's very little AEW can do to combat or change that.
For a brief time, AEW had an advantage in negotiations with talents. WWE had a Vince McMahon problem; it was run by a doddering old man with a very narrow view of who could be a star in his company.
If you desired to be a top star and you didn't fit McMahon's mold, it was advantageous to look elsewhere.
Whether founded or not, that same perception doesn't exist in Paul Levesque's WWE. I would argue there's still a very narrow scope of stars in that company, too, but for now, most wrestlers who join WWE think they can be stars in that company.
When it began, AEW had a schedule and workload advantage over WWE. AEW touted in its earlier days a more manageable schedule for wrestlers, one that didn't require non-stop touring year-round with house shows and only required wrestlers to be at TV tapings and PPVs; the rest of the time could be spent with their families or at home.
It was a massive advantage for AEW right out of the gates.
WWE, smartly, has pulled back on its aggressive house show schedule. Today, the WWE working schedule is very similar to that of AEW. Another advantage was lost.
More than anything, though, AEW isn't cool right now. It was cool when it started, the coolest promotion through the pandemic, and it was cool when crowds returned in 2021. It's not cool anymore. We don't have to revisit everything that put it in this position, but as perception goes, WWE is cool; AEW is not.
When AEW was the hot upstart paying people more to work less in front of rabid crowds and wasn't run by Vince McMahon, they had the free agent advantage. Most of the large-scale perception war jumps went from WWE to AEW. That's flipped, and AEW has lost most of those advantages besides pay and more freedom. They can still offer more money to the people they want to retain or sign, but what we're finding out this week with people like Vaquer, and likely will find out with May, is that's not the primary motivation factor for many of today's wrestlers.
American dollars are good, but dreams and moments are much more highly valued currency.
Again, if you've never lived through a healthy wrestling ecosystem, this may surprise you, but it will be cyclical.
AEW won't always lose these perception wars.
Hell, just last year, AEW WON a few of them by signing Kazuchika Okada, Mercedes Mone, and Will Ospreay.
When AEW launched, they scooped up several top WWE stars and prospects.
The worm turned, beginning with Cody and McMahon's ouster, and WWE started to have the advantage.
It'll flip-flop again. It always does.
We saw the same thing play out with WWE and WCW during the heyday of the Monday Night Wars.
My advice to you: embrace it.
Wrestler movement is good. Moving from one company to another is fun and interesting. I get that people are annoyed when wrestlers they like go to a company they don't watch, or they don't vibe with; I get it, I was once in your position, but it's not worth stressing out over.
Embrace the change.
Embrace that you had a great two-year story arc with Mariah May, don't fret that it's over.
I'll take a wrestling ecosystem that sees people have perfectly built and concluded two-year story arcs in a company over The Miz and Kofi Kingston, spending decades doing the same shit over and over again.
Bringing this entire story full circle, WWE deciding they need Cobb (42 years old) to leave NJPW right away just forced NJPW to give 22-year-old Callum Newman a main event title match. If Newman grabs that opportunity by the horns and has a great match, it'll be the beginning of an entirely new chapter of his career, and we'll always be able to look back at this moment as the turning point in his career.
I'm absolutely NOT comparing the two directly. Do not put in the newspaper that I'm comparing the two, BUT in 1990, when Hachiro Tanaka, an eyewear magnate, stole Genichiro Tenryu (40 years old) from AJPW, Giant Baba looked around at his roster and focused his eyes on a masked prospect to become his next big star. That masked prospect was Mitsuharu Misawa (28 years old). The rest, as they say, is history.
Each departure is a new opportunity.
If you can't see how fun and cool that is, you and I just look at wrestling in an entirely different way.
-Rich