Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

An update to an article from 11 years ago examining John Cena vs. Randy Orton, by the numbers. 

In October 2014, I wrote an article for Voices of Wrestling analyzing the never-ending cycle of John Cena vs. Randy Orton matches in WWE.

The article examined the numbers and stats surrounding the two interlocked histories.

As I'm sure you are ALL aware, WWE Backlash is this Saturday, and the next and likely final chapter of Cena vs. Orton is here.

There is no better time to update my piece from 11 years ago, so let's do it.

Note: When applicable, I included the October 2014 value for any data used here in 2025. 

Total Matches: 336

October 2014: 315

There have been 336 total matches involving John Cena and Randy Orton together, against one another, teaming with one another, six-mans, Royal Rumbles, Elimination Chambers, the whole nine yards. This number also includes a few Ohio Valley Wrestling shots.

What I find most interesting about the total number is how it compares to where that number was in 2014 (315).

The first Orton/Cena interaction occurred in July 2001 when Cena (then Prototype) teamed with Rico Costantino to take on the very random and hilarious duo of Bobby Eaton and Randy Orton. A guy who approached every match in his entire life by giving 110% effort no matter the time, place, or stakes... and Randy Orton.

From July 2001 to October 2014, John Cena and Randy Orton faced each other in the ring 315 times. If we calculate the average per month over 158 months, they met an average of approximately 2 times per month (1.99)

In the 126 months since I wrote Cena vs. Orton: The Numbers, the two have only met in the ring 21 times, or an average of 0.16.

The output slowed down tremendously (thankfully) primarily due to reduced schedules for both men as they entered the veteran phase of their careers, injuries, and, more than anything, Cena focusing more of his time on Hollywood.

These two had 121 singles matches from August 2001 to October 2014 and just two since:

February 7, 2017: John Cena vs. Randy Orton (SmackDown - Seattle, Washington)

February 11, 2017: John Cena vs. Randy Orton (House Show - Las Cruces, New Mexico)

PPV/TV Show Matches: 91

October 2014: 84

Again, this number shows how overdone Cena vs. Orton was during the prime of both men's careers and how the company has backed off of it for a multitude of reasons. When I wrote my piece in October 2014, it was building to a Hell in a Cell 2014 match between the two. Between my writing and the actual Hell in a Cell match, the two had a few matches on RAW, but after the October 26, 2014 Hell in a Cell match, the interactions between the two all but ended.

They team with one another (and Cesaro) to take on Kevin Owens, Rusev & Sheamus on the July 20, 2015, episode of RAW, then wait another two years before The Wyatt Family duo of Bray Wyatt and Randy Orton (don't ask) was defeated John Cena and Luke Harper (don't ask).

The SmackDown singles match between Cena and Orton followed soon after. After that match in February 2017, the two didn't share a televised ring until the Survivor Series 2017 PPV when the duo teamed up as part of Team SmackDown LIVE in a losing effort to Team RAW. This was in the peak era of Team Blue Shirts vs. Team Red Shirts. I don't remember a thing about this match, but here are your combatants for posterity:  

RAW vs. SmackDown LIVE Survivor Series: Team RAW (Braun Strowman, Finn Balor, Kurt Angle, Samoa Joe & Triple H) vs. Team SmackDown LIVE (Bobby Roode, John Cena, Randy Orton, Shane McMahon & Shinsuke Nakamura)

Total Televised Singles Matches: 22

October 2014: 20

Again, the theme of this update is how overdone Cena vs. Orton was for a time and how WWE has resisted the temptation to return to it much since then.

Since we last looked at these numbers, the two have had only two televised singles matches.

Here's the breakdown by year:

2002: 1

2003: 0

2004: 0

2005: 1

2006: 0

2007: 4

2008: 3

2009: 5

2010: 2

2011: 0

2012: 0

2013: 1

2014: 4

2015: 0

2016: 0

2017: 1

2018: 0

2019: 0

2020: 0

2021: 0

2022: 0

2023: 0

2024: 0

Overall Singles Record: 14-6 (1 No Contest)

In my October 2014 piece, I correctly predicted Cena's victory over Orton at Hell in a Cell. It would be Cena's third of four straight wins over Orton. In fact, the last time Orton defeated Cena in a singles match was at the 2014 Royal Rumble.

I wouldn't expect Orton to turn the tide at Backlash.

LOLCENAWINS (but this time as a heel).

Overall Record: 211-44-6

October 2014: 203-41-5

Cena's overall win percentage over Orton is 80.8%, propped up, of course, by a bevy of house shows where WWE often wanted the fans to go home happy with the babyface prevailing.

Cena's 80.8% win percentage over Orton is his fourth-highest win percentage over an opponent with at least 100 matches, trailing Seth Rollins (91.7%), Kane (89.1%), and The Miz (82%).

Cena's lowest win percentage against opponents with at least 100 matches is CM Punk!

Over 109 matches with Punk, Cena is 73-26-10 with a win percentage of just 67%.

For some fun Cena math, did you know that among the 331 listed opponents for John Cena on Cagematch, just 72 of them have a 100% win percentage OVER Cena:

Adam Cole

Aiden English

Andrade

Andy The Enterprise

Apollo Crews

Armando Estrada

Austin Theory

B-2

Bill DeMott

Bron Breakker

Carmelo Hayes

Chad Gable

Chavo Guerrero Jr.

Chavo Guerrero Sr.

Christopher Nowinski

Daniel Puder

Dave Taylor

David Flair

David Hart Smith

Diesel

Ernest Miller

Evan Bourne

Fiend

Frankie Kazarian

Goldberg

Gregory Helms

Hurricane

IShowSpeed

Jacob Fatu

Jamal

Jerry Lawler

Joe Hendry

Johnny

Justin Sane

Kalisto

Keiji Sakoda

Kenny Bolin

Kevin Federline

Kevin Thorn

LA Knight

Lance Storm

Lil Cholo

Logan X

Manu

Marcus Cor Von

Mason Ryan

Matt Hardy Version 1.0

Maven

Mike Bell

Mikey

Mitch

Mojo Rawley

Neville

Nicky

Nova

Otis

Penta

Rosey

Sandman

Santos Escobar

Scott Steiner

Shane Ballard

Shane McMahon

Shannon Ballard

Shannon Moore

Shark Boy

Shinsuke Nakamura

Simon Dean

Spike Dudley

Torrie Wilson

Tyler Reks

Yoshi Tatsu

What's your favorite name on this list? There's a bit of noise with some Royal Rumble names in there, but who cares, we're just having fun.

The one that immediately jumped out to me was Torrie Wilson as I was trying to rack my brain of figure out what the fuck had to happen to result in a Torrie Wilson vs. John Cena match that Torrie won.

It turns out that Torrie teamed with her then-partner Billy Kidman in a winning effort against the duo of John Cena and Dawn Marie at the WWE Rebellion 2002 PPV in Manchester, United Kingdom.

Who knew?!

Better yet, her team won in all seven (!) instances of Torrie Wilson teaming up with either Billy Kidman or Taiji to face the formidable duo of Dawn Marie and John Cena.

Torrie is second only to Nova (!) in total matches where an opponent defeated Cena every time. Nova has nine such instances.

The Nova matches come with a bit of an asterisk as he was the OVW Heavyweight Champion during much of Cena's time there as Prototype.

BUT!

Not always.

Nova and Rey Mysterio defeated John Cena and Redd Dogg thrice on January 2003 SmackDown house shows.

To date, Cena has never gotten his revenge on either Torrie or Redd Dogg. There are still a few more months, though.

Avg. Singles Match Cagematch Rating: 6.22

October 2014: 6.34

Cagematch ratings for Cena vs. Orton matches have remained relatively consistent over the past 11 years since I first wrote about them.

Although the overall rating has slightly decreased—likely because newer users are rating Cena vs. Orton matches lower—the most recent singles matches have ratings of 6.78 and 6.76.

Despite a few outliers, such as a rating of 3.39 for WWE Unforgiven 2007 and 8.44 for WWE Bragging Rights 2009, the ratings show remarkable consistency across 14 data points, with a standard deviation of just 1.35.

Consistently mediocre is still consistent.

I don't have a ton of reviews on record for Cena vs. Orton matches, as a large majority happened before I launched Voices of Wrestling, but I did review Hell in a Cell 2014. Here's what I had to say about the match:

Rich Kraetsch: This feud needs a legendary match to become what WWE wants it to be, this wasn’t it but this was good. This may have been their best yet, at the very least, this was light years better than their 2009 Hell in a Cell match. Orton using multiple RKOs out of nowhere was a good touch and should bode well for his future face run. What more can you say? Good on both of them for having an exciting match and good on WWE for not putting this on last. ***1/2

Days As Champion: 1898 (Cena) & 1372 (Orton)

These are the days these two men have held championship gold in WWE.

John Cena is a 14-time Undisputed WWE Champion, 5-time WWE United States Champion, 3-time World Heavyweight Champion, and two times he's held both the World Tag Team and WWE World Tag Team titles.

Cena's longest individual reign lasted 380 days as WWE Heavyweight Champion, starting with his title win against Edge at WWE Unforgiven 2006 and ending at the onset of the WWE No Mercy PPV. Cena tore his pectoral muscle on RAW before the show, so the title was awarded to Randy Orton.

Then, on the very same PPV, Randy Orton lost the title to Triple H. Just an hour or so later (yes, I'm serious), Orton defeated Triple H to win back the title he was awarded earlier in the evening.

Orton is a 10-time Undisputed WWE Champion, 4-time World Heavyweight Champion, and 2-time WWE World Tag Team Champion. He also once held the World Tag Team, WWE Intercontinental, Tag Team, and United States Championships.

Orton's longest individual reign is his 203-day reign as WWE Heavyweight Champion, which began at WWE No Mercy 2007 and ended at WWE Backlash 2008, when he lost a four-way elimination match featuring John Cena.

Only a few of these title reigns occurred after publishing my original piece.

Cena won the United States Championship for the fourth and fifth time in 2015, had a 14-day run with the WWE Championship in 2017, and his current run with the Undisputed WWE Championship began at WrestleMania 41.

Orton had a few more, starting with a 23-day reign as WWE SmackDown Tag Team Championship with his Wyatt Family breather (again, don't ask): Bray Wyatt and Luke Harper.

Orton had two additional WWE Championship reigns: a 49-day reign in 2017 and a 22-day reign during the COVID-19 pandemic in 2020. In between, he had a 28-day reign as United States Champion.

Orton's two most recent titles are his 142-day and 74-day reigns as RAW Tag Team Champion with his then-RK-Bro tag partner Matt Riddle.

Orton has not held a WWE title since May 2022, and I don't expect him to hold one after May 2025, either.

Average PPV Buys: N/A

October 2014: 312,444

One of the more critical aspects of my Cena vs. Orton study from October 2014 was looking at the plummeting PPV buy rates from PPVs that heavily featured these two.

My study, 11 years ago, has been used in many arguments about the Wrestling Observer Hall of Fame case for Orton, including by the Hall of Fame curator, Dave Meltzer.

The conclusion I came to in that original study was that the duo had once over-delivered on typical WWE PPV buys in a given year, but by 2013, they started to be absolute poison to PPV buyers:

2007 Cena vs. Orton: 373,500

2007 Overall: 254,667

2008 Cena vs. Orton: 329,000

2008 Overall: 279,417

2009 Cena vs. Orton: 259,500

2009 Overall: 249,222

2013 Cena vs. Orton: 181,000

2013 Overall: 253,300

We can't update this study per se since the launch of the WWE Network in February 2014 made 1:1 comparisons of PPV buys from that era to 2017-2013 impossible.

But we can compare it to other 2014 PPVs, and the conclusion is similar to the one we had with pre-WWE Network PPV buys: people did not want to pay to see Cena vs. Orton anymore.

According to data compiled by Wrestlenomics, Hell in a Cell had 23,000 buys domestically (United States). That was down 12,000 from the previous month's Night of Champions PPV and down 9,000 from the next month's Survivor Series PPV.

Poison!

The 23,000 domestic buys for Hell in a Cell 2014 were the lowest post-Network PPV buy number of the year until the December 2014 TLC PPV (17,000).

Tickets Sold: 15,297

That's the number of tickets estimated by WrestleTix to have been sold to WWE Backlash emanating from the Enterprise Center in St. Louis, Missouri.

WrestleTix estimates the arena is set up for 16,640. With 15,297 already out with several days to go, you'd assume WWE could sell most of the remaining 1,343 tickets.

This would be the third match between the two from the Enterprise Center (formerly Scottrade Center).

The arena hosted the February 2, 2009 episode of RAW, which featured a World Heavyweight Title Street Fight between Cena and Orton as a special after-RAW Dark Match. Remember those? Unfortunately, Cagematch doesn't have attendance data for this show.

Cagematch has an attendance figure for the return bout between the two from the same arena on January 17, 2014 for a WWE Live House Show. The listed attendance for this show is a "capacity" of 6,000, so we may not be able to glean much from this.

A good comparison point, though, is that the most recent episode of RAW to take place from the Enterprise Center (October 7, 2024) sold a reported 8,296.

So, for this PPV, at least, fans are amped up about seeing Cena vs. Orton for the (hopefully) final time.

Wish I could share the same sentiment.

-Rich

Files

Comments

Matthew Allen

Great article, Rich, but I have to file a small correction. John Cena's longest reign as Undisputed WWE Champion did not end with a loss to Randy Orton, but to an injury. Cena tore his right pectoral muscle in a match with Mr. Kennedy on the go home show for No Mercy 2007. Orton was then awarded the title at the start of the No Mercy PPV by Vince McMahon.

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

Ah right that super convoluted No Mercy show where Orton was awarded the title then HHH beat him for the title then Orton beat HHH for the title at the end of night. So technically, to correct your correction, Orton's reign didn't begin with defeating Cena, it began with defeating HHH -Rich

Doug Hunt

I was at the 2014 Rumble in Pittsburgh, back when I was a "WWE-Only" fan....shudders those were dark days. The crowd was so bored they were chanting the most random things. I am so pumped to not watch this show as I'm seeing Alice in Chains and Mammoth in Saturday. But I'm pumped for the IRL, if y'all are doing one.