"Where's The Lie?": Dissecting The Unhinged Obsession With Hanging On Every Word Of The Man Who Saved American Pro Wrestling (Patreon)
Content
Tony Khan saved American wrestling from a sports entertainment monopoly, making him a forever target of insecure WWE boosters threatened by AEW's existence and other assorted loons that can't let go of the Monday Night War
The pattern has repeated for entirety of AEW's existence. Tony Khan speaks, and the assortment of retired or banished ex-national TV wrestling personalities desperately clinging to relevence and the other assorted loons that make up the collective amatuers of the almost always embarassing wrestling media (not to mention the cottage industry of shut ins chasing Elon pennies on X) investigating his every word like they are performing a crime scene investigation.
Let's just get this out of the way, AEW is an unmitigated success, full stop. There is no reasonable, well informed counter argument to be had. They are, by far, to the point it is kind of silly and embarrassing to even bother pointing it out, the most successful pro wrestling start up since Vince McMahon destroyed the rest of the industry four decades ago, and it isn't even close.
Dynamite is one of the biggest cable TV hits of the decade, a consistent top ten performer, often living in the top five or higher on Wednesday's, sometimes number one or only trailing NBA games, and one of the top performing cable programs overall, especially so when measured against cable originals. This might surprise the ignorant or uninformed, or those who listen exclusively to the goof troop types listed a couple paragraphs above, but any serious person who studies the television industry would tell you the same and laugh you out of the room if you attempted to dispute it. This is how AEW was able to secure four separate media rights deals from WBD in their first five years of existence, two of which were rewritten deals after WBD agreed to tear up previous contracts due to overperfromance. Dynamite, and AEW as a cable property, is and has always been a big hit and clear television winner.
AEW's 2023 All In Wembley owns the largest paid attendance (81,035) in professional wrestling history. Go argue with a wall. All data supports this, including (and especially) the infamous turnstile count. The turnstile count of 72,265, weaponised by the not-so-bright to dispute the reported attendance, actually supports the paid attendance claims, as the turnstile percentage (89.2%) falls in line with AEW/industry standard turnstile percenatges for large scale events (roughly 90%).
Set aside All In 2023, the second Wembley show in 2024 drew more fans (53,922) than any other American wrestling promotion since the close of WCW has drawn in any entire year, (and in some cases their entire history) and it isn't even close. The 2023 All In Wembley show did a $10M+ gate, something no other wrestling company in history has achieved aside from WWE. WCW never had a single $1M gate in its history, AEW has had several in just under 6 years. You can adjust for inflation if you like, AEW still has WCW beat.
Those attendance and gate comparisons include TNA, the business of which some still laughably compare to AEW. I will humor this.
AEW's worst performing PPV of all time (Full Gear 2019 or 2020, take your pick) outdrew TNA's best performing PPV of all time (Genesis 2006 or Hard To Kill 2024, again take your pick, both estimated around 60,000 buys) by tens of thousands of buys. AEW has eclipsed TNA's all time attendance record (8,100) roughly ~45 times, and has eclipsed TNA's paid domestic attendance record (6,700) over 50 times. Keep in mind that TNA was founded in 2002, while AEW has existed for under 6 years. Many like to point to TNA iMPACT! topping out years ago at over one million viewers per week, without the context that Dynamite's ~600,000 viewers today is far more impressive (and valuable to advertisers) than TNA's ~1M viewers 15-20 years ago, due to the changing television ratings landscape. iMPACT! was never anything close to a top ten performing show on cable, which is why it slowly tumbled down the cable prestige line from Spike to Destination America to Pop TV to Pursuit Channel to where it now resides on AXS TV, which also happens to be owned by the same parent company that owns TNA, meaning if not for that connection, iMPACT! would very likely no longer even have a television home. Let me be clear. There is no facet of TNA's business at any point over its 23 year history that is in any way even comparable in the same stratosphere of AEW's business, to even debate this is foolish, and anyone who attempts to do so should not be taken seriously. Any AEW comparisons to other American wrestling startups over the last two decades, such as MLW, Billy Corgan's Lightning One era NWA, WOW, etc are utterly pointless.
But to the goof troop and assorted loons, success is and can only be measured against WWE (and this is the real tell that the "AEW is dying" crowd knows it's a success, because they ignore the apples to apples comparisons of other startups and skip right to comparing it to daddy). Everything is framed from the perspective of the Monday Night War. This is the only frame of reference these people have, because they have been brainwashed by years of WWE documentaries and Eric Bischoff desperately clinging to and milking his precious 83 weeks. WCW briefly won what in hindsight amounted to nothing more than bragging rights, a pissing contest that ultimately contributed to the death of the company, and that meaningless ratings war and the warped nostalgia around it frames the way today's shallowest thinkers assess the performance of AEW. If you aren't beating WWE, you must be failing. That is the one and only measuring stick to be had, because middle aged wrestling fans can't let go of a dick measuring contest from 30 years ago.
AEW is never catching WWE in the only metric that matters, revenue. AEW is also a very successful, stable, and profitable wrestling promotion. Both of these things can be, and are, true. In the context of "Is AEW a success?", how it is performing in relation to WWE literally does not matter. Any analysis that begins with or if framed around "If AEW wants to win..." or "AEW will never beat WWE unless..." is a tell that the person delivering it is hopelessly stuck in the Monday Night War timewarp and should be handwaved as someone providing nothing of real substance. The answer to any question beginning with anything resembling "How can AEW beat WWE?" is who fucking cares, because it does not matter. In a world where WWE doesn't exist and AEW's metrics are no different than they are today, you'd have to be a fool to conclude that AEW isn't succeeding, but instead we use a measure of success from 30 years ago and these neanderthals refuse to evolve.
Ask these people what "winning" actually means in today's world, and I bet they can't even answer it. The ratings war they are obsessed with barely exists with audiences split by streaming and RAW moving to streaming full stop. Is "winning" some abstract measure of perception or market share? The real game, from the start, was putting AEW out of business or making them irrelevent. I don't know who needs to hear this, but WWE are the ones losing here. AEW "wins" by existing at a meaningful level that takes a piece of market share (while driving up talent cost, which is the real fight that TKO knows they are losing).
Deep down, I believe most of the grifter crowd understands that AEW has "made it", which is what drives all of the insanity over AEW existing. These people always existed, we saw them deeply insecure a few years earlier when NJPW was the smark promotion of choice (nothing eats at the fragile insecurity of a WWE obsessed loon like other fans preferring other styles of wrestling), and a half generation earlier when it came to peak ROH. Railing against TNA was always pointless as they were never a real threat to WWE's dominance and never earned the kind of smark cred NJPW or ROH did. AEW is the perfect storm of being a critically acclaimed alternative product while also proving to be the first successful WWE alternative in a lot of these people's adult lives. This stokes tribalism in a culture that has never been more brand obesessed and brand loyal, and this has evoked jealousy from ex-industry types who were either not invited to the party, see Tony Khan as an interloper who succeeded where they themselves failed, have a twisted and bizarre loyalty and/or admiration for Vince McMahon (and by proxy, WWE, the "right way" to do wrestling), or all of the above. While I enjoy AEW, it is still too similar in style and presentation to WWE for my tastes, but to these types of critics, Khan is doing wrestling "wrong", because he doesn't do it the same way WWE does it or the way Vince used to do it. There is only one right way to do wrestling, because that way won. It annoys them that there is a fanbase that enjoys Khan's brand of wrestling, it annoys them that it has proven to be successful, so they have to find a way to tear it down. The easiest and laziest way to do this, is to say "they can't beat WWE". Concern trolling, pearl clutching, and manipulation of facts are all part of the strategy. We are scared shitless and confused that this thing that isn't Our Brand found an audience, so we have to convince everyone that this thing is actually failing. Tony Khan once said that AEW is constantly under attack, and it is. And by proxy, so is Khan himself. Every time he speaks, his words are sifted by derganged internet prospectors looking for gold in the form of bad faith criticism and engagement bait.
The latest example of the unhinged dissection of every word uttered by Tony Khan came this week, in a 53 second clip making the rounds of Khan discussing AEW with Yahoo! Finance, where one minor flub became chum for the disingenuous and the ignorant.
The clip begins with Khan saying, "It feels like 2025 is in a lot of ways the best year we've had, we're having a great-".
At that point, the interviewer cuts him off, so while we can only guess how he was going to finish that statement, what is unquestionably, factually, objectively true, is that 2025 will be the best financial year AEW has ever had, due to the new media rights deal, which according to Variety, is worth “upwards of $150 million per year when all elements are taken into account.” The previous deal was worth an estimated ~$45M. Dave Meltzer and Brandon Thurston both estimate that AEW should easily be profitable in 2025, and it should be noted that both estimates, particularly in the case of Thurston's, skew deliberately conservative in their asessments.
So, objectively, 2025 will be the best year AEW has had, from the most important measurable standpoint, revenue. Hard to take any reasonable issue with that. But then came the mistake, one phrase that fed the cretins for days:
“We’re doing fantastic. This is a huge year for us. We grew the business so much with the simulcast, we’ve brought in new audience with Max and streaming but also we’ve been able to grow our cable audience year-over-year.”
This, of course, is not true. AEW's cable audience was down in Q1 2025 vs Q1 2024, and remains down in Q2. But it seems Khan knew he misspoke when he said "year over year", based on his follow up, when the interviewer pressed him on YOY growth:
“A lot of people thought when you start simulcasting AEW on Wednesday nights and Saturday nights, oh ok a lot of people they’re still going to watch the show but people are going to migrate to streaming. Well actually our cable audience when we started simulcasting went up and we have a great audience on Max streaming every week too."This is factually correct. AEW's cable audience, has, in fact, increased since the rollout of the MAX simulcast, which cooincidentally was at the start of 2025. Dynamite averaged 610k viewers Q4 2024, and is averaging 618k viewers over Q1 & Q2 2025. Collision, which to be fair has often aired out of timeslot in the current quarter, in totality is currently averaging 385k viewers Q2 2025, versus 348k viewers Q4 2024. I know we exist in a post fact world, but 618 is still larger than 610, and 385 is larger than 348.
Context and common sense would tell you that when Khan said "year over year", what he meant was the end of last year compared to what they've done so far in 2025. He set the statement up by saying 2025 has been a great year, and followed up the mispoken "year over year" bit with accurate clarification that the cable audience has grown since the end of last year, and after the rollout of the streaming simulcast. What do you think the disingenuous ghouls chose to focus on? The pile of facts, or the mispoken "year over year" phrase, which he corrected when pressed? Context and common sense don't matter when there is an agenda at hand, it doesn't matter that he clarified, Tony Khan is a LIAR.
Aside from the usual Elon penny chasers and grifters, even mainstream media like Awful Announcing joined the pile on, because shitting on AEW is good business. WWE brand loyalists love a good AEW shitpost, nothing is more comforting than comradery, and as just about anyone in wrestling media will tell you, anti-AEW content sells.
And so it goes. And it will continue to go, as long as AEW continues to thrive in a world where many see its existence as a threat to the chosen brand, and thriving only counts if you win the mythical war with the non existent stakes.
JL