Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

Joe Reviews All In: Texas

Yes, more show length discourse

Who I thought was the star of the show

I'll tell you which spot prevented which match from rising from very good to great

Why Hangman was the right choice despite feeling like he was completing someone else's story

Files

Comments

Gerhard Köber

Darby is not a world champion! Never!

WC

The Death Riders story really is the Bloodline for grown-ups, for all the good and ill that entails. Same core character (disgruntled top baby-face spouting nonsense about the competition being inferior, despite obviously being a coward who never wins on their own), a promising start that quickly devolved into repetitive nonsense, and a final build that energized the fanbase culminating in crowning a top guy. At least this version didn't take 4 years, and actually has a a sensible ending. Tying the story into Hangman's redemption arc will be the thing that makes the story be remembered more fondly over time. This show was definitely egregiously long and pretty meh. I think every match under-delivered, though I can't rate the Toni Mone match as I didn't watch most of it.

Sean Obst

40 minutes in and we are still complaining about the length of this show. First time I couldn’t finish one of these reviews.

Andrew Hyland

Flagship boys, two men, one brain. Thanks for the two reviews.

Dave Schneider

The difference between people that watched the show live and those that watched it on delay is so vastly different. Not that it was a perfect show, but the ones that didn’t watch it live seem to have gone into it ready to complain. Knowing how long the show was in advance seems to have shaded some of their perspectives.

Dustin

I May be in the minority but I thought the length was fine it didn’t drag on Saturday. I do think the big matches could have been spread out more so you didn’t have such a slow start, but I was so pumped for the show that carried me through the first 2 hours then the last 4 were great.

Jose Bautista

Good bit on making the AEW diehards wait 3 days for a review to just shit on the show lol wasn't a fan of the show either and for the show length I already mentally prepared for 6 hours(I only caught the last 30 minutes of the pre show) so the length didn't really effect me especially a nice early show.

Craig

See your point Joe and everyone has right to their opinion. I felt that the show, specifically the final stretch did an excellent job in restoring the feeling (ugh) for a lot of the AEW fanbase. (Respectfully disagree your take on Hangman's sustained reaction upon winning) on. As Dave said on WOR, the post Brawl Out stink seems to have finally been lifted. It also helped I watched the show unspoiled, yet piecemeal.

Craig

I also feel that WWE melodrama is much, much worse than when AEW flirts with it. However, I can see why it's not to everyone's tastes.

Someone

Dude went full on Boomer for this review lol. I knew the show was long before the 30th time you said it. And yeah the tag match was great not just good.

George Atsaves

I liked that all the big matches were at the end. Made the show feel like a Wrestle Kingdom where it just kept building and building towards a main event. I also didn't think the show dragged FWIW. It wasn't a perfect show by any means but it didn't drag.

MJ H

I can't help but agree with this because these reviews, while obviously honest and well informed, just don't reflect my experience watching the show live (or the reactions I saw from other in the know fans who watched it live).

Daaave

I definetly think watching live the length was less of an issue. I can imagine being away and looking forward to catching up only to see the show length being a bit of a bummer from get go. But watching it live I didn't really think about length too much, not until the tag title match and then once that was done we were into the 3 big ones so I was invested heavily. Like using the Post Wrestling guys as example and they didn't have major issue with length and those 2 hate anything remotely long normally

Todd Craven

I'd rather watch another 8 hour show (which doesn't take my anywhere near 8 hours since I don't watch live and skip even entrances...Prime has great replay) than listen to another 5:50 hours of reviews of an 8 hour show from the same site. Now I realize that was on me, and I don't usually listen to Good, Bad & Hungee, but the Flagship pushed that at me instead of a Flagship show. Also, that was by far the best review of the show from this site. (Two guys together is always superior to 1.) Additionally, I thought Jesse Collings had more unique to say than Joe and Rich, who both said the same things, just in their own personal ways. Again, all on me for listening to it, but in the future, just skip shows the site has already covered & you're already days behind, or do a review together on the Flagship. There's no reason, both guys couldn't have waited until Tuesday night or something and done their same 1:30 together. I don't have an issue that I have different opinions, but the audio was just too much for nothing new...I can't skip forward through a podcast like I can a PPV. I'd much rather have had a review of Supercard of Honor from Joe or Rich than the 3rd/4th All In review from VOW. Anyway, I appreciate the effort, but just take this as constructive criticism for future coverage for customers.

TheMightyKyle

Particularly when there's a built-in urgency to watch the entire show. It's human nature. All the points of criticism have validity, but the overall tenor seems to be tilted by that frustration. I didn't watch the pre show and enjoyed the main card overall even with the subpar first 1.5 hrs. A lot of us have no problem watching college and NFL football all day, so I had little problem with this good afternoon show going long.

Christos C

I often have to watch shows the next day as I'm in the UK. I always watch unspoiled but sometimes feel less positive than Joe or Rich. This I feel the exact opposite like we watched two different shows entirely but I could watch live! Also perhaps a question of how you rate a wrestling show: an average of each match or weighted towards the top. The crowd wasn't as bad as suggested here I didn't think!

Christos C

I think I agree. I watched in London noting that the show started when the sun was glaring on my TV and ended at 2am and I skipped the pre show. I think I have a double think take of the show should have been shorter but also didn't feel a drag at the time. If I watched the next day with 6hrs on the clock I might have been like Jesus Christ though!

Devin Axtman

Nobody sang Mistico’s song but it was hot in the building throughout the show for the parts that delivered. I don’t know if it was the acoustics and/or how it was miced. But it was super hot

Medellin

It’s Joe Lanzas version

Christos C

I wouldn't be quite this harsh as different views are fine but think they'd have been better just to cover on the Flagship. The Jesse Collins and Hungee reviews seem more insightful and reflect more of what I saw and felt from the show. I think I posted this elsewhere but feels like Joe and Rich were watching a different show at times even though I agree could be shorter and the first three matches were quite mid.

Jasen Omega

Joe and Rich need another vacation. I didn't watch the pre-show, so the overall length was cool for me. Main event paid off a year's worth of story. If they did the run-ins at the start of the match, that would have sucked.

Anthony Romano

It's so funny there were zero complaints Saturday night after the show about its length. But the people who had to make a job out of it do nothing but complain about the length.

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

Im glad you had no issue with the length of the show. Im really not sure why some of you think the lenght of an EIGHT HOUR SHOW wasnt going to be a talking point or that it isnt reasonable to think that EIGHT HOURS is too long for a show.

Van Hammer

Wrestling show length discourse is the same as movie length discourse. Very boring to listen to. If you’re already predisposed to dislike something because of the length, just don’t watch it.

Medellin

Joe you really need a new mic

Doug Hunt

Agree about Thekla leaping of the screen. I know its unfair to compare, but her arrival came as May debuted as Blake Monroe. Seeing Thekla now vs Blake in NXT is eye opening to say the least

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

I am not predisposed to disliking anything. I clearly laid out why I thought the length of this specific show, which was one of the longest wrestling shows of all time by the way, was a negative. The show was 8 hours long. In my view, it hurt the show. Im not telling you what you should think is boring or not boring as a talking point, but the length of this show is part of the story and it would have been utterly ridiculous to ignore it.

Jared Welch

I always felt like Hangman is a better chaser than champion.

Daaave

If AEW ppvs were Beatles albums, this one would be the White Album

Joshua

Been a while since we've had Bad Vibes Joe on the review. Welcome back! This was a tough listen my man. No idea what's going on with their crowd sounds. I thought it sounded real good on YouTube. I've also had other ppvs and tv shows too where I thought they sounded quiet but other people say they were loud.

Dwayne

Some of These comments read like "How dare you say you don't love the production of this PPV" I strongly agree on these points. I had to watch this in 2 sittings. Once live and then the big 3 matches later

Ruairí Hegarty

Thank you Joe and Rich for reviewing the show and for rewarding your patrons with it rather than leaving it until the flagship. Keep up all the great work!

Joshua

I didn't notice any complaints Saturday either. Could just be a live vs vod thing. Sometimes seeing the length of those vods intimidates the hell out of me.

Joshua

Someone on a different review of this same show said that all promotions pay for the crimes of one and I felt that perfectly encapsulates the complaints I hear every time AEW does something that WWE has done to death.

Eric C Braun

Good review. It seems like AEW is gonna make All In a big spectacle, about giving fans big payoffs and "moments." I would rather skip all the long entrances and run-ins but idk if a lot of the audience agrees with me.

ctwomey

Not sure if its a related issue, but the overall master volume level on all Joe solo shows is very low. Compared to Rich's/Flagship etc. Have to jack my device volume all the way up to 10 and it's still pretty low even then. Makes it hard to do listen to these shows while driving/doing loud manual labour work, etc. You gotta be somewhere quiet.

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

Without getting too much in the weeds, I recorded this one with lower volume settings as I continue to troubleshoot the bad audio, but once again it didnt work and was arguably worse than ever. I give up, it is what it is, im done obsessing over it. The recording volume will go back to normal next time

Michael

Complaining about AEW’s crowd micing as you record a review with the volume so low the audio is almost undetectable.

Fred Morlan

I think the volume thing is on your end.

Jasen Omega

I know we're giving you guys shit, but we appreciate your honesty. I think skipping the pre-show helped it feel not so long for me. This one was long, but the one when Super MJF fought Jay White felt like 100 hours. I guess I was just pumped up for this one, like a lot of us.

HKMT

ZERO? Lol

Michael

It isn’t.

Brett

I’m usually in agreement with joe 95% of the time, more like 45% today. Honestly, this review kinda sounded like you wanted to get the review done for your patrons (thank you!) and then you saw the show was 8 hours and got annoyed 🤷‍♂️ I’m not sure how dustin winning was a bizarre decision. Its pretty standard to give the fans something that will make them happy after not delivering an advertised match and especially after a guy practically announces retirement. Kyle Fletcher will be fine. I thought the crowd was dead until dustins title win and then they came alive. We got different ears so I don’t know what you were hearing. Especially when it comes to Bryan Danielson getting a bigger reaction than Page? When Hangman came out it was clear that this was who the crowd had been anticipating all night. I didn’t time how long the audience cheered after page won but maybe they calmed down because swerve was still out there and then page was doing the business with the briefcase. I do remember he got a big reaction before he even pulled the belt out of the case and then a sustained roar after he did so. I love bryan danielson too but lets be real. If we’re arguing pops then the only one that rivaled any hangman reaction was the bell pop for omega/okada. Thats it.

Jason Shubnell

I can't say I really disagree with much of what you said, but my takeaway watching the show was just much more positive. I wonder if others feel that way.

Jacob Glowacki

As someone who was there live, I never once thought, "This is a cold crowd" at any point in the show, other than maybe the women's gauntlet, which definitely got the bathroom break treatment.

Jacob Glowacki

Sure - and that's a fair critique if that's the way it came across on your TV. Just giving the live perspective. I may also have just been in a particularly hot section.

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

One thing I have learned over the last 15 years, is that people tend to be more annoyed if you think something is merely good that they thought was great than if you think something is bad that they thought was great.

Jason Shubnell

That's the beauty of entertainment....

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

There are people who thought the show was too long right here in these comments. Im genuinely baffled that so many people are surprised that some people thought an EIGHT HOUR SHOW was too long.

Jacob Glowacki

It's notable to me that I've seen high praise for this show from places that still enjoy WWE. Plus some "I gave AEW a try, and liked it!" from WWE influencer types.

Christos C

I think the issue a lot of us are having is it seems both Joe and Rich watched a show quite frustrated and the analysis just didn't seem as proportionate or as relevant as other reviewers and the Flagship is usually the best in the game! It seems in an alternative universe where they watched it live and relaxed it seems certain the review would be more positive so people are baffled a bit!

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

Listen man, I didnt watch the show "frustrated", I was excited about watching the show. I just didn't like it as much as you did. I dont know what else to say.

Christos C

I think there's a bit of confusion here. I agree the show should have been shorter but All In 2024 was 6 hours and DoN 2025 an all timer PPV was 5.5. I think that a lot of people are saying is sure next time don't go that long but it didn't seem to destroy the enjoyment of a show when watched live.

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

I thought those shows were better. It was a good show with some massive flaws, and being one of the longest shows in history was one of those flaws. I have read all of your comments and you are just going to have to accept that I didnt like the show as much as you did.

Warzone97

Crowd wasn't dead during the women's gauntlet

Carlos R. Pastrana

Same critique I (and many others) have had with Rich’s. I watched this live and thought it was an excellent show that, though it was very long, never felt long or boring. No match was sub-3, and there were 2 or 3 4 1/2-plus matches, including a phenomenal main event. If any other company had had a show of this quality, everyone would be breaking out the pom-poms. AEW is a victim of its own quality, and I guess we are all spoiled

Joshua

I dont know if that's the case here. You can say you thought the show was good all you want, but you spent 90% of your review dogging it, including the usual Solo Joe thing of staying on one complaint for far too long. Kinda doesn't jive

Joshua

They havent even let her talk yet either, which I thought could be her biggest strength.

Danny

Glad you didn’t just mention the length at the top and brush past it. It effected all the big matches we’d all been looking forward to and simply cannot happen again. Great review, and appreciate you and rich also in his review calling out stuff and not going along with the majority.

Danny

Wasn’t ideal? Mate the show lasted longer than my daily shift at work. Unacceptable. I shouldn’t have to not see my kids for the day to be able to watch a wrestling show I’ve been looking forward to for weeks.

Danny

His complaint was something that effected almost every match on the show so he had to spend a big chunk of the review on it.

Danny

Just incase they read this and take the constructive criticism on board. I want to say I thought both reviews were great and if they’re both away again I hope they do it the same way they did here 👍