Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Wrestling's endless reliance on Attitude Era nostalgia needs to end.

Can we please get wrestling promoters and wrestling fans to quit the Attitude Era?

We can't keep doing this.

We just can't.

Who am I kidding?

For those that didn't watch TNA Slammiversary last night (Joe recapped it on today's episode of Flagship Plus): one of the show's highlights was Bully Ray challenging the new TNA Tag Team Champions The Hardy Boyz for a match at TNA Bound for Glory 2025 (October 12): Team 3D (Bully & Devon) vs. Matt & Jeff Hardy.

While not official yet, TNA's teasing of the match suggests that it will happen.

"This October at #TNABoundForGlory… The Hardys vs. Team 3D — one last time?!"

Ugh.

We're doing Dudleys/Team 3D vs. Hardys nostalgia in 2025, and a company's top tag team title will be on the line.

The first straight-up Dudleys vs. Hardys match took place at a WWF House Show on January 29, 2000, at the Ervin J. Nutter Center in Dayton, Ohio.

The show took place 29 days after the feared Y2K disaster and the dawn of a new millennium.

"I Knew I Loved You" by Savage Garden was the top song on the Billboard charts.

Savage Garden has been broken up for over 24 years.

The top TV show of the day was Who Wants to Be a Millionaire hosted by Regis Philbin on ABC.

Philbin passed away 4 years, 11 months, and 24 days ago.

The top movie in theaters on January 29, 2000, was The Hurricane, a highly recommended film starring Denzel Washington as Rubin "The Hurricane" Carter, a former star boxer wrongly convicted of murder.

We're 25 years, 5 months, and 18 days away from January 29, 2000, today.

Only 14 years had passed since Carter's release from prison, following a 19-year prison sentence, to when The Hurricane film was released in theaters.

Hell, Carter's entire prison sentence happened during the time from the first Dudleys vs. Hardys match to today!

With six years to spare, no less!

Carter was in jail for so long that Bob Dylan wrote a whole damn song about him being in prison for such a long time.

(I prefer the Mos Def, Common, The Roots version because, of course, I do.)

We've been confined to the prison of nostalgia for the Attitude Era for far too long.

It's not just TNA.

At All In Texas, AEW teased the reunion of COPE (Edge) and Christian, the third piece in the 2000-2001 WWF Tables, Ladders, and Chairs matches alongside the Dudleys and Hardys.

In the span of a few weeks in July 2025, top wrestling promotions are grasping at nostalgia of three-way tag matches that took place a quarter of a century ago.

When will we get over it?

Will we ever?

Look, I loved those matches.

The SummerSlam 2000 TLC match is one of my favorite matches from that era, and to me, it's the best in the series - the one I would most recommend to people if they wanted to truly get a feel for what those matches were like during that era. The WrestleMania X-7 one is a very close second, but I tend to prefer the SummerSlam 2000 one.

Again, I enjoyed watching those matches and revisiting them from time to time. They were a foundational piece in my pro wrestling fandom and that of many fellow fans, as those matches are now constantly replicated.

However, I was only 13 years old when those matches occurred.

I was in the 8th grade.

I'm now quickly approaching 40 years old.

What's worse about this newest nostalgia push for the Dudleys vs. The Hardys is that 11 years ago, TNA already did this!

Yes, 11 years ago, this very same company presented these two teams as nostalgia acts!

On the August 14, 2014 episode of TNA iMPACT!, Team 3D opened the show, saying the Dudleys were there to handle business when The Hardys' music hit.

Announcer Mike Tenay put over the classic matches these teams once had.

Matt Hardy grabbed the mic and said, "Let's face the facts, it's been 12 years since the four of us shared the ring together. A long time."

Again, put this into perspective: 11 years ago, these two teams talked about how they hadn't wrestled in 12 years.

A long time, indeed, Matt.

The two teams wax poetic about the past matches they had: the Royal Rumble 2000 match, WrestleMania 2000, SummerSlam 2000, WrestleMania X-7, while the Manhattan Center crowd chants "ONE MORE MATCH!"

Bully says, "Sounds like this crowd wants us to have one more match."

Matt: "Do you people want to see a historic one more match?!"

The crowd explodes. Yes! Finally! The Dudleys vs. The Hardys.

Devon ends the promo: "Oh, it's on, ONE MORE TIME... the Dudleys vs. The Hardys!"

11 years ago.

That night was the final time the two teams faced one another in a straight-up tag match.

Smartly (and we're talking about 2014 TNA here), when they had more matches featuring the two teams, they made sure to include a third team in the mix, in this case a young(ish) duo they were trying to make into stars: the duo of Davey Richards and Eddie Edwards.

It was a great way to stoke the nostalgia flame of the three-way plunder heavy tag matches that made these teams famous, while also introducing a new team to the mix to try and leverage that nostalgia into fandom for The Wolves.

It was smart.

I'm giving credit to 2014 TNA.

What is happening?

The end result of the 2014 Dudleys vs. Hardys feud was great. They had a series of well-received matches in the summer and fall, culminating in a Full Metal Mayhem match on the October 8, 2014 episode of Impact, where The Wolves retained their TNA World Tag Team titles in a match that garnered a 4.5-star rating from Dave Meltzer.

If you need to do nostalgia, that is the way.

This, whatever we're doing in 2025, is not it.

I often make these comparisons to give you an idea of how ludicrous wrestling's attachment to the Attitude Era is, so let's do this one.

It's been 25 years since the first Dudleys vs. Hardys match, so let's go 25 years from 1998—the peak of the Monday Night Wars. That gets us to 1973. Who were the WWF (then WWWF's) World Tag Team Champions in 1973?

The titles only began in June 1971 when Luke Graham and Tarzan Tyler defeated Dick the Bruiser & The Sheik in a tournament final.

The WWF did have a set of tag titles in early 1970, though, in the form of the long-defunct WWF International Tag Team Championships. The most famous holders of those titles are probably Bepo and Geto... The Mongols. The decidedly not Mongolian tag team of Canadian Newton Tattrie (Geto) and Croatian Nikolai Volkoff (Bepo).

The Mongols would lose their tag titles in June 1971 after a 368-day reign to Bruno Sammartino and Dominic DeNucci.

I want you for a second to imagine an episode of 1998 WWF RAW is War, just after a Val Venis vignette with Jenna Jameson, just before Triple H and D-Generation X cut a promo about their dicks to build up a match with The Rock, a segment where Bruno and Dominic DeNucci come out and talk about their series of matches with The Mongols.

Now envision these fucking guys walking to the ring as the crowd of teenagers in South Park shirts chant, "ONE MORE MATCH! ONE MORE MATCH!"

If we truly go 25 years from 1998 for this comparison, the WWF Tag Team Titles were controlled most of the year by the duos of Mr. Fuji & Professor Tanaka and Dean Ho & Tony Garea. It wouldn't be until 1975 that The Blackjacks got the titles. Why do I bring up The Blackjacks? Because in 1998, WWF tried to do a "New" Blackjacks nostalgia thing with Bradshaw and Barry Windham. Windham was seen as the old man of the team and he was cosplaying as his father: Blackjack Mulligan. The idea of the actual Blackjack Mulligan re-igniting the mid-70s Blackjacks would've been ridiculous.

So they used his son.

Flip to TNT and watch WCW Monday Nitro, a show lambasted at the time for featuring too many old wrestlers, and Rip Hawk & Swede Hanson are cutting a promo in the ring, building up to their big tag title match against Johnny Weaver & George Becker.

Or maybe you'd see Mr. McMahon's stooge Jerry Brisco jump ship, rip off the suit and put the trunks back on to re-form his champion tag team with Thunderbolt Patterson.

Brute Bernard and Jay York waiting in the wings.

It's absolutely positively inconceivable that this would happen in 1998 or in any other era in wrestling history.

But not this era.

Not in this era where fans, wrestlers, and promotions are prisoners to nostalgia for a bygone era.

An era where nostalgia from 30 years ago is re-experienced again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And again. And aga....

-Rich

Files

Comments

keith lipinski

Didn't DVon have a stroke a few years ago? Can Swede Hanson replace him in team 3D?

Tenese Sarwieh

Last time he wrestled I believe, was Impact 1000

Chad McLaughlin

At least with Cope and Christian there's an appeal of seeing them against teams they've never faced before. I don't understand why I would want to watch two teams have a much worse version of a match they had 25 years ago.

keith lipinski

He’s still protecting the business - like Regis. Bless him

Chris Burke

I agree with so much of this. I'd even go so far as to the say the television presentation of wrestling still hasn't changed enough since the Attitude era, even if match lengths and overall quality has tremendously improved. I also tried to think of the most bad faith way to respond to this article and all I could come up with was that AEW doing Omega vs Okada at All In was like when WCW tried doing Hogan vs Warrior at Halloween Havoc but that is obviously not the same (similar amount of time between both though!).

keith lipinski

He worked two other shows including a Dudley tag vs Onita/Dreamer in April 2024 which gave me closure feom Onita‘s ECW angle at the arena in June of 1998

Josh Huddleston

God, I wish this nostalgia shit would end. The attitude era wasnt even good in the first place

Malcolm Mark Spinedi

I’ve thought on this too. The problem is the fact medicine is too good. We didn’t have stem cells, ddpyoga, subzero ice tanks, and what not. It also helped that wrestlers were dumb and destroyed their bodies with a lot of drugs and alcohol. It was a miracle if you were doing prowrestling past like 35.

Doug Hunt

Savage Garden I sort of liked back in the day. The nostalgia needs to end. I just hope Cope and Christian put over young guys during their run. This Hardys 3D thing is just...

Malcolm Mark Spinedi

You know, I won’t live to see the answer to this question; but I do wonder what WWE will do when all these Attitude Era guys are finally gone. When they can’t wheel out Taker or Austin for a cheap pop. When they can’t bring back X or Y for a nostalgia pop? Will ppl care about another Rollins vs Finn match 20 years from now like they care about a Dudleys vs Hardys match today? While ppl sell out arenas to see Dirty Dom vs Rey like they do with Cena and Punk? I wonder.

Illmatic1

There will always be nostalgia

WC

The Attitude Era is what drove me away from wrestling for a decade and a half, so I REALLY have no time for any of this nonsense. Such a cringey, gross era.

Travis Zimmerman

I bring this up to my friends all the time, if we took a random non fan friend to a show and they saw any nostalgia act from the attitude era they’d immediately say “oh wow this guy is still going?” It’s instinctively universe breaking to anyone watching who took any time away from wrestling. If you threw on the nfl today and saw Warrick Dunn juke an all star out of his shoes you’d instantly say oh I’m watching something fake.

Carlos R. Pastrana

Not only did The New Blackjacks feature Barry Windham because Blackjack Mulligan would have been ridiculous in 1998, but the gimmick died a death anyway, because the Millennials who were there to see fake tits and Steve Austin’s schtick had no idea who Blackjack Mulligan and Blackjack Joe Lanza, Sr. were.

Jameson Fletcher

Christian can at least still go He has had a pretty good AEW run, and has turned out a lot better than most former wwf/wwe acts in AEW The Hardys and the Dudleys are completely cooked and that will be an atrocious match with a ton of shenanigans