Need A Quick & Easy P.R. Boost? Just Attack Dave Meltzer (Patreon)
Content
The history and evolution of Meltzer Bashing, who is responsible, the negative consequenses, and how wrestlers have learned to leverage Meltzer's reputation to whitewash stories and get themselves over in a post-truth world
A professional wrestler's job is to get over. If you can't get over, you won't get pushed, and you aren't going to make money. Wrestlers are workers who spend their entire lives working. Not just working the fans, but also working promoters, working the media, working the people they work with, in some cases working everyone around them, with the goal of getting over (with the fans, with the booker, with whoever else), receiving a push, and making as much money as possible. We all understand that this is the framework of the pro wrestling business. To some degree, a worker is always working.There are many ways to get over, and what gets over is constantly shifting and changing. That's the challenge faced by every pro wrestler, every booker, and every promoter in the history of this dumb business. The traditional ways are connecting with the crowd through great promos, a unique look, being cool and looking like a bad ass, or good in ring work. There are no hard and fast rules with crowd connection, and you don't even necessarily need to be talented in those traditional ways to achieve it. In rare cases, you don't need to be talented at all. The only thing that matters is that you get over, period. The fastest way to get over in modern wrestling is to find A Yeet. Finding A Yeet is the natural evolution of finding a catch phrase, which was the cheat code to getting over in the 90's. Your yeet can be a literal yeet, but can also come in the form of a catchy entrance theme, especially if it's of the singalong variety. Finding the right yeet, as with the practitioner of the namesake, can overcome a total lack of talent otherwise. Your entire persona can be nothing more than one big yeet, but if that yeet gets you booked on the biggest wrestling show of the year, the yeet has served it's purpose - it got you over, it got you booked, and it made you money. A modern WWE show is often just a series of yeets - oh, this is the part of the show when we singalong. This is when we make the bird sounds. This is the guy we (guided by piped in production) boo really loudly even though we're all smiling when we do it and don't really hate him (we even yeet heat now). This is the part where we all stand up and, well, yeet. Another quick and easy way to get over with fans, on perhaps a more micro and less meaningful on a larger scale level, is to bury Dave Meltzer on social media, most notably on X, the everything app, formerly known as Twitter. Thanks largely to the likes of the sleazy Conradverse, primarily Bruce Prichard, Eric Bischoff, and their compliant enabler, Conrad Thompson (whose soft, token "oh, c'mon now!" resistance to the bullshit spewed by his co-hosts does nothing to wipe away the responsibility he carries in unfairly tarnishing the reputation of the person he indirectly makes all of his money in building his podcasts around), there is an entire cottage industry of other assorted copycats and losers now playing the same "discredit Meltzer" card. They range from blatant Conrad wannabees (who unlike Thompson often don't even bother disguising the objective and make the Dave vitriol obvious), to washed up and/or ex-wrestlers who see the work and have followed the Bash Dave path in order to regain relevance, and various other wrestling media types, ranging from ex-website owners to untalented amatuer scoopsters, all of whom carry massive Meltzer envy. It all circles back to Conrad, Prichard, and Bischoff, the latter two of which have obvious decades long axes to grind with Meltzer, and whose "Meltzer is a liar" propaganda has spread easily in a landscape where shitty wrestling newz sites will aggregate literally anything and even shittier Twitter engagement accounts gleefully comply, all burying a man whose work vitually none of them read or consume, who they dislike because he does the one thing none of them can handle - report facts and the truth that may run counter to the narrative of their preferred wrestling promotion (almost always WWE, make of that what you will), with a presumed and bizzare accusation of bias that simply does not exist. There are multitudes of fans who speak with supreme confidence regarding Dave Meltzer who have never actually consumed anything he has ever produced. It is a fictionalized, made up version of him, systematically created by grifters who would otherwise carry no relevance if forced to produce content without ever referencing Dave Meltzer's Wrestling Observer or using Dave Meltzer's opinions as the lightning rod for virtually all of their talking points. Most of these people (the ones who actually make money) owe the man thousands of dollars in residuals. Wrestlers see the hustle and understand the benefits. Some are young and grew up in a post-truth world that extends far beyond the scope of pro wrestling journalism. Some have been indoctrinated by the girfters the same way the fans have. Some surely see through the hustle, but also see Meltzer (the "dirtsheets") as the enemy, as this has always been the culture in pro wrestling locker rooms, and understand the many obvious benefits of discrediting him. What they all seem to understand, is that the fastest way to gaining favor with many modern fans, or to clean up a P.R. mess, is to attack Dave Meltzer, to lean in to the narrative that he's the guy who "makes things up", the guy who is never right, the LIAR with the AGENDA (anti-WWE, paid by Tiny Con, etc). If Meltzer reports something unfavorable about you, whether it's true or not doesn't matter, because if you publicly call him a liar and insult him, people cheer you on and buy what you are selling, without even having to refute what he said or provide any evidence as to what he got wrong. It's gotten to the point that Meltzer often receives pushback when sharing an indisputable fact, or something like a verifiable television rating, even when shared without editorial comment. This is the trickle down damage that Conrad Thompson doesn't understand (charitable interpretation) or doesn't care (the reality) that he has caused. He has ruined the reputation of one of the only carriers of history, the real truthful history, of professional wrestling. An industry whose history is otherwise largely ignored (outside of a few scant and dedicated historians), of which the only other widespread version is the slanted and hilariously inaccurate horseshit pushed by WWE. The Conradverse and all of the assorted grifters, losers, and envious hacks that it has inspired, are slowly killing the documented history of the wrestling right in front of our eyes, by discrediting one of the very few chronicles of the real history we have. Meltzer is not beyond critique. I have critiqued him plenty over the years. He gets stuff wrong. Everyone does. Nobody bats 1.000, especially in wrestling, a backwards, antiquated secret society where everyone is distrustful and working all the time. Throwing the baby out with the bathwater is not the answer to valid Dave Meltzer criticisms. I believe everyone involved in wrestling media, even direct competitors, have a duty to back him up when he's being unfairly critiqued, for a number of reasons, not limited to the evaporation of trust and truth in media. We all need to stick together and defend each other, and I don't think that happens enough, but that's perhaps a larger scale discussion for another day. Columns like this, from people who take wrestling journalism and the history of the wrestling business seriously, should be commonplace.Meltzer also doesn't help himself. He often wastes tons of time on Twitter arguing with some of the dumbest people on the app, quote tweeting and debating the types of fans who are never going to learn or understand, because they aren't interested in learning or understanding. You can't save everyone, and Meltzer wastes way too much time trying. He suffers from the same ailment many who inhabit that wretched app suffer from, in that the more you use it, the more you believe it represents everyone, when the reality, is it represents almost no one. According to Google, 12% of U.S. adults get their news from Twitter. 10% of Twitter's users account for 92% of all Tweets. Many years ago, one of my biggest epiphanies was when I stepped back and thought about how many people I knew in my real life who ever talked about or discussed Twitter, and the answer was zero. Not a single person. It has been said so many times that it has become an overused cliche, but Twitter is not real life. It's an isolated world with algorithms designed to trap you until you are tricked you into overvaluing it's relevance. Meltzer invests too much time pushing back on hopelessly online dullards and trolls who have no interest in, and are never going to see things his way, and it usually just makes things worse for him. Twitter, and especially wrestling twitter, is a young person's game. It's memes and gifs and dunks and shitposts. Meltzer attempting to have adult conversations with willfully ignorant shitposters and a generation of fans who have been convinced he is full of shit isn't doing anyone any good. Let them go, not everyone is your customer. Post & ghost is the only way to leverage whatever usefulness Twitter offers. The few smart, worthwhile people who still quietly inhabit the app will see your work. Trust that they get it, and stop hurting your reputation with the people who matter by rolling around in the muck with the people who don't. Wrestlers understand who they are talking to on the app and how Meltzer is perceived. There were two great examples of this over the weekend. On September 29, Edris Enofe announced he was leaving WWE. On October 4, Enofe quote tweeted a Dave Meltzer touting the details of Enofe's exit along with a link to his newsletter with "You are a piss poor journalist. Probably the worst I've ever seen."Enofe offered no follow up on what he took issue with or what Meltzer presumably got wrong, and as of this writing, has not commented further other than replying to a fan, imploring him to "get (Meltzer's) dick out of your mouth". Here is what Meltzer wrote about Enofe in the Wrestling Observer:
Edris Enofe (Inyene Umoh, 31), said that he made the decision to leave the promotion. We’ve confirmed from a number of sources that this was his decision and not a company decision. He had not wrestled since July and had been working with Evolve. He hadn’t been on NXT television in about 14 months. He signed in 2021 and debuted in November. He mostly worked as a tag team with Malik Blade. He had a great physique so he got a shot but obviously his star had dropped. He said, “As of today, I will officially be leaving the WWE. This is a decision that I thought about for a very long time, and I’m gonna trust my gut on this. With that being said, for the past four years, I had the chance and the opportunity to meet and work with incredible people, from the wrestlers to the referees, to the creative team, to the medical staff, and of course to all the coaches who put in so much time and effort into making me better, and for that, I will always, always appreciate y’all, and of course to all the fans who have supported me and stuck by my side through all these years, thank you.”
At one point he got a WWE logo tattooed on his chest, which he later said he regretted. He signed with WWE with almost no experience, based on his look. He had worked for the Level Up promotion in Southern California and had exactly two matches under his belt when WWE signed him. He had suffered a shoulder injury that put him out for ten months. As soon as he returned, Blade was injured and is still out. He had done a feud in Evolve with Dante Chen, but one person close to the situation said that the process of the system knocked the passion out of him and he asked for his release. There were people who expected he would be doing so as early as April.
The first paragraph contains a direct and accurate transcription of what Enofe said himself on September 29, plus a confirmation that the statement was accurate via Meltzer's sources (sounds like journalism to me?), and a run down of Enofe's recent absence from WWE programming.The second paragraph is a summary of his career, all of which checks out according to cagematch and other databses. Meltzer cites a source "close to the situation" and explains he was told Enofe's exit was not a surprise and many expected it to happen much sooner. I'm not sure what Enofe could be taking exception with here, aside from the tattoo story, which as it turns out, ended up being a work. That's probably his gripe, but who knows? If something else more important is off base, Enofe has a right to dispute it, and we're all ears. Enofe may never clarify. If it turns out to be the tattoo story, the purpose of which was to work people, most rational people will say "So that's it? All of the important stuff is correct?". The temperature around all of this was that Meltzer The Liar is lying again, but nobody, including Enofe, has told us exactly what he's lying about. People have a right to defend themselves against inaccurate reporting, but the key is you need to express what you feel is inaccurate. This is unfair to Meltzer, with Enofe coming across like someone who is being intentionally vague, knowing full well how it will be taken, regarding something he didn't like written about him - assuming he read it at all. Andrade had a go at Dave on Sunday, presumably angry about Meltzer being critical of AEW rehiring him.
@davemeltzerWON You talk too much shit without proof, and Sir, I'll only tell you one thing: when my contract with AEW ended, I personally went man to man to thank MR. TONY KHAN for the opportunity to be in AEW, and that's all I'll tell you. If I wanted to talk more, I would show you that you're wrong about many things. But you keep killing the business! Yo le deseo lo mejor!!
Again, if Meltzer got "many things" wrong, we would all love to hear about it. Reporters get things wrong sometimes. There is always another side. I find it curious (and suspicious) that Andrade doesn't feel the need to directly lay out and dispute the "many things" Meltzer allegedly got wrong, while noting only one small detail that no one has ever disputed and that doesn't directly address anything Meltzer said (Tony Khan himself discussed Andrade's exit publicly following his final match, and gave no indication that their literal final interaction was contentious). From the Wrestling Observer Newsletter:
Andrade gave Khan the belief he was staying, Khan believed they had an agreement for a renewal that wasn’t yet signed, he pushed him until the end, even though those in wrestling who knew him said he was going to WWE. Then his contract expired and he left.
This matches reporting from multiple outlets in real time. Here is what Sean Ross Sapp reported at the time:
AEW talent said that Andrade was often very open about his contract status, and that his deal would be up in or at the end of 2023. Numerous talent also said that he’d mentioned that he’d planned to stay with AEW, and was considering another contract but by the end of his run had told wrestlers he was headed back to WWE. Several in AEW actually expected him to show up on WWE programming the week after he left AEW. Tony Khan publicly left the door open for Andrade’s return, but several that worked near Andrade said that it was a frustrating process, and that days before World’s End, he let them know that he was finishing up with All Elite Wrestling.Numerous sources indicated that Andrade made it clear this past Wednesday at AEW Dynamite he no longer wanted to be with the company and was planning on leaving. We're told that the situation surrounding Andrade's exit was less than pleasant, with some even saying a major disagreement had unfolded.
Sounds a lot like what Meltzer had to say this week (and at the time). Like Enofe, it leaves me wondering what exactly Andrade is taking exception with. If he disputes Meltzer's claim that the exit was something less than totally amicable, why didn't Andrade go after Sapp, or Meltzer, or anyone else when the story was happening in real time? It's notable that Andrade hasn't gone after Mike Johnson, who reported Andrade racked "multiple" Wellness violations, in a story that many people have speculated is WWE planted P.R. intended to make him (and Tony Khan/AEW) look bad. It's notable that Andrade hasn't gone after Jon Alba, who originally broke exclusive details on the story of his firing, including "at least one" Wellness violation, while independently confirming Meltzer's audio report that the release was disciplinary in nature. It is notable that Andrade didn't go after Cory Hays, who reported that WWE was unable to reach Andrade for "several weeks" in the lead up to his firing. It is notable that Andrade did not go after Sean Ross Sapp for reporting similar stories relating all of the above at various times. All of these reports, including Meltzer's own report of a disciplinary based exit, were far more salacious in nature than whether Andrade and Tony Khan shared a friendly handshake on his final night. Yet Andrade isn't pushing back directly on any of it. There is no currency in pushing back on those people, because there has been no systematic deconstruction of their reputations. There is no value is bashing them, only risk of further truth when they answer back. Meltzer's rep is already set in stone with Andrade's intended audience, nothing Meltzer counters with will matter to them. It's easy to see what's happening here. The "and that's all I'll tell you" is Andrade essentially admitting he has no real factual gripe, otherwise, he would defend himself and state it. He's upset at Meltzer's editorial opinion that AEW is making a mistake in bringing him back (fair), and is couching that with insinuations that Meltzer reported inaccuracies - inaccuracies that like Enofe, he fails to articulate (unfair). "If I wanted to talk more, I would show you that you're wrong about many things" is easy to say, and easy to get over with fans who already dislike the target. It's entirely possible, and fair to assume, that Andrade's motivations here are to be vague enough to cast doubt on all of the not-so-flattering reporting surrounding his exit by attacking the one source he knows many fans on Twitter do not trust, who also happens to be the same guy he's annoyed at for being critical of his AEW return.This is the playbook, and it always works with a (growing) segment of the fanbase. Because Andrade has attached all of this to Meltzer, and has not had anything to say about Alba or Sapp or Johnson, there are fans, most of whom lack any semblence of media literacy, who will now assume that all of the reporting around Andrade is bullshit, believing/assuming that it all came from Meltzer, a confirmed fraud (because Eric Bischoff says so) who Andrade is telling you is lying. That's the game, that's the work. And they all play it.Just another weekend of Dave getting everything wrong, while some of us aren't quite sure exactly what he got wrong.-J