Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

  • WONHOF2025-GordyListRichSolo.wav

Some files exceed the archive size limit and weren't saved: 1 file. Please note these limits are in place to keep this site running long term, without costing a fortune. You can favorite the creator though, certain milestones increase the limit.

Content

Rich flies solo for a Gordy List thought experiment on four WON Hall of Fame candidates: Samoa Joe, Seth Rollins, Junkyard Dog, and Zack Sabre Jr.

WON HOF Candidates discussed: 

Samoa Joe

Seth Rollins

Junkyard Dog

Zack Sabre Jr.

The Gordy List Questions

1. Was he ever regarded as the best draw in the world? Was he ever regarded as the best draw in his country or his promotion?

2. Was he an international draw, national draw and/or regional draw?

3. How many years did he have as a top draw?

4. Was he ever regarded as the best worker in the world? Was he ever regarded as the best worker in his country or in his promotion?

5. Was he ever the best worker in his class (sex or weight)? Was he ever one of the top workers in his class?

6. How many years did he have as a top worker?

7. Was he a good worker before his prime? Was he a good worker after his prime?

8. Did he have a large body of excellent matches? Did he have excellent matches against a variety of opponents?

9. Did he ever anchor his promotion(s)?

10. Was he effective when pushed at the top of cards?

11. Was he valuable to his promotion before his prime? Was he still valuable to his promotion after his prime?

12. Did he have an impact on a number of strong promotional runs?

13. Was he involved in a number of memorable rivalries, feuds or storylines?

14. Was he effective working on the mic, working storylines or working angles?

15. Did he play his role(s) effectively during his career?

16. What titles and tournaments did he win? What was the importance of the reigns?

17. Did he win many honors and awards?

18. Did he get mainstream exposure due to his wrestling fame? Did he get a heavily featured by the wrestling media?

19. Was he a top tag team wrestler?

20. Was he innovative?

21. Was he influential?

22. Did he make the people and workers around him better?

23. Did he do what was best for the promotion? Did he show a commitment to wrestling?

24. Is there any reason to believe that he was better or worse than he appeared?

Wrestling Observer Hall of Fame Archives

Visit our WON HOF Collection at https://www.patreon.com/collection/112554 for a full archive of all past shows and written pieces on the WON HOF.

Files

Comments

boopthecats

This ruled! Do it again please

Karl Preston

Hulk Hogan was the best draw of late 80s, but he wasn’t the best worker, alternatively Okada may have been the best worker in the world in the 2010s but he wasn’t the best drawer in the world of that time period.

Malcolm Mark Spinedi

Will listen to soon; but Freakin in the HOF? Barf. Curious where your stance is but I have a guess.

Grant Baxter

These are great and very thought provoking.

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

Freakin has been on the ballot twice and got below 10% both times. I suspect this year will probably be the same. CURIOUS WHERE YOUR STANCE IS. Do you really think I'm going to make a Tyler Black HOF case?! -Rich

Lee Connell

Just finished. Really good shit, but you said there’s no way ZSJ would be in your top 25 so who would be? I don’t mean to make more work for you so of course I don’t expect a list, but I honestly don’t know if I could find 25 better workers than ZSJ so I’m curious

David Bixenspan

Dude, you gotta research JYD more if you think his promos were just a bunch of ARF ARF I'M A DOGGY BS. There's not nearly as much out there from Mid-South as would be ideal because we don't have local promos for most of his time there, but everything available and the accounts from those watching at the time make it pretty clear that he was an all timer as a talker. That he was this terrible worker even before addiction took hold is also an old wive's tale. He was, at worst, perfectly fine in the stampede footage we have and actively good in a lot of what we have from his physical and mental prime. He was also absolutely a national star, as he became a touring attraction during the Mid-South run and was arguably the #2 babyface in the WWF for his first year or two there.

Travis Zimmerman

For a guy like ZSJ do you think people kinda always wrestling his style hurts his case? I’d vote for him this is more devils advocate but his list of opponents he had a great match with has a lot of variety but a lot of those were because he got X to have a ZSJ match.

Malcolm Mark Spinedi

Now I did say “I had a guess” where ya’d go lol And you have zigged where I thought you’d zag before. Maybe you really like that Authority run he had, and you were gonna get really objective there? Nah, you’re right, I was crazy lol BTW, keep doing these. I really like this thought experiments here. It’s a great exercise with the mind. Still hoping it gets Mox in the HoF at some point.

03heat

Kevin Nash had some negative words for Samoa Joe. That might make him more HOF worthy to you lol

Michael Farrow

Personally, this is where I think people have to look at their own biases. I was never a Ring of Honor fan. To me, the idea of using Samoa Joe's record in that promotion as a gauge for whether he's a draw seems faintly ridiculous. They lost a truckload of money, the promotion had to be bailed out by Sinclair Broadcasting. However, for you and Joe, this was a defining promotion of that era so you judge it more favourably than, say, Seth Rollins in WWE. Now, I don't think I have the guy really belongs in a hall of fame but to dismiss the latter for having a better career than the former seems unfair to me. And I can't stand that m***********.

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

I think it's unfair to judge everyone by one standard though. If the standard for a draw is: be part of the biggest and most successful company in the world that's largely had a monopoly on major American pro wrestling for decades, then the barrier of entry is going to be pretty tough for anyone outside of WWE. Whatever you want to say about Samoa Joe, he was years removed from ROH by the time the Sinclair switch happened. Blaming Joe for Ring of Honor getting sold 6 years after he left doesn't seem totally fair to me. Especially when he was there, they were a viable business and he was on top during their most successful period of DVD and ticket sales pre-Elite. -Rich