Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Downloads

Content

A mixed bag show that featured far too much utter nonsense, and an incredible main event with the wrong finish

The potential perils of this slow roll Bandido push, why it won't work, and why if they want to make a star, they need to push Bandido like a star now, not later

AEW's frustrating insistence of being a silly little sports entertainment promotion and their refusal to show the guts and creativity needed to present a true alternative that changes the game

Files

Comments

DD Franquez

Amazing review as always! Thank you for your hardwork

AndrewX

Alright before listening, scale 1-10 how bad was Joe's aneurysm over puppets this time? (thought of him immediately after it appeared from under the table)

Andrew Hyland

Stitching the song and end of the monologue was good stuff. Enjoyed this episode more than most and I enjoy them all.

Justin Adams

The problem with interviews is when they try something different, like the on stage interviews with the audience in the background or Renee acting like a sideline reporter as a wrestler makes their entrance, people bitch about that. Personally I'd do more in ring Schiavone interviews or even have an interview set off to the side so that all the interviews are live. My least favorite phrase on a wrestling show, overused by Mike Tenay and now Excalibur, is "let's go to the back." Cameras backstage are supposed to be "anything can happen" moments, not preplanned "Lexi ran into Hangman with her camera crew" segments on the rundown.

Danny

Not listened to the show yet will be doing at work tomorrow. It’s like WWE 10 years ago with all the backstage interviews. I miss the days of Dynamite being 4x 3.5*+ matches and maybe 1 in ring promo.

Phill Simmons Jr

Much as I love AEW that’s been one of my problems with them for a while people complain when they are the alternative and people complain when they’re too sports entertainment I don’t understand why Tony doesn’t just say fuck it and go all in (no pun intended) on being different because people are complain regardless especially with this company

SW

The puppet shit is so fucking cringe man. Peak millennial, reddit, disney adult humour. The whiplash of going from a mean Joe promo to that nonsense is sickening

Daaave

Sorry Joe, but your Bandido take is a bit of mess. It only works if you believe AEW are looking to get him into main event scene ASAP and you keep saying they want to do that but I just don't see evidence Bandido is getting a nice little upper mid card push. Tag title run, maybe a mid card singles belt next year. Maybe he'll challenge for world title on a tv next year. And its fine? Fletcher & Takeshita are clearly the 'get the rocket ready' guys in AEW. Takeshita is beating Okada, nobody else. I feel like coz you don't rate Bandido you're setting some unnaturally high bar/expectation, which when he or his booking doesn't hit that you can claim its failed and say you were right about Bandido.

george mg

Did Joe say "albacore?" Albatross?

Mark Eyles

I come in peace! I love your work and your analysis most the time. But your work on Bandido is far from your best, and the more you discuss it the more muddled it becomes. I think the issue I have with it is that you are pulling lots of threads to create your conclusion, but there’s too many holes in the threads you are using for the conclusion to make sense. You say the perception of the ROH title is meaningless, but also if Bandido isn’t main eventing the ROH PPV that creates the impression he isn’t a top guy? So by this logic the average AEW fan is so invested in ROH that they are following whether Bandido is not main eventing a ROH PPV, but at the same time the ROH title means absolutely nothing to them and adds nothing to Bandidos star appeal. His entire character and why people see something in him, is because of the charisma he gives off in the ring. That is his strength not his weakness. Last night showed that and the crowd connection it gives. You may not agree with that, but I don’t agree with your take on it. This is the area of subjective not factual, it’s not a hard truth. You compare him to Kyle Fletcher, then talk about how Kyle Fletcher is being groomed to be one of the top guys and saying he will sit alongside Hangman, Swerve, Ospreay etc. However with Bandido you talk about him being the very top guy (this is what you said on this audio). The standard for success you are setting for them both is significantly different, while trying to make it sound like apples and apples. You may end up being right on Bandido. But that’s because more people crash before making it to the top than it being a well thought out analysis.

Matthew Carlins

I’m gonna nominate Joe vs Puppets as Feud of the Year

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

I think the reason the ROH title means nothing is because they don't make any effort to make it mean anything, but at the same time, they think Bandido holding that title is helping to get him over. I WANT the title to mean something, and if it did, it WOULD be helping him right now. That was the point I was making. The Fletcher "one of" the top guys and Bandido "the" top guy thing wasn't intentional and I didn't intend to frame it that way. I think Tony's goal with both guys is to eventually have them working the top of the card.

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

Well, they clearly DON'T want him at the top of the card ASAP, or he would have beaten Okada. That's kind of my point. I think they should have given that a go, since to me, that's the long term intent anyway. Again, if you weren't ready for him to beat Okada, you don't have to book the match. Maybe the disconnect here is I think they clearly want him on top, and you don't see it that way.

Lee Connell

“with slightly better matches” I always take issue with this but it’s super rare that I actually watch wwe so maybe people that actually watch both can weigh in: are the matches really “slightly better” or are they *much better*?

Mark Eyles

Hi Joe Thanks for the considered response, it makes sense. The biggest gulf it seems would be on that idea of in ring charism and if he has it or doesn’t. One thing that strikes me with AEW right now is if you were to do a 4 pillars deal for the future something like Fletcher, Takeshita, Bandido and pick a 4th (I’d go Willow Nightingale others may not). That is way stronger than the last 4, and Bandido being in that helps it, rather than harms it.

Blue Meanie Mike

“It’s gone and it’s probably gone forever.” Yep.

Estevan Salas

I don’t think anyone is expecting Bandido to be pushed as a top guy right now. Why Lanza, who admits he doesn’t even like the guy, is demanding it, is confusing to me. He’s the current ROH champion (for whatever that means nowadays, but it’s something) and tag team champion. If you put those belts on pretty much anyone, everyone would say that person is getting one hell of a push. Why does he need to have THREE belts? Why does he need to be world champion right now? TK and the audience doesn’t seem him at that level quite yet, and that’s ok, he can get there eventually. Why does Lanza, who doesn’t like the guy, demand to see him at that level? My take? Lanza is moving the goalposts so he won’t take an L and admit Bandido is more over than he’d ever admit he is.

ctwomey

40:00 TERRY GORDY AIN'T HAD NO PUPPETS

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

I'm not "demanding" anything, I'm watching the shows and seeing him pin Okada to set up a singles match, and I don't understand why you would then have him lose the match. I'm setting aside my personal bias that I don't see him as a top guy to analyze the booking I am watching in front of my face. And to me, it makes no sense to have him lose that match. If you want to push the guy, just push the fucking guy. Otherwise, you run a risk of people seeing him at a certain level.

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

I think WWE matches are probably better than a lot of people give them credit for, and rank & file AEW matches arent as good as people give them credit for. AEW smokes WWE on PPV.

Travis Zimmerman

If you think puppets are fun next time one is on your screen call your significant other or friends or parents in the room and have them watch with you. If you do not feel embarrassed something is wrong with you.

Lee Connell

I try to keep an eye on IYO and Rhea because I think they fucking rule; and of course guys like AJ, Cody etc. but I just can’t stomach that product and I don’t really have time for it anyway

Jared Welch

Some of the best rants of the year

Half Browser

Didn't know you are part of the KISS Army 👍, do you think Bandido would be better suited in The Fed?

Malcolm Mark Spinedi

Sorry to be late here. Kids were a menace this week. Wanted to thank ya for explaining your point with Bandido one last time. I wasn’t getting your point I admit. You said he could be getting pushed correctly while also saying ya wouldn’t, it kinda felt like you were setting up to be angry no matter what. But I think I got it now: While you wouldn’t, you are kind of acknowledging that he’s good enough that you could be proven wrong, so they should try. Makes sense. Well the push could be a lot stronger, not gonna argue him beating everyone wouldn’t be better, I don’t think what he’s getting now is anything to sneeze at either. Being a tag champ in other feds maybe a joke in other feds, but the division is treated well in AEW, and his team with Brodie has been great. While at least one defense wasn’t the main event, those title matches have been great. And yeah, I agree he should have beaten Okada. Even if the endgame is Okada and Takeshita, you could remedy that in the C2 by have Okada beat Bandido or some else do it, and it’s Takeshita and Okada in the finals. Sides that, AEW doesn’t do a lot of title changes on TV anymore, which maybe another reason tv sales have dipped. This could have been a nice shock to that system.