Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

How does this happen in 2025?

How do we have multiple disputed results/spoilers copied and pasted across every major pro wrestling news website?

For those unaware of what I'm talking about this week, AEW taped their special Thanksgiving episode of AEW Collision immediately following the Thanksgiving Eve edition of AEW Dynamite from The Pinnacle in Nashville, Tennessee.

When spoilers started making the rounds, two results really had people scratching their heads and made immediate discourse waves on places like the Voices of Wrestling Discord:

Tay Melo def. Thekla

Roderick Strong def. Konosuke Takeshita

These were surprising results.

You could buy Strong over Takeshita as a way to play into the opening week upsets that are so common in round robin tournaments, particularly after Kazuchika Okada ate a loss on Dynamite to Kyle Fletcher.

Almost.

It's a little tricky to make sense of the IWGP World Heavyweight Champion losing a straight-up singles match to Roderick Strong, someone who isn't even particularly protected in AEW's booking with singles losses to the likes of Orange Cassidy and Claudio Castagnoli in 2025.

Had Tony gone mad?! Another wave of discourse about Tony Khan being a bad partner for NJPW, Tony "jobbing" out the top champion in NJPW, and the Wrestle Kingdom main event to the guy most known for obnoxiously screaming someone's name.

It certainly made the Thanksgiving Collision worth checking out just to see how the fuck AEW went about having Strong defeat the G1 Climax winner.

Well, he didn't.

Takeshita won the match.

The other result that raised some eyebrows—Tay Melo getting a win over Thekla was also not accurate. Thekla won.

So what the fuck happened then? How did these bad results get out there, and how did they get copied and pasted across the entire wrestling news space?

From what I was able to uncover, the initial bad report appears to have come from F4WOnline with "DJ KO" providing the incorrect results.

This DJ KO either straight-up lied or was very confused by everything happening throughout the night. I'm leaning more towards lying because when you watch the Takeshita/Strong match from Collision last night, no dispute won the match. Takeshita hit his move and won and his music played. There was no Dusty finish, no post-match beatdown, or anything confusing about the result or how it played out. Takeshita won clean as a sheet.

Thekla defeated Tay Melo in pretty convincing fashion, too, stomping her face into the mat and pinning her 1-2-3. Perhaps the person submitting the results couldn't distinguish Thekla from Tay Melo. If you have that issue, you shouldn't be sending in spoilers to a major wrestling website. The two women look very different, especially these days as Melo sports brown hair.

I won't even conceive of the idea that this person couldn't tell the difference between KONOSUKE TAKESHITA and RODERICK STRONG.

So, again, how does this happen in 2025?

I get one wrong report. I get that Ian Carey at F4WOnline was sent a report by someone who either straight-up lied or is very bad at telling the difference between two humans and published it.

F4WOnline has since updated that page with a note about conflicting reports about Takeshita and Strong. You'll notice Thekla losing to Tay Melo is still reported on that page.

What then happened is what always happens in this space. The Aggregators copied and pasted without doing any work or putting any thought into the process. And before long, one errant report sent to F4WOnline turned into the entire wrestling newsphere reporting two incorrect results from the taped Collision.

Gift a FlagshipPatreon.com subscription this holiday season!

Nobody thought to themselves, Ah, jeez, that's pretty weird that Takeshita lost to Strong and Thekla lost to Tay Melo. Should we ask around and see if someone else from the show can confirm these results? Nope. Who has time for that? We need to aggregate the next thing! Quick! No time to do any journalism or have any sort of thought about what we're publishing.

Cageside Seats' Cain A. Knight had a good breakdown of what happened, including admitting that Cageside Seats had the incorrect report as well.

Something Knight mentioned that I didn't even pick up on until this morning:

"I thought it was interesting as site after site copied the text that PAC won in the Blue League and Strong won in the Gold League, even though they aren't in those leagues in the C2."

So, at the very least, there were four things incorrect about the spoilers, and seemingly nobody at any of these sites noticed until several hours later, when people who were at the show had to point out in various places that, uh, the Collision results everyone is freaking out about didn't actually happen.

It's disheartening. But it's so typical.

It speaks to something I've harped on constantly in the past: the industry of aggregation has no time for thought, exploration, or confirmation. It's all about getting the headline out as quickly as possible so you can start working on the next one. Never a second to stop and think. Never any ability to say "yeah, this guy said this thing on the podcast, but is it true?" Who cares. Onto the next aggregation.

I don't even necessarily blame Ian or F4WOnline for having the wrong results. They got a report, presumably from someone they trust, that had some results wrong. Now, sure, should Ian or someone at the site said "Whoa, hold on, those are pretty shocking results—should we double check this?" Yeah, undoubtedly they should have. But I put more of the blame on the dozens of sites that copied and pasted what F4WOnline had without stopping to think about the results.

It's a copycat (h/t) industry, but what we saw this week was egregious, even by the rock-bottom standards I hold it to.

-Rich

Files

Comments

Malcolm Mark Spinedi

I try to watch AEW stuff spoiler free, so I had no idea about this. I did see Khan’s tweet poking fun at the whole thing though.

Francois Dillinger

I’m surprised this doesn’t happen more often to be honest. I’ve managed to avoid spoilers for a few months now after always reading them so I missed these particular ones but yeah, not surprised at all

keith lipinski

Wait, people still look at THE BOARD~!