All Of The Baby Brained Insecure Pissbabies Who Only Watch One Company Are Mad At The Mostly Correct WON Awards Again (Patreon)
Content
As has become yearly tradition, all of the assorted bad take machines and grifter class WWE state media types are really, really mad at the Observer awards.
So I've decided to start a yearly tradition of my own. Behold, here are the dumbest takes from the most ignorant people, embarrassing themselves over the WON Awards.
Bryan Alvarez took issue with a few of the results this year, namely the voters choosing Booker T as "Worst Announcer", and the voters not choosing Je'Von Evans for "Most Underrated" (in WON Awards parlance, "Most Overrated" and "Most Underrated" is meant to be taken as overpushed and underpushed).
Here, LaBar is agreeing with Alvarez that Collision should not have finished ahead of RAW or SmackDown in "Best TV Show" (Collision finished third, while the two WWE shows finished fourth and fifth, respectively). Personally, I think Collision is a far superior show to either RAW or SmackDown, but whatever, you can like what you like for whatever reason you like. What's funny is that neither LaBar or Alvarez is even quibbling with the show that actually won the vote — Dynamite.
Listen, I have my own quibbles with some of the selections this year. John Cena for "Most Charismatic"? In a year where he spent half of his time failing to effectively get over as a heel, exhibiting zero heel charisma, to the point the company had to abort mission? FTR should have been the runaway "Tag Team Of The Year". Harley Cameron was "Most Improved"? Did she improve at all? No one is going to agree with awards voting of any kind wholesale, and I certainly don't agree with all of this years winners.
However, LaBar's reasoning regarding the results, that the WON and its voters are "anti-WWE", and "hard to take seriously because they hate the most popular company", was astutey debunked by Sean Ross Sapp, who pointed out that the same voting pool chose WWE for "Promotion of the Year" the last two years. In fact, Paul Levesque won "Booker of the Year" the last two years as well (with Dave Meltzer himself advocating for Leveque both years), with WWE winning a total of TWELVE positive awards in 2024's results, by far the most of any promotion. That's certainly not reflective of a voter base that "hates the most popular company" or is "anti-WWE".
LaBar's problem, like the vast majority of WON Award critics, is that he can't wrap his head around a segment of wrestling fans following worlwide wrestling, and when warranted, enjoying worlwide wrestling more than WWE. It makes him feel insecure within the narrow scope of his fandom that there are fans that don't share his affinity for his favorite wrestling promotion, and he can't possibly understand thinking that WWE isn't the superior pro wrestling, which is super weird behavior, and leads to making a complete fool of yourself on Twitter as you dive in front of every bullet to defend the honor of the biggest, most popular, and most acclaimed wrestling promotion on Earth if anyone dares to prefer something else. WWE must receive all of the praise.
Which brings us to El Hijo del Ice Cube:
As noted above, just total ignorance that doesn't hold up to scrutiny, from someone who I am willing to bet has never read an Observer in his life. He has no idea what he's talking about.
What you have to remember, is that these are people who are convinced that the Wrestling Observer Newsletter is an anti-WWE propaganda vessel, which is preposterous to anyone who actual consumes Meltzer's content. It's a reputation unfairly developed by people listening to disingenuos, grifter class pundits, such as Conradverse co-hosts Bruce Prichard and Eric Bischoff, spew this deliberate, strategic, targeted nonsense for years. It's not Jackson's fault that he's ignorant regarding these awards, just like it isn't his fault that he has already burned off and leveraged his one and only discernible "talent" — that he looks like his father.
I like Sam Roberts, I really do, and unlike a lot of the usual girfter class anti-AEW and WWE state media types, I don't think Roberts is being disingenuous, calculated, or insecure. Roberts just loves his WWE, and I know he genuinely believes Booker T is a good announcer.
Some of you may be skeptical that he is being sincere, because Booker T is not only an irrideemably terrible announcer, but quite possibly might be the worst major league wrestling announcer of all time, but I don't think Roberts, or many hardcore WWE fans, agree with that. They view wrestling a lot differently than most of you reading this, or most newsletter reading, "smarky" type fans. They actually enjoy Booker T's absurdly bad announcing, they find it entertaining. They really think he's getting people over.
This Robert's tweet is a great example of different corners of the fandom simply speaking different languages. It's so interesting that Roberts points out that Booker T has "guided fan response" for several NXT talents. In other words, contributing to creating "Yeets", which is totally something WWE fans would value. The Observer readership prefer announcers that, I don't know, speak coherent sentences, pay attention to what is going on, know who all of the performers are (Booker often doesn't), and aren't doing juvenile (and sometimes horny) shtick. They don't give a shit about creating "Yeets". WWE fans think Booker T is "fun", the rest of us think he sucks. In these kinds of awards, Booker T is never going to get his flowers, he's going to get shit on, because he's really, really bad at bascially everything a hardcore wrestling fan is looking for in a commentator, and his awful commentary makes a really, really bad wrestling show, NXT, even worse. Winning "Worst Announcer" makes total sense, and he'll probably win it for as long as he's in the seat.
What's funny about the Roberts tweet, is that many of the back slap reponses accuse Dave Meltzer of being paid by Tony Khan, while Roberts, the person they are responding to and agreeing with, is literally a paid employee of WWE. Some of these people are just an entirely different level of stupid.
With all of the accusations of this year's WON Awards of being blatant AEW shilling, you have to wonder how many of these people don't even realize that AEW didn't even win any of the three biggest awards.
It was CMLL that won "Promotion of the Year", Mistico, a CMLL wrestler, who won the Flair/Thesz "Wrestler of the Year", and a NJPW match, Kenny Omega vs Gabe Kidd, that won "Match of the Year" (I suppose you could argue that match was on a joint show, but it happened in a New Japan ring in the Tokyo Dome the day after Wrestle Kingdom, on a show barely promoted at all by AEW). In addition, Saya Kamitani, a STARDOM wrestler, won two of the other biggest awards, Japanese MVP, and Female Wrestler of the Year.
These people don't have any idea what they are even complaining about. It's just Dave bad, AEW bad.
At least this Jason Burgos fella understands that this is a reader vote, even if he clearly doesn't know who the results. Year after year, some of the dumbest people breathing air believe Meltzer picks the awards himself. Many of these same people are PERPLEXED when something or someone places in both a Best and Worst award category, totally BAFFLED and utterly CONFUSED as to how the concept of voting works. Like the Sports Illustrated awards earlier this year, psychotic WWE fans attempt to convince themselves that Tony Khan is paying to win. Which begs the question, if Tony is buying these awards, why didn't he bother to purchase the three biggest ones, Wrestler of the Year, Match of the Year, or Promotion of the Year? There is no logic, there is no sanity. These people are hopelessy stupid.
The reality is that as 2023 and 2024 proved, it doesn't actually matter who or what wins any of these awards. The WON Awards are just another tool used by the worst people in media to spread their envy fueled Meltzer propaganda, and for the dumbest people in the fandom to immaturely lash out at more well rounded fans praising wrestling that might not be WWE. Only a WWE clean sweep would make these kinds of people happy, because they are deeply and hopelessly inscure in what they enjoy, and it eats them alive when others don't share the same fondness for the one promotion they pay any attention to.
Me? I'm just happy that lucha libre finally got some due, as CMLL for "Promotion of the Year" and Mistico for "Wrestler of the Year" were the two clearest and easiest choices on the entire ballot. The real unspoken bullshit in the WON Awards has always been the lack of lucha representation in the results. You just never hear about that, because lucha fans aren't diaper shitting babies like the vast majority of Twitter centric WWE fans.