The Flagship (February 19): Topics & Runsheet (Patreon)
Content
On this episode of The Flagship, we'll extensively break down the full results of the 2025 Wrestling Observer Newsletter Awards, talk about the beginning of NJPW's Fantasticamania tour, changes to CMLL match structure, fallout from last night's episode of Dynamite, Hangman doing the Cody stip, Saya Kamitani vs. Starlight Kid, and more!
Listen live tonight (Thursday, February 19) at 9pm EST/8pm CST: https://www.patreon.com/posts/flagship-live-19-151156426
2025 Wrestling Observer Awards
Our very first show in January 2012 covered the 2011 Wrestling Observer Awards, so, as is tradition, we'll go deep into the results of the 2025 WON Awards.
Read the full issue at https://members.f4wonline.com/wrestling-observer-newsletter/february-16-2026-observer-newsletter-the-2025-won-awards-issue/
We'll cover the full voting results, but to make things a little easier, here we'll just list the winners for each award.
Wrestler of the Year (Lou Thesz/Ric Flair Award): Mistico
Most Outstanding Wrestler: Konosuke Takeshita
Match of the Year: Kenny Omega vs Gabe Kidd
Best Box Office Draw: John Cena
Promotion of the Year: CMLL
Promoter of the Year: Salvador Lutteroth
Best Booker: Tony Khan
Tag Team of the Year: Young Bucks
Best Weekly TV Show: Dynamite
Best on Interviews: Hangman
Most Improved: Harley Cameron
Most Charismatic: John Cena
Japan MVP: Saya Kamitani
Mexico MVP: Mistico
US/Canada MVP: Jon Moxley
Europe MVP: Michael Oku
Women’s Wrestling MVP: Saya Kamitani
Feud of the Year: Moxley vs. Hangman Page
Most Underrated: The Beast Mortos
Most Overrated: Jey Uso
Best Brawler (Bruiser Brody Award): Jon Moxley
Best Technical Wrestler (Bryan Danielson Award): Zack Sabre Jr.
Best Flying Wrestler: Máscara Dorada
Danny Hodge Memorial Award (Non-Heavyweight MVP): Mistico
Best Television Announcer: Bryan Danielson
Worst Television Announcer: Booker T
Best Major Wrestling Show: AEW All In 2025
Worst Major Wrestling Show: WWE Wrestlepalooza
Best Wrestling Maneuver: Hangman's Buckshot Lariat
Most Disgusting Promotional Tactic of the Year: WWE bringing back Brock Lesnar
Rookie of the Year: Seri Yamaoka
Best Non-Wrestler: Don Callis
Worst Match of the Year: John Cena vs. Cody Rhodes
Worst Feud of the Year: Anthony Bowens vs. Max Caster
Worst Promotion of the Year: WWE
Best Gimmick: "Timeless" Toni Storm
Worst Gimmick: Heel John Cena
Worst Television Show: NXT
Best Book: The Irresistible Force - The Life and Times of Gorilla Monsoon
Best Documentary: Dark Side of the Ring - Daffney
Hangman Doing the Cody Stip
Joe recapped it on today's Thursday Dynamite Review, but we'll have a bit more discussion about the build to AEW Revolution, Hangman Page using the infamous CODY STIP to get a Texas Deathmatch against MJF, plus additional fallout from another great episode of AEW Dynamite.
Fantasticamania
The tour kicked off yesterday with Night 1
FantasticaMania 2026 Tag Team Tournament First Round MatchLos Viajeros Del Espacio (Futuro & Valiente Jr.) defeat Hijo de Stuka Jr. & Shoma Kato (10:17)
Hechicero defeats Zane Jay (10:03)
Fantasticamania 2026 Tag Team Tournament First Round MatchAverno & Magnus defeat Stigma & Tiger Mask (7:11)
Fantasticamania 2026 Tag Team Tournament First Round MatchAtlantis & Atlantis Jr. defeat CozyMAX (OKUMURA & Satoshi Kojima) (w/Mima Shimoda) (6:40)
Philip Marlowe Jr. & Unbound Co. (BONE SOLDIER Jr., Daiki Nagai & Titan) defeat El Desperado, Masatora Yasuda & Six Or Nine (Master Wato & Ryusuke Taguchi) (9:46)
Lightning MatchSoberano Jr. vs. Templario - Time Limit Draw (10:00)
Fantasticamania 2026 Tag Team Tournament First Round MatchEl Sky Team (Mascara Dorada & Mistico) defeat SHO & Ultimo Guerrero (16:40)
Night 3 (February 22) is the next important one with more tournament matches:
Hijo de Stuka Jr. & Shoma Kato vs. Tatsuya Matsumoto & Tiger Mask
CozyMAX (OKUMURA & Satoshi Kojima) & Ultimo Guerrero vs. House Of Torture (SHO, Yoshinobu Kanemaru & Yujiro Takahashi)
Six Or Nine (Master Wato & Ryusuke Taguchi), El Desperado, Masatora Yasuda & Stigma vs. Unbound Co. (BONE SOLDIER Jr., Daiki Nagai, Shingo Takagi, Titan & Yota Tsuji)
Lightning Three Way MatchHechicero vs. Soberano Jr. vs. Templario
Fantasticamania 2026 Tag Team Tournament Semifinal MatchAtlantis & Atlantis Jr. vs. Averno & Magnus
Fantasticamania 2026 Tag Team Tournament Semifinal MatchLos Viajeros Del Espacio (Futuro & Valiente Jr.) vs. El Sky Team (Mascara Dorada & Mistico)
CMLL Changes
luchablog.com had a great write-up about what's going on, you can read it in full here: https://thecubsfan.com/cmll/2026/02/18/cmll-capitans-rules-eliminated-torneo-de-escuelas-begins-cmll-mlp/
"CMLL dropped Captain’s rules on Friday, the same time they got rid of eliminations and made all matches end in one fall. It just took until Tuesday for CMLL to stream a trios match. There were no trios matches on the Friday or Saturday streamed cards. CMLL made no note of the change in recapping the Sunday and Monday non-streamed shows. Julio Cesar Rivera and Miguel Linares both emphasized that there were no captains in the main event and that only one person had to be defeated to end the fall.
Over the last few months, CMLL’s started to change the rules “only in AEW matches” and “only in outsider matches.” Those rules are nearly identical to what all matches now use. CMLL is still using two out of three falls for their tag matches but not the ones with outsiders. CMLL’s mostly eliminated two out of three fall singles matches in recent years – starting before AEW got involved with CMLL – so there’s no telling how long those rules will remain for tag matches. The rules changes, starting with the increase of AEW people, have led people to believe that these are changes driven by AEW. The feedback I get is AEW people have no more idea why those changes were made than the rest of us. They say they haven’t asked for any changes; they’ve just followed whatever rules CMLL gives them. The CMLL people they’ve worked with have said the AEW folks haven’t pushed back or asked for different rules. This appears to be a decision CMLL drove themselves."
The write-up also includes this incredible line:
"Captain’s Falls rules weren’t easy to understand. At one point or another, I tried explaining how they work to everyone from wrestling TV announcers to male porn stars."
The whole piece is a must-read.
Again, read it, now: https://thecubsfan.com/cmll/2026/02/18/cmll-capitans-rules-eliminated-torneo-de-escuelas-begins-cmll-mlp/
Saya Kamitani vs. Starlight Kid
Rich recently watched the Saya Kamitani vs. Starlight Kid match from the 15th Anniversary Supreme Fight 2026 in Osaka.
If we have time, he'll talk about it!