Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

This post is free for all members of FlagshipPatreon.com. Access thousands more hours of bonus wrestling content, columns, and in-depth coverage of wrestling's past, present, and future by upgrading to our $5 or $10 tiers.

----

It's hard to imagine a company that made $1.709 billion in revenue last year being so worried about fan and media sentiment, but WWE keeps surprising us.

Per a new report from POST Wrestling by Brandon Thurston and John Pollock, WWE objected to ESPN using letter grades in its editorial reviews of WWE events, and ESPN, unfortunately, abided.

As first reported in the March 9, 2026 issue of the Wrestling Observer Newsletter, Dave Meltzer reported that "someone on the WWE side… had gotten [the use of letter grades] killed."

You'll recall the pants-wetting that happened when ESPN writer Andreas Hale covered the first live event under their new five-year, $1.6 billion deal with WWE: WWE Wrestlepalooza 2025.

Hale dared to give the not very good at all show a "C," and the pitchforks came out in short order for the long-time combat sports reporter.

The reactions became so widespread that Hale appeared on Johnathan Coachman's Off The Ropes podcast to address the "controversy."

"The show's over. People already watched it. My match, the grade doesn’t mean nothing anymore. They got their views. It means nothing. But I think the bigger issue is, if we can’t be honest about what the show is, my journalistic credibility is under fire. And my grades mean something. For those who know at ESPN, I also grade UFC cars. I grade the fights. I grade boxing. If I give everything an A, then what does it all really mean? If I give everything an F, then I’m just a hater. But if I can give you an explanation as to what I’m giving it and why, which is what I did, then I think people will strive for more."

It was absurd that he even had to address this, and we covered it in detail at the time on The Flagship.

In October, Hale's review and grades returned as he gave a "B" to Crown Jewel.

Since October, Hale's WWE reviews have not featured a letter grade.

As Thurston and Pollock discovered, during the period when Hales' WWE reviews stopped including letter grades, his UFC reviews have continued to feature grades.

While it could certainly be a coincidence (it's probably not), Thurston and Pollock also found that Hale or other ESPN digital reporters have not had a story with original comments from WWE talent since a Hale piece written two days before Wrestlepalooza.

WWE will tell you until it's blue in the face that they don't care what people think, that they are focused on their business goals, the internet isn't real, blah, blah, blah, but it's clear time and time again, they are VERY worried and very aware of what people think and say about them.

Back in December, WWE President Nick Khan scoffed at the idea that he or the company cares about fan feedback online:

“I’ve never once searched my name on X. I’ve never once searched my name on the internet. Whether it’s positive or negative, I don’t care about that. I care about, at WWE, part of my job is ratings, revenue, and relevancy. We refer to it as the three R’s. Those are the things I’m focused on.”

Last April, WWE Chief Content Officer Paul Levesque said during an appearance on The Bill Simmons Podcast: "The internet is not real life."

He "clarified" on those thoughts on The Pat McAfee Show a few days later:

“I don’t put a lot of stock into what is on the internet unless it follows through to other things we do. When Jey Uso won the Rumble, there were a lot of people that had a their thoughts and comments and opinions on that, which is at the end of the day, all they are. But there are 15,000 people in a venue and, as Pat’s said, its been sold out all the time and Yeeting and going absolutely crazy when he comes out. So who do we listen to? The few people? Or the large crowd?”

On Sunday's episode of Flagship Plus (available on our $5 and $10 tiers), Joe went in-depth about the turmoil around the booking of WrestleMania, reportedly due to ongoing fan feedback.

This was coupled with the news story that Royce Keys wasn't on WWE TV because he was still learning WWE production—a preposterous excuse and, very clearly, intended to stamp out discourse about why Keys debuted at the Royal Rumble in Saudi Arabia and has been in mothballs since.

To add even more to the mix, a report came out that WWE was actually playing 4D Chess by taking the Undisputed Title off Cody Rhodes in January because, per a report from Fightful Select:

"One of the reasons the title was taken off of Cody Rhodes, was so that he would be featured in the Royal Rumble and Elimination Chamber matches, adding to the draw of those shows."

Which, as Joe pointed out on Flagship Plus, if you give one second of thought to, makes no sense.

The end result after it all is a man who didn't win the Royal Rumble or the Elimination Chamber is now the defending champion going into WrestleMania—dumb!

Khan says he's focused on the 3 Rs: ratings, revenue, and relevancy, but I'd suggest he add a P to the mix: petty.

Forcing ESPN to drop letter grades for their show reviews, even though the lowest grade given was a "C," is yet another example of how soft this company can be despite its continued overwhelming, unmitigated success.

We'll have more on this story on this week's Flagship, which airs live exclusively on our $10 tier.

-Rich

Files

Comments

Jameson Fletcher

I think more focus (like the Flagship does) has to be on how fucking terrible their "stories " are from a company that says it is all about the "stories". Who is worse at stories than WWE amd their affiliate brands? TNA, that is about it

Doug Hunt

Its ridiculous how gotten to they are. How long until they try to fire middle manager Paul?

Eric garcia

So Dave wrote about it last week yet POST is getting all the buzz from "breaking" the story?

The Flagship Wrestling Podcast (Patreon)

Part of this is Dave's antiquated content distribution. He should be doing more breaking news as paywalled articles on his site, not saving everything for the newsletter. -J

Carlos R. Pastrana

The perfect company for Fragile Phil, the biggest bitch of all.

Nick Fugitt

Irascibility and hypersensitivity is in the DNA of this company and it will never leave

Eric garcia

Funny thing is, Dave said he would do just that but now his only paywalled articles are about ratings. That's not drawing a dime

Rob Bihari

Dave? Antiquated? Pfft. Show your work.