The Art of the Work: Mercedes Moné vs. Willow Nightingale at All In (Patreon)
Content
Willow Nightingale and Mercedes Mone would've been the best match on pretty much any other AEW PPV in history that didn't feature a match I called perfect in an earlier column. It was a nearly impossible act to precede, but the greatness, simplicity, and timeless pro wrestling work of Willow and Mercedes will hopefully be remembered.
The timeless pro wrestling work I mentioned refers to the match's central focus: Willow Nightingale's broken hand. An injury also referred to as a broken wrist at points during All In. Hand, wrist, tomato, tomato, right?
I'm dubious it's a real injury. I just am. I have been since it was announced just days ahead of All In, and I'm even more dubious after seeing the match. I know Tony Khan said it was a legit injury; I know Willow Nightingale said it was a legit injury.
I don't believe them.
And frankly, it doesn't matter.
The new work is the old work.
It's a phrase my Flagship Podcast co-host, Joe Lanza, has said many times about working pro wrestling fans in the social media age.
The advent of social media has broken down the walls of wrestler/fan interactions like never before. For the first time in wrestling history, fans have direct, sometimes immediate access to their favorite pro wrestlers. The pro wrestlers likewise can share more than just a localized promo on the weekly television show begging you to come to the wrestling show in your hometown. Now they can let fans in like they never have before. We've all learned way more about our favorite wrestlers, their personalities, and their relationships.
The issue is that most fans take everything wrestlers post as earnest. This isn't the CHARACTER of said wrestler tweeting; no, it is the real human being. And if you do tweet or post in character, it's so wink-wink-nudge-nudge obvious that you are "playing" pro wrestler, so I know this isn't the real thought of the person I'm following.
But sometimes that line is blurred. Sometimes, and stick with me on this, pro wrestlers are lying to you. Sometimes, and again, this is wild, but bear with me, wrestling promotions are lying to you.
Nearly every adult fan now is "in on the work"; very few people don't know at least some aspects of the inner workings of pro wrestling. Everyone knows there's a booker, or someone running the promotion, who decides the winners and losers and the direction of a wrestler's creative. They get angry at bookers and company owners, never at the heels for beating up the babyface.
And because of that, it's easier than ever to work fans. They want to be in the know; they assume they always are, so when a promotion or a wrestler says something on social media, they buy it whole, especially if it's a wrestler they like and trust, and a promotion with the same feelings.
That's what happened with Willow's injury. AEW, Willow, and Tony Khan announced she had a broken hand ahead of All In, and everyone just believed it. Why would they lie? Why would a PROFESSIONAL WRESTLER OR A PROFESSIONAL WRESTLING COMPANY LIE ABOUT BEING HURT IF THEY WEREN'T HURT?! Listen to you, people.
And again, I don't really care if it was legit or not. Work me, baby. I love it. It doesn't matter if Willow's cast was all for show or a legit cast needed to keep her brittle bones together. The result worked.
Mercedes relentlessly attacked and maimed Willow's hand and wrist at one point, even ripping off Willow's decorative cast to reveal a layer of loosely applied athletic tape. After that, Mercedes PULLED on the wrist, yanking it back further and further as the referee, Aubrey Edwards, admonished her for kicking too much ass.
The key spot at the end of the match was exactly what I predicted it would be when Willow's injury was announced. Real or fake, work or shoot, Mercedes was going to put Willow in the Statement Maker (former Bank Statement) submission hold and stop on Willow's hand while Willow was reaching for the rope break in a callback to their iconic spot from Mone's match against Bayley at NXT TakeOver: Brooklyn.
And that's exactly what they did. And the spot meant so much more because the rest of the match centered around Willow's injured hand. The last week or so of the build centered around Willow's hand. Legit or not, who cares? It worked. Whether Willow just said "fuck it, it's already broken, maim it all you want," or pulled a Hiroshi Tanahashi pre-G1 template by tweeting out an image of an injured body part or an X-ray, then proceeding to have a month's worth of matches with opponents focusing solely on the body part he casually mentioned was injured beforehand.
I don't care. Willow should lie to us. AEW should lie to us. It's the professional lying business: lie to us. Lie to us all the time. Lying to us and getting us to care about something more is the entire point of this professional lying business.
Lie away and never feel bad about it. Fans will give you more leeway and trust you more now, too. Fans trust wrestlers and promotions the same they did in the classic days of pro wrestling, they just think they are in on it. That they are part of the work. And when you can work as well as Willow and Mercedes did on Sunday, man, there's nothing better.
Before I wrap up, let me say: this was the best AEW women's match since Jamie Hayter vs. Toni Storm at AEW Full Gear 2022. I still think that one is my favorite, but this one wasn't far off.
Willow vs. Mercedes was a fucking war. The type of women's match that would make antiquated wrestling promotions and out-of-touch wrestling fans squirm. Mercedes got busted open hardway pretty early in the match and wrestled the entire match with an increasing amount of blood pouring down her face, obscuring her eyes, pouring into her mouth, staining the mat. A great visual in the match saw Mercedes stand up and move hair out of her face, emphasizing the blood oozing out of her forehead, blood spittle emerging from her mouth with every labored breath.
In the other company, the match would've been stopped dead minutes in to allow the ringside doctor to close up the wound and get a handful of towels into Mercedes' face to ensure not a drop of blood is visible. Ironic, given that one of their biggest women's stars ever transformed her career and ascent into stardom via accidental blood.
But alas.
AEW and Tony Khan have never been scared of having women bleed all over his shows, and he never should be. Anyone who has a problem with Britt Baker bleeding buckets during pandemic-era AEW or Mercedes Mone gushing blood needs to look at themselves in the mirror first before pointing the finger at AEW or the women involved.
In this case, though, it wasn't even an intentional directive to get blood; it just happened, and credit to Willow, Mercedes, and AEW for using it to their advantage and embracing it.
Or maybe it was a carefully planned, masterful bladejob by Mercedes.
Who knows.
Who cares.
The new work is the old work, right?
-Rich