Kazuchika Okada & AEW: A Relationship of Convenience, Not Passion (Patreon)
Content
Kazuchika Okada had one of the greatest careers of any pro wrestler ever before his 30th birthday. By November 9, 2017 (Okada's 30th birthday), he had already been a three-time IWGP Heavyweight Champion, main-evented Wrestle Kingdom four times, had a G1 Climax victory to his name, and had eight matches rated 5 stars or better by Dave Meltzer.
Okada could've retired the day he turned 30 and already staked a claim as one of the great pro wrestlers of this generation and a no-doubt Wrestling Observer Hall of Fame inductee.
That's what makes everything that's happened since March 2024 so damn depressing.
Kazuchika Okada debuted in AEW on the March 6, 2024, episode of AEW Dynamite and, during that show, turned heel, aligning himself with the heel Young Bucks in their both-in-hindsight and real-time very bad EVP gimmick. On March 20, 2024, on Dynamite, Okada defeated Eddie Kingston to become the AEW Continental Champion.
In the time since, Okada has spent 1,147 days as some type of champion in AEW, including over 600 days as AEW Continental Champion, 168 days as AEW Unified Champion (don't ask), 316 days as AEW International Champion, and after losing the title in May, Okada is just back now with his second run as International Champion.
It's been 911 days since March 6, 2024.
The math isn't apples-to-apples, as there are overlapping titles in Okada's history, but the point is still the point: Okada has spent his entire AEW run as a champion of some sort.
And what have we gotten out of it? What has he gotten out of it? They don't seem to have any other ideas for Okada other than: give him a title and let him hold it while he wears a suit. No doubt about it, that's a good look! Okada can wear the fuck out of a suit, but there has to be more here. We need to have gotten a bit more out of one of the greatest wrestlers of all time, right?
I don't know if it's chicken or the egg, or who is to blame for Okada's lackluster, hamster wheel-esque run in AEW.
The company signed him in the spring of 2024 after a bidding war with WWE. Okada, fresh off a very uneventful final months' run in his previous home promotion, NJPW, felt out of place during his initial few weeks in AEW. He didn't quite belong yet. Shit, I'm not sure he feels like he belongs 911 days later, either. Will Ospreay, that dude belonged from day one. That belonging has culminated in him being the key figure in the main event of AEW's biggest show of the year, in a big, giant arena, where he won the World Title. Okada won a three-way match for a secondary title during the first hour of the PPV.
From day one, Okada hasn't felt like a fit, like he belonged, or like a priority to AEW. Likewise, Okada's performances have left a lot to be desired. During his initial run with the Young Bucks, Okada leaned heavily into gimmick-y heel mannerisms and his "BITCH!" catchphrase. All the effortless coolness, bravado, and braggadocio from his run as "The Rainmaker" in NJPW seemed to dry up in an instant.
His work, again, Hall of Fame-worthy before he turned 30, has been good but not great. There have been some GREAT matches in Okada's run; don't get me wrong, but they are so few and far between, and so rare throughout the calendar (typically we only see vintage Okada around Continental Classic time), that they've become more frustrating than enjoyable. Anytime I watch a great Okada match, I realize again just what we're missing with him in AEW.
Also, despite notching 78 matches since March 2024, Okada feels like such a part-timer in the promotion. If you recall, Okada hit the ground running in AEW wrestling non-stop on Collisions and Dynamites from his debut. Things hit a snag beginning with the April 21, 2024 AEW PPV Dynasty. There, Okada defeated PAC to retain his AEW Continental Title. Before Dynasty, Okada wrestled six times from March 7 to April 20. After Dynasty, Okada disappeared until May 15, when he faced Dax Harwood on Dynamite. A few more weeks went by, and Okada returned for AEW Double or Nothing 2024's Anarchy in the Arena match.
Then, a month later, he popped up to face Ultimo Guerrero on a random episode of Collision. 10 days later, he returned to AEW PPV to take part in AEW x NJPW Forbidden Door. It was a very wonky schedule for Okada, and it raised a lot of eyebrows about the star leveraging a great contract with restricted dates out of AEW. Something that has become increasingly obvious over the last two years, as Okada's appearances remain sporadic, with obvious "this was taped last week" segments appearing routinely on television or, worse yet, segments where Okada is backstage saying a line while people he's feuding with or aligned with are in the ring reacting to a video board. Again, an obvious pre-tape.
Okada's lack of English was always going to be a barrier to him developing as a bona fide American pro wrestling star. Still, if anyone could ever pull it off, it was him. There's a reason WWE had their eye on him as early as 2014. He had the look, the body, and the charisma to pull it off, language barrier be damned.
And if any major American pro wrestling company could create a bona fide American pro wrestling star out of a Japanese wrestler, it would be one without decades of awful, outdated portrayals of Japanese wrestlers. In case you're wondering, the former EVIL is spitting green mist on NXT. No, he doesn't have the Oriental Express theme music. Not yet, at least. Yes, he is a Master of the Martial Arts.
But like, if anyone was going to get the most out of a Japanese wrestler on American TV, you'd figure it would be AEW, right?
What have they gotten out of Okada? What memorable moments or segments do you recall? What feud of his really set your world on fire? It all seems so forgettable and so empty. We're now well past a year into Okada's entry into the Don Callis Family. It feels like the only meaningful story we've gotten out of it is the most boilerplate, milquetoast one; even Paul Levesque has this as one of his five ideas: Okada doesn't get along with his stablemates. Seemingly from day one, Okada has been side-eying stablemates, be it Konosuke Takeshita or Kyle Fletcher. There was some juice initially to the Takeshita vs. Okada feud, but it took so long to get there; I'm sure many of you were like me, just pleading with them to get to the fireworks factory already.
Now he and Fletcher will make faces at one another while Callis says everything's okay. How long are we going to do this for?
Also, never getting a true Okada babyface or Okada main event run now, more than two years into his run, feels like an absolute waste. Okada is 37-8 in AEW singles matches. He's 8-3 in AEW singles matches on PPV.
Can you guess how many AEW World Championship matches Okada has been in?
One.
He faced Bryan Danielson on a random Dynamite in Pittsburgh. It was AEW World/Continental Title match in October 2024.
Since then, nadda. Zilch. Zip. Zero.
That's a monumental waste of Okada, right?! For him to never even be factored into the mix of a World Title PPV program even once?
In-ring-wise, Okada's still had some great performances. He's still capable of ratcheting it up and delivering one of those patented Okada-esque performances. Still, it's certainly telling that, of his Top 25 all-time matches ranked by Cagematch.net's Cagematch rating, only two are from AEW: vs. Konosuke Takeshita (May 24, 2025) and vs. Will Ospreay (December 28, 2024). The output has still been pretty great; even Okada at half-speed is a lot better than most. Still, it's pretty glaring how much the high-end work has fallen off despite Okada rubbing elbows with arguably the best talent roster in pro wrestling history.
Okada seems to have cashed in his chips. The guy worked his ass off to be one of the greatest ever by the time he was 30, and now he's just coasting. He's making more money than ever, with a few significant weeks in November and December, working a part-time schedule, saying bitch sometimes, wearing a suit, and holding a title. It's not a bad life, I guess.
But I do wonder if AEW lit a fire under Okada's ass. If they actually realized what they have in one of the all-time greats and made an earnest effort to push him in a main event role, give him a World Title PPV push, would we see the Okada of old? Or do they know that Okada is dead and gone and never coming back? Honestly, I don't know. I'm not sure whether AEW's hamster-wheel booking is limited to Okada, or whether Okada himself is facilitating the hamster wheel.
We all know a couple like Okada and AEW. Together for whatever reason: money, they've been dating since high school, etc. They are together, and sure, they seem happy, I guess. They host boring parties; they barely seem to have any chemistry; the banter sucks; they have a few kids to see if that'll add a spark, but that drives a wedge between them even further. They are together, but at a certain point it feels like a relationship of convenience more than anything.
Okada wanted to leave Japan, and AEW wasn't WWE, and they paid him more, so here he is.
AEW wanted one of NJPW's biggest stars ever, but didn't really know why.
They just did. He was available, and they could afford him, so they did.
It's a relationship of convenience, not passion.
And we're all suffering for it.
-Rich