My opinion on Lanterns. (Patreon)
Content
Hey guys, hope you're all doing well. I recently finished watching Lanterns, and I thought I'd write my opinion on it for anyone who is interested. Spoiler alert by the way. I will be writing this with the assumption that you've seen the entire show.
Let's start with the positives. Firstly, I think the cast is great. My favourite is undoubtedly Kyle (who plays Hal), he made the character so fun to watch. I also like how they made Hal seem really competent at times, like the interrogation scene in the first episode or when he took out the drone in the sky. Jon Stewart was also an interesting character. The idea that he had been groomed from birth to replace Hal was quite an interesting one.
The limited actions and constructs were very entertaining; most of the flying scenes were well done. Some of Hal's flying was honestly some of the best flying I've ever seen. A lot of the story was also interesting; the idea that a Manhunters, one of the original peacekeepers of the Guardians, was hiding on Earth and had got an entire town devoted to it was quite interesting.
Unfortunately, as someone who really did want to love this show, I feel like it has a lot of problems. Keep in mind that as I list them, I am doing this all from memory, so feel free to correct me if I get anything wrong.
First of all, like a lot of people, I agree that this show might have been a good show, but it was not a good Green Lantern show. There is barely any action, we never got to spend any time on Oa, the vast majority of this show about space cops was limited to Nebraska. The constructs were used so sparingly that I think the ring was permanently on low charge. Even after Hal gets his lantern back, it still feels like the ring is always low on battery.
This is the same weapon that gives Guy Gardner the courage to stand toe to toe with an angry Superman but they barely use it. I've seen some people online get made fun of for this take with people saying they're just babies who want cgi battles. I don't agree with that. It would be like if the upcoming Harry Potter show only showed about two or three pieces of magic per episode. You come to Harry Potter for magic, the same way you come to Green Lantern for constructs. As an example, in the first episode, Hal lets himself get beat up in a fight so he can go to prison to interrogate somebody. But if he literally just used the ring to knock the guys out after they attacked him then he would have still gone to prison anyway.
One thing the show could've done was say that Hal's charging lantern had gotten damaged or that for some reason, it had been altered or whatever, so the ring wasn't getting charged completely. That made more sense to me than Hal Jordon being consistently low on charge and/or not keeping his lantern somewhere close by so he can charge it.
Another problem I had was the fact that Jon and Hal were both fighting over the same ring. Like, are the guardians suddenly incapable of making more rings? Didn't Guy Gardner get a completely new ring after Jon didn't take Hal's? As a matter of fact, when Hal died, why didn't the ring awaken and fly off to the next host? Also, if the ring still had some charge to it, did Hal try to summon it after he was released from prison? An extra also, if Hal disobeyed the guardians, as they implied, why not just remove the ring from him?
Plus, the show's pacing just makes it feel so long at times, in my opinion.
Moving on to some of the main characters. I will be primarily discussing the finale, which was the worst episode in my opinion.
Firstly, let's start with Kerry Kane, the main love interest of Hal, who is played by the same actress who played Rowena Ravenclaw's daughter for those who don't know. I personally wasn't very interested in the character. A part of me wondered if I was just being sexist because she was a girl, but I genuinely don't think so. She's introduced as like this intelligent and hard-working woman but in the first episode, she is primarily just getting in the way of Hal, who we all know to be a world-famous intergalactic space cop, which I think trumps a sheriff of a small town in Nebraska. The fact that this woman continued to not listen to Hal later after he proved that the man she insisted wasn't an alien was in fact an alien, did not make me like her more.
The two begin something of a slow-burn relationship, I think everyone can tell from the start that they'll get together. On a personal level, I didn't find this relationship very interesting. It's revealed later that the Manhunter had helped Kerry and saved her life; that's why like the rest of the town, she's very loyal to her. She has some good moments in the show, undoubtedly, like when she helps Hal, visiting him out of prison, telling the town to leave him alone and so on.
But Good Lord! I lost so much of any respect I gained for her in the finale. It was revealed that when Zoe (the manhunter) healed Kerry after she lost a finger, Kerry somehow got pregnant. On a side note, if that's possible then why doesn't the manhunter do that with so many of the other loyal women in the town and create a new group of manhunters? Back to Kerry, when Hal revealed that he found out her son was a manhunter, he did so with the best of intentions. He wanted to get them out of the town and somewhere safe.
This woman -I swear to god - states that her son has an upcoming football match as one of her reasons for refusing. Like, damn, at least he can die doing something he loves, I guess. She starts having an argument with Hal, who is not displaying any indication that he wants to harm her or her son, he is literally just arguing that it would be safer for everyone involved to move somewhere else and in the middle of it, she just turns around and shoots him. I'm sorry, imagine if Mary Jane just suddenly turned around and shot Spider-Man in the head. I'm supposed to like her after that?
Moving on, Guy Gardner isn't in the show that much, though he is interesting for the parts he is in. In the finale, Guy realises that Jon tricked him so he could steal Hal's ring and finds out that Jon has an unsanctioned Lantern with which to chage the ring, shortly before Jon basically tells him to stay out of Earth. Now, I understand that the implication is that Jon will tell the guardian's that Guy took Hal's ring, but they represent it like Guy is afraid of him. I think if this exact scene had played out with any version of Guy Gardner then he and Jon would definetly be throwin giant green hands.
I genuinely did not like Jon at times, which is hard for me to say because he and Hal are my favourite Green Lanterns. Jon was the main lantern in the Justice League cartoon that I grew up on, he was the Lantern i used in my Talon story. Now, don't get me wrong, the actor's great and Jon has lots of good moments. His backstory is so interesting, the way that his parents moulded him into an almost emotionless robot was fun to watch. But - and I don't know how else to phrase this, emphasise the next sentence when you read it - he does some shit.
First of all, whose idea was it for him to bang a Granny multiple times? Who thought that would be a great thing to put on Jon Stewart? Many people's first impression of Jon Stewart by the way. Most of the stuff that Jon does in the show, good or bad, I can understand and I think works with his character. He is shown to be strong and smart. But sometimes he's just so dumb.
Like he spends the last couple of episodes arguing with his brothers, revealing that he has cut off his abusive parents who made him walk dangerous streets alone as a child and routinely shot apples off his head, but then at the end he's suddenly all chummy with them because he now understands that his mother was worried for him as she forces him to get shot at and walk streets alone at night where he could die?! She did all of this -by the way - because she wanted him to have the role that her husband didn't get. Off screen, they all forgive each other and are a family again.
Also, you know how there is Kerry who only admitted to killing Hal after he confronted her and there's also her manhunter son who broke Sinestro out of prison.....yeah, let them go. The woman who killed one of the world's greatest heroes over a single argument and her dangerous son, yeah....let them go. He implies that he's going to be there if her son does go evil, but what the hell is he going to do if the boy does go into politics and changes the world like he said he could? Is he going to openly attack a politician? Is she supposed to keep him on the right path? She shot her unarmed boyfriend over an argument!
Jon also confronts Guy without a charged ring, challenging Guy to take it. What the hell is he going to do if Guy does confront him when he has a ring that was barely charged? Second of all, the lantern that he hadn't yet used at the time was forged by Sinestro, who Jon clearly doesn't trust, yet he tells Guy that he's going to take over the protector's role of Earth without even seeing if the lantern works or if there are any traps or anything that can harm him from this lantern? It's during that scene that Jon says my most hated line in the show. But before I get to that, I want to talk about Hal.
As I stated previously, the actor made Hal so charming and charismatic and fun to watch. I genuinely think it's one of the best castings of all time. He is shown to be intelligent and experienced throughout the show, but there are issues that need to be mentioned.
As I mentioned previously, the man who many people consider to be the best lantern ever, and Earth's very first Lantern, barely uses the ring which somehow is always just on the brink of dying. But my main issue is quite frankly the treatment that Hal, a beloved character for many, gets.
At the start, the show actually respects him greatly, showing him to be famous on Earth, signing autographs and so on. But by the end of the show, he lost the ring. Side tangent: how the hell does Jon stealing his ring work? Can anyone just take a ring off a lantern and use it? Could I physically wrestle Hal's ring off him and become the next Lantern? But by the end of it, Hal Jordon - who probably saved the world a few times, I would guess - has lost his ring, been locked in prison for ten years, spent the rest of what remains in his life in a town that hates his guts and on his final day of living, he gets punched in the nose and then murdered by his girlfriend?
For context, imagine if Superman or Spider-Man lost their powers, got stuck in jail for over a decade, became hated by everyone and then got beat up by their succesor and then shot by the love of their life because they were trying to protect her son. Would you want to watch that? Like I know that DC likes to shit on him at times but this is horrendous. The man has been Green Lantern for decades; how many lives would he have saved? Yet this is his send-off? On a show where he barely uses constructs, he's sent off with a plain old bullet? Was he killed in a glorious battle with Sinestro? Did he die saving someone? Was the body actually a fake like I had been hoping throughout most of the season?
No, he died in a domestic dispute.
Which brings me to Jon Stewart's worst line, a line that in my opinion is up there with 'We are the Flash, Barry'. Jon tells Guy that Hal died a hero. No! No, he died because the woman he loved shot him! Literally, the best defence to that which I've seen on the internet is 'she's from Gotham' and that kind of makes sense to me, funnily enough. Hal Jordon, one of the greatest heros to ever exist, died via domestic dispte in a town that hated him and he got a funeral where not even ten people atteneded and was pretty much just made in the first place so Jon could get the ring off his body.
In case you couldn't tell, I really hated the finale.
Which was a shame because the rest of the show is decent, the interrogation scene in the first episode is some of the best writing I've ever seen. It's just this poor writing near the end that really ruins it. Once more, the show is good as a show, but not as a Green Lantern show. Barely any powers are used; we've visited perhaps two planets, three if you count a flashback sequence and Hal Jordon has the most disrespect a Lantern has seen since the last time Kyle Rayner opened a fridge. People argue that those who say this are just babies who want CGi fights...but that is what Lantern is.
If you wanted a detective drama, you would've been better suited making a story about Martian Manhunter, Huntress, the Question or even use this as a chance to introduce Green Arrow into the new Dc universe. Instead, you took a couple of characters with acess to one of the best weapons in fiction and limited them to Nebraska. Space cops limited to Nebraska. I know budget is a concern, which brings me back to my previous point, you could have made a show with characters that have less flashy powers. More examples would include Wildcat, Black Canary or even a spinoff show about Hawkgirl, her powers are limited to wings and a mace. Even better, make a Mr Terrific show.
This review has turned more into a rant, admittedly.
Overall, I want to put the show at a 6 to 7 out of ten. It's entertaining at times, the cast is great but the writing gets so bad near the end and it is so horrible for Hal Jordon fans.
Thanks for reading. Feel free to tell me your opinions, did you like the show? Dislike it?