Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

Eps avail on Hulu!

Files

Previews only

FIREFLY Episodes 4-5 Sync Yours!

Comments

Kaizen

To answer your question about the fencing duel, I'll base this on my experience in sword (fencing, Historical European Martial Arts aka HEMA) bouts (e.g., the "duel" format): It's pretty realistic as an outcome the way Mal wins. A fencer usually plays (duels) by specific rules and etiquette, and we know that Mal does NOT play by the rules. So while we might debate the exact moves (I've never seen the behind-the-back thing as a baiting move, but sure, there are behind-the-back guards you could use, so the concept is fine), and Mal running at him is really exaggerated, but the premise of baiting someone inexperienced and then they rush in is a very real scenario. The sword being broken is fairly realistic - they usually don't snap at the hilt like that but they do break often in duels. The way Mal wins by capitalizing on the distraction and smacking the sword away is good and very doable, especially with the element of surprise. The throw of the sword blade is impressively lucky or Mal practices throwing sword blades a lot, LOL. Then punching Atherton with the hilt of the sword is great choreo, very realistic. So, overall, the concepts of the major beats of the duel/fight are quite good, how it descends from a fancy duel into a scrappy brawl, just where Mal wants it. So, while we could nitpick the details of the fight, I give it 7/10 for realism. They got a lot more correct than do most TV/movie swordfights!