Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Files

Previews only

CHERNOBYL EP 5 Sync Yours!

Comments

Greg in East TN

I had not seen this series before, so it was all new to me, too. I wanted to see the complete series before I made a comment on the series, and hopefully put you and everyone else at ease about our power plants. I operated a commercial nuclear power plant for 15 years, so I know a little something about it. And I remember how the culture in US nuclear plant operation, maintenance, and testing underwent a major shakeup after the accident. From Wikipedia: "With dozens of direct casualties, it is one of only two nuclear energy accidents rated at the maximum severity on the International Nuclear Event Scale, the other being the 2011 Fukushima nuclear accident." (There is an excellent mini-series about the Japan accident, too). I'll try not to delve too deeply into the technobabble of the industry. And I'd be interested to know what you watched after this (you said it was going to be a Hallmark fact check video). Russian nuclear plants are a very different design from US power plants. However, the principles of splitting an atom is the same for every reactor. I think he gave a great explanation of how a reactor works in Episode 5. One thing people need to understand is Megawatts as it relates to nuclear power. A watt is a unit of power or energy. A megawatt is 1 million watts. In power generation, MW thermal (MWt) refers to the thermal energy produced by a reactor, while MW electrical (MWe) refers to the electrical energy output from the generator. Essentially, MWt measures the heat input, while MWe measures the electricity output US nuclear power plants have two containment structures surrounding each reactor. A steel inner liner and a 3-foot thick, reinforced outer containment building. Having a containment building at Chernobyl would have prevented many deaths, as nothing would have been released into the environment. MODERATION: It takes a neutron at a specific energy level to split an atom. When the atom splits, it goes into two pieces, not all the same, which makes all kinds of fission byproducts, all with different elements (more about that later). It also produces two to three neutrons that go off into the reactor. The force of a newly ejected neutron is too much to split an atom. It would be like a ping pong ball bouncing off a bowling ball. That's why they need a moderator. In the US, we use water. The water moderates the neutrons by absorbing some of the energy from every collision. That's what is called moderation. REACTIVITY: This is basically a measure of reactor production or shutdown. A reactivity of 1 means the reactor is at steady power, not increasing or decreasing. POISON: In nuclear terms, poison is the ability or capacity of an element to absorb neutrons. The more an element is capable of absorbing neutrons, the "blacker" it is. Poisons are the main reason nuclear power plants don't change load to meet demand. The biggest fission product poison is Xenon (pronounced (zee non). As mentioned in the show, it is produced, but burnt off and/or decays during power operation. It has a half life of around 7 to 10 hours. So after a drop in power and less Xenon burnt up, there will be a buildup of negative reactivity. But after 7 hours or so, the level will be dropping because of the half life. So you can't swing the load around, or restart a reactor right after a trip because of all the positive reactivity you'd have to add to overcome the negative Xenon coefficient. In the US, there are two types of commercial nuclear power plant : A Boiling Water Reactor (BWR) and a Pressurized Water Reactor (PWR). From here on, I will be talking about a PWR, as that was the type of unit I operated. In a PWR, the Reactor Coolant System (RCS) is what circulates the water through the reactor to keep it cool (610F to 557F). It is water solid, except for a Pressurizer attached to 1 of the 4 RCS "loops" The pressurizer is where the volume of water and pressure in the RCS is maintained. Each loop has a Reactor Coolant Pump (RCP) which pumps the water through the reactor then to the steam generator (SG) then back to the reactor. The reactor coolant water travels through the inside of thousands of tubes inside of each steam generator (one SG per loop) which cools the reactor coolant, then it goes back to the reactor. There is a water level maintained in each SG on the outside of the tubes to make steam. The non-radioactive steam produced in the SGs goes to spin the turbine and generator which makes electricity. FUN FACT: In the show, you hear the term "SCRAM". The industry is getting away from that term and is using the word "Trip" more now. The origin of SCRAM is that during early experimental reactors, the control rod(s) were withdrawn and inserted by using a rope to pull it out. In an emergency, there was a man on top with an axe to cut the rope. So SCRAM is short for Safety Control Rod Axe Man. In the US, reactor coolant water contains dissolved boron, a powerful neutron absorber. A small part of the RCS is diverted to the Chemical and Volume Control System (CVCS). When in operation, the RCS and CVCS work together to control the amount of water in the RCS and the amount of boron in the RCS. During startup, the control rods are pulled out and then the dilution of the boron in the RCS is started. That's how a reactor is started and how power is raised. Shutdown is just the opposite, boron is added to the RCS. Remember that reactivity is a measure of change in the amount of power (or change in the number of neutrons generated by the reactor). When the reactor reaches 0 MW, boron is still added to the RCS until a certain amount of negative reactivity is obtained. The difference between the 0 MW and the negative reactivity added by the dissolved boron is the shutdown margin. From what I could tell by the series is that the Russian reactors use graphite for a moderator and water just for heat removal (or to transfer reactor heat to steam energy to turn the turbine). And like the guy said in the trial at the end, theirs is cheaper to build and operate. But they don't have containment buildings, and their control rods are the main method of controlling reactor power. After all that, if you're still reading, this is how it affected the US nuclear power industry. All nuclear power plants are overseen and licensed by the Nuclear Regulatory Commission (NRC). Plans, specifications, blueprints, training, testing, etc., must all be approved to obtain and maintain an NRC license to operate a plant. After Chernobyl, all of our procedures, drawings, testing, etc., underwent stringent review. There was a procedure upgrade program that was initiated to decrease chances of a mistake or confusion when performing a procedure. A Human Factors program was initiated to eliminate confusion or mistakes when operating because of badly worded or confusing equipment nomenclature. A new method of writing, review, approval of, performance of, and completion results review was initiated. An increased emphasis on professionalism of personnel was begun. Safety always was and still is a top priority at US nuclear plants. It's a real shame what happened over there. And we may never get the whole truth about what happened. I know Russia isn't the only country that has different public stats and real stats. But I live 5 miles away from the 2-unit nuclear power plant where I worked and feel comfortably safe here. I know that at one time nuclear power plants was a hot topic and lots of people were for them and lots against. It is not my intent to stray into that debate. I just thought I'd share some of experience with you and all the other good folks here. Be well, Greg