DevBlog #1 - Coal Powerplant UI (Patreon)
Content
Hello everyone,
Today I want to bring something different and show the evolution of the interface for the coal power-plant, which in most part reflects on the other power-plants too. This results from the work made with Edgar Jesus (@edgarajesus) which is advising on the game UX/UI/Design.
The Start
This is how the control panel for the coal power-plant was before, the one you're familiar with if you played Power The Grid before. You have 3 generators, each with a power of 6. A green buttons means that the generator is ON and red button means it is OFF. When you first start a generator, the button turns yellow and the red bar starts filling, once filled the button turns green and a value of 6 is added to your power.
The main problems with it that I can now identify are:
- A floating UI panel that is always presented on screen - this is bad, it takes unnecessary screen space also limits the movement along the map (feature not implemented yet).
- A confusing structure of what this panel does and how it does it - this structure was put together during the first steps of developing the game and was never changed. When I noticed players struggling to use it, I created a non skippable step-by-step tutorial on how to increase and decrease power. It seemed to work and I moved on.
- A general lack of information - in trying to make a small panel that could be always on the screen, the information it conveys is very limited. This stops the player from acknowledging various variables that are relevant to the power-plant. Having more information allows the player to develop a better strategy and give more depth to the game.
The First Iteration
The change is radical.
First, the buttons were substituted by a slider. The slider seems to make more sense as a power control. It also brings more options for the output power, allowing to fine tune its value. Also the idea of a generator jumping its production from 0 to 6 is technically oversimplified and creates confusion. With the slider you immediately see a response as the power starts rising until it meets the value you selected, it still takes some time to get there.
The coal consumption section shows the consumption rate, varying linearly with the power output and achieving higher values when the power is ramping up. This should give you an idea on how to operate the plant more efficiently has each ramp up has a cost. The "hours left" variable gives you the number you need to retain to avoid a resource shortage.
The maintenance cost was almost invisible before, being presented only in the guide. Now it is more accessible and you can see it rising as you expand a certain power-plant. If you build too many power-plants for the demand needed, you can see the piling maintenance costs eating the profits of your enterprise.
The navigation of the panel changed, it opens when you click on the power plant and closes when you click anywhere else but the panel. The buy coal section was brought into this panel since it is where it should be.
The Second Iteration
The next iteration of the panel was my attempt to make it match the top panel recently sketched:
I focused on the darker background behind the graph and took inspiration from a panel of another game (left panel):
The middle panel is the first I made, then the right one after learning that I'm confining the elements in a tight space. Social distancing for UI elements is a thing too.
Other improvements included moving the coal level numbers to another section. Before it seemed to have the same relevance as the Power on the slider which is wrong. The buy coal section had some information that could be combined in a new buy button.
At this point I was happy with the panel I created but Edgar had more tricks up his sleeve and sketched a new look:
Much better! It's lighter, the sections are well divided, the background fade is nice and more important it aligns with modern/minimalist look I'm going for. I don't like the mine cart but it is just an example.
The next iteration is to make some changes to the presented variables, as the "resource consumption" is going to replace of the "operational cost" and the "operational cost" is going to the middle panel.
That's all for this post, let me hear you thoughts below!
Stay tuned and have fun.