Gas Miner 4 (Patreon)
Content
Last post of 2020! Woohoo! I really hope you guys have been enjoying all this silliness I've pumped out this year. It's been a blast sharing it with you.
Here's some more of that gas miner story:
———
Oril stared at Julaa, trying to make heads or tails of what she had been telling him. “So, you play this like a game?” he asked. “You compete to see who can make the biggest arbitrage?”
“Nah, that wouldn’t work,” interrupted Geji. “Everyone would want to buy from the cheapest ship and sell to the most expensive. It wouldn’t be any fun.”
Oril nodded. They’d been talking about economies and arbitrage. If there was something fun about any of this, he clearly hadn’t found it yet.
Geji explained, “Instead, this is a collaborative game. We all brainstorm ways that we can manipulate the system to make really big trades.”
Oril’s ears frowned low. “So, you’re having fun … exploiting the gate ships?”
Thippo rolled his eyes. “We’re exploiting their broken monetary system, not the geroo who live there.”
Oril raised an ear higher. “Are you sure? It really seems—”
“When in doubt, simplify,” Julaa interrupted. She held out two fists in front of him. “Let’s pretend there were only two gate ships—one where a loaf of bread is one credit and one where a loaf is ten credits—and you alternate days between the two ships.” She raised her right fist slightly. “On even days, you buy three loaves for three credits,”—then her left—“and on odd days you sell one loaf to the first hungry geroo you encounter. To make sure the loaf sells, you undercut their market by selling it for nine credits instead of ten. Nine minus three—you pocket six credits every two days and eat for free.”
Oril scowled. “So, I’m exploiting a hungry geroo? Now, I feel awful.”
“Not at all, Oril!” Geji laughed. “That hungry geroo was accustomed to paying ten credits for a loaf, and he’s earning ten times as many credits as he would have had he worked on the even ship. From his perspective, odd ship bread was fairly priced, and you were offering him bargain-priced even ship bread.”
Oril looked down at his paws and fiddled with the necklace he’d made. “Huh. Well, then I guess I would be exploiting—”
“The baker on the even ship?” asked Thippo. “Nope. He sold three loaves at market price. He’s happy to have had the sale.”
“I don’t know about this, guys,” Oril said. He wrapped the necklace around himself and fastened the clasp behind his head. “Whenever someone is making money without doing work, then someone somewhere is getting cheated.”
“I know it seems that way,” said Julaa, “but we’ve thought about this a lot, and we’ve never found anyone who was harmed by it.”
“The company?”
“Well, not that I’d really care if we were cheating the company,” yarped Geji, “but it doesn’t even hurt them. The credits they issue aren’t real money.”
That made Oril scowl once more. He and Chenni had been comfortable for many years, but he still vividly recalled their early days when they were living paycheck-to-paycheck. Though they never went hungry, they had been on the cusp of losing their apartment more than once in those early years. Their credits sure felt real to him—doubly so when they had to borrow from friends and family to make rent!
“Company credits are just encrypted files,” said Geji. “Though they were valuable to us, they were worthless to Planetary Acquisitions. It’s not like they had to buy them with krakun golds. They just issued the credits whenever a geroo needed to be paid.” He lifted his ears and smiled. “But if you can come up with a counter example, we’d all be interested.”
Oril fidgeted silently. There had to be someone getting cheated, didn’t there? “Hrm. Okay, how about this…” he said, finally, “you’re not really trading bread, right? Let’s say copper bars are one credit each on the even ship and ten credits each on the odd ship, so you buy from the even ship and sell to the odd ship.”
Many heads nodded. Thippo said, “Sure, we’ve traded copper bars before.”
Oril’s eyes flashed with a “Gotcha!” He grinned and explained, “Except no ship should ever need copper bars. They shipped out with all the copper they’d ever need, and they recycle it endlessly. When a strand breaks, they toss it in the recycler and all the copper atoms in the wires are whisked away to be re-used when they make more.”
“It sure seems that way,” said Julaa, “but you’d be surprised. Managers will often sit on old stock just in case they might need it someday, and they’ll hold off on recycling junk they don’t need until they become desperate for shelf space.”
“Having stock looks good on reports, so it happens all the time,” added Thippo.
“Okay, but who’s selling us the copper bars?” asked Oril. “It obviously isn’t the company. You said that any credits the company receives are just deleted, so there’s never any incentive for the company to sell anything.”
Geji nodded. “Sure, that’s true. When we buy copper, you can be certain it’s coming from a black marketeer.”
“A thief, you mean,” growled Oril, “someone who has stolen from the company.”
Julaa shrugged. “Thieves do what thieves do. We aren’t exploiting anyone by buying what they sell. You may not like who is making a profit, but even then, we’re contributing to geroo, pumping credits into their economy by giving them credits they wouldn’t otherwise have.”
Oril’s frown deepened. “You’re right, I don’t like it.” He drew a deep breath and released it slowly. “But you wanted to simplify this thought experiment, right? So, let’s pretend that each ship only has a stock of ten bars worth of copper.”
Thippo clapped his paws and rubbed them fiercely together, grinning hard. “Now, you’re getting to my favorite part!”
“I am?” Oril felt worried, but all the ears around him looked encouraging.
“Yeah, keep going, Oril. You’ll see.”
“Um, okay,” he sighed. “So, you’re always going to buy even day copper and sell it to the odd day ship. So long as the even ship has some available and the odd ship wants some, you’ll continue trading. Eventually, the even ship is going to have a real shortage. They’re going to need copper for something and not have it.” He looked around at the crew. “You’ve victimized them—or at least helped the black marketeer victimize them.”
Geji smiled. “So, what’s the even ship going to do, Oril?”
Oril sat back and scratched his cheek. “Well, they wouldn’t tell the commissioner unless they have to,” he said. “The krakun solve problems by squashing geroo until all the problem-makers are all gone.”
Everyone nodded, Geji included. “Right! And if you eliminate the commissioner, then there’s only one other ship that ever visits the even ship, only one path for copper to come back after it has left.”
“Us?”
“Of course!” he said. “They’ll pay us to bring them copper.”
Oril threw up his paws. “Except that you wouldn’t do that! If you buy a copper bar for ten credits and sell it for one, you’d be losing money.”
“Right!” said Julaa. “So, to get the same mark-up, we’d buy a copper bar from the odd ship for ten credits and sell it to the even ship for a hundred credits.”
Oril stared, wide-eyed. “One hundred? But the going price for a copper bar on the even ship was one credit!” he gasped. “Why would they give you a hundred times what the bar is worth?”
“Well, there’s two simple reasons for that, Oril.” said Thippo with a grin. He lifted a finger. “First, they need the copper and there’s no one else who can import it.”
“So, we are exploiting them!” Oril crossed his arms.
“Not so fast!” said Thippo, raising a second finger. “The second reason is that now we’re selling to the company. The company will issue the hundred credits when they give them to us. Credits have no value to the company, so it costs them nothing. They don’t care how many credits we charge. It’s just a bunch of encrypted files to them.”
———
Reviewer's link: https://docs.google.com/document/d/1rsjSuzqtyCZqFiXGKZO0UaZ88FJ2NBHUDQJJ-DcvGMQ/edit?usp=sharing
Thoughts?