Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hello Everyone,

After yesterday's poll there was a lot of very interesting discussion going on in our Discord, which is amazing. We're very happy that we have such an active community that freely shares their thoughts and ideas, and OPR would not be where it is today if it wasn't for this great community. So first things first: Thank you everyone!

Since not everyone is on Discord, we wanted to make a post today covering two of the biggest topics that were discussed after the poll dropped, and make a new poll to cover some more points.

The first topic we want to cover is why all armies are getting the same conditions, instead of each army having their own conditions.

As we've already mentioned before, the long-term plan is for every army to have their own unique army-wide rules and conditions, so what you're asking for is already in the plans. Currently our intention is to update about 1/3rd of the armies each year, and giving them unique army-wide rules is part of that. So don't worry, unique army-wide rules and conditions are coming!

That being said, this is a long-term plan, that will require proper development and testing time, and we need an interim solution until every army has received army-wide rules. Since we don't want to rush things, we're taking the approach of having the same army-wide conditions across all armies, so that at least things are solid and fair for everyone.

The second topic we want to cover is why there are always such heated debates around this topic, and why it's been so hard for us to make everyone happy.

What we've already been discussing with the community for a few years now, is that there are certain things on which the community is almost perfectly evenly split in opinion, which means that no matter what we do, a large portion of the community will be unhappy with the result. Since there is no unified direction that the vast majority of players want us to go in, we're in the position of always disappointing a large part of the community.

Whilst we usually don't show poll results, we thought the results of yesterday's poll are so indicative of this situation, that we think you should see for yourselves.‍

For offensive army-wides, we can see that from the three rules options, two of them have an almost perfect 33% split, with one having 23%. Then when we zoom in on the two that had the 33% split, we can see that they're divided 49% to 41%. Whilst these results definitely indicate a certain preference in the community, as you can see there is no overwhelming majority here, so no matter what we do a large part of the community won't be happy.

For the defensive army-wide rules, we can see that from the three rules options we definitely have two favorites, but those are again at a very close 39% to 37% split, and when we zoom in those have an almost perfect 45% split. So again, the results have no overwhelming majority in either direction, so whatever we do a large part of the community won't be happy.‍

For the last question, we at least had a bit of an easier result here, with a 34% to 29% split when given the choice between many rules, and then a 50% to 36% split when zooming in on the favorites. That being said, even a 50% to 36% split is not amazing, because it still means that 1/3rd of the community won't be happy.

So, where does that leave us?

When results are so close, there is no "community guidance" in these matters, so in the end we'll have to rely on our own thoughts of what is best for the games, and for what we're trying to do with them. We hope that the players that didn't vote for whatever we ultimately choose to implement can at least be understanding of our decisions, and that showing the poll results here gives you a better perspective on things. :)

That being said, we're not done yet.

There were lots of other points that players brought up after the survey, which we think are valid for you to vote on. Should we keep army-wide rules as they are? Should we make them more unique? Should we remove conditions from them? Should we remove army-wide rules as a whole? Or should we do whatever we think is best? Lots to wonder!

To help us gauge where the community as a whole stands on army-wide rules, we've taken the most frequently shared opinions and put them into a poll. Make sure to answer here: https://forms.gle/qSXEvgNXfvRBYBkU6

OPEN THE NEW POLL

Thank you for your continued feedback and support, making these polls and talking to the community about them has been super fun, and we hope you've been enjoying the conversation too. :)

Happy Wargaming!
– OPR Team

Files

Comments

Red Laser Reviews

Why not have army wife choices? I love the option to go Blessed Sisters vs Blessed Sisters but my opponent having picked different army wide rules. Obviously they would have to still fit the "theme" but not options is always fun!!!

johnathan cuda

The one thing that has me confused here is you keep talking about slowly making unique army wide special rules but every army i currently have, 6 in total, all have different army wide special rules none of which are the ones mentioned in the poll. Are these going to be like secondary army wide rules?

Luka Žnidaršič

Why not give us the choice to choose the specific armywide implementation ourselves when building a list?

Marcin Drewek

Putting "conditions" and "unique" in one answear is a bit problematic 😅 i like the idea of unique but im not fan of condition. Just my opinion ✌️

Garboq

I feel like one of the core issues here is that there seems to be a disconnect between the "player fantasy" and the "army fantasy". What army wide rules should convey is how the army *feels*, rather than what it does, but it *has* to do something to make that feeling useful. What I mean is I play Prime Brothers. I love the -1 AP because I *feel* that I am playing a superhuman with any number of adjustments and armor. It *does* something. I also play Dao. The Visor works, even if conditionally, because itt *feels* that they are weak when in close quarters, panicked even. But I also collect High Elf Fleets and it feels... well, lackluster in comparison. It feels like a bonus more than it does an identity. When compared to fantasy, i.e., Wood Elves, which I also collect and play, Wild Veil gives them an identity, even if my playstyle doesn't suit it. It *Makes sense*, and it *works* despite my whining or wishes that it was a different thing. I'd love for them to get +1 to hit somehow, but I cannot deny that what they have, works. Vampiric Undead, works. It's the fantasy of the neverending army. So do Saurians, with them being burly and "primitive" and using every tooth and nail to fight. Whereas Mummified undead feels a wee bit off. Sure they are legions but... doesn't the ability (+4+2 range when shooting or chrging) seem better suited to someone else? I'd love for them to do something different, and I don't think that the flavor works, but it does something I guess... Anyway that I mean with this block of text is that the feel of an army can be good so long as the percieved value works out.

Marie Véronique

My biggest comment would be that we just went through a major change with 3.6.0, and any further change should wait until 3.7.0 next year, unless it is something so unbalancing that it needs immediate attention.

Andy Mihok

This! I was going to suggest the same thing. Everyone wins.

Whatever

Why are you guys so bad at making polls? Those "which do you prefer" questions needed a fourth answer of "I hate both of these." Also the last poll should have been completely disregarded after you saw how unhappy people were with the options, I know I didn't vote in it because I couldn't give my answer to it. Also you should stop pandering to the discord circlejerk because the opinions of people that want to avoid that cesspit shouldn't be treated as less important.

Gnurro

I'd like to bring up Goblin Reclaimers, not just Blessed Sisters and Blessed Sisters for army wife choices - have you seen Twin Goddess Minis...?!

Whatever

Also if you're so seemingly dead set on pushing changes through, can you at least leave the option for previous editions in the army builder?

Red Laser Reviews

HAHAHAHA I completely missed i did that but at least I used the blessed sisters instead of Ratmen or Havok brothers!

James Callos

Can we not do unique rules? Part of the problem with 40k is how complicated and nonsensical that gets. Instead, add it to the stat blocks. Not every army needs to have a rule forced on it arbitrarily like that. Sometimes an army is just a bunch of guys with rifles and thats fine

Necrobama

How can they make unique rules without conditions, there are only like 6 stats in the game, and there are over 50 factions+subfactions in the game

Necrobama

"I don't vote or engage in the community, i just complain in the comments and say every option is bad"

Whatever

Ah jeez, you're so right. I should just vote for things I don't want without saying anything, that's sure to put the game in a spot I enjoy.

Andrew Bullman (edited)

Comment edits

2026-11-14 11:00 Here is a question because OPR clearly wants to go through with this why not just do it. Let it be out their for a year maybe two and see how it performs then if feedback after that period of time ses "No people don't like this" move on try something else. Otherwise we are just going to see a repeat of last time a new rule was added that changed the game. It came out not even 3 weeks ppl gave their initial thoughts OPR panicked and removed the rules and slipped it into he bowels of advanced rules never to be seen again rather than giving people time to adjust. Community plastering qith the oatreon supporters good keep it going but once your releasing it to the public own it.
2026-11-13 17:50 Here is a question because OPR clearly wants to go through with this why not just do it. Let it be out their for a year maybe two and see how it performs then if feedback after that period of time ses "No people don't like this" move on try something else. Otherwise we are just going to see a repeat of last time a new rule was added that changed the game. It came out not even 3 weeks ppl gave their initial thoughts OPR panicked and removed the rules and slipped it into he bowels of advanced rules never to be seen again rather than giving people time to adjust. Community play testing ithe the patreon supporters good keep it going but once your releasing it to the public own it.

Here is a question because OPR clearly wants to go through with this why not just do it. Let it be out their for a year maybe two and see how it performs then if feedback after that period of time ses "No people don't like this" move on try something else. Otherwise we are just going to see a repeat of last time a new rule was added that changed the game. It came out not even 3 weeks ppl gave their initial thoughts OPR panicked and removed the rules and slipped it into he bowels of advanced rules never to be seen again rather than giving people time to adjust. Community play testing ithe the patreon supporters good keep it going but once your releasing it to the public own it.

Jeremy Allan

Yeah honestly the range thing made me really unhappy with the new rule set, I muuuch prefer the method of hold vs closest, it allows you to play more shoot / agressive melee without having to worry about how your melee block can't get the bonus because now they're charging from 3ft away!

Savage Bruski

I thought the survey was a little off because you're just repeatedly asking "what's not the worst on this list? And now this list?"

Jeremy Allan

A lot of people are really unhappy with the decisions made for 3.6 especially with those army wide rules so I think that's why it's happening

StaleWhiteBread

Havok brothers would be great wives. They are very passionate about their choices and will speak up about them!

Pudge

Just put out a poll rating how much people like or dislike conditions for army rules. This way you can measure people’s disdain for army rules with conditions.

Mark Shepherd

i had to take every option that wasn't 'what opr thinks is best' because they have proven to make really bad choices. They are becoming that which they worked to replace...

Mark Shepherd

someone will just make a 'previous version' army builder these days, easy to do with AI And ignore robert, he's obviously incapable of not being that which he despises

Mark Shepherd

I think its a psych eval, you choose the one you like, then they hit you with all the other options in any combination, until finally adding the one you most liked back in. You have 3 options, you choose one.. they ask about the other two together, and indifferent. then they ask you about the one you chose and another one, for each combo. In the end they will have a more nuanced Hierarchy answer then 1 poll entry. Just choose every answer that counters 'what OPR decides is best for the game' and we all win

Urian Borda

As long was we wipe out those "when using Hold/Charge" people, I'm happy.

Savage Bruski

Well, if I were being honest, I could see all of these adding flavor to a certain army perfectly, but not all of them, that's why I was annoyed. Like the one that triggers/effects ONLY the closest unit - okay, that sounds perfect for the hive minded sort of tyranid/alien hives nature, but would suck with an army like HDF or battle brothers.

Levi Cain

I think a big part of why the community is so split on the different methods, (Hold/Charge vs Over 9"/6" Away vs etc) is because different armies are going to want different conditions; with each army looking to fill a different vibe/playstyle. For example, I'd argue that the GF Orc Marauders currently getting Surge when shooting/charging enemies over 9"/6" away doesn't quite feel right. They're orcs. They want to get in there and *fight*. That 9/6 inch range requirement feels much more tactical than the rest of the army's vibe. Getting Surge when shooting/charging the nearest enemy unit makes a lot more sense to me; dog-piling the nearest target like a bunch of berserkers feels very orcish. My recommendation would run a poll asking about each individual army currently using a conditional rule; asking which condition each one should use. I imagine you might see some more decisive results that way.

Levi Cain

For starters, the limitations of how the Army Forge works. On the technical side of things, the "army wide" rules are just baked into each unit's base cost. Making army wide rules changeable would probably require a complete rebuild of the Army Forge. Don't get me wrong, I don't necessarily think it's a *bad* idea, it's just not a practical one.

Luka Žnidaršič

Nah. You can value units without the armywide. Then you can enable the specific army wide and deduct points from the whole based on which units are selected then round to 5. Eg. Spearmen -2.3, Knight -3.4, Mages -2, sum=7.7, round to 10. Enabling armywide costs 10 points. Voila. Those costs on each unit can be static to make it simple.

Old Man Patches

Unique army-wide rules would give every army its own "feel" and Identity. I also like the option of choices, like Orks of different clans having different specialties or fighting styles, which can add flavour.

Old Man Patches

Unique army-wide rules would give every army its own "feel" and Identity. I also like the option of choices, like Orks of different clans having different specialties or fighting styles, which can add flavour.

PontifexMaximus

I'm surprised how effectively the audience keeps dodging this hidden but elephant-sized metric: Random: "I came to OPR because I am tired of the current edition of 40k!" OPR Community: "Great! How can we make OPR a better experience for you?" Random: "Make it less like OPR and much more like the current edition of 40k, please!" Also - I don't understand why it is necessary to utterly remove prior army lists when putting these new toys in play. Every single "Army-Wide rule" is just a variant on an ability that OPR pretty much already has available for an individual unit somewhere. I get that OPR is trying to eke out a brand identity for itself and get away from its roots (and don't deny that for even a moment), but if the idea is to get the Patreon people to do the legwork of keeping the stuff they like, then you can at least thin the border between Official and Community army, and make a system for high-level supporters to not only make available their "alernative" lists for a faction, but to update the Army Builder to directly point out lists that are just simple tweaks or restorations of previous faction list concepts. If I want, say, to play an "older" style of HDF, why should I have to spend hours sorting through the Flea Market system of Community lists, rather than get some recommendations?

GravityDog Mechwarrior

I prefer fewer rules. adding more complicated rules just so every unit feel special bogs down the game.

Steven Elkhome

Just speaking as (sort of) a professional economist, this is just genuinely good survey design. For people who don't understand what's going on, this is similar to the "Condorcet method" and generates a net of "X is preferred to Y" so you can determine all sorts of interesting things, but ideally it'll generate an option that is preferred to all other options when compared one at a time.

Steven Elkhome

I am strongly in favour of OPR doing whatever seems like most fun, and then just using points to balance.

Stuart Jones

Would you ever consider adding Teflings to the setting? Not as their own army, but it would be cool if you released a small collection of half-Daemons models that can be swapped in for the models in various Human Empire units. It would add some interesting variety to the Empire, and I'd like to see what a half-Plague human would look like.

Fudgemaker17

You guys are terrible at making polls. Seriously, it's like no one read the comments on the last one. You aren't including any poll options that express a negative view of "These are bad choices." You are presenting only two possible solutions and have no way of indicating what's actually wrong. The only negative framing is "completely remove them from the game," which I haven't seen anyone say (If you didn't want them, just... don't use them.). The problems are simple enough: most people don't like "conditions" on the army rules, and the rules aren't unique; I wouldn't have needed 16 polling questions to derive that.

Appolyon

I think the main problem is, that every army wide rule is supposed to have the same condition. But I think, for some armies 9"/6" might be the right choice, while for other it's closest target and for again others it is the hold/charge action. I imagine Closest target" being the preferred choice for melee or short ranged armies, while the 9/6 rule is liked by those who prefer shooting from afar. "Getting a bonus for close combat, after you exhausted yourself by running a long distance is just stupid, but getting it the same bonus for shooting, if your enemy isn't right up your nose and you can aim, isn't.