Help Me Pick a Thumbnail (Patreon)

Hey guys! I need some help picking a thumbnail for a new gaming channel video. Which one do you guys find more eye catching? #1 (on the top) or #2? (on the bottom).

To help you choose here is some info about the game: The game is an investigation style game, where you have to unravel a story by searching words to find short video clips in a database. The clips are out of order and you have to try putting the story together as you go.