Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Content

For those unfamiliar with British radio, we have a show called "Desert Island Discs" where stars from all over the world select their eight favourite records (along with a book and a luxury treat).

It's a fun thought experiment, so in that spirit...

Let's do Desert Island Books.

If you were stranded for the next year on a desert island, what books would you bring to keep you company?

Let's make this difficult and say...

You can only choose 3 books.

What books would you choose and why?

Would you choose the complete works of a writer with whom you wish to become more acquainted? Like Shakespeare or Chaucer?

Would you bring a religious text either for its offering of spiritual comfort or its smorgasbord of riveting stories? The Bible has tales from every genre to suit every mood.

Or perhaps you would choose something educational, like an encyclopaedia, book of art, or history series?

Would you lean towards comfort reads and escapism? Or opt for anthologies of classic short stories and poetry? Or perhaps an energising blend of the two?

Would size be a factor? Proust's In Search of Lost Time and Joyce's Ulysses could certainly be lifelong literary companions.

Would you choose books you have already fallen in love with, or go for something new?

Your choices with this thought-experiment might inform how you approach your reading today.

I'll reveal my three choices in the comments after readers have weighed in!

Files

Previews only

Comments

Tim Trippel

Given the above comment that I could the Bible and Shakespeare's Works are givens then: 1. Lord of the Rings 2. Les Miserables 3. Walden

Josh LaMar, He-Him

1. The Divine Comedy by Dante 2. Complete works of Jack Kerouac, Big Sur, if you force me 3. Complete works of Shakespeare, Hamlet if you force me

Anna B.

What a great question ! Well if it’s just a year, then it would have to keep me thinking, keep me company, keep me feeling uplifted, and keep me somewhat entertained. 1. War and Peace - because I could think about a page or two everyday and actually get to know it really well and lots of characters to keep me company ! 2. Hitchhikers Guide to the Galaxy- to keep me laughing and imagining. 3. Guide for the Perplexed conversations with Werner Herzog- for camaraderie and to keep me going and to feel like I’m conversing with a friend, and to keep me thinking about life. If I could take a 4th book it would be nonfiction book like a psychology book or artist biography. There’s a book I have called Art in Theory from 1900-1990 and contains all these artists letters and writing about art, it’s like 1200 pages it’s just fascinating and it’s one of my favorite things!

SML

As I would have no interest in taking the Bible, I would replace it with the complete works of Terry Pratchett, because I can’t be serious all the time. Then 3 books: Bleak House by Dickens, War and Peace by Tolstoy, and last but not least, The Plays of Moliere translated by Richard Wilbur.

NicoleA

Oh gosh, the more you think about this question, the harder it becomes to answer. So I will go with my very first thoughts. 1. Middlemarch - maybe a desert island situation will force me to finally get through it. 2 Catch 22 - a long time favourite 3 David Copperfield for delight. (Assuming there is also the Complete works of Shakespeare and The Bible with me)

Eleanor

Since I already get the Bible for spiritual guidance and Shakespeare to challenge myself with, I'd select favourites to climb into over and over again. 1. Pride and Prejudice 2. To Kill a Mockingbird 3. War and Peace

Sharon Nolfi

War and Peace, Wuthering Heights, the complete poems of Emily Dickinson.

Elena

What a question! I guess the answer will depend on the period in life one is going through. I would take to a desert island books that I like very much in order to celebrate life. To me some of the most precious elements of life are love, beauty and sadness and I would like to think about them again and again. Especially on a desert island. 1) «Charlotte’s Web» by E.B. White. We all come from our childhood and this book taught me what love is. Every time I read it, I find new dimensions of love and how to love. And to live is to love (not necessarily a person but a book, painting, sky, fruit, ocean). 2) «Speak, Memory» by Vladimir Nabokov to reminisce about beauty because «aesthetics is the mother of ethics» as one of my favorite poets Joseph Brodsky said. 3) The Ten Thousand Leaves. A collection of Japanese poetry to reflect on sadness and how sadness gives us roots and depth. And I am very sorry - this is a very very odd mix!

hardcoreliterature

Very nice answer. Thank you, Elena! I love that Charlotte's Web shows you new dimensions of love every time you read it. In regards to Nabokov, I was just rereading some of his Speak, Memory the other day - what a master of the language! I will have to pick up The Ten Thousand Leaves - I find Japanese poetry puts me almost in a state of meditation, of no thought :)

Sharon xx

This was fun but totally impossible. I've actually posed this challenge to one of my daughters and my other half. They're yet to come back with their answers. lol Disclaimer = the answer will be different on different days because books are my life but [for today only] here are my three: - 1) That Glimpse of Truth, chosen by David Miller [Short Story Anthology] - 100 of the finest short stories ever written. I chose this because it's like taking a hundred authors with you and, as Ben will attest, this is probably the best short story anthology I've ever seen. In the Amazon UK reviews someone has actually put, "If I was going to a desert island I would take this as my book." 2) In Search of Lost Time by Marcel Proust - Vintage Proust edition in six volumes. I am so excited to read these I couldn't possibly leave them behind. They're also beautiful to look at [look fab in my palm tree covered shelter] and I think would be perfect to re-read again and again. 3) Poetry of the First World War, an Anthology by Tim Kendall. Oxford World's Classics edition. Poetry from this era feeds my soul in so many ways. I love british military history and this book contains a lot more than just the poems. From the blurb. . . ."The work of each poet is prefaced with a biographical account that sets the poems in their historical context. In addition, Tim Kendall's introduction charts the history of the war poets' reception and challenges prevailing myths about their progress from idealism to bitterness."

hardcoreliterature

I have shared this thought experiment with a few people close to me too and I LOVE how much it stumps people. It typically takes me throwing out my three to get the ball rolling - even then people keep saying "it's impossible". As Elena and you have both pointed out, it's highly mood dependent. But I so love your choices here, Sharon. I'm proud to say I could have guessed your first two (and was strongly leaning towards that anthology myself), but the war poetry is a very nice surprise! We'll have to do some war poetry in the book club - some of it really makes me well up.

Bill Freeman

I shall bring three, each for my head, heart, and soul – and these in no particular order: * Chapters 5-7 of The Gospel of Matthew: Jesus’ Sermon on the Mount. * Anna Karenina by Leo Tolstoy * The Buddha and the Terrorist by Satish Kumar

hardcoreliterature

Tremendous choices. I might have guessed with Anna Karenina and it *might* be one of mine too. I've never heard of your third one, but sounds so intriguing I absolutely must pick it up. Thank you, Bill!

Tom Pearsall

Frankly I would probably bring the biggest survival guide I could find, The Bible (even though I am atheist), and the Norton Anthology of World literature. At the end of the year I would hopefully be alive and wiser. But really, the books I find myself reading over and over again are Blood Meridian by Cormac McCarthy, Absalom Absalom! by Faulkner, and Heart of Darkness by Conrad.

hardcoreliterature

The survival guide is a good idea! "How to Get Off a Desert Island" might be a good book too ;) Very nice choices, and interesting choice of the Bible despite being an atheist. Blood Meridian is a book I'm rereading continuously - I'm thinking this might be the next podcast episode. Brutal book. McCarthy is a master. Faulkner is tremendous too, and HOD by Conrad was my favourite book for a very long time. My first reading of it is still rooted in my memory - it gave me chills and held me transfixed for hours, compelled to finish in one sitting.

Frans van der Mark

I would bring the following three books: 1- Anna Karenina - the book that I am currently reading and that also will be good for quite a number of re-reads. 2 - Great expectations - the book that made me fall in love with literature in 1991. 3 - surprise book! collected poems by Philip Larkin. I don't know anything about this but it was picked by David Walliams on Desert island discs in 2009, so it must be good.

hardcoreliterature

Very nice!! Thank you for weighing in, Frans. Hooray - another vote for Anna Karenina! Ah, Great Expectations made me fall in love with literature too. My sixth form teacher read the whole thing aloud to us and it's one of my fondest memories in life. Larkin's a great pick and I could list so many great poems from him. Perhaps 'An Arundel Tomb' is my favourite :)

Anonymous

Ken Palmer Ben, You will know that the BBC Radio 4's "Desert Island Discs" allows the castaway to also take The Bible and the complete works of Shakespeare, in addition to a book of choice. Assuming you will also allow this, my three books as follows. 1. "The Go Between" by L.P. Hartley. This was also made into a great film, directed by Joseph Losey, with a brilliant screenplay by Harold Pinter. 2. "David Copperfield" by Charles Dickens - also the favourite of Tolstoy according to the biography I'm reading. 3. "Anna Karenina" No apology for being another to choose this great book.

hardcoreliterature

Ah, yes! Of course - they do give you those. Very nice choices, Ken. I believe David Copperfield was Dickens' own favourite too. No apologies needed for Anna Karenina. I'm ecstatic that so many were moved this significantly by Tolstoy's work. I've not heard of your first choice, but I studied many of Pinter's works back in university, so I'll have to grab this one myself :)

Caroline P

I am way behind with this. What a difficult question..mainly because some books that I cherish are not necessarily renowned great books but they are books that meant something special to me and might see me through a long spell on a desert island. So after a long thought I decided I needed books that would be keeping me on my toes for a very long time in case of no rescue 1) well having just started reading In Search of Lost Time by Proust I can see many years of pondering and entertainment..plus a lot of reading in all the volumes, which of course count as just one book. An excellent desert island choice. 2) I like Crow, by Ted Hughes..I don’t think I will ever totally understand all of it so that might me a good contender to take to a desert island. Plus it is a bit wild and devilish..and I might have moments where I feel like Crow in the book. 3) I first read Wuthering Heights when I was 14 years old. I fell in love with it because it spoke of an England I could connect with. The moors, the harsh climate and the starkness of the countryside. The passion and love also appealed to my 14 year of self. I have re read the book many times and each time it recalls that first reading so clearly. I am right back to being 14 and sitting in the garden reading…It is a comfort read for me, which sounds strange considering it is not a gentle book at all. Who can say why I would have to take it with me…but I would. And a desert island sounds lovely but I wonder if I might get too accustomed to the sand and warm tropical breezes..I might need to be reminded of moors, heather and the rougher side of living.

hardcoreliterature

Wonderful choices. Thank you so much for sharing, Caroline. I think one could be occupied an entire lifetime with Proust. Like you, I've cherished Crow. And very interesting that Wuthering Heights is one of your choices - I first read it as a first-year undergraduate on a long train journey across the country on an autumn night and could not put it down. Like you, picking it up now always recalls that time in my life and there is something comforting about it for me. It will definitely be on the upcoming book club schedule and I think the discussions would be very interesting indeed.

Josh Freeman

How to survive in a island and how to build a raft

Joel Duthie

My favourite game! I have been playing this since I was a kid although it was Mars rather than a desert island and originally albums (CD's). I was also more generous with my travellers and allowed 5 albums, books and movies. I ask this of everyone and it's never asked of me so I'll jump on the one opportunity I may have to showcase the books that make up my Mars-voyage-travel-kit. 1] Moby Dick; I have read this book multiple times and with each reading it gets richer! I consider this book as well as my #2 book to be more along the lines of scripture. It is as though each sentence has been hand carved. I can open my ragged book to any page and be in awe. Sublime! 2]Hamlet; Sacred writings! Like with Moby Dick I can turn to any page and be blown away as if it's my first read - this strikes as exactly what you'd want as a castaway. 3] Alice in Wonderland; Although I reread Blood Meridian more often I think that Alice, and all the great riddles contained within would be a better choice and keep me from an early noose. I find that I am loving Alice more and more with each passing year. "We're all mad here, I'm mad. You're mad". **Honorable Mentions (I think five books is fair...) 4]Marcovaldo (Calvino); A beautiful collection of magical stories. This book makes me smile each time I read it. It's like reading a painting. 5] Blood Meridian; It reads like my worst nightmare - how cool is that! I'd have to smuggle along Winnie the Pooh to counter the effects that Blood Meridian would have on my psyche. I really do still ask this question of everyone and it amazes me how many people respond with books like The 7 Habits or 48 Laws of Power or biographies. Who are these robots?!?! Now lets do albums and movies! ha

Pierre Bolkonsky

1. War and Peace (Tolstoy) 2. Anna Karenina (Tolstoy) 3. To be determined. There is no third book that had as much impact on me as those 2. But if you put a gun to my head, I would add the collection of Al-Shafi'i 's poems (in Arabic, I don't think it was translated to English).

Tim Dominic

1. A Tale of Two Cities 2. Pride and Prejudice 3. How to Survive on a Deserted Island for Dummies