Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Dickens Seasonal Read Revealed (Patreon)

Published:
2023-10-29 20:51:27
Imported:
2026-06
Tags:
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • 241613807.mp4

Missing 1 full-res photo, 1 video, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

The time has arrived.

Excitement is in the air.

We are finally revealing the Secret Seasonal Dickens, which will be keeping us warm as we move into winter.

Let us know at what point in the video above you guessed the novel.

We're discussing the rationale for the choice, how to prepare for this particular read, and why Dickens is such a cherished writer.

Video Timestamps:

  • 0:00 The Secret Dickens Big Read
  • 3:48 Why read Charles Dickens?
  • 6:00 Life of Dickens at time of writing
  • 8:00 Dickens' world & characters
  • 9:30 The comfort of reading Dickens
  • 11:00 Lifelong reading assignment
  • 11:41 Why read Dickens every year?
  • 12:19 Reading like the first readers
  • 14:32 How to mark the end of your year
  • 15:11 About this Dickens story
  • 18:53 Our approach to this work
  • 20:00 the historical era of this novel
  • 21:39 appreciating the opening together
  • 22:23 Dickens Big Read revealed
  • 23:28 Two things for you to do to prepare
  • 26:11 Happy reading, everybody

Book Editions:

Questions for You:

1) What is your current relationship with our seasonal read? Is this a reread or a first read?

2) What is your relationship with Dickens generally? Which novels and adaptations have you enjoyed? What did you think of them? And how would you encourage newcomers to Dickens?

Happy reading, everybody!

Files

Previews only

Comments

Jessica

Is it completely nerdy that I’ve been watching for this post? The holidays and Dickens are tied together in my mind and heart. Needless to say, I’m eager to dive in and hear what we’re enjoying this holiday!

Jessica
>>120937156

Just a couple of minutes in... are we reading my favorite book of all time!?! Your clues are making me think so.

Jessica
>>120937156

*gasp* we are! Wow. What a gift. Thank you Ben! This novel personally means a lot to me 📚🤩

Anonymous

My first Dickens was Oliver Twist. I read it in May of this year while staying in London for a week. It was very charming but not particularly interesting. Reading it in London definitely made up for the weak bits. A week later I had to read Hard Times for uni and dropped it about halfway through, because I was dying of boredom. His characters feel very alive but in a way that makes them seem like uninteresting soap opera figures. I'm not very invested in them as I am with Tolstoi's characters for example. So my relationship with Dickens is not the best. Still looking forward to this year's read.

Kyle Woitas

Ive been looking forward to this. My guess was either The Pickwick Papers or Sketches by Boz. Figured you were going to go back to the beginning. Can't wait to start this. I love Dickens and have been cobbling together a full set.

Roxane Bremen

I can’t remember which dickens I read first. But I remember reading A Tale of Two Cities and it was it has been one of my favorite books of all time. I’m so excited to read this with the book club.

Mathew Morrison

I'm quite proud of myself--around the minute mark when you said the ending made you weep, I thought "it must be [correct answer]," because I haven't read any other Dickens novel with an ending quite as much of a gut-punch as this one! I read it first in January 2020, but cannot wait to re-read! It is, so far, my favorite of his. My introduction to Dickens was probably not ideal--the massive David Copperfield. I liked it, but it wasn't until covid that I discovered his ghost stories, A Tale of Two Cities, Oliver Twist, Great Expectations, and a few others. I've got an 1839 edition of Nicholas Nickleby that is probably my most prized copy of any book. Though, as good a condition as it's in, I can't say I'm keen on reading through it, even with clean hands and on a clean surface. I'm not sure I want to risk the poor spine, because it is a copy that somebody or sombodies really cherished and read through many times.

M. C.

Hello Ben and my fellow readers, that was the longest 26 minutes or thereabouts to find out. It's funny I just received my Dickens 6 book collection in the post today and that book was amongst them. Exciting! Looking forward. Thank you Maria.

Manoosh

Great choice! I just finished this great book with my in-person BookClub. Looking forward to Ben’s analysis & comments. One of my favorites books to re-read.

Anne Smith

I read this one in high school 40 years ago. I’m sure I didn’t appreciate it then. I started rereading it a few years ago and didn’t get past the slow start. So I’m very much looking forward to this read. I’m a big fan of Dickens and his vivid, colorful descriptions and character development.

Leslie R

Yay!! I’ve been hoping feverishly that this would be it! 7 mins in, my excitement was heightened, then I convinced myself otherwise. Haha. My excitement paid off! I’m delighted with the reveal. What a fantastic accompaniment to Tolstoy and Dumas! This is my favorite time and place to read about (fiction and non-fiction) and this selection feels like such a gift. Thank you, Ben. I’m so looking forward to reading what the group makes of the story.

Rob (del’ly frèé) McClusky

There is only one Dickens novel I wants to read with the club. This is the one. I’m no longer crankee for today.

Jeffrey

This is one of my all time favorite books! And it’s the only Dickens novel I have ever finished. And even more strange is the fact that I don’t really “like” Dickens’s writing. Please, no one should take that offensively. In general his writing is something that just doesn’t grab me. But this one, I absolutely love. I first read this in junior high school. This will be my 4th read. But I’m old enough that those 4 readings have been spread out over a significant period of time. I highly recommend this book, regardless of whether or not you like Dickens. Happy reading everyone! Jeff.

Mathew Morrison
>>120938962

It's funny how many books I was forced to read in high school, and hated, are now among my favorites. Shakespeare, mostly, as well as 19th century American writers. We never read any Dickens, which is really a shame thinking back on it.

ALEX LEMON

Great choice! Super excited for this one!!

Michael Cahill

Delighted with the choice. It’s been probably 45 years since my last read. The opening lines could not do a better job of describing accurately the world of confusion in which we now live.

Rachel Brown

Excited to read this one. Thanks for the advance notice Ben!

Catherine LeBlanc

I’ve been looking forward to this big reveal as well (maybe a fellow nerd, Jessica)! As soon as you said the novel had one of the most famous beginnings, I knew it had to be A Tale of Two Cities! I can’t wait to reread this: I read it in English class way back in high school: it will be fascinating to see what stands out to me at this very different stage in my life. Thanks, Benjamin, for inviting us into the world of Dickens to close out each year. And this video was really fun: giving us clues and building the suspense. 😊

Philip Mildenberger

Excellent choice! Haven’t read it yet. Very much looking forward to it

Anne Smith
>>120938962

Shakespeare was not part of my education and I am just now getting to know him because of Ben’s enthusiasm and this book club. The only problem is there’s not enough time to read all the things!

Tena Sue

This will be my first read of this book. I actually don’t think I’ve read any Dickens before (I am familiar with A Christmas Carol but just from the movies). Excited to read Dickens with the group! Thanks for telling us early, gives me time to buy the book! 🙂

Brian Whooley

I don’t normally condone celebrating Christmas before Halloween; but for the seasonal Dickens reveal, I am delighted to make an exception! This will be a second read for me of this work and I am looking forward to seeing how the ten intervening years will change my experience with it.

Susan

This will be a first reading for me. I thoroughly enjoyed Edwin Drood last year. I have been anticipating the enjoyment of this year's read since January. A Secret Seasonal Dickens Read- what a wonderful idea, Ben!

Debra

Like Matthew Morrison, I'm proud of myself - I guessed the title when you said the ending made you weep. I was sure when you mentioned the iconic opening. Around 60 years ago, when I was a child, a sailor who worked for my Navy Dad gave me this book. After reading the beginning paragraph, I was so confused and decided the book was too hard for me. A couple of decades ago, or so, I again attempted the book - I loved it. I still have the copy in my book collection and look forward to rereading with the group. I'm not a great Dickens fan, although I liked last year's Edwin Drood but most Dickens seems too slapstick for me. I'm hoping to appreciate Dickens more by listening to Ben's excellent lectures and reading people's posts.

Caroline P

Yipppeeeeee.. i love this Dickens.. what a treat! I nearly thought you were going to say The Old Curiosity Shop until you said the best ending and starting.. then I guessed and smiled a lot. I just looked and I have lost my old, much read copy so that means I can treat myself to a new one. Yipppeee. This is going to be the best of rereads!

hardcoreliterature
>>120937156

Thank you, Jessica! Dickens and the holidays are both beautifully connected for me too. I am so happy to know that this is your favourite book of all time! It is truly an incredibly special novel for so many reasons and I’m so excited to read it with you! ☺️

Rashmi

I’m so excited to hear this reveal! I just started the audio book (Simon Callow) about 3 weeks back after finishing Jane Eyre (and wanting another good story). I did not expect this one to be to the bc pick for 2023. It will be my first time reading it but not my first CD book. I will pause and wait for the group to start again… I love how you have seasonal reads, and a mystery Dickens book as well as the Christmas Carol in December, Ben. So looking forward to the communal read! Also, Ben, hearty congratulations on reaching the milestone of 100k YT subscribers! You will soon have millions- you certainly deserve a large audience. :) 🎉

Hazel Sun

This will be the first read of a tale of two cities for me. I read Edwin Drood with the club last year and it was my first Dickens read other than a Christmas Carol which I’ve been rereading annually for years. Then I backed up and read Great Expectations. I loved all of them! So I have no doubt that this year’s seasonal real will be another favorite. Reading Dickens has been truly magical, and yes, this year’s been quite a journey for me, I feel like life keeps knocking me down. So I have been waiting for this announcement and today was the perfect day to do it. 🙂

Constance Stanton

This was the first Dickens novel I read when it was assigned in school. It made such an impression that I went out and read every one of Dickens novels, courtesy of the public library. But this was decades ago and at this point I can’t recall the details of this story. However, the opening paragraph that Ben read and the one he referred to at the end are firmed housed in my memory. This time, I’m going to try to appreciate the literary merits a bit more and not just the plot.

Clare Shepherd

My first edition of Dickens was my uncle's old Chapman and Hall edition in reddish brown buckram. I loved them because I loved both Dickens, the illustrations, and the fact that uncle Bill gifted them to me. I am excited to be rereading The Tale of Two Cities, even though it is not my favourite, but maybe this reread will fix that. Thanks for announcing early Ben, and I look forward to the 2024 schedule.

Chrissy

Hello, Ben! I feel as I’ve not seen you in such a long time ! I’m usually excited about upcoming reads at the HCLBC, but I’m capering about like an organ grinder’s monkey over this one. I didn’t guess the title until you mentioned the Bastille (up until then, my money had been on Oliver Twist (one of Dickens best known books, bought you to tears, etc). Our seasonal read this year will always remind me of my mother, who, although not a great reader (and certainly not a lover of literature) could still recite the opening paragraph, having studied the novel when she was at school in the 1940s. Although this will be a first read for me, I own two different editions. The Chapman & Hall (which I’ve been collecting), and the Penguin. To make it extra special, I’m going to indulge in the former. This is going to be a wonderful experience, and I can hardly wait to begin!

Aubrey Blalock

Which publisher will you read from with the book club? Thx.

Daniel Franya

I've only ever read A Christmas Carol, but as soon as we read War and Peace I just knew this would be the one(I won't spoil for those wanting to be surprised) I tried starting it a few times, but had this itch in my brain saying to wait and I'm glad I did. Very excited to dive in!

Vicky

Oh just read this early last year and still think about it! Will def re read along with you all and will deserve the easy enjoyment after Gravity’s Rainbow (which I am also enjoying having started early but it ain’t easy 😅)

Julie Grimes

I'm not lying (but I am bragging), I figured out the book at minute 3 second 39 when Ben said it made him weep at the end. I've cried somewhere in the middle of every Dickens book, but AToTC is the only one that makes me BAWL at the end. So, obviously not my first read. This might be my fifth? I know I read it twice as a tween/teen and did not like it. I thought it was boring (first read) and too sad (second read). This is why I maintain that marketing Dickens to youth without it being read aloud is a major disservice to Dickens. Irony is lost on children and wounds teens. When I finally came to love Dickens (not until age 25 after several reads), I reread ATofTC and kicked myself at how good it is. I am in love with Sydney, and I disliked him intensely when younger. ¯\_(ツ)_/¯ As I've noted, I read Dickens extensively as a youth and even did Davld Copperfield in grad school (I was only 20) and just hated him. It wasn't until (a much older) friend told me that he read Dickens whenever he was depressed and I demurred "But Dickens is so DEPRESSING!" and he replied, "Really? I think he's hilarious," that I gave him another shot. I guffawed all the way through that David Copperfield I had already given 4 chances. I've gone on to read many many more. Edith Dombey (Dombey and Son) is in the top three of my favorite female characters in literature. If you can, Dickens really should be read aloud. I do not know if there is a more communal author. Seriously, find a friend. Or just read aloud to yourself. So much of the power and humor are lost if you can't actually hear the cadence and rhythm of his prose. Just beware of doing it too well. We used to take turns reading chapters in our home. After Bleak House, I have to read everything because "You do the voices."

Lee Newman

This was the book that lead me to loving Dickens. My 9th grade 1977 introduction to Dickens via Great Expectations was a disaster for me. Not until 1995 reading this book during a divorce broke the negative spell. While I remember the impact I am looking forward to re reading the text with all of you!!

Nadine

I have read seven Dickens novels, including A Tale of Two Cities. I am a huge fan of this book and excited to read it again with this book club!

Anne M

This reveal just put a big smile on my face! I guessed when you began describing the book. I fell in love with Dicken’s in college when I read David Copperfield for a class. I read this one in 1985 so it has been a few years. Very excited for this read!

Lisa Hutchinson

I bought a copy of A Tale of Two Cities weeks ago to round out the French Revolution year that seemed to be shaping up given War & Peace, The Count, (I am reading Les Miserable asynchronously right now) and A Tale seemed to be the perfect round out to this year’s French Revolution exploration. A Russian, a couple of French, and now British authors to explore themes inspired by a war and prevailing cultural shifts that redefined humankind’s relationship with government. I literally cheered out loud, Ben, when you said it was the Dicken’s novel with the most memorable opening line -YES!! I was going to read it regardless- but now I’m so excited to read it alongside you and the Hardcore Literature Book Club co

hardcoreliterature
>>120938335

Beautiful choice of reading Dickens whilst staying in London, Chris. And I can totally understand not loving these two works. I find that there can be quite a range in quality when it comes to his stories and readers can also diverge a bit when it comes to their favourites. I think there’s a strong chance that this year’s choice might improve your relationship with him!

hardcoreliterature
>>120938387

Very nice guess, Kyle :) I know I’d love to discuss both of them. The Pickwick Papers is actually one of my personal favourites. I’m very excited to read this year’s choice with you!

Anonymous

Oh fantastic! I guessed it when you mentioned that the ending made you sob! I've read it twice and can't wait to get started reading this wonderful book with the club, great choice Ben. I'm hoping to read along with the Simon Callow audio!

Kandy Westmoreland

I knew when you said the ending made you weep. It did that to me as well. It is m favorite ending of all books I’ve read. My next favorite ending was. “Frankly Scarlett I don’t give a damn”. I read Tale last year, 2022, along with WAr & Peace, the Count, Jane Eyre and Brothers K. When this years syllabus came out I was a little disappointed. This year was full of rereads and I loved these books better with a second read. I’m sure I will enjoy this reread as well.

Tatiana

Reread. You picked the best one because it was written not long after The Count of Monte Cristo. (Might Dickens have read Dumas?) It is a great period of time to hang out in. And Vive la France! P.S. Ben, you keep blowing up my tsundoku pile with new things I cannot resist.

Leen Verbraken

🤭 This was like opening an early Christmas present! I’m excited to dive into this one. I’ve never read it and I must admit I don’t know what the story is about.. I have a really old Dutch copy (I think early 20th century) with a beautiful cover with a lot of detailed artwork. But it’s falling apart when you open it🥲. I found it years ago, I bought it because the cover was so amazing.. I wanted to read Thomas Pynchon ‘s novel in november, but still making my way through the Count..

hardcoreliterature
>>120938729

That’s so amazing, Matt! You guessed it so quickly! I’m completely with you on the power of the ending. And David Copperfield is a lovely one to have as your entrance Dickens. That one has a special place in my heart because it was one of the very first I read when I got into Dickens as a child. And an 1839 Nicholas Nickleby! Wow. That sounds like it’s a first edition binding of the original instalments. I can understand not wanting to handle it. What an incredible treasure! :)

Kirsti Kårvåg (KrisKringleReads)

Oh, I just bought this book this summer, can’t wait to read it! I read David Copperfield at the start of the year, and LOVED it!

Jason

I had a feeling this would be it with the lingering factoids I had in my head from my perusal of Dickens' wikipedia pages after reading David Copperfield this year. After War & Peace and The Count of Monte Cristo, I had a feeling you'd pick the Dickens that had a link. And the reveal is like a best of times, worst of times thing for me. It was the best of times as I already owned a copy (a 4-in-1 from Grammercy with Great Expectations, Hard Times, a Christmas Carol, and this), but it was also the worst of times because my excuse for going to the book store today became a little flimsier. Maybe I'll go anyway!

hardcoreliterature
>>120938889

That is such an exciting package to have turn up, Maria! I can’t wait to enjoy this great book with you and hear what you make of it :)

Mathew Morrison
>>120938729

I think it might be one of the first 'complete' editions! I believe the date is September or October of 1839. I do keep it in a special place, under a little plexiglass box, along with a small wooden cross my father made from wood from my late grandfather's childhood home (probably more info than necessary, but just to highlight the place of honor it has). I can't wait to see how everyone else reacts to this novel!

William Califf

Looking forward to reading this, my previous experience with Tale of Two Cities is a heavily abridged version in grade school and the Wishbone series (which I’m sure many of my fellow readers in the U.S. will be familiar). I am also looking forward to reading a Christmas Carol. One of my families traditions on Christmas Eve is to watch the George C Scott version of A Christmas Carol so I look forward to adding a reading to that as well.

Erika Kozlowski

I'm so excited! I have the Folio Society version - can't wait to reread!!!

Leia Smith
>>120941000

I was hoping this would be the Dickens for exactly that reason! I am so excited to read it with the club.

Ruth Kenny

I haven't read this one by Dickens, but when you said it had one of the most famous opening lines in fiction, I knew it! Looking forward to the read-a-long; as always Ben, you bring to life every book that you discuss.

AB

YAY!!! ToTC was my very first guess and I knew it for sure when you said CD wanted to act as the hero. My knee jerk thought was, Which hero? But 🤐. My first time reading back in high school, I loved the romance. College reading with a French major, I loved the historical aspect. Last six or seven times as an adult, I still love both those and so much more.

AB
>>120938962

I agree. I think hormones make so much marshmallow fluff of our adolescent brains that the good stuff you have to think about doesn’t stand much of a chance! 😆😆

Kristen Egener Chaddah

Perfect timing! I was just thinking today, as a matter of fact, I wonder when Ben is going to announce our seasonal Dickens read. And, lo and behold, up popped your video. I’m excited! I feel I am on a roll and in rhythm with the book club. It’s a lovely feeling. I’ve had to let Invisible Man go for now, but it was a wise decision, as I couldn’t have read it and Jane Eyre both by this time. I’ve finished Jane, which I absolutely adored on a second read. The novel has been a comfort to me this month with the horror unfolding in the Middle East. I can say I have personally experienced the Falstaff effect. Onward now with Dickens. Yay!

Tory

Dickens. Those would be the books that I approach and then find myself backing away from largely because of the size and the complexity of the language involved. Lately, I've been reading H. P. Lovecraft and taking the time to investigate words and concepts and individuals rather than just skim past. It helped. So, having had that experience, I am now fortified and matured enough as a reader to make the attempt again. I think that's part of why I joined this group -- to experience the book with others who can help me over the rough spots and show me what I've been missing.

Munchin S

Originally I thought Copperfield but once I heard the line about most famous opening I got it. I read it many years ago and loved it. Excited to re-read. Strangely I only remember Carton. The female lead did not stay with me. I cannot tell you anything of note she did so I'm excited to re-visit all of these characters and explore the book with others.

Jan Mariolle

Wahoo!!! This Dickens story fits perfectly into the Napoleonic era we have been dipping into. I’ve been reading Patrick O’ Brian’s Aubrey/Maturin series centered on the British Navy. I am thrilled to be reading this story with the bookclub as there are always so many exciting points of view, beginning of course, with Ben’s lectures. While I’ve read most of Dickens novels, this one will be a first time experience. I attempted it many years ago and dropped off too early. I am so happy that this book is our surprise! Thank you!❤️

Nigel Burmester

I'm very excited about this choice of Dickens for the seasonal read. I've only read a few of his books and this is one of them. I absolutely loved my previous reads. I was totally pulled into the story both from a historical interest and the characters and plot line is just fantastic. I'm so happy to do this reread with the HLBC. To read it more in-depth than before, and I'm sure to grow to appreciation it even more. I would like to get through all of Dickens in my lifetime, although that seems like a tall order. I've read maybe four or five at this point. His character's stay with me long after many of the details of the novels are forgotten. My wife and I are currently listening to Barbara Kingsolver's Pulitzer Prize winning Demon Copperhead which is a modern, Appalachian retelling of David Copperfield and we are constantly find ourselves comparing the characters and story line to the original.

Eluisa Brunetto

I guessed it when Ben said that Charles Dickens would have wanted to play the main character of his novel. When he mentioned the iconic opening, I was pretty sure it was A Tale of Two Cities. I read it about 2 or 3 years ago and loved it. It is one of my favorite works from Dickens. I'm looking forward to rereading it especially with Ben's guidance which always makes every book so much more enjoyable. I love Charles Dickens. He is one ofy favorite authors.

Karen Bird

This is a reread for me. I last read it in High School, so I need to revisit it, to see what I will think this time, because it didn't impact me at the time. Great Expectations and Bleak House blew me away. I do love the opening and closing paragraphs of this book. I am not sure there are any better in all of literature. I have reread these multiple times.

Margie

I love Dickens and I love A Tale of Two Cities. I already have my copy that I have read 3 times. Now I will read it again with all of you. I am excited.

Tiffany

Oh I feel so stupid. At 5:00 I was convinced it was Great Expectations and then at 8:30 decided it was Oliver Twist. A Tale of Two Cities is one of the two Dickens novels I *have* read, but it's been at least 10 years and I didn't do a close reading.

Andrew Kiepek

This will be my first formal Dickens read. I attempted this novel in 7th grade for English class and couldn’t get past the first 20 pages. I’m excited to see how I’ve grown as a person and a reader in the decade since. I’m excited to dive into this one; Dickens seems to be an especially enjoyable author.

Kevin Kilroy

I’m looking forward to reading Tale of Two Cities. I’ve never read it. All I know of it is the opening, the ending and there’s a character who knits a lot (I think). Love a Christmas Carol and try to read that ever holiday season. Years ago I saw Patrick Stewart perform a one man show of a Christmas Carol on Broadway. Absolutely amazing and really gave me an appreciation for how well written that story is.

Juanita Boutwell

I read an abridged version of this about thirty years ago and liked it. I have just in the past two years fallen in love with Dickens and have finished off Great Expectations, Oliver Twist and am currently reading Bleak House. I'm excited to be re-reading the 2023 book, it was on my short list for which Dickens to read next. I agree with the comment posted by "Munchen S" - I remember Carton and that there was another male character that was important, but not the female character at all.

Josh LaMar, He-Him

I guessed at the 7 min mark. It was the train travel …. I purchased a copy when I visited Dickens’ house in London earlier this year, excited to finally read this one. I also picked up a stack of other books at the same time :) Since I live in Paris, it’s great to be able to visit the locations and revisit the Musée Carnavalet-the history of the city of Paris-to follow the history. Happy to do a book club field trip should any of you find yourselves here in Paris as well.

Kathleen Kelly

First time read for me! Serendipitously, I happened to pick this novel up in a used bookstore not long ago! 🍀

Glamaris Cohen

I didn’t guess it until almost the end…. I’m a relative newcomer to Dickens, so I didn’t know any clues really; I only thought I knew when Ben said it had one of the most famous beginning lines. I am so excited to read this book for the first time with this group!!! I’ve only read Great Expectations, David Copperfield, The Mystery of Edwin Drood and A Christmas Carol so far, and was hoping the seasonal read would be ones I’ve had on my very long “want to read” list. I can’t wait to get my copy! Let’s do this!!

Jenny

I remember reading Edwin Drood as a teenager and being very disappointed that there was no ending as CD had died before finishing it. I haven’t read any other Dickens books so this will be a first read. I’ve seen numerous Christmas Carol films over the years so I’m looking forward to reading this and ToTC with the book club.

Cai Vail

I’m ashamed to say that this will be my very first Dickens apart from A Christmas Carol. Gasp! I know, who do I think I am calling myself a reader? I watched an adaptation of Little Dorritt a while back and felt like…perhaps Dickens was a bit too twee or goofy for my liking? But I’m sure I just haven’t given him a proper chance. A lot of people consider Les Mis to be over the top and it ended up being one of my favorite reads ever, so I’ll keep an open mind. I’m excited to dive in with all of you, and truly it’s a perfect cap on this year that has been packed with French Revolution and post-Revolution era stories. Your joy and love for Dickens is encouraging, Ben! And, I am on the edge of my seat in anticipation over the announcement of next years’ schedule. I can tell by your excitement that it’s going to be good :)

Jonathon Glover

Merry Dickens everyone!! Wow! This post has exploded with activity. Lots of excited Dickens fans out there. This is a first time read for me. I have only ever read Great Expectations and Christmas Carol, and they were both in the last year. So I am coming in with fresh eyes and a relative naivety for Dickens. Looking forward to discussing it with everyone! 🎄

Thomas C

Looking forward to finishing this book. Your clue about iconic openings gave it away, but I must admit I never finished this school reading assignment. Looking forward to this particularly after my current reads of this era.

Emily White

This will be a first time read for me. I've previously read Hard Times, Great Expectations, & David Copperfield and loved them all, though Great Expectations is probably my favourite so far. I'm from Portsmouth so Charles Dickens has been very much part of my life as he is someone our city is very proud of (even though he only lived here for the first few years of his life). I feel I know next to nothing about a Tale of Two Cities apart from it being set during the French Revolution. I haven't even seen a fim or TV adaption of it so I am really looking forward to reading it.

Randy

I remember trying to read this as a teenager and the only memory I have is thinking, "he just compares things over and over - how boring!" Now that I have a much deeper understanding of literature, writing, and reading, I can't wait to give this another attempt.

Bethany Thompson

PERFECT TIMING! I’m discussing this book in the spring with my 10th graders :) I read this in my 12th grade year and remember staying up late into the night to finish it - I will never forget its effect. I sobbed myself to sleep! It’s unforgettable!

Cindy Hayes

YES,YES,YES! My favorite book of all time by my Favorite author of all time. I was watching this video with bated breath and the minute you gave the first clue I started cheering. My husband thought I was nuts. I love this book and read it at least once a year. I finished it most recently in the spring right after War and Peace. I love Dickens and have read a little over half his works since he is my special writer. Tale of Two Cities in my opinion is genius. It is serious and mysterious, historical and romantic and even in some places humorous. The language is so beautiful that no one else could have written it but Charles Dickens. Thanks Ben. What a perfect Christmas gift!

Erica Solomon
>>120948427

A book club field trip would be fun. I live in the United States. As such, I’m unable to take you up on your offer. But I hope others who will be in Paris do.

Cindy Hayes
>>120949831

Do not be ashamed that you have not read this, be excited. You get to experience for the first time. In many ways I am jealous.

Erica Solomon

This will be my first reading of Dickens. I’m excited.

Penelope Gough

That was exciting! I didn’t guess till the 18min mark. I have read a lot of Dickens and my favourite is probably The Pickwick Papers followed by Hard Times although Great expectations …… actually many favourites. Recently reread David Copperfield because of the Demon Copperhead read. But have never read this one. When I was in primary school we had films on a Friday afternoon. That was one of the films shown and it terrified me. My mother was quite unsympathetic when I started to be fussed about going to bed at night. All I can remember now is a carriage roaring through the streets and possibly running someone over? I’ll be interested to identify that part. I was about 10 at the time so maybe understandable. I did once win a trivia prize for my team by being able to identify the opening lines. I cannot wait to start this read. Thanks Ben..

Carol Keller

I had my fingers crossed for this one but wasn’t absolutely sure until you said it was the most famous opening. I’m very excited for this first reread since high school when I really did love it. Other than Christmas Carol, I’ve never gotten through another Dickens. Maybe this will be my gateway drug to more! Looking forward to it!

Anonymous

Great! I read this once before and loved it. Can you recommend an audiobook?

Joan Wilson

This will be a reread. The first time was high school; my experience wasn’t great. I’m confident this reading will be better. I guessed correctly when Ben mentioned the famous opening lines. I’m looking forward to reading with the group. This entire year has been delightful and rewarding.

Andy Workman

I read this for the first time about 2 years ago. I am looking forward to revisting Madam Defarge. I am always puzzled how she never makes it onto lists of "worst literary villians."

Adrienne

So looking forward to this read. I visited both London and Paris for the first time this past summer and I love historical fiction so I am very excited. I have read a couple of Dickens' novels but this one is new for me. Headed to my local bookstore next weekend to get my copy.

Jane

Yes ! I guessed it a few weeks ago :) how did that happen ? I just had a feeling I suppose. It could be wishful thinking as this is one of my all time favourites and not my first read. Just to say how excited I am about rereading it here with the group. I saw a stage adaptation a few years ago in the UK and it was brilliant ! This novel has me in tears at the beginning and sobbing at the end but… it truly is a gift of sheer joy. This is the time of year when I start travelling around but of my three different copies I m taking the brand new one with me that I ordered a few weeks ago only. Crazy. Oh my heart :) another revelation the 2024 reads. Congratulations to Ben on reaching 100,000 you deserve it you have brought literature to so many people and at such a high standard thank you .

Sharon

I've been so swamped with college and art course homework that I recently reluctantly decided to let my HLBC membership lapse for a month or two until I can catch a breath. Ben, I've been a member long enough to know that November is your 2024 book schedule announcement month, as confirmed in this video. After watching this video, I suddenly had a serious case of FOMO so I decided to continue with everyone, if only to be a silent fly on the wall for a bit. I have my eye on two novels for 2024 that I'm 99.9% certain that you're going to announce and I'm thrilled that they're already in my library. As for A Tale of Two Cities, I've been collecting the Everyman's Library set of Dickens' novels, and darn it, I never purchased that one. (I'm also admitting that I was wrong...I thought you would select Pickwick Papers for the Secret Dickens!) Thanks for the advance notice, especially because there's a long delivery time in the U.S. for the Everyman's Library edition. Again, please know that I'm very [im]patiently waiting for your 2024 announcement video...I'm just hoping you won't keep us waiting until the end of November for your big reveal!

Serena

Finally, we get to Dickens. I’ve been waiting for this. When you said iconic first and last lines, I said “A Tale of Two Cities.” I’m delighted. Memories of romance, betrayal, riots, streets blocked off in Paris, blood on the cobblestones, and those old women wielding their frightful knitting needles are settled in my everlasting neurological brain circuitry, even after my first reading over thirty years ago. It will be fun to get your take on this great book. I anticipate hearing your lectures on Dickens with great pleasure. It’s almost like waiting for the next installment of a Dickens' book. I’m ordering the Penguin hard copy tonight.

Yoknapatawpha

I had guessed in January at outset of HLBC with reading of War and Peace and Count of Monte Cristo that the Dickens would be Tale of Two Cities. Ding ding ding. I have finished my slog through Monte Cristo (ugh). I'm behind on reading but Paradise Lost and Invisible Man will be re-reads, and I think Jane Eyre will be a dash-off. Not so Gravity's Rainbow.... a book I started a couple of years ago but abandoned after 80 or so pages. I will slog thru this one too if it kills me. And complete Dickens before 12/31/2023 at 11:59pm. There!

Ann Lowe

I smugly state that I guessed this after War & Peace. I thought the French war would fit perfectly. Charles Dickens is my special author this year. I had read this book when I was in high school. I was the last of 4 kids and I heard my mother reading and explaining how wonderful the first and last lines of the novel were. She had memorized the lines. I just finished this book a few weeks ago, and I had read it previously. It’s a great book. I think a surprise Dickens at the end of the year is such a fun present. I’m dying to know the reading schedule for next year. Congratulations on reaching 100,000 Ben! So well deserved. I’m always telling people about the HCLBC.

Kristen Egener Chaddah
>>120957635

Good for you! I found The Count of Monte Cristo a slog too, but I kept reading to the end. There is satisfaction in completion 🥲

Kristen Egener Chaddah
>>120949848

Merry Dickens to you! I’m enjoying reading the comments. You’re right! An explosion! This excitement and anticipation is infectious!

tara williams

Very excited to read this novel for the first time with everyone. My family reads the Christmas Carol every Christmas and Great Expectations, which I loved, is the only other Dickens I've read. I also can't wait to hear the schedule for next year!

R.R. Scott

What a great announcement! ATOTC is a perfect fit for this year. Not just because of the novels you've selected to precede it over the past several months, but because we are all living in a state of intense political tension and conflict at home and abroad. This is not just a reference to the awful wars unfolding, but also to the tense class struggles that exist across a variety of social movements. Slipping into this novel, like slipping into A Christmas Carol over the holiday season, feels like a proper fictional compliment to what is "in the air" right now. While the novel's historical setting is not an exact mirror of our world today, I do sense that it can be explored as a redressing of the hopes and fears and the trials and tribulations that exist currently. Now, I say this not having read the novel for more than a decade, so I am excited to return to it and and explore it with a more mature eye (one honed by the experiences of this club). I believe this was my second or third Dickens novel. I fell headlong into the bicentenary celebration of Dickens in 2012, absorbing a number of biographies and, of course, some of his novels and other writings. Pickwick was first, which probably is not a typical nor recommended first exposure to Dickens' longer works (though I did enjoy it and kept going!). I enjoyed my first reading of ATOTC, though looking back on it I recognize I did it with more of a flourish for "literary accomplishment" without fully appreciating the text. I am certain that the lectures to come will improve my experience with the novel. As for film adaptations I've not seen any of this book, aside from The Dark Knight Rises which is a more loose interpretation, but when I have watched Dickens on film, I've found that the BBC serials from the 2000s have been excellent by all metrics used to measure these things. Is there one from that period for ATOTC? I'll being going to check as soon as I post this! All that said, for any one new to Dickens, as I was when I first read this, it is an easy novel to slip into, as it moves quickly and, from what I recall, has a much more slim and modern feeling than some of the others. While I did not guess this would be the Dickens novel for this reading year (for some reason David Copperfield kept chiming in my head), I am excited to return and explore this novel as a more mature reader and against the backdrop of our grave new world. --- Ryan

Serena Kirby

This will be my first read of ATOTC, and I'm very excited. The only other Dickens I've read so far are Great Expectations, which I thought was just okay, and David Copperfield which I loved.

Latona

This was very exciting :) I loved the reveal and only guessed it when you mentioned the historical aspect, Ben. I haven't read it before but I am, of course, familiar with the beginning. I'm really looking forward to this one (and to catching up with the other reads :)) Have a great day, everyone!

Elizabeth Madden

I have always loved History and since studying the French Revolution for my O levels over fifty years ago, I have been fascinated by that period, so I first read ATOTC as a complement to my studies. I haven't read it since, but I can still remember specific scenes and, of course, the memorable opening and closing lines. I always enjoy reading Dickens, even though his style can sometimes feel a bit overblown and melodramatic, but this should be an interesting revisit.

Caroline P
>>120937156

Haha, Jessica, I loved how your comments here ran.. how brilliant that it was the book you hoped for. Isn’t this reading going to be fun!

Rainier traveler

Not only with this be my first read through of the book this will also be my first read of Dickens ever. Wow excited to read this one with you all!

Dermot Dunne

Wonderful! I guessed when you mentioned the iconic opening but earlier when you talked about Dickens travelling between Paris and London I had an inkling. I read it for the first time just a few years ago so I'm looking forward to re-reading it now. I love the theatrical (or even cinematic) way he creates a sense of location and staging for the various scenes and also the special bond between the characters of the story. Happy reading everyone!

hardcoreliterature
>>120938962

I've also really been marvelling over the years at how much I appreciate the books I didn't like in high school. They really do put some incredible works on the syllabuses, but they only become truly resonant with age and lived experience :)

hardcoreliterature
>>120939071

Thank you, Leslie! I'm am so thrilled that you were hoping for this one :) It's going to be such a wonderful experience reading it with you all!

hardcoreliterature
>>120939168

I'm so thrilled to hear that, Jeff! I cannot wait to hear what you make of your fifth reading of this incredible novel. It's a really special one, and I think it will always show us something new on each reread :)

hardcoreliterature
>>120939398

Thank you very much, Catherine! :) I'm so happy you're excited for this one too! I'll also be very keen to know what resonates with you this time around. I definitely think this is a story that shows us something new at different stages in our lives!

Tatiana
>>120957635

Are you still considering a Faulkner project next year? I have a copy of Absalom, Absolom, which I have never read, ready to go, but it has to wait till after Gravity's Rainbow, which will be an all in effort.

hardcoreliterature
>>120939486

I'm so excited to hear what you make of your first read, Tena! I think this is a really great one to get started with when it comes to Dickens :)

hardcoreliterature
>>120939518

I'm very excited to hear what you make of your second read, Brian. I think that ten-year period will have a profound effect on the story!

hardcoreliterature
>>120939547

Thank you, Susan! It was so much fun reading Edwin Drood with you :) I can't wait to hear what you make of your first reading of this year's choice!

hardcoreliterature
>>120939796

That's so incredible that you guessed the novel immediately, Debra! I love the story you have attached to your copy of the book. I'm tremendously excited to hear what you make of your reread!

hardcoreliterature
>>120939890

The Old Curiosity Shop is another one that I'm aching to discuss because I actually just finished a reread of it :) This was one of the first ones I read so it has a lot of special meaning for me. I can't wait to reread this year's choice and hear your thoughts on it, Caroline. I'm loving the excitement everyone has for it!

hardcoreliterature
>>120939959

Aw, thank you so much, Rashmi! I really appreciate that tremendously :) I must say it felt a little bit surreal having one of those silver play buttons turn up! And I'm so happy that you're excited for this year's Dickens. I'm very keen to hear what you make of your first reading of this one. Incredible serendipity that you chose to start listening to the Simon Callow audiobook a few weeks back! ☺️

Nancy Fitzpatrick

Did you say which edition you'll be using in your lectures? I'm finding it meaningful to follow along when you're reading excerpts. I last read ATOTC in high school 70 years ago! And just came back to Dickens during the pandemic, when I relished David Copperfield. I was stunned at how much I enjoyed it. I'm very impressed with how much he's influenced contemporary writers such as Diana Gabaldon. (I confess her Outlander story got me back into reading and not fearing big books.)

Elizabeth Madden
>>120969012

Yes, I agree, Dermot. As a theatre buff, I love the theatrical aspects of Dickens's writing style and his creation of memorable characters. I can still remember the awful Mme. Deforges sitting knitting beneath the guillotine from over 50 years ago when I last read this book.

Ms P

I guessed it the moment you mentioned the opening. I've been meaning to read it for a long time, and have a Kindle copy ready to go. I hope I'll be able to hop along - I'm still only 1/4 through Invisible Man and finished Book IV of Paradise Lost. At least I won't feel bad about not joining in with Gravity's Rainbow, because I've read that one!

Mo Simpson

This was my first Dickens. It’s been 50 years since I sat in a classroom sketching the characters as the teacher lectured. As a young teen I hadn’t read anything like it! I was mesmerized. My son still has that copy with a few sketches between the pages. I’m so looking forward to revisiting this after so much living and reading. Perhaps I’ve learned a few things since then. I’ll file this read under “Best of Times”. Happy holidays, everyone!

Brittany

I am so excited to be reading this in the bookclub! It's my favorite book of all time, so a re-read for me, but I'm not sure how many times:) I usually read at least parts of it every year. I got tricked earlier on in the video with the word friend being mentioned so much, so I thought it was Our Mutual Friend until you said the part about the beginning and end. I am a huge fan of Dickens. I read ATOTC for the first time in 8th grade and loved it so much that I've read as many of his other books that I have time for. My current favorites are ATOTC, Our Mutual Friend, and Little Dorrit.

Yoknapatawpha
>>120957635

Tatiana, yes still thinking about Faulkner minigroup starting January. Absalom, Absalom-- as much as I admire it-- is a tough place to start Faulkner though. We will likely start with a more tractable work such as As I Lay Dying or Light in August. Have you worked with a minigroup before? Perhaps you can help me understand the mechanics of how such a group could work?

hardcoreliterature
>>120940053

It's very exciting to hear that this will be a first read for you, Hazel :) I would love to know how you feel this one stacks up against Edwin Drood and Great Expectations. It sounds like you've had a real tough year to contend with, so I really hope Dickens is able to offer some restoration and comfort for you. I personally don't know where I would be if it wasn't for the novels of Dickens, and the plays of Shakespeare, when life is most difficult 🙏

hardcoreliterature
>>120940074

That is such an amazing story, Constance! What a powerful entrance to Dickens :) I love that this one motivated you to read every single one of his works. I can't wait to hear your thoughts upon returning to such a special novel!

hardcoreliterature
>>120940130

What beautiful bookish treasures you have, Clare! The Chapman & Hall editions are gorgeous. I’m obsessed with the illustrations in my facsimile versions. I can’t wait to read this great novel with you :)

Cindy Hayes
>>120975524

I love that your son has your old copy. What an awesome gift to share with him. Maybe he can read it with you.

Rashmi
>>120955258

Ben mentioned the one narrated by Simon Callow which I have as well. He’s great! :)

hardcoreliterature
>>120940143

I'm so happy that you're so excited for this one too, Chrissy. It's so lovely that this was such a special one for your mother. And how marvellous that you are collecting the Chapman & Hall editions. They're amazing, aren't they? The facsimile editions are some of my favourite books in my collection. I love just taking down a random one and poring over those illustrations :)

hardcoreliterature
>>120940543

That's amazing that you guessed it from our reading of War and Peace, Daniel! Your inner voice gave you some superb advice there :) I can't wait to hear what you make of it!

David Campbell

Before this reveal, I was guessing that this year’s Dickens might be Oliver Twist or the Pickwick Papers. Once Ben mentioned this one had one of the most famous openings I figured it was Tale of Two Cities. My first read of Dickens was only last winter, and at that time I read A Tale of Two Cities and A Christmas Carol. Since then I have also read Great Expectations and I started reading Bleak House (I was trying to read I according to the original serialization schedule, but found it too difficult to stay engaged with the book while only reading 2-3 chapters a month - I’ve decided for the moment that I don’t think serialized reading works for me). The past year has really been the start of me re-engaging with reading literature (also coming up on a year with the book club). I am excited about re-reading A Tale of Two Cities as it will be a good marker for how I have grown as a reader over the past year. I am also looking forward to reading as a group experience this time around.

hardcoreliterature
>>120940729

I can't wait to hear your thoughts on this great novel, Vicky :) I'm so happy to hear that you're enjoying Gravity's Rainbow. It's definitely an incredibly challenging one, but there are definitely a lot of rewards there. Once you break into it, it can become a tremendously fun read!

hardcoreliterature
>>120940832

That's so awesome you got it immediately, Julie! I feel the same way about Dickens and the ending of this one. It usually takes quite a bit for me to choke up from a book, but this one just destroys me every time. I also had the same shifting relationship to Sydney as you. Dickens definitely 100% benefits from reading aloud and also some lived experience. Along with Austen, I've found my appreciation of his work today vs when I was younger is on a whole new level. Irony is so difficult to apprehend and a lot of his humour went over my head when I was younger. I was fortunate to have a teacher for Great Expectations who read/performance the entire novel aloud to us over the year and he had the whole class in stitches :)

Rashmi
>>120939959

You certainly deserve every accolade. Please show us the silver play button award in a video soon- I’m not familiar with it and would love to share in your celebration. :) 🎊

Jessica
>>120937156

Thanks Caroline! The book I hoped for was Bleak House. The book I couldn't bring myself to hope for was ToTC. Didn't know life could get THIS good. :)

Jessica
>>120937156

I mean, War and Peace and this masterpiece in the SAME year. Is this heaven?

hardcoreliterature
>>120940849

Wow. It sounds like this one came at an incredibly challenging time in your life, Lee. I'm really looking forward to hearing what you make of it this time around!

Jim P.

Excited as well to have this as my December read! I remember trying to read this when younger and just could not get excited enough to continue. Love the encouragement by Benjamin to persevere, will definitely do this time. Thanks Benjamin!

Jeffrey
>>120957635

Hello Yoknapatawpha. I’m interested if you do something with Faulkner. Feel free to direct message me on Patreon (if that’s possible?) once you have the details. Thanks!

hardcoreliterature
>>120941000

That's incredible, Lisa! It definitely does round out our exploration beautifully. And Dickens has an enormous amount to add to the discussion. I love getting these writers talking with each other. We can put Dickens, Tolstoy, Dumas, and Hugo in conversation with each other :) I'm thrilled that you're excited and I can't wait to discuss this great book with you!

hardcoreliterature
>>120941668

That's so awesome you got it right away, Kandy! I'm glad I'm not alone in the ending making me weep. I feel exactly the same way about loving books more on the reread. At this point, I actually enjoy rereading to reading something new. I can't wait to hear your thoughts on this one!

Ellen M

It’s been soooo long since I read this that it will be like a first time read, but I know I loved it (and remember being so creeped out by the Madame and her knitting needles !) Ben, I appreciate the reminder to browse in a book store, choose a copy that speaks to me - or take the time to simply enjoy being in my favorite book store. I’m guilty of the one click purchase or ten second download from my library. I’ll consciously be remembering that browsing my local indie bookstore is one of my favorite things to do

hardcoreliterature
>>120941735

Thank you, Tatiana! I'm so excited to hear your thoughts upon rereading this great novel :) I believe Victor Hugo introduced him to Dumas in 1847. I feel like he must have read his work! What a time for lovers of literature. Also, the word tsundoku is simply superb. I relate to having such a pile!

hardcoreliterature
>>120941856

I'm so thrilled to hear that, Leen :) I cannot wait to hear what you make of your first reading. Try to keep yourself protected from spoilers! Nice one on continuing through the The Count of Monte Cristo. I must say, I really do miss Edmond Dantès. I'm already looking forward to reading it all over again!

hardcoreliterature
>>120942423

Wow! That's fantastic that you got it from Tolstoy and Dumas' great novels being on the schedule, Jason. Your feeling was right :) I do love having a good link between works. I can't wait to hear what you make of this one!

hardcoreliterature
>>120942746

I'm very excited to read this great work with you, William :) I love your family's tradition. That's beautiful. I have a little Christmas Eve tradition that involves reading A Christmas Carol and watching It's a Wonderful Life. I'll have to add the George C. Scott film into the tradition!

hardcoreliterature
>>120943080

Aw, thank you so much, Ruth. That is so lovely of you :) I can't wait to read this one with you and hear what you make of it!

Leen Verbraken
>>120941856

I got till chapter 31 this summer, read some other books in between and started all over again … And didn’t regret it: it’s an impressive story with great characters.. one you can read over and over again.

Lora Mantelman

A Tale of Two Cities, along with the upcoming Hamlet!? Are we the luckiest ones or what. Thanks for all you do for us Benjamin. My cup runneth over.

hardcoreliterature
>>120943145

That's amazing you got it on your very first guess, Andrea! I can't wait to hear your thoughts as we move through this fantastic work together :)

hardcoreliterature
>>120975021

I'll personally be working from the Penguin paperback edition :) How wonderful that you came back to Dickens during the pandemic! I found him to be a huge comfort over lockdown. I can't wait to hear your thoughts on this great work, Nancy.

hardcoreliterature
>>120943490

I love the synchronicity there, Kristen! It definitely sounds like you're in a fantastic rhythm with the book club. I'm happy to hear that your reread of Jane Eyre has been such a comfort to you. I know exactly what you mean. Charlotte Brontë definitely has the power to cure just like Shakespeare and Dickens!

hardcoreliterature
>>120944121

Your engagement with H. P. Lovecraft is superb, Tory! It sounds like you're really bringing a lot of focus and love to his works :) I'm excited to hear what you make of Dickens' novel. We'll definitely be able to crowdsource some meaning as we appreciate him together!

hardcoreliterature
>>120944536

David Copperfield is another one that I would personally love to discuss :) I'm very excited to hear what you make of your reread of this one, Munchin!

hardcoreliterature
>>120945499

I've been making my way through Patrick O’Brian’s superb Aubrey-Maturin series too, Jan. Fantastic books :) And I can't wait to hear what you make of your first reading of this Dickens novel! ☺️🙏

hardcoreliterature
>>120945516

I love your goal of getting through Dickens in your lifetime, Nigel. That's a very exciting reading project. You're a quarter of the way there :) His characters really stay with me too. Like with Shakespeare, when I think of a specific Dickens novel it feels like I'm recalling a memory of real events and characters feel like old friends. I'm very excited to reread this year's choice with you!

hardcoreliterature
>>120947156

Nice one on guessing it, Eluisa! I'm so excited to read this one with you :) It sounds like this a very special one for you!

Cindy Hayes
>>120948427

I love Paris. I will be there in June with a cruise group. I wish I had time to meet you and see the city with a native who loves reading. We will do a quick driving tour of the city followed by a dinner cruise down the Seine. You have one of the most beautiful cities in the world.

Kristen Egener Chaddah
>>120994190

Me too! I appreciated that reminder too. I followed up with a visit to my local second hand book store (before clicking). They did not have S Tale of Two Cities but did have A Christmas Carol complete and unabridged, so I did not go away empty handed. Cost me $2.50 😁

Josh LaMar, He-Him
>>120948427

I agree!!! I’m actually American but I’ve lived here for almost 5 years now :) Hope you have a great trip!!!

Clare Shepherd
>>120940130

I xan't wait either, but my old Chapmans are a lille fragile now znd the print is smallish, so I will probably read my Folio Society ones, or get a Penguin copy.

Mavis Kim

My first Dickens read was Great Expectations freshman year in high school and I hated it, hardly remember anything about it. I think a major turning point for me was a Shakespeare class I took in college, favorite class ever, and then I started to seek out the classics. In my 20s I read David Copperfield, A Tale of Two Cities, and Bleak House. Loved them all, but went through them so fast that I skimmed over what I couldn’t understand and didn’t stop to think about what it was about them that I loved. That is why finding this treasure of a book club last month was such a blessing. I don’t have any people in my life I can talk about great books with or who can understand how fun and exciting it is to have a secret Dickens read revealed! Now I am a 50ish empty nester who’s rediscovering my old love of reading/re-reading, and you can be sure that I will be re-visiting Great Expections with great expections!

Mavis Kim
>>120994190

I am looking forward to picking up a new copy of A Tale of Two Cities too. My current copy is a very small Bantam Classics paperback version from 30 yrs ago when I first read it. Nostalgic, but not very comfortable to hold while reading and definitely no room for marginalia!

Susan Knox
>>120956470

Cookie, I guessed at the same point as you. My reading experience mirrors yours as well, except my first read was almost 40 years ago. Whenever my dad came upon my mom lost in her knitting he would call her Madame DaFarge (sp?) I have only read 4 Dickens - this one, Great Expectations, last yrs read, and A Christmas Carol. I thought this was going to be Our Mutual Friend bc of the number of times “friend” was used. 😄

AB
>>120942746

Wishbone! 😆😍😆🐶 Lovely reminder there!

Ruth Kenny
>>120943080

15 pages a day is an achievable target. Looking forward to the lectures 😊

Ruth Kenny
>>120939890

I thought it was going to be The Old Curiosity Shop, right at the start, before I heard Ben talking about ATOTC.

mariah schneider

I haven't read anything by Dickens, though I've seen plenty of adaptations. I'm hoping that we will get to Bleak House at some point, but I will probably pick it up sometime next year regardless. I'm looking forward to venturing into Dickens' world. I'm also excited about the upcoming release of next years book list.

Patrick O'Connor

I love this story. It is quoted in my favorite Star Trek movie. I also saw the movie in HS. I just never read it until 2022. I wished I had sooner. After reading it I wanted to find some discussion on the story and that is how I came across the Hardcore Literature Book Club. I had a feeling all year it would be this Dickens based on the reads we had. It is an amazing historical drama and I look forward to reading it again.

Yoknapatawpha
>>120957635

Hello Jeffrey. I certainly will try. I'm relatively new to Patreon and HLBC and am trying to figure out how to organize a "deep-dive mini group" focused on an author outside of the Book Club reading list and Ben's talks.

Dan

I’m very excited about this Dickens read . First, after being a lover of non-fiction throughout my whole adulthood, I intentionally set out to engage with fiction during the pandemic. I found a beautiful old copy of Tale of Two Cities in a Little Free Library and it was the first piece of classic literature I’d chosen to read and an adult. I LOVED IT. I fell in love with the Characters and was shocked at how approachable it was. Second, this will be the first read I’m doing “live” with this community. I joined last week after discovering Ben’s intro to War and Peace on YouTube and am currently reading that and working through the Shakespeare project over the course of the next year. Im excited to be a part of the regular discussions live with the group.

Jessica

I have been a silent but enthusiastic member of the bookclub for about a year now. And I have been eagerly awaiting the Dickens seasonal read announcement. A Tale of Two Cities is a re-read for me…and I am sorry to say my least favorite Dickens - however, that first reading was while I was in school. I have a wonderful feeling I am going to enjoy this second read immensely! Agree with others saying they guessed Oliver Twist or The Pickwick Papers for this year, I was convinced it was down to those two!

Mike DiMartino

I read my first two Dickens books last fall/winter—Christmas Carol and David Copperfield. Really enjoyed them so I’m looking forward to reading this novel! Thanks as always Ben for the great intros and lectures.

Libby West

Hi Everyone. I don't get to engage as much as I'd like to with the reading you are all doing but I keep trying. Last year I started Edwin Drood but severe weather forced me out of where I was living and I no longer had the time to finish it. This year I will try again! I'm guessing (hoping) that it's A Tale of Two Cities. Mostly because at about time stamp 7:16 you're talking about Dickens life moving back and forth from London to Paris. And that's exactly how that famous first paragraph starts off the whole book.....that wonderful back and forth rhythmic pendulum swing of descriptors. I don't ever get tired of reading that first paragraph. This year, I hope I finish the whole story. Thank you Ben for all your good work.

Kari Y

This was my first Dickens. I read it…decades ago, and I don’t remember everything that happened in the story, but I’ll never forget how it moved me. I guessed this might be the secret Dickens based on War & Peace and Count of Monte Cristo, and I was sure within the first few minutes of Benjamin’s introduction. I’m looking forward to reading it again all of these later, and I expect the effect it will have on me will be even more profound this time around.

Caroline P

Hello, my new edition of The Tale of Two Cities arrived today… just as I found my old one (tut) . But I am going to struggle to hold back on this.. all I want to do is get the fire burning, settle down and read until it is done

Kristen Egener Chaddah

I started listening to the audible Tale Of Two Cities with Simon Callow reading and it is absolutely fantastic. He does all the voices magnificently. I am completely hooked. I still need to get my own copy of the text. I prefer to listen and read along at the same time. But in the meantime I am utterly absorbed in the story. The writing is out of this world wonderful! Perhaps the best Dickens ever! I read A Tale years ago, maybe in high school. I remember the outline of the story. I have forgotten how well written and dramatically charged it is - and funny too - in places. I could not be happier with the seasonal Dickens selection for 2023.

Kristen Egener Chaddah
>>121028245

Welcome Dan. I joined the book club last fall. I can’t believe it’s a year already and what a year! I’ve read more fiction in the last 12 months than I have in decades. 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻

Kristen Egener Chaddah
>>121001558

That is one of many reasons I appreciate this wonderful book club. I am among kindred spirits who enjoy discussing books they’ve read.

Jaye Cee

Nice. I guessed quite early in this video, the combination of being very well known and that dickens was travelling between Paris and London around this time. A little like Jane Eyre, it’s a book I either dipped into or half read when I was too young, know sort of what happens, but don’t really remember anything. Apart from that and film / stage adaptions of A Christmas Carol and Oliver Twist, I’ve never read any Dickens, so I look forward to digging in properly with the group and the lectures. I like how it interconnects with other literature relating to the time period, as I feel im starting to get an understanding of that corner of history. My only thing is that since childhood I’ve had reoccurring dreams about guillotines, but perhaps this study of the time period will somehow put that to rest.

Paul Servini

Thanks for annoncing this earler than usual giving me time to get hold of my copy. I love reading Dickens and always have ever since first reading David Copperfield at school. I've read Tale of Two Cities once before but didn't like it very much. I'm going to give it another try.

RachelEvelyn L

Woohoo already ordered my copy and so excited to crack into it! I attempted ATOTC many years ago, captivated by the beautiful first lines but was discouraged quickly by the obtuse language. Now with many more years of classics under my belt (and this club) I will hopefully enjoy it more. I love heavier and emotional reads during the fall/winter season too and ATOTC seems to fit that bill perfectly. I have only read Great Expectations by CD and loved it - it'll be fun to read A Christmas Carol and ATOTC back to back in the next couple of months. Can't wait to hear the schedule for next year, and huge congratss on reaching 100K Ben! You deserve it a hundredfold and more! Hope you were able to take a moment and celebrate the milestone 🎉🎉

Greylyn Gaillard

How exciting! I read this when I was 16 and still have the same copy of the novel on my bookshelf, so I can’t wait to see what my younger self left in the margins :)

Patricia Dattoma

Hello all, I just joined this book club today! This will be my first time reading “A Tale of Two Cities”. I was convinced the pick was “Oliver Twist” :) I have only read “A Christmas Carol” in the past, so I am looking forward to digging in & marking up my book. Happy to be here & big congrats on the YouTube milestone, Ben! Well deserved!

Aaron Marion

This will be my first Dickens novel besides "A Christmas Carol". I look forward to it! This has been an author I have always wanted to dive into but never pulled off the shelf. Why? I do not know. Other things would grab my attention more. I very much look forward to it. Wondering how well I'll be able to keep up between this and Gravity's Rainbow. I think it depends on how fast Gravity's Rainbow is. But I'll do my best!

Kathy Smith

I just joined this morning. What great Christmas gift to myself to read

Kathy Smith

Oops hit the post button by mistake. Going to find a used edition of the book, since this will be my first try at noting in the book itself. I need to get used to writing in a book!

Alexandra Seidel Santos

Hello, just joined up today amd looking forward to reading “A Tale of Two Cities”. I’ve read “Oliver Twist” and “Great Expectations” but that was some time ago. As I was raised using library books, I have never annotated in the book itself, so this will be someth8ng completely new.

Tatiana

This is great on audio!

Signe Kopps

I love this book! "It was the best of times, it was the worst of times..." has helped me get through so many hard times in my life. I'm looking forward to the 2024 reading list. I struggled this year to create the habit of persevering to the end of the few books I read. I believe this habit will make it easier to get through the wonderful big books Ben has in mind for us next year. .

Signe Kopps
>>121200786

Do you have a recommendation for a narrator? Libravox has a recording by Paul Adams.

Signe Kopps
>>121214318

Adding that I was reading Tale of Two Cities in school when we learned that John Kennedy had been shot. The opening line has been weirdly reassuring for a long time.

Tatiana
>>121200786

My library has one on Hoopla narrated by Gildart Jackson. I imagine any with a proper English accent is good. I did not want to hear it read by an American.

Peter F

Looking forward to this read. My undergraduate thesis was based on "Hard Times". Have not read this yet.

Hannah
>>120994190

Agree - going to try and find this in a local indie second hand if I can :)

Hannah

Really looking forward to this! My only Dickens thus far has been Great Expectations which I enjoyed. I started David Copperfield this year but it wasn't the right time for whatever reason. Looking forward to finding a copy of this and A Christmas Carol in my local second hand book shop! On adaptations, I haven't watched any! Did anyone watch the recent BBC series of Great Expectations? I've been meaning to watch for a while, mostly for Olivia Colman!

Hannah
>>120960500

I'm very similar Serena, except I only got about 100 pages into DC this year before putting it down. I think the size intimidated me but I definitely want to go back to it.

Ashley August

I’m excited for this one! I’ve only ever read Great Expectations as a high school child.

Raphaël

Hello, I actually never read Dickens and I started to read in English just this year, but this video made me really wanna try it out. Just a question, anybody knows where to buy a hardback facsimile such as the one Ben is showing in the video? It is gorgeous but hard to find! Thanks

Ms P
>>121342520

Ebay - I've just ordered myself a copy for £5.75. Just type in 'dickens a tale of two cities chapman and hall facsimile' - there are several copies available now.

cheryl foden

Just bought a pristine leather bound Easton press used volume of Tale of Two Cities. Filled with beautiful illustrations. The former owner clearly never read it.

Stephanie Ecklund

I remember reading Great Expectations in school. I have not read anything else but one of my very good friends loves everything Dickinson.

Suz R

Was able to obtain a Wordsworth edition for under $4 which is perfect for my budget. If it is a book that I know I will reread then I will look into getting a more solid copy. Looking forward to another Dickens read a long.

Gonzalo Broto

Hello Ben and all members of HLBC! I have a question about this read (forgive me if it has already been answered): is there going to be an introductory video to the book before the first lecture, or the next video will already be Lecture One discussing the first chapters? Thanks! I'm looking forward to reading my second Dickens (I have only read "A Christmas Carol" so far!)

Stacy McDaniel

I just rejoined and have really been missing the amazing content. I have not been reading much lately, but I am ready to dive back in. This is my first Dickens. I know and have several of the stories but have not read any of them. About a month ago I bought a Barnes & Noble Classics version for $1. I am really looking forward to reading this!

Angie

I knew what it was as soon as you said it was something you read when young & one of the most popular, around 3:10 mark. I’m excited - I read it when I was young & had the same experience. I also still have the same copy!

Walker Rowe

I just joined two days ago and Ben in his welcome message said read A Tale of Two Cities. So read 30 pages ago. I put a question of procedure in the wrong discussion thread so won’t repeat it here. As for my copy I found a copy in my mom’s books. But it’s four novels in one book. Hardback. This anthology is so heavy I can hardly read it in my chair as it crushes my chest, so I’m sitting at my desk. Not the most comfortable way to read.

Laura F.

Just rejoined and delighted! I am also very excited next year's list....I am still saturated thinking about War and Peace last Jan-Feb. and am, in truth, impacted by it above all others from last year on a daily basis. And especially now....when is the date of release next year's reads?? Cheers from USA

Kevin Groarke

I’d previously read GE and DC as well as ACC (many times as I taught it in a secondary school for a number of years). I inherited the Folio Society’s complete Dickens collection last year and have my copy of AToTC at the ready - no marginalia in this one though. 😉 Looking forward to sharing our thoughts.

Kate Araya

I've been following Ben on YT for the last year when I needed a break from studying. I am so busy so I am still on War & Peace - almost through, and I have read quite a few of the books on this year's and next year's lists - but I was really hooked on Ben's channel when he spoke about how much a novel changes you and for you depending on your age and your experiences prior and while reading it. To re-read ATOTC is my focus when this semester soon ends, making me feel so excited as I FINALLY have a community of classic readers with whom I can share the experience. Thank you for this Book Club!

Patty Page

Hi all. Just joined in time for Dickens read. Bought a volume of 4 Dickens books a few years back. Marker was at chapter 3 so thats the extent if my knowledge. 🤣🤣Great Expectations and Oliver Twist have some long ago memories. Look forward to learning how to best absorb these wonderful tales.

Amber A
>>121394100

I always feel so sad for the book and the previous owner when I find pristine beautiful editions that were never read. Always hopeful I won’t suffer the same fate as the previous owner. A great reminder to keep reading.

Jenny Garber

I read for freshman English in high school way to many years ago. I knew it was about French Revolution and the first sentence but I can’t remember anything else. If I remember straight this teacher I thought she was one of the worst teachers I ever had. We spent more time talking about what the in/it crowd was doing then learning. The more I think about this I don’t think we finished the novel.

Christin Elliott

This will be a reread, and the only book that has ever made me cry. Like Dickens, I became obsessed with the era. So much I’ve collected a nice little collection of nonfiction regarding the time period. I’m hoping this time around I’ll be able to retain more, and intrigued to see what reveals it self to me I missed the first time.

Justin LaCasse

I originally read this book (or pretended to) in high school over 30 years ago, and remember little to nothing of it. As I get older, I appreciate literature much more. As a father of 5 (ages 4 to 15) , I am hoping to inspire my children to value good books like this. Earlier this year, I read Great Expectations with my oldest 2, and we enjoyed it not just for the writing, but for the conversation it inspired. It was around that time that i purchased an Everyman's copy of "A Tale of Two Cities" in hopes that it would be the mystery Dickens novel. What a great surprise and delight to see that it is. I look forward with anticipation to ACTUALLY read this book, and to see where the conversation with it leads us!

Yumi Yarns

This will be a reread for me and, to be honest, I was slightly disappointed as I didn't enjoy it as much on my first read through years ago. However, the first time I read it as an audiobook and I've since realized that, while convenient for getting the overall gist of a story, for myself audiobooks don't allow me to really live the books and immerse myself in the writing as much as a hard copy does. So, I took Ben's advice and when I couldn't find a secondhand copy that I liked locally, I picked up a Penguin Clothbound Classics edition (i've been eyeing these beautiful & fun editions for awhile). I'm so glad I did, physically reading the text has already made it so much more enjoyable to experience. I've actually only read A Tale of Two Cities and a Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens. I love a Christmas Carol and, like I said before, wasn't a huge fan of A Tale of Two Cities. But, I've always read a Christmas Carol in a physical book or watched The Muppets, lol. This year I'm looking forward to sharing it as an audiobook with my husband since he's never read it and does much better listening to audiobooks. This will be his first Charles Dickens experience so i'm really hopeful that he likes it, too!

Emily

No captions??

Daisy

This will be my first read of A Tale of Two Cities, which will be my second Dickens novel after Great Expectations. Looking forward to continuing reading one Dickens every year.