Home
Creators
Search Recent Random
Posts
Search DMs Popular Hash Lookup Tags Random
Importer
Import FAQ
Register Favorites Keys Review DMs Logout
Community
Telegram ThePornDude
Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

New Show Suggestions! (Patreon)

Published:
2024-06-01 15:31:00
Imported:
2026-06

Content

Dollhouse is unfortunately coming to an end soon so we'll have to find a replacement. I'll do a poll like I did last time but first I want to hear your suggestions!

I think I'll definitely include Smallville and Charmed in the poll because I got suggested Smallville alot and I really want to watch Charmed lol but leave some suggestions in the comments!

Comments

Graeme McCutcheon

I'll never miss an opportunity to plug Orphan Black, so may I suggest...Orphan Black? Underrated show, not too long (5 x 10 episode seasons), and I think you would gel with it.

McPhee242

Roswell OG Also something I haven't seen anyone react to but would be a fun one is Grosse Pointe. Great show and has a bunch of Buffy references in it too.

Stargazer1682

Lucifer Marvelous Mrs. Maisel Doctor Who Agents of SHIELD Stargate SG-1 Quantum Leap (the original)

Bisibia

The good place! As much as I love these shows, I think it would be nice to see you react to a show that is 22 minutes instead of 44... And you haven't done any comedies yet sooooo....

Bisibia

Also Community is the best sitcom ever. Community.

Da_Bill

Smallville and Charmed are great choices but would love to see you react to Doctor Who.

Thomas Hansen

The Leftovers Lost Freaks and Geeks Gilmore Girls Battlestar Galactica Wynonna Earp

Daniel

Battlestar Galactica has some familiar faces and is also amazing

PeachyKeen

I would love a reaction to The X-Files! It’s such an iconic show and I remember you mentioning you wanted to watch it at some point.

Pumpkin 3.14

Lucifer, Person of Interest, IZombie, and Scream Queens.

Nica Marie

My So Called Life Harper's Island Designing Women Living Single

Anthony
>>139628816

I think she'd probably love the mysterious elements of it, but would be grossed out by much of the stuff that crops up, based on her reactions to some demons on Buffy/Angel.

Michael Baker

My long shot wish would be Wonderfalls. And for a more likely choice I’ll say Pushing Daisies.

Moon Logic

My So-Called Life Twin Peaks

Absolute0

Peaky Blinders, Netflix' Daredevil, Lost Girl, Orphan Black

Keith Goodnight

Doctor Who is top of my list for any reactor who hasn't seen it already.

Christopher simeon

Agents of shield if you enjoy marvel. It is buffy and angel spiritual cousin via whedon.

Aech2

I think there are amazing Episodes of Quantum Leap (1989), so maybe select episodes? I just never see anyone react to those ones. Lost is great too.

Eddie Veltre

24 is another great show, it’s filled with action, drama and incredible plot twists about a goverment agent played by the incredible Kiefer Sutherland

Nikho_Ronin

Black Sails The Good Place Battlestar Galactica (2005) Gilmore Girls

Simon

There are a LOT of really good shows out there. Just off the top of my head; Orphan Black; the Marvellous Mrs Maisel; Killjoys; iZombie; The Good Place. There's also one more Whedon show; The Nevers. Like Dollhouse and Firefly, it sadly didn't go the distance, just 12 episodes in total. And Whedon had already quit by then. But it's definitely worth checking out. Lastly, if I had to think of a show that would be the best fit for the kind of stuff you've watched up to this point, I'd 100% go with Wynonna Earp.

Kevin Karst

I think it would be nice if you watched a comedy show for a change. The three best ones in my humble opinion are: - Friends (the best one) - Scrubs - The Office If you're looking for non-comedy shows, then Breaking Bad and Game of Thrones are the obvious choices. I don't think I know anyone who doesn't love these shows, if they've seen them. The Last of Us would be great too, it's always fun to see reactors getting jumpscared. :-D

PeachyKeen
>>139628816

That’s probably true lol but that’s also the fun part! I think the pros far outweigh the cons and getting into the mysteries and conspiracies of the show would be an amazing watch, not including some of the best MOTW episodes ever. It’s such a classic.

Petra Marie

Gilmore girls and friends

Denni Caid
>>139631672

I adore Agents of SHIELD and will ALWAYS ALWAYS recommend it. Such a well written show.

Michael Noss

I'd like to see you watch Smallville. Heroes would be a good choice for some action and suspense. Being Human is horror drama (the U.S. version, there's a U.K. version I've never seen). If you want a mystery/detective show with a supernatural twist, I suggest Lucifer or Izombie. You should also do a monthly movie reaction, starting with the Buffy and Firefly movies!

HookedOnSwans

I love both Smallville and Charmed, but honestly my first choices would probably be Battlestar Galactica or Merlin. Both have some familiar faces and are amazing shows. I would also suggest Once Upon a Time if you haven't seen it yet, Doctor Who or Heroes. Or if you want a shorter episode runtime, Community is one of the funniest sitcoms I've ever seen

PT Gunn

Wonderfalls Marvelous Mrs. Maisel Orphan Black

Steve

Pushing Daisies is exactly the earnest and sweet type of show I suspect you'd really love watching. It's unlikely to win, but I've no doubt you'll enjoy it, if you do ever get to check it out

anticonstructivist55

Smallville even tho there are 10 seasons, which mean it's an over decade to finish it

Rileymetal

Black Sails Orphan Black Lost Girl Marvel's Agents of SHIELD (and the MCU in general) Daredevil and Jessica Jones

Sean Ellingham

Agents of S.H.I.E.L.D. will always be my top pick, but I do have others as well: - The Good Place - Orphan Black - Agent Carter - Lucifer - Daredevil - The Americans

El

One thing I'd like to suggest is that if you're going to stick with three concurrent shows that you do some long and some short. Since Veronica Mars is mid-length (72) and Firefly is very short, the length of new show could then be used to determine what the options for replacing Firefly are, too. The Good Place (53), Person of Interest (103), Dark (26) (as long as you're OK with subtitles) and School Spirits (8, but with a second season coming in 2025) would be my top picks.

El
>>139628816

She'd be grossed out, but that still doesn't seem to stop her from wanting to continue, so I doubt that would be a dealbreaker.

Jontor11

Original Charmed is great! But it unfortunately loses its charm by the last couple of seasons. Original Roswell (3 seasons) would be right up your alley. (These two shows aired at the same time as Buffy). Wonderfalls (1 season) is a FANTASTIC show. I would love for you to watch Alias. It's a sci-fi/agent/mystery show that I think you would like.

Anthony

I don't think anyone in the history of the world has ever reacted to Scrubs (I might be exaggerating slightly) but it has a great blend of silliness and heart-rending moments. I think you'd like it, but realistically I don't think it has a chance.

Stephen Knueppel

Battlestar Galactic, Legends of the Seeker and Spartacus

Zoot!

Highly recommend The Good Place next. If you have any familiarity with the MCU, I'd also put Agents of SHIELD top of my list too.

Tom Tattershall

The Magicians is a great supernatural fantasy series that has few to no reactions. Five seasons with 65 total episodes. Kind of a college age Hogwarts including a Narnia-type otherworld.

Audra Foxgrove

I am enthusiastically recommending The Good Place and Person Of Interest.

Gau Thier

I'd say The Good Place and Lucifer if you haven't seen those already.

GusterXZ

12 Monkeys SyFy Series, probably one of the best underrated time travel stories I've ever seen. Has 4 seasons of 13Ep each.

Nogusta

Hannibal is a great show about friendship and food. Very heartwarming. Best to go in blind to avoid those pesky spoilers. :)

Freefall
>>139628089

Definitely recommend this as well! and it has Kristen Bell in it too

Artemis Nix

Once Upon a Time or The Good Place

SirCheetah

Teen Wolf is a fun one to get into

Stargazer1682

Oh boy, looking at some of the subsequent replies, there are so many good choices. Definitely echo: The Good Place Lucifer Community

cruzinbosco

- Gilmore Girls (7 seasons) - Life Unexpected (2 seasons) - Roswell 1999 (3 seasons) - Friends (if you haven't seen it) - One Tree Hill (9 seasons) - Third Watch (6 seasons) - Dawson's Creek (6 seasons) - The Haunting of Hill House (mini-series)

sonofcoul

The Haunting of Hill House would be awesome !

Edwin Lee

Battlestar Galactica Hannibal Lost The Expanse Netflix Jessica Jones Lost Girl

Alexis Cardarella

The Expanse, Black Sails, Orphan Black, Crazy Head! (coined the British Buffy), Six Feet Under, Black Sails

Kirsten (Heavenli24)

If you haven’t already seen them, would love to see you react to: The Last of Us (only 9 eps) Roswell (original 1999 version) Lucifer My So-Called Life

NC

-Smallville -Lucifer -Roswell(Original) You've indicated before being a k-pop fan. While not Korean I highly recommend an anime called "Oshi No Ko". The premise is a little weird if you look it up, but it mainly deals with the Japanese entertainment industry and being a young celebrity in the social media age. The themes translate very well to k-pop idols.

CraigK

Doctor Who (the reboot, 2005+) is at the top of my list, as well

Stephen Knueppel

Battlestar Galactica, The Expanse, Terminator - the Sarah Connor Chronicles, Legend of the Seeker, Game of Thrones

Tjbosslyfe

1 Vampire Diaries If you liked Buffy Vampire diaries you'll like it too . 2 Smallville . 3 . Agents of shield 4. One tree hill

Da_Bill

Has to be Doctor Who next for me - from Christopher Eccleston onwards. Buffy is my number one all time show and Doctor Who is number 2 because they both have great character development mixed with really crazy storylines.

JenM

Doctor Who is my vote

Jontor11

I think Charmed is right up your alley. You'd love it. Smallville is not as good.

Thom Purdy

For something different, I highly recommend "Pushing Daisies"! It is wonderful, weird, and whimsical, Also only 22 episodes.