Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

⚡Auto-Sync (Prime Video) | 🎬 Requests | 🍿 Pick-A-Flick | ▶️ YouTube | 💻 Watch/Download

I have no words. It was heartbreaking in. every way. My heart at times physically hurt in my chest. Unimaginable. I love to learn of individual stories and his was to hell and back.

Files

The Pianist (2002) - Full Reaction - Popcorn In Bed

Watch the full reaction to The Pianist on Popcorn In Bed.

Comments

SEAN ƴü KAY

Love you for picking this one out of the blue!!!

Thomas Wetherell

This is one of my favorite movies, as sad as it is at times. While the whole thing is good to this day it’s still the final thirty minutes between Szpilman and Hosenfeld that shines the most in my eyes. For him to have suffered at the hands of the Germans so greatly and for so long only to end up arguably owing his life to a German officer is remarkable to me. Such a shame that neither of them ended up getting to see their families again and that Hosenfeld died so ungraciously in a Soviet gulag. Very glad someone finally reacted to this one.

Erik Locquiao

Another great WWII story is “The 12th Man.” It’s been my submission every month for the pick-a-flick, hope it wins soon!

Rick Rodriguez

Immensely powerful film and one of Polanski's best.

Ted Whalen

The Pianist is such a powerful movie. It is an absolute classic war movie which is a must watch. I thought that Adrien Brody was amazing as Wladyslaw Szpilman.

Shawn Kildal

Saw it at the theater. I remember going to my car afterwards and just sitting there. After about 15 minutes or so I realized maybe I should start the car and go home.

K, Zachary

I got woken up not by the ding from Patreon. But my gf telling me the sirens are going off huh WHAT!?😳 Grab my phone look we got a ding from Cassie. ❤️ The Pianist is up. "Zach the dogs are scared. Severe T storm headed our way. I know you love PIB ❤️ and I do too. ♥️ But Priorities". The Pianist is going to have to wait till she get's home tonight. So what Polanski did with this is film pretty amazing. I invite everyone to go watch the making of this movie on YouTube. That being said I am going back to sleep. 😴💤.

Rose

Chopin’s Nocturne in C-sharp Minor, Op. posth. is deceptively difficult piano piece. It was the last classical piece I was learning before quitting piano lessons. The challenge for me was the musicality and rubato. This musical masterpiece alone has inspired so many people to learn how to play the piano. Thomas Kretschmann - my initials are on your natz cert ;) I was surprised to see him in person at the Los Angeles Convention Center in 2010 when he became a naturalized U.S. citizen. He went over a barrier to cut in line to get a front row seat at the oath ceremony. I was supposed to manage the crowd but he looked at me with those piercing blue eyes and I was like, “loved you in ‘The Pianist.’” This is my favorite Adrien Brody film.

Jacob Lunbeck

A very hard but important watch. After the Nazis invaded Poland, the Polish government quickly fell. They were no match militarily and surrendered. (A lot of people today don’t know that Russia and the Nazis were actually on the same side at the beginning and they invaded the country together which is part of why Poland didn’t stand a chance) The Nazis then setup what was called “The General Government” which for all intents and purposes was simply an extension of the Nazi government (Poles didn’t even hold the top positions in it, they were held by Nazis). As to what the average person thought of what was happening to the Jews, it varies wildly depending on the country. In Poland for example, much of the native population (Not just the Jews) were heavily persecuted as well so they were aware of what was happening. Hitler and the Nazi leadership spent many years prior spreading the lie (One that they had deluded even themselves into believing was true) that the Jewish people were secretly controlling much of the world. This was combined with the lie that the reason Germany had lost World War 1 was because the Jews who fought on the German side had turned on them at the last minute. This is called the “Stab-In-The-Back Myth”. After spreading these lies for many years, they then used them as justification to enact their Anti-Jewish policies, first in Germany itself, then in the countries they occupied.

MikeLL

Devastating movie.

Clay F

Important film. Thanks much for reacting to this. I liked your outro. The war in The Pianist takes place 1939-1945, so Władysław went through hell for a long time. “The Pianist” and “Schindler’s List” occur in Warsaw, Poland. The two movies cover same, similar, and different facets of the German occupation of Warsaw. In Europe, the Germans (Nazis) exterminated (mass murder) six million Jews, but the primary reason Germany invaded and conquered Poland was for territorial gain. Great Britain and France declared war on Germany in response to Germany crossing into Poland in 1939. But Great Britain and France for the most part too weak militarily compared to Germany to do much about it. Great Britain and France had previously appeased Hitler’s territorial demands in Austria and Czechoslovakia but said would declare war on Germany if Germany invaded Poland – that was the official start of WWII = September 1, 1939. The US didn't declare war on Germany until 2 years later in December 1941.

Clay F

1939 – Germany invades, conquers, occupies Poland. The Pianist movie starts. Germany divides Poland with their ally Russia. 1940 – Germany invades, conquers, and occupies France. Germany essentially controls continental Europe. 1941 – Germany invades Russia. Japan bombs Pearl Harbor. 1944 – Russia attacks German forces in Eastern Europe. Allied forces including US, Great Britain, Canada, etc. major attack German forces in Western Europe (starting with D-Day landing in France). 1945 – Russians liberate Warsaw from Germany in January to control Poland. Germany surrenders in May. The Pianist movie for the most part ends. US dropped atomic bomb on Hiroshima in August. Władysław Szpilman horrendous experience in the movie was for 5.5 years = Sept 1939 (Germany invaded Poland) to January 1945 (Russians liberate Poland).

Mohammed Alshahrani

This movie is a very important movie. It is hard to watch but must be watched at least once. Its importance lies not only in documenting the atrocities of war but also in serving as a stark reminder of the devastating consequences of hatred and violence. As we reflect on this powerful film, we must hold onto the hope that the horrors of war will never be repeated. Yet, it is disheartening to recognize that similar acts of violence and oppression continue to unfold in various parts of the world today. The lessons from history must guide us toward a future of peace and understanding.

Clay F

Arguably a duty as a citizen of the world is to watch this movie, which is still relevant today in that autocratic fascists filled with nationalist racist hate still exist. We can never let our guard down.

Doc Larry/old geezer

The movie is compelling true story about the human spirit and overcoming evil in the world. The acting was first rate. I always feel it’s my duty to mention the Director Roman Polanski In 1977, Polanski was arrested for drugging and raping a 13-year-old girl. He pleaded guilty to the lesser charge of unlawful sex with a minor in exchange for a probation-only sentence. The night before his sentencing hearing in 1978, he learned that the judge would likely reject the proffered plea bargain, so he fled the U.S. to Europe, where he continued his career. He remains a fugitive from the U.S. justice system. Mr. Polanski in my view is worse than the Nazis that he portrayed in his movie. He was an example of pure evil. Yes, he’s talented. Yes, the movie is a masterpiece in cinematography. I would not tell anyone not to watch this movie, it is important to know who this Director is and what he’s done. There’s no question he’s guilty. Yes, there are other young victims of Mr. Pulaski.

JL_83

Adrien Brody took home his first Oscar for this, which led to a memorable moment between him and presenter Halle Berry; it’s also of note that he was in competition against Nicolas Cage, Michael Caine, Daniel Day-Lewis, and Jack Nicholson, all of whom were already winners so it was like his own special underdog moment

Dork Diggler

This movie is a prelude to America's future.

Catherine LW

You may as well not watch any movies made in Hollywood, with its widespread pedo culture.

Catherine LW

After the war other Jews stepped forward and claimed that Captain Hosenfeld helped them escape capture. He was later declared a Righteous Gentile by the state of Israel. Very sad and unjust ending for him.

Joe J

Cassie still watched the movie Doc. I agree with everything you said, but at this point you're just beating a dead horse. Just my two-cents.

Joe J

Cut in line!! The nerve of these celebrities, geez.

Joe J

Good luck with changing human nature.

Doc Larry/old geezer

Joe J thank you I always appreciate commentary from the individuals on this channel and on Patreon. My intention was just to get the information across. Watching this movie is an individual choice. It is a well done movie no question. Feel free to comment on any post I do if you have any opinion about the content. This Community Joe is one of the best on the Internet.

Ted Whalen

Clay- in 1939 the French military was considered to be a strong force, maybe the strongest in the world. However, it was a combination of outdated strategy, leadership issues and technology shortcomings which played a major factor in France’s defeat to the Germans.

2-Can

There is a lot to fix in this timeline: August 1939 - National Socialist Germany signs pact with International Socialist Soviet Union, also agree to partition of several Eastern European countries, including Poland, as well as to not ally themselves with any country against the other. 1 Sep 1939 - National Socialist Germany invades Poland from west. 17 Sep 1939 - International Socialist Soviet Union invades Poland from east. 22 June 1941 - National Socialist Germany betrays its International Socialist ally by invading eastward, starting with Eastern Poland. . . . (saying the Russians 'liberated Warsaw' in Jan 1945 is a bit of a stretch - the Soviets kept it) I'll go with this (and leave it there) 18 Sep 1993 - Soviets liberate Poland by finally withdrawing.

Gray

(POS director aside) It is an amazing movie about survival and a very tough watch as you showed during your reaction, i've seen it a couple of times now so it's easier to get though the hard parts. Looking at the news it's terrible that something like this is happening right now, how can history repeat itself so quickly.

2-Can

Really? Which two countries are you suggesting will invade us (the way Poland was)?

Gábor Árki

I for one am glad this has been left out of the poll, because this led for a reaction, and I doubt this movie would have been able to win a poll. I think many have seen it, but unlike Schindler's List, it seems to have faded somewhat from popular circulation over the years. Also, there are the controversies surrounding its director. I admit, I haven't seen it either since its initial release. It was a great reaction, and as often happens when watching emotional movies with Cassie, made me feel like my own emotions are dialed to 11. Once Germany occupied Poland in 1939, they dismantled the existing Polish government and imposed direct control, effectively eliminating any form of self-governance. The Nazi regime aimed to dominate all of Europe and viewed the Eastern territories, especially the vast plains of Poland and beyond, as their rightful Lebensraum (living space). The policies and decisions regarding the persecution and extermination of Jews were made by the German occupying authorities. However, it's important to note that some of the local Polish population supported these actions. By that time, years of populist, antisemitic propaganda had deeply influenced public opinion across much of Europe. Many people had come to believe harmful stereotypes: blaming Jews for World War I, the Great Depression, or accusing them of exploiting the poor through wealth and influence, etc. These widespread, toxic narratives helped enable and justify the atrocities that followed. Many were simply too afraid to say or do anything and simply looked aside, or just relieved it doesn't happening to them. As for the story told, it is based on Szpilman's own book and is regarded as a highly accurate portrayal of events. Many of the atrocities depicted in the film are corroborated by historical documentation and eyewitness accounts. Roman Polanski, himself a survivor of the Holocaust, took a restrained and realistic approach, avoiding unnecessary dramatization or sentimentality, which makes the horrors shown feel all the more real. The movie doesn't give much details, but one of the most controversial decisions of the Soviets during the war was the Warsaw Uprising of 1944. When the Polish resistance launched an uprising to liberate Warsaw from Nazi occupation, the Soviet Red Army was already just outside the city. But once the uprising started, the Red Army halted its advance and did not assist the Polish fighters, despite being within artillery range already. They even refused to provide supplies for the rebels and denied the use of their air fields to the British and American forces to resupply and help the Poles. They simply waited for the Germans to crush the rebellion, and kill everyone involved, so that it would be easier to install a communist puppet government after the war and occupy the country. The film also doesn't go into detail about the fate of Szpilman's family, although everyone probably assumes. In reality, they were all deported to Treblinka extermination camp during the mass deportations from the Warsaw Ghetto in 1942. Like nearly all who arrived there, they were killed shortly after, most likely in the gas chambers. These are not easy films to watch, but I think they are essential and everyone should see at least a few, so that we keep remembering what happened, learn from it, and hopefully never to repeat it again. But I'm afraid as that generation is passing away, we as a society starting to forget and no longer fear that it may happen again. I think the war did scar that entire generation. My grandparents, living through it as children or young teenagers for example always had a tendency to hoard things and keep large supplies of food in their house. They did not throw away anything that may be useful for something in the future, and they were always adamant not to throw away or waste any food, and had their pantry stocked full. One other movie I would like to recommend is JUDGEMENT AT NUREMBERG (1961). It is a courtroom drama portraying a fictionalized account of the real post-war trials of Nazi war criminals held in Nuremberg. As a bonus, it features a young William Shatner (before his Star Trek fame) in a small supporting role. I doubt it would ever win a poll, but maybe it has a chance of being handpicked. PS: sorry, this turned out to be very long.

Dork Diggler

Yeah maybe I worded it incorrectly. In the future America will invade and oppress other countries as they have promised to do.

Gábor Árki

Even though the British and French declared war in 1939 as depicted in the movie, there really hasn't happened much after that. They didn't want to invade Germany, and were just waiting for the Germans to attack until the summer of 1940. These two armies were not that weak. And the Germans were not that strong then as often assumed. Many historians think that if the Sudetenland hasn't been given to the Nazis in 1938, or the Czechoslovaks do not go along with this decision and choose to go to war, they would have had a really good chance of stopping the German's in the fortified positions they had in this area. But after the Sudetenland has been given to the Nazis, there wasn't anything left to stop the German army to take over the country. Similarly, as Ted wrote, it was mostly due to outdated strategy, bad leadership and simply luck that the Germans could beat the French and British armies in 1940. The French had an impenetrable fortress system (Maginot Line) built in the German border. And they placed their troops to the Belgian border knowing well, that any attack against them had to go through the Belgians first giving them time to prepare a counter attack. But the Ardennes between the two was considered to be impassable for mechanized forces, so not much troops were left there. The French reconnaissance even discovered the German troops marching through there and reported their sightings of massive German military columns, but these were ignored by the leadership as nonsense or diversion. If they would have left enough troops in the Ardennes, and would have acted on these reports, it is likely the German advance that relied entirely on surprise, and rapid and aggressive forward movement with the aim of taking key river crossings, would have been halted.

Catherine LW

I see history repeating itself, with people blaming Jews for all wars, economic failures, etc. Some never learn…

Catherine LW

Ok, pal. 🤦🏻‍♀️😂

Catherine LW

I read that Kretschmann escaped from East Germany during the Cold War. It would be interesting to hear his story.

Bill Maurer

Some great posts about this movie and Poland's dismantling and struggles through WW II. As a WW II history buff, I was recently introduced to a "legend" among Polish and world history, Witold Pilecki. Polish officer who formed one of the first "counter insurgencies" against the Germans who then volunteered, yes volunteered, to be arrested and sent to Auschwitz to investigate what was going on and form an insurgency inside Auschwitz. He was the first person to tell the Polish exiled government in London what was going on and later, the world. Escaped after nearly 3 years in Auschwitz and made his way back to Warsaw. Fought against the Germans in "the Warsaw Uprising" only to be captured and sent to a prison camp in Germany (they did not recognize him as a Auschwitz escapee as he was using a false name while imprisoned there). After the war he volunteered to go back to Poland to report on the Soviet and Communist takeover of his country. He was captured, tortured and put on show trial for his "supposed" crimes only to be executed. Netflix has a movie on about him called,"Pilecki's Report" but it is a bit confusing as it bounces around from moments in his life. Still good, but more you know of him the more you get the film. Hopefully Cassie will get to review it one day https://youtu.be/C0LuqcsEFiw?si=6a_hl2VwNlgzyhfy Thanks

Ted Whalen

Bill- thanks for that information about Witold Pilecki (I am definitely going to watch that movie).

Ted Whalen

The Germans “secret weapon” of the Blitzkrieg was providing the soldiers with Crystal Meth (the recommended dosage was one tablet during the day, and two tablets at night).

Dave

Hi Alex - please remove your comment , and please refrain from getting personal in future comments. Thanks.

Ted Whalen

Sergeant York is a great movie. I think that this may have been the first war movie that I watched.

Clay F

Thanks. I added "Germany divides Poland with their ally Russia" and changed to "Russians liberate Warsaw from Germany in January to control Poland." You have too much detail for what I wanted in my timeline. Also, while Nazism was known as National Socialism, Nazi Germany was not socialist but instead facist -- a far-right political ideology.

Just Plain Bob

Clay, the Nazi party was literally called the Nationalist Socialist party. It was shortened to Nazi. Not speaking to their politics - though Hitler did believe in state control of the factors of production (so long as the “state” was embodied by him, of course) - just that the use of the term is historically correct.

Clay F

Good points Ted. What is striking is that Germany invaded and conquered France the next year (1940) in record time. Great Britian was essentially alone.

Clay F

The Nazi Party's official name in German was Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei (NSDAP), which translates to National Socialist German Workers' Party in English. They also used the acronym NSDAP. They had facist far-right regime conrol of the factors of production. Hitler hated and despised socialism. Were the Nazis socialists? No, not in any meaningful way, and certainly not after 1934.

2-Can

Negative to Nazi Germany being ‘far right’. That was a lie concocted by the Soviets to try to limit the Overton Window of permitted debate to choosing between national socialism and international socialism. The two ends of the political spectrum are not defined by authoritarianism (authoritarians are at one end, extreme individualism/anarchy is at the other). America is not trapped between these two supposed ‘extremes’ - we are well to the right in valuing individual liberty (although we do have fans of varying degrees of government authoritarianism at the expense of individual liberty). I’m done talking politics in this thread, but I’ll challenge this when it’s raised. I prefer we keep this talk to movies.

Jake McNulty

Also worth mentioning about this film is that the director, Roman Polanski, experienced the holocaust himself when he was only a child. From his Wikipedia article: The Polański family moved back to Kraków, Poland, in early 1937, and were living there when World War II began with the invasion of Poland. Kraków was soon occupied by the German forces, and the racist and anti-Semitic Nuremberg Laws made the Polańskis targets of persecution, forcing them into the Kraków Ghetto, along with thousands of the city's Jews. Around the age of six, Polanski attended primary school for only a few weeks, until "all the Jewish children were abruptly expelled", writes biographer Christopher Sandford. That initiative was soon followed by the requirement that all Jewish children over the age of twelve wear white armbands, with a blue Star of David imprinted, for visual identification. After he was expelled, Polanski would not be allowed to enter another classroom for six years. Polanski's father was transferred, along with thousands of other Jews, to Mauthausen, a group of 49 German concentration camps in Austria. His mother, who was four months pregnant at the time, was taken to Auschwitz and killed in the gas chamber soon after arriving. The forced exodus took place immediately after the German liquidation of the Warsaw Ghetto, a real-life backdrop to Polanski's film The Pianist (2002). Polanski, who was then hiding from the Germans, saw his father being marched off with a long line of people. Polanski tried getting closer to his father to ask him what was happening and got within a few yards. His father saw him, but afraid his son might be spotted by the German soldiers, whispered (in Polish), "Get lost!" Polanski escaped the Kraków Ghetto in 1943 and survived with the help of some Polish Roman Catholics, including a woman who had promised Polanski's father that she would shelter the boy.  Polanski attended church, learned to recite Catholic prayers by heart, and behaved outwardly as a Roman Catholic, although he was never baptized. His efforts to blend into a Catholic household failed miserably at least once, when the parish priest visiting the family posed questions to him one-on-one about the catechism, and ultimately said, "You aren't one of us". The punishment for helping a Jew in German-occupied Poland was death. As Polanski roamed the countryside trying to survive in a Poland now occupied by German troops, he witnessed many horrors, such as being "forced to take part in a cruel and sadistic game in which German soldiers took shots at him for target practice". The author Ian Freer concludes that Polanski's constant childhood fears and dread of violence have contributed to the "tangible atmospheres he conjures up on film". By the time the war ended in 1945, a fifth of the Polish population had been killed, the vast majority being civilians. Of those deaths, 3 million were Polish Jews, which accounted for 90% of the country's Jewish population. According to Sandford, Polanski would use the memory of his mother, her dress and makeup style, as a physical model for Faye Dunaway's character in his film Chinatown (1974). In October 2020, Polanski went back to Poland and paid respects to a Polish couple who helped him hide and escape the Nazis. Stefania and Jan Buchala were recognized by Yad Vashem, Israel's Holocaust memorial, as "Righteous Among the Nations". Polanski recalled Stefania Buchala as being an "extremely noble" and courageous person.

Just Plain Bob

Clay, I believe that, if you read my post again, you’ll note that I stated that I wasn’t speaking to their ideology. The commonly held name for the Nazi Party was National Socialist (including William Shirer’s excellent “Rise and Fall of the Third Reich”). As for Hitler’s disdain for socialism, particularly as practiced by the Soviets, it’s pretty common knowledge. As was Stalin’s hatred of fascism. Ironic, since they both filled camps with “undesirables” and proceeded to murder them by the millions.

Mike Lemon

There are cures for TDS, touching grass for instance. Maybe try some. If you want to discuss politics and I can explain what you aren't seeing, hit me up on reddit ( u/MikeLemon ).

Bill Maurer

the actor who played Captain Wilm Hosenfeld, is also in "Downfall" about the last few days of WW II told from the Hitler's bunker in Berlin. Another great WW II movie based on a true story

Jake McNulty

Also, if you're interested, Polanski's filmography also includes "Repulsion" (1965) with Catherine Deneuve, "The Fearless Vampire Killers" (1967), "Rosemary's Baby" (1968) with Mia Farrow, "Macbeth" (1971), "Chinatown" (1974) with Jack Nicholson and Faye Dunaway, "The Tenant" (1976), "Tess" (1979), "Frantic" (1988) with Harrison Ford, "Bitter Moon" (1992) with Hugh Grant and Kristen Scott Thomas, "Death and the Maiden" (1994) with Sigourney Weaver and Ben Kingsley, "The Ninth Gate" (1999) with Johnny Deep, "Oliver Twist" (2005), "The Ghost Writer" (2010) with Ewan McGregor and Pierce Brosnan, "Carnage" (2011) with Jodie Foster, Kate Winslet, Christoph Waltz and John C. Reilly, "Venus in Fur" (2013) and "An Officer and a Spy" (2019). Worth checking out in my opinion.

Above Average Dave

"Our socialism is the socialism of the community of the people, not the socialism of class warfare." A direct quote in 1936 to...Time Magazine, which marveled at Germany's "economic miracle." The quote is from that guy who led Germany from 1933-1945 referring to his pre-war economic policies. Time also printed a glowing article about him in 1939 showing him at his Eagle's Nest (which Cassie saw in BAND OF BROTHERS), approvingly calling it his "Home in the Clouds.” It described the Berchtesgaden retreat in glowing terms, noting its “harmonious” furnishings and “quiet cheerfulness" and showed him as a warm, reflective leader with his gf, his beloved dog and friends. 12 days after the article came out, Germany, and then the USSR, invaded Poland. That action created the events in THE PIANIST. To say he was far right is to ape propaganda originating from the USSR and The Workers Daily in the US. He believed in government control of all businesses, usually through overbearing partnerships where the government was directly involved in dictating or "strongly suggesting" levels of production and deciding what products would be emphasized. Corporate officers had to be party members in good standing at all major corporations. In 1938 his government took nearly full control of all industries that had anything to do with the upcoming war effort. Also, never forget that, before the war, Germany was the most technologically advanced, educated country in Europe, and likely, the world. The leader we all despise was propelled into office in large part by the advocacy of university professors, students, and government workers. So, while this government favored a form of socialism with significant government control (a left-leaning policy) it was never far right (full laissez-faire capitalism) or even right0leaning. It was, at its core, an authoritarian government that started with strong strains of socialism, including government having a hand in major industry. It, and the USSR, had far more in common with historic war lord/gangster/mafia-style rule than anything else. The biggest mistake people make about history, or when reguritating post-event/revisionist talking points, is to ignore the original context from the times when that history was happening. THE PIANIST explores a lot of that context, and is a brutal watch.

Mike Lemon

"Hitler hated and despised socialism." Really? Let's see. But first, there will have to be national socialism. Otherwise the people and their governments are not ready for the socialism of nations. It is not possible to be liberal to one's own country and demand socialism among nations. - Hitler After all, that's exactly why we call ourselves National Socialists! We want to start by implementing socialism in our nation among our Volk! It is not until the individual nations are socialist that they can address themselves to international socialism. - Hitler There is a difference between the theoretical knowledge of socialism and the practical life of socialism. People are not born socialists, but must first be taught how to become them. - Hitler In socialism of the future…what counts is the whole, the community of the Volk. The individual and his life play only a subsidiary role. He can be sacrificed—he is prepared to sacrifice himself should the whole demand it. - Hitler It is not Germany that will turn Bolshevist, but Bolshevism that will become a sort of National Socialism. Besides, there is more that binds us to Bolshevism than separate us from it… The petit bourgeois Social-Democrat and the trade-union boss will never make a National Socialist, but the Communist always will. - Hitler

Stick Figure Studios

In this thread you'll hear a lot of things about the director of this film Roman Polanski (who you might remember as a character in ONCE UPON A TIME IN HOLLYWOOD; he was the little guy who was married to Sharon Tate, as he was in real life, which means that in actuality he lost his wife and unborn child to the Manson gang) and not all of them are good. I don't begrudge anybody for whom "separating the art from the artist" proves too difficult a task and they just have no desire to watch films directed by Polanski, or Woody Allen or Mel Gibson or which feature Kevin Spacey or Michael Jackson or whomever (these are decisions that everyone has to make for themselves), but one thing about Polanski that is not insignificant to his art is that he himself was a Holocaust survivor who lost his parents to Auschwitz. Thus he brought a lot of personal experience, honesty and authenticity to the events portrayed in this film which is a big part of why it is so harrowing. Whatever one thinks about him personally, he truly was/is a phenomenal director whose movies do have artistic and social/educational value... THE PIANIST being no exception. Yes, it is a difficult watch, but I think it is an important one and I'm glad you got a chance to see it. Adrian Brody is fantastic and deserved the Oscar he won for his performance. It is also, I always hesitate to say this but I feel compelled to, sadly relevant again given things going on in the world today. Hopefully, we will learn from this history rather than be condemned to repeat it. :-(

Mike Lemon

"Nazi Germany was not socialist but instead facist-- a far-right political ideology." Not really. Fascism isn't "far-right", especially in the modern sense of (U.S.) left/right (and not even in the sense at the time) Let's look at some Mussolini, the "Father of Fascism". "For this I have been and am a socialist. The accusation of inconsistency has no foundation. My conduct has always been straight in the sense of looking at the substance of things and not to the form. I adapted socialisticamente to reality. As the evolution of society belied many of the prophecies of Marx, the true socialism folded from possible to probable. The only feasible socialism socialisticamente is corporatism, confluence, balance and justice interests compared to the collective interest." - Mussolini, March 20, 1945 Some of the things Mussolini has done, and some that he is threatening to do go further in the direction of Socialism than the English Labour Party could yet venture if they were in power. - George Bernard Shaw, Feb 7, 1927 Mussolini told the young man of his admiration for Communism—‘Fascism is the same thing’ [as Communism]. - As quoted in The Politics of Upheaval: 1935-1936 (The Age of Roosevelt, Vol. III), Arthur M. Schlesinger, Jr. The question is often asked in America and in Europe just how much ‘Fascism’ the American President’s program contains [edit to note- that is The New Deal]. Reminiscent of Fascism is the principle that the state no longer leaves the economy to its own devices, having recognized that the welfare of the economy is identical with the welfare of the people. Without question, the mood accompanying this sea change resembles that of Fascism. More than that cannot be said at the moment. - Mussolini’s book review in Popolo d’Italia, July 7, 1933

Clay F

I read William Shirer’s “Rise and Fall of the Third Reich” 50 years ago when I was 10 years old -- what I could understand. Hitler’s Third Reich was entirely fascist in character. That has nothing to do with USSR propaganda. The majority of scholars identify Nazism in both theory and practice as a form of far-right politics. Far-right themes in Nazism include the argument that superior people have a right to dominate other people and purge society of supposed inferior elements. Mike's quotes (or alleged quotes) of Hitler's lip service regarding "socialism" mean nothing. Propaganda. Hitler did not value socialism, except as fake rhetoric to advance the Nazi Party.

Clay F

From Britannica: Were the Nazis Socialists? What’s the difference between National Socialists and every other kind of socialist? Were the Nazis socialists? No, not in any meaningful way, and certainly not after 1934. But to address this canard fully, one must begin with the birth of the party. In 1919 a Munich locksmith named Anton Drexler founded the Deutsche Arbeiterpartei (DAP; German Workers’ Party). Political parties were still a relatively new phenomenon in Germany, and the DAP—renamed the Nationalsozialistische Deutsche Arbeiterpartei (NSDAP; National Socialist German Workers’ Party, or Nazi Party) in 1920—was one of several fringe players vying for influence in the early years of the Weimar Republic. It is entirely possible that the Nazis would have remained a regional party, struggling to gain recognition outside Bavaria, had it not been for the efforts of Adolf Hitler. Hitler joined the party shortly after its creation, and by July 1921 he had achieved nearly total control of the Nazi political and paramilitary apparatus. To say that Hitler understood the value of language would be an enormous understatement. Propaganda played a significant role in his rise to power. To that end, he paid lip service to the tenets suggested by a name like National Socialist German Workers’ Party, but his primary—indeed, sole—focus was on achieving power whatever the cost and advancing his racist, anti-Semitic agenda. After the failure of the Beer Hall Putsch, in November 1923, Hitler became convinced that he needed to utilize the teetering democratic structures of the Weimar government to attain his goals. Over the following years the brothers Otto and Gregor Strasser did much to grow the party by tying Hitler’s racist nationalism to socialist rhetoric that appealed to the suffering lower middle classes. In doing so, the Strassers also succeeded in expanding the Nazi reach beyond its traditional Bavarian base. By the late 1920s, however, with the German economy in free fall, Hitler had enlisted support from wealthy industrialists who sought to pursue avowedly anti-socialist policies. Otto Strasser soon recognized that the Nazis were neither a party of socialists nor a party of workers, and in 1930 he broke away to form the anti-capitalist Schwarze Front (Black Front). Gregor remained the head of the left wing of the Nazi Party, but the lot for the ideological soul of the party had been cast. Hitler allied himself with leaders of German conservative and nationalist movements, and in January 1933 German President Paul von Hindenburg appointed him chancellor. Hitler’s Third Reich had been born, and it was entirely fascist in character. Within two months Hitler achieved full dictatorial power through the Enabling Act. In April 1933 communists, socialists, democrats, and Jews were purged from the German civil service, and trade unions were outlawed the following month. That July Hitler banned all political parties other than his own, and prominent members of the German Communist Party and the Social Democratic Party were arrested and imprisoned in concentration camps. Lest there be any remaining questions about the political character of the Nazi revolution, Hitler ordered the murder of Gregor Strasser, an act that was carried out on June 30, 1934, during the Night of the Long Knives. Any remaining traces of socialist thought in the Nazi Party had been extinguished.

Above Average Dave

Important to note, while much of the American media was skeptical and then cautionary about Hitler, Mussolini was an absolute darling of the American media. After he invaded Ethiopia in 1935, they cooled a bit, but came back on board by 1937. At least, until he joined the Axis.

Ted Whalen

Bill- 100% agree about Downfall (bring me Fegelein)

Above Average Dave

Britanica is post-event and filled with revisionism, Clay, as is a lot of condensed anthologies. If you want to understand how it was presented, received by the German people and the world and perceived pre-WWII, go read the newspapers such as The NY Times, the Hearst papers of the day and magazines like Time and The Saturday Evening Post from, say, 1931 until, well, 1939 and that lovely style-house proud-type piece time did on the German Chancellor. You'll be reading about a completely different reality, but one that rule perception until Sept 1, 1939. Oh, and if you read Shirer's early reporting from Germany that he did for the Hearst newspapers, it's nothing like The Rise and Fall. It was similar to many of his cohorts - laudatory of the economic situation, the realative wealth of the middle class and the very socialist involvment by the government in public life, from The Hitler Youth, to control of the media and direct control of school curriculum. But as I said, his government ultimately had more in common with Gangsters/The Mafia or, if you prefer governmental analogies, with Genghis Kahn, the pre-parliamentary kings of Europe and the Dynastic Emperors of Asia.

Mike Lemon

"and it was entirely fascist in character." See my second comment (the Mussolini one).

TheSingulatarian

If you want to see a Holocaust movie that in my opinion is better than "The Pianist" or "Shindler's List" watch "The Gray Zone"(2001) Directed by Tim Blake Nelson. A group of men put into an impossible situation have to make a deal with the Nazi 's but ultimately find some redemption.

Henry Graham

This film is an extraordinary achievement. Polanski's greatest films are the ones in which his own trauma is to the fore. Chinatown and Macbeth are both haunted by the death of Sharon Tate, and in The Pianist he melds his personal experience with Władysław Szpilman to create an unforgettable narrative of pain, loss and improbable survival. Polanski's mastery of space is astonishing, you can feel life and death in the margins of every shot, and he creates images you can't unsee.

Stick Figure Studios

Another thing that I've noticed Polanski tends to do is tell his stories very subjectively. The camera is often placed near the protagonist and the audience experiences things through his/her eyes. I first noticed it in CHINATOWN and then when I saw this in the theater, I couldn't help but catch that so much of the story is told from Spizlman's POV. He is in virtually every scene and often we see things from a distance just as he does.

Henry Graham

Yes, that's a great point, it's a definite hallmark of his filmmaking. There's something chillingly flat and unaffected about the way Polanski depicts the violence and cruelty in this film, which makes it even more horrific to watch. We are trapped in the role of mute witnesses, just as Szpilman is.

thansen

I put off watching Polanski's movies because of some awful things he did but then I found out some of the things he went through and maybe relaxed my criticisms a bit. There is no doubt, however, the man is talented. One of my favorite Shakespeare adaptations is his brutal and stunning Macbeth. A funny vampire movie called The Fearless Vampire Killers, of which he and Sharon Tate star. Rosemary's Baby, which is just as good as the masterful novel by Ira Levin. Oddly enough, the one movie I thought I would love is Tess, but while it is beautifully shot and produced, I found it mostly dull.

Mike Lemon

"Mike's quotes (or alleged quotes) of Hitler's..." 1- Quote from Hitler according to Otto Wagener, in Hitler—Memoirs of a Confidant, editor, Henry Ashby Turner, Jr., Yale University Press (1985) p. 170 2- As quoted by Otto Wagener in Hitler—Memoirs of a Confidant, editor, Henry Ashby Turner, Jr., Yale University Press (1985) p. 288 3- German Volksgenossen! Hitler's opening speech at the new Winterhilfswerk, Deutschlandhalle, Berlin, (October 5, 1937) - Speeches 4- As quoted in Hitler—Memoirs of a Confidant, Otto Wagener editor, Henry Ashby Turner, Jr., Yale University Press (1985) p. 16 5- As quoted in Hermann Rauschning, The Voice of Destruction, New York: NY, G.P. Putnam's Sons (1940) p. 131. "...Hitler's lip service regarding "socialism" mean nothing. Propaganda." Is it only propaganda when it counters your narrative?

Stick Figure Studios

Yeah, while it's certainly no excuse at all for what he did, the man has been through more than his share of tragedy. There's enough drama in his life for three movies.

Clay F

Did you read the Britannica piece how Hilter paid lip service to socialism as propaganda to grow the Nazi Party? Alleged quotes? I will assume the quotes are true. But even as you note: "according to Otto Wagener" or "As quoted by Otto Wagener" -- no one else saw or heard Hitler make those two quotes.

Scott Macaulay

Well you’ve seen WW2 from the Polish side, Americans, Jews, the Brits and Soviets. Time to watch Downfall and see inside final days of the beasts behind it all….

Mike Lemon

Otto Wagner is the author of the book, it doesn't mean he was alone with Hitler and "no one else saw or heard Hitler make those two quotes". "Did you read the Britannica piece" Above Average Dave went over that.

Brian's Dog

Great reaction! The bread in this film looked so good, every loaf.

Gray

Yeah Downfall is fantastic, Stalingrad 1993 is really good also but is brutal too. Letters from Iwo Jima & Tora Tora Tora from Japanese perspective

fastecp1

This was hard to watch. I will never understand cruelty to others. I did not trust the man who took his watch. I saw that coming a mile away. And I had a feeling that the German officer wouldn't kill him for a few reasons: he knew the war was ending. And he knew he would have a lot to answer for when he met his maker, and the German race looks up to strength, survival, and people with skills. I'm not saying he didn't have good in him, but it doesn't erase all the bad he had done up to that point. I love true stories; they are some of the hardest to watch.

Stick Figure Studios

DOWNFALL has what is in my opinion the greatest performance an actor gave playing Adolf Hitler, and it was by the normally warm and lovable Bruno Ganz no less.

Clay F

True about the quotes, but I go with Britannica over you. Even Above Average Dave acknowled that Hitler's government ultimately had more in common with Gangsters/The Mafia. Any state control by Hitler was not driven by socialism [an aim to create a more equitable society] but by his facist quest for power and to implement his right-wing political ideology. "Were the Nazis socialists? No, not in any meaningful way, and certainly not after 1934." "To say that Hitler understood the value of language would be an enormous understatement. Propaganda played a significant role in his rise to power. To that end, he paid lip service to the tenets suggested by a name like National Socialist German Workers’ Party, but his primary—indeed, sole—focus was on achieving power whatever the cost and advancing his racist, anti-Semitic agenda." "... the brothers Otto and Gregor Strasser did much to grow the party by tying Hitler’s racist nationalism to socialist rhetoric that appealed to the suffering lower middle classes. ... however .... Hitler had enlisted support from wealthy industrialists who sought to pursue avowedly anti-socialist policies. Otto Strasser soon recognized that the Nazis were neither a party of socialists nor a party of workers, and in 1930 he broke away." "Hitler allied himself with leaders of German conservative and nationalist movements ... Hitler’s Third Reich had been born, and it was entirely fascist in character. ... Hitler achieved full dictatorial power [of Germany] ... communists, socialists, democrats, and Jews were purged from the German civil service, and trade unions were outlawed .... prominent members of the German Communist Party and the Social Democratic Party were arrested and imprisoned in concentration camps." "Hitler ordered the murder of Gregor Strasser [the sole remaining Nazi leader who legitimately supported socialist ideas] ... carried out on June 30, 1934 ... Any remaining traces of socialist thought in the Nazi Party had been extinguished."

K, Zachary

Cassie, As soon as she got home she changed. We watched this she said she was looking forward to all day too. We thought that you putting this off subconsciously because it was going to be a hard watch. At least that's what we quietly thought. In the movie you see against a ocean of intolerance you see little glimpses of humanity shine through and all though these people are in the minority there actions make all the difference in the world. Since we're all human, we all have an obligation to care about abuses that deny the human dignity of others. This was definitely a hard watch both of us were so impressed by your reaction Cassie. Other Polanski movies for people to consider are. Chinatown, Tess and the Fearless Vampire Killers. Are just some movies we liked She is already asleep. Now I have to fight with the dogs for a spot. Have a good night everyone.

Catherine LW

Took the words right out of my mouth. Cassie has seen all theaters, various perspectives and campaigns, all that’s missing is an inside look at the end of the Third Reich in Hitler’s underground bunker in Berlin. Bruno Ganz gave a brilliant performance which astonished me as the only performances prior to this bordered on parody. Another great but little known film is Sophie Scholl: The Final Days. True story about Munich University students who form The White Rose, in resistance to Hitler’s war and policies. Sophie, her brother Hans and their friend Cristophe are captured, interrogated by the Gestapo, and prosecuted at trial. Very moving story about the courage of one’s convictions, no matter the dreadful consequences.

2-Can

There is a good book about him called The Volunteer, if you’re interested. This guy deserves to be well-known .

Robert da Spruce

I haven’t watched this since it came out in 2002. I remember it being incredibly heartbreaking and sad at the time. This film hits different in 2025 though This is not the place for such conversations. So I’ll leave it at that I know this was very difficult to watch Cassie. Thank you for sticking with it

Stick Figure Studios

All stories about Nazi Germany hit differently in 2025 than they used to.

Ted Whalen

Catherine- 100% agree about Sophie Scholl the final days. It is such an amazing story about a group of college students who were trying to make a difference, despite knowing what the consequences would be.

Mike Lemon

Find different sources of news.

Catherine LW

BTW, the tool with the bread and jam that Szpilman received from Captain Hosenfeld was an old fashioned can opener!

Joe J

It's hard for me to get past the POS director.

Scott Macaulay

Downfall would be an excellent bookmark to Cassie’s Ww2 odyssey.

Joe J

I feel like I'm back in high school history class, lol. Just a thought, maybe reddit would be a better place for this.

Mike Lemon

I've offered to talk on reddit many times ( u/MikeLemon ), but nobody takes me up on it.

Clay F

Mike — you do agree that Hitler exerted autocratic control not as an aim to create a more equitable society but instead to implement his right-wing political ideology?

Bill Maurer

I've read "The Auschwitz Volunteer: Beyond Bravery" which was his official report about his time in Auschwitz transcribed into English. I also read "A Rebel in Auschwitz" by Jack Fairweather ... both excellent books. "A Rebel in Auschwitz" was more of a biography of him. Both excellent books.

Tyler Foster

The thing about news is that it ought to be the same no matter where you hear it if it's being reported correctly. Otherwise what you're looking for is opinion.

Mike Lemon

"you do agree that Hitler exerted autocratic control " Yes. "implement his right-wing political ideology" No. "Right wing", especially American right, is diametrically opposed to Nazism and fascism (and we may as well throw in any other form of socialism). That is what everyone has been telling you this entire time.

Mike Lemon

@Tyler- -A man travels through time to save a woman he has only seen in a photograph. -An AI sends a soldier to the past to save the AI in the "present". -A woman learns to be a bad-ass by fighting off a killing machine bent on ending her. Those are all true quick summaries of The Terminator, all different depending on what the "reporter" was inclined to see. And that isn't even touching on intentional deception to push a narrative or gain votes for "their side" or even straight up lying or even stupidity. Then there is the problem of what are the "facts". I could give example for days, from Covid, to politics, to entertainment, to language itself.

Clay F

The majority of scholars identify Nazism in both theory and practice as a form of far-right politics. Far-right themes in Nazism include the argument that superior people have a right to dominate other people and purge society of supposed inferior elements. That’s what I been trying to tell you.

Coleton B.

Hi, Mike! No need to give examples; please adhere to Rule 3 and refrain from discussing political topics in open channels, thanks so much and I apologize for any inconvenience!

Mike Lemon

I didn't discuss anything political so keep it to yourself and stop harassing people!

Coleton B.

I'm sorry you feel as though being reminded of the rules by which you've agreed to abide feels like harassment, but it's not. No need to be so confrontational! Try to have a better day!

Mike Lemon

"being reminded of the rules by which you've agreed to abide" ...by rules WHICH I DID abide... "feels like harassment," Because it is. We can know that because the people that DID TALK POLITICS got no mention from you. So again, stop harassing me.

Tyler Foster

The guy is a moderator enforcing the rules. He's not harassing you. He's doing his job.

Mike Lemon

"The guy is a moderator..." Yes. "...enforcing the rules." None were broken, hence my comment.

Milton Reduxed

I'm surprised you didn't just go ahead and start whining about Sydney Sweeney's fascist jeans advert

Dave

Terry, please remove this comment and please refrain from further political commentary in future comments.

Keith Jacobsen

Movies like this really give me a reality-check and remind me to be thankful for the small things, or things that SEEM small in the present, like having a full fridge/pantry, unlimited clean water in my tap, a warm bed to sleep in, and living in relative peace. Also how fleeting all those things can be, that they CAN be taken away.

Milton Reduxed

Britain were standing alone against Germany through 1940 into 1941 while all of mainland Europe had either surrendered, cooperated, remained neutral or been defeated; So I wouldn't call Britain weak And it was Japan then Germany who declared war on the USA bringing them in

Milton Reduxed

Funny how America is supposedly so awful but everyone wants to flee there for safety & prosperity

Catherine LW

I think the weakness was military. Both Britain and France disarmed after WWI, thinking it was the war to end all wars. They were exhausted and depleted- losing almost a generation of young men. Churchill warned Britain to re-arm itself in the 30’s, seeing Germany break the Versailles Treaty, but he was a backbencher and no one listened. When war broke out, Britain begged for ships and materiel. Even their newly formed SAS had no small arms to carry in their missions except for those donated by the NYPD in the US. They were rolling out cannons from museums to guard their coast. Fortunately the spirit of the British people held up when they stood alone.

Ted Whalen

Gabor- I just saw that there is a new Nuremberg movie (Nuremberg 2025) that is going to be released in November. It sounds like the movie will focus on psychiatrist Douglas Kelley who is challenged to see if Hermann Goring (who is played by Russell Crowe) is fit to stand trial. https://youtu.be/YJieVh-PLYs?si=lkell0y7zVJoRL-w

Zane From Canada

Is anyone else having synchronization issues?

Clay F

Milton -- Britain was unable to do anything about Germany invading Poland anytime soon. In the movie, the Jewish Polish family was so happy hearing on the radio in 1939 that Britain had declared war on Germany b/c of the german invasion of Poland -- the family was saying everything is going to be alright -- big relief.

Clay F

I didn't.

Zane From Canada

My copy (DVD) is going slightly faster than the recording. I'm having to constantly pause.

Clay F

Her stream of the movie synced perfectly with my stream of the movie on US Amazon Prime. If your DVD is a European DVD that could be 25 fps, whereas her stream is 24 fps. If that's the case, you could speed up her reaction slightly by a factor of 1.0426: 1. If streaming her reaction on a PC or laptop, right click on her reaction video and then click "inspect". 2. Then go to the console tab in the new window that pops up and copy/paste or type in: document.querySelector('video').playbackRate = 1.0426

Zane From Canada

That could explain it. I think my copy is European.

Above Average Dave

That's....not a "far right" theme, Clay - it's a human theme (and endemic in primates and many mammals in general if you look at their tight groups). To characterize this as "far right" is to ignore analogous actions of the "far left," as well. Clearly, the theme of tribal/village/city-state/national superiority is theme of humans since tribalism and blossomed under city states. Go look Sumeria, Babylon, Persia, the Assyrian Empire, the Egyptians, Greeks (espcially under Alexander), Romans, Mayans, Incas, and especially the Aztecs, virtually all of the American Indian tribes, all Chinese, Japanese and Southeastern Asia empires, virtually every empire of Europe and India and on and on. It is difficult to look at any era or poltical system where this behavior and attitude wasn't part the stated or unstated but tacit philosophy of countries left-center- and right-leaning. This urge/behavoir does not reside in any political phiosophy exclusively and is — very sadly — endemic to the human race. The evidence of history proves it over and over again. In fact, it so prevalent and endemic, my greatest fear about this behavior is that may be somehow encoded in or DNA.

Clay F

Dave -- good reply but surely you acknowledge the nomenclature widely used = terms like "far-right" or "alt-right" for groups like Nazis (or neo-Nazis) and white supremacists. These groups generally united by their extreme interpretations of right-wing politics and often promoting ideas such as racial supremacy, nationalism, and anti-immigration sentiments. Below is well written and informative. Far-right politics, often termed right-wing extremism, encompasses a range of ideologies that are marked by ultraconservatism, authoritarianism, ultranationalism, and nativism. This political spectrum situates itself on the far end of the right, distinguished from more mainstream right-wing ideologies by its opposition to liberal democratic norms and emphasis on exclusivist views. Far-right ideologies have historically included reactionary conservatism, fascism, and Nazism, while contemporary manifestations also incorporate neo-fascism, neo-Nazism, supremacism, and various other movements characterized by chauvinism, xenophobia, and theocratic or reactionary beliefs. Key to the far-right worldview is the notion of societal purity, often invoking ideas of a homogeneous "national" or "ethnic" community. This view generally promotes organicism, which perceives society as a unified, natural entity under threat from diversity or modern pluralism. Far-right movements frequently target perceived threats to their idealized community, whether ethnic, religious, or cultural, leading to anti-immigrant sentiments, welfare chauvinism, and, in extreme cases, political violence or oppression. According to political theorists, the far right appeals to those who believe in maintaining strict cultural and ethnic divisions and a return to traditional social hierarchies and values. In practice, far-right movements differ widely by region and historical context. In Western Europe, they have often focused on anti-immigration and anti-globalism, while in Eastern Europe, strong anti-communist rhetoric is more common. The United States has seen a unique evolution of far-right movements that emphasize nativism and radical opposition to central government.

Clay F

There is both left-wing terrorism and right-wing terroism. Below is taken from the Wikipedia section entitled "Right-wing terrorism." Right-wing terrorism, hard right terrorism, extreme right terrorism or far-right terrorism is terrorism that is motivated by a variety of different right-wing and far-right ideologies. It can be motivated by Ultraconservatism, ultranationalism, neo-Nazism, anti-communism, neo-fascism, ecofascism, ethnonationalism, religious nationalism, anti-immigration, anti-semitism, anti-government sentiment, patriot movements, sovereign citizen beliefs, and occasionally, it can be motivated by opposition to abortion, or homophobia... ...Although they frequently take inspiration from Fascist Italy and Nazi Germany with some exceptions, right-wing terrorist groups frequently lack a rigid ideology. Right-wing terrorists tend to target people who they consider members of foreign communities, but they may also target political opponents, such as left-wing groups and individuals. ... they are targeted because they are representatives of groups which are considered foreign, inferior and threatening by them.

Clay F

Merely because the Nazis exerted autocratic state control does not make them socialist. The Nazis have long been labeled and identified as far right and facist in nature by the vast majority. The Nazis, despite having "Socialist" in their name (and despite Hilter's self-serving rhetoric and propaganda), were not truly socialist in their ideology or practices: *Core Tenets: Socialism, at its core, advocates for collective ownership or control of the means of production to achieve greater social equality and reduce income disparities. Nazism, on the other hand, was a far-right, totalitarian ideology based on nationalism, racism (particularly antisemitism), anti-Marxism, and anti-democracy. *Rejection of Socialist Ideas: Adolf Hitler and the Nazis actively suppressed and banned left-leaning parties like the Communists and Social Democrats, who advocated for socialist principles. They also dismantled trade unions, which traditionally played a key role in socialist movements. *Economic Control vs. Ownership: While the Nazi government exerted significant control over the economy, particularly in relation to wartime production and resource allocation, this was more aligned with fascist economic theories focused on state benefit and power rather than collective ownership for social equality. Private ownership of businesses, though heavily regulated, generally continued under the Nazi regime. *Propaganda and Misdirection: The term "socialist" in the party's name and Hilter's selective use of the word "socialism" for the Nazis were utilized strategically to attract working-class voters, where socialist and communist parties were influential. However, the Nazis' true ideological goals were far removed from traditional socialist aims. While the Nazis used the term "Socialist" in their name and exerted autocratic control over factors of production and public life, their core ideology and actions were opposed to fundamental principles of socialism.

Clay F

I am not going to say anymore in this thread. I've already said way too much. Plus, I don't really have time.

Bill Maurer

yup ... been saying that for sometime. Bruno Ganz (RIP) was phenomenal in that movie.

Catherine LW

No, I used a digital version.

My_Cousin_Mose

Rule number 3 has always been and seems to still be very unevenly enforced.

Milton Reduxed

Yes but framing it as Britain being weak is not how I would characterise it so much as Germany being the most formidable military in Europe, with a larger army than Britain, and added strategic advantage of bordering Poland

Clay F

Milton -- good point. The word "weak" wasn't a good choice but lazy. I think I did say "compared to." Britain had a powerful army. Strategic issues.

Catherine LW

I agree. Unlike Spielberg, Polanski does not manipulate emotions. While I think Spielberg is an excellent director, I think he is frequently manipulative, using music to influence the viewer’s emotions. I know many like the scene in Schindler’s List where Schindler breaks down and says “I could have saved more”, it didn’t happen and was contrary to Schindler’s character. He was stoic and unemotional. That scene didn’t ring true to me. Polanski is a pervert and creep, but I think he is a better filmmaker.

Henry Graham

I have similar reservations about Schindler's List. Spielberg's intuitive filmmaking gifts are frequently on display in that film, but you can feel his desperation to try and find a tonal balance to the horrors that he captures in the film's first half. Aspects like the child in the red coat, the cheap suspense around the shower/gas scene, or yes, Schindler's emotional collapse at the end (he's a much more compelling character when he's protecting Jews purely for his own monetary gain) are all details that reveal Spielberg's humanist/populist instincts clashing with the material. Polanski is far from a humanist, and the sheer banality of the cruelty and suffering he depicts in The Pianist makes it get under the skin more.

VOCFM

If only this movie wasn't made by a man who drugged and molested (kind way to put it) a 14 year old girl, and then skipped to Europe because he was going to be arrested. Crazy that actors don't care if they support a literal paedophile as long as its a movie on this topic, seemingly. Exceptionally hard thing to look past, which isnt a comment on the movie itself, it's just gross

VOCFM

exceptionally hard when it's blatantly obvious he did it

VOCFM

"He was later declared a Righteous Gentile" LOL direct implication that us goy are unrighteous by default LOL