Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

FINAL POPCORN IN DREAD POLL

  • Final Destination (2000) 446
  • Van Helsing (2004) 312
  • Carrie (1976) 471
  • Friday the 13th (1980) 282
  • Dawn of the Dead (2004) 299
  • They Live (1988) 298
  • 2025-10-03
  • —2025-10-06
  • 2108 votes
{'title': 'FINAL POPCORN IN DREAD POLL', 'choices': [{'text': 'Final Destination (2000)', 'votes': 446}, {'text': 'Van Helsing (2004)', 'votes': 312}, {'text': 'Carrie (1976)', 'votes': 471}, {'text': 'Friday the 13th (1980)', 'votes': 282}, {'text': 'Dawn of the Dead (2004)', 'votes': 299}, {'text': 'They Live (1988)', 'votes': 298}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 10, 6, 5, 59, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 10, 3, 15, 30, 16, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 2108}

Content

Here are the top 3 from each of our previous Popcorn in Dread polls!

Multiple votes allowed, ends Sunday at midnight!

LIVE PICK A FLICK TONIGHT AT LIKE 5 or 6PM-I will do a post the second I know for sure!

Comments

djKENTO

Glad to see a certain film didn’t make the cut. Voted for They Live. Not totally a horror film or whatever but it’s one of my favorites and it’s more relevant every day.

Jake McNulty

It's gonna have to be "They Live" for me.

Jake McNulty

Hope one day Cassie decides to watch the original Romero "Dawn of the Dead"

Above Average Dave

I've been dreading this. HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA! (ahem). Hope you're well, Cassie.

William Brownlee

Carrie will probably win. Most people have heard of it or the remake, but I am not a big fan. Horror movies in general I avoid. But "They Live" is a little more science fiction.

Andrew Heller

I mean carrie is a classic, but van helsing is a ton of fun….hopefully she watches it sometime, final Destination just like the scream series, i just couldnt get into…not to say they were bad just not into them

Obie Brown

Seeing her experience all the Final Destination films will be a hoot!

Doc Larry/old geezer

This was going to be a fun Halloween season for Cassie and the gang. Especially now with the boys getting older. there’s so many movies to choose from as well.

Macabre Movie Maniac

Alex, let's go take a $hit. Go ahead and take a $hit by yourself. Do you want them to associate you with that watery sting in their eye-that reflexive gag at the back of their throat? 🤣🤣🤣🤣

Thomas Cooney

This is a relatively "weak" list, in my opinion lol - some are classics, some are just blood-filled "fun," but all in all kind of senseless... I'm torn.

Bill W

Pass on all of these.

Joe J

FD and Fri 13th make for great reactions. Carrie is very over-rated IMO. I think of They Live as more a sci-fi film.

Jack

I feel both excited and sorry to have Cassie go through the Final Destination movies. As much as we love her, we love to see her suffer more haha

Carlos

Carrie :~)

Story Archer

You know, I just thought of the PERFECT 'scary but not too scary' Halloween movie - the original Flatliners. It actually takes place in and around Halloween and has an absolutely star-studded cast at a time many of them were relative unknowns... it even kind of has a good message in its resolution.

MikeLL

Carrie is a fine choice I'm happy to go with, but I threw in a vote for Friday the 13th also.

MrKsummer7

These can’t be the only films Cassie’s planning to watch in October?

Natalie Mangan

I just want They Live for her reaction to the fight.

Story Archer

I had to go with Van Helsing here. Not a real fan of any of the films but I'm always down for Kate Beckinsdale in a corset. Speaking of which... what about Underworld? Has she seen those?

Walter

Nope. She said there were some already in the pipeline.

Walter

oh hey, that's a good one

Shehab Dawoud

There’s no way she’s going through all of them. It’ll be by 2030 if she does.

Shehab Dawoud

Did I hear right that the top 2 will get a reaction?

baz0348

She's seen underworld it's on her YouTube channel

Story Archer

Thanks - not sure how I missed that one.

Big Lazy Dragon

Voted for both Carrie & Friday the 13th, but I rooting for Carrie to win. Not only was it based on Stephen King's first published novel, but it was also the first of over 100 movies & television adaptations to be based on his work.

Walter

It's funny, I think I dread Halloween reactions as much as Cassie. For me though it's because I really don't like most of the typical "horror/scary" films out there. I went with Carrie because it's the closest to being an actual classic. And Van Helsing because, I don't know...Hugh Jackman?

Joe J

No chance of it ever being watched...unless a PAF winner.

Collar City Guy

I came here to chew bubblegum and vote in a poll, and I'm all out of bubble gum!

MrKsummer7

How did They Live get on the list? It's a science fiction/action film, not a suspense thriller. Honestly, Carrie isn't anything either until the end. Van Helsing, what a waste of a good idea. The film did so poorly at the box office, it's one of the reasons Stephen Sommers hasn't directed anything since 2013.

Joe J

Yes.

Brent Petty

Forget Hugh. Kate Beckinsale is in Van Helsing.

Dave

No

Brent Petty

My prediction is she will be reacting to The Exorcist at exactly a quarter to NEVER.

Patrick Flanagan

Ugh, two weeks movies in the lead. At least VAN HELSING is falling behind

Will

interesting to see so much negativity to final destination. I think they're peak silly fun horror movies.

Jonathan Caro

They Live, Final Destination or Carrie…

Story Archer

Really? Why do you say that?

Joe J

I predict Cassie will save The Exorcist for her last channel reaction before her retirement.😆

James Damar

All of these would be fun to see :)

Joe J

Story - IMO, the film could never win or place on any poll. Cassie would never pick it as a PPoTM.

Joe J

Is the poll decided already? Okay, give it a few more hours, lol.

Bill W

That's not enough to make it worthwhile.

Joe J

FD will make for a great Cassie reaction, that's why I voted for it.

Bill W

Cassie isn't a spiteful person.....but I hope she never does it out of spite. It's the one movie she said she wouldn't watch and it's the one movie people consistently nag her about.

Stick Figure Studios

IMO the two best movies on this list are CARRIE and FINAL DESTINATION, so they have my vote. As much as I would love to see a VAN HELSING reaction because I just get a kick out of that movie, I can acknowledge that it's not very good, so despite it getting this far in the polls, I don't think it winning would make many people very happy. THEY LIVE and DAWN OF THE DEAD are both good and worth a watch, But I would love to see her react to the original George Romero DOTD before watching the remake. As for FRIDAY THE 13TH, while I realize it is a classic and the first of an iconic franchise, I've never been able to get through it. I've caught bits and pieces over the years and I just found it so awful that I never had any desire to finish it nor watch any of the other Jason movies. Maybe that makes me a bad cinephile. I don't know.

Stick Figure Studios

I'd love to see her watch the original and then react to the remake.

Stick Figure Studios

I agree. I doubt it'll happen though. At best we'll probably get the first one, but I do love those movies.

Stick Figure Studios

That is a non-negotiable hard no from her. It's a shame because I think it is quite possibly the greatest horror movie ever made, not just incredibly scary but also profound and poignant. THE EXORCIST is horror as art. Still, she has sworn that she will never watch it, which is ironic because given how far she's comevin her tolerance of scary and gory movies, I actually think she could handle it now.

Stick Figure Studios

Yeah, the negativity directed at FD in this group surprises me. I've always liked them myself and have found that they are, in general, pretty well-liked (and indeed the box office success of the most recent one guarantees the continuation of the franchise).

Joe J

Looks like Carrie and FD will be the winners. Carrie was never a favorite of mine. FD will make for a good reaction from Cassie...I hope, lol.

djKENTO

Jeepers Creepers.

Mark Vaderr

Anything but Final Destination. Hoping for Carrie.

Mark Vaderr

She still hasn't seen Night of the Living Dead.

Stick Figure Studios

Love it or hate it, CARRIE is a classic horrir film. I avoided it for a long time just because the picture on the video box used to scare me as a kid, but when I saw it parodied in a Tiny Toons episode, I realized I had to see it. By that point I was already a huge Brian DePalma fan, so I loved its surreal,hypnotic beauty (it plays like a fever dream). Despite being the first movie ever based on a Stephen King story, I still think it's one of the best. As for FD, I love those movies and agree that they would make for a great reaction (the extended set pieces are really something to behold).

Mark Vaderr

To be fair, this is Cassie's 5th year of doing this and she's seen a good amount of top notch horror films already. Yes, there are plenty more that she can see, especially old school classic films from the 1930's & 40's, even if they are considered tame by today's standards. This is not my favorite list either, but that's how it goes sometimes.

Stick Figure Studios

A solid creepy movie, but probably not considered scary enough by the horror buffs of this group to qualify as a legitimate contender for an October reaction. I suggested the Audrey Hepburn thriller WAIT UNTIL DARK once for "scary, but not too scary" month and it did not go over well.

Philip Alan

Exactly why I voted for it! 👍🏼

John Casamassa

Van Helsing and They Live are the only two I care about, which is probably why neither one will get watched.

Alex Gorell

So do I it’s my guilty pleasure really. Idc what people say it’s a fun movie.

YodatheHobbit

She also started early, pre october to fit more in.

Mark Vaderr

Van Helsing could've been a lot more. It had good potential, but I still thought it was a fun film. It did gross $120 million at the box office domestically, that's not poor. It wasn't a flop like say "Mars Attacks!" was.

John Casamassa

Van Helsing isn't a horror movie in the traditional sense at all. It's a monster movie in the same way as the Mummy movies (which were also Steven Sommers films), which both Cassie and Carly enjoyed. While I'm not going to claim that Van Helsing is a great movie by any stretch, I really don't understand the hate it's getting the comments.

Stick Figure Studios

I know. I'd love to see her react to that classic as well, though I don't think it's necessary to see before DOTD as they are completely isolated stories.

Blue Collar Hero

Most likely just burn out from seeing soo many other reactors already reacting to FD

YodatheHobbit

I know, one's good, the other my whole family kept laughing at after renting from Blockbuster.

Alex Gorell

Between GoT and Horror films I’m probably going to be skipping 90% of her reactions this month. Can’t wait for tender November.

Mark Vaderr

Van Helsing is a fun guilty pleasure. Unfortunate, because I think it could have been great. The potential was there. Imagine if Guillermo Del Toro had directed it.

Stick Figure Studios

@John: VAN HELSING has pretty much been a cinematic punching bag since it's release. I find it goofy and enjoyable, but it seems to make a lot of people really, really mad for some reason.

Stick Figure Studios

It's also got a killer masquerade ball sequence that puts the one in the musical PHANTOM OF THE OPERA movie (a story that is known for its spectacular masquerade ball scene) to shame.

YodatheHobbit

Mark Vaderr There are still SO many more interesting, more current and better written scary movies out there to be honest too. The Orphanage as one example. Also, one I just saw most of, not really scary, but more body horror... Blue My Mind. Gross and sad which actually turns into something I think Cassie might like at the end.

Mark Vaderr

I only saw the first Final Destination film, it's decent, but I despise it's ending. It was enough for me to avoid the sequels.

Walter

When I first saw The Mummy, I didn't like it because I wanted a more serious, Raiders of the Lost Ark type film. I watched with a mental reset and ended up really enjoying the movie. Van Helsing is very similar for me, except I haven't been able to do the 'mental reset' - the sillier aspects still really annoy me.

YodatheHobbit

Why did so many people start loving B/C movies?

Lennart Wollmershäuser

Carry and They Live are absolute classics. The original Dawn of the dead, too. The Remake has its moments, but is no match for Romero‘s atmospheric nightmare

Bill W

I don't think it's the gore or on-screen shock that she's opposed to.

Stick Figure Studios

@Mark Vader: You would probably appreciate the film's original ending. It was far more poignant and I personally prefer it to the theatrical ending... although the new finale was not enough to ruin the movie for me. Indeed I liked it all enough to watch (and enjoy to some degree or another) all the sequels. It's one of my favorite horror franchises.

Mark Vaderr

I love that the parody on Tiny Toons got you to watch Carrie, and I know which episode you are talking about. 🤣🤣🤣 There was also a good parody of Carrie on the television show "Medium".

Stick Figure Studios

@Walter: I had a similar initial reaction to THE MUMMY. Time and rewatches have helped me appreciate it more.

Stick Figure Studios

Agree that the Romero original his superior, but the remake was surprisingly good. Much better than it at any right to be.

Bill W

One of the Asian Angels called it "Game of Thorns"...so that's how I'll refer to it now. 😀 Thorn in my side! She could be doing like 20-30 more movies in place of the 1 series.

Stick Figure Studios

Tiny Toons not only made me feel smart for catching so many cinematic references, it also actually introduced me to a number of cinematic classics (I saw their parodies of CITIZEN KANE and SUNSET BOULEVARD before I ever watched the real things).

John Mellor

Final Destination? Who picked that over those classics? Some people here need to do some research on horror.

Russell

Friday the 13th is a must see. They Live and Carrie are both good but the Dawn of the Dead remake is mediocre when compared to the original. Watch the original before diving into questionable remakes. Final Destination is meh, kind of dumb, bored me. I think a great and fun Carly acceptable movie would be Fright Night (1985).

Gray

Looks like run away top 2. Final Destination will be entertaining and i've not seen Carrie. Dawn of the Dead is my pick, I remember seeing it when it came out at the cinema and being suprised at how entertaining it was, still love the original though. Day of the Dead (1985) probably still my favourite though.

Michael O'Connor

They Live is a Modern Statement whose message dwarfs that of the other films. They Live should be watched by all as should 1984, Idiocracy, Solent Green, Escape from New York and the other Dystopian Classics. Which might be a good New Poll I.e. "Dystopian Classics."

MrKsummer7

What helped kill Van Helsing was the really over-the-top, cheesy acting from all the characters whose names do not end with Jackman or Beckinsale. You can lay all that at the Director's feet. I was heavily in the film industry at the time this film came out. My friends and I are big-time horror fans, and we were excited when it was announced. But after watching a few times, we’ve come to loathe it, because practical effects should have been used for the monsters, not the poorly aged CGI it is now. Good idea ruined by bad writing, poor casting decisions, and obvious studio interference. Such a disappointment!

Joe J

GoT is very good for the channel. YT views are high and Cassie has gained like 800 new paying patrons. This is a business.

Just Plain Bob

The original Dawn of the Dead is the best zombie flick of all time IMO. But Day of the Dead doesn’t get nearly enough love. It’s a gem of a movie. Romero’s original dead trilogy is must see for cinephiles.

CJ Clontz

OMG Carrie!!!!! Classic!

Cliff Endicott

Can I have a write-in entry for "Stir of Echoes"?

Collar City Guy

Those who know know, those who do not perhaps I gave them a good laugh 😂, even if it's at me that's okay

Stick Figure Studios

Yeah, Stephen Sommers is not exactly a subtle director and the performance He got out of Richard Roxburgh in particular is incredibly hammy and over the top. I still enjoy it, but I get why folks were disappointed.

Stick Figure Studios

I don't know. I think the message of FINAL DESTINATION is pretty substantial as well and probably even more timeless and existential.

Stick Figure Studios

I did. I think FINAL DESTINATION and CARRIE are the two best films on here (though I will confess to not having seen FRIDAY THE 13TH and it's entirety, but what I have seen looked very poor).

Robert Evans

I can never forgive 'Day of the Dead' for its giant underground caverns in forking FLORIDA

MrKsummer7

Replace it on the list with Invasion of the Body Snatchers (1978). An excellent remake of the 1956 film. Great directing by Philip Kaufman. The performances by Donald Sutherland, Brooke Adams, Jeff Goldblum, and Veronica Cartwright are so believable and vivid. The film evokes a chilling feeling that there’s no hope as it slowly moves towards its end, then finishes off with an unforgettable scene that is truly haunting, even to this day. It’s a solid sci-fi horror classic, I believe Cassie could handle and not be too scared to watch.

Clay F

+1 for Dawn of the Dead 1978

Shehab Dawoud

The message in Carrie trumps both: Fuck around, find out!

K, Zachary

Here is the thing last year I was pushing Friday 13th pretty hard then a few people talk some sense into me. I stopped suggesting things because she gets so many but we watched Friday 13th in June for 40th anniversary and both of us agreed it wasn't for Cassie sure it would be to react to but we didn't think she would like it. Now Carrie is something that is one of the top 20 horror movies ever made and was nominated for an Academy Award for best supporting actress. Friday 13th although the franchise made up my teen years I wouldn't recommend for Cassie.

Richard Maurer

The best films, both on the first two polls and this one, got pushed out by the mediocre to bad ones, so it’s different day, same results as normal here.

Clay F

Plus, she is really liking it. She looks forward to GoT every week more than any other content. It's because she is invested in the characters.

Clay F

Carrie!!!!!

Richard Maurer

The FD films are generally considered to be pretty mild for the horror genre.

Clay F

Kate Beckinsale is hot but that can't salvage Van Helsing.

Vak

Of the clear top 2, I have to go with "Carrie" just because: a.) it's old and classic Stephen King - arguably before he kind of lost his stories in page count and booze, b.) it has a FANTASTIC cast that still holds up, and c.) I had a college professor way back in my freshman year who stuck it on the curriculum of a generic English class. (Speaking of which, the next time Cassie holds a poll/contest to pick a new TV show, somebody please remind me to suggest "Community.")

Clay F

Where did she say she would react to the top 2? I guess that means = Carrie and FD.

Shehab Dawoud

I’m pretty sure she said it during the trivia

Richard Maurer

Basically Flatliners is a film that could be watched any time of the year. So even though it’s a good movie and I might vote for it on a regular poll, I wouldn’t vote for it on a horror poll unless the other choices were really bad.

Javier Hernandez

Three classics, two pretty good ones, and Van Helsing a movie executive's fever dream that misses the mark at every opportunity (except for that slow-mo tilt up Kate Beckinsale's leather pants) . I hope it shakes out 1. Friday the 13 2. Carrie 3. They Live 4. Dawn of the Dead... if the either of the other two win then we reshuffle.

Richard Maurer

If I had dollar for every time someone asked for The Exorcist here I’d have a whole lot of dollars. And if Cassie reacted to it she’d have a whole lot of dollars. Which goes to show how strong her objection to watching it is, as I’m sure she realizes she’d get a LOT of views if she did watch it.

Richard Maurer

There’s a certain scene which, in a film full of monsters, manages to destroy my ability to suspend disbelief due to the sheer impossibility of what happens. Obliviously I can’t mention the scene, but you probably know at what stage of the movie it occurs ;-)

Richard Maurer

I don’t hate FD but there are better movies in this poll. That being said there are also Two bad movies in this poll and if either of them get closer to FD or Carrie I will add votes to help keep them in the lead.

Story Archer

Well, it's a horror/thriller set in and around Halloween - there are even Halloween costumes in it with Halloween themed-events going on in the background. Seems pretty on the nose to me.

Cole Jennett

She said on the upcoming post this week that she would watch the winner and runner-up

Richard Maurer

Voted for the two best films (imo, of course, which also happens to be the correct opinion ;-)) They Live and Dawn of the Dead. I don’t really care one way or another about FD or Carrie. But I will add votes FD and Carrie if it looks like Ft13th or VH are catching up, because I don’t want either of the bad films to win.

Richard Maurer

Dawn of the Dead. While I agree with the opinion of many here that the original ‘78 version was better, and in general don’t like remakes, this remake is actually quite good and it works as a stand alone film, different enough from the original that it wouldn’t negatively effect the original if it were to be watched after the remake. And seeing as the original isn’t in this poll I’m happy to vote for this one in its stead.

Richard Maurer

I get it, but I’m always going for a movie I consider a “real”, good, horror movie, especially at Halloween. But if it were between Flatliners, Van Helsing, and Friday the 13th, I pick Flatliners.

Richard Maurer

Her attempt at a Romanian accent was “cute” - but not enough to make me sit through that movie again.

Nick Ireland

I re-watched Friday the 13th a couple weeks ago. It really hasn't aged well at all., but I appreciate the nostalgia factor. I think Carrie would make the best reaction.

Stick Figure Studios

I've never really had a desire to see it. I've caught bits and pieces of it on TV over the years and it just looks terrible.

Stick Figure Studios

True, Shehab, But I also feel like that could be the message of just about any horror movie.

G

Carrie is such a classic

Richard Maurer

I’m not sure why They Live keeps getting the “it’s not a horror film” rap while in it’s the same poll as Van Helsing. VH is an action film first, horror distant second. Meanwhile TL is horror, just happens to be sci-fi based horror. This reminds me of Alien vs Aliens. Alien is definitely a horror film, but Aliens, while being a sequel, is first and foremost an action film. Both are in a sci-fi setting, but that doesn’t change the genres they truly belong to.

Stick Figure Studios

DAY OF THE DEAD is better than it's given credit for, but it's still the weakest of the original trilogy.

Mike Lemon

Welcome to the club. I've only watch 12.5 reactions this entire year.

Nick Ireland

I wouldn't waste your time. It's not one of the older horror movies that have now become cheesy or funny but still enjoyable, it's just incredibly dull.

Nathan Jasper

I mean, it's a slasher, of course it's dull.

Cole Jennett

Top 2 will be watched, it’s fairly safe

Wesley White

All are good choices, except "Final Destination" I hate that franchise! But with "Van Helsing" in third place I think there's hope for you to react to it which is something I've been wanting to see you and Carly react to since your reactions to "The Mummy" movies, and I got you two the matching T-shirts for the occasion like I did for you for the first Mummy movie lol! I don't care what people say about it, yes it has it's flaws, it's not perfect, it's not a masterpiece, but to me its got more positives than negatives, and it's a fun entertaining crossover/homage to the Universal classic Monster films, plus honestly as shockingly as this may sound, this is my favorite Hugh Jackman role that's not Wolverine, in fact this is my favorite role he's ever done while Wolverine is #2 to me lol! Heck, I love the movie so much that I have it completely memorized word for word and I have the soundtrack on my Ipod lol! It literally is the perfect scary/but not too scary movie, it's basically like "The Mummy" but with a Gothic tone! I just hope at some point this spooky season you and Carly get to watch it, I've been anxious for the past two years! All and all, good choices, love and support, Happy Spooky Season, and God bless y'all and the family🥰😇🙏🤗😉✌🌹

TheSingulatarian

Great movie but everybody and their brother has already reacted to it.

Clay F

So looks like Carrie and FD will be the 2 of the 6 to get a reaction. With her reacting to top 2, that means poll is essentially already decided. Will be reactions to both CARRIE (1976) and FINAL DESTINATION (2000). --Bye Van Helsing, Friday 13th, They Live, Dawn of the Dead. Bye "Dawn of the Dead" (2004). Watched 1978 original a few months ago and liked it. Liked that had a strong African-American male character -- not that common in movies in 1978. I read that the remake Dawn of the Dead (2004) (I have not seen) is worthy and violent but stripped away the political (or social) satire of original. Bye "Van Helsing" (2004). Why does the hot Kate Beckinsale do movies like VH and Underworld? Such a waste of scenery. Bye "Friday the 13th" (1980). In 1980, many people went to the theater to see Friday the 13th (1980). I was one of them. 45 years ago. I was 16 (they didn’t check IDs back then if you looked old enough which I did). I have not seen it since – that I can remember. The critics panned it. A definite fan vs critic divide at the time. Bye "They Live" (1988). I’ve been trying to decide if I want to watch this. Looks interesting but I wonder if it has aged well.

Mike Lemon

I am really curious how a "None of the Above" option would fare on some of these polls (but not from the horror-haters on horror polls, or any genre-haters on whatever genre). And I am even more curious how an alternative vote/instant run-off poll would have affected the original poles. None of these "winners" even got to 20%.

TheSingulatarian

Cassie might actually check out for "Day of the Dead" mid film. Tom Savni and Greg Nacarato do a first-rate job on the effects.

Cole Jennett

I’d imagine most people in here are more interested in Cassie’s reaction. Kind of irrelevant how many other reactors have done it.

Chad Laurence

Idk I think my list is better. Jeepers Creepers, The Ritual (2017), Fright Night (2011), Session 9 (2001), House on Haunted Hill (1999), Friday the 13th (2009). FD isn't terrible just idk, seems like a wasted vote. Carrie is whatever, not my cup of tee. Never cared for older horror movies. I can barely visually or audible handle a select few 80s horror movies. Gremlins being one of them. The Texas Chainsaw Masscre remake with Jessica Biel was "scary" at the time. Haven't watched it since I saw it in theaters lol.

Chad Laurence

There's better movies from the genre that are within the last 30 years that could be on this list. Dawn of the Dead 2004 is probably the best movie on this particular list.

Stick Figure Studios

The '78 INVASION OF THE BODY SNATCHERS is a terrific movie and I'd love to see a reaction to it. Unfortunately, it's not going to be replacing anything in this poll. We shall have to wait for another time for that one.

Clay F

Based on current votes, both Carrie and FD reached 20%. My guess is that any poll format would not alter Carrie and FD being the top 2. If she were reacting to only the top 1, then poll format could make a difference.

Rod Reavern

NONE of these movies are Halloween-themed -- Cassie could watch these any time of year (except the holidays, I guess). "Trick 'R Treat" (2007) is a far more fun and frightening movie to watch in October than any of those. Anyone who has actually seen the movie will include it in their annual Halloween movie marathon rotation -- it's a tragedy that not enough scary movie fans have seen it!

Russell

For a Halloween mix Carrie, Friday the 13th and the ORIGINAL Dawn of the Dead (not the 2004 one) make sense. Van Helsing? Meh, They Live (great movie but for Halloween?) and Final Destination- bleh, not a fan. To each their own. I will watch the Carrie reaction though.

Mike Lemon

@Clay- 2581 / 5 = 516.2 Neither Carrie (edit-513) nor Final Destination (edit-462) got there. And for completeness 2435 / 5 = 487 No movie in that poll got there either.

Clay F

Current 1,546 votes total (not 2581 or 2435) Carrie = 349/1546 = 22.6% FD = 330/1546 = 21.3%

Mike Lemon

"...would have affected the **original poles.** " (edit- Damn, just noticed the typo. Oh well.)

Mike Lemon

Add in Trick or Treat (1986) for a double feature and you have my vote.

Chris Thom

They're alright. Just done to death on reaction channels.

Clay F

Oh ok. I see what you are doing.

Chris Thom

Good one. Haven't seen that in a long time but vaguely remember Julia Roberts being in it.

Clay F

I hope you (and our other fellow patrons who like VH) get a reaction to VH one day -- you are a definite fan. Yet, here, I don't think VH will finish 3rd -- but will be close among the bottom 4.

Story Archer

Kiefer Sutherland, Oliver Platt, Kevin Bacon, William Baldwin and, of course, the good Miss Roberts. Knowing about this movie won me a lot of games of 'Seven Degrees of Kevin Bacon' back in the day, this one and 'He Said, She Said.'...

Alex Gorell

I’m curious as to what the .5 reaction was.

Just Plain Bob

There’s another important distinction between They Live and Van Helsing. Van Helsing sucks. I’m not a believer in Rotten Tomatoes scores to judge the artistic value of a film and Van Helsing is no exception. With a score of 24%, it’s way over-rated.

Chris Thom

Dawn of the Dead, Carrie, and Friday the 13th seem the most Halloween to me. They Live is good, but that's more sci-fi, and less seasonal. Final Destination movies are alright, but not my personal favorite. Van Helsing I don't remember much about.

Chris Thom

Hard to beat Trick 'r Treat as far as Halloween themed. It's pretty solid, too.

Chris Thom

Enjoyed the remake quite a bit.

MGCR

Just Plain Bob

Amen about Stephen King. To me, his best work was before “It” (several hundred pages too long and a horrible ending). By then, editors were afraid to actually EDIT. He was STEPHEN KING after all. And the decade plus of booze and drugs certainly didn’t help.

Just Plain Bob

Curious to know what else you liked. My top 3 King adaptations would be The Shining, Salem’s Lot (I know, everyone else hates it) and The Mist. I thought Carrie and Christine were very well done, just not scary. To me, they’re both supernatural dramas more than horror movies.

MGCR

Carrie, the Shining and IT with Bill Skarsgard.

Brandon Melling

What about The Shawshank Redemption? Or Misery?

MGCR

Dammit. Keep forgetting Shawshank was Stephen King.

Tim Weaver

Shining is a good movie but terrible adaptation. Changed soooo much. Fave adaptations for me would be 1. Misery 2. The Green Mile 3. Stand by Me 4. Sometimes they come back 5. Shawshank 6. Dead Zone

Richard Maurer

Clay - They Live has aged quite well, much like the film Idiocracy.

Kristin

They Live is a classic and a must, regardless of where it finishes in this poll.

Chris Thom

Dr. Sleep was pretty enjoyable. And Dead Zone. The IT miniseries was my favorite for a long time.

Chris Thom

Never heard of Sometimes They Come Back. Is that a newer one? Movie or show?

Clarence Newman

I like Carrie. It's also perfect for this channel because it's a combination of Cassie and Carly's names, which means that Carly would have to watch it too. A fusing of the two sisters into one reaction video, if you will. I think Cassie would appreciate the metaphor, especially if Ben made sure there was a bluebottle in the room while they were watching.

Brian Lowery

The DOTD remake doesn’t get nearly the amount of praise it should. Probably Zack Snyder’s best looking film next to Watchmen, and written by James Gunn, it features an amazing cast including Sarah Polley, Michael Kelly (steals the movie), Ving Rhames, and Ty Burrell.

Art of Free Speech

Carrie is okay, as a movie (and I love the joke Cassie/Carly=Carrie), but I still think Final Destination is so much more original, less gory, and more fun to watch, at least for me.

MrKsummer7

Well, on a positive note, if Carrie wins this poll, Cassie will experience another Brian De Palma Film. Hopefully, she’ll eventually see these Scarface (1983) Dressed to Kill (1980) Blow Out (1981) Carlito's Way (1993)

Brian's Dog

I like several things on this list, but I gotta go with Friday the 13th. It is the most culturally significant. Out of all the movies here it's the one likely to be used on general movie trivia nights. There is a good reason for that.

Clay F

1. Shawshank 2. The Green Mile 3. Misery 4. The Shining 5. Stand by Me 6. Christine

Clay F

I will watch it.

Clarence Newman

I'd be happy with Final Destination, Art. They're both on my wishlist.

Clarence Newman

JP Bob. I loved Salem's Lot when I was a kid. I was a Starsky & Hutch fan so I liked it for David Soul.

Clay F

Agree is culturally significant. Currently in last place. Carrie (1976) is also culturally significant. Was definitely part of the pop culture back in the day.

Clay F

As for Final Destination (2000), I am glad the poll entry is only for the single movie -- the original -- and not for the entire Final Destination franchise.

MrKsummer7

I have the director's cut version of D of the D ’04. I have watched it enough to know every part of the film. Even went to a private screening of it on the back lot of Universal, 2 months before the film premiered. Referring to political satire, what are you talking about?

John Cranberry

I'm gunning for FD so she can watch all 5 (don't care much for Bloodlines) 1 through 5 are the best. I have 5 on 3D and it's fricken awesome!

MGCR

OK, so what I'm understanding here is that it's only the miniseries that suck. It with Tim Curry, the Langoliers, the Tommyknockers, the Shining etc.

Stick Figure Studios

Yeah, I think one can make the argument that CARRIE is just as culturally significant. It's certainly the better movie.

Stick Figure Studios

It surprisingly good. Much better than it had any right to be.

Lennart Wollmershäuser

Yeah, it was. I do think the use of Johnny Cash's "The man comes around" has quite a bit to do with that, it just sets the tone so perfectly.

Stick Figure Studios

As I recall, one character in the movie even keeps accidentally calling Carrie by the name "Cassie."

Stick Figure Studios

Oh, there are much more than just 5 (especially in the last few years), but CARRIE Is definitely up there.

Mike Lemon

No love for Cujo or Pet Sematary?

Robert Baldino

It's easily the best and most interesting movie on this poll.

Clay F

I did not say the remake 2004 had political satire. The original 1978 had political (or social) satire, e.g., on race and consumerism.

Stick Figure Studios

I thought BLOODLINES was probably tied with the fifth one for second best of the whole series (though I do love each one to some degree... Even the fourth one which is easily the weakest).

Stick Figure Studios

I'd love it if she reacted to the whole series, but I doubt it will happen.

Nolofinwe

Watch the exorcist for God sakes and grow up -make your sister watch it with you. ! Be a Man: 😜

mikethemotormouth

I think this means that if and when she/they get to it, we have to keep referring to her as Carrie until she yells at someone "It's Cassie!" 😆

mikethemotormouth

Agreed a classic and a must, just not for October

Sarah Frost

Was it necessary to be so rude?

Clay F

My point was is we didn't vote for the whole series. Thus, I hope she doesn't auto-react to the whole series, which I agree is unlikely. But if she wants, that executive decision is her choice. I could see placing the franchise in a poll with other franchises. I could see placing FD2 in a sequels poll.

Andrew Heller

I dont understand that part…its made by the same guy who made The Mummy, which is lauded , but people hate van helsing…they pretty much mirror each other…a monster adventure with quirky sidekicks

Andrew Heller

I def think its burn out….like i said in one of my comments its not like they are terrible, its just very formulaic by now, between FD and Scream, they just dont hold my interest

Andrew Heller

Carrie is good and heartbreaking at the same time, thats why i think she would enjoy it more…its not total horror, but its def creepy

Andrew Heller

I agree with this wholeheartedly, Van Helsing is what it was intended to be…an excuse to have a bunch of universal monsters in one movie, but i thought they did it well! Its pretty much the mummy juiced up

Stick Figure Studios

Yeah, I can see that too. If FD2 were placed in a sequel's pole, I doubt it would get the same enthusiasm that SCREAM 2 did... but then that might all depend on how she reacts to the first one.

Andrew Heller

I keep forgetting about The Dead Zone….its not super scary and pretty good!

Andrew Heller

She should watch Executive Decision lol

Clarence Newman

Still on it, Flag. Back home Tuesday. Had to do 14 days given the 10 hour flight.

Richard Maurer

I don’t like The Mummy very much either, but It’s better than Van Helsing.

Tyler Hale

Night of the Living Dead was never recommended?

Chris Thom

The one with the roller coaster opening was pretty good. Or that intro was at least. Pure nightmare material. That scene was very well done.

Chris Thom

I always see the sequels or remakes get requested a lot more for some reason.

Chris Thom

Good one. I always forget about that one too. Stranger Things had some references to it I think.

Gray

perhaps next October she can do the original Night & Dawn of the Dead

Walter

@Andrew I can only speak for myself, but I think The Mummy balances action, humor, and a sort of tongue in cheek silliness. You’re right that Van Helsing does the same, but I think the balance is off.

Chris Thom

Also curious what the half reaction was. lol

Chris Thom

Doubt Carly would stick around for that. She barely made it through a prestige thriller with Harrison Ford and Michelle Pfeiffer, directed by the guy who made Forrest Gump and Back to the Future.

Chris Thom

Was it always considered a classic? Or was it revisited later and reappraised?

casual_juergen

I went for Carrie, because it is a classic and for me fits "scary not too scary". And Van Helsing, because I think Mrs. PiB would enjoy it the most out of this list.

Chris Thom

The amount of comments on these has been cut in half. We need your linguistic and conversational skills back.

Nolofinwe

hahahaha. i gave it a shot ! lol

Nolofinwe

it was "tongue-in-cheek". geeze ! give it a rest

John Casamassa

@Stick Figure Studios Yeah, and I have no idea why. It's not a masterpiece by any stretch, but it's fun, pays pretty good homage to the old school Universal monster movies, and has one of the best monster smackdowns in all of cinema as the finale. Been waiting for a Van Helsing reaction on this channel for literal years, but I don't think it's going to happen.

Richard Maurer

I recommend it every Halloween, but my recommendations rarely make the polls and I believe it’s only a coincidence when they do.

Richard Maurer

People really take “stuff” way too seriously here, don’t they?

Richard Maurer

Sad that Van Helsing is in 3rd place……should be at the bottom where it belongs.

Richard Maurer

After the second one the quality really drops off. I haven’t seen Bloodlines because I can’t make myself care. Especially when there so many new, interesting horror films out that I haven’t seen yet.

Richard Maurer

The later Ft13th movies are much more “culturally significant” than the first one. She could watch part 3, 4, or 6 and have a better grasp of its “ cultural significance”. Not like it really matters if you see the first one.

Richard Maurer

Why not for October? More of a horror movie than many of the movies that get watched in October. I mean, look at last year.

Happy Hanukkah

"... I believe it’s an error when they do." FTFY. :-P

Clarence Newman

Except the one in Horror of Dracula. He can stay.

Clarence Newman

Cassie will be happy. It only takes her two hours to read the comments now instead of four.

Clay F

Yeah -- I am somewhat surprised it in 3rd place -- but it's 3rd place is not by much. The bottom 4 grouped close together in the high 200s votes (274-297) -- all within 1.2%. A surprising 3rd place but not necessarily an impressive 3rd place. 3. Van Helsing - 14.8% 4. They Live - 14.2% 5. Dawn of the Dead - 14.0% 6. Friday the 13th - 13.6% The top 2 (Carrie and FD) are well over 400 votes. 1. Carrie - 22.4% 2. FD - 21.1%

Clarence Newman

That's just the Patreon default. Cassie will rectify that shortly. Won't you, Cassandra?

Clay F

CURRENT Carrie - 22.4% FD - 21.0% VH - 14.7% They Live - 14.2% Dawn - 13.9% Friday - 13.7%

Obie Brown

The FD movies fluctuate in quality, but the good ones are genuinely fun.

Richard Maurer

Why is this poll so long? No film has changed its position since the beginning. Can we end it already?

Clarence Newman

She will. She just hasn't got round to it yet. Kind of get the feeling Cassie is not reading the comments so much at the moment. Haven't seen any likes for a while. There'll be a reason for it, though. Sometimes she just needs a time-out.

Clarence Newman

Interesting that Friday the 13th is dead last. I'm not a fan of the film, but even I know it's iconic.

Richard Maurer

Seriously, I don’t really care about ending this poll that much. Nothing’s going to catch up with FD and Carrie anyway. It’s just funny that several polls have been ridiculously long recently.

Clarence Newman

10 days is apparently the Patreon default, which THEY should change so Cassie doesn't need to think about it. Two days should be the maximum length and even one day would be fine. The fat lady is generally singing by then anyway.

Cole Jennett

Ending it any sooner likely has no impact on when she has them scheduled in to be watched. She also said it would end Sunday at midnight when she posted it.

Joe J

Flag - FYI if interesed. The channel Totally Whatever will be reacting to Fright Night and The Omen this month.

Clarence Newman

Agreed Cole, but if you have a fave that’s languishing with no chance of winning, there’s also the matter of wanting to be put out of your misery. Never happens to me of course. My films always get the mass vote.

Clarence Newman

Not interested. Nope. There are no other channels.

Joe J

So, Carrie and FD it is. Add these to the already watched and confirmed list which includes The Fly, Monster Squad, Scream 2, Sinners, Train to Busan, and The Blair Witch Project. Does Cassie have a few more surprises?

Clay F

That is interesting. I suspected that Friday would be in 3rd. But the bottom 4 are all within 1% of each other.

Clarence Newman

Towering Inferno might be better. Folks with their heads on fire is more befitting Scary But Not Too Scary.

Clarence Newman

Or Bullitt. Heads catch on fire in that one too.

Clay F

Nosferatu (2024) for October Thelma & Louise (1991) after October

Chris Thom

Editor is going to be really busy this month.

Chris Thom

Seven hours left on the poll now.

Matthew Saban

What about Tremors 2: AFTERSHOCK with Carly?

Cole Jennett

It was just on a sequels poll and got like 10th out of 12.

Richard Maurer

Well, it’s Carrie and Final Destination then. Could be worse.

John Casamassa

Well, this year's looking like a wash for me.

Kristian

It's iconic, but the acting doesn't hold up and the script is quite lazy, compared to other horror classics, so maybe people didn't think Cassie would enjoy it as much?

Joe J

FD will be a wild reaction...that's why I'm here, lol.

Richard Maurer

I can’t complain too much about FD, but I’d be more enthusiastic if I hadn’t already seen about a dozen reactions to it.

Jim

I think Carrie is going to push Cassie’s boundaries to the extreme, and it will be very entertaining. It’s a great movie.

James M

Surprising considering how bad "Van Helsing" is. I am not a horror fan so I've only seen Carrie and Van Helsing from this list. I guess Friday could be worse but it's hard to imagine.

Mark Vaderr

To the extreme? I think "IT" did that for Cassie.

First Name Ella

Seriously... a lot of people here have questionable taste tbh.

First Name Ella

Bro, do you know her/are a mod or something? I hope so... because otherwise using her full name like that is... something

First Name Ella

Yeah I really want her to react to that one. I mean, Van Helsing!? Really!? It's such a bad movie. If she's going to be scared, it might as well be a decent film. Although there's no scares in Van Helsing, just a lot of cheese.

First Name Ella

I mean, Cassie has made it pretty clear she won't watch anything with the devil in it, and while I don't quite understand it (it's not like these films are celebrating the devil, and refusing to watch Rosemary's Baby is a crime onto itself), but it's her channel and a decision she has made probably due to her LDS beliefs, so we should accept it.

First Name Ella

Why? They're all the same- if you've seen one you've seen them all- and after the first one, it's just all about "how can we make the kills as gory/shocking as possible?"- something we KNOW Cassie won't like. So why would you want her to react to the other FD films when there are so many actually decent horror movies out there?

Shawn Kildal

The last 2 movies of the franchise, might be the 2 best movies out of all of them.

Richard Maurer

I’m really struggling to think of anything in Carrie that would be considered “extreme”. But you never know, Cassie thought What lies Beneath was scary, somehow.

Nolofinwe

Lovely , nothing like the demonic murder of high school kids in combination with the blood pigs !what a thrill for Satan himself

Nolofinwe

Cassie missed the Boat with missing "the Blob". I knew it would not win... people have short memories. but it is absolutely a Horror classic . and the star Steve McQueen ? what more could you want

Nolofinwe

I hate to break the news to you but all of today's horror and they shouldn't even be called Horror they are bloodyslasher , twisted ,sick ,demonic ,macabre , and they all have "The Devil" behind them wether he appears or not . Hollywood has them as much to ruin the Horror genre as any other

Grad

Clay: "Nosferatu (2024) for October" Is this confirmed? What about 1922?

Nolofinwe

How do you know she's LDS she marry Ben and he must be right

Clarence Newman

Don't think anything's going to beat The Fly. Sometimes during that one, Cassie acted like she was having a broken leg set. Carrie will be fine.