Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Popcorn Requests 1-50 Poll

  • #3 City Slickers (1991) 443
  • #5 Jack Reacher (2006) 307
  • #10 Caddyshack (1980) 384
  • #14 Falling Down (1993) 274
  • #23 Short Circuit (1986) 307
  • #36 Mars Attacks! (1996) 223
  • #38 Sister Act (1992) 299
  • #48 Little Shop of Horrors (1986) 224
  • #50 Watchmen (2009) 372
  • 2025-12-01
  • —2025-12-05
  • 2833 votes
{'title': 'Popcorn Requests 1-50 Poll', 'choices': [{'text': '#3 City Slickers (1991)', 'votes': 443}, {'text': '#5 Jack Reacher (2006)', 'votes': 307}, {'text': '#10 Caddyshack (1980)', 'votes': 384}, {'text': '#14 Falling Down (1993)', 'votes': 274}, {'text': '#23 Short Circuit (1986)', 'votes': 307}, {'text': '#36 Mars Attacks! (1996)', 'votes': 223}, {'text': '#38 Sister Act (1992)', 'votes': 299}, {'text': '#48 Little Shop of Horrors (1986)', 'votes': 224}, {'text': '#50 Watchmen (2009)', 'votes': 372}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 12, 5, 6, 59, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2025, 12, 1, 16, 25, 59, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 2833}

Content

I just went live randomly and drew 9 movies from our Popcorn Requests page from #1-50!

Quite an array of movies, can't wait to see what wins!

Multiple votes allowed-ends Thursday

Happy December!

Cassie

Comments

Andrew R

Falling Down FTW!

Tyler Foster

Please, Little Shop of Horrors! And watch both endings!

Collar City Guy

Get better soon Cassie and a happy early birthday too you! 🎈🎉

Mark White

I’m already predicting City Slickers to win, but I would love it to be Falling down! Michael Douglas reflecting how many of us feel when you can’t get a breakfast!

Omar

Here again for short circuit even tho I know it’s a losing battle lol

James M

Hoping for "City Slickers". A couple of great acting performances in there. Also a lot of fun with holidays coming up.

LukeG84

Holy shit this is a touch poll. So many excellent movies Cassie absolutely needs to watch.

Gray

I'm voting for the comedies but most probably Watchmen will probably win this

Oisin Clissmann

I really hope she watches it even if it doesn't win. It's still very relevant and relatable today.

Joe J

We'll need a run-off poll of the top four.

Cole Jennett

Short Circuit, Jack Reacher and City Slickers for me

Shehab Dawoud

Meh. None of them are among my favs, although Falling Down is an experience alright! Anything but Caddyshack, aka the most overrated, unfunny comedy ever.

MikeLL

It got my vote, too!

James M

Surely not. It's not that popular a movie plus all the members who love the downer movies are cheering for Falling Down (yuck)

LukeG84

Sweet, just noticed multiple votes allowed. In no particular order, I voted for: City Slickers, Jack Reacher, Short Circuit, Sister Act, and Little Shop of Horrors. Any of these would be perfect. 🍿

Dazman

City Slickers. The perfect blend! Watchmen is a bit dark and quirky, a few fluffy comedies worth seeing but not poll winners and who needs Tom Cruise playing a 6'5 character that now has a series...

Gray

Looks like City Slickers is doing well and it's a comedy movie i've not seen too!

LukeG84

Have to say it again, what a poll. Even the movies I didn’t vote for would still make for a great reaction video. Cassie can’t go wrong with whatever wins here.

Clarence Newman

Got to be City Slickers. A funfest for Cassie and Carly amid all the Thronesy stuff.

LukeG84

Love City Slickers. Rewatched it for the millionth time just a few months back. It literally never gets old.

Clarence Newman

Why 4 days, though, Cassie? Two is plenty, or better yet, whenever City Slickers is in the lead.

Michael G

After the events of the Red Wedding, it is good to see so many Comedies make this list. I only have one I am pulling for, and that is Sister Act; Comedy, Music, a fun time.

LukeG84

Cassie needs to see Short Circuit sooner or later. It’s a classic.

Captain Hammer

I wish more reactors would do City Slickers 2 after they watch the first one. I really like it too. More in some ways.

Anthony Carlson

One of my votes is Falling Down. One big reason why is this: Man On The Edge by Iron Maiden. That song is based on the movie….😎

Milton Reduxed

Falling Down & Short Circuit 💪🦾

LukeG84

I’d be happy if it won. Such a weird and wonderful musical with so many a-listers. Cassie would enjoy it, that’s for sure.

Phil Stubblefield

"...You're saying I can record something I'm not even watching?" 🐮

Eric Parpart

Hoping City Slickers wins. You then can do CS 2- which is another fun one AND a wonderful sequel

Charles Briggs

If Watchmen (2009) Wins just make sure it's the director's cut it's the best version 👍

MikeLL

Look on the RequestsApp and make a poll of the top 10? 8? 6? Christmas themed movies. (NOT like Die Hard. REAL Christmas movies.)

Adam Doyle

A great selection, while I am a sucker for Caddyshack, I am not sure that would be up Cassie's alley as must as City Slickers or Sister Act. Falling Down and Short Circuit are also good. Watchmen is can be passed on, and maybe save Mars Attacks! and Little Shop of Horror's for next year's Scary But No Too Scary Halloween.

Timothy Williams

You will love City Slickers! It is so funny and amazing with Billy Crystal and a great cast of characters. It is just funny it is moving and philosophical.

Aaron Ritchie

I think Sister Act would be the one you’d most enjoy on this list

David Livingston

That may be true, but Cassie be warned there's an explicit scene in there (that's all I'll say) - just wanted mention it and 'warn' you.

Chris Thom

I would maybe skip to the sequel. The music is so good in that one. Lauren Hill is amazing.

Dazman

Its a comedy with heart and some brilliant moments. It's been high on the chart for ages and it's about time!

Chris Thom

Almost feels like a Halloween-lite poll.

Paul Stelter

"Short Circuit" will make you feel a little less apprehensive about AI. A little. :) "Mars Attacks" is really silly and yet Tim Burton managed to get an incredible cast for it.

Dazman

So they all cancelled eachother out 😂

Charles Briggs

Wow it been a while since I've watched the director's cut i don't think i can recall the scene your referring to 😁 but to be honest the whole film is pretty graphic in it's depiction of violence just the way i like it 😁👍

Chris Thom

Weird that the studios won't just let Snyder do his thing and release it how it is. Seems like everyone likes his director's cuts more.

Mike A

Glad you didn't lose the results, Cassie. :-D

Charles Briggs

Yeah that's Hollywood for you always messing with a great directors work you would think they would learn to leave Zack Snyder well enough alone but that's Hollyweird for yah

Dan M

Lots of nice movies in this list. But I just watched When Harry Met Sally again last night, and I forgot how much I love Billy Crystal as an actor and comedian. So it’s City Slickers all the way, which reunites Crystal with Bruno Kirby. A nice mix of comedy, western, and buddy movie, sprinkled with a lesson in family values. And the cherry on top…Jack Palance’s breathy voice.

Dazman

Her heart needs to be warmed after Red Wedding!

Dan M

Sister Act is my second choice after City Slickers. Definitely a feel good movie.

Clay F

For my tastes, there have been better PR 1-50 polls. I voted two: --CADDYSHACK -- somewhat of modern classic -- everybody should watch once. --FALLING DOWN-- been so long since I've seen it. Jen Murray didn't like it b/c apparently not fully PC. I saw the Sister Act play off-Broadway but don't think I've ever seen the movie. Looks like City Slickers will win. Gets good reviews. Other advantages of CS winning is will remove a No. 3 from PR, patrons will no longer be asking for it in the comments, and will no longer be around to destroy another poll. I don't think I've seen CS -- generally not into slapstick comedy -- but will watch the reaction and hope I like it. I much prefer CS winning over Short Circuit. Watchmen might be competitive w/CS in this poll. "Gritty and visually striking, Watchmen is a faithful adaptation of Alan Moore's graphic novel, but its complex narrative structure may make it difficult for it to appeal to viewers not already familiar with the source material."

fastecp1

Falling Down

Chris Thom

Still never seen Little Shop of Horrors. Wouldn't mind an excuse to finally see it.

Dan M

Falling Down is a good movie. I’d just like to see some more comedies in the coming weeks.

Brent Petty

CS actually has some pretty good serious moments as well. Not a lot of slapstick, TBH.

Dan M

Totally agree

Dan M

Just reverse the order, and I’m on board 😊

Anthony Carlson

Fair enough. Btw off topic, at least you guys are bowl eligible!

LukeG84

It’s a weird and wonderful musical with so many a-listers. I highly recommend it, even if it doesn’t win this poll.

Brent Petty

Yay! I honestly think half of the numbered polls should be top 50. Let the other half be top 100 or 500 or whatever. This way at least it's a selection of films we know a good amount of people want to see reactions to.

Clay F

Brent, that's good to know.

Biggman83

I definitely don’t rate Caddyshack. I know it’s treated like a classic by you Americans.

Blake Evans

Oh Cassie, You’re killing me smalls! You need to watch everyone on this list. But Watchmen, Sister Act, and City Slickers all have my highest hopes.

Dan M

Three in a row, baby! 🏈 🎉🔥

Chris Thom

You might really enjoy Sister Act 2 for a young Lauren Hill. Amazing talent. Worth seeing.

Cole Jennett

It was more me listing them than a particular order

Dean Holt

Honestly I’d be happy with any of them. Watchman probably my least favourite with City Slickers, Jack Reacher & Mars Attacks being my top 3. Little Shop & Short Circuit I’ve not seen since the 90s so they could be fun rewatches of me. But I honestly think Cassie would love Sister Act & City Slickers as they are both good comedy’s and I think she needs to watch a few more funny movies to balance out the darker things she’s been watching. Little Shop of Horrors if it doesn’t win would be a very good choice for October film.

Chris Thom

Completely forgot there was a sequel. Not sure how, I saw both as a kid a hundred times.

Brent Petty

It even has an Oscar - Jack Palance won for Best Supporting Actor.

Richard Maurer

C’mon Watchmen. City Slickers should not win. Or come in second. Or third, fourth……..

Brent Petty

Cassie, if City Slickers wins, it would be a great reaction with Carly.

Anthony DiBern

Watchmen has to be the director's cut. It is a hell of an experience, and it's incredibly dark. I think you'll have the most fun with Short Circuit and Sister Act. Little Shop Of Horrors is also incredibly fun in that quirky musical sort of way. City Slickers is also a really fun but I haven't seen it in a really long time. I just hosted Falling Down at a local theater, so it's probably my favorite of the bunch, but it's also a very dark, depressing movie. Mars Attacks is probably the worst of the bunch on this list, but I get a weird kind of enjoyment out of it.

Richard Maurer

Agree about Watchmen. The others, not so much.

Richard Maurer

Be nice if she watches the top 2, if Watchmen comes second anyway. If City Slickers comes in second to Watchmen she doesn’t need to bother with second place.

Walter

Jack Reacher is my choice. My guess is Cassie would enjoy Sister Act or City Slickers the most. We will see.

Clarence Newman

Dead inside you are! City Slickers is a bowlful of puppies and you know it.

Clay F

Joe J comment below: "We'll need a run-off poll of the top four." I doubt that happens. Yet, would be interesting = the anti-CS vote would be diluted less.

Dean Holt

You might be surprised how good CS is Clay as Brent’s said I don’t remember it being slapstick humour. Just depends on if you like Billy Crystal as some don’t find him funny. But the highlight for me is Jack Palance as he plays a great character in it.

Clarence Newman

City Slickers and Watchmen are neck and a much longer neck. It's basically a giraffe against a bulldog at this point.

Blake Evans

It’s my nostalgia. I grew up on both so they hold a special place for me, regardless of quality.

Clarence Newman

I think Richard should have his membership suspended for the duration of this poll. He is a disruptive influence to my dreams of victory.

Clay F

Yeah, the word "slickers" arguably evokes length. I am still holding out hope for Caddyshack -- currently a solid 3rd.

Milton Reduxed

@Dan, There's going to be loads of soppy movies in December. Falling Down will level that out with some masculinity and dark humour

Clay F

Go Caddyshack!! Currently a solid 3rd place and catching Watchmen. I never thought I would necessarily be cheering for Caddyshack, but that is the nature of this poll. Caddyshack is a vital member of the Bill Murray collection.

Katie Jackson

I'm definitely rooting for Sister Act but not sure it's gonna make it. I've loved that one since I was a kid. Still a lot of fun today, and I agree the sequel is also just as good.

KyloJames

Wasn’t ‘Jack Reacher’ in 2012??

Clarence Newman

That's well cryptic, Blake. You mention three films and then say you grew up on both. It hurts my head.

KyloJames

If she can handle Game of Thrones, Saw, Hill House, and literally every uncomfortable movie/show she’s watched, Watchmen is child’s play. Let’s get real lmao

Richard Maurer

Clarence- I think you should stop promoting trash movies. So I guess neither of us will get our wish.

Clay F

Yep, good catch. 2012, not 2006. "Jack Reacher is an above-average crime thriller with a smoothly charismatic performance from Tom Cruise."

Stick Figure Studios

Honestly, there's a lot of good movies here (CITY SLICKERS, JACK REACHER, SHORT CIRCUIT, FALLING DOWN, LITTLE SHOP OF HORRORS, SISTER ACT and WATCHMAN are all films I wouldn't mind seeing a reaction to), so I'm not really invested in which one wins. If the one in the lead happens to be a movie I like, then I'll throw my weight behind it as well. If it's one of the few on here I don't care for, although for whichever good film has a chance to beat it.

Stick Figure Studios

But I suspect she would be fascinated by JACK REACHER, and not just because it's Tom Cruise but because she has personally met the director Christopher McQuarrie.

Stick Figure Studios

That was kind of my reaction. With only a couple exceptions, every title on this poll is a winner, so I suspect I'll be happy with whatever comes in first.

Clarence Newman

I am certainly misunderstood in my time. But occasionally one of my little dust bunnies gets its moment in the sun. City Slickers is looking like one of them.

Blake Evans

We both agreed we like Watchmen, but disagreed about the other two, Sister Act and City Slickers.

Stick Figure Studios

CITY SLICKERS is a very good, very funny and very sweet movie. The cast is terrific but Jack Palance positively steals the film. He won an Oscar for his performance.

Stick Figure Studios

@Clarence: Richard just has very passionate and very narrow tastes and he is not at all shy about it.

Walter

excellent point

David Collins

Michael Douglas is underrepresented on the channel. Had to vote for Falling Down.

Stick Figure Studios

I don't. I think that is a terrible movie. One of the worst sequels ever made.

Stick Figure Studios

With only a couple exceptions, I think every movie on this list is good

Clay F

I am glad for you Clarence. You have been a big supporter of CS.

Richard Maurer

Blake - you really need to spell things out for Clarence. Of all the knives in the drawer, his needs sharpening the most. ;-)

Clarence Newman

And personally slighted Chris McQuarrie by NOT reacting to his personal recommendation of Klute!

Stick Figure Studios

Looks like CITY SLICKERS has pulled ahead... which I'm fine with.

KyloJames

I panicked thinking it had actually been THAT long since it released 💀

KyloJames

Really liked Tom Cruise as Jack Reacher! I think Cassie would really enjoy it

Richard Maurer

Stick - Actually my tastes are pretty broad , but they don’t usually run towards mainstream comedy, especially “lite” comedy which I just don’t find funny. Otherwise I agree completely with your statement.

Stick Figure Studios

I have never been as enamored of it as everyone else is either.

Clarence Newman

He's right, Blake. Too much Maurer will dull anyone's head sponge.

Stick Figure Studios

It's a good film. I saw with my dad in the theater as an adolescent, but I revisited it again in my 40s and it resonated a lot more.

Blake Evans

No worries all. It’s very Monday for me too.

Stick Figure Studios

I've never been a big fan of CADDYSHACK. It and MARS ATTACKS are the only two movies on here my particularly interested in revisiting. Every other title I'm fine with.

Mike Lemon

"I prefer Kittens." So... Young Einstein (1988)???

Stick Figure Studios

I hope not. I love the first one, but I do not care at all for the sequel.

Clarence Newman

I'm not fan, but I could go for some Basic Instinct or China Syndrome.

Stick Figure Studios

Yeah, I have never gotten the love for that film. That and MARS ATTACKS The only two movies on here I don't want to see win. Every other option, as far as I'm concerned, is good.

Stick Figure Studios

Although I wouldn't mind it winning, I actually wouldn't be surprised if WATCHMEN won.

Stick Figure Studios

I doubt it will win, but if it does, I suspect Cassie will need to see the version that has the theatrical ending. That will help her like the movie... then she can watch the originally intended ending and be horrified by it, but it won't color her affection for the film.

Richard Maurer

Clarence - 27 snakes, close to 200 tarantulas (approximately, haven’t counted in awhile).

Richard Maurer

Mike - more like Hellboy, except I only have one cat.

Tyler Foster

I would suggest actually playing them in the order where she watches the ending that she will probably like last. FWIW, the difference between the theatrical and director's cut is a single edit, with the two cuts branching into a Y. There are no other alterations or changes throughout the rest of the movie. So the watch-along video could be edited in a way where there is a watch-along for both cuts just by moving the other ending into the right spot at the edit.

OddThomas

Short Circuit!! Think Wall-E but in the 80s.

Patrick

✅ '8 Seconds' (1994) It is National Finals Rodeo week after all...🐂

Stick Figure Studios

CHINA SYNDROME for sure, but there is no way in hell that BASIC INSTINCT will ever get a reaction on this channel.

Happy Hanukkah

SFS: "Jack Palance positively steals the film. He won an Oscar for his performance." And he then repaid us by stealing an Oscar from Vanessa Redgrave!!! :-P

JohnnyUtah

Finally a poll worthy of all the votes!!!

Happy Hanukkah

Come now, let's not get carried away. Looking at this poll, City Slickers is a Top Ten movie! :-)

Milton Reduxed

There's an American theatrical cut of Basic Instinct, if Cassie could watch that version I think it's possible

Happy Hanukkah

Mike, I prefer pheasants, so Young Sherlock Holmes.

Clay F

Like Cassie, I was hoping #4 CHILDREN OF MEN (2006) would be selected for the poll.

Richard Maurer

Truth is I don’t hate CS, unlike Short Circuit and Sister Act. But I do think it’s mediocre movie. Caddyshack, Falling Down and Watchmen ( the 3 I voted for) are all much better movies - imo.

Happy Hanukkah

"He is not at all shy about it." Hush hush, eye to eye.

CJ Holden

I had to go with Mars Attacks, Short Circuit and Sister Act. The first will probably be the most fun reaction, the 2nd is a childhood favourite of mine and the 3rd is just one of those rare, perfect feel good movies.

Jerrod Acree

City Slickers is a personal favorite of mine and my father’s.

Adam Doyle

Caddyshack, like many comedies from its era is a bit raunchy and not PC but there is enough there to still offer up a few good laughs.

Steve Holton

Disclosure (1994) is a Michael Douglas thriller Cassie and Carly might enjoy. Based on the Michael Crichton (Jurassic Park) novel of the same name.

Mark White

Arrh don’t say that Stick! I was hoping for that one day. I remember saying something similar in the comments when Cassie was going to watch American Psycho, but many people told me it shouldn’t be a problem with the sex scenes. I mean after GoT it’s quite tame really.

Mark White

Doesn’t that make the whole Patreon requests thing into doubt?! How can 50th place be doing so well against numbers much higher in the list?

Nolofinwe

Can’t go wrong with city slickers you just can’t . Even the sequel is tons of fun

Mark White

I’m envious Richard! That’s so cool that many snakes and tarantulas.

Chris Retzlaff

It is a tons fun...as long as you find that ☝️thing plus its got my crush Helen Slater in it

Chris Retzlaff

Wouldn't you like to be a pepper too

Chris Retzlaff

Big fan of Falling Down....might not be my favorite Douglas performance...but its close

Scott Boyer

Short Circuit! 🥰 "Hey, laser lips, your mama was a snowblower!"

Clay F

Mars Attack is currently last place of the 9 choices. Short Circuit (currently tied for 4th) not doing too bad.

Kawaii Leonard

Caddyshack isn't really all that funny, besides the gopher bit. Murray rambles on throughout the movie about nothing.

Michael Bachman

Too bad Local Hero wasn't drawn randomly.

Ted Whalen

Dan- the rumor has it that Penn State is looking to hire the BYU coach. I hope that Cassie doesn’t put a “Mormon” curse on the Nittany Lions!

Ted Whalen

Anthony- are you happy about the Fitzgerald hire? It seems like a good move.

DavidJPL

The "A-B-C's" of the BEST, Classic comedies of the modern era are: A - Animal House (1978) Done! B - Blues Brothers (1980). C - Caddyshack (1980). *** (new member, I have been meaning to tell you this since Animal House! Thanks!) :)

Anthony Carlson

Ted Whalen- I was surprised we hired a new coach so quickly after we fired Jonathan Smith! Pat Fitzgerald is a great hire in my opinion. The only thing holding Pat back was Northwestern is an academic first school so he couldn’t do much with the resources. Michigan State should have plenty for him to work with.

DavidJPL

I recently watched this and had forgotten how many classic lines are from this. My favorite: "If hate were people, I'd be China!" LOL

DavidJPL

Agreed. Caddyshack now. (And then Blues Brothers). And then City Slickers with Carly.

Stan the Man

Just a heads up Cassie or MoDS or whoever. Short Circuit might be a problem for some viewers. Much like Mickey Rooney in Breakfast at Tiffany’s, Short Circuit, a kids movie, has a prominent role for a racist caricature done by a white actor(Fisher Stevens) portraying a middle eastern man. I know some of you will not care. That’s totally fine. No one says you have to. But I think it’s important to make sure Cassie is aware of the feelings certain communities have towards the movies she’s watching, including whether or not they contain brown face/black face. That sort of thing.

djKENTO

If Watchmen wins PLEASE WATCH THE DIRECTOR'S CUT!

Buran Doyon

Die Hard is a REAL Christmas movie. sigh

Clay F

Excellent point Stan. Thanks for mentioning it. Short Circuit will likely not finish in the top 3 in the poll. That Mickey Rooney portrayal in Breakfast at Tiffany’s is horrendous.

DavidJPL

OMG you guys! It is one of the best comedies of all time in the modern era! (See my own comment). The dry wit of Bill Murray, Chevy Chase, Ted Knight, and more - and the over-the-top bombast of Rodney Dangerfield - are hysterical and legendary!

Clay F

All 3 good.

Biggman83

There’s better performances by all of them. It’s subjective though. Not all US comedies hit with me

Clay F

Mark -- good point. It's because of the super low participation at Popcorn Requests. Also, many requests made by people no longer patrons.

Happy Hanukkah

Chris: Given that Cassie has reacted to no less than six Superman movies (with four different actors in the title role), it is incomprehensible to me that she has yet to react to Supergirl (1984)! :-)

Richard Maurer

Are you trying to scare people away from the movie?

Richard Maurer

Mark - Big time commitment, but otherwise yes.

Clay F

Caddyshack (now in 2nd place) overtook Watchmen. Caddyshack now looking to unseat City Slickers. If that doesn't happen, maybe she will react to the top 2.

N M

REACHER!

Shehab Dawoud

I genuinely did not laugh once and have had no desire to see it again. I haven’t most of these, so I could be surprised.

John Rando

I hate when people have more of a passion for NOT caring than caring. It’s kinda sick.

Paul Cox

Nobody's saying don't watch Short Circuit if it wins. Just giving a content alert. Fisher Stevens has said he feels bad about doing the role the way he did it, and definitely wouldn't do it now. Yes, 1986 feels way past the time we all should have known better, but it is what it is.

Tyler Foster

It's also just like...everyone is allowed to have their own opinion. It's definitely something that happens in the movie, so Stan the Man is fine to point it out and JAKH is fine to not care about it, and neither is more definitive than the other. Like Stan says, it's just useful to know.

Tyler Foster

That would immediately be my #1 most anticipated reaction of whatever week it was dropping during.

djKENTO

the modern era? Dude the newest movie on there is 45 years old...

Tyler Foster

Basic Instinct is a little hard to picture, but American Psycho is a pretty good counterpoint. I would have thought that AP would've been a no-go on the sexual content more than the violence (even if it's horrifying). That said, Basic Instinct does have more outright nudity. I could go either way on it being possible.

Tyler Foster

Just don't watch the sequel. The original is great, one of my favorite detective thrillers of the 21st century. The second one...woof.

Tyler Foster

I love Klute, but for Cassie and Carly specifically, I would rather get a What's Up Doc? redo with the both of them than Klute.

Tyler Foster

I would imagine that Cassie's community is large enough that top 100 is still movies that a lot of people want to see. Does it seem like that many people in these replies are disappointed by any of the selections?

Tyler Foster

I have always thought Caddyshack feels like each of the four top-billed stars are in different movies and it doesn't congeal. Many mentions of Blues Brothers on this poll and I would much, much rather see that.

Clarence Newman

Mark. As long as the results keep falling my way, I'm perfectly ok with it.

Clarence Newman

Richard. My wife advises me that we are never going to visit you.

Clarence Newman

As a fan of City Slickers, Tyler, I can safely say we are not!

DavidJPL

Yes, modern. As opposed to the true Classic Comedies like "M*A*S*H" (1970), "The Odd Couple" (1968), "Dr Strangelove" (1964), "The Apartment" (1960), "Some Like it Hot" (1959), and even "Bringing Up Baby" (1938) and "Duck Soup" (1933)! And more. (Feel free to Google: 'Greatest Comedy Movies of All Time'). Sorry to be the old guy here, and perhaps we're in yet another era of Comedies this new 21st Century, but if so, anything in the past 25~35+ years owes tribute to these legendary 'A B C's' of Comedies as I call them.

David Patterson

If Little Shop wins, I recommend that she watch the Special Edition, give her thoughts, then immediately watch the theatrical ending.

Tyler Foster

I would suggest that the '20s-'40s were probably an era in comedy, the '50s and '60s, the '70s through to the '90s, and the '00s and '10s, and maybe the '20s is the beginning of a new era.

Stick Figure Studios

I recommend the opposite. Watch the theatrical ending and then watch the originally intended ending.

Tyler Foster

Better suggestion: one poll of traditional Christmas movies and another poll of non-traditional Christmas movies. (I really hope Cassie does The Long Kiss Goodnight this year.)

Stick Figure Studios

This occurred to me as well, Stan. It is definitely a racist caricature (although not quite as ugly as Mickey Rooney in BREAKFAST AT TIFFANY'S imo... whatever my opinion happens to be worth on the subject, which is certainly not as much a person of actual Middle Eastern descent), but it is also a relatively minor aspect of the film as Ben is a supporting character with only a few scenes. In the sequel, Ben is actually turned into protagonist which on the one hand I guess is kind of progressive because it centers a Hollywood Blockbuster on a Middle Eastern character, but on the other hand it is a stereotypical character performed by a white guy. So... *shrugs* who knows? Ultimately I still think both movies are worth watching as long as the viewer is made aware of this element. Same thing with Blake Edwards' THE PARTY with Peter Sellers in brownface, offensive by contemporary standards to be sure, but also a brilliantly hilarious movie that I'd love to see Cassie react to at some point.

Stick Figure Studios

BLUES BROTHERS is the best of those I think. ANIMAL HOUSE is okay, but I have never liked CADDYSHACK.

7KingKong7

Watchmen is an important movie to watch at least once even if you arent into comic books

DavidJPL

For sure, someone with more expertise and time than me could certainly parse-out some time frames. But I do feel that some 'modern' sensibilities significantly changed and updated around 1970~1975 or so, in terms of society, technologies, and so on. A movie from 1965 looks much more dated than a movie from 1980 does.

DavidJPL

Time to give it another try! :) "Be the ball Danny". lol

Stick Figure Studios

Yeah, BLUES BROTHERS is a vastlly superior movie. Heck, ANIMAL HOUSE (which is also kind of a mess, but still pretty funny and was filmed at my old alma mater U of O) is even better.

Adam Doyle

True, if you ever watch the behind the scenes documentary about the making of Caddyshack, the whole production was a mess and some actors even refused to work with others. 100% Agreed about Blues Brothers, and I could swear she watched it, but I didn't see it on her Letterbox.

Tyler Foster

I said this on another comment but I prefer the other way around. Better to go out on the ending that she is almost certainly going to enjoy more. Still, I'll be happy as long as both are watched (I only ever personally watch the DC ending).

Stick Figure Studios

Yeah, It is the same exact movie right up to that moment third act. Then You get either Jim Belushi or Paul Dooley.

Tyler Foster

City Slickers is no When Harry Met Sally, but Cassie has seen that (and I have never heard whether or not Carly also has or not).

Tyler Foster

Can't say I'm a big fan of Animal House either. If we were picking a movie directed by Harold Ramis, then for me it would be Analyze This.

Mike Lemon

Oh no, an actor played a role of something he is not! How awful. Next thing you know there will be gay people playing straight, blacks playing white, white playing Japanese cyborg, slightly nutty pretend pirates playing Indians, hispanics playing Italians (edit- Scottish playing Egyptians pretending to be Spanish)... When will it stop? Actors should only be allowed to play themselves!

Richard Maurer

I hate Short Circuit, but mostly because it’s unfunny and very cringey.

Javier Hernandez

As much as I love Watchmen I don't know that it will resonate with Cassie. There are twists on US history, a fictional 1980's with Nixon as president, and flashbacks that aren't always clear. I do love the story of subversive super-beings, so maybe "Bright Burn" would be better for her Scary, But No Too Scary October 2026.

Richard Maurer

I have an annoying busy-body cousin who told me she’d never visit me as long as I had my snakes. After she walked away I said to my niece “Remind me to get more snakes.”

David Patterson

i would prefer to hear her thoughts on the SE 1st before watching the TE.

Tyler Hale

If we get to do Watchmen, I’d settle for the Snyder Cut.

Seymor Butz

Really hoping for city Slickers here, Cassie needs a feel good movie after the red wedding....lol

Richard Maurer

Where are all the Snyder bros when you need them? Are you guys going to let Watchmen lose to City Slickers? Seriously, it’s interesting how the number 3 film on Popcorn Requests is battling the number 50 film. I’ve said it before and I’ll say it again, a films place on this list doesn’t necessarily reflect its popularity.

Mike Lemon

I think the top 1766 are movies people want to see. They may not know it yet, but they do.

David Patterson

I, too, prefer the SE, but Cassie being Cassie NEEDS to watch the TE

Clarence Newman

Jerrod. Please tell me you and your dad went on a cattle drive together afterwards.

Shreddy

Michael Douglas considers "Falling Down" as his best performance. (And his father, the actor Kirk Douglas thought the same)

Just Plain Bob

I voted for it, for whatever good it’ll do. Excellent adaptation of a comic whose own creator thought was unfilmable (of course, Alan Moore didn’t want any of his stuff adapted for the screen). In fact, I think the film’s ending is actually better than the comic.

Stan the Man

Blues Brothers is amazing. John Candy ordering Orange whips makes me laugh everytime. And like…on paper, you’d think, how is that funny? But there’s just something about the way Candy says it. I’m smiling about it now just thinking about it. Blues Brothers just oozes “cool”. Like Dan Aykroyd is my spirit animal in that movie. I always thought it’s a shame he never had like a Bill Murray type 2nd coming moment where a hot young director writes a cool role just for him. Kinda like Bill had with Wes Anderson or Sofia Coppola. Dan just mostly stuck to comedies except when he pops up in something like Pearl Harbor, and you know what? When I saw that movie I was thinking shit I’d rather stay here and watch Dan break Japanese codes than Ben Affleck fall in love.

Matthew Brown

My dad worked on falling down as a camera man grip man (the guy who helps with the set) michael Douglas and Robert devall were very nice guys

Story Archer

Wow, this batch runs quite the gamut...

bgb1975 (Brian)

Before: C'mon either Falling Down or Caddyshack! After: Curses! Foiled again!

diego kontarovsky

Watchmen is a shallow movie that misses the point of the source material, and the Snyder Bros are a cult born of Russian bots.

Clay F

Two reasons patron poll results don't match PR rankings: A. Patron participation at PR is incredibly low. Almost infinitesimal. B. Many requests at PR were made by people who are no longer patrons. I think still worthwhile to rely on random selection from PR for poll candidates. Two potentially better ways (but more work): 1. Patron noms for candidates for specific poll by patron form submission. 2. Solicit patron noms for specific poll via a post comments. Somewhat akin to The Unofficial Official Poll Suggestion Post on Oct 29.

Clay F

Short Circuit not funny to me. My ex-wife liked it back in 1980s (we were married). I hurt her feelings when I made fun of (trashed) the movie. @Mike -- could bring back painted black face for white actors to portray black characters. Do you have a black-faced lawn ornament?

Shad Kanyak

I’m a bit interested in finally watching City Slickers. I’ve seen a lot of early Jack Palance films and he was awful in all of them. My memory of pop culture around City Slickers was that he was kind of a hit. I remember the one arm push-up at the Oscars. Curious to see how much his acting improved.

Gro Do

C'mon. "Johnny 5 alive", people.

Clay F

A PiB patron comment on the Breakfast at Tiffany’s reaction: Mikey: “As an asian american... I absolutely hate this movie. I watched it for the first time when I was in high school, and I remember staying up that night feeling so ashamed that this is how white people see asians...”

K, Zachary

We showed the list to my Dad to let him choose one, since we are hanging out with him this week in Rio San Juan, DR We chose Caddyshack he said either Falling Down, or City Slickers. So we chose both for him.

Baldemort

Johnny 5 is alive?

Mike Lemon

"Mikey: " That's not my f****** name! (edit 2- censoring the harshness since Clay clarified) edit- Or did you know someone named mike you are quoting?

Terry Yelmene

Anyone of these except 'Watchmen'... definitely not a Cassie movie.

Clay F

Mike -- I would not be that offensive to call you Mikey. Mikey was the profile name of the PiB patron I am quoting.

Mike Lemon

"@Mike -- could bring back the painted black face for white actors to portray black characters." Oh, f-off! This is the second time in two days you have accused someone of racism just to be an ass. Hopefully a mod steps in sometime and puts a stop to it.

Clay F

Mike this thread is about two examples: 1. White person playing a racist caricature of an asian. 2. White person playing a racist caricature of a middle eastern man. You said: "Oh no, an actor played a role of something he is not! How awful." Why is black face any different than the two examples discussed here?

Stephen Malloy

I’ll be shocked if Cassie doesn’t love City Slickers.

DavidJPL

Yes! Stan the Man, "1060 West Addison? That's Wrigley Field!" LOL I totally get it. Everyone has their own tastes of course, but all of these actors (lots of early SNL) are admired for a reason. And I totally agree about Dan Aykroyd; see also "Sneakers", "Grosse Point Blank" and others!

Mike Lemon

"2. White person playing a racist caricature of a middle eastern man." Two thing- 1- Indian, not "middle eastern". 2- It wasn't racist, just a caricature. "You said: "Oh no, an actor played a role of something he is not! How awful." " Then you screamed "racist" just because someone disagreed with your take. Again, for the second time tin two days. Both are totally uncalled for, totally unjustified, and just a dink move that should get you a ban.

Paul Cox

Even in 1961, there was significant pushback against Mickey Rooney's role in Breakfast at Tiffany's. This isn't some 21st century revisionist take. It was a bad move then and it's a bad move now. Short Circuit probably had similar pushback in 1986, though I admit I haven't done any research into it besides looking to see how Fisher Stevens feels about it now (he's ashamed). Yes, there are limits of what's acceptable. We're a society. I don't know why that's so hard to understand.

Jerrod Acree

Boy I wish. We thought about it.

Paul Cox

And for the record, I still haven't seen a single person say "Don't watch Short Circuit because..." Anyone who wants to watch the movie is free to do so anytime.

Catherine LW

Bruce Willis says it’s not.

Tyler Hale

Snyder Cut of course;)

mikethemotormouth

"That's the whole point, you record it so you can watch it whenever you want"

mikethemotormouth

Glen being obsessed with Godfather Pt II is the best

Clay F

Two examples here: 1. White person playing a caricature of an Asian. 2. White person playing a caricature of an Indian. You said: "Oh no, an actor played a role of something he is not! How awful." Mike - compared to the two examples here, what is the difference of a white person via black face playing a caricature of a black person?

Richard Maurer

Clay - I prefer the random draw polls, precisely because a 50th place movie can compete with a third place movie. I was glad to see Cassie said in live she is planning a random poll from 1 to 500, but I wish she’d go further, at least 1 to 1000.

mikethemotormouth

What could be more in the Christmas spirit than terrorism and grand larceny? Oh right, and murder. Let's not forget about all the murder.

Mike Lemon

Probably not, but she is full of surprises.

MikeLL

I could really get behind Tyler's idea. 2 polls of different kind of Christmas movies for different kinds of folks. Real good idea!

Alexis Vorian

Mars Attack is great, but not her kind of movie. City Slickers FTW!

mikethemotormouth

And of course she has to see The War of the Roses(1989)

Rob Jones

The Watchman is not a movie she would enjoy. Whomever suggested this one doesn’t understand Cassie.

MikeLL

Yep, some bland generic film from the 90's is always going to win a poll like this. This time it is City Slickers. The 90's are very popular here on PiB. Me? Give me the 30's or 40's everytime, but that is just me. Gone With The Wind anyone? Stagecoach? Ninotchka? The Big Sleep? The freaking Philadelphia Story that Cassie wants to see? I'm still waiting on all of these. Oh, sorry, bgb, for hijacking your comment. My bad.

Larry Darrell

Have you seen Monte Walsh (1970)? If not, I recommend it.

Larry Darrell

City Slickers ain’t generic to me.

Cole Jennett

I agree with the first sentence, but people will always request the movies they enjoy the most. It’s hard to blame them for that.

FranciscoGios

I really do want a reaction for Caddyshack. But your movie to watch should be Sister Act, Cassie.

TheSingulatarian

"Watchmen" is a super-hero movie. I would suggest she watch the Directors Cut or the Ultimate Cut. The theatrical cut cuts out too much of the story. There is also an extended cut of "Little Shop of Horrors" the original ending from the stage. It is a bit of a bummer, but the effects are rather impressive.

TheSingulatarian

Tom Cruise did not have the proper physicality to play that role. The TV series is better.

TheSingulatarian

Rooney was certainly no Japanese soldier from "Gilligan's Island".

2-Can

Caddyshack. So that Cassie can finally sing “I’m Alright” - and mean it.

Shad Kanyak

I have not. With the exception of Batman ‘89, most of what I’ve seen him on are his noir films of the 50’s.

TheSingulatarian

For your sore throat try a saltwater gargle or a medicine gargle called Cloroseptic. Though I am not sure they make it anymore. I hope you feel better soon.

Patrick Switzer

I know Cassie will like City Slickers and probably Caddy Shack

Chris Thom

Basic Instinct and Fatal Attraction are great. Hope we see more of his thrillers on the channel. A Perfect Murder and Wall Street are top performances in my book.

Brent Petty

No. That was my point, that polls should mostly be top 50, because those are the ones people want to see.

Chris Thom

Vanessa Redgrave is great. But did take me way too long to realize she and Maggie Smith were different people.

Dave

I kindly request that this thread ends here. The discussion is borderline racist and we have patrons accusing each other of being racist, so this is done. Please refrain from such discussions and accusations in the future. Thanks.

Chris Thom

Would definitely be unique for her. Doubt she's seen a superhero thing quite like it. Assuming she never saw The Boys. lol

Chris Thom

Sounds super familiar, but can't place it.

Happy Hanukkah

Listen up everyone! If you want to hear good stories about Michael Douglas and Robert Duvall, you have to vote for Falling Down! :-)

Chris Thom

Just realized it's a different movie than Batteries Not Included. Been getting those mixed for so long.

Mark Vaderr

Don't look at me. Watchmen is one of the three films I voted for. The others being "Short Circuit" & "Mars Attacks!" City Slickers is a nice movie, but I never saw it as a great movie as others do.

Mark Vaderr

Would you say that "Falling Down" & "Mars Attacks!" are Cassie movies?

Mark Vaderr

Isn't this why Cassie created the channel? To watch movies, she normally wouldn't.

Richard Maurer

I threw Mars Attacks a pity vote. It wasn’t originally one of my top three but still way better than City Slickers.

VirtuallyVeronicka

Hopefully this means you’ll watch the top 2️⃣!!

Walter

And yet, it’s still a great movie. The tv series is a far better adaptation of the character though, no doubt

Jens Kristensen

What a line up. I would love a "Short Circuit" reaction...

Clarence Newman

Nice to see that Kindergarten Cop (1990) had a positive influence on comedies that came after it. City Slickers (1991) also has a scene titled "Who is your daddy and what does he do?"

Richard Maurer

Krampus is more of a Christmas movie than Diehard. It needed to be said.

Richard Maurer

Here we go again. Kill Bill, 300, Starship Troopers - all were “definitely not Cassie movies” - except they were. She liked all 3 of them. Let her watch the movie and she’ll decide if she likes it or not.

Terry Yelmene

Very good point! 'Falling Down' and 'Mars Attacks' would likely be less enjoyable for Cassie than a 'City Slickers', or a 'Sister Act', or a 'Short Circuit'. - The reacts for the first two might be okay, just less well suited (and enjoyable) than the last three mentioned. I just think 'Watchmen' would be a bad PiB react.

Richard Maurer

Kindergarten Cop is actually somewhat funny, unlike City Slickers.

Richard Maurer

Cassie does not need to like a movie to have a good reaction to it.

Richard Maurer

I like Caddyshack but it depends heavily on Bill Murray, Rodney Dangerfield, Chevy Chase, and the underrated Ted Knight. The main story about the caddys is virtually worthless without those comedians.

Clarence Newman

The first part of your comment is accurate, Richard, unlike the second part. I feel you need to go find your smile, and there’s no better way to do that than to watch City Slickers. It may turn out to be your one thing.

MikeLL

Clay, reading your post reminded me that I haven't updated my requests in months and months. I just looked and there are 7 films I have requested that have a reaction now. I looked for a way to delete those requests, and didn't find a way to do that. I suppose it doesn't matter for already seen films. But my #1 requested film has been seen (Bringing Up Baby) and I'd like my #2 film to move up. I can still add a request, so the app isn't totally broken, but Planner needs to work on it so that it is easier (or possible) for people to participate. I'm probably wrong, I haven't looked at the app in months! So some those of us with access aren't really keeping up with it.

Richard Maurer

I’ve seen CS. It’s not the worst thing I’ve seen but hardly memorable. And my smile is on my face, waiting for something worthwhile.

Richard Maurer

Looks like City Slickers has this one. Like Twins, best thing I say is that it’s another “Why is that in the top 10?” movie we never have to see in a poll again.

Richard Maurer

I will say if the poll were just CS, Jack Reacher, Sister Act, and Short Circuit, well, I’d probably vote for Jack Reacher. But CS would be a close second!

Clarence Newman

Jack Reacher would lose by a short leading man.

Buran Doyon

Just added a vote for Caddyshack. Not my favorite on this list but City Slickers is number nine on this list for me... Jack Reacher is probably number eight but Cassie would love it, she loves the Tom Cruise Mission Impossible series. I wonder what her "favorite" movie would be on this poll. I think she would appreciate all of them, Watchmen and Falling Down aren't in her comfort zone, but are well done in lots of respects. My vote for Cassie's "favorite" movie on the list is Sister Act.

Above Average Dave

The Director's Cut of THE WATCHMEN takes it from a mid movie to something very satisfying.

Richard Maurer

“Zed’s dead, baby. Zed’s dead”.

Joe J

For me, City Slickers > Caddyshack...and that ain't saying much, lol. I've just never warmed up to the comedy genre.

Richard Maurer

Mike - go to your requests, find a film you want to remove, scroll to the right and it should have a ‘remove’ button.

Tyler Hale

Definitely improved upon the story but I loved it right when I saw it in the theater.

Tyler Foster

I definitely believe she'll like City Slickers. Caddyshack, I'm not so sure. I don't expect her to hate it or anything, but I dunno how deeply its type of humor is going to land with her.

Just Plain Bob

For me, this one’s a three horse race between Watchmen, Falling Down and Caddyshack. Three very different movies in three different genres but each is great in its own way. I never cared for the Tom Cruise version of Jack Reacher. Reacher’s physicality is such a big part of the character that it was impossible for me to reconcile the NFL linebacker sized character of the books to the much smaller Cruise. I find the Amazon tv version infinitely superior, with Alan Ritchson’s portrayal of the character spot on with the character in the books (at least, the handful I’ve read). City Slickers and Sister Act mostly bored me to tears at the time I saw them, being perfect examples of the bland 90s comedy genre. The only memorable thing about either one was the great Jack Palance in Slickers. Otherwise they were like plain oatmeal, without flavor but also nothing objectionable. Short Circuit made little impression on me when I saw it in theaters. I was much more interested in the older girl I was dating at the time (I was 17, she was 22) and couldn’t be bothered much with what was happening on screen. And Mars Attacks! was one of those movies that was, and still is, squarely in my wheelhouse; eccentric, bizarre humor, notes of horror and completely different from typical Hollywood fare. If filmmaking was a science, the Mars Attacks! formula would’ve worked for me. It didn’t. It was a complete swing and miss. But at least Tim Burton tried to do something unique. Kudos to him for that much.

Tyler Foster

I don't think the Ultimate Cut is necessary, assuming I'm correctly remembering that this is the one that puts back in the Black Freighter stuff. That one definitely feels like a "just-for-the-comics-fans" level of commitment.

bgb1975 (Brian)

I'm kinda bummed that "Falling Down" is so low on the list. I think that one is on my top ten that I would like Cassie to see. It would be a good one for Carly, too. I thought "City Slickers" was ok, but I don't think it's worthy of the top two here. Glad to see Caddyshack is at number two. I hope she will watch that one as well. I don't think I ever saw "Watchmen". I did read the comic book, though. I remember wondering what the big deal was about.

Joe J

22 is a grown woman. My mommy would've taken a switch to her, lol.

Just Plain Bob

My mother wasn’t really happy about it. But I sure was.

Richard Maurer

Joe - Not really a comedy genre fan either, except for absurdist movies like Holy Grail, Airplane, Young Frankenstein, etc.

Richard Maurer

The Jack Reacher type action movie was done better by movies like The Equalizer, John Wick, and especially The Accountant. Mars Attacks was my forth choice. Tim Burton has always been hit or miss for me, and Mars Attacks was a (minor) hit for me. I didn’t like it that much on first viewing but it’s grown on me since. And the very blandness of movies like City Slickers and Sister Act is what made them objectionable.

Clarence Newman

This is no surprise to me, gentlemen. I'm betting you both have posters of Aubrey Plaza on your wall.

Clarence Newman

I think if you bring up the film, then hitting the same button either adds or removes it. Therefore, if you've added a film you want to remove, just click the "add" button again.

Richard Maurer

Posters on my wall? Been a long time since that was a thing. I do however enjoy YouTube shorts of Aubrey Plaza. Well, her and Mona Kimura anyway.

Stephen Dias

“City Slickers” is currently winning; I suspect Cassie will appreciate it. I also think she’d get a kick out of “Sister Act,” which I voted for.

Chris Thom

The 'blander' movies were fun for kids. Maybe even geared toward them? They had simpler, easily digested messages. Twins felt a bit like that growing up. Some of them I haven't seen since 15 and curious if they hold up.

Chris Thom

Got nothing. But first thoughts are Star Trek or a Robin Williams sketch.

TheSingulatarian

I heard through the grapevine that all your Trek content got nuked today. So sorry to hear that with everything you have on your plate. I don't think the Elisons buying Paramount is going to be a good thing. Let's hope they don't get their hands on Warner Brothers as well.

Mike Lemon

I'm still seeing most (all?) of the Trek stuff. YouTube thinks I'm in...looking...Bosnia, if that matters. But I'll say again, every "creator" should be backing up their content to another platform (NOT Patreon).

Chris Thom

There are no platforms where copyright can be ignored completely. That's not legal.

Kevin O'Donnell

If Watchmen is chosen, please watch the extended cut. It's even better

Milton Reduxed

I don't get it because there are increasing numbers of reaction channels who are straight up screening the full movie now, but Cassie seems to have more copyright issues than they do?

My_Cousin_Mose

@Milton are those reactors even half the size of PiB? I don't follow very many reacters but the only ones I have seen doing that are the smaller channels.

Brent Petty

Their Forrest Gump YT reaction is gone, too. I noticed today.

Mike Lemon

@Brent- I still see Gump as being up.

Mike Lemon

@Chris- True, but other platforms aren't "strike first, then it's up to you to prove innocence" like YouTube. From what I understand, others are more of "companies have to prove your guilt first."

Richard Maurer

My weekly reminder that we still need a reaction to Fantastic Four: First Steps.

Richard Maurer

He’s dead Jim is from classic Star Trek. When Bones checked people with his tricorder on the show he’d say “he’s dead Jim” so often it became a cliche. The second one is from Pulp Fiction, of course.

Joe J

She'll wait too long as always, lol.

Clay F

The top 3: -City Slickers (1991) -Caddyshack (1980) -Watchmen (2009) Last place of the 9 choices will likely be Mars Attack or Little Shop of Horrors.

Richard Maurer

I’m afraid you’re right. And that just gives people who don’t like superhero movies ammunition - “ See, these movies don’t do that well on YouTube.” - they might do better if it didn’t take a half year to get to them. I wish Cassie would just make them a Popcorn Pick of the Month once in a while. I mean they can’t do any worse on YouTube than her normal picks.

Richard Maurer

I don’t really like the musical version of Little Shop, the original is better, but I’d still rather see even that over City Slickers.

Collar City Guy

Agreed, the @8 minutes of greatness that are the Bil Murray and Rodney Dangerfield scenes does not justify the other 90 minutes of boredom

james sweeney

If you're going to watch Reacher, watch the TV show. Skip season 2.

Clay F

+1 for Reacher S1

Christian Becker

No love for "Falling Down"? I'm shooketh I say!

Nolofinwe

Not big on Whoopi Goldberg anymore but sister act is a good movie those songs are fantastic

Nolofinwe

And you can’t beat Caddyshack for just pure laughs. “Hey baby I’ll bet you look great before electricity”. “ good lookin boy , oooh know i know why tigers eat their young “

Clay F

"Though unabashedly crude and juvenile, Caddyshack nevertheless scores with its classic slapstick, unforgettable characters, and endlessly quotable dialogue."

bgb1975 (Brian)

"I like you, Betty." "That's Danny, sir." "Danny."

Brent Petty

Maggie Smith was also very good. "Look, it's Reno." (Pause). "And Gomorrah."

Brent Petty

I swear it was gone yesterday. I even did a search in her videos on her YT page and it wasn't there. Weird.

Chris Thom

Sequel might be better. But I'm a big Lauren Hill fan. Saw her live in Berkely and she was incredible.

Chris Thom

Kaielle just did hers yesterday i think.

Richard Maurer

I saw her Thunderbolts reaction. Didn’t see her doing FF though. Edit: I checked and she hasn’t done FF yet. You must have mixed the two up.

Chris Thom

Oh someone posted a picture of the poster on Extra Butter chat. It's Short Circuit. I want to see that again. Don't think I've watched that since I was nine. But Batteries Not Included was the one I was obsessed with as a little kid.

Art of Free Speech

Sadly there are a lot of comedies that fit that mold for me, and for sure Caddyshack is one of them. I love comedies of growth with characters we feel warmly about (think 10 Things I Hate About You, Big Bang Theory, Friends), but I tend to despise comedies of chaos, or comedies which ask us to admire incompetence or idiocy (think Dumb and Dumber, Big Lebowski, Caddyshack).

Art of Free Speech

I despise modern Whoopie, but loved her in Sister Act. It's just a fun, warm comedy.

Art of Free Speech

Agreed completely on Cruise's Jack Reacher, and I generally like Cruise's acting. I'm a shorter guy myself, and I just couldn't imagine myself playing Reacher. I fully agree on City Slickers being dull and a bit campy. Sister Act, though, I felt was just good, clean, warm fun. There was growth in both Whoopi's character and in the sisters themselves, and there were moments, for me, of genuine joy in seeing them succeed. I liked them, which is more than I can say for the characters in City Slickers or Caddyshack. Mars Attack was also a huge miss for me, but yeah... it was an attempt at something different and I'll give it credit for that. We're certainly missing that kind of innovation, successful or otherwise, in Hollywood today.

Art of Free Speech

I agree. Sister Act is the most Cassie-like movie on the list, which is one of the reasons I voted for it.

Richard Maurer

There were so many Spielberg wanna-be kid’s movies in the 80’s, some more tolerable than others but as I was in my late teens - to late 20’s back then I was not as enthusiastic about most them, and they’ve only gotten even less tolerable over the years.

Chris Thom

269 people voted for it. Not bad for a lesser-known movie from the 90's.

Dean Holt

Tbh, I really like both movies but couldn’t really get into the show. But I’m going to give it another try.

Travis Underwood

If nothing else than to setup a backstory for SC2 :)

Jens Kristensen

Yes indeed... I am very fond of SC2, - always loved that one as well.

Rod Reavern

Ugh... "City Slickers" really!? I mean, sure, Curly had some funny lines, which I won't spoil. But I could not care less about Billy Crystal as a middle-aged yuppy learning "how to be a real man" on horseback. Even though I'm admittedly around the age of Billy Crystal's character Mitch, I cannot relate to his character at all. Maybe because my family has a cottage and I learned camping, orienteering, and horseback riding in summer camp as a kid, it just doesn't resonate with me as an adult. Honestly, the only reason for Cassie to watch "City Slickers" is that MAYBE she'll watch the sequel, which is much funnier and more entertaining. It's an actual ADVENTURE with stakes -- not wimps becoming less wimpy -- and drops that pointless moustache guy in favour of Jon Lovitz, who, while annoying, actually has personality and a connection with Mitch. Unfortunately, the sequel will never win a movie poll, so Cassie watching "City Slickers" is totally pointless! "Caddyshack," "Watchmen," "Jack Reacher," "Falling Down" and even "Short Circuit" would all be better choices.

Clayton Johnson

Cassie is going to fall in love with Norman

LukeG84

Surprised to see City Slickers still in the lead. Cassie's going to love it. Would be a good movie for Carly to watch too.

Nolofinwe

Watchmen just plain stinks There’s no other way to say it never lived up to the comic not even close- is Reacher going to be the midget version with Tom Cruise ? Worst casting from book to movie in history haha. -Caddyshack in all time classic- I hope we get to see that and despite the appearance of Whoopi Goldberg -I’ll say it again sister act is an excellent movie. Especially Considering what comes out of sick, twisted and now dead Hollywood

Nolofinwe

Aw Danny , This isn’t Russia … is it ? Is it Russia … No sir … I didn’t think so.

Clay F

1. City Slickers - 443 2. Caddyshack - 384 3. Watchmen - 372 . . 6. Sister Act - 299 . 8. Little Shop of Horrors - 224 (next to last) 9. Mars Attack! - 223 (last place)

Rod Reavern

“Watchmen” isn’t perfect but it’s a decent adaptation. Honestly, Zack Snyder’s gritty visuals matched the grim tone of Watchmen better than actual comics, which had inexplicably bright colours and minimal shadows. I also thought the change to the ending made more sense. The Lovecraftian psychic trauma bomb was too cartoonish. Snyder’s movie was infinitely better than the HBO series, which was a bastardized sequel to the comic book version, which referenced how stupid the original method was by randomly dropping seafood every once in a while. Tom Cruise’s “Reacher” was fine. He proved that Jack Reacher didn’t need to be huge to get the job done, making him far more relatable, because it was how his mind worked that made him an exceptional investigator. What’s his name from the Amazon Prime series does physically embody the role better, but it always begs the question WHY baddies dare to mess with him in the first place. Tom Cruise’s stature explains why baddies continually underestimate his version of Reacher. I like “Caddyshack” but I never understood why Chevy Chase was considered the breakout star of that movie because he was the least funny character. And BTW I thought that long before I learned about how toxic he was behind the scenes. But that doesn’t change the fact that “Christmas Vacation” is my all time favourite Christmas comedy. Honestly, Cassie could react to it a second time and I’d watch it. I’m glad “Sister Act” isn’t even close to winning. Even as a kid, I never liked that movie. Whoopi will always be a wise bartender to me, not a comedian.

MrKsummer7

Cassie, if you choose to react to Watchmen, please use the Ultimate Cut. It's the best version.

Samuel Champ

Oh my gosh I voted for the winner! I don't think that's ever happened. 😁

Clint Patac

There was a Jack Reacher in 2006? Or is it 2012?