Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Pre 1960 Black and White Movies Poll

  • Citizen Kane 1941 340
  • Sunset Boulevard 1950 183
  • Double Indemnity 1944 147
  • On the Waterfront 1954 149
  • City Lights 1931 66
  • The Thin Man 1934 119
  • All About Eve 1950 100
  • Paths of Glory 1957 90
  • The Night of the Hunter 1955 111
  • The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari 1920 44
  • 2026-09-02
  • —2026-09-05
  • 1349 votes
{'title': 'Pre 1960 Black and White Movies Poll', 'choices': [{'text': 'Citizen Kane 1941', 'votes': 340}, {'text': 'Sunset Boulevard 1950', 'votes': 183}, {'text': 'Double Indemnity 1944', 'votes': 147}, {'text': 'On the Waterfront 1954', 'votes': 149}, {'text': 'City Lights 1931', 'votes': 66}, {'text': 'The Thin Man 1934', 'votes': 119}, {'text': 'All About Eve 1950', 'votes': 100}, {'text': 'Paths of Glory 1957', 'votes': 90}, {'text': 'The Night of the Hunter 1955', 'votes': 111}, {'text': 'The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari 1920', 'votes': 44}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 5, 5, 59, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 2, 5, 48, 24, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 1349}

Content

Who is up for some black and white no color nonsense movies?! ;) I decided per your suggestions to split it into two polls (pre and post 1960) and excited to have another movie change my pre-popcorn in bed mind about b and dub films!

Comments

Geoff S.

All these are a must watch. Waterfront definitely so.

Bill Maurer

Citizen Kane has been called the greatest work of cinema, ever. You should watch it no matter how this poll goes

Canadianant

I will have to leave this one in the capable hands of other patrons as my knowledge of this era is limited at best. MY black and white film knowledge pretty much begins and ends with the first half of the wizard of oz, of and the movie clerks (1994)

Christopher Brown

City lights is a fantastic Charlie Chaplin movie I prefer modern times but city lights will work.

dachen13

Would be great if we could have polls for pre 1960s films every month. Just so Cassie can continue getting to know older films. A foreign film poll would be sweet too!

Henry Graham

A big Yes to whatever wins here. We need more of these films on the channel, please!

Mark Walston

Double Indemnity. Like the other films, its unforgettable. Very few reactors have the kind of range that you've displayed many times. Double Indemnity should be on your list, wether it wins the poll or not. Note: your list is fabulous and you really can't go wrong with all those great films to choose from.

Hunter DeRensis

I'd be over the moon with at least half of these winning.

Geoff S.

Get ready for your close up Cassie!

John Liebling

How about a silent era poll? Charlie Chaplain and Buster Keaton. Cassie if you do watch one or a few Charlie Chaplain films, make sure after you watch Chaplain, played by Iron Man...Rober Doweny Jr.

Gray

Only seen Paths Of Glory so looks like I'm watching something new from how this poll is going 😀

Birdy

Eve!!

WestBound

Citizen Kane is on my top 5.....of most overrated movies of all time

Keith Brown

So many great classics ! Maybe split them into categories such as comedies, dramas, film noir, thriller/suspense, war, 1940's, 1950's, 1960's. I guess what I'm saying there are dozens upon dozens of these movies and you could miss some true gems .

Paul Cox

Hardly matters which channel polls it, All About Eve never performs well. It's the community's loss, because I think Bette Davis is made for being reacted to.

JPDotCom23

Come on, guys, get her to watch Marlon Brando in 'On the Waterfront', pre-Godfather.

fish_thefilmcollector

Citizen Kane? Really? So many more appealing and enjoyable movies on this list!

AceofSpades501

On the Waterfront is a contender! Everyone bring it to the top!

Larry Darrell

First half of Wizard of Oz was Sepia tone. ;-)

Canadianant

True enough Larry. I also forgot about Ed wood (1994)

Jens Kristensen

What a awesome line up. I say start from the top...

Birdy

C'mon! Don't diss the 30s!

abraham wilson

Watch all of them. I haven't seen Dr Caligari, but they are all great. If I had to pick one I'd probably say All About Eve.

colbyshannon

The Night of the Hunter ('55) is one of the most haunting, visually striking American films ever made. …right up there with…well, Citizen Kane. It was a hugely influential film for many filmmakers to come. …definitely should be watched. … Then again.. as others have observed, just about every film on this poll is a seminal classic. … All About Eve has one of the sharpest, snappiest scripts…way ahead of its time. Double Indemnity is essential film noir…although another Barbara Stanwyck film I probably would've preferred more here is Preston Sturges' rom-com masterpiece The Lady Eve (1941).

Birdy

I agree

Clay F

I voted these 6: Paths of Glory 1957 Sunset Boulevard 1950 All About Eve 1950 On the Waterfront 1954 The Night of the Hunter 1955 Double Indemnity 1944

Clay F

There is not bandwidth on channel for "dozens and dozens of these movies." True gems will be missed. There are other interests (e.g., modern movies). Cassie has done great w/old movies but I don't see what you propose happening, except maybe in a limited fashion (e.g., 2-3 polls per year).

Clay F

I don't see that happening. There are too many other interests on the channel to have a poll for pre-1960 films every month. A foreign film poll once per year would be nice.

dachen13

Once a year would be tragic (at least IMHO 😭). I agree my wishes would be unlikely but that’s sort of why I don’t really watch reaction channels anymore. My movie taste is extremely different from theirs which is also totally okay. I don’t mind what Cassie does in the end since it’s her channel and her work and the audiences have their say based on what’s popular but I’d find it maddening if I did that with my viewings where I only saw a specific niche and then never tried anything new and expand my palette. I watch 800 movies on average every year and most if not all the movies I see are pre-1960 or foreign cinema. But an average fifty to hundred are main stream plus new releases. I really wouldn’t care if I broke the algorithm or not as long as I was exploring cinema widely. I just hope she gets to see more soon. To think of one example. She started discovering Hitchcock cinema years ago, we were all super excited. Till now, she’s only seen a very few of them and not all of them.

Alex Leach

I’m a great admirer of Bette Davis but I could never get into AAE. My favourites are Jezebel, The Letter, The Little Foxes and Now, Voyager.

Clarence Newman

In the absence of Streetcar Named Desire, this is the way. It would be funny if Cassie watched On The Waterfront, then watched Robert DeNiro doing an On The Waterfront monologue in Raging Bull.

Clarence Newman

A legendary, epic, lauded, much studied, intelligently shot masterpiece of a movie.....which may stand as the most boring two hours of my life.

Clarence Newman

My brother thinks Bette Davis was ugly. Not just unattractive - 'ugly'. I patiently await the day he realises that she had one of the most captivating faces in movie history. They literally wrote a song about her eyes.

Clarence Newman

I'm up for this. One Chaplin, one Keaton, one Harold Lloyd and one Laurel and Hardy.

casual_juergen

I am giddily looking forward to Mrs. PiB reacting to the Thin Man. Won't happen with this poll, but sometime ;)

KingofCoo1

A Streetcar Named Desire should be on the poll.

Clarence Newman

OK, where is Streetcar Named Desire? It's only the best black and white film ever made and Cassie would expand her Mount Crushmore if she saw Brando in that movie. If Streetcar was on here, it would be destroying Citizen Kane, but it's not, so my toys are leaving the pram.

Ike

ALL ABOUT EVE. Easy pick. Citizen Kane: I am a retired aviator and if you ever asked me ‘which is the great airplane ever created?’, I’d have answer - several in fact - but I would demand that you at least visit the National Air and Space Museum to examine the Wright Brothers’ “Flyer”, which was the first, ever - period. Is it the best? No, but it was first and that is CITIZEN KANE in my opinion. It’s not the best movie on this list, but I guess you should have a stamp in your movie passport of having visited it at least once.

Keith Brown

Sorry, I missed the 30's ! My mistake !

Seymor Butz

A little disappointed Goodbye Mr. Chips from 1939 didn't make the list.

Jake McNulty

I’m literally voting for all but one of these films (I haven’t seen “The Thin Man”).

Carol_White

Why do you want her YouTube channel to fail?

Happy Hanukkah

This is a terrific list, since you have undoubtedly decided to watch The Maltese Falcon (1941) regardless. :-)

MikeLL

Absolutely shocked to see Citizen Kane take the lead here. And very pleased. I had no expectations about this poll, the subjects of which are my very favorite films. Kane is utterly engrossing and fascinating. Well deserving of all the praise it has garnered throughout the years.

Richard Maurer

Not one horror or sci-fi movie (except Cabinet of Dr. Caligari, which has no chance) in the poll? Disappointing.

Mike Lemon

There is no shame in falling asleep during a reaction and having to spread it out over multiple watching. For fun, maybe change outfits each time and change the background slightly, then just cut together the video and pretend like nothing happened.

Mike Lemon

The Moon has been called a big wheel of cheese, that doesn't make it true.

Nick Ireland

I'd take anything at this point. Whatever happened to Baby Jane would be fun too

George G

I watched "the Thin Man" a while back(I rented it from Blockbuster!!)...very funny! Much funnier than I was expecting. Double Indemnity with pre "My Three Sons" Fred MacMurray was also great!

Above Average Dave

This means Ike is likely Navy all the way and NFOD 😁.

BriGuy

Spot on. There are all sorts of technical innovations that Orson Welles deserves credit for, and he's a brilliant actor, but this movie somehow just isn't compelling, especially for those with more modern cinematic sensibilities -- and I say this as someone who absolutely LOVES old movies (especially from the 1940's). Cassie will not enjoy this film.

CJ Clontz

All about Eve!!! Bette Davis at her best!

Elliot Nesterman

These are all genuine classics, many among the greatest movies ever made. Just watch them all. Chronologically might be a good order. Citizen Kane has often been called the greatest film ever made, but in any case it is always in the top 5 films of all time. Sunset Blvd is one of the greatest films noir. As is Double Indemnity. On the Waterfront is notable not only for having a great script, cast, and direction, but for Brando's truly stunning performance. City Lights is one of Chaplin's finest, and one of the finest romantic movies ever made. The Thin Man is perhaps the most delightful comedy/mystery ever filmed. William Powell and Myrna Loy have such remarkable on-screen chemistry that they were eventually cast in fourteen films together, including five Thin Man sequels. All About Eve? Fasten your seatbelts, it's going to be a bumpy ride. Paths of Glory is Kubrick at his early best, with fine performances all round. In 2008 The Night of the Hunter was rated the second-best film of all time by Cahiers du Cinéma, behind Citizen Kane. The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari is a hugely influential horror movie, and the one that introduced America to the German Expressionist style of film.

Richard Maurer

I guess we’re getting Citizen Kane out of the way then.

Professor Tim Day

I love Kane but I dont even teach it in my Intro to Cinema course any more. Although there are interesting ideas on comparing it to today's political climate--too many archival stuff like newsreels and the film's language. For pure entertainment and Cassie's tastes--Double Indemnity, Sunset Boulevard and All About Eve are great picks. Their ideas are a bit more timeless.

Joe J

I won't watch it, but it was going to win the minute the poll went up.

fargoboyle .

Thought it was The Third Man for a second, that would have been a good shout

Chris

Unironically recommending a Citizen Kane/Minions and Monsters double feature.

David

The Thin Man, On the Waterfront and Double Indemnity on the same poll? This is heresy. Citizen Caine will get votes and win purely on name recognition I think.

David

It was ground breaking for how to shoot movies, but as for entertainment value, I agree with you.

Mark Vaderr

Cassie, massive respect for you putting "The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari" on this poll. Sadly, very few people care about it. Overall, a good array of movies to choose from.

Norman Vadeboncoeur

It won't win, but I think you'd really enjoy The Thin Man. One of my favorite couples in cinema.

Mark Vaderr

Richard- Yeah, it would've been great to get "The Beast from 20,000 Fathoms" or "THEM!" or "Cat People" or "The Invisible Man" on this. Was also hoping for a couple Hitchcock films as well.

Clarence Newman

Shush. October’s coming and there’s only 3 good horrors left.

Clarence Newman

I grew up with those films. I remember liking the Petula Clark one.

Brett Richey

People just clicking on the one they've heard of again? All About Eve and Paths of Glory blow the borefest that is Citizen Kane out of the water. Most of the others do too tbh. Sure, it's groundbreaking on a technical level... but it's just not very interesting. I'd rather watch Welles in front of the camera in The Third Man, but it's not an option.

Christian Becker

But Paths of Glory made it onto the poll - big success ;-) But alas, it’ll be Citizen Kane ;-)

Stephen Dias

Huh. My suggestion is not on the list. Random Harvest (1942).

Clay F

Thanks for the list. The Night of the Hunter is on my watchlist. I look forward to seeing a young Robert Mitchum.

Birdie Num Num

She would love it! But most here have not seen it, I'm sure so it would never win a poll.

Mike H

Citizen Kane should be reserved for film students. No one deserves to watch that for entertainment. Regretfully, I think that's the only one on the poll that I've actually seen.

Clarence Newman

Oh yes, I forgot Wolf with Jack and Michelle Pfeiffet. Legendary.

Stephen Dias

You'd think it would still appear on the list.

Michael Lewis

My favorite movie here is The Thin Man, but I voted for Double Indemnity because it's the best movie on the list. Citizen Kane was a technical marvel for its time, but the dramatic content is far from compelling and makes, I think, for a dry and tedious watch for modern audiences now used to its then-revolutionary techniques.

Chris Thom

Did a tour of Hearst Castle not too long ago, so wouldn't mind seeing Citizen Kane again. Don't remember a ton about it, but I did see that David Fincher movie Mank in the interim. Sunset Blvd. also an all-timer classic. Any budding movie expert should probably see both.

Uncle Phoenix

I would definitely have to pick up some “Glaucoma Medicine” to be able wo watch a Whole Pre 1960’s movie.

Richard Maurer

They really should call this the “anti-YouTube poll” I love old movies but they’re usually death on YT. Maybe Citizen Kane will do okay but I wouldn’t count on it.

Richard Maurer

Just be glad it doesn’t have a sequel.

Bill Maurer

I saw it once and every movie buff/connoisseur should watch it as well. Like 2001: A Space Odyssey. I saw it once and tried twice, but i just did not see the greatness in it

DarthRandal1138

Kane appears to be running away with this one (as it should!) so I’d say maybe try and watch the second place finisher as well at some point?

Geoff S.

Karl Malden should have won the Oscar for that speech in the cargo hold alone.

crazyivan

No Cary Grant or John Wayne movie? Blasphemy!

Mark Duedall

He should have been a contender.

Geoff S.

He was! Nominated but didn’t win.

Catherine LW

Wow Citizen Kane running away with it! I voted for Sunset Boulevard and City Lights, but I am ok with Kane. Rosebud…

Catherine LW

It’s not going to fail with one old film per month. 🙄

Catherine LW

I am disappointed that Notorious didn’t make it either.

Catherine LW

Oops forgot to add The Thin Man as my vote.

Mike Lemon

Well, I hear insomnia is a big problem for some. Those people might "watch" this every night for the next 50 years to fix that. She could get a billion views on it this year alone.

Catherine LW

Unpopular take but I hate the music in The Third Man. Jarring and incongruent.

Larry Darrell

We need another one of these with comedies. Only 2 out 10 comedies up there. I love these films, but there is a lot of depression and sadness happening here.

Just Plain Bob

I voted for Citizen Kane and The Thin Man. Glad to see Citizen Kane doing so well but sorry to see The Thin Man trailing so badly. Nick and Nora Charles are probably my favorite on-screen couple (with the exception of Grace Kelly and anyone).

Larry Darrell

Here with you Abraham. I feel you.

Thomas Meredith

Cassie would absolutely love Nick and Nora

Larry Darrell

We need to splice in some comedies though.

Happy Hanukkah

I am stunned this poll does not include the classic I Was a Teenage Werewolf (1957)!

Happy Hanukkah

True, these are all classics, but couldn't we have included some movies that are more up Cassie's alley, such as M (1931)?

Phil

It's not going to win but i think it's a perfect movie (for a reaction and otherwise)

Paul Stelter

Night of the Hunter would be good for Halloween, and Paths of Glory for Veterans/Armistice Day. Arguably the best war movie ever made even though it's a courtroom drama.

Eddie Perkins

Citizen Kane, really? Double Indemnity or even Night of the Hunter. I think she would have loved Double Indemnity.

Eddie Perkins

I've watched it three times. I'm not saying it's bad, but it's way overrated.

YodatheHobbit

Going with Citizen Kane since it's one of only 2 I've heard of.

Jens Kristensen

I rewatched "Animal Crackers" yesterday... its a silly, goofy and really funny movie... 100 years old in about four years and still great.

Henry Graham

This is inexplicable to me. I find Citizen Kane to be terrifically entertaining, very moving and endlessly rewatchable. If innovation was its only virtue I don't think it would still be as beloved.

Henry Graham

I am simply staggered by the number of people here claiming Citizen Kane is no fun!

Long-time Sci-Fi Enthusiast

The trouble is there are so many wonderful films that are pre-1960, as I discovered myself over the decades. I appreciate any reactors that decide to explore as I did, i know they will not be disappointed. After all, it is not for nothing that it is referred to as "The Golden Age of Hollywood ". Equally, British Cinema had it`s best period in the 1930`s & `40`s, with some wonderful films. The Ealing Comedies & Gainsborough Pictures Melodramas, the former included stars Alec Guinness & Alistair Sim. Alistair Sim also worked in the latter studios, who also had among their directors a certain Alfred Hitchcock.

Richard Maurer

I Was a Teenage Werewolf was better than the name implies, but “classic” might be going a little too far.

Jeff Graham

I definitely enjoyed others movies on this list more too, but voted for Citizen Kane because it's important to watch as a film often stated to be the best movie ever.

Jacob Neff

It's one of if not the best screenplay of all time.

Jacob Neff

All of these are must see. Having to choose is criminal.

Happy Hanukkah

Sure, there might have been some better movies, but a full semester is devoted to it in every reputable acting academy, as Michael Landon's first film role!

Richard Maurer

I remember watching Little House on the Prairie, wondering when he was going to change into a Werewolf.

Richard Maurer

I went with Night of the Hunter, not that it matters now, Citizen Kane has this in the bag.

Happy Hanukkah

You too? I'm still upset that they tricked me into wasting some 170 hours of my life!

Richard Maurer

Seems silly now, but those were more innocent times.

Clarence Newman

Agree with that, Jeff. It’s a box that needs to be ticked. But just the once.

KyloJames

Double Indemnity!!! Classic

Richard Maurer

Clarence - I used to think Katherine Hepburn was unattractive, till I saw her in Bringing Up Baby.

Joe J

Voting totals show low interest in these B&W polls. A number of top films missing from both polls doesn't help.

Clay F

The films in this pre-1960 poll are top films. Pre-1960 polls always have lower participation.

Stick Figure Studios

Same. I've been pushing it on the channel for a long time. If it's one of my five submissions when I won trivia night. It is an extraordinary work of art and a worthy contender for the title of greatest film ever made. I do not understand those who do not see it as engrossing human drama in addition to a magnificent technical achievement.

Stick Figure Studios

All of these are great films, but two of them were on my own five submissions when I won trivia night: CITIZEN KANE and CITY LIGHTS. I'd fine with either, but I'm especially pleased to see that KANE is winning. It's a rite of passage for any serious film buff.

Richard Maurer

I recognize its importance and artistic merit. Still not a film that I feel the need to see again. I’ve seen it a couple of times. Still I’ watch Cassie’s reaction.

Stick Figure Studios

@Henry: Me too. I think a lot of people just approach it with the wrong mindset. In some ways it's a victim of its own reputation as the greatest film ever made. People watch it expecting to be completely blown away by it, not realizing that they've already seen many of it s innovations in all the other movies they've watched because they have become so commonplace. I liked it when I first saw it, but I really grew to love and appreciate it the more I learned about film and the more times I watched it. I don't agree with those who say it only needs to be seen once. I think it needs to be seen multiple times to be truly appreciated

Stick Figure Studios

Once again, I agree, henry. I think it is fantastic not just as a piece of brilliant filmmaking but as a piece of compelling human drama.

Stick Figure Studios

I'm going to disagree with this and say that it can actually very entertaining for those who aren't just film students long as they are open to the experience, although I do you think it is true that it is probably easier for people who love and appreciate Cinema as an art form to find Great value in it then those who are just casual movie watchers.

Stick Figure Studios

I've been pushing it for a long time. It was one of my five submissions when I won trivia night. Truly a great film and long overdue watch.

Alex M

So many classics here! Sunset Boulevard - one of my first watches in my classic movie journey and an outstanding introduction to the joy of “old movies”. Double Indemnity- I’ve never seen anyone play the vamp better than Barbara Stanwyck. On the Waterfront - one of Brando’s best (although to me Streetcar was his very best, just barely edging out The Godfather). And possibly my favorite of this list: All About Eve. In addition to the incomparable Bette Davis at her best, you get the always wonderful Thelma Ritter and arguably the finest rendition of a genuine SOB in George Sanders’ Addison DeWitt. I’m ashamed to admit it but I’ve never seen Citizen Kane, an unforgivable sin I know. Same for Night of the Hunter, one I’ve been meaning to watch for quite some time. Time to get busy.