Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

Hi friends, ! How are you? I’m having a bit of a sad week, one of my kids is in a bit of a crisis with his autoimmune again and I feel pretty helpless and stuck about it. The good things Im focusing on this week were the smell of a fresh rain, a new fall drink at my fav drink place, ordered a halloween puzzle and planned a night with friends to do it and the kids crying laughing trying to pull a prank on me. What were your good things?

Did anyone watch the emmys? I saw Widows Bay swept, have any of you watched that? I think I might have to now-one friend told me it’s scary and she can only watch during the day! I also saw the adorable Knight of the 7 Kingdoms' two lead stars on the red carpet and just fell more in love with them!

Speaking of them-this week's uploads will be the last two epis of KOT7K and our poll winner Citizen Kane, and GODZILLA! Next week will be cellular (our PaF winner), Clerks and A Bridge too Far! This week will also be our first Scary but not too Scary Poll! Classic Horror-make sure to go vote!! I have a few titles in mind that I am planning on watching already this year for SBNTS October, but you all get to help me pick the rest with polls throughout the month! I won't start any new TV shows at least until after October! Dun dun duuuuunnnnnn!

Did I tell you we’re going to do a halloween scary movie trivia night again? Have that on your radar!

Also on the radar-Extra Butter Night next week on 9/22!

Don’t forget to enter Pick a Flick for September-not too scary of picks ok? ;)

Have the best weekend!

Cassie

Files

Comments

WestBound

Please watch Arcane next as our weekly show

Walter Crockett

Charles Foster Kane!!!!! 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉👏👏👏 Let’s Go!!!!

Rosario Cicero

It’s highly unlikely that she’ll recognize CK as one of (many say THE) greatest films of all time but it’s a movie that everyone on the planet should watch at least once

ghostmoan

My wife and I loved Widow’s Bay. Even if you don’t watch it for the channel I would definitely recommend it Mrs. Cassie, it’s an excellent series

Jay Davis

Unpopular opinion but... I really like this Godzilla.

Geoff S.

Oh, I hope your child feels better! My sister struggles with that too and it's hard.

Richard Maurer

Cassie - why call it Scary but not too scary when one of your stated goals for 2026 is to watch the scariest movie you’ve ever seen? Kind of makes the “ not too scary” part meaningless. I prefer Popcorn in Dread, it’s much less cumbersome . Hope your kid feels better soon.

Anthony Carlson

Citizen Kane should be an interesting reaction. It’s considered one of the greatest films ever made (AFI number one for years and years). I hope everything is ok with your oldest (Edit: whoever it is). And for Carly as well.

Gray

I'll be ticking off Citizen Kane too then, getting through some classic cinema after Gone With The Wind earlier this year.

Mojo One Thousand

Oh man, hope everything improves with your kiddo.

Mike Redford

Yup, gotta love "Dunk and Egg". Best wishes to your son. Hope all's well soon. I'm looking forward to october so much this yr. Binging the scary favorites, your SBNTS reactions, crisp cool air, apple cider, sweatshirts and jeans, etc. Gonna be a real VIBE

WestBound

I am sooo sorry I commented before reading . I pray that your little makes a speedy recovery

Clarence Newman

I will help you choose if I must. As you seem to be watching The Blob with a young Steve McQueen, it would only be right and proper and fair and equitable to then have a Steve McQueen poll, of which the following films would be fab: The Cincinatti Kid (1965) - Young stud poker stud takes on The Man for all the beans Bullitt (1968) - There are no other car chases. This is the car chase. The Getaway (1972) - Ok, if you watch this one, just remember, she still married him after he slapped her silly. Papillon (1973) - Simply the best McQueen movie. His best performance, Dustin Hoffman's best performance. It's quite long, though, so prepare for numbness in the nethers. Towering Inferno (1974) - You should just watch this one. Literally tens of thousands of comments over the past year, begging for a reaction to it. Why do you hate us, Cassie? Why? Also....speaking of fab stuff.....it's time for A Hard Day's Night with The Beatles. You need to experience Ringo's enormous great hooter, with his poor little head trembling under the weight of it. Also, Horror of Dracula. But you know that already cos someone here's got it tattooed on his forehead. Love to your boy. All a mother can do is love and the rest will work itself out.

Jenny_M

I'm so excited for Citizen Kane! Also, as someone who is a lot like you with horror, I can say that Widow's Bay does have some scary moments, but it's not actually that bad. Without any spoilers, I can say that it's equal parts funny and scary.

Michelle Roebuck

I think you’ll enjoy Widow’s Bay. A great show to react to during October.

Stick Figure Studios

Sorry to hear about your child, Cassie. Hope everything turns out okay. :-( WIDOW'S BAY is terrific. My wife and I are huge fans of Matthew Rhys and probably would have watched it just because he's in it, but the writing and the filmmaking is actually really good. It is primarily a horror series, but it has a strangely quirky and ironic sense of humor. It's both funny and scary. I love it. But what I am really excited about is that you are finally taking the plunge and viewing one of the most important films ever made: Orson Welles's masterpiece CITIZEN KANE. It's a rite of passage for any serious film buff. I realize that you heard mixed things ranging all the way from it's being of the most overrated movies of all time to it it truly is one of the greatest (if not the greatest) films ever made. Personally speaking, I tend to be in the latter camp as it is one of my favorite films (which is why I submitted it as one of my five pics when I won trivia night). II think it is extraordinary work of art that gets richer, deeper and more rewarding with each subsequent view... I have seen it maybe 20 times in my life and I never tire of it. At any rate, don't let these varied opinions of it intimidate you. Sometimes I think KANE has become a sort of victim of its own heightened reputation. I'll talk more about it after you actually watch it, but you just do what you always do and have as genuine and authentic reaction as possible. I actually think you will like it because while it is true that the techniques used in it were very innovative at the time, it also works as compelling human drama and is actually a sort of mystery (as you will see). Really looking forward to that. As always, Keep up the good work.

Clarence Newman

Yes! "Scary But Holy Crap I Just Soiled Myself" should be the new slogan. We'll have you watching Evil Dead as a warm-up before you know it.

DarthRandal1138

You should definitely react to Widow’s Bay. It’s wicked funny, and pretty squarely falls into Scary But Not Too Scary territory.

Anthony Lopez

One little thing, A Bridge Too Far should have subtitles for the non English parts, sometimes streaming services mess with them

Clay F

My guess -- just a guess -- is she views "Scary but not too scary" not for each movie but instead collectively in sum for the October movies. One super scary movie in combination with multiple movies that include somewhat scary, mildly scary, or not that scary = a "scary, but not too scary" October. That's essentially a trademark for her now. I also like Popcorn in Dread.

Brent Petty

Suggestions for the other October polls: Fallen (Denzel Washington), Frailty (Matthew McConaughey, Bill Paxton), the first Paranormal Activity, and Dawn of the Dead (2004), and Panic Room (Jodie Foster, Kristen Stewart). Panic Room is more of a tense thriller than horror, but it's good.

Hunter DeRensis

Widows Bay would be a great show to react to. It's very funny.

Garrett Wilson

Ironically you're about to watch a movie about enjoying the good things. My good things are my fridge is full of my favorite steak, I'm about to be in a short film, and my 20 year class reunion is coming up!

Doc Larry/old geezer

I think Citizen Kane (1941) is a good choice. It’s one of the great classics. A terrific follow-up, even if it’s off-channel, would be The Magnificent Ambersons (1942), Orson Welles’s second feature film as director after Citizen Kane. Welles in his prime was remarkable, a gifted director, actor, and storyteller. I have to give myself some credit for opening up my own horizons, too. I’m glad I watched CODA (2021). It was completely unexpected, and since I’ve spent this week on my back with COVID, it was a very pleasant surprise. I also think CODA would be a good choice for the channel. I think Cassie would enjoy it, and if Carly, even as a brand-new mother, can still find time to watch it with her sister, I think she’d enjoy it too. Just my opinion.

Richard Maurer

Wait, Evil Dead is considered scary?

Jake McNulty

A few “Scary-but-not-too-scary” suggestions: Addams Family Values Death Becomes Her What We Do in the Shadows

Jacob Neff

I know scary but not too scary is your thing, and I know you swore it off when you started this channel, but I really think you're ready for The Exorcist. I too had sworn it off earlier in life, but it turned out to be far more thoughtful and poignant than I expected. Far from just another demonic scary movie.

Mark Deadman

I'm two episodes into Widows Bay. It definitely seems like an interesting show.

Richard Maurer

Clay - But last October was overwhelmingly scary, something that should be continued, imo. And Popcorn in Dread just sounds way better.

Jay Davis

I didn't notice that A Bridge Too Far was coming next week until I saw your comment. Thrilled! Adore that movie having watched it countless times. Looking forward to seeing PiB watch it now.

Dan

Highly recommend Widow's Bay.

Clay F

Tonight will watch your full reaction to A Knight of the Seven Kingdoms (S1:5-6). Looking forward to it. Will be a first watch of those two episodes for me. I loved the first 4 episodes which I watched a couple of months ago, and rewatched with your reactions. Sending positive signals to your boy.

Steve Holton

Best wishes for the health of your family! My good things this week were some good health outcomes for family, celebrating the California Gustine Festa, and the interesting and entertaining book “Dark Matter” by Blake Crouch. The book made into a series for Apple TV with Joel Edgerton and Jennifer Connely that I look forward to watching. 😊

Robert da Spruce

Sorry to hear your kid’s going through a rough time. Hope they feel better soon 🙏 Have you been watching Season 4 of Ted Lasso? I watched the latest episode last night. That show always puts a smile on my face Have a great weekend Cassie!

Steve Holton

Agree CODA (2021) is a heartwarming and uplifting film. Hope you feel better soon Doc Larry! 😊

Richard Maurer

Five movies with a sixth coming soon. Do you know what “flop” means?

Clay F

+1 for CODA. I got covid shot 3-4 months ago (when I got flu shot) -- hope that significantly reduces my chances of getting covid or makes the symptoms less severe if I do get covid.

Richard Maurer

It’s not nearly as bad as some make it out to be, certainly better than Godzilla ‘98.

Björn Karlsson

This is my fifth "October season" on this channel. I will be very very disapointed if you not doing a reaction of "Let the right one in" this year...

Joe J

I don't care what she calls it as long as I get a few movies I like. Hoping for The Fog (80), The Omen (76), and Horror of Dracula (58). Be disappointed if I don't get one of those at least.

Xavier Casanova

Can we get Doctor Sleep or Midnight Mass for Scaretober, please?!

Nim

💯 Papillon. They don't make films like that anymore. Midnight express also 👍. For years I heard about the legendary car chase in Bullit and when I finally got around to watching the film I was a little underwhelmed. Probably all that built up expectation. The car chase in Ronin is still my favourite.

Joe J

Just Godzilla for me this week. Still hoping you will react to "Midnight Mass" (2021), just seven episodes.

Gary Granata

I would include Love with the Proper Stranger (1963) and Baby the Rain Must Fall (1965).

My_Cousin_Mose

I hope your child feels better soon!

Stick Figure Studios

MIDNIGHT MASS is one of the best things I've ever seen. It's what made me a huge Mike Flanagan fan.

My_Cousin_Mose

And i also think that you should really stop telling people about pick a flick- if they are too lazy to take 5 seconds to update their movie month to month thats on them. But with 500+ entries the odds of winning are uninspiringly low.

K, Zachary

So both of us felt the need to 🙏 for your family this week we had no idea why we just did. We lit a candle in our church, and prayed. My gf Eva tells parents to trust your maternal instinct, or paternal instinct. You see it nature with a mother bear helping her cubs across the road. When it comes to parents your gut instincts are your maternal or paternal instincts. Good things in the fall Eva loves baking apple spice, pumpkin spice muffins, cookies. We leave apples attached to the fence posts for the deer. We have huge set up for the birds right out are bedroom window. We focus on our three dogs and two cats and our bird. That's how we stay happy by making them happy by making other people happy. Kat from Kat watches horror movies is doing Widows Bay, she is also doing Crystal Lake a prequel to the original Friday 13th (1980) which comes out October 8, on Peacock. We really think that House Of The Dragon you would like the characters it's the closest thing to Game Of Thrones. The Pitt won for best drama that deserved to win. That's the best show on TV right now. Indiana Fever are coming on. Caitlin Clark 🫶 has been doing USA basketball for nearly a month. So we can't wait to see her tonight.

John A

Speaking of Kane, you should react to Undertaker vs Mankind Hell in a Cell

Rene G.

Here’s my scary I soiled myself type of movie: Terrifier trilogy

Above Average Dave

God bless to your son, and to you and the family, Cassie. No more helpless a feeling than a sick kid. My heart goes out to you all.

Just Plain Bob

Let the Right One In is a terrific movie and would be an excellent film for an October reaction. But it has subtitles, so there’s no way it gets a reaction.

Just Plain Bob

The five Monsterverse films have cost an estimated $800 million to $840 million to make. They’ve made a little over $2.5 billion. Tastes vary, so you can certainly question how good they are. But they’re definitely not a collective “flop.” Personally, I’ve found them, for the most part, to be dumb popcorn fun (I’ve found some of the human characters to be very tiresome, though).

Richard Maurer

Bob - agreed, not great but mostly fun is how I’d describe them.

Mike Lemon

I've been saying that since the beginning.

Mike Lemon

The Exorcist isn't about "being ready," it's about not wanting to watch it. Why can't people respect that?

Mike Lemon

@Richard - "This week will also be our first Scary but not too Scary Poll!"

Wesley White

Hey Cassie, I'm sorry to hear about one of your kids getting sick again, my heart goes out to you! I wonder what kind of prank they tried pulling on you lol! The only good thing that's going on with me is that I just started my one week vacation from work to "somewhat" celebrate my birthday next week, which just so happens to be your "Extra Butter Night" lol! And I've also gotten started at getting the pieces to my costume for Halloween this year, in my case, I'm dressing up as "The Shadow" an old-school superhero based on the 1930's radio broadcast show of the same name and the 1994 Alec Baldwin movie, I highly recommend that movie, it's so underrated and deserves more love, I'll be sure to send pictures so you can see 😁 Fun fact, The Shadow predates Batman and Superman, and also served as an inspiration to the creation of Batman! Hope you got my fan letter, sorry that it's 29 pages lol, but like I said the majority of it is the voting polls I came up with that I so hope you'll consider posting in the future! I also hope you enjoyed reading the "story" part of the letter about my life lol, I hope you found it interesting and I apologize for some of the extreme parts in it! I'm looking forward for your reaction and starting the Monsterverse with "Godzilla (2014)" it's gonna be one heck of an adventure lol! Take care, love and support, hope Carly's doing okay (give her a hug for me), see you on Extra Butter Night/My Birthday lol, you and Carly are the best, and God bless y'all and the family🥰😇🙏🤗😉✌🌹

Mike Lemon

I said this when the poll was going on, but I'll say it again- there is no shame in falling asleep watching Citizen Kane. You can even have fun with it- change outfits each time you wake up, edit the half dozen or so takes together, but pretend like nothing happened.

MikeLL

A week with Citizen Frickin Kane is a good week in my book!

JONATHAN REDFERN WILLIAMS

Re: The Halloween Poll, Bride of Frankenstein (1935) is actually a sequel to Frankenstein (1931), Cassie. If that film wins the poll, it might be better to watch Frankenstein (1931) first and then Bride of Frankenstein (1935). Just a suggestion!

Richard Maurer

Even Cassie can make mistakes sometimes ;-) But I made a post asking why she’s calling it that when she wants to watch “ the scariest movie she’s ever seen”. I also gave my opinion that Popcorn in Dread is much better (which it is).

Richard Maurer

Bob - unfortunately you’re probably right.

Joe J

Happy for you Stick with Citizen Kane, been a long wait for you.

Catherine LW

I am trying to boost my immune system since getting shingles last May. Still suffering from nerve damage. I recommend to anyone over 50 to get the vaccine. It’s a terrible disease and very painful. That said, I hope you can bolster your boy’s immune system with supplements in addition to what your doctor advises. I hate hearing about sick children. 😔

Kevin Farrell

Bob - why do you say that? She's watched movies with subtitles before.

JONATHAN REDFERN WILLIAMS

To all fans of The Graham Norton Show, the new series will start next week on Friday 26th September. And WHO will be the first guest on the new series?? One of Cassie's favourite Hollywood actors.... TOM CRUISE!!

Kevin Farrell

Throwing out Midnight Mass as another horror miniseries to keep in mind. From the creator of Haunting of Hill House.

Rene G.

YkW, im sick and tired of this horror October only reactions. I want horror reactions outside of October even November. I’d be dead years from now if this continues. I have a perfect replacement for exorcist. Human centipede

Rene G.

Arcane sucks season 2

Kevin Farrell

Say it ain't so Garrett! My reunion is in a few years too, but I swear it was just a few weeks ago that I was bantering and messing around with my buddies in the hallways! How time flies.

WestBound

Sucks ? Lol if season 1 was 10/10 2 was an 8

Rene G.

Tales from the crypt tv series please?

Rene G.

Then there’s no point of a reaction channel

Jacob Neff

I respect it. I also know how rewarding it is. When Cassie first started, she wouldn't have wanted to watch Game of Thrones either, so according to your statement, no one ever should have encouraged her to.

Mike Lemon

She doesn't want to watch The Exorcist because she is morally, maybe religiously, opposed to it (1). It isn't a case of, "I don't think I would like it." (1) She may change her mind in the future, but in the now, the people who are basically saying, "F' your morals, watch this movie I (edit- we) want or we are going to badger you into it" are evil (and I'm not being facetious).

Rick Williams

I am sorry your boy is having A rough time. You just have to roll with it. I started having autoimmune issues at 4. My teenage years were rough but then I was good for over 30 years with a few light flare ups during that time. Unfortunately i am currently having a big flair up and taking It one day at a time. It gets frustrating and overwhelming at times but you just have to keep going. Your son has you and the rest of his family. That means more than you now.

Jacob Neff

I was morally/religiously opposed to it too. My beliefs didn't change, but I'm glad I was persuaded to watch it because there was more to it than I had thought.

Just Plain Bob

That would be awesome. It will also NEVER happen.

Mike Lemon

She's already watched Frankenstein.

Cole Jennett

I don’t really understand the fixation on what she calls it. Does it really matter?

Rene G.

Why not?

Rene G.

what is this?? the MTV TRL channel?

Rene G.

God, we live in such a coddling society.

Chris Thom

Was nice to see Pluribus win some Emmys. Mostly because it was one of a very small number of new shows I actually watched this year. But really interesting premise and fantastic central performance. It won Lead Actress, Writing, Production Design, Editing, Theme Music, and was nominated for Best Drama. A bit slow in parts, but well worth the watch. Created by Vince Gilligan who did Breaking Bad and Saul.

bgb1975 (Brian)

A Perfect World, Cassie! Pleasepleasepleasepleaseplease.

Chris Thom

What did you think of Gone With the Wind?

Rene G.

Popcorn Dread aka "SOILED MYSELF" movie recommends : Cannibal holocaust, Serbian film, Lords of Salem, House of 1000 corpses, Devil's rejects

Keith Brown

Can't wait for "A Bridge Too Far" and as the actors' names roll out at the beginning of the movie Cassie's reaction of Oh My Gosh ! He's in this movie ! Oh My Gosh ! He's in this movie too !! OH! I, can't believe ALL these stars are in this one movie !!

Chris Thom

Was just going to mention the show, but then I saw your last line. Been waiting for an excuse to start that show, maybe this is it. lol. Apple TV has been pretty great so far.

Kevin D

I watched widow’s bay and it was a good series

Steve Holton

Hope things improve soon Rick.

Joe J

Some other films are also off limits not just The Exorcist. I think she feels the imagery in some films will be too disturbing and will linger in her thoughts too long. I can certainly understand that.

Keith Brown

As a older PiB Patreon member I wait and hope Cassie and the members under 40 find the viewing of the classic film "Citizen Kane" a joy to behold. The camera and acting techniques introduced to moviegoers are amazing plus the movie has a great mystery plot to follow as Kane's life unfolds.

Mike Lemon

Respecting someone's wishes and/or not peer pressuring someone into doing something they really don't want to do = "coddling". What? Cassie has named only a very few movies on her "no list," what is the one people obsess over? One of the two or three that she has explicitly said no to.

My_Cousin_Mose

I'm sure I've seen you and Richard each say this at least three times. (edit- grammar)

Rene G.

at this point just watch all the movies that have lost in the frying pan

Matt

4th th th

Richard Maurer

Would it matter if Lord of the Rings was called Lord of the One Ring, But it Controls Sixteen Other Rings - No, I Didn’t Miscount, The One Ring Never Actually Controlled the Three Rings the Elves Had

Matt

I love it

Matt

Citizen Kane is considered one of the best movies ever made and first time I watched it I was thinking its probably not as good as the hype then after I finished it I remember thinking that was one of the best movies ever made

Mark Vaderr

Were the kids successful with their prank on you? What did they do? Also, can we have another bracket soon? 16 movies chosen from the top 500? Please, Cassie!

Richard Maurer

If only Orson Welles had gotten together with Ishiro Honda and made a crossover sequel called Godzilla vs Citizen Kane. We could be watching that this very week!

Richard Maurer

Rene - be serious. You have to be trolling here. Cassie will never watch Cannibal Holocaust or A Serbian Film. No one would let that happen, including me. Some movies really are too much for Cassie.

My_Cousin_Mose

I've been hearing all my life how boring of a movie it is so I'll probably give it a shot just to sate my curiosity.

Richard Maurer

She would have to pick it herself. If it were on a poll people wouldn’t vote for it, because it’s foreign with subtitles. Worse they’d probably ask for the unnecessary American remake instead.

Just Plain Bob

It won’t happen for two reasons. First, Cassie doesn’t like horror. (She is also almost certainly completely unaware of the show’s origin in comics.) And I doubt that she’d appreciate the humor in the show, much less the ironic lessons that so many episodes impart. Second, there are a significant number of patrons that enjoy calling people “whiners” and other epithets if they don’t like the series Cassie chooses to react to. Those same patrons would lose their minds if she devoted a reaction slot a week for several months to a show THEY don’t like. Hypocrisy is something they practice; it’s not something they understand, least of all in themselves.

Richard Maurer

The more she says no, the more they push - some people can’t take no for an answer. I’d like her to watch Hereditary, but she’s said no to that one too. I hope she’ll reconsider but I’ll never push it - it’s her decision to make.

Patrick Flanagan

"You provide the haiku, I'll provide the kaiju"

Jacob Neff

I wasn't aware it had been continued to be brought up.

Chris Thom

I think CODA actually won best picture that year at the Oscars.

Clay F

Currently 415 PAF entries for Sep. “Sing Street” (2016) is the fan favorite w/5 picks. Littlefinger is the dad. Awesome movie.

Rene G.

Doesn’t like horror, yet continues her October horror reactions. Make it make sense.

Matt

Widows Bay wins are definitely well deserved, best show of the year!

Rene G.

At this point, this channel is like the demolition man utopia. As Simon phenix once said, a bunch of sissies.

Rene G.

Then those recommends are all slop and no one asked for

Donnie MOORE

Theres some great made for TV movies that I never see any reactions to. -SALEMS LOT 1979 a Stephen King Story -THE NIGHT STALKER 1972 -TRILOGY OF TERROR 1975 An anthology -CATS EYE 1985 not made for tv but a good Stephen King anthology.

Richard Maurer

Rene - She continues horror reactions because they’re popular with a decent segment of her patrons and they generally do well on YouTube.

Stick Figure Studios

I was going to say that it's not boring at all and you should prepare to be enthralled, but then I realized maybe it's better for you to go in with very low expectations because then perhaps you'll be pleasantly surprised. CITIZEN KANE is a magnificent movie, but it's also probably a victim of its own hype. People here it's been called the "greatest movie of all time" and then they go into it expecting to witness the "best they've ever seen on screen" but they possess neither the cinematic knowledge or historical context to properly appreciate it, so they end up being disappointed and refer to it as one of the most "overrated" things they've ever seen. So instead I'm going to tell you that yes, it is "long" and "slow" and "boring." Don't expect much from it. In fact, you'll probably hate it. ;-)

Stick Figure Studios

I love the Shadow (both the character, the radio series and the Alec Baldwin Movie). I thought about dressing up as him myself for Halloween at some point. Also, quick little tidbit of trivia that you may or may not know, but the original voice of the actor on the old radio show was none other than... Orson Welles.

Stick Figure Studios

I am so pumped. I've been wanting this movie for years. I made it one of my five trivia night picks.

Stick Figure Studios

As the English poet Robert Graves once said about William Shakespeare, "He really is very good, in spite of all the people who say he is very good." I think the same thing could be said about KANE. Is it the greatest movie ever made? Maybe, maybe not. I don't think such a thing even really exists, but it's certainly a worthy contender for that honor.

Richard Maurer

When we were first discussing this I proposed making it Extra Butter only, mostly to give incentive for people to join EB, but I also knew if the general population were let in it would get way too many people involved and the odds would be crap - which turned out as I feared.

Just Plain Bob

I’d throw in Dark Night of the Scarecrow (1981) and Don’t Be Afraid of the Dark (1973).

Stick Figure Studios

Orson Welles used to jokingly say in interviews that CITIZEN KANE was not the greatest movie ever made, but his next movie was going to be!

Stick Figure Studios

Yeah, this has been a long time coming, although in a sense maybe it's better that she experience it now when she has more cinematic knowledge under her belt and it will be much easier for her to appreciate it.

Just Plain Bob

I prefer Welles’ Touch of Evil (1958), but Citizen Kane is fantastic.

Stick Figure Studios

It's a magnificent film. I don't necessarily expect any of our younger patrons wanting it for the first time to be as enamored of it as I was on my first viewing, but the more people that see KANE, the better. Maybe it will even inspire some folks to give it another watch, because it is definitely a film that improves on subsequent viewings.

Just Plain Bob

I saw something on Kat’s channel I never thought I’d see. She got genuinely upset (really, really angry) over The Devil’s Rejects.

Matt

Never seen that, but I'll definitely watch it now 👍

Richard Maurer

Jacob - yeah it’s become not only a Halloween tradition, but also gets random comments throughout the year. There are quite a few people who seem obsessed with getting her to watch The Exorcist. I certainly wouldn’t mind if she did, I’d be right there to watch with her, but there are many other horror movies that she hasn’t said no to that I’d rather she watch anyway.

Just Plain Bob

I keep seeing recommendations for horror tv shows for Cassie. First, let me acknowledge that I don’t ever see that happening, unless it’s a short one season that could fit within the reaction slots for October. That said, if Cassie were to react to a series, I’d recommend the following: Kolchak: The Night Stalker (20 episodes + two tv movies that kicked off the series) this is the series that Chris Carter ripped off to such great effect with the X Files X Files (11 seasons, 218 episodes) I’d recommend only the “monster of the week” episodes (and, even then, only select episodes); the mythology really falls apart as the seasons stack up Masters of Horror (first season only - 13 episodes) offerings by John Carpenter, Joe Dante, John Landis, Tobe Hooper, Dario Argento and more; truly they are masters Tales from the Crypt (seven seasons; after season 4 or 5 the quality diminishes) fantastic adaptation of the comic books of the same name; patron Rene recommended this first and it got me thinking Tales from the Darkside (4 season) an anthology series created by legendary horror maestro George Romero Twilight Zone (5 seasons) the granddaddy of weird, creepy tv shows and still the best

Wesley White

Yes I did know that, and considering Cassie is about to react to "Citizen Kane" how fitting lol!

Donnie MOORE

Hate it when the kids get health issues. 😔🙏🏽

Just Plain Bob

Richard, that was exactly my thinking. Subtitled movies have no chance unless EVERY movie in the poll is subtitled.

Gray

I liked alot about it but I did have to watch it in two sittings and I'd say It's unlikely I would watch it again tbh

Just Plain Bob

It matters because some of her patrons hate horror and will grasp at ANYTHING they can find to warn her off watching genuinely scary movies. They start up with that nonsense about it scarring her. As long as “not too scary” is part of the name, they’ve got their excuse (as if they needed one). For that matter, IMO she should seriously consider asking a couple of horror fans from the community to give her horror movie advice. Richard would be an obvious choice. As it is, whoever’s giving her advice clearly knows next to nothing about horror. If I were looking for suggestions on all time great films, for example, I’d probably ask Stick and one or two others. I would NOT ask someone that hates anything in B&W, or that was made before they were born, or hates subtitles, etc.

Just Plain Bob

The opening shot is legendary. Gorgeous and some kind of feat of engineering (you’ll understand why I say that when you see it). It languished unseen for decades. The studio released their own cut, which I’ve never seen but have heard bad things about. Welles’ drafted a long memo detailing how he INTENDED it to be cut. Forty years later, the studio finally followed his advice and gave it a limited re-release. That’s when I saw it - and it was love at first sight for me.

Mayhem Theater

Do you? Just because a cash cow made back it's budget doesn't mean it isn't waste of money lackluster slop. Godzilla vs Kong was stupid but a much better sequel where Godzilla x Kong was a step back down. Things can still change with the Paramount Warner Bros Merger eventually going to happen and the death of the deaf actress

Morris B

Good luck with all the health stuff. You'll be back asap. Hopefully <3 <3 <3

Kevin Farrell

Ah that makes more sense. Bummer. That's leaving tons of good movies on the table.

Steven Perez

Having watched every Godzilla film made since I was a kid, I agree with you. That's the great thing about Godzilla. There have been plenty of interpretations of the character, so one is free to enjoy any and all.

Clarence Newman

Ooh, what’s that second one? Never heard of it, so I need to check it out.

Clarence Newman

Nim. I understand, but nothing sounds like McQueen’s Mustang in Bullitt.

Clarence Newman

Hell no. I asked Richard for advice once. Now I have a tattoo of Christopher Lee chewing on my butt.

Canadianant

Agreed nim. Ronin is the better chase at this point and was shot at full speed with the actor is the cars. Bullitt is well known as on le of the first of a kind I believe but it's not as exciting to a modern audience

Richard Maurer

Not my fault! I told you to put it on your neck.

Mike Lemon

I'm going to say it again- Can we get a "rule 6 - no pictures" ? We already have the chat that was ruined day one with the picture obsessed. Let them stay there.

Rene G.

yeah well, the ending saved her from agony towards them. lol

Clarence Newman

Yikes. I believe that’s the only time a WWE commentator has seriously used the phrase “Stop the damn match!” Brutal.

Richard Maurer

Kat didn’t like House of a 1000 Corpses either. And while I don’t agree with her about either film, I’m not expecting Cassie to ever react to them.

Richard Maurer

Kevin - 100% agree. But a large segment of our fellow patrons are close-minded to anything other than their narrow range of interests. Trying suggesting anything that’s outside the mainstream here and you’ll always get comments complaining about it.

Richard Maurer

The definition of a “flop “ is a movie or movies that lose money. It has nothing to do with a film’s highly subjective artistic merits, or lack thereof.

Rene G.

and at this point, needs more Kat collaboration reactions as her emotional support for such extreme horror stuff. lol. Terrifier would be a good start. :p Or final destination sequels with her and Friday the 13th stuff

Rene G.

Btw who's winning the halloween movie polls lately??

Richard Maurer

Steven - agreed, except Godzilla ‘98. I’m pretty sure your Godzilla fan credentials can be revoked for liking that movie.

Nim

Agreed mate 👍

Nim

I think that's the other reason. I was influenced by more modern car chases I'd grown up watching so I couldn't really appreciate just how groundbreaking and fresh it was at the time. Don't get me wrong the Bullit car chase is fantastic but I think it would have served me better not having years of built up expectation so I should probably never mention the Ronin car chase for the sake of the next generation 😂😉.

Dean Holt

I really liked it too, it took a lot of criticism because when it look like Godzilla was about to fight or do something in the first half of the movie. It cut to something else. - But out of all of these I’d rank it around 3rd. Behind Skull Island and King of the Monsters.

Clarence Newman

I didn’t think you could here. It’s an Extra Butter thing.

Dean Holt

I know as a person who’s a bit obsessed with watching movies. I definitely should have watched Citizen Kane a long time ago, but it’s something that every time I’ve thought about watching it. I’ve just put something else on. But I’ll definitely check it on now but I’ll be honest I’m still not that excited about watching it. - Definitely looking forward to watching Godzilla, but next weeks is looking pretty good. Cellular is an ok movie, Bridge to Far I’ve not watched in a while so definitely looking forward to watching that & Clerks I’m very interested to see what Cassie makes of it lol. I know Cassie said she wanted a 100k view on a PaF. Just looked on YouTube and if The Last StarFighter had won (got into the last 10) CineBinge & Jen Murray are very close to getting 100k. Also if she likes Clerks some one got around 250k views on YouTube for Clerks II. ….. Just an update I’ve just watched CineBinge reaction to Last StarFighter and it’s just gone over 100k views

Ginko

Mike, I don’t think Cassie has ever said she’s against The Exorcist for moral or religious reasons. From what’s been shared, it sounds more like sensitivity to the imagery itself (especially the demonic scenes with a child), like Joe mentioned. I don’t think she’s ever been super clear about the exact reason, and the pinned FAQ/rules post doesn’t even mention any rules about suggestions, let alone a “no-list.” Because of that, I don’t think the requests bother her much, so I don’t see why anyone else should take issue with people asking. Especially if they’re new here.

Sonny

What's the new fall drink?

Mike Lemon

The Blob...??? Or did you mean 'writing'?

Mike Lemon

"especially the demonic scenes with a child" In other words 'morally, maybe religiously, opposed to it .'

F0ZYWOLF

Has she seen The Lost World 1925 one of the first stop motion feature films it was also a location similar to where they go in the movie UP

Ginko

The point is that if the requests bothered her enough to be an issue, it would be in the pinned FAQ post. Since it’s not, I don’t think it’s fair to call people disrespectful for asking.

ProgressiveRoxx

Now that you have finished Andor I would love to see some reactions to the animated Star Wars shows, starting with Clone Wars. It is aimed at kids so you may even want to watch it (off stream) with your kids too. It does get darker in later seasons, especially when Order 66 is enacted.

Mannygogou

I sometimes mention "Sphere (1998)" as a not-too scary pic. Hmm let me look... well it shows up as a type of psychological thriller with aspects of... you know... the-genre-we-oft-not-speak-of 😶

Just Plain Bob

I’ve really enjoyed the couple of collaborations they’ve done so far. I’d love to see more.

Mark White

Hey Cassie, I’m so sorry to hear about your Son’s continued health struggles. You are in my thoughts. 🙏 I understand how hard it is to watch the one you love struggle with their health and there is nothing you can do to help. Lucy was in so much pain last week, she threw up! All the meds have failed her. We just hold on in hope for the DBS treatment assessment in January 🫰. Should be an interesting and varied week ahead. I haven’t seen Godzilla, but it will please your monster heads on here to have another one. I haven’t watched AKotSK yet, but soon I hope. Citizen Kane is a must for a cinephile, even if, like me, you think it’s just ok. You can appreciate its importance in film history. Anywho, all the best Cass. You are the best ❤️ P.S please give Horror of Dracula a try in October 🙏

Just Plain Bob

Godzilla ‘98 is the Cannonball Run of kaiju films.

Mannygogou

Someone suggested a Poll with titles pulled randomly from PaF submissions... but with this twist - The winner is chosen from the loser end, from the titles who got the fewest votes! Okay, a poll is a popularity vote... which is not the nature of PaF... and the winners of such polls are the movies that have been "seen the most" by the group which is also contrary to the nature of PaF. We already know every PaF selections are carefully thought out and vetted movies that are one-in-a-lifetime per member pick of a movie they most desire... it goes beyond a guilty-pleasure movie because it's only one, a list of one. Therefore any one PaF is worth watching, that's why it's chosen randomly or by wheel... which is random. A poll to remove randomness... but random is the goal. Therefore subvert the poll nature by picking the poll loser as the winner! 😶

Joe J

Clay likes photos...we are doomed. You have to use the mobile app to post photos here in comments.

Robert Evans

As some who also deals with auto-immune issues your son has my best wishes. Widow's Bay is terrific and while it is horror comedy you have already watched things much scarier. I think you can handle it.

Byrd N. Hand

Of course, Cassie *did* say at the beginning of the year that one of her goals for the channel was to see a new 'scariest movie she's ever seen.' Frankly, "The Exorcist" and perhaps "The Texas Chainsaw Massacre"... and apparently "Hereditary," from what I'm hearing (haven't seen it myself), are the only titles I can think of that *might* actually dethrone "The Shining" for her. 🤷‍♂️ (Maybe "Suspiria" would also have an outside shot?)

Richard Maurer

I said it would be fun idea for April fools, but I suppose you could do it anytime. I think Cassie might be afraid of angering people, you know how cranky people can be.

Byrd N. Hand

My main issue with "Citizen Kane" is the same I have with "GoodFellas" and "Saving Private Ryan": I just never felt that invested in any of its characters. 🤷‍♂️ It's a film I greatly appreciate, but I'll never *love* it. Outside of the opening, the scene that most sticks in my mind is when Joseph Cotten's character is so bored by the performance that he starts tearing patterns in his program -- not only for being spoofed in a Simpsons episode (the one with the "Streetcar Named Desire" musical), but also because it's something I *swear* I used to do as a kid in church. 🤨

Mannygogou

Someone: "I think we just want more PaF movies...!" Dude: "Yes"

Mannygogou

the gameyfication of such a poll would be interesting to consider... Hmm... the loser wins... Therefore to want your pick to win... you'd have to vote for the title you don't want to win... which maybe are the popular and more-seen titles... You absolutely can't vote for the one you want to win... but if you don't vote at all you're not even in the game... hmm... To be in the game you'd have to subvert the subversion of a poll of a poll...

Richard Maurer

Mark, you and Lucy are in my thoughts, hoping for the best for both of you. Having gone through a recurring medical issue the last 2 months that I have (hopefully) overcome I have experienced a small fraction of what Lucy must be going through, and she has my deepest sympathy. And that you still took the opportunity to promote HoD was truly touching. Thank you, my friend.

Richard Maurer

Dean, you’re not alone in that Citizen Kane boat, many people put off watching it. The hype that’s it’s “greatest movie of all time” or whatever, combined with the feeling of a school assignment you get from being told it’s “required viewing” makes people want to avoid it. When I finally broke down and watched it I felt underwhelmed - nothing can live up to all that hype. After time to reflect I still don’t think it was the best film I’d ever seen, not really my genre for one thing, but you can definitely see the innovation and appreciate it for that, if nothing else. My advice would be don’t go into it expecting to be amazed, you might enjoy it more.

Mark White

Thank you Richard ❤️

Richard Maurer

Mike, that’s a whole other can of worms.

Mike Lemon

True. I offered a simple solution last year or the year before but it is what it is.

Richard Maurer

I can see posting links if you want but the pictures stick out like a sore thumb - which I suppose is the idea. But they are kind of annoying, a Sing Street jpeg isn’t going to get me to care anymore than I already do, which is not at all.

Mike Corrao

I just really hope your kid/kids are feeling better. No need to talk about movies. Family and health first.

Richard Maurer

Me too, just has to be the right movie.

Richard Maurer

My idea is that only Cassie knows what’s happening until the poll is over. Then it’s revealed everyone voted for the wrong movies - as an April fools prank I think most people would get a laugh out of it. But it ends with a movie nobody wants to watch. Instead of random they would probably want to make sure all the movies were at least somewhat popular. Maybe take them from the top fifty requests?

Joe J

Clarence could photo-bomb comments with Cannonball Run photos. That will horrify Ben and he'll then ban all photos...lol.

Mark White

Really would love to see towering inferno and Buillet on PiB one day 🙏

Joe J

Lucy is in my prayers Mark. When our loved ones are suffering it is the worst feeling.

Mark White

Cathrine sorry to hear that. Shingles suck big time! Hope you get better soon. 🙏❤️

Richard Maurer

That would horrify many patrons also. We don’t want a mass exodus.

Mark White

+ a million for “A Perfect world” 🙏

Mark White

+1 for Death becomes her. I’m sure Cassie and Carly will love it. But it could and arguably should be watched outside of October. I feel the horror fans would revolt if that’s counted as anything to do with horror.

Mark White

I was wondering what the prank was?!

Richard Maurer

Cassie mentioned in a live (PaF, I think) that the 2 movies that scared her the most were The Shining and Nosferatu’24. I’d give the edge To Nosferatu though, she was a seasoned horror film viewer last year when she watched it, instead of the novice who watched The Shining. What movies could really scare her? Besides the ones already mentioned? There are many but limiting it to (off the top of my head) the ones that actually have a shot of getting watched here: Ring (Ringu) ‘98 It Follows Ju-on: The Grudge Paranormal Activity Sinister

Richard Maurer

Those all would definitely cover the not scary part. I hope this year is like last year’s Halloween, mostly scary with the weak stuff kept to a bare minimum. It would honestly be a huge disappointment to the horror fans here if we went back to the way things were before last year.

AceofSpades501

"History shows again and again how nature points out the folly of men" Blue Oyster Cult

Steve Holton

Very sad to hear that, Mark. Hope better days come soon.

Night King01

I heard widows bay is a comedy as well.

Mark Vaderr

I really like this movie too, it's fun and entertaining and there's some good acting in it. I like the backstory in it as well.

Bryan Erickson

Widow’s Bay is great. Really fun vibe. There are scary moments, but nothing you can’t handle.

Dean Holt

Cheers, tbh I’m going in with very low expectations 😂. But we shall see what I make of it. I actually can’t wait to see what Cassie makes of Clerks, I’m pretty sure she will hate at least a couple of characters 😂.

Richard Maurer

There’s only one character I really disliked and his name starts with a R. If you don’t hate him from the first movie you will in the sequel.

Richard Maurer

She should watch it for a live sometime.

Mark White

Thank you Steve ❤️

Dean Holt

I think she will definitely hate R but she also might not like J 😂. But I know his humour isn’t for everyone and it’s completely understandable if you don’t like it, but I’m actually a big Kevin Smith fan. Don’t know if you’ve heard of it but he did a Horror film called Red State it’s completely different from anything he’s done and I really liked it.

Mark White

Jacob, I have to admit I have bought the Exorcist up on occasions. So I may be partly to blame. My inquires have been a “Polite knock at the door” just to see if Cassie had changed her mind. I too have argued, is it that bad? You have seen worse, but I think on reflection Richard and Mike are right to say respect Cassie decision not to watch it. I’m going to change my way on this one. Also, on reflection I quite like the fact Cassie has stood by her decision even against consistent asking. It shows she is no push over and knows her own mind and won’t let people like me change it. Good on her, I say.

Just Plain Bob

Widow’s Bay sounds like a good tv series to react to…after October.

Clay F

Mark -- Thinking about y'all. Hoping for the best.

Clay F

Moments ago, she gave a like to my latest comment with an image.

Mike Lemon

Nice minifig. If it's not insanely price on BrickLink, I may have to pick that up.

Catherine LW

True. How many times has Downfall lost?

Chris Thom

Used to love Sphere. Watched that on cable a lot.

Chris Thom

I was obsessed with that intro as a kid. Epic use of miniatures.

Catherine LW

Bless her, Mark. ❤️🙏🏻

Chris Thom

She'll probably appreciate it. But with a movie from 1940 it's pretty much impossible for it not to feel dated. If not for the acting style or black and white. But that's part of the fun I guess. Makes you feel like a proper film aficionado.

Kit Taylor

Hey Cassie thanks for all the hard work. I can't believe that "A History Of Violence" is so far down the ratings list on your website. It's a slow-burn action movie with an incredible twist starring Viggo Mortensen (Aragorn) with music by Howard Shore. I put a vote in for that and for "Vanilla Sky", two of my all-time favorites. Anyone reading this that agrees with me on AHOV please go vote it up! David Cronenberg, Ed Harris, Maria Bello, Viggo Mortensen... freakin' phenomenal.

AceofSpades501

I just found out Citizen Kane isn't streaming anywhere in the U.S.

Clay F

You can stream (rent or buy) Citizen Kane (1941) on Amazon Prime Video in the US.

Isaiah Metz

After this godzilla don't stop there there, there will be a couple sequels after 👌🏼

Mark White

Thanks Catherine ❤️

Mike Lemon

I'm not allowed to say where (maybe one of the special people can jump in and say), but when I did a simple search for - Citizen Kane - I found at least seven places with the full movie, including one Spanish dub, and that isn't even counting archives.

Chris Thom

Could've sworn this was on the channel already. Or at least the American one with Chloe and Jenkins.

Chris Thom

Hope you're doing alright. Sometimes when I get up in the morning I can't feel my hands and it scares the s-- out of me. Would imagine nerve damage is frightening. That feeling after the dentist is freaking awful.

Chris Thom

Richard, if Cassie was planning on watching Horror of Dracula this year, would you care if it was for a LIVE chat? Or Extra Butter Watchalong?

Chris Thom

I saw them at the county fair in 2015. They were good.

Richard Maurer

I’d prefer a regular reaction but a live would be fine. Beggars can’t be choosers..

Richard Maurer

She’s doing all the monsterverse movies apparently.

Richard Maurer

I liked Clerks and especially Dogma a lot. Liked most of his other movies too, just not as much. I thought Red State was pretty good. I know a lot of people hate Tusk, and I’m not its biggest fan but I liked how weird it was.

Richard Maurer

Hopefully this will not become a trend. If it becomes one I will automatically skip any post with an image attached. In fact I’m pretty much doing that already.

Richard Maurer

I still wish they do something exclusively for Extra Butter. PaF wise. Maybe once a quarter put everyone’s name on a wheel and spin it, winner gets a movie pick. And to keep everyone engaged, if you win you only have to sit out a quarter. This is like how TBR Schmitt does their version of PaF, except you only have to sit out a month if you win.

Richard Maurer

Mark - I don’t even think inquiring, once in a while, about The Exorcist is a bad thing. The problem is you get lumped in with certain people who ask incessantly, practically every Upcoming post it seems. I honestly didn’t realize you were inquiring about it, I just tend to tune out the Exorcist requests because there are so many, so often. I’m not going to name names but certain people ask way to often about The Exorcist to the point that it just becomes nagging instead of a polite inquiry.

Richard Maurer

Cassie - as a horror fan I really enjoyed last year’s movie selections, for the most part (could have done without Scream 2 but that was the patrons fault). I hope this year is similar with the “not too scary” part kept to a bare minimum. I’m not saying that every film should be at Nosferatu’24 level scary, just that I hope the majority of films are real horror films and not films from other genres masquerading as horror.

Chris Thom

Just remembered she did your pick The Fly last year as a LIVE chat. We got to see her almost throw up in real time.

Stick Figure Studios

Certainly aspects of it are dated, but other aspects are very contemporary. That's one of the things that made it so brilliant was that it innovated so many techniques that we still use to this day. I also think it's a pretty compelling human drama with a mystery at its heart that she will ultimately get into.

Stick Figure Studios

Yeah, TOUCH OF EVIL is great. I also like F FOR FAKE and THE MAGNIFICENT AMBERSONS.

Richard Maurer

Chris, this reminded me that she said the classic horror poll winner would probably be watched for a live chat also there’s going a horror trivia live - that doesn’t leave much room for anything else.

Joe J

Very curious what films Cassie picks herself. I assume Ben and the mods source the films for the polls.

Clay F

At least "A History of Violence" is Top 500 at Requests - one of my favorite movies. I upvoted. Have you assigned priority points or upvoted?

Tyler Hale

I don’t think it’s an unpopular opinion. It’s a divisive film but I think it’s among the best Godzilla movies. Not perfect but I thought Gareth’s directing elevated the film

Clay F

I just now promoted it in “Movie request chat”

Richard Maurer

Except yours, I will continue to berate you as usual.

Richard Maurer

No and not the American one either, thank goodness.

Richard Maurer

And The Fly wasn’t my pick. A lot of people, including me, were upset because it lost a poll by vote yet never got a watch, which is something Cassie would normally do if it were any other genre.

Harvey Lee

Citizen Kane and Godzilla what an interesting mix bag we have here (I haven't seen any of the KOTK series so I can't comment) But it'll be an interesting couple of watches . And Cassie has seen the original Godzilla '54

Rene G.

Kudos to the guys who put my requests on PAF list: Descent, chucky, The car, THe crazies. Hopefully it gets wins or more votes

Clay F

YT views for recent reactions. 106k (5 days) – Andor S2E10-12 70k (9 days) – One Battle After Another 49k (11 days) – Rashomon (1950) 107k (2 weeks) – Andor S2E7-9 83k (3 weeks) – Andor S2E4-6 107k (4 weeks) – Obsession (2026)

Mike Lemon

Of course, that means basically nothing since YT changed what a "view" is on August 24th.

Richard Maurer

It means they got x number of “views” in comparison to other videos by whatever standards YouTube is using now . I’m not sure why you’re obsessed with it meaning “nothing”. You’ve talked about “engagement” being different from views, which sure, YT makes many separate categories, but you still need views to get engagement. If you’re saying the view numbers are artificially high, okay, but are they not artificially high for every YouTuber then? Which would equal things out as far as view counts go? I’d be more concerned with the reported use of A I to assess whether a video deserves a strike ( copyright or otherwise). This is likely the cause of the sudden increase in strikes, seemingly at random and for confusing reasons.

Richard Maurer

Cassie has seen 3* total Godzilla movies - G’54, Shin Godzilla, and Godzilla Minus One. *4 if you count Godzilla ‘98, which I do not.

Richard Maurer

I recently joined TBR Schmitt’s Patreon and, at least when it comes to horror, they have a far more…let’s say, ‘enlightened’ view as to what’s good and what’s not so good. They just started a foreign language horror poll ( I know, what???) and facing some stiff competition, Let the Right One In is dominating the poll. To further prove the point they recently had a horror sequels poll that Dawn of the Dead ‘78 won easily over Scream 4 (apparently not all their patrons are “enlightened” if they’re voting for Scream 4). And Pearl, another great movie came in forth but it was only 7 votes behind Scream 4. Also have to give credit to Samantha, one the reactors, who puts the polls together. Putting movies like Dawn of the Dead ‘78 or Pearl on a poll in the first place gives their patrons a chance to vote on them. Also for having a foreign language horror poll - could that even happen here?

OddThomas

The Godzilla stuff is great. The human characters not so much

Richard Maurer

No, she rarely watches silent films.

Joe J

PiB is falling behind other reactors in getting movies up weekly on YT. Seems like business as usual for Cinebinge, CinePals, Maplenuts, and others. I mainly just watch edits so they are important to me.

Mike Lemon

@Richard - I'll show the problem using an extreme hypothetical example- Cassie and Lassie both watch El Diablo, Cassie gets 50,000 views and Lassie gets 100,000 views. That is all the information we see, but YouTube sees 95% of Cassie's views stuck around for the whole video and watched all the ads, Lassie had 95% of views back out after 3 seconds and didn't watch any ads- who had more actual views? Who had more "engagement"? According to you (and Clay) it was Lassie.

Clay F

All reactions listed in my OP were posted to YT after Aug 24, w/exception that Obsession posted Aug 22. So views for each reaction listed are relevant as comparison (approximation) with respect to each other. One Battle After Another at 70k views is better that Rashomon at 49k views? Edit: Could completely ignore views without more data. Want engagement to funnel in new paid Patreon members.

Clay F

Joe - be patient. Edits come. My opinion is timing is reasonable (see below). Posts to Patreon – time between full and edit. 26 days – Andor S2E10-12, full Aug 20, edit Sep 15 26 days – One Battle After Another, full Aug 16, edit Sep 11 14 days – Rashomon, full Aug 19, edit Sep 2 22 days – Andor S2E7-9, full Aug 13, edit Sep 4 22 days – Andor S2E4-6, full Aug 7, edit Aug 29 12 days – Obsession, full Aug 10, edit Aug 22

Clay F

There are two other reactors I am subscribed to their Patreon for 3 years: Jen Murray and Hold Down A. Below are Jen Murray's 6 most recent edits. Jen Murray - Posts to Patreon – time between full and edit. 64 days – Futurama 5x5-6, full July 16, edit Sep 18 19 days – DS9 5x26, full Aug 29, edit Sep 17 5 days – Captain Marvel, full Sep 11, edit Sep 16 90 days – Twilight Zone 1x11-12, full June 18, edit Sep 16 47 days – Curb 3x3-4, full July 30, edit Sep 15 17 days – DS9 5x25, full Aug 29, edit Sep 15

Clay F

Ames hasn't done edits for most of her reactions. Below 6 most recent edits. Hold Down A - Posts to Patreon – time between full and edit. 99 days – War of the Worlds (2005), full June 12, edit Sep 19 2 days – Fast Times at Ridgemont High, full Sep 11, edit Sep 13 35 days – Gladiator (2000), full Aug 1, edit Sep 5 21 days – National Lampoon Vacation, full July 18, edit Aug 8 133 days – Dirty Harry, full Mar 20, edit July 31 22 days – Bill and Ted's Excellent Adventure, full Jul 4, edit July 26 She been reacting to TNG for 17 months (since April 2025) and has not done any edits. She waiting till she completes the series before doing any edits.

Bill Maurer

Nice last name. I don't count the 98 version of Godzilla either.

Joe J

Clay, PiB time to edits is even worse than I thought. Cassie has multiple professional editors, so these times seem way too long IMO. When I followed Jen I remember she posted what she called raw edits (no intros & outros added yet). These seemed to come sooner to patrons.

Richard Maurer

Mike I get the difference between views and engagement. But do you think your average YT viewer knows, or cares, about the difference? All they’re going to see, based on your hypothetical, is “Lassie” got twice the views Cassie got. If they are unfamiliar with both of them they more likely to check out the one with 100k over the one with 50k

Clay F

Joe -- Jen now has no raw edits. Also, Jen has paid editors for years, even when her channel was barely surviving. Jen's last 6 edits came to Patreon an average of 40 days after the full reaction. PiB much better. Reasonable. As with many reactors, Jen doesn't really cater to patrons on edits. Low priority. Edits are only important as prep for YT reactions. Not significant issue how long after the full reaction.

Clay F

For many reactors' Patreon (e.g., Jen, Ames, Klaire, Licha, etc.), the focus/priority is full reactions. For Jen and PiB, patron commenting on edit posts much less than for full reaction posts. For Jen, paid Patreon membership (not YT) saved her channel. For most people who watch only edited reactions of a given reactor, they don't join Patreon but instead watch YT reactions.

Joe J

Why is PiB no longer posting to YT at the same frequency as before? Copyright? Well, copyright isn't stopping the PiB direct competitors who are still posting to YT at the same frequency as always. By hook or crook, got to get the content on YT week in, week out. When PiB YT postings are delayed many weeks (or more), this is of course also a hardship too many patrons who do not watch full-reactions. Many PiB patrons join to support the channel at the lower $3 and $6 tiers. Safe to say Cassie would miss that support. Not everyone has the income or the desire too watch full-reactions.

Mike Lemon

"All they’re going to see, based on your hypothetical, is “Lassie” got twice the views Cassie got." Yep, and that is why I keep telling people that "views" are basically worthless. "But do you think your average YT viewer knows, or cares, about the difference?" I doubt the average YT viewer cares about views at all.

Clay F

Joe - How is 3 weeks avg a hardship? Simply watch the edited reaction when posted. 3 weeks avg is reasonable.

Joe J

Yeah Clay, we can always watch stuff on YT, if it ever gets to YT. Didn't Cassie always turn edits around in about one week? Now three weeks is somehow reasonable?

Clay F

Yes, 3 weeks is reasonable, no matter what happened in the past. She had the one good editor Matt who turned stuff around but I think his availability dropped off. Not sure. My guess is 3 weeks could be the new status quo. Of course, with continuing efforts to improve as feasible and economical. You could save $3/$6 per month by not being on Patreon and instead watching YT reactions (if not pulled down). An advantage of being on Patreon is get the edit on Patreon before the YT premier and unaffected by what happens on YT.

Joe J

I certainly hope three weeks isn't the new normal. Better be a good backlog of reactions working through the pipeline to feed the hungry YT beast with (3) postings weekly.

Richard Maurer

“I doubt the average YT views cares about views at all” - Well obviously some do. Personally, J’m going to continue to compare videos by views as there’s no easy way to compare them by engagement.

Mike Lemon

You could not worry about it at all and leave that to PiB... "Well obviously some do." Some is not the average. Some people think the Moon is made out of cheese, the average person doesn't.

Richard Maurer

And your last name also. Yet some do count it, the clearest example of a ‘guilty pleasure’, emphasis on the Guilty part.

Catherine LW

Thanks, Chris. Sorry to hear about your condition. Hope it heals quickly.

Catherine LW

Thanks, Chris. Sorry to hear about your condition. Hope it heals quickly.

Katie Sivak

Maybe you can start Fast and Furious franchise after Oct