Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Classic Halloween Movie Poll

  • Dracula (1931) 146
  • The Wolf Man (1941) 37
  • The Bride of Frankenstein (1935) 104
  • The Invisible Man (1933) 60
  • The Creature from the Black Lagoon (1954) 88
  • The Blob (1958) 196
  • 2026-09-18
  • —2026-09-21
  • 631 votes
{'title': 'Classic Halloween Movie Poll', 'choices': [{'text': 'Dracula (1931)', 'votes': 146}, {'text': 'The Wolf Man (1941)', 'votes': 37}, {'text': 'The Bride of Frankenstein (1935)', 'votes': 104}, {'text': 'The Invisible Man (1933)', 'votes': 60}, {'text': 'The Creature from the Black Lagoon (1954)', 'votes': 88}, {'text': 'The Blob (1958)', 'votes': 196}], 'closes_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 21, 5, 59, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2026, 9, 18, 15, 12, 58, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 631}

Content

Hey guys! Let's pick a classic Halloween movie! 🎃

Vote for what you'd like me to watch below. The poll will be open for two days!

I'll probably do a live watch-along of the winner for Extra Butter, and then it'll be up afterward like a regular Patreon video so you can watch even if you miss the live! 🍿

Comments

Juan Cantu

Oh, you mean classic classic. I’ll let the boomers decide this one

David Blount

The Blob is a fun, schlocky drive-in low-budget movie. Steve McQueen is 18, I think, in it. The remake with Kevin Dillon captures the campy, low-budget, low-stakes fun. If you watch it, please don't be scared and nervous. It's not that kind of movie.

Dan M

These are all great movies, but I think The Blob would be the most fun reaction. On a side note…I’m willing to bet Richard Mauer is voting for all of them 😅😉

Brian Shannow

Creature from the black lagoon, then follow it up with The Shape of Water

Ted Little

Given the opportunity, I would have voted for all the ones from the thirties and forties. I would also have liked "Dr Jekyll and Mr Hyde" from 1931 to be on the poll.

Bill Maurer

The Blob and the coolest man to ever come out of Hollywood, Steve McQueen

Dan M

I like the idea of following up the OG The Blob with the 1988 remake. It really is a good movie, despite some cringy FX.

Canadianant

At some point I would love to see an Ed wood reaction. In that vein I voted for Dracula with Bella Lugosi.

John A

No Abbot and Costello?

Carolee Barry

tough one between Dracula and Wolfman. I gave Wolfman some love since I could only select one

Clarence Newman

Hey, there's a typo up there. Dracula (1931) should be Horror of Dracula (1958) on account of Dracula (1931) being as hammy as a school play where all the scenery is made of ham and Horror of Dracula being THE definitive version of Dracula that is literally hamless and therefore safe for vegetarians. Rectify thy faux pas, Cassandra!

Phil Sexton

Surprised Bride of Frankenstein isn't doing better. From a film quality perspective I think it's the best of the lot (though I love them all).

Clarence Newman

That could be a typo too. Maybe she meant Bullitt.

Jens Kristensen

Let's be fair... all are fantastic viewing...

JohnnyUtah

As long as we get Halloween II watch all the Classics you want Cassie 😅

F0ZYWOLF

The Blob is a great choice it gets my vote, you should also consider silent horror movies as well like Nosferatu and The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari

David Collins

No "Abbot and Costello" movies is unfortunate. :(

Above Average Dave

The Blob features a young Steve McQueen, or "Steve McTeen" if you will. And even if you won't 🤣 btw, Cassie - does Ben have a fav NFL team or is it just hockey and baseball?

Jacob Wagner

The Blob plus 80's The Blob compare and contrasts how effects evolved

Steve Holton

Steve McQueen (Billed as Steven for this early role) had one of his biggest financial regrets making "The Blob". The film was an independent production, made by a religious group with few Hollywood connections. And Steve McQueen had little confidence the film would succeed so he took an upfront payout instead of a percentage of the gross. Of course, the film became a huge hit and Steve McQueen missed out on a fortune. On the bright side, this financial fiasco did later spur him to negotiate a great deal for points on the gross for the film "The Towering Inferno"

Robert Jewell

When I hit my selection, it goes on then suddenly disappears so I don't know if PIB is getting it or not. Plus I want to make a comment when I do. Let me know if you're receiving.

Richard Maurer

I voted for The Blob, mostly to keep Dracula ‘31 from winning. Of the films in this this poll, Bride of Frankenstein should be winning

Jake McNulty

I’m going to go with “Bride of Frankenstein” on this one. I actually prefer it over the first film since Karlof’s portrayal of the creature feels much closer to the book in the sequel.

Richard Maurer

I’m glad you said it for me. Clarence. It might look self-serving if I wrote it.

Larry Darrell

Can someone help me out, it’s been a minute since I checked. How high on the request list is Horror of Dracula (1958)? Last I saw it was staying in the 20s or 30s, and at one time was the highest requested Horror film, of any decade.

Larry Darrell

Ditto. Other than Bela Legosi being introduced as Dracula, there really isn’t much to react to with the 1931 film. She could definitely check that out on her own time.

Joe J

No interest in the first four films listed. I hope "The Blob" can hang on and win, by far the most entertaining of the films listed IMO.

Hunter DeRensis

Real ones know that The Invisible Man stands head and shoulders above the rest for effects.

Joe J

I wouldn't mind seeing a reaction to Halloween II, but it will never win or place high on a Poll.

Joe J

Good to see you back Clarence.

Clay F

Are you on PC?

Dan M

Well, I lost that bet.

Joe J

Those really old dated films just don't do anything for me anymore.

David D

A few of these movies, aren't just classics, they're actually good. I think the Bride, Frankenstein, and Invisible Man aimed higher than the others. FWIW, the Bride might be the best, but the Invisible Man is probably more entertaining. AFAIK, none of these are actually bad (though I haven't seen all). Also: big vote here for Werewolf by Night (MCU). It's fun, not "must-see", but it's unique and perfect for Halloween.

Steven Perez

Definitely pulling for BRIDE. The rest are bona-fide classics, but BRIDE is the best of them all.

Robert Kern

please not the blob by far the worst and least classic of all these great movies

Robert Kern

the blob may be fun but its not a great classic horror movie like the others

Robert Kern

not an old classic I think the Blob is also 2 new for this poll

Robert Kern

The blob isnt in the same league as the others on this poll It sticks out like a sore thumb

Just Plain Bob

Five ACTUAL classics and that POS that was the original The Blob. So, of course, The Blob is winning. There are definitely alternatives to the Universal Classics. But not the f***ing Blob. It’s just this side of Attack of the Killer Tomatoes. What about the Hammer classics, most notably Curse of Frankenstein and Horror of Dracula? Or the sci-fi/horror films of the 1950s (Them!, The Thing from Another World, Invasion of the Body Snatchers, etc)? The original Blob is so bad it’s one of those rare occasions I’d recommend the remake FAR MORE than the horrible original. It’s not even “so bad it’s good” level of bad. It’s just “so bad the negative should’ve been burned” bad.

Old As Dirt Bert

McQueen's character was supposed to be 18, but he was 28. He took the role because he needed cash. My favorite "schlock" is the tailpipe close up during the race.

Robert Kern

Thats to bad Id go for anything on this list over the blob cant believe its winning In fact i dont think it should even be a choice

Clay F

I don't think I've seen any of these movies. I tend to vote for the more recent movies in these old movie polls. But I see that The Blob (1958) is a cheesy B-movie (no thanks), and Creature from the Black Lagoon (1954) and The Wolf Man (1941) are a wasted vote b/c both losing big time. So I am stuck with three 1930s movies. Heard good things about Bride of Frankenstein. Richard recommends it. I voted Bride of Frankenstein (my top choice) but would change my vote to Dracula if that stands a chance to displace The Blob. Only 200 patrons have voted. Still early. Typically, can have 1000 patrons or so voting but this an old movie poll so participation may be less.

Robert Jewell

Now it's working, Clay. Sometimes it's like my phone takesa while for the Patreon post to digitally connect to my phone. Thanks.

F0ZYWOLF

thats true, though it is a good time

Clay F

Robert, glad it's working. I find PC more reliable for polls but phones do work.

Brian Clark

Gotta be the Invisible Man for that fantastic Claude Rains performance!

Clarence Newman

I wasn’t gone, Joe. I was in the corner, subliminally jonesing for another silent movie poll.

Robert Jewell

Ok, I chose The Wolf Man because it is definitely imo the best of the choices by far. It has atmosphere, an empathetic lead, a quality of romance, a tremendous score, a smart screenplay and taut direction. I was fairly positive Dracula would lead the choices and it's got some good beginning eeriness, but it just gets wooden and stilted after a while. The other selections are enjoyable enough, but The Wolf Man is really more what I think Cassie'd get into the most.

Clay F

What do you think about Bride? That is what I voted. The Wolf Man currently a distant dead last. Unlikely to get a reaction from this poll. I would give The Wolf a shot.

Robert Kern

yup yet the worst movie is winning from the 50s It doesnt even belong here IMHO

Alex M

Sorry to see TCFTBL not doing better. One of my favorites. I remember seeing it as a kid early one Saturday morning after a sleepover at a friend’s house. Despite Steve McQueen being one of my absolute favorite actors I’ve never seen The Blob. Looks like I’m gonna need to give it a watch.

Robert Kern

Obviously we boomers are not seeing the blob is winning I was so excited to see this list until I voted and saw the blob is beating these true classic B&W movies Its from another decade and in color

Bill Maurer

yup, Abbot and Costello Meet Frankenstein is a must watch !!!!!

Jimmy Stewart

Abbott and Costello meet Frankenstein is missing , Dracula, Frankenstein and the Wolf man, has it all in classic, comedic fashion.

Collar City Guy

Believe it or not, The Blob was loosely inspired by a bizarre 1950 police report from September of 1950 when a mysterious, glowing substance was found by Philadelphia police officers John Collins and Joe Keenan who reported seeing a glowing, object fall from the sky. When one officer touched the jelly, it felt sticky or left a slimy residue, and it seemingly dissolved or evaporated into a sticky mass without a trace shortly after backup arrived. The Philadelphia Inquirer ran an article about the event titled "Flying Saucer Just Dissolves," which caught the attention of the film's future producer, Jack Harris and the rest is history, though it's real origin was much more mundane than featured in the movie. (Taken in part from Google)

Ginko

The bright side is pretty bittersweet though… he didn’t get to enjoy that money for very long

Just Plain Bob

Saw where genre icon Joe Dante (The Howling, Piranha) ranked the original Blob #5 on his personal list of worst horror films ever made. I’d drop it a couple of slots.

Collar City Guy

I mentioned Abott and Costello Meet Frankenstein during the SEPTEMBER PICK-A-FLICK DRAW live when Cassie asked for suggestions for scary but not too scary movies for Oct, when she said "that could be fun" I really hoped it had a shot at a reaction, hopefully it stillt does!

JohnnyUtah

I mean Halloween II is 45 years old but yeah I know it's not a "classic"

Joe J

The Blob is quite entertaining, Creature is quite good but no chance on this poll. The really old films are very dated and boring...for me anyway.

Robert Jewell

I'd give BoF a B/B+. I give The Wolf Man an A. In all of these films except The Wolf Man I don't particularly care about the characters. (I'm being a bit vague because I don't want to give away plot points.) But yeah, I prefer in this Universal school of filmmaking to feel empathetic rather than just observing their eccentricities. Like I prefer Son of Frankenstein to all the Universal Frankenstein films because I can relate to the story and characters and acting more.

Mark Vaderr

Juan-As a member of Generation X, I say that you need to be more open minded. These black & white horror movies are some of the best around.

Mark Vaderr

Clay- You don't know what you are missing. Dracula, The Invisible Man & The Bride of Frankenstein are very good.

Richard Maurer

I’d go for anything on this poll over Dracula ‘31. Lugosi’s portrayal is hammy and not scary at all. There are other movies he’s way better in.

Geoff S.

The Blob-weirdest theme song for a horror movie. Burt Bacharach too.

Rick Moreno

Cassie, I'm excited for you to get into more of these classic Universal movies. One recommendation for you: Watch Dracula back-to-back with its Spanish-language version. Filmed simultaneously with the English version (at night, while the English was done in the day) the Spanish version is better in almost every way, other than Dracula himself. Same sets and all that, and the female lead is terrific in the part.

Mark Vaderr

The Blob? Are you Fu*#!&g kidding me?! The massive disrespect being shown to these classic horror films is disgusting. Dracula or The Invisible Man should be winning this. Bela Lugosi's most famous role and Claude Raines' greatest performance are being overshadowed by a "B" movie. Disgusting!

Richard Maurer

Horror of Dracula is currently the highest horror film on the Request list. Dracula ‘31 isn’t even close.

Russell

Creature from the Black Lagoon is a must see at some point. The Blob, meh, but young Steve McQueen in it is pretty funny.

Christian Becker

Oh, the irony - all our plots and stratagems for naught ;-). Drumming up support for Horror of Dracula time and time again, and then we get Dracula (1931) in the poll. Which may be a good sign, because Cassie decided to watch HoD anyway?

MikeLL

My choice is The Bride of Frankenstein, but I share your sentiments that The Blob is a ridiculous choice. Not half the movie the other classics are.

AceofSpades501

"It creep and leaps and glides and slides across the floor..."

John A

People have their tastes, it has nothing to do with being open minded

John A

I mentioned it when these old monster movies were first brought up and a bunch of dorks scoffed at it so who knows

John A

I don't see why it wouldn't win or come close on a poll, Halloween is one of the most popular horror franchises

John A

Try watching Abbot and Costello meet Frankenstein, if you can stand it you might find an interest in the 30s movies. I remember liking them as a kid anyway lol, not sure how they'll hold up now

Christian Becker

I voted for Lugosi. I'd like Cassie to see as many versions of the Dracula story as possible. Well, and the 1931 Dracula is part of the Count's cinematic history.

Christian Becker

Ahhhhrgh... Idea: how about a Dracula movie bracket? There are still myriads of Dracula movies out there - maybe not many good ones, but there are a lot. 😉

JohnnyUtah

This is true, I don't wanna risk it though, just go ahead and watch Cassie 😅

David Collins

Hopefully it means she's going to call an audible and make it a PPotM. * fingers crossed *

Steve Holton

@Ginko. Yes, though Steve McQueen was once appointed to a Presidential honor guard for saving several fellow marines from drowning during Arctic war games, he was also frequently in trouble for breaking rules. And sadly, one punishment work detail was to clear asbestos from old Navy ships without proper safety gear. His family is convinced this led to his early death from mesothelioma just a few years after The Towering Inferno.

Jake McNulty

Why not vote “Bride of Frankenstein” then?

Jake McNulty

I agree, make it a double feature.

Larry Darrell

Who’s Joe?? Has someone blocked me?? How did I get blocked and not you? I’m way less obnoxious than you Clarence. ;-)

Mike Lemon

Then she can watch the sequel for Clint Edgecomb's film debut.

Silver Machine

Another depressing example of democracy in action.

Richard Maurer

I’d argue The Blob is on par with most fifties monster movies - except for the theme song, which is horribly cringy.

Richard Maurer

I wonder if someone made a mistake and thought HoD was the 1931 Dracula, since HoD is unfortunately listed as just Dracula in the thumbnail? Otherwise I can only assume it was on purpose.

Richard Maurer

I will, if it has a shot at winning. Doesn’t seem likely at this point. To be honest I don’t really care what wins this poll.

Starpartyguy

Creature from the black lagoon is the best if the lot but there’s no denying that Lon Chaney and Bela Lugosi are the best monsters ever!

Richard Maurer

Since Horror of Dracula is the #1 horror film of any era on Requests, I believe either a mistake was made - assuming that HoD was the Lugosi one; or a intentional slight was made by someone. I can’t see any other reason it would be slighted like that. By the way, Lugosi’s Dracula isn’t even close to #1.

Richard Maurer

Clarence, what are you going on about, my phone definitely didn’t try to “fix” my sentence.

Richard Maurer

Robert you correct - except for Dracula ‘31, it’s definitely better than that.

Just Plain Bob

There were certainly plenty of stinkers in the 50s. But there were also some great ones, like the ones I named. I have a feeling this got on the poll because either Cassie received terrible advice concerning classic horror (par for the course) or she thinks McQueen is cute and wanted to see him in something else.

Clarence Newman

You have a history of typing with your elbows, Richard. I can generally make out one word in six.

Clay F

Joe -- I will watch the reaction to The Blob which looks like will win the poll. I hear you about really old movies but there have been several I like. I generally prefer modern movies.

Larry Darrell

I’ve said it before, and I’ll say it again. She needs a producer.

Just Plain Bob

Makes me sick that The Blob is even a choice. Might as well do a rewatch of Howard the Duck.

Robert Evans

I agree that 'The Blob' is not like the others. The rest of the field is from the core Universal Horror canon. I was so torn between 'bride' which would be more fun and "creature' which is among my favs.

Larry Darrell

I love the remake of The Blob from 1988. Way better film. Did I miss where she asked for suggestions? This seems like something that was thrown together from old suggestions and past polls.

Mark Vaderr

John- "I'll let the boomers decide this." Oh yeah, it's only about taste. What was I thinking? Cassie watches a wide variety of movies, Robert should know that.

Larry Darrell

She reacted to Nosferatu (1922) last year.

Mark Vaderr

Mike- I would be fine with Bride as well. I'm not that big on Creature From the Black Lagoon either, but it's better than The Blob.

Larry Darrell

I feel the same about The Wolf Man. The best of the original Universal Monster movies.

Richard Maurer

No, we just got what they wanted us to have.

Richard Maurer

Some of us are busy, we have to multitask.

Richard Maurer

The Blob is the worst film in the poll, but it’s only slightly worse than Dracula’31. I know, I know, it’s a “classic” but Lugosi’s performance as Dracula has always been one of my least favorite portrayals. Lugosi’s not a bad actor though, he’s great in Son of Frankenstein, White Zombie, The Raven, etc.. But his Dracula is one of the least scary ever. Even as a kid he wasn’t scary to me.

Richard Maurer

Anyway I feel obligated to vote for the Blob just because of the insult to Horror of Dracula and Christopher Lee. If any other movie in this poll were in second place I’d vote for it but I refuse to vote for the inferior Dracula ‘31.

Richard Maurer

Except for Dracula ‘31, of course. It should never win.

Clay F

Richard - I wondered what you had against Dracula ’31. Now, I understand.

Chris Thom

The oversight does seem a bit cruel. So, so close...yet so far away.

Larry Darrell

I’m still waiting on the update. Maybe she’s planning on it already since it is the #1 HORROR REQUEST. Maybe she forgot to mention it here. Or maybe she has no idea. This is actually the reason I haven’t been checking on the requests that much. I’ve yet to be led to believe that the requests have any effect on the proceedings. Aside from a once every 2 or 3 month random Top 100 draw poll. This is also why I’ve kept all my priority points on Horror of Dracula. Until I see any results, there’s no point in playing with my points any.

Richard Maurer

Taste is subjective. But close- mindedness comes into play when you write off a whole genre without giving it a chance.

Chris Thom

Guess I'll vote for Bride then. I've only seen Invisible Man and parts of Black Lagoon.

Richard Maurer

Because of past mistakes (Kingdom of Heaven and others) i believe it possible it was a mistake based on a lack of due diligence and that damnable thumbnail. If The Blob wasn’t included I’d think they just grabbed a list Universal horror movies and cut and pasted the poll. But while I hope it wasn’t intentional the possibility is still there.

Mark White

This will be a pole that will excite some paterons and it shows Cassie is thinking of fans of this genre which can be overlooked sometimes. I personally don’t have a lot to interest me on this poll, but my vote would be TCFTBL. I do remember enjoying it as a kid. I’m am however confused as to why “Horror of Dracula” 1958 is not on here. It’s high on the requests lists. Is it being held of the poll as it’s already a shoo in for October already?

Richard Maurer

There is the possibility she’s planning to watch it as the #1 horror request, but I don’t want to get my hopes up. It would ruin my reputation as a world-class cynic.

Mark White

Either a typo or it’s already slated for October? 🤔

Richard Maurer

I’d like to believe that about Horror of Dracula Mark, but as a well known cynic I have a reputation to uphold.

Richard Maurer

Clay - Christopher Lee in Horror of Dracula (and sequels) is so much better than Lugosi it’s not even a contest.

Richard Maurer

Could be Mark, but don’t….don’t give me hope (dramatic music swells).

Mark White

Your reputation is safe with me 😉😆

Stephen Dias

My son and his friend did that routine for a high school show. It’s near and dear to my heart.

aarswft

Lol what are we doing. Who is voting for these movies?

Stephen Dias

Honestly, I’ve only seen pictures from all of these movies, but haven’t actually watched any of them. They all seem super cheesy, which can be fun.

MrKsummer7

Clarence, being a huge Hammer House of Horror fan, I agree. The D ‘31, is way overrated. Skip it and start w Horror of Dracula, then Brides of Dracula, finish w Dracula Prince of Darkness.

Clarence Newman

By the end of October, Richard will either be doing a jig like the guy from Deliverance or he'll be paraphrasing Al Pacino in Godfather 3 - "Just when I thought I was in, she pulled me back out."

Clarence Newman

Mark. If we did a PiB remake of Cannonball Run, you know Richard would be the Doc, don't you? Cassie would be Farrah Fawcett, of course, and I would be Tara Buckman's jumpsuit.

MrKsummer7

Is there a write-in for this Poll? Mine is Abbot and Costello Meet Frankenstein

Richard Maurer

You'd be in the Gumball Rally remake.

Joe J

Cassie does sometimes take pity on us lifers, lol. Clarence got "Cool Hand Luke", Clay got "Lost in Translation", and Stick got "Midnight Run".

Mark Vaderr

Richard- I wholeheartedly disagree with your take on Dracula '31. I never found Lugosi's Dracula to be frightening. The movie is filled with mood and atmosphere. Lugosi adds a certain charm to the movie and Dwight Frye is great as Renfield. I will agree that Christopher Lee is a more frightening Dracula. I just like the '31 Dracula for other reasons. It's just that The Blob is nothing special. At least go with Bride, or The Invisible Man, or The Wolf Man, they are so much better. I'll say it again, Claude Raines is superb as The Invisible Man.

Rob Nichols

Solid list, I would've voted all if I could.

Catherine LW

I still hope Cassie will watch some classic Twilight Zone episodes - some are scary but not too scary!

Catherine LW

I remember howling with laughter when first watched The Blob.

Richard Maurer

You could be more right than you know.

Richard Maurer

MrKsummer7 - I’d rather she skipped Brides of Dracula, which is badly missing Cristopher Lee and watch Dracula Has Risen from the Grave, and maybe Taste the Blood of Dracula.

Mike Lemon

"I’m am however confused as to why “Horror of Dracula” 1958 is not on here. " I would guess it's because whoever made the poll used the first appearance of each monster (not including lost films).

Richard Maurer

Sorry, but I think voting for something else is probably pointless anyway, and I can’t bring myself to vote Dracula ‘31, not when Horror of Dracula is at the top of the horror list on requests.

Wesley White

Good choices especially having 5 out of 8 of the Classic Universal Monsters on this poll! My vote is for Dracula (1931) because it's a classic and it's what helped put Universal Studios on the map and started it all for all their classic movie monsters! Plus recently I met the granddaughter of Dracula himself Bela Lugosi, his granddaughter Lynne Lugosi Sparks, she was very kind and fun to talk to! I actually did an impersonation of her grandfather right in front of her and she literally said to me that I nailed his voice and posture as Dracula right on the money lol! Though I also would love to se you react to "Horror of Dracula (1958)" as I'm sure many of us patrons on here do, but that should be for a different poll, in this case the "Hammer Horror Poll", ah shoot I should've made that into a poll with my fan letter... D'OH!!! LOL🤣 "The Wolfman (1941)", "The Invisible Man (1933)", "The Creature from the Black Lagoon (1954)", and "The Bride of Frankenstein (1935)" are all great movies! I've never seen "The Blob (1958)"! So, I'll leave the idea for a "Hammer Horror Poll" down below as I end this comment! Love and support, and God bless y'all and the family 🥰😇🙏🤗😉✌🌹 "Hammer Horror Poll": . Horror of Dracula (1958) . The Curse of Frankenstein (1957) . The Mummy (1959) . The Curse of the Werewolf (1961) . The Hound of the Baskervilles (1959) . The Phantom of the Opera (1962) P.S. I heard "Horror of Dracula" is being re-released in theaters this coming October as the "uncut" version of the film. Fully restored footage that was edited because the MPAA thought they were do disturbing for viewers at the time! I'm gonna see it in the theater when I have the chance😁

Joe J

In my book, Lee is by far the best Dracula. I have liked all his Dracula films, and the ones with Cushing, wow what a legendary pairing those two made.

Catherine LW

Gets my vote. Anything with Claude Rains!

Richard Maurer

Claude Rains is in The Wolf Man too.

JarHead0351

It's one of my favorite old movie, the diner in the movie is nearby and serves the "The Blob Burger" and the theater (next town over from me) in the movie plays the movie once a year and the town host The Blob festival then too. A fun time.

Chris Thom

I wonder if my Boomer parents have seen any of these. Mom used to watch Twilight Zone back in the day and it freaked her out badly. But I don't think I've heard either of them mention any of these.

Chris Thom

The religious group made it just for funding? Or is there a message to it? Haven't seen any of the versions yet.

Steve Holton

Hi Chris. Most of the films made by Irvin Yeaworth and his company were for religious or motivational purposes. And there may be an intended theme in this film, some critics claim it capitalizes on the red scare fears of that era. But it seems meant as popular entertainment. So, the creative choices are probably steered more to what will appeal to an audience and make a profit. Though, of course, a picture can have a message and also be very profitable.

Arturo

Dracula (2000) Not the best of the Dracula movies, but one that maybe Carly can watch IF she has a googly eye blanket. Also Fallen (1998) with Denzel

MrKsummer7

Re Brides of Drac, the scene in the horse stable when the locks start falling off the coffin, is still a pretty chilling. Peter Cushing as Van Helsing still the best to ever play the role. BTW what about a gothic mystery film like The Hound of the Baskervilles 1959, Christopher Lee with Peter Cushing as Sherlock Holmes, Directed by Terence Fisher.

Richard Maurer

I’m pretty much fine with any of the Hammer films, at least till the 70’s when things started to go off the rails.

MrKsummer7

How is one of the best sequels ever made staring legendary Boris Karloff getting beat by a bowl of silicone gel mixed with red food coloring? 🙄

Richard Maurer

While I’d enjoy a Hammer poll, Horror of Dracula would win that easily. It would be much more of a contest if she just watched HoD and the poll was the rest of the films you listed. I’d pick Curse of Frankenstein then.

Richard Maurer

Mike - It’s a Universal monster poll except suddenly The Blob shows up. For some reason.

MrKsummer7

I say petition for a Boris Karloff poll.

Richard Maurer

Even for boomers these movies were the ones you mostly watched on your local late night horror host’s show. I know I did, I was blessed with parents who allowed me to stay up as late as I wanted on Friday and Saturday. And one local station had a horror host on Friday after the 11:00 news. When that show was over they ran horror movies the rest of the night. If it was a good selection I’d try to stay up all night to watch them. I never made it, came close a couple of times, but I would usually nod off around 2:00 am.

Richard Maurer

I’d vote Bride of Frankenstein in that poll.

MrKsummer7

My vote The Body Snatcher 1945

Clarence Newman

I think Cassie is itching for some early Steve McQueen to prepare for Blue Eyed 60s Legend Month in November.

Mark White

In that case Clarence, I would like to be Captain Chaos! 😆 I’m sure Tara will appreciate you 😉

Rick Rodriguez

I think people are thinking it's the Chuck Russell The Blob

Mark White

I got “The Insider”. However Mike is still waiting for Indictment: the McMartin Trial. Joe, we could also do with a 90’s action flick on a boat with terrorists, a cook and miss July 89!

Mike Lemon

@Richard- I think you are giving the poll maker too much credit. I doubt they even considered "Universal" at all. My guess is they typed "classic monster movies" into a search, clicked the first link (or read the A.I. summary), and picked the names that looked familiar (and weren't silent).

Mark White

Yep, now that would make sense. As usual Mike, you have figured it out.

Mark White

Clarence, I’m going to suggest the fact that Cassie has put a “like” to your comment might mean: read, understood and already got it for October. 🫰 crossed for Richard.

Clarence Newman

Don't mention crosses in front of Richard. He will catch fire.

Richard Maurer

It is a rather generic list. I’m starting to think I got Shin Godzilla, and that’s it.

Richard Maurer

For the record I’m not against anyone else enjoying Dracula ‘31 or expecting anyone to agree with my opinion. But I need to express my strongly held opinions, if for no other reason than to solidify them for myself. Otherwise I might change them on a whim. Or end up holding two opposing opinions simultaneously, which I sometimes do.

Richard Maurer

I used to wear a cross earring, back in my “wild” 90’s days.

MikeLL

It's a travesty, is what it is. The whole point of her watching the original Frankenstein should have been to get her to this point, to watch the excellent sequel. She did use her watch of Frankenstein to prep her watch of Young Frankenstein, but the sequel should have been part of that prep.

Nolofinwe

The blob is Steve McQueen's first movie it's a lot of fun to watch ! it's a classic 50s monster movie... Perfect for a "scary not too scary" night

bgb1975 (Brian)

Abbott and Costello Meet the Killer Boris Karloff

MrKsummer7

Abbott and Costello Meet Dr. Jekyll and Mr Hyde w Boris Karloff

Eddie Perkins

The Blob doesn't fit in with this group, and I can't believe it's beating out all these great Universal Classics. I'm just shaking my head!

Eddie Perkins

Another one who has a problem with the Universal Classic Monsters.

Eddie Perkins

I also have The Bride. I have no idea why she included the Blob in this great group of classic monsters.

Eddie Perkins

I agree 100%. The Blob is worth a watch, but every one of these is far better than The Blob. It has no place here!

Jimmy Stewart

Yup, all the great classic monsters and a bonus one at the end, I watch this movie every year!

Eddie Perkins

Not to take anything away from Bulitt, which is a great movie, but my favorite McQueen movie is Papillon, and it has the second-highest rating among his movies on IMDb. I have no idea why she put The Blob on this list; it doesn't fit.

Bill Maurer

It's a horror poll. Agree 100% on Papillon. Great movie

Mark Vaderr

Richard- Interesting point. This poll is aptly named as a classic poll, but there is very little to choose from. Especially when we see polls that have at least 10 different choices. Not one silent film, like "The Cabinet of Dr. Caligari" or "The Phantom of the Opera". No other black & white thrillers, like "Svengali", "Dr. Jekyll & Mr. Hyde", "The Old Dark House" or "White Zombie". Not one of the horrors with Vincent Price or from Val Lewton. "The Blob" is considered to also be a monster movie, so why not put "THEM!" or "The Thing" on here too? Very suspicious.

Eddie Perkins

I would love for her to watch Horror of Dracula. Or even have a Hammer poll, but this looks like she started listing all the classic Universal monster movies that are dear to my heart and suddenly, for some reason, ran into The Blob and crashed, and everyone was on board with her. I'm so confused.

Xev

I don't watch horror movies and the amount of hate Blob is getting makes my vote really easy, lol

Clarence Newman

Agreed on Papillon, Eddie. His best acting by far.

Richard Maurer

Who knows why the patrons vote the way they do. At least I had a clear agenda.

Richard Maurer

The worst thing about the movie is that song.

Old As Dirt Bert

Steve was in several films before The Blob, but it was his first starring role. He needed a paycheck, but didn't like it and wouldn't talk about the film later in life.

Richard Maurer

Now that I think back this really isn’t that much different than the first Classic horror poll, the one I asked for every upcoming post for about a year. Even though I provided a list of every major horror/monster movie from the 30’s through the 60’s (left out silent films because I knew they had no shot) the poll was all Universal except King Kong, which won. Funny how history is repeating itself and the only non-Universal movie is winning again.

Happy Hanukkah

With you on the blocking, Larry. Joe must be a busy little beaver, as I'm seeing 10 replies out of a reported 30.

Happy Hanukkah

Unlike me, your block did not age well. "Block of ages, just for me, let me hide myself!" 🎵

MorahSDG

Can’t believe Blob is winning, outside the theme song and Steve McQueen being always cool, it’s a very boring 50’s movie. Bride and Invisible man are the best here.

Joe J

Maybe we get another collab this October with KatWatchesHorror. Just a consequence of course, but Kat reacted to The Creature from the Black Lagoon (54) and The Wolf Man (41) just in the last month or so.

Clay F

Hoping for The Bride. Patron participation seems less in these old movie polls. Compare this poll to single-vote polls this year w/modern movies. This poll (Classic Halloween Movie Poll) – current 589 patrons have voted. Trivia Winners Picks Poll (Sep – earlier this month) – 921 patrons voted. New Releases Poll (Aug) – 961 patrons voted. Cassie’s Picks Final Poll (May) – 1,011 patrons voted. Noms of Oscars Past Final Poll (April) – 1,072 patrons voted.

Old As Dirt Bert

Yep, there's fewer of us old folks every day. We always want movie fans to see the films that made a diff or inspired a younger filmmaker. The Blob was an example of a low budget B-movie that got popular because of novelty, not quality. When kids are making out in a drive-in, quality and plot don't matter too much, but a fun film could fill awkward moments.

Stewart Menzies

Good Halloween movie to watch, " Mama" The guy who played Jamie Lannaster in GOT, is in it, so is Jessica Chastain. It's quite a jumpy scary movie.

Chris Thom

Excellent writing on those.

Nolofinwe

yeah he was a famous pain in the ass . I mean Michael Landon didn't pitch a fit over his starring role and I was a teenage werewolf

Silver Machine

Just wondering, Richard. Do you think Frankenstein (1931) is scary? Do you think Claude Rains' portrayal of the Invisible Man wasn't hammy?

Richard Maurer

Frankenstein was a bit scary when I was a kid, unlike Lugosi’s Dracula. Claude Rain’s portrayal of the character of the Invisible Man was meant to show a decent into madness and he had to do it with his face covered with bandages or off-screen (invisible), so no, it wasn’t hammy at all. I’ve already said Lugosi was good in other roles. The problem with his Dracula is that he played the character on the stage many times before he filmed the movie, but still played it like it was a stage play, something not uncommon in that era with other actors. It’s not entirely Lugosi’s fault though, someone should have told him he wasn’t in a play and needed to tone it down a quite a bit.

Eddie Perkins

I'm jumping over to Dracula from the Bride. If everyone else does this, maybe we can pull ahead of The Blob.

Richard Maurer

Does Joe just block people at Random? Larry and HH aren’t exactly known for attack posts.

Geoff S.

I want to see a Hammer Horror poll

Old As Dirt Bert

It was hip for the time, and released as a single. It was written by Burt Bacharach and Mack David and got to #33 on the Billboard hot 100.

Old As Dirt Bert

Cassie got a Blu-ray of The Blob (and of Them) in October of '23. Soon there'll be only 5 contributions (of mine) hoping for a reaction.

Collar City Guy

If you want to see a good reaction to Them! And other 50-60s Sci-Fi Jen Murray has a reactionsto it, and War of the World's, Forbidden Planet and others as she really enjoys the genre

Joe J

Other reactors are much better for older sci-fi, fantasy, and horror.

Richard Maurer

This is the second classic horror poll, second one where all the movies were Universal except for 1, second time all the Universal movies lost - last time to King Kong ‘33

Old As Dirt Bert

I watch Jen occasionally. The problem reactors have with watching old flicks is the old flicks=fewer clicks equation.

Joe J

The Blob won this one easily. Interest in this Poll was low, most single-vote polls get around 1,000 votes.

Richard Maurer

Yeah, well most people around here don’t like anything outside the 80’s / 90’s. That’s their problem, not mine.

Joe J

Older movies just ain't a thing on this channel. Only 16% of all movie reactions Cassie has done have been pre-80s movies.

Björn Karlsson

0 % of her reactions have been swedish movies 😒😒😒😒

Richard Maurer

What about Swiss movies? Same thing, right? ;-)

Mike Lemon

@Bjorn - That's not fair- one was almost Swedish (Girl with the Dragon Tattoo).

Richard Maurer

The song doesn’t really give scary monster vibes. It’s more “I think this movie’s stupid but I need a paycheck” vibes.

Richard Maurer

You know, I don’t watch Rom-Coms. So when they have Rom-Com polls I don’t vote in them. Just a thought.

Xev

That's your business

Richard Maurer

Horror of Dracula (not the one on this poll) moved up to 15th place on the Requests list thanks to someone adding it to their priorities.

Joe J

I really hope Cassie just watches HoD, she is certainly aware it is the Dracula film everyone wants a reaction to.

Richard Maurer

If there isn’t some confusion between it and Dracula ‘31. In Requests HoD is unfortunately listed as Dracula 1958 (Dracula is the outside the US title for HoD). The ‘31 version was probably intentionally listed in this poll as all the other movies are Universal studios films ( except The Blob) but who knows for sure?

Joe J

Just an FYI Richard. "Totally Whatever" has a $25 Producer Tier PAF open just through Thursday. You can submit two films between 1950 and 2010.

Richard Maurer

Of course that would coincide with being out of work for the better part of part of 2 months due to illness and money being tight. Otherwise I’d probably go for it

Joe J

Hope you're feeling better Richard. I'll put in HoD as one of my films. Odds are quite favorable on these PAFs.

Richard Maurer

Thanks Joe, I’m seem to be better now and am back to work now. And thanks for putting HoD in as one of your films