Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I was hoping for scary but not TOO scary... oh my gosh. How is this only PG-13?? I was so excited to watch James McAvoy again, but I definitely wasn’t prepared for some of this!

⚡Auto-Sync (Peacock) | 🎬 Requests | 🍿 Pick-A-Flick | ▶️ YouTube 💻 Watch/Download

Files

Split (2017) | Full Reaction - Popcorn In Bed

Watch the full reaction to Split on Popcorn In Bed.

Comments

Clarence Newman

Yeah, it's pretty creepy. Then again, I always find nutcases-who-might-just-be-out-there far more unsettling than actual horror (see Silence of the Lambs). McAvoy is great, though, and no one plays deer-in-the-headlights better than Anya Taylor-Joy. It might be the eyes.

Erik Locquiao

“Mr. Glass…” chills every time

John A

Are we really going to make her watch part 3 though? I can't even remember the name of it it was so bad

John A

Probably because she has literal headlights for eyes

Blake Evans

James McAvoy gives a masterclass in acting in this film. He's even better in Glass, which I hope Cassie does end up watching. I'm one of three people in the world that actually likes it.

Canadianant

Is there an artist with a bigger swing between his good movies and his terrible movies? This one's on the good side but man he's made some stinkers. McAvoy is a genius in this . Even more amazing is that supposedly he got the job after someone else dropped out? Truly a master class!

Wes

My Tuesday night is now booked to watch this with Cassie. I sense there will be a lot of squirming haha

JL_83

I’m not a big fan of this movie to be bluntly honest, but McAvoy was still phenomenal so I can appreciate that

Nick Ireland

Betty Buckley, who plays the psychiatrist in this movie, also played the gym teacher in Carrie.

OddThomas

For more M. Night Shyamalan: Lady in the Water

Just Plain Bob

I remember this being quite disappointing when I saw it in the theater. It had been hyped up so much, so I may have been measuring it against the hype instead of giving it a fair shake. About to watch Cassie’s reaction, so I’m curious to see if I’ll like it better the second time around.

fromage

I think it's kinda a shame that the true nature (or connection/lineage) of this film was spoiled for you prior to you watching. It's kind of unavoidable unless you watched it completely blind or when it first released in theaters. The internet just won't allow secrets to fly under the radar for long, especially here in the reactor-sphere when interest is floated for reactors to watch certain films. The shock of the ending was something truly special and completely unexpected. And people who go into this film already knowing the connection don't get quite the same feeling. That's okay though, because the film is good enough on its own and you still had a good time! That's what's important.

Eddie Perkins

About time. I have been waiting for this. I'm glad you liked it. When it comes to M. Night Shyamalan's movies, The Sixth Sense will always be my favorite, but this is a close second. I know Glass isn't as good as the first two, but I have only seen it once, and I could watch it again.

Kyle K

I personally loved Glass but I’m a bit of a Shymalan shill

OddThomas

Betty Buckley (the psychiatrist) was also in another Shyamalan film, The Happening. I won't say it's a great movie, but it is a lot of fun.

Just Plain Bob

Better than I remembered but still not as good as its proponents often claim. As for multiple personality disorder, I thought that I remembered that it’s still controversial in many quarters. So I looked it up and, depending on how the question is phrased and which community of psychiatrists are questioned, between 20% to 50% don’t believe in it. It was recognized in the DSM decades ago, but homosexuality used to be regarded as a mental illness in the DSM and wasn’t completely removed from the DSM until the late 80s. Point being, it’s hardly a manual comprised of hard and fast rules but, rather, it evolves as our understanding of human behavior evolves. One thing I really liked about the movie was that the doctor wasn’t treated as infallible. She made mistakes. HUGE mistakes. I’ve read about at least three serial killers that absolutely fooled their psychiatrists. Two of them were actively murdering women while under treatment and their psychiatrists believed they were making great progress. One of them, Arthur Shawcross, attended a court mandated therapy session with a dead body in the trunk of his car (he had previously been convicted of raping and killing two children). Probably the most famous case was Kenneth Bianchi, one of the two Hillside Stranglers. He claimed to suffer from MPD and several psychiatrists that espoused the disorder believed him and were prepared to testify on his behalf. A psychiatrist retained by the prosecution tricked Bianchi into revealing the truth: he did not suffer from MPD. He’d seen Sybil and read up on the issue. He subsequently dropped the pretense and agreed to testify against his cousin, the other Hillside Strangler.

fromage

Hmmm, yeah that's a tough one. I'm usually all for allowing someone to reach their own conclusions on a "divisive" sequel, but I gotta be honest, I'm not a fan of the third film in this series either.

Mojo One Thousand

"Casey's" father seemed familar to Cassie. He is played by Sebastian Arcelus, and he is in "The best of me" which has a Patreon exclusive reaction. However, a quick look through his filmography, I would guess it would be "Madam Secretary", as Cassie has referenced that a fair bit in the past. James McAvoy is very good in this.

Shehab Dawoud

The Visit would’ve been a better M. Night movie for the season.

Simmeland

It wasn't advertised as being set in the same universe as 'Unbreakable', it was considered a surprise ending that everyone who saw the movie in the theaters talked about.

Richard Maurer

One of Shyamalan’s best, up there with The Sixth Sense and Unbreakable.

Chris Retzlaff

I personally loved finishing the story with Glass. Any chance to see Crumb again is great. And I think the story itself comes together really nice... better than some of the Marvel or DC movies of late

Chris Thom

Shyamalan had a pretty great series on Apple Plus called Servant. Worth a watch. His movies can be VERY hit and miss, but if you like his style, you like his style. The tones are usually fairly similar and consistent, with different setups. And some kind of twist or swerve at the end.

Chris Thom

The one where they aged really fast on the beach was a bit tedious. But he does do 'unsettling' quite well. Almost always. Sometimes the 'lessons' from the buildup in his movies just don't quite resonate.

Brent Petty

Cassie, now that you've watched a lot of the more well-known horror films, you should react to The Simpson's Halloween specials they have every year. The one where they spoof "The Shining" is hilarious.

K, Zachary

Glass was the name of 3rd one. It's like Split meets Unbreakable. I remember Unbreakable besides They Live it's the only two times, I had gone into Blockbuster and demanded my money back because the movie was so bad and it said on there sign satisfaction guaranteed. As I found it doesn't work that way. I remember watching Split at my buddies house my friends wife was hiding under the blankets. We kept telling her it's not that bad we have seen a whole lot worse. Anya Taylor-Joy was recently in that series called Lucky on Apple TV that was a good series.

Larry Darrell

I concur. I was there when it happened. Nobody knew. All anybody knew was that this was just another Shyamalan movie. No one expected there to be a final scene featuring characters from another film from 16 years prior. Here’s the trailer from 9 years ago… just another Shyamalan movie. https://youtu.be/sUuB7pRLs5o?is=CDRaXxg3tem1z8RB

VOCFM

I remember watching this and thinking it was overrated, however im going to rewatch now and see if ive changed my mind. Im curious lol edit - I liked this better this time for sure, but I also thought parts of glass were in this movie.

MrKsummer7

Ready for some M. Night Shamalama!! 🤘

Annie519

I love it too! I understand why people wouldn't but you can't deny it's worthy watching, if only for James. I also think it's worthy watching for Bruce Willis too, this was one of the last things he did before retiring. And even then he was already showing sighs of having frontotemporal dementia (FTD), it just hadn't been made public yet. I do think that the film had to be changed due to this, so I don't blame the film.

Annie519

James McAvoy was phenomenal in this, by far his best performance! The way he was able to switch from personality to personality in an instant was amazing to watch and he didn't even need to change his clothes anymore, you immediately knew who it was just by the voice or body posture. And I honestly think his performance during the therapy session when Dennis finally stops pretending to be Barry should be studied in film class. What makes him even more impressive is he wasn't the first choice for this movie, it was actually Joaquin Phoenix but at last minute was changed, I can't remember why. James was cast 2 weeks before production started. So, that meant he not only had two weeks to learn and study DID but prepare to play 9 different people. Sure, most of them was for a few minutes but when he had to quickly switch you instantly knew who it was. And speaking of that scene while shooting James was actually getting frustrated and to pump himself up he hit a prop door and he just so happened to hit the only metal part of it. He broke his hand and didn't tell anyone for 3 days. You can see his broken hand in the film, it's when he takes his glasses off as he's buying the flowers. I have always seen that Kevin is a victim, the real monsters were his mother and Casey's uncle. I think that flashback moment with Kevin's mother and when you see her uncle howling and on his knees without his clothes was far more disturbing than anything with the beast, well besides eating the girls alive. Anya Taylor Joy was also excellent, this was very early in her career too. Also, it was such a smart idea to make this an origin story for the Unbreakable universe. And what’s so great about that is, Kevin was in Unbreakable. He was the little boy whose mom bumped into David at the stadium. In fact, Kevin was supposed to play a bigger role in it but Shyamalan just couldn’t figure out how to work him in and then chose to dedicate a movie to him, but he couldn't get financing since Unbreakable didn’t do well at the time. So he did other projects and it’s a good thing too he waited because to me it made it better and we wouldn’t have had James most likely and I'm not sure if this movie would have worked without him or had been as good as it was.

My_Cousin_Mose

Overall it's a good movie and superbly acted. However I think the twist at the end was very weak. The beast won't attack anyone with trauma? I dunno it just didn't do it for me and I think Shyamalan could have done better. And by extension I could really do without the entire pedo plotline since its only purpose is to set up the disappointing ending. I would pass on watching the third movie. It's just bad and kind of a slap in the face to Unbreakable.

Chris Retzlaff

I dont believe for one second you forgot the name of the third movie...just trying to be cheecky??? Cone on man

Clay F

I liked it. Better than Friday 13th and Unbreakable. McAvoy incredibly good acting. Anya Taylor-Joy good too. Skip Glass (unless wins a poll) – worst of the trilogy. Glass has no points at Requests – nowhere to be found among the 6000+ movies on the leaderboard. Two James McAvoy movies I recommend: --“STARTER FOR 10” (2006) (romance/comedy) (McAvoy as lead w/Rebecca Hall, Benedict Cumberbatch). --“THE LAST KING OF SCOTLAND” (2006). McAvoy is great. Forest Whitaker won Best Actor Oscar. McAvoy's character anchors the narrative as the primary POV lens.

Mojo One Thousand

Thought so, the other viable option was "House of Cards", and I certainly don't recall that coming up as much as "Madam Secretary".

Clay F

SBNTS Sequel Poll last year (2025). Scream 2 and Blade 2 beat Split. 1. Scream 2 - 588 votes 2. 10 Cloverfield Lane - 552 3. Doctor Sleep - 482 4. Blade 2 - 432 *5. Split - 405 6. 28 Weeks Later - 343 7. Halloween 2 - 306, 8. Underworld 2 - 268 9. Alien 3 - 232, 10. Tremors 2 - 210 11. Nightmare on Elm Street 2 - 153, 12. Poltergeist 2 - 132

Chris Thom

Sounds like quite a few youTubers joined Patreon this year, because it seemed like Split was way more popular on the LIVE chats than it was here in the past.

Richard Maurer

Scream 2 won, and then didn’t do well on YouTube. Hopefully no more Scream sequels in the futures

Richard Maurer

The twist at end was that it was set in the same reality as Unbreakable, a twist people seem okay with sharing for some reason.

Richard Maurer

I liked Glass but it was definitely the weakest film of the “trilogy”.

Chris Thom

Was Lady in the Water any good? I think I saw it at some point, but don't remember much about it. Vaguely remember it being the most different of Shyamalan's movies.

Chris Thom

True. But it became BIG news pretty quick. Spoiler laws never seemed to apply to that one for whatever reason.

Chris Thom

Part enticing, part terrifying. She always looks like she's planning something...for good or evil, yet to be identified.

Keith Jacobsen

"If this was me, I'd have no idea how to load a gun!" No time like the present Cassie, it's the information age, you could watch a 5 minute YT video on how to load and fire a pump shotgun and be well on your way! Very fun reaction.

John A

You find it hard to believe I forgot the name of a shitty movie that came out like a decade ago? Make it make sense

John A

I remember Lady being too different that I didn't like it because of my expectations having loved his movies before it. I have read a few times to give it a second chance but who knows. As for liking movies of his that everyone else hates, Glass was a major let down for me but for some reason I just kinda like the Happening...

John A

None that I can think of. I absolutely loved his best movies but my god are the rest bad

Chris Thom

Yeah, I remember The Happening getting terrible reviews. The setup was quite good and the buildup was tense, and then it never really went anywhere. Some things that didn't quite make sense or seem plausible. And Mark Wahlberg was definitely miscast for that part. But it's also one that I think people have found, or will find in the future, and enjoy it well enough.

Joe J

FYI - in "The Blob" YT premiere I asked Cassie via superchat to consider "Horror of Dracula" this year. I didn't get an answer either way which is unusual. Maybe she has decided to watch it and didn't want to tip her hand? Hope remains, we shall see.

Kyle K

I don’t know about either of Happening or Lady in the Water. I remember having watched them once long time ago they must not have been good enough for me to watch again.

Chris Thom

Thought she looked familiar!

Chris Thom

Would imagine that movie Primal Fear did a lot to convince people, maybe professionals even, that Dissociative Personality Disorder is more performative than real. I really don't know. But would imagine with enough trauma it could be a very plausible defense mechanism to split. But as far as criminals I think it would matter how predatory the crime was. Oh and speaking of Primal Fear, I bet Edward Norton was a big reason why McAvoy took the part. I always think of him as his younger brother.

Joe J

Actually Chris, paid patreon subs are down YTD. End of GoT for the most part I would guess.

Chris Thom

I really think Cassie would enjoy House of Cards. For two or three seasons, at least.

Chris Thom

There was someone on YouTube that was really pissed off about PIB and KOTSK. I didn't quite understand the post. I thought GOT fans liked it?

Chris Thom

Fascinating about Bruce Willis. So curious if he himself knew when he needed to retire? Or if he wanted to keep going indefinitely? Or if friends or directors and producers had to force his hand?

Chris Thom

I haven't seen it yet, but I forget that title every time. Split is way easier to remember for some reason. Probably because it's brought up a lot more.

Chris Thom

Some of his stuff is more thoughtful and planned than others. But he's one where you definitely suspect when a money-grab is happening, more than artistic fulfillment.

Richard Maurer

Lady in the Water was better than most people said it was, just don’t expect too much. It’s not one of his best films.

Just Plain Bob

Sadly, I agree that far too many people look to movies for information, often failing to take into account that they’re watching ENTERTAINMENT, not a documentary. One expression of this is when celebrities are looked to for information or explanations about issues they know little or nothing about. I remember in the early 90s when Lorenzo’s Oil came out in theaters. I’ve never watched it but understand it’s about a couple’s struggle to find a treatment for their son for a disease I presume to be fatal. Susan Sarandon played the mother. In the early 90s, CNN and others frequently broadcast Congressional hearings live, often for hours. Susan Sarandon was called as a witness to testify about the disease her fictional son suffered from and the bureaucratic red tape surrounding experimental treatments. A Hollywood actress was answering questions about a complicated topic because she played pretend. This wasn’t Mayim Bialik answering questions about neuroscience (in which she has a PhD). It was a woman whose degree is in drama; not a medical doctor or someone specializing in pharmaceutical medicine, not an expert in government administration or even possessing a law degree (those last two could presumably address issues such as liability or tort reform). Just an actress. And she was being treated as an expert witness because she spent a few weeks parroting words fed to her in a script written by someone else.

Richard Maurer

Also I wonder how much of that is studio influence. I could just see a studio saying “ we’ll fund your movie - IF you put another one of those twist endings you’re famous for in the movie”.

Richard Maurer

After watching LiteWeight Reacting’s reaction to The Mist I’m getting a bit worried. That “one thing” destroyed her. She was crying uncontrollably and saying ‘I hate this movie and I hate the people who recommended it’ ( she apologized later ) Cassie; Just for the record - I voted for They Live. Don’t blame me for this. :-)

Clay F

I believe there is some retention of GoT fans who joined PiB Patreon to watch GoT. Impossible to know how many (if any). PiB paid Patreon members were less than 3000 at the start of GoT (had been on a steady decline in first half of 2025 in the months leading up to GoT). Then peaked at 3800+ during GoT. Now at 3300. I think Andor and KOTSK helped to slow the decline since GoT end.

Clay F

3,692 - Oct 28, 2024 (previous record high) 2,960 - July 21, 2025 (GoT announce) 3,850 - Sep 8, 2025 (record high) 3,659 - June 7, 2026 (GoT S8:E6 full reaction post to Patreon) 3,568 - June 20, 2026 (Andor S1:E1-3 full reaction post to Patreon) 3,365 - Sep 25, 2026 3,314 - Oct 13, 2026

Richard Maurer

I’m sure some GoT fans stayed. Just as I’m sure some left because it was done. Adding a popular series is always going to bring new subscribers. But they are not all going to stay when that series is done.

Clay F

My guess is a little less than half of those becoming paid Patreon members to watch a new series remain paid Patreon members when the series is complete. But it's fluid and changing, and other factors.

Chris Thom

Yeah, that's probably true. I quite liked his Apple Plus show, but I also heard they gave him a TON of money for it. Like a ridiculous amount that he probably didn't even remotely need to tell that story. It got stretched out for four seasons when it could've been two and a half, maybe.

Clay F

I have not watched LiteWeight's full reaction to The Mist (posted to her Patreon last month) but may watch it. I've never seen The Mist but what I've read is generally not the greatest (like you, I voted They Live). I saw that her edited reaction posted to YT but makes little sense for me to watch the edited reaction b/c I've never seen The Mist. I would be lost.

Clay F

That SBNTS Sequel Poll last year was conducted when paid Patreon membership was peaking after GoT had started.

Clay F

I've been a Patreon member of hers since 2024 (with a few month interruption in 2025). Similar to Cassie, she reacted to many series I like, e.g., Band of Brothers, Pacific, True Detective S1, Chernobyl, Queen's Gambit, Andor, Shogun. She recently completed Breaking Bad (great show) and now doing Haunting of Hill House (love that miniseries, which I first watched here at PiB).

My_Cousin_Mose

Maybe twist was the wrong word but you know what I mean. I think the Beast could have been thwarted in a much more interesting way. I agree it would have been really cool to see if Cassie would have made the connection between the movies herself and seeing that reaction. I imagine scarce few reactors end up watching Split spoiler free.

Above Average Dave

Is the Minky Blankets promo still going? And if so, does anyone have the code? I would love to get my wife one of these for Christmas. 😀

Richard Maurer

The Mist is a good movie with a great ending. I just like They Live a little more . But there’s a certain part of The Mist that’s very hard for sensitive people to handle. That may have played a small part in my voting for They Live also.

Joe J

I enjoy watching LWR from time to time, quite an emotional lady for sure. Also, been watching Molly Bee, who recently posted NotLD, Re-Animator, and Dog Soldiers.

Richard Maurer

Yeah I ‘ve been meaning check out Molly Bee. With movie selections like those it’s hard not to.

Richard Maurer

Well if they were going to vote for movies like Scream 2 I won’t miss them.

Gray

I guess Vince dosn't watch the news then 🙄. Decent film and as others have said James Mcavoy was fantastic but you'd think they'd let him use his Scottish accent for one of the 24 personalities.

Cole Jennett

I see it was answered in Extra Butter, but for anyone else the code is “popcorn” and it’s still active.

LukeG84

Finally found the time to watch this one. Wasn't expecting Cassie to drop the reaction so soon, and I of course had to rewatch Unbreakable first. No matter how many times I rewatch this movie, it still blows me away by how intense it is. Cassie, thank you so much for watching this one. I've been desperate for you to watch it for a while as I knew you would love it. Even made it my PAF, which I have now changed of course. I can't wait for you to watch the third and final movie in this trilogy, Glass (2019). IT WILL BLOW YOUR MIND! P.s. Anya Taylor-Joy is in Glass too.

Above Average Dave

Thanks, as always, Cole! Just used it to get an early Christmas gift for my wife!

Yaisu

James should've gotten an oscer for this movie.

Clay F

LWR can be emotional. Took me a while to become acclimated. I think genuine.

Richard Maurer

If her reaction to The Mist was acting she deserves an Oscar. Definitely a genuine reaction.

Mister Lou

Are you going to keep going with Glass.. et cetera?

Aaron Ritchie

I love how at one point when McAvoy switches alters, Cassie immediately says “oh it’s Patricia” without him having to utter a single word. An absolute masterclass.

Justtired

I’ll show my age here, but she was also the stepmom (? I think) in the tv show Eight is Enough