Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Poll: Free Roam vs. Guided

  • Free-Roam 326
  • Guided 192
  • Not important to me 97
  • 2024-06-23
  • 615 votes
{'title': 'Poll: Free Roam vs. Guided', 'choices': [{'text': 'Free-Roam', 'votes': 326}, {'text': 'Guided', 'votes': 192}, {'text': 'Not important to me', 'votes': 97}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2024, 6, 23, 15, 1, 59, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 615}

Content

Poll time! Since we are progressing hard on day 4 I have to make a decision on how in general the downtown experience is going to be. I am currently at 50% of the renders done, the Dollhouse is coming along nicely...

 (this is WIP without postwork, it will get a bit darker...and filled with people)

...so I was thinking about the exploration part of Downtown and if we should make it different or actually not. I was about to make it more about the exploration, but now that it is setup time I am hesitating and actually asking if this is something that adds to the experience...or not.

If you think about the past days in Blackmore, it has been a guided experience. You visit the places one after the other, basically trading the free-roam aspect for the safety that you get to see everything. there is of course the freedom to explore the areas that you are in and look around or talk to people, but you get guided from place to place. Makes it easy for the story to be told as well.

Now for Downtown, there is the possibility of you just walking around, exploring it yourself. A bit more like the Femdom City approach...that means of course you have more control on what to see and what not, but also increases the chance to miss scenes and characters.

I have been thinking about this, and I am unsure, I would like to ask you guys on what you prefer in general. So I have set up another poll for it...

Please let me know in the comments as well, maybe you have an entirely different idea!

 Sweet dreams...beautiful nightmares!

Have a good start into your week and

stay kinky!

Files

Comments

Abra-slave-666

Hmmmmm the free roaming is an attractive option but the chance to miss character's and stories is the part that bothers me so for me is guided

Noah

I voted Guided. but whatever the decision. It will always be a pleasure to play your games.

david

Both put mark which we suppose to go , and freeroam open

Seiren

I'm going to say guided for now, with the possibility of some late game free roam. Maybe even a few updates in the future solely dedicated to free roam activities. I think it may complicate things for you to allow us to free roam so early. I like the idea of having it eventually, but I think the current system has worked well for the flow of the story. We still have a lot of new places and people to visit in Blackmore.

Darktoz

well it is not entirely free roam...for example you cannot decide to go back to the tower, you just can decide where you want to go in downtown ;)

Lost Soul

I think the guided is fine so far, long as we’re allowed to look at things and talk to npc’s on our way to our destination. I think with that alone it makes the world feel alive enough to make it seem our character isn’t just stuck on rails. With free roam I feel we would just be wondering where we need to go to complete routes rather then it actually adding anything to the game really.

6721

free roam adds replay ability i feel like

Frank Kuschmann

I would like to walk around free on my own. I always liked games where you have to discover unknown areas first without knowing what you have to expect and what kind of surprises await to you.

Darktoz

yes especially when you find out you missed something :D

Darktoz

yes, very good point. the "mini free-roam" scenes where you can look around in a new room will of course be there in the future!

Arne H

I also prefer free roam in downtown. It makes it more interesting to play again and maybe discover something new that was missed in the first round. I like to play through your great games several times. So far, that has been less motivating with SoB than with FC Mantis.

Seiren

I understand - a sort of curated version of it can work within a limited scope for now.

Osk0

Missing stuff just makes me feel unnecessarily robbed. I think the guided with mini free roam section set up you've used so far is perfect. At this point I'm just bitter towards open world free roam stuff that usually just ends up wasting your time with grind or confusing layouts.

Thevault 87

free roam would be fun as hell, especially with the amount of random "bad endings" we could stumble upon

TwixtVixen

This is exactly how I feel! The Guided with mini free roam approach of Blackmore has been one of its selling points for me.

unic

Hey! Harley Quinn forever!!!

Andrew

I love that you get guided so that you don’t miss any of the characters or scenes. That is a big part of why I love this game.

Daniel

Personally I dont mind as long as theres no chance of missing out on any of the storyline.

WskyNeat

Guided, I hate to miss any of the action anywhere!

Josh c

I mean, I'll go around looking for everything

Draupnir

guided cuz i think its easier to create an immersive and gripping story. when everything can be roamed freely is much harder to do that since everything has to be somewhat open and accessable at all times.

Darktoz

yes, but also miss them ;)

Darktoz

well, you can still miss some characters or monsters by decision, for example the slug queen

Darktoz

no, that will not happen :)

Darktoz

yes, i have a similar preference when i'm playing

Darktoz

then let's hope you will find what you are looking for ;)

Darktoz

yes, on the other hand guided can feel forced, like you have no freedom in your choice

Frank Kuschmann

... until she hits your head with her axe - lol.

Gogo Gogo

In my opinion the free-roam experience is the better one, because you can build your own story and discover everything new and the game gets a lot more interesting to replay and discover new things in new runs.

Mike

I would appreciate the free roam because it has more of the video game feel to it as opposed to just clicking through a visual novel.

Draupnir

yeah you probably wanna find a sweet spot where the player has some autonomy but the whole experience doesnt feel too loose and meaningless. for example femdom city. you can visit underpass job day in day out and the whole thing feels somewhat generic due to that. but implement a unique encounter where you meet a group of girls in the underpass that bully you and force you to clean their shoes etc. that would feel much more amazing.

Darktoz

there are actual unique encounters like that with the mantis official for example in the underpass...but if you make every encounter unique for a job that is supposed to be done daily that is too much scenes for me to do

Darktoz

yes, and my games should feel a bit different from a normal visual novel!

Draupnir

right. the way mantis is designed its impossible to make only unique encounters. no question. i dont remember having such a scene. but im not sure when i last played. one of later scenes i remember is that warden girl who is collecting our money, taking me for a walk as her dog. i should check out whats new , or what i have missed :)

Ronin_498

Free Roam please. I agree wit Gogo and Mike's comments.

Darktoz

another free roam vote, seems like this is going to be the popular choice

Mike

But that also gives you a reason to play multiple times, to go back and see what you missed or try different actions. If it’s too guided, one play through and you’ve seen it all.

MH

i like free roam but i understand it might lead you to miss things. but this might also increase the replay value. also, if the memory room remains unchanged, you know you missed some scenes if they arent unlocked.

Sensual Blue

I like free roam, as it adds to the sense of intrigue and suspense when playing, and adds replayability.

Darktoz

yes i think the memory room will stay like that

Darktoz

seems like free roam is the popular choice :)

Darktoz

don't worry, i will make sure that the scenes are hard to miss :), kind of like they are right now

Archaon the Everchosen

That's good to hear, thanks! That makes free-roam a lot less stressful :)

Heis Fumin

Any ETA 🙃? Cant wait for day 4 🥲

Darktoz

too early for an ETA, since i am only halfway done with renders and animations, sorry

Heis Fumin

All good, great things take their time :)