Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Poll

Should I port Femdom City to Ren'Py?

  • Yes! 472
  • No! 139
  • 2023-01-22
  • 611 votes
{'title': "Should I port Femdom City to Ren'Py?", 'choices': [{'text': 'Yes!', 'votes': 472}, {'text': 'No!', 'votes': 139}], 'closes_at': None, 'created_at': datetime.datetime(2023, 1, 22, 13, 15, 44, tzinfo=datetime.timezone.utc), 'description': None, 'allow_multiple': False, 'total_votes': 611}

Content

I have been going through the comments of the last post and read them all. I realized how much love there is for the game and its characters. I am rendering new scenes for it for the first time in ages and I really like going back to the old characters :)

But for some the experience of Femdom City is still a kind of buggy one, especially with loading saves and on mobile.

The Visual Novel Maker engine used for fcity is pretty much abandoned and doesn't really get support, so I am thinking of something that I have avoided so far just because of the workload that comes with it: Porting the game to Renpy! For those who don't know: Renpy is the engine used in Shadow over Blackmore. It has nothing to do with the artwork, but the mechanics of the game. How smooth things run, how saving and loading is handled, all that sort of stuff!

The upside would be no more saving issues and a functioning mobile version. Most likely a more stable experience and a better overall performance on desktop as well (that is not 100% guaranteed, since you can only say that for sure once it is ported). If the end result is good and stable, I might also publish the game on steam (nice for you if you want to have it in your steam library, nice for me to get some additional exposure. Oh, and the game would get translated in other languages, since Renpy makes that easy...

The downside would be that this would take time and I can't say how much. But femdom city mantis currently has the most content of any of my games. By far! I think if you go and play it for the first time and explore everything until you get to day 86 you spend 2-4 hours ingame! If you've played it you know how many animated scenes this game has! So it is by no means an easy task.

I also don't know how many of the userbase really have performance problems and/or saving and loading issues. It could be 2% of the player base and these are just very vocal or it could be 20% and most of them just say "well, it is what it is"... 

If you want to take a look at it yourself just compare the performance of The Shadow over Blackmore and Femdom City MANTIS. If both work equally well for you, you might just want a faster update with the current engine.

Tell me what you think in the comments and please vote so that I can see what you, my community, think about it!

Should Femdom City MANTIS be ported to Ren'Py, yes or no?

Stay kinky!

Files

Comments

Andrew

Does the art stay the same for fcity or does the 3d art look like the art in sob

Darktoz

the art stays the same. like pointed out above, render engine and game engine are two different things

Zilljah

My usual answer to this is “Whatever is best for the creator.” But if you’re working in a system that’s no longer being maintained, and if you’re already familiar with an alternative that you feel is a better option, then change is good

Michelle

Isn't Renpy not the engine used in most adult games? For example, BDSM tournament The menus look always the same

Aaron

I voted yes, but I'd like to suggest that you hold off making a decision until you port one scene of day one, and see how long that takes. If it's a huge time sink, it might not be worth it, Figure out what you're dealing with before you make a final decision. IMO.

Azguella

"The downside would be that this would take time and I can't say how much." I can't say we have all the time in the world because we are not in jail but we still have a lot of it and investing that time on something that has potential better performance with other things that can help and is not abandonware is a good time investment in my opinion

Darktoz

That is RPG Maker. BDSM Tournament, The Asylum and Captured by Dark Elves were all made in RPG Maker. it is usually used by adult devs when there is a third person character that you can control and run around with

Darktoz

i think it is the best solution for the long term and the worst solution in the short term, if we are just looking at it from my perspective

Darktoz

well, it would require a set up before we can get to porting the first scene. the GUI and the mechanics would have to be ported first, and then we can make the first scene but i get what you are saying. if i realize that it takes a year or so to port we will abandon the thought of porting it

Darktoz

true, but i think it also depends a bit on how long this would truly take. maybe it is not as hard to port as i think, but maybe it is even worse ;)

Azguella

Expect the worst hope for the best

Eugene Hardy

As for me my only problem with FS is that we cant replay already unlocked scenes (like gallery) cos save slots only 8. PS but i'd really like to see FS ported to SoB visual engine/render of how its called, interesting to see new look for familiar characters.

Darktoz

that is not going to happen. it would be too much work. basically would have to recreate every scene and every character in the other render engine. yes, save slots would be basically unlimited. like it is in shadow over blackmore

Eric Larson

I only want you to do it if you want to. I honestly had savings issues with the android version but switched to PC and didn't have any.

ian scott

Pc hasn’t been a problem for me. I’d rather see it on renpy. With that said, if the original engine isn’t supported it’s probably worth it to switch. Guess it comes down to how long we’d have to wait. I love this game.

Darktoz

yeah the android version is pretty much a mess. if we decide to stick with the old engine i think we do not longer make an android version

Darktoz

i really don't know how long this will take. i think it is a good suggestion to take a long look at it and try to port the intro and the camp and see how long it takes...and if it is more than a month of work i just make it over time or finish it with the old engine

Sigmer

Porting to renpy is better. Both for performance and dealing with save file issue, that i have to deal with. It makes it more replayable as you can skip alot easier.

Darktoz

fcity also has a skipping function. you have to press control to skip forward

Vilian0Vic

I didn't have many technical issues with it, but I think the opportunity to release it on Steam alone is a pretty big pro for porting.

Darktoz

you mean for additional exposure of the game or because you want to have it in your library?

Kevin

Since I got past day 25ish,I have not been able to save the game on mobile. So it is difficult to explore multiple routes/characters since I go back to day25ish anytime I try to save.

BlackedDarked

I like the og system better but what makes it easier for you do it.

Deadmanfrank

I did have a few issues with the save game in fcity and it would be nice that it get ported for stability.

Vilian0Vic

Both, though with a bent towards more exposure. Though as others here have pointed out, best to see how much effort ot would take and decide based on that.

Darktoz

yeah the mobile version is nothing but trouble at the moment, no doubt

Nanus

Since I didn't face any performance issues with fcity so far, I don't see the necessity for porting it to Renpy. Would be a great loss of precious time in my opinion, that could be better used to proceed in the storyline.

Mondy

I voted yes, but first of all I will complete this version

The Otter

The game is better with the new enginge - I like your new game but if I had a choice I prefer Femdom City MANTIS. Thats the point why my vote is Yes....

Edge

I wouldn't do it, it's too far along, prefer new content on it.

Darktoz

new content is also going to come, but yes, it would take longer and i could do additional content instead of spending time porting it

Darktoz

yes, saving is what most people who are voicing complaints have trouble with

Darktoz

the easier way is just leave it with the current engine. the problem is that the story is already at 86 days and nearing the end. the longer you play people tend to have issues/problems with saving and it can get frustrating if the game crashes at day 72 or so and you can't load your save file

Edge

Thank you for the reply, Femdom Mantis is at like 80%. Renpy is great for future projects and if it ain't broken don't fix it, your decision of course, good luck!

Frankeneinstein

Regarding FCM - 'Usually, the better road is the one that leads to a long term happiness no matter how hard the path." Looking at your pros/cons, for you (not us), the remake would be the more effective decision for everyone; long term. You probably know that many developers are doing this. Obviously, my answer is do it. It seems it would be the best for you and all of us in the long run. I don't know if you remember but I was one of the first who asked about the javascript save issue. Also, as you know I am using Linux. So I'm teething at the bit to play FCM even now. I would say do it. I can wait. Are you going to upload portions of FCM as you remake it? That would be brilliant and far easier to swallow. Porting is far more important to me than new content; although I wouldn't complain if you did a little of that as well. Seems like this post hit a lot of nerves.

Darktoz

no, if i port it i would port it in one go. unless i decide to do it and it takes forever, then i might release part by part

Draupnir

as for performance both games work well for me. about porting the game im not convinced. the only benefit is that savefiles can be used for future updates. so i guess the obvious question is how many more updates do you plan? if its only 2 or 3 and then the game is done it seems too much effort. if you wanna go like 5+ updates and have lots of ideas still it might be worth it to make savefiles last

bambagera

I think along similar lines. If it helps with finishing it, sure. If not, then why bother? Mantis already is the second attempt, why start a third?

Darktoz

it is not the reason that savefiles can be used for future updates, but for the reason that some players are not able to load their savefiles at all. i think so far savefiles have always worked for updates (for femdom city)

Eric Larson

I'm perfectly fine with things the way they are, PC version works great. If you decide to change the engine I'm sure it'll be even better!

Frankeneinstein

1 go is fantastic. How about letting it run and take a tiny rest/vacation? :-)

TransKelly89

My choice is to go the renpy route. As you mentioned there really isn’t any support for the current program that you used for most of the making of Femdom City. And in my opinion at this stage it would probably be better in the long run and look better using the Renpy engine. Especially if you or the players run into issues with the game, there isn’t any support anymore for the current development program. Myself and others have Ive waited a long time for an update. So what’s waiting a bit longer going to hurt. I would much rather wait longer for a smoother game play experience, better graphics, and a smoother running game. Especially a game with one program instead of a game using 2 programs to make it. I honestly think it makes more sense at this point to start fresh and make the game on renpy. Using the same game storyline and plan. Just in a different program. You could even take the time if people are willing to wait to make some new characters or add more choices in the game to make it better. I also agree with Frankenenstein. I think it just makes more sense at this point to start from scratch so to speak. And remake the full game in/ using renpy. You could even add more things into the game depending on what you’re willing and wanting to do with the game. And what the majority of players would like to see. I did enjoy playing the old FCM, but I think it’s better at this stage to start over again using renpy. But still stick to the same storyline and similar characters. I’m more than willing to wait. Sorry for the long reply.

Darktoz

thanks for the detailed feedback! keep in mind that new characters and more choices can also happen in the old engine. it isn't tied to that :)

Taylor Hernandez Im

I saw switch there's time to time I don't get beyond entering the rich district before it won't let me save

Chilopod

Wow that's a tricky decision. I played M.A.N.T.I.S. so often and it must have been a ton of work. I don't know, how accepted erotic games are on steam but if you think, that steam has no problem with that, i think you should give it a try. It would definetly get bought buy more and more people, if they get to know your content. The bdsm scene grew a lot over the last 2 decades. However you decide: I wish you the great feedback you deserve. :) I won't vote, cause i have no clue how long it will take and i trust your decisions more than mine.

Chilopod

I have no problem to play this game everytime from the start again. But i don't know how patient the others are and the new players will be.

Darktoz

i am not exactly sure but futadom world and other erotic games are already on steam. but i don't know if it attracts more players and is even found through a normal steam search since steam limits that i think

Darktoz

do you know the day where that happens?

warren

I voted "No" because it would take a lotta time and effort, and also because it would change the artistic vibe of the game kinda like "colorization" of an old black and white movie.

Darktoz

thanks! keep in mind that the artwork would stay the same. only the menus would change

triskaidex

I've had lots of save issues, which prevent me from playing.

Darktoz

yes, this is i think the #1 reason why porting makes sense

Oysterhead

I'd say only if you hire someone for the port as to not slow down progress on new content.

Darktoz

that would be the best solution! but it would have to be someone that is not only trustworthy but also proficient in both renpy and visual novel maker!

Volond_27

I'm surprised so many people voted in favor of it. I think if the options were: 1) port to RenPy, delay all new releases and updates by X months; 2) release 2/3/4 updates for Femdom City and Shadow over Blackmore the results of the poll would be very different.