Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout

Content

I need some honest feedback on an ambient track I made.

I needed another simple ambient track to mix it up so that the main ingame theme of tSoB doesn't get too repetetive, but I didn't find anything so far. I have had trouble finding good simple loop music in the past already and it takes a lot of time to search.

Long story short I decided to make something that fits the athmosphere myself, but it is very hard for me to rate my own track and if it is good enough for the game, so...:

Download 

It is nothing fancy, but if you could download the track, listen to it and give feedback in the comments if you think it would be fitting and is good enough quality, that would be nice! Thanks!

July is finally almost over and the weather is getting worse where I live. For rendering that is certainly good news. Progress was good though, despite the hot temperatures. Still have a lot of scenes to render but at least it is certain that this will be the biggest tSoB update so far...once again ;)

Have a good start into august and

Stay kinky!

Files

Comments

Arthur

Amazing, thanks for your great work mate <3

NerdyGothKitty

So overall I think the general concept works and fits the game, but that first sound needs a bit more depth. As it is, it sounds a little hollow and incomplete to me. The other sounds that come in at 0:03 sound good though.

bacace124

It's solid! Just make sure the vol mix is alright in game, that bass can take over really easy

Vilian0Vic

The first few seconds when it's just the beat sound a bit off. Can't quite put my finger on it, it's a bit like the sounds are too close to each other. The rest of the song is a solid base however, though I think it needs at least one more element in it to bring in a bit more variety. PS: That picture you posted is funny. :D

Darktoz

can you say what would give the first sound more depth in your opinion?

Darktoz

true, good that you point that out

Darktoz

would it be better if the beat and bass start at the same time right away?

Andreas B.

Sound is good for me 👍

NerdyGothKitty

Hard to say. Maybe more reverb, layering a slightly-offset copy of the sound on top, or adding more of a 'thump' to it. Not really sure.

Ozzywald

the atmosefair of it is spot on, it might be a good idea to fade the bass part in though, just so it doesn't hit so hard thereby making a bit of a "shadowy" theme rather then a house song. and be careful with the volume mixing as repetitive bass beats like that can really start to get annoying if its suppose to listened to for a long time.

Darktoz

yes, good point! maybe it isn't the best for a theme that is playing long

Vilian0Vic

No a bit of a buildup is fine. Gave it another listen and it sounds fine now. Maybe just a random feel.

Frank Kuschmann

Even though it's just a little bit more than 1 min the sound is great and fits very well into the dark and eerie atmosphere of TSoB - in my opinion. You has composed it yourself? Hats off! To what kind of scenes in the game are you going to play it?

Mabuse786

Too much bass and undefined bass. I mean more defined bass is better. I am a sound engineer. But OK, just wrong frequencies for the bass. 80 Hz and 100 is the one you should aim to.

Darktoz

mmmh...it is difficult to know for me what the current Hz of the bass is, but I will try! thanks for the advice!

Darktoz

I thought about it changing from the main theme when the protagonist spots a clue or something unusual. or maybe walks through an odd place

B. Freundlich

Sounds good but after 30 -32 seconds there is a little highlight missing in my opinion.

Darktoz

any idea on what that highlight should be?

HalfBreedMix

Sounds good, just make sure to add some variety to it.

B. Freundlich

Very good question !I can imagine what it is but hard to descripe it some kind of a higher tone but very mild. Maybe some kind 2 or 4 dark piano tones. Sorry I'm not a musician but here maybe something similar like in the beginning of this song here: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=L5q4uYj-gyg

B. Freundlich

or maybe like here in the intro.

Darktoz

like...more drums? another bass?

Rascal

It's a good beat with a good hook, but around the third repeat (about 15 seconds or so) I was expecting the next layer to introduce itself. Maybe some high hat or something like that. Then, later, I was expecting some sort of counterpoint melody (like with electric guitar or synthesizer) to add some texture. You may have heard this before, but the ambient music from CP 2077 has some great examples of dark background music. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=1W6hQhj5NVk

Darktoz

thanks! will listen to it!

eldritch enlightenment

In my opinion it's unatmospheric, boring and generic I think that you can do better, but don't spend too much time on soundtrack, it is not as importan as rest of the game (especialy when you consider the fact that current soundtrack is really good)

Darktoz

unathmospheric sounds a bit harsh, i don't see it like that but thanks for the input and maybe you are right and it doesn't fit with the rest of the quality. Soundtrack is a really important part of the game, I spent literally days and weeks finding the current tracks. finding and buying the right tracks can take a looot of time :)

Charger Pup

Sound tracks make or break a game. That said, I've ended up turning off the ambient music in probably every game I've ever played after a while. No matter what you do, if it's played enough, it's ambient track is going to become a distraction to at least a portion of your players. I don't think there's any way around that. However, just about every game that I personally believe has a good sound track, the ambient track(s) are all variations on the game's theme song re-sequenced or the tempo changed for the current mood. Slowed down or playing around the melody for chill areas, sped up or emphasized for combat or other important scenes. Examples that come immediately to mind are World of Warcraft where many of the city & region themes are in the main theme(s) representing the various factions and expansion packs over the years which are themselves sometimes variations on the original theme from the original 2006 version, and The Elder Scrolls games Morrowind, Oblivion, and Skyrim. The exceptions of that rule tend to be games where there's some kind of "radio" functionality: Bethesda's versions of Fallout, CD Projekt Red's Cyberpunk 2077 (I highly recommend Radio Vexelstrom for the Femdom/BDSM & metal crowd!), etc where the player can effectively choose the style of music they want to hear. But, given those are really big budget games, I'd never expect that kind of functionality in games where the dev(s) aren't musicians themselves wanting to show off their work.

Darktoz

mmmhh...true, i tend to get annoyed at most ambient background tracks as well after a while and tend to turn stuff of and listen to something else. sounds like i have to give Radio Vexelstrom a listen

Zilljah

Charger Pup and Rascal covered what I'd have said. CP2077 has great examples of background music that suits a game with dark themes that's not just repetitive thumping

Darktoz

true...that budget from cp2077 is a bit out of my league, though :D

Stephens

Cool track mate, the bass fits well with your other tracks and gives off that dark foggy and often claustrophobic element. Maybe could add a few extra subtle hisses of smoke and have the snare sound more creaky, like stepping on a loose floor board. Otherwise great work and always good to see more Bellatrix ;)

Darktoz

oh, interesting! thanks for the input, i really like the hisses of smoke idea

Consumer

seems ok? am i listening for quality? hard to give feedback without knowing the context.

Darktoz

yes you are a bit late, that was 4 months ago ;) was asking if the quality was good enough to put it into the game