ASL2: Chapter 34 "Open Communication" (Patreon)
Downloads
Missing 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.
Content
-- CHAPTER 34: Open Communication --
****
-- SUNDAY, DECEMBER 14, 2008 --
I felt something tickle my balls, and with a start, I jerked awake.
“Mmph!” somebody grunted, and as I sat up, I realized I’d just shoved my dick an inch into a girl’s throat. She took it like a trouper, gagging only slightly and keeping her head down, breathing heavily through her nose until I pulled back. And then she resumed rhythmically pumping my shaft in her hands and sucking on the mushroom head as if I’d never interrupted her.
My eyes fluttered for a brief second, giving me just enough time to see the copper red-haired head bobbing up and down in my lap before my heavy eyelids closed themselves. Normally that would be the point when I’d sigh, relax, and let my head loll back onto my pillow while soaking up the exquisite sensations of an excellent morning blowjob; but I didn’t do any of those things. As soon as my heavy eyelids closed themselves, I opened them again right away, not wanting to miss a second of the incredible sight before me.
Summer smiled around a mouthful of meat, pleased by the expression on my face. Her royal-blue eyes sparkled in the morning light while she sucked on my knob and stroked my shaft with both hands. Knowing she had my complete and undivided attention, she winked at me playfully and then swiftly impaled her throat on my upright shaft, slam-fucking her face all the way down until her puffy pink lips were sealed around the very base of my towering tool.
I groaned in rapturous ecstasy and reached up to caress her silky red locks. Summer moaned around my meat and then pulled up until she just had my mushroom head still inside her mouth, and she tilted her head to the side so that my stiff dick visibly dented her cheek outwards.
Dawn was sitting up beside her and reached down to caress Summer’s cheek. I could feel the pressure of my best friend’s fingers tracing the cap of my cock through the thin membrane, a rather surreal feeling for sure. “I told you he’d love it,” Dawn drawled with a mirthful smirk.
“Mmm…” Summer responded with a hum, gazing up at me with undisguised adoration.
It was as if nothing in the entire universe pleased her more than to see that she was pleasing me. I could tell in her gaze that she was seeking some kind of affirmation from me, so I reached up to caress her other cheek and confirmed, “I DO love it. Thank you.”
Summer beamed and promptly swallowed my schlong again.
I made sure to keep my face and visual attention on Summer so as to reinforce for her how much I loved her morning blowjob. But at the same time, I let the rest of my higher brain functions boot up and took stock of the situation.
Last night, after Dawn and I had come to our agreement to release her from her oath of mono-dick fidelity, we returned to my bedroom to find Adrienne and Summer reclining in my bed still talking as well. I don’t know exactly what they were talking about as they stopped their conversation as soon as Dawn and I came through the door. Summer gave me the same kind of puppy-love look of utter joy and happiness at the mere sight of my face that June had been giving me lately, and did I mention that both absofreakingly gorgeous busty bombshells were both still completely naked?
But Adrienne gave me a rather melancholic smile, and I could read the tension on her face. She’d certainly turned a corner away from her weeklong depressive state and into rejoining the living with tonight’s little orgy, but I could tell she still had a ways to go before returning to “normal”. Plus, her lack of quality sleep or peace of mind had left her bone tired, emotionally as well as physically.
And so the four of us had crawled into bed together, Adrienne under my right arm with her head pillowed on my shoulder. Dawn hugged herself around my left arm, her head on the pillow beside me. And Summer spooned herself up behind Dawn.
But now it was morning, with Summer showing off her first-rate talent for fellatio and Dawn sitting up my left side. But the bed was empty to my right, and I found myself wondering where Adrienne was.
My eye line had drifted away from Summer for a moment to the empty space beside me, and then I looked up at Dawn with a questioning look.
She immediately gave me a reassuring smile and gestured with her eyes. I understood that Adrienne was fine and had gone downstairs or something. It was at that point that I realized there was a good amount of light streaming around the cracks in the curtains and that I must’ve slept in. For all I knew, all three of the girls had left the room to let me rest, and only now were Summer and Dawn coming back to wake me up in this pleasant fashion. It would certainly explain how both Summer and Dawn were dressed in my t-shirts.
Scratch that, only Dawn was now wearing a t-shirt. As if she could read my mind (which, well… maybe?), Dawn had tugged at the shoulder of Summer’s t-shirt, and the redhead caught on quickly and pulled off my prick so she could sit up and do that cross-armed yanking thing I loved so much to whip my t-shirt over her head. The position of course put Summer’s spectacular breasts on full display, and after tossing the t-shirt aside, the impish young vixen gave her chest a little shimmy to put those puppies into motion. And after popping a pinky finger into the corner of her mouth to give me a coy look with her twinkling royal-blue eyes, the redhead scooted forward to straddle my hips and park her puffy pink pussy above my prominent prick.
Dawn reached between me and Summer to elevate my cock and hold it steady for docking. She then leaned in and started kissing Summer’s puffy lips in an erotic display of Sapphic performance art that made me groan at the beauty of them together in combination with the sensations of Summer’s sweet snatch sinking ever lower to surround my swollen shaft.
The two of them did pull away from each other and stop making out just long enough for Dawn to similarly remove her shirt, but otherwise Dawn’s and Summer’s lips remained locked together for a long while as if they were magnetic. I eventually got my best friend to shift over and park her pussy over my eager tongue so that the three of us formed a triangle of lustful pleasure with the two of them continuing to make out. I reached up to play with my best friend’s boobies only to find that Summer had beaten me to the punch. Dawn then grabbed my wrists to direct them towards Summer’s boobies instead, and my hands went honka-honka on those hooters to my happy delight.
Two minutes later, I switched boobies, and it was while I was tweaking Dawn’s nipples and slithering my long tongue up her twat that I finally got my best friend to squeal her orgasmic satisfaction, and then she slipped off my face.
Now I could focus all my attention on the gorgeous redhead writhing in my lap like a belly dancer. I could practically hear Shakira singing about how her hips don’t lie while Summer gyrated around my upright pole as if she were listening to the same music in her own head. But after a minute or two of admiring the beautiful babe fucking herself on me, I felt a surge of adrenaline kick in as I yanked her chest down against mine, intertwined our legs, and rolled us over.
I managed to complete the maneuver without disengaging my dick and proceeded to pound the hell out of her. Just as with last night, Summer got hotter the harder I hammered her, and I seriously did my level best to pulverize her poor pussy. After another two minutes, I went ahead and pulled out of her just long enough to step back off the foot of the bed and then drag her by the legs to the edge of the mattress so I could slam myself back in. Summer howled in ecstasy as I raised both her legs over my shoulders and used my new position to really let my legs muscles help out. But then she quickly found herself unable to scream out loud as Dawn rejoined us, parking her pussy over Summer’s eager tongue so that the three of us re-formed a triangle of lustful pleasure with Summer on the bottom and me and Dawn making out.
A minute after THAT Dawn stopped kissing me, gave me a playful wink of her own, and bent over to complete a sixty-nine position. When I paused for a moment to catch my breath, Dawn ducked her head to lick at our joining and really tease Summer’s clit with her tongue. But then I went right back to banging Summer’s wet box.
Summer was HOT, and I mean that in multiple ways. Clearly, she was an extremely attractive young woman, so she was super-duper hot in terms of being beautiful. The temperature of her pussy also felt quite high, surrounding my shaft with a wet warmth that felt oh so fucking GOOD, simultaneously as smooth as hot butter but with the intense heat of a sauna. And on top of all that, she was moaning and groaning and thrashing beneath me as if she was on FIRE. Seriously, I lost track of how many times Summer climaxed beneath me, each time screaming her satisfaction into Dawn’s sweet snatch.
It was after one such screaming orgasm when Dawn tapped my hip and looked up at me, a clear request for me to pull out. I did so without hesitation and my best friend quickly glommed her mouth around my wet prick, tasting the redhead’s orgasmic juices that coated my cock.
Fuck my face, babe, she told me without actually telling me, although her words were loud and clear in my head.
So I grabbed my best friend’s head behind her ears and rather savagely pumped my prick while she stared up at me, her throat making “glug, glug” noises as my shaft slid in and out of it. At the tail end of that face-fuck I slammed myself in to full-depth, holding it there making her choke on my cock until her eyes started to water. Only then did I finally pull out of Dawn’s mouth, and while she gasped for air I plugged myself back into Summer’s snatch to start plundering her pink pussy once more.
“Flip her over and fuck her ass,” Dawn growled at me as soon as she caught her breath. At the same time, Dawn dismounted Summer’s face and sat back on her heels to watch me with an eagerly wicked grin. “I want to lean over her bent body and gaze up at you in adoration. I want you to grab my ears and fuck my face again before letting me guide your fat, swollen cock into her gaping sphincter so you can just grab onto her tiny waist and impale her pretty little tushie with your massive prick.”
“YES! YES!” Summer squealed as she started to sit up. She chirped with excited merriment, “Fuck my ass! Fuck my ass!”
I grabbed the redhead’s hips and roughly flipped her over, not that she was resisting. The moment Summer got parked on all fours, Dawn was already leaning over with her face in Summer’s crack, slathering her spit all over her girl-bestie’s crinkled butthole. She then picked her head up, and for a second I thought she was going to swallow my dick. But instead she merely smiled at me for a moment, batting her eyelashes coyly.
Fuck my face, babe, she told me again without actually telling me.
Her eyes popped open wide as I suddenly invaded her mouth. And her throat started making those “glug, glug” noises again. Dawn had definitely been on a face-fucking kick these past few months.
“Pleeease will you fuck my ass now?” Summer started whining. “I need it! I need you in me! Pretty please with a cherry on top?”
Dawn abruptly choked from trying to laugh, and she pulled off my prick. She gasped for breath while jacking my rod with her right hand and then started laughing for real. “Okay, okay. Sorry, got distracted there for a minute.”
“Put him in me! Stretch my tight asshole with that gorgeous dick. I’ve been dying to feel him filling me up so-- UNGH!”
Summer grunted the moment my fat cockhead pushed through her slimy sphincter, slickened only by Dawn’s spit. But she exhaled and relaxed, evidently accustomed to accepting a dick into her backdoor. Still, it was a pretty tight fit, and I definitely had to grab onto her tiny waist and put some power into my arms to slowly puuullll her body back to meet my forceful push.
“Ohhh… shiiittt…” Summer groaned as I sank deeper and deeper into her colon.
“Fuck yeah,” Dawn growled, holding Summer’s buttcheeks apart so we could both watch inch after inch of my big dick disappear within the redhead’s anal highway. She spit one more time on my meat to help slicken the way.
At last I was all the way inside Summer’s ass. She quivered, her whole body trembling as she absorbed the intense sensations.
I was absorbing them too, having not felt this particular pleasure for more than seven years. It’s not like I could remember what her ass felt like so long ago, but I was certainly enjoying it now. Her pussy had been hot, but her ass was even hotter. Her rump was round but firm, densely muscled and oh so fucking tight around my tumescent tool. She’d once offered to be my “butt-slut”, and at this very moment I definitely wanted to accept that offer.
Still keeping Summer’s asscheeks spread apart, Dawn sat up straighter to stare deep into my eyes and moan huskily, “You’re such a fucking stud. I get so hot watching you sodomize her. We’ve been talking about doing this for soooo long… Mmm-mmm-mmm… So many fantasies finally fulfilled.”
“Fuck yeah…” Summer agreed from beneath us.
Dawn finally kissed me, a passionately volcanic liplock that ended when she bit my upper lip and slowly retracted, tugging my lip with her until it popped free. “Fucking POUND her, babe.”
I pounded her.
I pounded the hell out of her.
The harder I hammered her, the more Summer screamed.
The more Summer screamed, the more amped up I got.
The more amped up I got, the harder I hammered her.
And so the cycle continued.
Dawn eventually moved over to the head of the bed and spread her legs. She grabbed Summer’s head and yanked it into her crotch, moaning rapturously as she closed her eyes and grinned a wicked grin. I stared at my best friend’s gorgeously sweaty naked body as she writhed and wriggled, crooning out a quick climax faster than I would’ve thought possible. Dawn was REALLY enjoying this, perhaps even more than Summer and I were.
“Cum in her fuckin’ asshole,” Dawn growled before grinning. “Cum in her asshole and fill her up so I can slurp it all out and snowball it back to her. Cum for me, babe. I am SO fucking happy we’re finally having these threesomes I’ve been dreaming about and I can’t WAIT to taste your sperm! Cum for me! Cum, babe, CUMMM!!!”
“Argh-argh-AAARRRGGGHHH!!!” I grunted as I slammed forward one final time and began splooging all my spunk into Summer’s clenching colon.
“CUMMM!!!” Dawn howled.
“AAAAAAHHHHHH!!!” Summer screamed as she started cumming again too.
“CCCUUUUUMMMMMM!!!”
Two minutes later, I found myself slumped on my side with my wet half-hard erection waving in the air. Beside me on the bed, Dawn had just finished hoovering my jism out of Summer’s stretched sphincter and was now crawling up Summer’s spectacular naked body for the snowball. She didn’t baby bird my jizz this time. Instead, she bent her head forward and gave Summer a surprisingly tender kiss while feeding the other girl my sperm. Summer moaned as she swallowed and stared up at Dawn, all of her attention on my best friend for the moment. But once the pair of them had devoured every last drop of my seed, they finally turned back to me.
“Well THAT was a pleasant way to wake up,” I told them both sincerely.
Summer gave me an almost bashful smile. “Did you really like it?”
“Like it?” I shook my head. “LOVED it. Thank you.”
“My pleasure,” she replied warmly.
“And mine,” I quipped with a laugh.
Dawn waggled her eyebrows suggestively. “We should do this more often, don’t you think?”
I smirked and nodded. “Sounds great to me.”
****
Although Dawn had mentally reassured me that Adrienne was fine shortly after I woke up, it was still quite a relief to see her smiling in the kitchen when the three of us finally arrived downstairs. My more-beautiful-than-words ex-fiancée was dressed casually in one of my tank tops with baggy arm-holes that flashed vast quantities of side-boob and a pair of my gym shorts. She’d been wearing a lot of my clothes ever since moving in as they made her feel like she still had a part of me with her even when I wasn’t around.
I went into the kitchen to give her a quick kiss and a hug.
Adrienne then smiled at Dawn and waggled her eyebrows at Summer. “Sounded like the three of you were having a pretty good time.”
Summer blushed and gave me a coy look. “Between last night and this morning, he’s been everything I dreamed about. Better, even.”
Dawn smirked. “Notice how she didn’t even mention me. Now that she’s finally landed the whale, I’m chopped liver.”
“Ohmigawd, D, no!” Summer quickly turned and wrapped up Dawn in a bear hug. “You are amazing and you know it. I love you! I mean, I don’t love-love you, but you’ve been so important in getting me this far and I know how much you’ve helped in getting me and Ben to this point and I… I’m rambling, aren’t I?”
Dawn giggled and leaned forward to nuzzle Summer’s cheek before pecking it. “No sweat, girlfriend.”
I arched an eyebrow. “‘Girlfriend’?”
Dawn rolled her eyes. “Girl who’s a friend.”
We all chuckled at that.
“Hungry?” Adrienne gestured to the skillet on the stovetop.
“Always.” I noticed Adrienne had set out plates for four, which reminded me that there were two others who lived in the house. “Have you seen Kim or June?”
Adrienne had already returned to the stove and nodded without glancing back at me. “They left just before Dawn and Summer went upstairs to wake you. Picking up BJ from his grandfather’s place.”
“Ah.” I went to join Dawn and Summer at the dining table.
“Also, I have some news.” Now Adrienne glanced back at us over her shoulder.
I nodded but didn’t respond verbally, just waiting her out.
Adrienne took a deep breath, clearly collecting herself. A chill went down my spine as my overreacting imagination immediately started speculating on all the worst possible things she could say to me, like: ‘I’m moving back to New York’ or ‘I wanna get back together’. Shit like that.
But instead she gave me a nervous smile and explained, “Sasha’s coming over here early.”
****
I’d already told Adrienne on Friday that I’d agreed to meet Sasha at the O.G. Berkeley house Sunday night so she could hook up with Eve for the first time. At the time, Adrienne hadn’t particularly liked the idea of being separated from me any more than she had to. But between Saturday’s meet-up at the San Fran apartment where Sasha put the interlocking hearts necklace back on, and last night’s stress-relieving orgy, Adrienne had apparently worked up enough gumption to start reading and replying to Sasha’s texts again, and she’d agreed to let Sasha to come over to my house in the afternoon.
Meanwhile, both Summer and Dawn went home to change their clothes and probably spend the day together. That left me and Adrienne a good couple of hours alone together, which turned out to be not such a great thing. See, with Summer around, and to a lesser extent Dawn, Adrienne felt the need to put in the effort of keeping her shit together, as it was. Nevermind that Adrienne had spent a good chunk of last night talking to Summer about the break-up, the Alpha/Queen Bee supermodel simply could NOT fall to pieces in front of other people.
But just her and me? There was no need for false bravado in front of me. I was her Rock. She felt free to completely relax and just feel however she felt with no filters, and in this particular case, it meant freaking out about everything Sasha might say to her when she arrived. I soon found my arms full of sobbing girl as her overreacting imagination immediately started speculating on all the worst possible things Sasha could say to her, like: ‘I’m moving to Europe tomorrow’ or ‘I wanna get back together’. Shit like that.
I decided that some distraction was in order, but not the sexual variety. I wanted to get Adrienne out of the house, to focus on something else, so on impulse I put her on the back of my motorcycle and rode her out to the local mini-golf/arcade complex. She looked at me like I was crazy when we pulled into the parking lot, but I insisted and she went along with it. Five minutes later she was shouting curses at digital zombies while we did our level-best to blow their heads off with matching plastic laser rifles. And I allowed myself a little smile.
After blowing way too much money in the span of an hour, Adrienne was feeling much better and let me bring her out to the mini-golf course. We talked about whatever happened to pop into our heads, nothing serious. Then we talked about something that was really serious, about Taylor Brynn Kwong and how what her idol was going through was so much worse, losing a loved one she could never get back. In comparison, a break-up was nothing, right?
I told her it was okay to feel pain over what she was going through and she didn’t have to minimize its importance. But at the same time, it did put things in perspective. We were here, weren’t we? Healthy, wealthy, and wise? Well, maybe not wise (“You’re definitely not wise, Tiger”), but healthy and fairly well-off, financially (“I do have millions I’m not doing much with on top of my modeling income”). So what was there to complain about?
I did ask her if Adrienne was feeling up to rescheduling her postponed or cancelled modeling gigs, and she gave me a noncommittal shrug. Inside, I admittedly wondered just a bit if she’d EVER go back. Part of me relished the idea of her just moving into my bedroom forever. Part of me knew that would never happen, and I wasn’t a hundred percent sure how to feel about that fact.
In the end, though, we finished up our round of mini-golf, we both missed our 19th-hole putts, and I put her back on my motorcycle for the ride home.
Sasha would be there soon.
****
Can you guys see if Dawn can come over, too? There are some things I want to say to her as well.
Sasha had sent the text to both me and Adrienne on our three-way chat thread. I showed my phone to Adrienne, and while she looked surprised, she answered my unspoken question by replying, “Yeah, sure, go ahead and text her.”
I quickly shot Dawn a message, explaining that I didn’t have any details yet but that Sasha wanted her to come join so they could talk as well. She didn’t reply for a few minutes, but when she did it was to send a thumbs-up emoji and say she’d be here in twenty minutes.
The request for Dawn to join us must’ve been a last-second thought, because Sasha arrived less than five minutes later. I went to welcome her at the door with a kiss and a hug while Adrienne remained standing by the couch, not totally sure what level of affection they should have now that they were officially broken-up. But Sasha left me and immediately wrapped up Adrienne in a fierce squeeze before pulling back and pecking her on the lips.
Adrienne was still dressed in the same clothes she’d worn to the mini-golf/arcade place: baggy cargo pants and a Cal hoodie, although she’d now ditched the trucker hat and aviator sunglasses. Sasha, on the other hand, was the one who looked like a fashion model. She wore strappy wedge sandals, a pretty skirt hemmed above the knees, and a three-quarter-sleeved mock turtleneck top that hugged her considerable assets. Her hair was in a stylish updo, dangling earrings adorned her face, and her only necklace was the interlocking hearts one that Adrienne had given her. Not for the first time, I marveled at her transformation, remembering the way she used to dress in college with minimal makeup and baggy clothes trying to hide her beauty.
Quite frankly, sans makeup and with an expression that looked like she’d rather face a firing squad than be here, Adrienne looked like a street hobo in comparison to Sasha’s cool elegance. I’d managed to distract her for a little while and they’d parted on Saturday on pretty good terms, but now that Sasha was here, the stress was back.
Sasha noticed this immediately and worked quickly to put Adrienne at ease. Rubbing Adrienne’s arms, she took a seat on the couch and tugged Adrienne down to sit beside her while I headed for the armchair. Sasha’s expressive brown eyes were focused on her ex-girlfriend, and she offered a reassuring smile while saying gently, “Relax, honey. I love you. This is going to be good for us. Well, not good-good in the sense that we’re still breaking up, but I’ve done a lot of thinking this weekend and I do hope you like my ideas.”
Adrienne sighed a little wearily. “You’re never short on ideas. Open communication and all.”
“Don’t knock open communication. I thought our relationship was so much the better for it.”
Adrienne shook her head slowly. “Open communication was your overcorrection to how closed-off your relationship with Rod was. You felt like you could never truly be yourself and the stress of trying to separate who you thought you needed to be for him and who you really wanted to be ate at you from the inside.”
“True. And as soon as I got into a relationship I felt a hundred-percent safe in – with Andie, actually – it was such a relief to be able to completely open myself up.”
I frowned. “Andie gets credit?”
Sasha glanced back at me. “Oh, you got me started, totally. If we’re talking about credit, the credit is yours. You were the first one to start accepting me for who I am and also encouraged me to be honest with my true feelings without judgment. I’m the flower that bloomed under your sunshine.”
“But Andie…” I led her.
Sasha smiled. “You started me on that process, and when we officially became boyfriend and girlfriend you helped me finish my journey. But in all honesty, it was with Andie during TDW that I first started open communication. We told each other everything: our hopes and dreams, our love for you, our occasional jealousies, everything. Even with you, at first, I was afraid of saying something that might upset you or make you love me less. But with her, I felt free.”
“Huh.”
“Don’t feel bad. Like I said, it was feeling in that safe space with you that got me started. And of course after Andie left, I started practicing open communication with you and then Adrienne as well.”
“You know there is such thing as too much open communication,” Adrienne sighed. “Not everyone brushes things off as easily as you do. You tell me not to take some of the things you say personally, but they can be pretty personal, you know?”
Sasha nodded. “I know, and you also know I’m really sorry for the times I made you feel hurt, even if that wasn’t my intention. Clearly, open communication alone doesn’t solve all problems, otherwise we’d still be together. I’m sure there’s a happy medium somewhere between the way I communicated with Rod and the way I communicate with both of you, and I’m still trying to find a good balance. But at the same time, I’m pretty sure the right answer is a lot closer to where I am today than to where I was with Rod.”
“Fair enough.” Adrienne bit her lip and hugged herself, clearly anxious. “So you were saying you had some ideas? Ideas for what?”
“Well, ideas for what I want to do with my life. I’m pretty set on quitting my job, leaving San Francisco, and going out to explore the world a bit.”
Adrienne immediately deflated, and she swallowed thickly. I slid over from the armchair and wedged myself into the small gap between her and the couch’s armrest, spooning myself against her back while Adrienne shrank into my chest.
“We talked about this yesterday, didn’t we? Please don’t feel like I’m abandoning you,” Sasha said gently while reaching a hand out to Adrienne’s knee.
“Then don’t abandon me,” Adrienne bit out a little roughly.
“Well that was actually one of my ideas. There are a lot of things for me to figure out and get organized before I go. Plus, right before Christmas isn’t the best time to try and figure out last-minute travel. I need to put in two weeks’ notice at work. I don’t have a lot of stuff, but what little I have will need to go into storage, under the assumption that you wouldn’t want your ex-girlfriend’s stuff sitting in her room reminding you of me every time you looked in there. And actually, I figured that once I move out, you probably wouldn’t want to stay in the apartment at all and would either move in here with Ben or otherwise find somewhere else to live.”
Adrienne raised her eyebrows. “I believe you said you had some kind of idea that would somehow resolve my feelings of being abandoned?”
“Oh. Right. Sorry.” Sasha gathered herself and gave Adrienne a nervous smile. “Just spit-balling here – open communication and all – but I was hoping you’d move back in with me for a while.”
I sat up straight at that, and Adrienne frowned in shock. “What? Why in the world would I do THAT?”
“I’m serious. We did the break-up and you moved out for more than a week. But now that we’ve cleared the air a bit, I want us both to think of this less as a break-up, and more as a transition in our lives that we both need. First of all, I know that look on your face you got right before you left the apartment on Saturday – the look of having a million thoughts running through your head and wanting to write them down before you lost them.”
I chuckled and rubbed Adrienne’s upper arm. “You definitely had that look.”
Sasha smiled. “The gears were turning. Like I said: I figured you would want to move out as well, and you were making plans.”
Adrienne glanced over her shoulder back at me for a moment before admitting, “Well… yeah…”
“So I thought: Why don’t we make these plans together? You know more than anyone I know about traveling: Where to go, where to stay, who to stay with, places to go to feel safe, places to go if I’m feeling in danger, stuff like that.”
I scowled and muttered, “I don’t like the idea of you going anywhere you think you might feel in danger.”
Sasha gave me a wan smile. “I know, and thank you for caring. I’ll always be your fish, Ben.”
I blinked, not sure how to respond to that.
Adrienne arched an eyebrow. “You want me to help you plan how to leave me?”
“I’m not leaving forever. I’ll come back, eventually. I was thinking a year off would be a good round number, to leave right after New Year’s and come back in time for Christmas. I won’t make you any promises about us getting back together or anything like that, because at the end of the day, I really think your ‘forever love’ lies with someone else.” Sasha’s eyes drifted up to mine, and she gave me a pretty intense look.
Honestly, I couldn’t tell if her look implied that -I- was Adrienne’s forever love – or that Sasha couldn’t be Adrienne’s forever love because she really wanted to be with me.
“Anyway, you can help me organize and plan my trip. I can help you organize your own exit from the apartment and help you figure out where exactly you want to go to next. But more importantly…” Sasha took a deep breath and shifted her hand off Adrienne’s knee to lean forward and hold Adrienne’s forearm instead. “I’d really like for us to be together again, for a little while at least. I DO love you. I think you know that. I will ALWAYS love you. I just… I can’t marry you.”
Adrienne scowled. “You think I want to just hang out every day with the girl who broke my heart?”
“Yes. I do,” Sasha stated evenly, with a bit of an eyebrow waggle that dared Adrienne to contradict her.
Adrienne’s scowl deepened and she looked away. Her eyes narrowed and she seemed inclined to go ahead and contradict Sasha just for the sake of it.
“C’mon, honey,” Sasha urged. “Think of it as a vacation. Those last few days in Bora Bora were fun, weren’t they? Even though we both already knew then that it would all be over soon? I want you in my arms again. Hell, I want your face in my crotch while Ben’s shoving his dick up my ass from behind.”
“You don’t get to ask for that when you’re the one who broke up with me.”
“I’m just being honest. Open communication, remember? It’s what I want. And this is where YOU take a crack at open communication and tell the truth.”
“What truth do you think that is?”
“That the only thing you want right now more than your face in my crotch while Ben’s shoving his dick up my ass is to pull MY face into YOUR crotch while he’s shoving his dick up YOUR ass.”
Adrienne started chuckling for a moment, but she took a deep breath. “We can’t solve all our problems with sex.”
Sasha waggled her head. “With the three of us, though, it doesn’t really hurt. And it starts with you joining us tonight at the other Berkeley house. We can invite Summer along now that she and Ben have finally hooked up. I mean, let’s do the math here: you, me, Ben, Dawn, Summer, June, Eve, Eden, and Emma. It’s been a while since we had a nine-way.”
Adrienne exhaled slowly and reached up with her free hand to take hold of Sasha’s wrist. “You don’t play fair, sugar.”
“I know. I learned from the best.”
But Adrienne shook her head slowly. “I’m not convinced that if we do this, it won’t hurt all over again when you finally fly away.”
“It’s gonna hurt all over again when I finally fly away whether we do this or not. I mean yeah, you can hole yourself up in Ben’s bedroom until January, crying to yourself every day while Ben’s at work, and ultimately never see me again. Or, you can move back in, we can have an amicable separation while organizing our respective plans, have some extra time to talk about all the things we never got around to talking about, and then when the time comes, we can part as friends.”
I squeezed Adrienne from behind and rubbed her upper arm, telling her, “She does make a lot of sense.”
“You just want that nine-way she was talking about.”
I snorted. “YOU just want that nine-way she was talking about. I already know I can get all eight girls anytime, anywhere.”
Adrienne sighed and gave Sasha a steady look. “It wouldn’t be all fun and games. There’s a lot of pain still inside, and I worry it’s gonna feel like my heart’s breaking over and over again every time that I look at you.”
Sasha shrugged. “Would it really be any worse than what you’ve already went through since we got back from Bora Bora? I think you’ve done your mourning. You were a hollow shell of yourself for more than a week, but you look a helluva lot better today than you did yesterday. I’ll keep wearing our necklace. I’ll keep telling you how much I love you. I’ll remind you that we did both agree in Bora Bora that we needed this separation, but I’ll also remind you that I’m coming back. You guys are my family now. The prodigal daughter will return.”
“You’d better.”
Sasha smiled. “Try it out. Come home with me tonight. We can snuggle up the way we used to. I’ll still have to go into the office, but I’ll come back home at lunchtime. And if the whole thing is too much for you to handle, you can come right back here and we can at least say we tried, no worse for wear. What do you think?”
Adrienne glanced up at me, her look asking if I was okay with this. I gave her a warm smile that told her without needing to actually tell her that I’d always love her, and that she would always be welcome to stay with me, but that I would also be happy for her to go back home.
She narrowed her eyes and gave me a look that told me without needing to actually tell me her suspicions that now that Summer and I were banging, I just wanted her gone so I could get the wicked hot redhead into my bed instead. I couldn’t actually hear her words in my head the way it was with Dawn, but I got the gist of it anyway.
I chuckled, went ahead and fondled her breast playfully, and gave her a look that said I would NEVER kick Adrienne out of my bed – I’d just get them both into a threesome instead.
Adrienne giggled and snuggled herself up against me with a sigh of contentment.
Sasha glanced back and forth between us, looking surprised. “Did you two just pull a ‘Dawn’?”
I blinked. “What?”
Sasha chuckled and shook her head. “Nevermind. Speaking of which, you did text her to see if she could join us, right?”
I nodded. “Yeah. Based on her text, she should be here any mi--”
We all heard the sounds of a key sliding into the lock of the front door. Dawn knocked on the wood as she came inside to announce her presence and smiled when she saw all three of us on the couch. “Now this looks cozy… What’s up? Am I late?”
Sasha grinned. “You’re right on time.”
****
Dawn gracefully sidled onto the armchair while I remained tucked into the corner of the couch with Adrienne spooned up against my chest and Sasha next to us. Once she got settled, she shrugged and gave Sasha a curious look. “Ben said you had something to say to me?”
Sasha took a deep breath. “Ooh, so many things. Where to begin?”
Adrienne chuckled. “Just say the first unfiltered thing that pops into your pretty little head. That’s what you usually do in times like this.”
Sasha giggled and sharpened her attention on the newcomer. “First thing that pops into my head? You’re so freaking beautiful, Dawn. I mean really, I’m in awe of you.”
Dawn smirked and glanced at me and Adrienne for a moment before returning her attention to Sasha. “Um, thank you.”
“It’s been such a pleasure to get to know you better this past year. I mean, we were never really close in college, and then when you first came back Ben was kinda freezing you out, and then after Ben started letting you back into his life Adrienne and I were kinda freezing you out. And even after we stopped freezing you out we kinda spent most of our time in San Francisco and you spent most of your time in Berkeley and we only got together every now and again and ohmigawd I’m rambling now but the point is I’m sorry about all that. Still, back to my original point, it’s been such a pleasure, and not just the physical pleasure because ohmiGAWD you’re so good with your tongue and your fingers and I’m getting distracted again and do you see what happens when you tell me to just go with whatever pops into my pretty little head?!?”
By now, all three of us were chuckling at Sasha.
Taking a deep breath, Sasha collected herself, eyed Adrienne for a moment, and then looked back at Dawn. “Have they told you yet that I’m leaving?”
Dawn glanced at me before returning her attention to Sasha. “Ben said yesterday that you were thinking of quitting your job and leaving San Francisco. Backpacking around Europe for a while, perhaps? Meeting up with model friends in various cities to explore the world and get away from it all.”
Sasha nodded. “I spent a lot of my early years feeling obligated to stay with Rod and his family in return for taking me in after my parents abandoned me. I feel similar obligations to both Ben and Adrienne even now.”
When Sasha paused, Dawn narrowed her eyes and inserted, “But…”
“But Adrienne and I need some time apart to reevaluate what we both want in life. I still love her – I love both of them – but I realized that the primary reason I don’t feel ready to settle down with either of them is because I don’t feel like I truly know who I am without them. I’m still trying to discover ME. But like I said: I still feel a sense of obligation to both of them for everything they’ve done for me, and I’m afraid that guilt over… well… abandoning them like this will eat away at me.”
Dawn arched an eyebrow. “And something you want to say to me will somehow assuage that guilt?”
“Dawn, you’re beautiful - and I mean more than just physical beauty.” Sasha took a deep breath and then smiled. “I know some shit went down at the end of junior year and you left, but ever since you came back I’ve seen nothing but absolute loyalty and dedication to making the lives of everyone around you better.”
Dawn blinked. “Umm, thank you?”
Sasha chuckled. “Adrienne has Ben, her Rock. After everything he’s done for her these last couple of weeks despite the way the end of Bora Bora went down, I know she’ll be in good hands. But you’re Ben’s Rock. I asked you to come here because I know how much you love him, and because it’s so very important to me that I know you’ll take care of him the way I know that you can.”
Dawn furrowed her eyebrows for a moment in confusion, not quite understanding where Sasha was going with this. Actually, neither did I, and when I glanced at Adrienne, she looked just as perplexed as I did.
“Well, uh, thank you for the compliment, I think,” Dawn finally replied. “But I don’t think it’s any secret that I intend to take very good care of Ben.”
Sasha shook her head. “Can I be honest?”
Adrienne snorted. “When are you not?”
Sasha ignored the jibe and kept her focus on Dawn. “Look, I know it’s not my place to tell two other people how they should live their lives. But I’m leaving soon and I’m in a weird head-space right now and I’m feeling ALL kinds of internalized pressure to make sure I take care of the things I need to take of before I go and if there’s one regret I have more than anything else after Bora Bora – well except for breaking Adrienne’s heart, honestly – but other than that, my biggest regret is Ben.”
Adrienne, Dawn, and I all looked at each other with perplexed looks.
Sasha fixed her gaze on me and took a deep breath. “I want to see you happy and know you’re in good hands before I go.”
“I AM happy.” I gestured out at both Dawn and Adrienne. “I’m in great hands.”
“Adrienne’s broken right now – my fault, I know. You’re spending so much time and effort taking care of her, and I love you for that. And this thing you have with Dawn… I… I really think it’s past time you two stopped pussy-footing around each other with this ‘best friends’ shit, honestly.”
Dawn frowned. “Meaning?”
“You love him more than life itself. He loves you above all others, myself and Adrienne included. You’re the air you each breathe, right?”
Dawn and I shared a confused look at each other. Dawn replied a little hesitantly, “Well yes, of course.”
“Adrienne called it ‘nottogether’ in high school. Your love for each other goes well beyond the bounds of friendship. I mean, saying you two aren’t ‘together’ is absolute bullshit and you know it. You love him… romantically. You’re IN love with him. You’ve sworn ‘‘til death do us part’, and promised to never touch another man for the rest of your life.”
I interjected, “Well, about that…”
But Sasha was already finishing, “That’s called a commitment. You do realize that swearing an oath of fidelity and promising ‘‘til death do you part’ are both wedding vows, don’t you? I realize it’s not my place to dictate to you the terms of your relationship, but in the spirit of open communication I wanted to make sure that I told you how I felt about you two and your relationship. Selfishly, I’d feel a lot better about flying off from here knowing you’d finally claimed him.”
Dawn sighed and shook her head. “That’s not gonna happen.”
“Why not?”
“Well for one thing,” Dawn explained, “last night we agreed for me to rescind the oath of fidelity.”
Adrienne sat up and frowned at me. “Wait, what?”
Sasha looked confused. “That’s a BAD thing. Why the hell would you do THAT?”
Dawn rolled her eyes. “Wasn’t my idea. Ask him.”
All eyes were suddenly on me. Taking a deep breath, I exhaled slowly and explained, “She’s a sexual creature and I know she still gets cravings. Rather than have her bottle up those cravings under some misguided ‘Perfect Dawn’ desire to somehow keep herself ‘pure’ for me, I told her I loved her enough to let her indulge in those cravings every now and again.”
Dawn sat up straight and pulled her head back with a frown. “That’s not what you said last night.”
I blinked. “Uh, yes I did.”
Dawn shook her head. “That’s not what -I- took away from that conversation.”
I canted my head to the side. “What DID you take away from that conversation?”
“That you’d convinced yourself I could never actually go the rest of my life faithful to you. That me swearing that oath only set me up for failure. That you had already decided I would inevitably disappoint you, so you’d rather accept a flawed Dawn and expect me to occasionally ‘get a little extra’, as you put it, rather than stress yourself out wondering when, not if, I’d eventually break my oath and therefore break your trust in me forever.”
I frowned. “That’s not what I said.”
“Isn’t it? Isn’t that exactly what that whole bit about me turning you into Ryan 2.0 was about?”
Adrienne now sat up straight and pivoted to look at me curiously.
I took a deep breath, rubbed my forehead, and made a face. “Okay maybe I may have come across that way last night.”
Dawn’s eyes narrowed. “I agreed to rescind the oath to spare you the stress and anxiety of wondering when I’d inevitably disappoint you. That doesn’t mean I ever intend to actually take you up on the offer.”
Sasha frowned. “Telling him you never intend to actually take him up on the offer is kinda like promising you’ll never take him up on the offer.”
Adrienne nodded. “You’re raising expectations again.”
Dawn rolled her eyes. “Fine. I’m gonna pick up a coupla hobos off the street every other Saturday to make me airtight. Be ever so grateful--”
“You already used that one last night,” I cut her off and held up a hand. “Look, please shut up for a second and let me try to clarify.”
“Oh, you mean you shoved your foot into your own mouth far enough that it’s wedged in tight and you need a minute to scramble your brain into coming up with a better way of wording it that makes you sound less like a paranoid asshole.”
I didn’t verbally respond. Instead, I shot Dawn a look that plainly said, ‘I love you, alright? I’m trying to make this better. Can we please not have this turn into a fight when I know both of us don’t actually want a fight?’
At first, Dawn’s eyes narrowed like she wasn’t done being pissed at me yet, but apparently my look got its message across because she took a deep breath and huffed a bit but otherwise didn’t continue.
Fine.
That wasn’t the voice in my head. Well, it was “a” voice in my head, but it sounded exactly like Dawn.
Moving on.
“Yes, I fully acknowledge that I most likely came off like a paranoid asshole last night, more concerned with my own anxiety than acknowledging the strength of the commitment you were trying to make for me. I let the focus of last night’s conversation stay too much on my feelings and not enough on yours. It’s clear right now that despite our best efforts, you and I still aren’t on the same page about this topic. So all we can do right now is try again. Open communication, right?”
I glanced at Sasha and got a smug little smile from her.
Turning back to Dawn, I said, “Here’s as open as I can make it. I love you. I’ll love you forever. I want – very badly, I might add – to make sure you and I are in each other’s lives for… well… for the rest of our lives. I directly violated Adrienne’s Morris Camp ultimatum for me to stop seeing you because I couldn’t stand the thought of ever being parted from you. I forgave you for everything that happened between us at the end of junior year. I forgave you for running away first on that road trip with Gwen and Robin, and then running away to dye your hair, change your name, and be a ranch hand. That’s not to say everything’s on you, because I know you’ve had to forgive me for a lot of shit I’ve done as well.”
“You have done nothing to me that requires forgiveness,” Dawn muttered dismissively. “Nothing. I’m the failure here.”
“You’re not a failure. You’re flawed, yes. I’m pretty fucking flawed too. All I really want is for the two of us flawed human beings to grow old together, so long as we’re together, and that doesn’t require a hundred-percent Ben-ogamy. You’re not perfect. You get urges. I need you to understand I’m okay with those urges. When you get an urge, I honestly want you to tell me about it. I need you to understand that I’m NOT going to get mad or upset or never look at you the same way again because you and I will be on the same page in acknowledging that you get these urges and that we've already agreed that it's okay with me. Our love is strong enough - and I'm secure in my manhood enough - to help you have these experiences without worrying you love me any less or that I alone am not good enough for you.”
“Except that you alone ARE good enough for me. I’m getting really sick of rehashing this same argument.”
“Maybe I am. Maybe I’m not. I’m not telling you to go out and seek a TP, but if you get the urge, I’m okay with it. Look, I had this same conversation with Sasha just yesterday about communication and trust while she traipses around the world. If you find yourself in a situation where you stop and realize, ‘Yes, I wanna do this’, then I want to know about that. I don’t want you to hide that, bottle it up, and let it fester until it rots you from the inside. I’d rather you be honest and believe that I’ll be alright with it. All of this is just to say again: I. Love. You. A lot. ‘Til death do us part. And my love for you at this point is kinda bulletproof, actually. Nothing short of a nuclear bomb is gonna make me stop.”
Dawn scowled, but she nodded and stated plainly, “I love you, too. A lot. Including that nuclear bomb, really, because I love you unconditionally. There’s literally nothing in the universe imaginable that you could do that would make me stop loving you. And every single day I’m trying to find a way to prove it to you.”
“That’s just it, I don’t want you to keep trying to prove it to me. I know it. I believe it. I feel it… right here.” I tapped my heart. “You keep trying to prove it to me because you’re constantly asking the question about whether or not I still trust you. You fear losing that trust. Well let me turn that around for a minute. Will YOU trust that -I- will continue to love you, no matter what?”
Dawn narrowed her eyes. “No. Quite frankly… no.”
“Why not?”
“Because your love for me isn’t quite a ‘no matter what’. You did say last night that if you ever walked into a room and unexpectedly found me riding some dude you would shut the fucking door and never speak to me again.”
I sighed. “Well yes, there’s that nuclear bomb.”
“I told you then that you’re a fucking moron for believing I’m capable of doing that to you. And it’s precisely because you DO think I’m capable of doing that, that I DON’T trust you’ll continue to love me, no matter what.”
I took a deep breath and exhaled. “No, I don’t think you’re capable of doing that to me. I know you, and I know how much you love me, and in plain simple fact you’ve NEVER been one to fuck around without me. Hell, you initially didn’t want to hook up with Summer because you said you didn’t know how to hook up with another girl without me. Now granted, that one still happened and we both know I was totally fine with it. But for you to sneak off and bang another man without my knowledge or permission? No, I genuinely trust and believe you would NEVER do such a thing to me, hence me calling it a nuclear bomb.”
“Thank you for that. Still, it seems to me that we need to figure out the line where you DO think I’m capable of something that would erode your trust in me.”
I shook my head. “That’s the same conversation we already had last night. I wanna talk about YOUR trust in ME.”
“I DO trust you.”
“You just said thirty seconds ago that you don’t. I asked if you’ll trust that I will continue to love you, no matter what, and you said ‘no’.”
“Of course I don’t trust that. I live in constant fear of you losing your trust in me and hating me again. I couldn’t bear that.”
“Okay, okay, freeze that. Let’s stop right here. Because THIS is the important part.” I held out my palms in both directions to make sure nobody else said a word. Taking a deep breath, I looked at all three of the girls before focusing on Dawn. “There are two issues between us right now: Last night was all about whether or not I can trust you. Tonight I really want to talk about YOU trusting ME. Your constant fear comes from the voice of insecurity in your head that drives you to set these Perfect Dawn standards in the first place. This is where I’m asking you to listen to MY voice telling you to trust ME and believe me when I say I will be with you forever. This is me insisting that we ARE soulmates like Brooke and DJ, like Brandi and Dayna – pair-bonded for life. We WILL be together forever. You need to believe that. You need to trust that. Because I DON’T want you living with that constant fear of losing me.”
“I don’t want to live with this constant fear either! And the only way I’m going to be able to stop having this fear is by reassuring both you AND myself that I’m never going to set off one of those nuclear bombs! Hence the promise of Ben-ogamy. Hence the oath of mono-dick fidelity.”
I shook my head. “I didn’t want that. That’s why we rescinded the oath.”
“Because my oath was stressing you out, raising expectations and setting you up for disappointment when I inevitably failed you.” There were tears in Dawn’s eyes, and her lower lip was quivering. “You think I’m gonna crack again.”
By now, Adrienne had shifted closer to Sasha on the couch, so I shifted forward in my seat to reach out and hold Dawn’s hand as well as rub her knee. “I DO think you’re gonna crack again, but not in the fall from grace sense. I genuinely believe you won’t fall into the arms of a Jaron or Dalton or any other hunky Adonis and cheat on me. You love me too much to do that kind of thing behind my back. And it WOULD be cheating, because Sasha’s right: The two of us trying to say we’re not in a romantic relationship is bullshit. I’m in love with you, and you’re in love with me. What we have isn’t a conventional boyfriend/girlfriend relationship, but titles aside, we are both as committed to each other as any romantic couple. I acknowledge that you love me, are in love with me, and have no intention of forming these kinds of emotional bonds with any other man but me. So no, I don’t think you’re gonna crack and end up fucking some other dude without my permission.”
Dawn looked confused. “But then why did you just say you DO think I’m gonna crack?”
“I think you’ve never had faith that I could ever truly love the real Dawn. I think you spend years and years building Perfect Dawn trying to be the ideal version of yourself, not only for me, but also for your family, your friends, and the entire world at large. We both know Perfect Dawn cracked a few years ago. You took off, dyed your hair, changed your name, and worked to rediscover yourself. When you came back, you told me that Perfect Dawn was gone but that Pretty-Fucking-Good Dawn would accept her imperfections. Thing is, we both know Pretty-Fucking-Good Dawn isn’t all that different from Perfect Dawn. You still want people to like you, you still got that glow when Sasha complimented you for being so freaking beautiful a few minutes ago. And you still hold yourself up to certain ideals that don’t necessarily reflect who you truly are.”
Dawn frowned. “Is it wrong to want to make myself better? Isn’t self-improvement a noble thing?”
“I’m not asking you to stop trying to improve yourself, but there’s a point where fixating on achieving perfection becomes unhealthy, makes you unhappy with yourself, and paranoid that you’ll somehow lose me. Dawn 2.0 is better than Perfect Dawn, totally, but it’s not Real Dawn. And it feels like you’re presenting a façade of improvement to cover up your flaws instead of actually conquering your fears. Honestly, I think it’s not that you’re trying to improve yourself, but rather that you’ve got a massive ego that absolutely will not accept you being anything less than the most beautiful woman in the room (or at least Top 3), the hardest-working student, or the most purely dedicated partner. And even DJ recognized that it wouldn’t take much – just the slightest prick to your ego - to push you back into your obsessive-compulsive behaviors and self-destruction if you let your fear of losing me take over. THAT’S how I’m worried you’re gonna crack.”
“So what, you want me to stop trying to improve myself or something?”
I shook my head. “I want you to stop making self-improvement the be-all/end-all goal. Here’s a crazy concept: You can be yourself, stop worrying about how else you can improve yourself, be exactly who you are right here, right now, and trust that I will be a hundred percent happy with you the way you are. Huh? Crazy, right?”
Dawn’s eyes narrowed. “Yes. That’s crazy.” And she was serious.
I sighed and squeezed her hand. “How do we make that idea LESS crazy to you? What can I do? What can WE do? Adrienne, Sasha, Summer, Eden, Emma, Kim, June, even Eve. I can call in Brandi and Dayna… Brooke and DJ will be coming home for Christmas. Hell, our parents. What can any of us do to reassure you that your place and position in our lives is secure even if you’re not quite perfect? How can I make you believe I’ll love you ‘til death do us part, Forever and Always, no matter what?”
Sasha leaned forward. “You could marry her.”
Dawn and I stared over at her and simultaneously blurted, “WHAT?”
“What?” Sasha shrugged like it was no big deal. “I’m just saying: if you two got married, wouldn’t you both feel more secure in your relationship? Hold a big ceremony, publicly define yourselves as a wedded couple, promise to have and to hold in sickness and in health and all that jazz.”
Adrienne murmured quietly, “Put each other’s names down as your emergency contacts.”
Sasha winced and reached over to rub Adrienne’s shoulder. “I’m sorry, honey.”
“No, no, we don’t need to rehash that argument,” Adrienne insisted. “You’re just repeating the things I wanted from you in search of security.”
Dawn shook her head. “I don’t need a piece of paper from the government to tell me who the most important person in the whole world is to me. I love Ben… unconditionally. And for me, that means I DON’T need to put a title or wedding certificate to prove it.”
Sasha arched an eyebrow. “Even though you just said ten minutes ago that every single day you’re searching for a way to prove it.”
Dawn looked up at me. “I asked him last night if he’d trust me to be a hundred percent faithful if we were married.”
Sasha’s evaluated me. “And?”
Dawn’s eyes narrowed. “He didn’t give me an answer, actually. He said he didn’t like my proposal and then decided he wanted me to take back my oath of Ben-ogamy.”
“Getting married solely to prove a point is not a good reason to get married.” I shook my head. “This really isn’t about you proving your love to me. I’m trying to make this conversation about ME proving MY love for you. I really, really want you to trust and believe that -I- love you unconditionally.”
“I get that, and I don’t want YOU marrying ME just to prove that point either. We’ve been over this: I don’t want us getting married at all. That was Perfect Dawn’s dream. I really AM happier being your best friend.”
“Then we don’t need to get married. Ever.” I took a deep breath. “Admittedly, I’m wondering if what we NEED to do is get you LAID.”
Dawn blinked and pulled her head back. “Excuse me?”
“I think you’ve become Ryan 2.0. I think you’re waiting for the other shoe to drop, waiting for something to happen between us – maybe not a nuclear bomb, but a bomb nevertheless – that you think would shatter my faith in you.” I took a deep breath. “I think maybe what we need to do is find a couple of guys to make you airtight (preferably not street hobos), and then afterwards when I still love you more than life itself and you are still the air that I breathe, maybe only THEN will you trust that I’ll love you no matter what.”
Dawn frowned. “Okay yes. Now I KNOW you’re crazy.”
“Want an even crazier scenario? How about if you go get laid with another guy WITHOUT me? And then afterwards when I still love you, still accept you for who you are, and assure you that your place is by my side for the rest of our lives, ‘til death do us part, maybe only then will you truly be at peace.”
Dawn shook her head and stood up, pulling her hand away from mine. “I don’t think I want to be part of this conversation anymore.”
“Dawn, please.” I stood up with her.
“How big of a fucking MORON are you gonna be?!? This crackpot idea of me banging some other dude without you just to prove a point? You think I’m going to stoop to letting just any dick into my body for… for… for WHAT?”
“No, that’s not what I--”
“Don’t you fucking get it?” she cut me off. “I DON’T NEED ANYONE ELSE BUT YOU!!! NEVER. EVER. NOT NICK. NOT ANDREW. NOBODY!!! FOR THE REST OF MY FUCKING LIFE!!! ALRIGHT?!?!”
I held out my hands. “I saw the flash. I saw the desire.”
“They’re fucking FLASHES. Do we need to get into a philosophical discussion about wants versus needs or something? Yes, there’s a sexual being inside me that sees a hot guy and thinks, ‘Hey, I’d like to tap that.’ You gonna say you don’t see some big-titted movie star and have a flash where you think, ‘Hey, I’d like to tap that’?”
“Of course not.”
“Open communication, right?” Dawn literally pushed up the sleeves of her sweater above her elbows, facing me as if she were literally about to start throwing punches. “Full, unadulterated, a hundred percent honesty, right?”
I glanced over at Sasha and Adrienne before looking back at Dawn, nodding. “You seem to be implying that you haven’t been a hundred percent honest with me before now, and that part saddens me. I’ve always tried to be a hundred percent honest with you. So YES, open communication please.”
“We’re gonna end up having a fight.”
I glanced at the others momentarily. “Sasha calls them ‘discussions’.”
Adrienne snorted. “Heated discussions.”
I rolled my eyes. “We’re already having a heated discussion.”
Shaking her head, Dawn stared up at me with icy fire in her blue irises. She took a half-step closer to me, clearly challenging me. “I don’t trust you to love me no matter what. I genuinely believe our relationship is wholly conditional on me not doing something to fuck it up. I think last night’s discussion was the more honest one from you, the one where you told me how even when you walked in on me and Summer that one day, despite you ordering yourself to have faith, you couldn’t help but panic that I was with some other guy. And you’re not wrong to mistrust me, because I don’t fully trust myself. I know how flawed I am. I obsess about my flaws. I don’t believe I’m good enough to be your wife because I believe I’ve already committed the unforgivable sin and therefore don’t deserve to be your wife.”
“I forgave you a long time ago.”
“Doesn’t mean I ever forgave myself.”
“Dawn…”
“This is why I am searching every single day to find a way to make it up to you. This is why I am searching every single day to find a way to make it up to ME. I had my dream within my grasp and I fucked it up. Do you have any idea how soul-crushing that can be?”
“Well, yeah, I kinda do.”
“Doesn’t it still eat at you?”
“Sometimes. Not always.”
“Then you’re more resilient than me.”
“Then you need a therapist who can help better than I can.”
Dawn barked a short laugh. “Yeah, probably. But that doesn’t change the fact that I am NEVER taking another man into my body ever again. I wish you’d believe me on that, but you don’t, and I don’t blame you. I’m not trustworthy. So I’m okay with rescinding the oath so I can spare you from being Ryan 2.0 waiting for me to fail. But I’m still making that oath to myself, you understand? It’s important to me for ME that I don’t let you down again.”
I sighed and reached out to hold her arms. “Fair enough. I won’t push you on that.”
Dawn snorted as she backed away from my grasp. “Oh, NOW you won’t push me on that.”
“I’m sorry.”
“Don’t be.” She waved me off. “I earned your mistrust. I committed the crimes, so my record is stained, and I’ll have to live with that the rest of my life.”
“I want to help you not look at the situation that way. I want to help you believe that my love for you IS unconditional.”
“Sure, except for the whole ‘don’t break my heart again’ condition.” Dawn shook her head. “I’m sorry, but you can’t convince me your love is unconditional because I already know better. And you can’t convince me to ever marry you because I already know I don’t deserve you.”
“Dawn…”
“I don’t deserve to marry you, and nothing you say will change my mind. Adrienne would be a far better wife, if she’d have you – you never question HER Ben-ogamy. Sasha, actually, might very well be your best choice. Actually, I take that back - you really SHOULD marry Kim. Your biggest hang-up before was that she kept deferring to you as her Master, but if she’s coming into her own – and we’ve all clearly seen her boss you around when it comes to BJ and the household – then her being a total sexual submissive in the bedroom isn’t a deal-breaker. June, actually, is starting to really show the kind of passion and dedication you need from a life-long partner. Fuck, I’d have you marry Eden if you could get away with it. That girl will move heaven and earth for you.”
After Dawn’s voice trailed off and she started huffing a bit, Adrienne canted her head. “You’re not gonna suggest Summer?”
Dawn shook her head. “Summer’s not a good match for you. She’s got… issues.”
Adrienne snorted. “We ALL have issues.”
Dawn shrugged. “Harem girl, sure. She needs Ben in her life, certainly. But she’s not wife material.”
“That’s kind of a big change from before. What happened? Why not?”
Dawn gave Adrienne a bit of a cold stare. “I’ll give you open communication for me, but I’m not telling Summer’s secrets when she’s not here to defend herself.”
“Fair enough.”
“What about YOU?” Dawn took a half-step towards Adrienne. “Open communication, right? What’s YOUR excuse for not marrying Ben?”
Adrienne blinked. “Were you not there when I asked him and he turned me down flat?”
“Because he knew you wanted Sasha and were picking him second-best.”
Adrienne sighed. “I’m not picking him second-best right now. He’s my Rock, and that’s good enough for now. I already told him I’m not going to try and get back together with him on the rebound.”
“What about a year from now? Or two? Open communication, right?”
Adrienne held her hands up and then gestured at Sasha. “Honestly? I’m not yet over THIS relationship and don’t have the bandwidth to think that far ahead yet.”
“Fair enough.”
“But you really should believe him when he says he’ll love you unconditionally,” Adrienne added. “Nobody knows better than I do that Ben doesn’t need me to be perfect in order to love me forever. Okay yeah, my sexual preference for a woman’s lush curves over a male’s muscles means he doesn’t have to worry about me ever fucking another man, but that doesn’t mean I haven’t made my share of mistakes. I blackmailed him into sleeping with me in the first place. The amount of baggage I carried from my previous relationships should have sent him running back to his virginal high school friends, but he accepted me for who I am anyway.”
Adrienne took a deep breath and fixed Dawn with a serious look. “He makes me want to improve myself too, but I don’t do it out of fear. I do it out of wanting to be a better person… for him.”
“I want to be a better person for him, too,” Dawn insisted.
“There’s a difference between fearing you’ll fail him and wanting to be better for the sake of ensuring you’ll be there for him in the future when he needs you. He’s my Rock, and I want to be his Rock too.”
“I want to be his Rock as much as you do. Probably more.”
“You ARE his Rock, but you also want it so much you fear losing that position and it terrifies you.”
Dawn pursed her lips and looked away.
“Knowing he loves me despite all my flaws is why he’s my Rock. I’m not perfect, never will be, and yet I know with absolute certainty that my Tiger will never leave me.” Adrienne reached out to hold my hand. “Forever and Always.”
“Then maybe YOU should marry him,” Dawn muttered.
Adrienne sighed and gestured at Sasha in response.
“Fine.” Dawn turned to Sasha. “What’s your excuse?”
Sasha blinked. “I’m not ready to settle down period, with Ben or anyone else. Hence why I’m flying off to another country, remember?”
Dawn shook her head and then whirled to me. “And then you.”
“Me?” I pulled my head back.
“I changed my mind. You really shouldn’t be getting married to anyone either.”
My eyebrows popped. “What?”
“I’m serious. Don’t get married. Why the fuck do YOU need a piece of paper to tell you who you love? You do realize that you’re legally only allowed to marry one of us, right? And yet didn’t you say that calling any of us your Number One would therefore imply that a Number Two exists, and a Number Three, and four and five and six? Weren’t you supposed to stop ranking the women in your life?”
“I DID stop ranking the women in my life,” I insisted. “I love all three of you, but that love is different for each. I don’t rank them or compare them, because my relationships with each of you are equally different.”
“Then don’t get married. Don’t choose a Number One. You’re Adrienne’s Rock, right? She’ll be in your life forever. Sasha’s going to explore the world, but she’s still your fish, isn’t she? Regardless of what… or who… she finds out there, you’ll always love her, won’t you?”
“Of course.”
Dawn pointed to herself. “I’m your best friend – your deeply flawed, self-flagellating best friend who needs a therapist right now. But I promise you I’ll love you forever and be with you until the day I die. Kim is your hanamuguri. Brandi, Brooke, and the twins will be your sisters forever. Dayna and DJ, too. Maybe June and Eve will eventually fly away from the nest and find their Happily Ever Afters elsewhere like Paige or Andie or even Lynne. If you ask me, you’re stuck in the same ‘wife and 2.5 kids with the picket fence house’ dream that we grew up with together, and maybe it’s time you let go of that dream and embraced your reality. You are NEVER going to have only one woman in your life. So why are you hung up on this idea in your head that you HAVE to marry anybody? If you ask me, I think you had the right idea in your coma dream.”
I frowned. “My coma dream?”
Dawn gestured with her whole arm at Adrienne. “Get her to buy a big house across the street from the other Berkeley house, work things out to bring all the girls you love most within the walls of those two buildings, and live Happily Ever After.”
Adrienne snorted, promptly choked, and yet couldn’t stop laughing even while she continued choking.
“HA! ERK! HA-HA-ERK! Ohmig-ha-ha-ERK! ERK!”
Sasha was pounding Adrienne’s back, I dropped down to Adrienne’s other side. And even Dawn crouched down beside us with concern.
Fortunately, Adrienne managed to stop choking, although she kept laughing as the tears streamed down her cheeks. Sasha, Dawn, and I all shared confused looks for a moment, not understanding. And finally I asked her, “You alright?”
Sasha added, “What’s so funny?”
Adrienne gestured at Dawn, back at herself, and then back at Dawn. Inhaling deeply, she managed to get both her breathing and her laughing under control, and then explained, “Great minds think alike.”
Dawn arched an eyebrow.
Adrienne grinned. “I already decided yesterday: I’m gonna buy us a big house.”
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------
For anyone who can’t wait, VIP tier now has up through Chapter 42 (https://www.patreon.com/posts/58191049). Remember that all authors thrive on feedback, so let me know how you're enjoying the story! Leave a comment here or come chat with us on Discord! And be sure to connect your Discord account here on the Patreon website to get access to the Patron-Only channels!