Home Creators Posts Import Register Favorites Logout
haven't archived this post yet. have a subscription? use the importer!

Downloads

  • ASL2 [65 Fine].txt

Missing 1 file, as this post has not yet been imported.

Content

-- CHAPTER 65: Fine --

****

-- FRIDAY, MAY 22, 2009 --

“Eden and I are breaking up.”

Eve’s words hung in the air as if they’d formed tangible letters that hung over the four of us on my bed. Eve and Eden were looking at each other, mixed emotions on both of their faces. I glanced at June, and when June looked back at me, she looked just as shocked as I did.

June was the first to find her voice and said, “I still don’t understand.”

“This is mutual… ish,” Eve began with a wince.

“She’s not dumping me,” Eden stated quickly. “Not exactly. We stayed up late last night talking, and both came to realize that this romantic relationship isn’t working out for her.”

“I still love this girl to pieces,” Eve explained. “She’s my best friend. We do everything together. And I would never want to hurt her.”

“But I could tell that once the shiny new car smell wore off of our relationship, she was… It’s just that…” Eden sighed.

“I’m not gay,” Eve stated finally. “I mean, I’m totally gay when it comes to sex. Well, I’m bisexual, clearly. But romantically, I’m not a lesbian. I think I always struggled with that part… being in a publicly lesbian relationship with our friends. Like, they never gave us a hard time about it and totally accepted me and Eed being gay. But whenever we hung out around other couples and I saw the girls with their boyfriends I just felt… I felt…”

“You said it felt wrong to be holding my hand instead of a hot guy’s hand,” Eden muttered quietly.

“Eed, I didn’t mean it like that,” Eve said defensively.

“Except that you kinda did SAY it like that. You used the word ‘wrong’.”

“I’m sorry. I told you I was sorry about that.”

“I’m not blaming you for feeling the way you feel. It’s cool. I get it.” Eden sighed in resignation. “I’m not angry.”

“But you’re still upset.”

“Well yeah, I’m gonna be,” Eden muttered with a sigh and a scowl. “But I care about you too much to try and trap you into a romance that doesn’t make you feel good. And we both agreed that a time like this, when you’re moving back home with your parents while I’m staying here, is the best time for us to break up.”

June and I were ping-ponging our eyeballs back and forth between the two girls. I felt a little weird, like I was voyeuristically intruding on their private conversation, and didn’t want to make a sound. But Eve pursed her lips and looked over at us.

“It’s just that I can’t see myself eventually getting married to another woman,” Eve explained to me and June. “I know that’s a long, long ways away; I’m only nineteen. And I did offer to stay in the relationship with Eden for now.”

“And I told her I didn’t want to make her stay in a relationship she’d already decided had no future,” Eden told us with a dismissive wave. “Better to take a break, promise to be friends, and then work on that friendship when she comes back to school. That way there wouldn’t be any unfulfilled expectations.”

“I still feel like I’m letting you down,” Eve groaned, turning her attention back to Eden. “I’m the one who started this relationship by telling you I was falling for you.”

“It takes two to start a relationship and I was just as happy to explore what we could potentially mean to each other,” Eden replied. She pursed her lips and gave Eve a brave smile. “It was a great relationship while it lasted, and now I’m hoping it turns into a great friendship again. I don’t want to lose you. You’re a special, special girl.”

“You’re the special one.”

“Thank you. And I’d like you to continue thinking that, without any pressure to feel like you have to maintain romantic feelings for me just for my sake.” Eden took a deep breath and exhaled slowly. “Think about everything Adrienne told us about her relationship with Sasha, and about how letting Sasha go was the right thing to do. Think about what Adrienne told us about how important it is to truly be who we feel we are inside.”

“Adrienne said that stuff to help you come to terms with being gay,” Eve pointed out.

“And her advice still rings true to help you come to terms with not being gay,” Eden countered. “I know it left you questioning what you wanted for the future, and that’s okay.”

“You say ‘okay’, but I know you’re hurting inside.”

“I’ll be alright,” Eden insisted. “I’ve still got a great support structure.”

“Do you? Emma’s moving in with your parents.”

“Ben and Adrienne are still here.”

I arched an eyebrow at Eden, wondering just how much she would end up leaning on me for “support”.

Eden caught the look and smirked. “Relax, I’m not asking to come back and be a secret girlfriend again.”

“You sure about that?”

Eden sighed. “Eve and I are breaking up, yes, but I’m not going to fall off a cliff of despair over this. The writing’s been on the wall for a while now.”

“And here I thought your relationship was going great,” I muttered before fixing my gaze on Eve. “I thought you were getting ready to tell your parents you were in a lesbian relationship.”

Eve nodded. “That’s what really sealed the decision for me. The idea of coming out to my parents? It didn’t feel right. I’m romantic for men. Hell, if you didn’t already have five different women in line ahead of me, my own Jie Jie included, I might’ve seriously entertained making a run for you.”

I blinked. “So that’s what tonight was about. You wanted to playact being my girlfriend and see how it felt.”

“I did. And it just felt… right.” Eve nodded. “I was making love with my boyfriend. And even though you and I aren’t actually together, all I could think in the middle of it all… with your big, heaving body thrusting into me over and over and over again… nngh… Sex with other girls is just sex, and there’s nothing wrong with that. Sex with Eden meant so much more to me, because she truly is special. But the way you made me feel tonight? It just reinforced the idea that at the end of the day, I want to be with a man.”

I winced. “You sure that wasn’t just the orgasms talking? I know the effect I can have on a woman. I wonder if you were with any other guy and it didn’t feel quite so good… would you feel the same way?”

Eve shrugged. “Only one way to find out.”

I arched an eyebrow. “So that’s the decision? You’re gonna go out there and find some other guy to have sex with and confirm your heterosexuality?”

Eve snorted. “Of course not. I mean, I intend to go out there, start dating again, and confirm I’m hetero-romantic. I was never the type to put out for just any random dude and I’m not gonna start now. But eventually… if I find the right man… yes, I’m gonna sleep with him and see if I feel the same way. Maybe he won’t be as good as you.”

“He definitely won’t be as good as Ben,” Eden stated firmly.

“Said with all your wealth of experience with other men,” Eve remarked drily before turning her attention to me and repeating, “Maybe he won’t be as good as you, and if not, I may come to realize I was happier with Eden and come begging for a second chance.”

I winced. “Now I’m thinking I should’ve done a shitty job of making love to you and you’d have gone right back to Eden right now.”

Eve laughed. “You couldn’t have made it bad for me if you tried, and it wouldn’t have erased the last several weeks of discovery for her and me.”

“I suppose.”

“And you DID make it good for me… great for me… amazing even.” Eve smiled. “I told you that was lovely and everything I could’ve dreamed of. I’m so glad you finally got my ass. Was it everything you dreamed of?”

I grinned and rubbed her shoulder. “Better.”

“I’ll bet you say that to all the girls you’ve just de-virginized,” she muttered with a smirk.

“Well I’m definitely not going to ever say anything negative in such a situation. But seriously, that was… amazing. Thank you. It means a lot that you still wanted to share that with me.”

Eve’s eyebrows waggled. “And I’m still gonna wanna share it again.”

I arched an eyebrow. “Meaning?”

“We’ve only had the one round, right? Surely you can get it up for a few more. June was right all along: I really do like the butt stuff. Or did you think we were done with you already?”

I blinked. “Oh… uhhh… With the whole breakup news, yeah I kinda thought we were done.”

Eden smirked and started crawling her way up Eve’s body, kissing exposed skin as she went before slurping one of Eve’s nipples into her mouth and tugging it upwards with her teeth before the mammary’s pliant flesh snapped back down. My baby sister grinned and explained, “We agreed that we’re not officially broken up until she leaves on Monday. I knew she wanted to have a sweet lovemaking session with you before then, and I thought it would be tomorrow or something, but I guess this little minx didn’t want to waste any time getting your big dick up her ass. Long story short, we’re gonna have fun with you together as much as we can until the clock strikes twelve.”

“Ooh! Ooh!” June exclaimed excitedly, staring down at me. “I’ve always wanted to eat Mei Mei’s pussy while she’s riding you reverse cowgirl with your big dick up her butt. Can we do that next?”

I snorted. “Uh, don’t look at me. It’s your sister’s asshole. Ask her.”

“Mei Mei?” June promptly asked.

Eve snickered at her sister. “I’ll make you a deal. You go first.”

“Really?”

Eve grinned. “Remember… July comes AFTER June.”

****

-- MONDAY, MAY 25, 2009 (MEMORIAL DAY) --

The morning air was cold against my right cheek, the pillow reassuringly warm against my left. I snuggled deeper into the covers and their cocooning heat while pressing my chest against her back, covered only by a thin layer of cotton. As my senses came alive, the fingers of my right hand reflexively squeezed the large bare breast I was currently palming beneath her nightie. My left arm snaked beneath her pillow, with the hand dangling off the edge of the bed.

Breathing deeply, I let my head roll forward to push my nose into Dawn’s ice-blue hair, smelling her sweet fragrance. Reflexively, I ground my morning wood into her bare-bottomed ass, but not wanting to wake her, I forced myself to stop dry humping her ass and calm down. Then, I silently let my right hand drift away from her bare breast and brought it down to the narrow gap between her thighs. With the heel of my hand on her ass, I probed with my middle finger until I found her juicing slit still wet from the load I’d dumped in her last night, and gently pushed the digit inside.

Dawn sighed at the slight penetration but didn’t stir. I coated my fingertip in what moisture I could find, pulled out, and then traced my finger up her labia until I could nudge the tip against her clit. She shivered slightly as I teased her love button, but she didn’t wake. So I repeated the maneuver again and again. And when I judged her pussy to be slick enough for entry, I shifted my hips, took my prick in hand, and guided my mushroom head up into her pink folds.

Dawn moaned but didn’t startle when I pushed the first few inches in. I’d woken her up in this manner enough times over the years so that the sensations were familiar instead of frightening. She reached back with one arm to cradle my head while I hooked my forearm against her midsection to help draw our two bodies closer together. And she groaned at the moment of complete penetration before sighing dreamily and murmuring, “Love the way you wake me up, babe.”

“Glad to hear it,” I murmured before kissing the back of her neck.

At first, I simply slow-dicked my soulmate as we sprawled on our sides. I held her hip in my hands while she found a good pace to push her booty back at me. But as the pleasure built, she started to roll over onto her stomach and I rolled right with her in perfect sync so that we didn’t get dislodged. There had been no warning, we both just knew it was time to move to the next step as if this were a dance routine we’d long ago mastered. And she then extended her arms forward and out to the sides, groaning gutturally into the mattress as I began to pick up the pace.

Presently, Dawn propped herself up on her elbows and pumped herself back to meet my pounding thrusts. At times it felt like SHE was fucking ME, really ramming herself back to skewer her soaking-wet snatch on my steel-hard shaft over and over and over again.

“Fuuuuck meeee…” my lover moaned. “Fuuuuck meeee…”

“I’m fucking you… I’m fucking you…” I groaned right back.

“Neeeever… stoooop… fuuuucking… meeee…”

“For the rest of our lives. ‘Til death do us part.”

Dawn snickered at that last bit and then abruptly came to a stop. This move wasn’t part of our regular dance routine, and I arched an eyebrow in surprise. But Dawn was just changing positions, reaching back with one hand to hold me at bay while she pushed herself forward and off my prick. Flopping over onto her back, she spread her legs invitingly and beckoned me with both hands while I heard, Come fuck me this way, babe, ringing in my head. I wanna look into your eyes when you cum deep inside me.

Worked for me.

I quickly slammed my schlong straight back into her saturated snatch. Dawn sighed and smiled and draped her legs over my forearms while I folded her in half beneath me and really hammered her into the mattress. We thrashed and bashed and smashed into each other’s body with lusty abandon, Dawn crying out two more climaxes in this position before she wrapped all four limbs around me and stared up into my eyes. With every thrust, her gaze bored into the back of my soul, repeating, I love you… I love you… I’ll love you for the rest of my life.

‘And I’ll love you for the rest of mine,’ I replied in kind, smiling down at my eternal lover and best friend as I felt the surge of energy well up inside me like a tidal wave rushing towards the shore.

Within seconds, the wave made landfall and crashed over the surface. I bellowed my release and watched Dawn’s sky-blue eyes flashing as she found simultaneous satisfaction with me. She screamed, I screamed, we screamed together as our bodies shook and shuddered, her spasming snatch sucking out streams of steaming semen that splattered straight inside her welcoming womb.

And then I collapsed.

And we were done.

But just for now.

“Mmm… I’m gonna miss waking up to this,” Dawn groaned. “Is it too late to turn down my internship?”

“Yes. This is your dream job and you know it,” I mumbled with my forehead planted on the mattress, breathing hard.

“True, but I’m starting to wonder if the commute would be worth it.”

I chuckled. “Maybe a midweek night or two if you seriously can’t last five nights away from me.”

“I don’t think I can seriously last five nights away from you.”

“Okay no biggie. I’ll tell Summer and Adrienne to expect you coming back on Wednesday nights or something.”

Dawn giggled. “You should probably do that.”

I grinned and sighed. Scooping my arms beneath her body, I clutched my best friend close and nuzzled her nose. “This is gonna be SOOO weird having you out of the house for so long. I can’t remember the last time we went so many nights apart.”

“Your New York trip for Strawberry.”

“That was just a week. This is gonna be three months. Even when you lived in The Birdhouse and I lived with Kim, June, and BJ, we still never went three nights in a row apart.”

“We’ll be alright. It’s for the best. With me out of the house, you’ll have extra time to spend with Summer and Adrienne. You know your girlfriend deserves more of you than she gets as it is.”

“Actually, I disagree. I think Summer’s doing just great with the time she already has and would be just fine if I dialed it back a bit. She really doesn’t require a lot of maintenance.”

“But Adrienne does,” Dawn said with a sigh.

I picked my head up a little farther away from Dawn’s face and frowned. “Is something wrong with Adrienne?”

Dawn winced. “Not ‘wrong’ per se. She gets it: Summer’s your girlfriend and deserves the lion’s share of your attention. And you’ve always been spread thin with everyone else.”

I arched an eyebrow. “Not THAT thin. Kim and June have required less and less of me the last couple of months. Yvaine’s been a once-a-week thing. I know Eden and Eve have been occupying a lot of my time this weekend trying to get in as much as they can before the stroke of midnight on their relationship and all that, but otherwise they’ve been pretty low-key. And Emma’s never been demanding to begin with. Truth be told: I think I’ve spent a LOT of time with Adrienne lately.”

“Of course you have.”

I paused and narrowed my eyes. “Why did you just say that as if you meant the exact opposite?”

“No, I’m serious. You’ve spent a lot of time with Adrienne. More time than you’ve spent with me, even.”

“And yet…” I led her.

Dawn sighed and shook her head. “She’s not… happy. She’s more… ‘fine’… in the way that you define the word, you know?”

“Of course I know. You think Adrienne’s putting on a brave face to cover up all manner of resentments?”

“I dunno. I do know that something’s wrong, or at the very least, not everything is great. Maybe it’s the stuff with Sasha. Like… Adrienne told me a long time ago that she thought Sasha might eventually get tired of the whole globe-trotting thing after a few months and come home. But that hasn’t happened and Sasha seems happier than ever. Maybe she’s missing the Tri-Delts now that the seniors have graduated and moved on. Maybe the stuff with Taylor messed her up more than she wants to admit. Look, I’m not saying to do your bull in a China shop impression and make a bigger deal out of this than it needs to be. But I do think so many of us moving away from Berkeley is an opportunity for you and your Tigress to spend some serious quality time together. Joking aside, I don’t plan on coming back here every Wednesday. I mean yeah, I’ll totally be back on Friday night to spend the weekend with you. But midweek? I can totally recommend doing some relationship maintenance with Adrienne, y’know?”

I nodded. “I will.”

“Good.”

I smiled. “Does it really mean so much to you that I work on my relationship with Adrienne?”

“I want her happy.”

My smile broadened. “Thank you for being such a good friend to Adrienne. It means the world to me how well the two of you have gotten along ever since we moved into The Nest.”

“Your happiness is my happiness, remember? I know how important Adrienne is to you. And… well…” Dawn blushed. “She’s become pretty important to me. With Summer ascending into a bigger role in your life, that’s left me and Adrienne with a lot of time to ourselves. There’ve been a lot of late nights staying up talking--”

“Talking and…” I led her.

Dawn smirked. “Talking and… stuff… We’re both sexual creatures.”

I chuckled.

“It doesn’t hurt that she’s the most fantastic lover I’ve ever known. The things that girl can do to my body?”

“THE most fantastic lover?”

Dawn laughed. “Second to you, of course.”

“She said you’re the best pussy-licker, period - including me.”

“High praise given how many different tongues that girl has had on her clit.”

“Indeed.”

“But beyond the sex, she’s been a really good listener. She’s been a really good cuddler. And…” Dawn sighed and got a faraway look in her eyes before finishing, “she’s been a really good friend.”

“I’m glad you feel that way.”

Dawn switched her gaze back to me. “Take care of her, huh? That’s the silver lining in me moving out for a bit. Don’t neglect her, because on the nights when it’s just you and Summer alone in this big bed… I just… don’t… I don’t like the idea of Adrienne being alone. She doesn’t do well when she’s alone, you know?”

I nodded. “I know.”

“She’s a bright yellow sunflower… thirsty for the light.”

“I’ll be sure to shine a lot of light on her then.”

“Good.” Dawn gave me a firm nod.

I grinned and pecked her forehead. “Anything else?”

“Make sure to water your plant.”

I rolled my eyes. “Can we stop with the Summer as a plant jokes?”

Dawn smirked and then continued, “Keep me in the loop on this Penny stuff. I don’t want to see that get out of control.”

“Neither do I.”

“Don’t let Eden turn secret girlfriend again, especially on the rebound after Eve.”

“Of course not.”

“Yvaine will be fine, and I’ll be back next weekend so we can take care of her together.”

I chuckled. “She’ll need the rest of the week off the way you and I absolutely destroyed her yesterday. We didn’t go overboard, did we?”

“Pssht. She loved every second of it.” Dawn giggled. “Your little ‘Spread ‘em, Pleasure Doll’ routine? She loves it.”

I chuckled. “I rather enjoy it myself.”

“She rather enjoys us teasing her with Summer, too. I think next weekend we might actually need to have her and Summer cross the line.”

My jaw dropped. “You’re not serious.”

“C’mon, you can tell they both WANT it.”

“Of course they do.”

“And Summer talks that fantasy ALL the time.”

“Summer’s crazy. She calls me ‘Daddy’ every now and again.”

Dawn giggled. “Would you like it if -I- started calling you ‘Daddy’ at the same time?”

“Don’t even go there.”

“Hey, if you marry Yvaine, then Summer could call you ‘Daddy’ for real.”

“Holy shit, I can’t believe you actually said that out loud.”

“Ooh, if you knock up Yvaine, you can give Summer a little sister.”

“Did you really go there? Really?”

Dawn snickered. “I’m kidding, I’m kidding.”

“Kidding-not-kidding?”

Dawn just giggled. “Seriously though, for now we can start small by giving them what they want.”

“Did you bring up me marrying Yvaine and giving Summer a little sister just so that mother-daughter incest would seem like ‘starting small’?” I shook my head. “We can’t seriously… I mean… That’s a pretty big line to cross.”

“Is it really a bigger line than you and the twins?”

“At least the twins and I are the same generation.”

“It’s not like Summer and Yvaine can knock each other up. Neither of them will cross the line on their own. But if Master and Mistress order them…” Dawn’s voice trailed off as she giggled. “Ooh, you just got really hard inside me again. Does the idea of switching holes on the fly between Summer and her mom while they’re making out with each other and grinding their clits together turn you on? Can you imagine pulling your dick out of Yvaine’s tight asshole and immediately cramming it down her daughter’s throat moments later while they’re in a sixty-nine? I think you can… Ooh, you’re getting SOOO hard inside me right now. I can feel it.”

“Ohhh, fuck, Dawn…”

“Ready to go again, babe? All without ever pulling out of my cum-soaked cunt? Huh? You like that? Feel me milking you? Feel my tight cunt clamping around your cock? Fuck yeah, babe. Start fucking me again. Ooh, yeah. Just like that. Soooo good. You gonna add another load to my already saturated snatch? Fuck yeah you are! Fuck! Fuck! Now I wish Yvaine was here today so we wouldn’t have to wait. But I suppose the anticipation will just make it that much sweeter. Fuck! Fuck! Fuck me! Fuckme-fuckme-fuckme! Ungh! Ungh! I love you so much, babe, I love you so much!”

“Love you too…” I grunted between thrusts. “I love you too…”

Dawn gripped my skull and kept our foreheads pressed together. She whimpered and panted beneath me, and in a somewhat calmer voice she crooned, “I love you, Ben. Just… I love you. I’ll miss you, but I know you’ll be in good hands while I’m gone.”

“I will be. And I love you, too.”

Dawn giggled and started undulating her body beneath mine. “Imagine Yvaine giving her daughter a rimjob and then spreading Summer’s cheeks apart to smile up at you, pleading for you to slam your fat cock up her daughter’s tight asshole.”

I chuckled and shook my head. “Seriously, save the fantasies for next weekend when we make them a reality. I don’t need them.”

Dawn’s eyes shimmered up at me as she smiled, already knowing what I was going to say next.

“Right now, I only wanna be with you.”

****

None of the departures were really goodbye, and yet it definitely felt like a moment of transition. Dawn and Emma were the first to leave in the morning, Emma driving them off in the twins’ Camry. Both would be returning on Friday night. I then went over to The Aerie to spend the day with BJ while I still had time.

In the late afternoon before dinnertime, Kim and I started packing her things into the minivan. I gave BJ a kiss and a hug and told him to be good both for Sofu (Kim’s dad) and Nana and Grandpa (my parents). I told Kim I looked forward to seeing them both again Friday night as well, and then Eve came over with Eden.

Unlike the other three, I wasn’t exactly sure when I’d see Eve again. I hugged her and told her I hoped it wouldn’t be three months, and she whispered into my ear, “Don’t worry. I won’t be able to go three months without feeling your dick up my ass again.”

She then smirked and pecked me on the cheek before returning back to Eden and giving her now ex-girlfriend a teary hug.

Eventually, though, Kim backed the minivan out of the driveway and drove off. Adrienne, Summer, June, Eden and I then looked around at each other before nodding and heading for The Nest.

Well, all of us except June.

I frowned and glanced over at her. “You’re not coming?”

She smirked back at me and replied drily, “I don’t live with you.”

Indeed, while Eden had asked for and received permission to move into Dawn’s bedroom during the weekdays rather than live alone in The Birdhouse, June had made clear she was just fine remaining in The Aerie during the week even if Kim and BJ were no longer there. Never the most social creature by nature, she was actively looking forward to living alone for the first time in her life.

I chuckled and gestured towards The Nest. “I know you don’t, but you know I’m making dinner for everyone.”

“I’m good, actually” she replied with a smile. “I asked Lynne and Bert if I could join them for dinner tonight.”

“Oh! Okay…” I nodded slowly. “Uh, are we still meeting at my place for breakfast tomorrow before work?”

“Yep. I’ll see you then,” June stated with a smile and a friendly wave before pulling her hands into the sleeves of her sweater, crossing her arms over her midsection, and turning to head down the sidewalk towards Lynne and Bert’s apartment.

I watched her go for a bit, took a deep breath, and then finally turned around to join the others in The Nest. Summer and Eden were already over by the front door, but to my surprise Adrienne was standing right beside me and I startled just a bit.

“Don’t read too much into the symbolism of it all,” she murmured sagely.

“Symbolism?”

Adrienne shrugged. “First night that Kim’s gone and June elects to spend it with Bert and Lynne instead of you?”

“Baby bird finding herself a more suitable nest, that sort of symbolism?”

“You said it, not me. And you gotta admit, that nest is far less crowded than this one.”

“I think I’d prefer to think of it as a baby bird stretching her wings and being on her own for a bit.” I waved her off. “It’s fine; I’m not sweating it. June knows I’ll always be her Ge Ge, and that she’ll always be my Songbird.”

Adrienne studied my eyes for an extra half-beat before blinking and smiling. “Uh-huh.” And then she turned to head back for The Nest.

“‘Uh-huh’? What’s that supposed to mean?” I called after her.

Adrienne chuckled and just kept walking.

I simply sighed and followed her home.

****

Three nights earlier, I sat at the head of the dining table looking around at twelve of the closest people in the world to me. Tonight, after ferrying out all my dishes and then taking my seat, I looked up and saw only three.

“What’s wrong?” Adrienne asked, seated to my left as she reached out and took hold of my hand.

I blinked and shook my head. “What? Nothing.”

“Tiger… You can’t lie to me.”

I shook my head again. “Nothing’s wrong. I was just thinking about how on Friday night we had thirteen people at this table, myself included. Now, it just feels so… empty.”

My Tigress winced. “There’s that word again: ‘empty’.”

My mind flashed back to our conversation that first night in New York. Adrienne had thought our lives were going ‘perfect’, but then I’d told her Valentine’s morning that I woke up feeling ‘empty’. And she hadn’t taken it very well.

I squeezed her hand and reassured her, “That’s not how I meant it. Honestly, I meant ‘empty’ as in… literally empty - as in a lack of human beings seated at all those empty chairs. I really should take out the expansion leaves and shrink it back down to a table for eight. Wasted space.”

Adrienne’s eyes tightened at the mention of scaling the table back down, and she looked as stricken as I’d felt a moment earlier.

Summer, seated to my right, spoke up. “I get where you guys are coming from. We used to fill up this table all the time, either with the Tri-Delt Nesters or with family. But this is just a temporary situation for a few months. Most everyone is coming back, right? I have an idea: instead of taking out the table leaves, why don’t we find out which TDN girls are sticking around for the summer, invite them to come hang out, and maybe bring a few of their friends?”

“It’s not about sex,” I muttered.

“I didn’t say it was,” Summer countered.

“Ben’s right though: I can’t keep trying to fill the void with horny sorority girls,” Adrienne sighed.

“I dunno…” Eden drawled. “Might be worth a shot for me.”

Adrienne blushed and reached over to take hold of Eden’s hand, who was seated to her left. “I’m sorry, rugrat. Not being a good big sis at the moment. How’re you holding up?”

Eden waved her hand dismissively. “I’m fine.”

I arched an eyebrow. “I’ve never liked this wo--”

“I’m fine,” she insisted, cutting me off.

Adrienne smirked. “Pretty soon, you’re only gonna get as far as, ‘I’ve never’, before they cut you off.”

I shrugged. “All good, so long as the message gets across.”

“Look at me? Do I look like a wreck?” Eden held her hands up. “I’m perfectly, perfectly at ease with the break-up. The writing was on the wall about Eve being hetero-romantic, we agreed to stay friends, we had an amazing weekend with my big brother there, and now we have some time to decompress.”

Summer, Adrienne, and I all looked at each other and then back at Eden.

My baby sister rolled her eyes. “Seriously, guys. “I’m fine, and not in the way Ben defines the word. Seriously, I’m fine. I’m perfectly fine. Totally fine.”

****

“I’m not fine!” Eden groaned as she pulled her knees up to her chest, grabbed the hem of her long nightshirt, and tugged it over her knees and down to her shins. Wrapping her arms around her now nightshirt-covered legs, she sobbed with great heartfelt shudders before setting her forehead down atop her kneecaps.

Adrienne set her mostly-empty wine glass down on the coffee table, wrapped her arms around Eden’s shaking body and hugged her fiercely.

Nestled against my side with my left arm around her midsection, Summer sighed in sympathetic sadness and glanced over her shoulder back at me. I winced and exhaled, hating to see my baby sister like this. I genuinely thought she’d been “fine” this whole weekend - “fine” the way I defined it in the sense that she’d been covering up all manner of resentments while putting on a brave face until Eve finally left and went home.

“It’s alright to not be fine,” Adrienne soothed, stroking her adoptive little sister’s back. “You don’t have to try and hold it in anymore, try to cover it up or anything like that. It’s just us. You can let it out. You can tell us everything.”

“I just don’t know what’s gonna happen!” Eden cried. “I mean Eve and I TALK about staying best friends but is that even really possible? Doesn’t everyone say the whole reason why people shouldn’t cross the line between friendship and romance is because it’s impossible to go back to being friends afterwards?”

“Clearly not,” Adrienne insisted. “Look at me and Ben! Or Ben and Dawn! Multiple failed romances and yet we’re right back together again.”

“That’s different. Mom and Dad would never let you two be estranged, and the same goes for Ben and Dawn. There’s too much history and love for either of you to be out of his life for very long. Eve and I don’t have those kinds of bonds. What if she comes back in the fall and decides she wants to move out and get an apartment with Piper or something? Huh? What if I can’t control the way I feel about her and start pestering her to give romance another shot and she freaks out and runs away? What if SHE decides absence makes the heart grow fonder and SHE wants to give romance another shot but I’ve already moved on with someone else? Am I supposed to wait for her? Am I supposed to keep myself pure and pining until X number of months have passed and I’m officially allowed to date again? How the fuck is this supposed to work?”

“There’s no one-size-fits-all solution,” I told her. “Believe me: after all of my own failed relationships, I should know.”

“Great. Remind me to never-ever take your advice on relationships, Mr. Repeated Failures,” Eden muttered.

“Harsh, but not entirely undeserved,” I admitted.

“What about you?” Eden grumped, gesturing at Summer.

My girlfriend winced. “I’m afraid I wouldn’t have any good advice for you, either. All of my relationships have been disasters, except for this one.”

“Well with Ben’s track record,” Eden scoffed, “I wouldn’t get your hopes up.”

“Eden,” Adrienne scolded.

“I’m sorry, I’m sorry.” Eden buried her face in her knees again and groaned in frustration.

“I’m obviously the one with the closest situation to yours,” Adrienne said with a sigh. “And even I can’t have all the answers. Every relationship is different, and there are no magic cures. All you can do right now is take a deep breath, and then another, and another, and another. Keep moving. Keep breathing. Because tomorrow the sun will rise. And who knows what the tide will bring?”

Eden picked her head up and arched an eyebrow, but I actually beat her to it. Looking at my Tigress, I asked, “Did you just quote Cast Away?”

Adrienne smirked. “I think I did.”

“I have the sudden impulse to get a Wilson volleyball and call it my new best friend,” Eden muttered.

Summer shrugged. “There are worse ways of dealing with grief.”

I furrowed my eyebrows and gave my girlfriend a concerned look. She caught my gaze, grimaced, and looked downward.

“I recruited a dozen sorority girls to move into my house so I could drown myself in pussy,” Adrienne muttered.

I mused on that and shrugged. “Ditto.”

Eden gestured at Summer. “It was your idea to see if there are any more Tri-Delt Nesters around who might want to move in.”

Summer waggled her head. “Yeah, but then you’d either have to clue them into your family secret or go without big brother dick.”

Eden made a face. “Okay, definitely NOT recruiting a bunch of sorority girls to move in. Maybe I should just rebound and fall right back in love with my big brother?”

“Eed,” I warned.

“Kidding.”

“Kidding-not-kidding?” I asked.

“Yes,” Eden replied with a sigh. But then waving dismissively, she turned her attention back to Adrienne. “How do you deal with it? Sasha telling you she wants to stay friends while every day you ask yourself, ‘What is wrong with me?’ ‘Why couldn’t she love me the way I thought she would?’ ‘Is it really the reason she’s giving me or is there actually something else that she’s not telling me because she’s trying to spare my feelings?’”

“I don’t ask myself that stuff every day,” Adrienne replied with a wince and a weary sigh. “For one thing, Sasha lived and breathed Open Communication enough that I genuinely don’t think she ever avoided telling me something in an attempt to spare my feelings; believe me, that girl hurt my feelings all the time. But for sure, I did find myself asking, ‘Is it me? Is it because she’s hetero-romantic, or could she love another woman but she can’t bring herself to truly love me?’ ‘Am I to blame? Was it something I did? Was it something I said?’ ‘If only I had been selfish a little less.’ ‘If only I had listened a little more.’”

“If only I had been a little smarter,” Summer muttered quietly. “If only I had been a better girlfriend. Been a better lover. Been a more compliant slave. If only I had been more perceptive. Recognized what he wanted - no, what he needed from me. Would it have made a difference? Maybe he wouldn’t have gotten so mad. Maybe he wouldn’t have punished me so severely. Maybe… Maybe… Maybe…”

Eden had picked her head up and was looking at Summer in surprise, but Summer was sort of staring off into the middle distance, her eyes unfocused. Eden glanced over at Adrienne, and then at me.

Hugging my girlfriend back to my chest, I rubbed her shoulder and asked, “Hey, you alright?”

She didn’t respond right away, still staring off into the void and muttered, “Maybe… maybe… maybe…”

“Summer. Summer.” I shook her a little more vigorously.

My girlfriend startled, and she looked back at me over her shoulder, eyelids fluttering. “Wha-? Ben? I… Uh…”

“You alright?” I repeated.

She blinked twice and nodded immediately. “Uhhh, yeah.”

I looked skeptical. “You sure?”

“I’m sure, I’m sure. I’m fine, I’m fine.”

Adrienne’s expression caught my eye, and I looked up at my Tigress and found her shaking her head slowly with wide eyes as if to say, Don’t let her deflect this one.

I arched an eyebrow and rubbed my girlfriend’s upper arm, murmuring, “I’ve never liked this word ‘fine’. It always seems like a word to cover up all manner of resentments.”

Eden clapped. “Hey, you got the whole thing out!”

I rolled my eyes and rubbed Summer’s shoulder again. “Hey, you can talk to me. You can talk to us.”

Summer frowned. “Y’know, it’s getting late. Maybe we should turn in for the night.”

I looked up at the clock. We’d been drinking wine and talking for about an hour after dinner, but it was still quite early in the evening. “It’s barely after eight,” I stated reasonably.

My girlfriend smirked, took my arm around her waist, and brought my hand up to cup one of her perfect tits outside her sweater. “I wasn’t suggesting that we sleep.”

I sighed and pulled my hand off her boob. “I’d rather we all take the time to talk tonight. In fact, I think this is a perfect night to uncover all manner of resentments. Eden’s admitting she’s not really fine about this breakup with Eve. Adrienne’s admitting she’s not really fine about her breakup with Sasha. I’ll be perfectly happy to tell you just why I’m not fine either.”

“Why you’re feeling ‘empty’, in fact,” Adrienne pointed out.

I rolled my eyes and shot her a look that plainly said, ‘Not helping.’ And then I went back to hugging my girlfriend as I said, “Can you please help me understand a little about why you’re not really fine as well?”

Summer’s eyes tightened, and as she swallowed thickly, I felt like I could actually see her reluctance to revisit the past making her start shutting down again. Time and again, I got tiny glimpses into the traumatic events that had scarred Summer’s psyche over the years. And time and again, I couldn’t bring myself to push her into thinking about things she didn’t want to think about anymore.

Adrienne apparently felt no such compunctions. “C’mon, Summer. Didn’t you just say a minute ago that you wished you’d been a better girlfriend? Didn’t you just say you wondered how differently things might’ve turned out had you recognized what your boyfriend needed from you? This is your chance, right now, to make a difference in your relationship. If you don’t start to open up to him now, you’re never gonna be like me and Dawn in his heart. Our romantic relationships with him fell apart, but we’re still together, still strong, because of the foundations of support and trust we built together.”

Summer’s jaw dropped open as she stared at Adrienne in surprise.

“If you can’t bring yourself to tell him the truth about what happened to you, you’ll never have those same foundations,” Adrienne continued. “If you keep hiding things from him, you’ll never find the intimacy you crave. Being attentive and loyal will only get you so far with Ben; lots of girls can be attentive and loyal for him. Being a perfect sex doll isn’t even all that special when he’s got a harem of… well… girls like me and Dawn and Eden here servicing his every need. You wanna graduate from the ranks of casual girlfriends who merely keep him company into the kind of woman he might actually consider spending the rest of his life with as a true partner or not? You’ve been here with us for a while now. You’ve seen how much he and Dawn share in each other’s lives. If all you ever want to be is the hot piece of arm candy that stands next to him and looks pretty for the rest of your life, then by all means just keep doing what you’re doing. But if you aspire to ever mean something more, you’re gonna have to let him in.”

Summer continued to gape at Adrienne in utter shock. Even I was pretty surprised by the cutting bite in my Tigress’s tone.

Taking a deep breath, Adrienne glanced over at Eden and gestured with a twirling right index finger. “C’mon, rugrat. Let’s let the two lovebirds have some privacy; they’ve got a lot to talk about. You and me? We’ve got a lot to talk about ourselves. I can’t promise you I’ll have all the answers. But the fact is, we’re in the same boat: in love with people who just don’t quite see us ‘that way’.”

Eden nodded as she stood up. “I wanted to believe I was fine with it all… but now that she’s gone… this just fucking SUCKS.”

“I know it.” Adrienne turned and gave me one last mournful look. “Believe me, I know it.”

With that, both Adrienne and Eden headed up the stairs. Summer continued staring away at the far wall for a while, letting me hold her but neither pulling away nor leaning back into my embrace.

But at last, she took a deep breath and looked back at me. Summoning up her courage, she exhaled slowly and gave me a nervous look. “You wanna know this stuff, don’t you?” Her tone was more ‘statement’ than ‘question’.

“I don’t want to cause you any more pain,” I told her sincerely.

Summer shook her head. “Adrienne’s right: I can’t keep avoiding this stuff.”

“I’m ready to listen if you’re ready to speak.”

“I am. Well…” Summer eyed the wine bottle, seized it suddenly, and then filled her empty goblet to the very top. And only after it was full did she pick it up, take a deep breath, and say, “But I think I’m gonna need a LOT more of this stuff if we’re gonna get through it all.”

****

-- TUESDAY, MAY 26, 2009 --

“Holy fuck! Fuck! Fuck! Yes! Yes! Yes! Ohmigawd it’s so good. Ohmigawd it’s so goooood!”

The lusty, busty redhead beneath me writhed and wriggled while repeatedly flinging her pelvis up against my penetrating prick, her ginger landing strip rubbing up against my short and curlies. I held her wrists, pinning them down against the mattress to either side of her head while her brilliant blue eyes flashed up at me.

“I’m gonna… I’m gonna… Can’t take it anymore! I’m gonna… ccccuuuummmm!!!”

Penny thrashed within my grasp as a monster orgasm tore throughout her entire body. She shook and shuddered and squealed and screamed her satisfaction. And just as her climax started to fade, I pulled out, flipped her over face-down, and slammed myself back into her tight twat to repeatedly ram my rigid rod right up her succulently-sweet snatch.

“Unnnngggghhhh…” Penny groaned as I jackhammered my pelvis against her heinie. She was lying on her right cheek with both arms spread to the sides while I held her hips up in the air to keep her pussy at a convenient height to receive my pounding thrusts. Delirious with post-orgasmic pleasure, she was as relaxed as she’d ever be. So with her ass upthrust before me, I spread her cheeks with both hands and briefly gazed down at her winking starfish. And after popping my thumb in my mouth to coat it with spit, I pressed my thumbpad down against her tightly-crinkled anus.

Penny shivered and moaned as she tensed up, the same way she always had whenever I started messing around with her butthole. “Holy fuck, Ben,” she whined. “I… I… I don’t… I never… Ohmigawd…”

I stopped pressing, adjusted my grip to hold her hips, and started to really lay down the lumber. I’d given Penny four orgasms already, or was it five? And as I put a cap on the sexual creature inside me that REALLY wanted to violate my pretty project analyst’s virgin anus, I settled myself down for the final stretch, seeking my own sweet release.

Shortly after, I slammed forward one final time and groaned as my cock cannon began firing great wads of sticky jism into the darkest recesses of pretty Penny’s pulsating pussy. It was my turn to shake, shout, and shudder in satisfaction as I squirted out scores of semen shots into her saturated snatch. And when I had finished splooging her full of all my sticky stuff, I collapsed downward across Penny’s back, both of us gasping in the aftermath.

We couldn’t stay like that forever, though. As with all of our lunchtime nooners, we’d have to get back to work in a timely manner and still needed to grab quick showers before returning. So as soon as I caught my breath, I pulled out of her pussy, rolled over onto my back, and then stood up next to the bed.

“You good?” I asked her with a bit of a self-satisfied smirk, knowing full well that I’d once again blown her pretty little mind with my sexual prowess.

“Holy fuck, Ben,” Penny groaned. “I thought I’d eventually start getting used to this - jaded, even. But ohmigawd… I can’t even find the words…”

I chuckled, my ego enjoying the moment. As good as I knew I was, it was still nice to hear this kind of praise every now and again. Certainly I knew the other lovers in my life had all become… well, not exactly jaded… but at least accustomed to my excellence to the point where they simply expected Fourth of July fireworks every time as a matter of routine. If nothing else, I appreciated that aspect of my relationship with Penny.

“C’mon, let’s go clean up.” I paused to extend my hand to her.

Goofus struts off to take a shower without a backwards glance. Gallant chivalrously helps the well-fucked maiden try to stand up straight after he’s pounded the hell out of her.

Uh, something like that.

In any case, Penny and I headed into her shower, and with Goofus and Gallant still squarely in the back of my mind, I took extra care to soap her up and clean her off.

We were face-to-face while I was soaping her arms and shoulders when Penny pressed herself against my chest and hugged me close. She closed her eyes and sighed quite happily. I felt myself tense up just a bit, recognizing the strength of her infatuation with me, and not for the first time I pondered whether or not we needed to sit down and have a conversation about the non-romantic nature of our relationship.

But before I could say anything, Penny looked up at me with her brilliant blue eyes. She cocked an eyebrow and murmured, “You started playing with my butt again.”

I blushed in mild embarrassment and muttered, “Sorry ‘bout that. I know you told me that’s not your thing, but I just got carried away a bit.”

“It’s alright. I’m sure your other lovers surrender their assholes to you all the time.”

I shrugged. “I’m not gonna talk about what anyone else does or doesn’t do. Right now, my focus is on you.”

She stared up at me and blinked slowly. “You could make it good for me, couldn’t you?”

I arched an eyebrow. “Um, what?”

“Anal sex. I’ve never… I mean… the whole thing just seems so… nasty. And yet… I know with all your experience…” She bit her lower lip and then leaned forward, setting her forehead down against my shoulder. And after taking a deep breath, she looked back up at me and finished, “If you really want to do it that much, I’ll let you.”

I shook my head slowly. “I’m never gonna pressure you into doing anything you’re not comfortable with.”

“But for you I would. For you, Ben.” Penny’s brilliant blue eyes shimmered with moisture that had nothing to do with the shower spray around us.

I felt a catch in my throat as I took a deep breath. Swallowing thickly, I gave her my full and undivided attention while holding her head and replying gently, “I appreciate the offer, but that’s really not necessary.”

“Your other lovers give you their asses, don’t they?”

I rubbed my forehead. Didn’t I just get through this conversation with Eve?

You had this conversation with Eve before Christmas and it took five months to finally get into her ass. Time for a new conquest!

Penny’s not a conquest.

She kinda is…

She’s a co-worker.

A subordinate.

You know what I mean.

Giving Penny a firm look, I stated, “I told you I’m not gonna talk about what my other lovers do or don’t do. And whether or not they have anal sex with me has no bearing on whether or not you should.”

“But I want to give you something special. You know I’ve never done it before. I want you to be the first.”

“You don’t have to do that.”

“But I WANT to. For you. Because I…” Penny’s voice abruptly cut off as she caught herself before finishing the three-word phrase.

I winced and rubbed her shoulders. “Penny… Maybe we need to talk about--”

“I love you,” she stated plainly with a whine in her voice. “I can’t not say it anymore. I love you. I need you. I spent the entire holiday weekend missing you. I cuddled with a pillow, wishing I could be in your arms. You have no idea how many times I jilled off the last three days reminiscing about all the things you’ve done to me.”

“That’s not love; that’s lust. It’s the orgasms talking, Penny.”

“It’s NOT just the orgasms. Don’t impugn my feelings for you!”

“Impugn?”

“Belittle. Diminish. Discredit. Whatever. My feelings are real. I lie awake at night wondering if you’re thinking of me even though I know you’re not. I talk to Winston for hours on end about these emotions I have inside, about how much I really DO love you!”

Did the crazy cat lady just say she talks to her cat for hours on end about her love for you?

“Penny, we barely know each other,” I reasoned. “You have to understand how sudden and completely out of left field this is for me. Two months ago we weren’t really friends. Our relationship to date had been entirely about work with just a little bit about sex these last few weeks. I mean, I’d been making the effort to build a friendship between us, but still, there’s no history together on which to build real love.”

“Yet,” she interrupted. “We haven’t had a chance to build real love yet. But we can build it. I WANT to build it… with YOU.”

“Penny… I can’t build real love with you. I’ve got a girlfriend, and--”

“And she’s a pretty blue-eyed redhead,” she interjected with a grin. “You’ve got a thing for blue-eyed redheads it would seem.”

I held up my hands and twisted to turn the shower off. We were both cleaned up enough anyways. And as I grabbed a towel off the bar just outside the curtain, I shook my head and said, “You’re a very pretty girl and I’ve enjoyed the two of us adding a physical component to our relationship. But I’m sorry, I don’t feel the same way about you.”

“Yet. You don’t feel the same way about me yet.”

Taking a deep breath, I bunched up the towel over my face and groaned for a moment. Then, shifting it to start drying my hair instead, I popped both eyebrows and said, “I don’t want to lead you on into having expectations of us developing something romantic.”

“You’re not leading me on. You’ve been very clear about our relationship being purely professional.”

“Thank you.”

“Well, professional AND sexual.”

“Obviously.”

“But I can’t help the way I feel.”

“I get that.”

“And I’m thinking that if I let you fuck my virgin asshole, maybe it might help change your mind?”

“Uuuugggghhhh…” Groaning again, I wrapped the towel around my waist and stepped out, stalking back towards the bedroom.

Gallant would’ve stayed and handed Penny her towel rather than walking away.

Shut the fuck up, dude.

Back in Penny’s bedroom, I dried off as quickly as I could and started putting my clothes back on. Penny joined me in the bedroom a minute later, with her towel still wrapped around her torso. She made no attempt to start getting dressed.

“I’m sorry,” she said quietly. “I know you don’t want me to be in love with you.”

“It’s not your fault,” I mumbled quietly. “Maybe it was a mistake for us to start doing this. And I think the best course of action is for us to stop sleeping together.”

“What? NO!”

“Penny, we work together. I’m your boss. We live in a world of logical analysis, and the most logical thing for us to do now is hit pause on the physical aspect of our relationship.”

“No, you can’t! I love you!”

“And that’s the problem. I’m not diminishing… not ‘impugning’ your feelings for me. I acknowledge that they’re genuine and sincere. But you being in love with me would mess up our working relationship.”

“You never cut June off for being in love with you!”

I winced. “That was different.”

“Different how? She told me she fell in love with you. Bending over that conference table feeling your fat dick burrowing into her bowels for your brainstorming sessions became the highlight of her days! You told her you didn’t feel the same way, and you worked with her to manage HER expectations, didn’t you?” Penny’s eyes were on fire as she repeated more strongly, “Didn’t you?!?”

With a sigh, I admitted, “I did.”

“Then WORK with me on this, alright?”

“To what end? Penny, I’m never gonna love you back the way you want.”

“You don’t know that.”

“I’ve got a girlfriend now. I didn’t have a girlfriend before when June fell in love with me.”

“So bring me along! Summer likes other girls, right? I’ll do anything you want me to… ANYTHING. I’ll eat her pussy while you bang me from behind. I’ll fingerbang her cunt while you shove your big dick up her ass. I’ll let HER fingerbang MY cunt while you shove your big dick up MY ass! I LOVE you, Ben. And I’ll do ANYTHING I have to!” she howled at the top of her lungs. “I just want you to love me!”

“Penny…” I winced. “Do you have any idea how unhinged you sound right now?”

“Unhinged? UNHINGED?!? Good fucking lord, Ben, you have NO idea what I might sound like when I REALLY get unhinged!!!” she howled with arms outstretched, a movement that loosened her towel and made it fall to the floor.

And lord help me, my first thought was about how wickedly sexy Penny looked with perky tits, flushed skin, and righteous rage.

Man, you REALLY like sticking your dick into crazy. Or is it that sticking your dick into them makes them crazy? Chicken or egg scenario?

Shut the fuck up, dude.

I blame Adrienne for this strange fascination with riled up girls.

For the love of… shut UP!

Completely naked and still a little bit damp, Penny suddenly launched herself at me, wrapping her legs around my waist and her arms around my neck as she jabbed her mouth at mine, trying to kiss me while I struggled to hold her at bay without hurting her.

“Penny! Penny! Penny!” I stammered, dodging her kisses that landed on my cheeks, nose, chin, and even my right eye. “Hold up!”

“You’ll love me, I promise!”

“Penny! Seriously! Penny!” Finally, I grabbed her around the waist and spun her around. Pivoting forward in a sort of Krav Maga tackle move, I pushed her and jumped on top of her at the same time, planting her face-down on her bed with my forearm across her shoulders to keep her pinned down with the bulk of my body on top of hers. “PENNY! STOP!”

All energy fled out of her as she started sobbing.

“Penny… I’m sorry…” I murmured quietly, panting to catch my breath. She’d stopped resisting, so I shifted my weight off her and stood back up next to the bed. “I just… We need to stop, alright? If we continue, it’s only gonna lead you on into believing this is going to develop into a deeper and more emotional relationship than I’m prepared for. You’re moving too fast for me right now. You say you’ll do anything you have to? Then you and I need to take a break, alright? I’m not saying forever, but at least until you can show me you can keep a lid on these overwhelming emotions, do you understand?”

Penny whimpered into the bed, clutching the bedsheets as she continued to cry.

Winston the cat perched on the windowsill, giving me the stink-eye.

“I want to respect the love you have for me, but I can’t return it,” I stated carefully. “I’m not gonna claim it’s the orgasms talking and merely lust, but the orgasms are only gonna fuel the feelings that I need you to get better control of. So we’re gonna stop having nooners, stop with the hookups, and both take a step back so we can reevaluate our relationship, alright? Can you do that for me? Can you do that with me? Because in all honesty, the only way I’m ever gonna come back to this apartment with you is if I believe with a hundred percent certainty that we’re on the same page about what this relationship means… and about what it doesn’t mean.”

Penny shuddered, but she looked back at me with teary eyes and nodded slowly.

“Please tell me you understand.”

She clenched her eyes shut and choked out two sobs. But after quietly shivering for another few seconds, Penny slowly sat up and turned around to face me. Covering her nudity by crossing her legs and holding both arms over her chest, she nodded her agreement slowly and muttered, “I understand. I’m sorry, Ben. I know I lost it for a second there.”

I winced. “Yeah, you kinda did.”

“You must think I’m such freak.”

“No, of course not.”

“Ugh! I’m such an idiot!” Penny bowed her head and rubbed her right temple. “Summer… Dawn… Adrienne-fucking-Dennis… I know I don’t measure up to girls like that.”

“You’re a beautiful young woman, and any man would be lucky to have you.”

“You don’t need to butter me up anymore.”

“Not trying to butter you up. I mean it. In difference circumstances, I would’ve loved to explore the potential of building a relationship with you. But these are the circumstances we have: I have a live-in girlfriend and we share a house with two more women. I’ve got a baby mama and a two-year-old son. You started this by telling me you just wanted to find out what was so special about me in the sack, and I tried to be very clear from the beginning that we could never be more than physical.”

“You were, you were.” Penny sighed. “I’m the one that let my feelings get involved.”

“Our working relationship is what’s most important to me,” I stated flatly. “There’s no room for romance here, and I don’t want to lead you on into believing I might someday come to fall in love with you. I can’t do that. I can’t let myself do that. I’m taken, plain and simple. My love belongs to others. And if you can’t accept that, then we’ll never be able to have sex again.”

“I can accept it. I can accept it.” Penny bit her lip and looked up at me. “I don’t want to stop. You’re too good.”

“But we have to stop, at least for now. You do understand that, right?”

Penny grimaced as if she’d rather eat live grubs crawling all over a decomposing subway rat, but she nodded. “I understand.”

“I wish it didn’t have to be this way,” I said one last time apologetically as I fixed my clothes and prepared to walk back to the office alone.

Gallant would wai--

Shut UP.

Taking a deep breath, I repeated, “I wish it didn’t have to be this way, but it’s what we have to do. Will you be alright?”

“Yeah, yeah.” Penny nodded, her expression sullen and her eyes downcast.

I felt bad. I knew I’d hurt her. But I really didn’t have any other choice.

A moment later, she flicked her gaze up to mine, blue eyes glimmering as she added softly… very softly…

“I’ll be fine.”



----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

For anyone who can’t wait, VIP tier has an 8-chapter lead: https://www.patreon.com/posts/63304076

Remember that all authors thrive on feedback, so let me know how you're enjoying the story! Leave a comment here or come chat with us on Discord! And be sure to connect your Discord account here on the Patreon website to get access to the Patron-Only channels!

https://discord.gg/fg3m6MdfN9

Comments

KC Forever

Trouble in paradise this chapter. I knew Eden was going to be super needy after her breakup with Eve. Also the whole thing with Penny was a disaster waiting to happen, Ben really needs to stop thinking with his dick and focus on the relationships he already has. Since Ben’s real rock (Dawn) will be absent for the most part during her internship, he’ll be forced to deal with his relationships with Adrienne and Summer on his own. I get the feeling they are “fine” as in Ben’s definition of the word, Adrienne wants more deep down and still is as needy as ever after her relationship ended with Sasha, and Summer is still struggling with her trauma with past experiences, she already knows what she needs to do in order to become a life partner for Ben but it remains to be seen if she can find it within herself to do so, but I really hope she does. (Perhaps with Yvaine’s intervention?)

Uppercase

Agreed. At some point he has to learn from experience. These conversations always go the same way (and BTW, writing a grown professional woman in her mid20s behaving exactly like a teenaged girl with similar coloration did in BTC is not a great look, from an authorial/reader standpoint), and Ben keeps getting into these predictable situations. Ben wants to be just casual sex buddies with a girl, despite trying to be friendly and affectionate, and his interior monologue congratulating himself on his presumed comparatively superior treatment of his partners. And it ends up the same way. Maybe Ben's treatment of women in the bedroom is not extraordinary and should be the standard of decency, but this work makes him out to be a super-nice, super-generous, considerate lover, and it's always the crazy bitch's fault for getting too attached or for cheating on him or whatever. Like, recognize what story you're in, Ben. You don't constantly visit your doctor for a STD panel, do you? Of course not, because there are no STDs in this story. So stop solo-fucking and playing the boyfriend to girls with whom you don't want to get serious. Saying "I am not looking for a relationship, I have too many women in my life" has, on more than one occasion not only failed to produce the desired result, but causes the woman to instead make it all about herself being inferior to Adrienne etc. Furthermore, he's a father with a child. He has NO business doing ANYTHING that could endanger his living. Maybe the sexual harassment rules are looser at his company, but he's in one of the most progressive states in the country. Even if the company is fine with Penny pitching a fit over her sexual relationship with her boss not going where she wanted, and accepts Ben's explanation about their prior understanding and his commitments elsewhere, I'm pretty sure that if it's not an actual crime, it's at least something she can sue big time for. Ben is having sex with his subordinate. There is no way to get around that or dress it up. He can cost his company heavily, and that's going to impact his ability to make a living, curtailing bonuses or promotions even if it's not a firing offense (a feature of the universe even more implausible than the lack of STDs, FWIW). Ben shares custody of his son with a college student. Even if their parents footed the whole bill and they don't have student loans, he still needs the income stream for BJ. Adrienne can't take over the child support on the savings from a < 5 year modeling career while paying Bay Area property taxes, and Ben is way too toxically masculine in certain ways to not spend a solid half page whining about it even if she did. TL;DR - Ben should never have started sleeping with Penny. From a Watsonian (in-universe) perspective, it was abhorrently irresponsible and from a Doylist (reader/writing) perspective, it was a transparent plot device to manufacture drama.